Oh boy... here we go.
Before I start this post - my intention is not to disrespect anyone's opinions or preferences on what they like from their Who episodes. This is all my personal opinion, based on what I personally fell in love with the show for, and that may very well oppose your own. I am passionate about this subject but mean no malice or disrespect to anyone who's opinions differ.
That being said.....
What the fuck did I just watch? Like, seriously? Okay, granted, Chibnall's era wasn't brilliant - we all know that. But, the finale for any doctor is SO important, and I genuinely feel this was the worst written, least "important-feeling" and least sensical episode of the Chibnall era. Not to mention, 13's final moments feel genuinely emotionless for me, which is a huge difference from nearly every other regeneration scene filling me with emotion - whether that be epicness from Eccleston's, sadness with Tennant's, nostalgia and reminiscence with Smith's, or the pure reverence I felt seeing Capaldi let go, after what felt like he just finally made sense of his eternally confused, almost frustrated genius.
(Side point: watching 12's regeneration again after watching 13's time, I immediately miss the almost-empty majesty and choral notes of Murray Gold's musical writing for the show. I hate the spectral, meaningless musical scoring for 13's era.)
Okay, so, from the beginning.
Firstly, the train scene was cool - but feels like way too cool an idea to just use for an almost-throwaway opening. Dan leaving so soon and with so little fanfare felt really rushed - like they just wanted some artificial heartache to keep people interested. It feels like, apart from introducing the Cybermasters as a villain again, the first 10 minutes could have been cut from the episode and very few people would have noticed.
Tegan and Ace being back felt like PURE fan service. Fan service that is well inter-linked to the plot and serves a genuine purpose is cool - but this? It felt cheap. Fine, Kate's in-universe answer does make sense, it feels like they're there for a reason, which is a good start... but that good start is where it ends. Their characters only add another reason to insert Baker and McCoy into this episode, so any sincerity added by bringing them back falls really flat.
So, let me try work this next bit out. The master is in league with both the Cybermen and the Daleks - one of which wants to turn the earth into a Cyberfactory, and the other wants to completely melt the planet with volcanoes? Aren't the Daleks more than powerful enough to bring a couple of ships and blast earth to smithereens with a few laser beams? And, why would the Cybermen be okay with the planet being turned into a lava-filled mess if they wanted to build a factory there?
Anyway... onto the next confusing bit. The Master kills the top seismologists to keep the Volcano scheme under wraps, fine. But, what is the significance that most of the plot that takes place in 1916? Okay, he cosplays as Rasputin, a fun idea on the surface - but, like... why? Why can't he transport the Cyberplanet with the Qurunx on it to 2022? What specific reason do the writers have here to split the plot across 2022 and 1916? And, I'm also failing to see the continuity between which happened first for the Master's Timeline. Usually, if a plot is split between two timezones, it either means the Doctor and her enemy's timelines are out of sync - making for some clever "timey-wimey" writing to make it's way in (not seen here), or it is at least explained (even if it's eventual) which happens first and last for all parties involved. But, here, the master suddenly goes from classy Seismologist to beardy Rasputin - in a way that feels completely disconnected. They almost feel like two stories. For most of this episode, I was under the impression that the Master was experiencing two different stories from his perspective but one from the Doctor's; and I still can't tell how I should interpret it all. It seems shocking given how much dialogue here is "hello, I am this character and here is what I can see/what is happening in front of me", yet there are still such confusing discrepancies left woefully unexplained.
So, the master gets captured by UNIT only to get rescued by Cybermen that he brings in via Ace via the shrunk-down version of Ashad. This, again, seems like such precious runtime wasted, as the only reason he didn't have access to shrunken Ashad was he decided to gift it to Ace - which is obviously the only way the writers could manage to shoehorn her in (apart from the paintings, and lets also ignore that rather pointless, immediately-forgotten subplot). So, why didn't he use the technology at his advantage to accomplish his goals anyway? Some say villainous theatrics - which, on one hand, I understand; and is definitely on-brand for the master - but his usual villainous theatrics don't include pointless roundabout plot threads that end in an "aha!" moment that could have been done completely without said plot thread. It makes him seem weirdly stupid given his (often well-portrayed) infinite genius.
