r/gallifrey • • Dec 18 '23

DISCUSSION Moffat’s sexism ruins his stories

6 Upvotes

Merry Christmas!

Decided to try and get in the festive season this morning by watching A Christmas Carol. What a great story! I hadn’t rewatched it since it aired and it really could be the best Christmas Special. Not only does it feel maybe the most festive since the plot hinges so much on the time of year and a traditional story, it has a really imaginative and well realised setting, and Doctor actively plotting to use time travel to A Christmas Carol Kazran is a genius and really engaging plot and a fun reinvention of the story. So why am I left with such a bitter aftertaste?

Largely, it’s the treatment of the only two significant female characters in the story, Amy and Abigail. Neither one of them gets to make an interesting active choice at any point, and they are both treated as Sexy Lamps. (The Sexy Lamp theory refers to characters who could be replaced in a story with an inanimate object that exists only for other characters to desire)

Amy gets put back into her sexy police uniform for a gag about her and Rory doing some sexy roleplay on their honeymoon. Sure. Fine. But the joke is made about 4 times in the episode, and it just gets dull, especially after a full series of comment’s about Amy’s fashion, which then don’t go anywhere. It is a choice made only so she can be objectified by the other characters (Rory to Kazran: “Eyes off the skirt”). And yes, Rory is also in a costume - which is not directly commented on, as Amy’s is, and is also a big clunky goofy one, not a sexualised uniform. And even when Any does get to interact with the plot in an interesting way, as the Ghost of Christmas Present, Moffat makes sure to clarify that this is “The Doctor’s idea.”

But the treatment of Amy is largely nitpicks. They’re frustrating, but her function in the story is on a major one - she is part of the group who need to be saved, not really the plot to get there. So I’m more willing to let those side. Abigail’s treatment is the bigger issue.

Abigail is possibly the sexiest lamp to lamp sexily in the entire show. She has an incredibly convenient perspective on Kazran’s father’s business - seeing him as a benevolent philanthropist who is offering opportunities to save the poor. Sure, it could be argued this is just the story she tells to convince Elliot Sardick to choose her, but she makes any action to suggest her beliefs contradict what she says, so we have to assume she does believe this, and is possibly then just too naïve to see Sardick’s true nature. This is only made worse as Kazran learns the error of his father’s and his own ways, but Abigail is never given an opportunity to show a change in perspective. But this makes sense - Abigail’s function in the story isn’t to be a rounded person. Her function is to be a sexy toy for Kazran to play with every year as he takes her on adventures and eventually fall in love with. Even though she knows she only has days left to live, she never even makes a comment on her days being taken from her for Kazran’s amusement, either to complain or