So, now the Master wants to do a forced regeneration on the Doctor. Okay, where the flying fuck is the sense in this? It doesn't even make two of him, because his body is out of action afterward. We have already seen the fact he can either turn every human on earth, or even every timelord in the Vicinity into him like Simm's master did in Tennant's era. But, here, instead he chooses to nearly sacrifice his original body to take over the Doctor's one body. He could literally have her imprisoned/killed and just pretend to be her? Or, better yet, duplicate his consciousness into her and have two of him present? Or, better yet yet, he could re-enact his plan from Season 4 and just copy every Human into himself again. Furthermore, this specific plan here requires him to harness the power of an entire fucking planet powered by a sentient ball of electricity (a WOEFULLY underdeveloped idea given how cool it sounds, and how good the VFX were for the Qurunx) - when his previous plan in Season 4 required one human-made machine with some extra tinkering. Why would he enact this plan, with so much less benefit, and that takes so much more power and planning? It baffles me.
So, fine, he takes over the Doctor's body in an attempt to besmirch her name. That goal in itself is quite well written and believable for an aspiration of the master, in all fairness. I still have no idea why specifically this had to happen in 1916 - and even if there was some lore reason that I missed for it - the world then has 108 years to remember the fact there was a second moon over the earth before the Earth gets destroyed in 2022. Why set up such a grand and obvious plan 108 years before the Earth gets destroyed, anyway? Why not have it all take place in either 1916 or 2022?
That aside, I think the AI hologram idea for the Doctor was quite clever. Watching both 9 and 10 make a hologram of themselves for both Rose and Martha always left me wondering "why doesn't he react to their questions like an AI copy of himself to help them out?" - so it's nice to see that realised here. I also think it's a nice touch that the interface maps itself to Tegan and Ace's specific doctors, even if I think their overall involvement in the plot is shallow and insignificant to the overall script's progression. However, if we're honest, the plans to take down the Dalek's seismic machines and the Cybermen's conversion process were both pretty fucking dumb. "Disconnect one wire and watch all the Cybermen around you die!" is so fucking weak.
And, the same could be said for how the forced regeneration of the doctor is so woefully explained. What even was the plan? Use the sonic like a fucking Harry Potter wand to whisk up the regeneration energy from the Cybermasters to "undo" the process? How does undo-ing it even work? It is branded as a "complete cellular overhaul", and it's implied that the manifestation of her old consciousnesses are all somewhat ethereal/purely mental or ideological, so how does that work as a good enough template to just whisk her back into being herself again? Surely, if anything (and being extremely generous), it would urge her on to become the 14th doctor and not just stay the 13th? I literally couldn't understand how this happened any less.
That being said, the Hologram trick using the Fugitive doctor, a face that the Master nor the Cybermasters would recognise it quite clever, and felt like a small, small sliver of the genius writing of Doctor who between season 1 and 6.
And what is the deal with Vinder being back? Was it meant to be some nostalgia trip referencing the same season? I don't see how he has any meaningful addition to the plot apart from being another pair of hands when the plot needs one. "Oh, who else can we grab from 13's run to help - oh yeah, let's get Grey Worm with dreads back, he was always the most memorable and charismatic character". It just feels so shallow. I was so confused from everything else when he entered the episode that it was only near the end I even clocked him, and though "wait... why is he even here again?".
This brings us to another thing I don't understand. So, the master is wounded in Russia in 1916, and the Doctor yoinks his TARDIS to 2022 whilst linking it to her own. Okay, cool. But... basically just after the Doctor leaves his TARDIS, he is randomly teleported into it with no explanation. Like... across space and through 108 years, he is just randomly plonked in it. Now, it is stated that his Type 75 TARDIS is more powerful than the Doctor's Type 40, so one could theorise that his Psychic link to his TARDIS was what pulled him back into it? But, why wouldn't the Master's TARDIS pull him in WHILST the Doctor is inside it so he has a better chance at stopping her? It all just makes no sense. I imagine the script saying "The MASTER is teleported from 1916 into his TARDIS in 2022", and just moving on like nothing happened. It's shockingly bad, but people seem to no notice this because "Master dances to Rasputin song haha funny".
(In fairness, that was funny, but not enough to distract me from all the plotholes and unexplained contradictions.)
So, the day is saved, monsters unsatisfyingly beaten and the Master SOMEHOW, very very cheaply can confront the Doctor upon the Cyberplanet. Can I just say, this is THE CHEAPEST death of any Doctor to date. It feels completely completely completely meaningless. 9 died to save Rose with a symbolic kiss, literally sucking the entire power of time itself to save her. 10 died saving Wilfred Mott, an old, insignificant man with nearly no time left anyway purely because he is a beautiful soul. 11 died after spending 900 fucking years looking after kids on a Christmas village, before the lost timelords themselves gave him more regenerations for their selfish gain, at his benefit. 12 died after spending god knows how long trying to salvage what was left of Bill Potts after going arguably mad trying to save Clara out of his toxic dependance on her Genius.
13 dies from the master using a fucking TV remote to control a flailing laser of a competely unexplained and underdeveloped electricity being thing after being randomly teleport 108 years to his TARDIS, JUST so he can enact this awfully-planned plot thread. It falls less than flat. It's completely completely meaningless.
And, to be honest, this lack of meaning carries on through the ending. Her and Yaz' relationship is left Aloof and awkward like usual. She legitamately holds her face for about half a second as her closest thing to any affection - even now she's got NO time left, she doesn't let herself feel or enact anything physical toward Yaz, nor validate Yaz' desires to do so either. The purely visual aspect of them sat on top of the TARDIS is cute, but it kind of ends there.
And, then... no big speech. No parading around the TARDIS with a beautiful, empty, poignant choral arrangement like 12 had. No crying in denial like 10 had, no scared and confused companion like 9 or 11 had. The only line worth remembering was "Tag, you're it."; which, I did like; but in comparison - I remember nearly every word of every pre-regeneration monologue (*insert joke about not forgetting a line of this*). It just feels totally, totally meaningless. The score is as big, clumsy, and focusless as it always has been (at least it's devoid of the "Chibnall Sad Noise"), the final words from 13 are weak and unmemorable, and the whole thing is such a huge let-down.
What confuses me even more is many, MANY people enjoyed this. From the reception I can see online, it's possible to theorise that more people enjoyed 13's ending than enjoyed either 10's or 11's, which both had me in fucking bits after watching. To see critics give it such a high rating is also genuinely baffling - it's like they're watching purely on spectacle, whilst giving no credence to the magic held within the sensical writing, focused plots, and pure distilled essence with in the musical writing of the RTD1 and Moffat eras of Doctor Who. I'm convinced most of these TV Critics are judging it as a "TV Episode", but not as a "Doctor Who Episode". Any fan from 2005 knows how genuinely Magic Who can be - it's not the VFX, it's not how many plots you can fit into one episode, it's not the fan service you get by meaninglessly crowbarring old characters in. It's the complex but explainable plots, careful pacing, somehow finding meaning in a small story in beautiful contrast to how big the Universe is made to feel, the memorable and chilling music work of Murray Gold.... this finale is just the epitome of how the Chibnall Era might have been good Telly, but was not good Doctor Who.
Anyway..... massive rant over. I would love to hear any thoughts you guys have. Anything that I've missed that makes any points of mine invalid - anything you noticed that you either liked or disliked. In a way, I want to be proven wrong that this episode was just pure dross. But, I just want to hear anyone else add to the discussion. I'm so passionate about this show, and I was umm-ing and ahh-ing through all 3 seasons of Whittaker's era, but this just sealed the deal in such a huge way for me.
Please, anything you have to say in response; whether you agree or disagree with me, or a bit of both on certain points, I want to hear it.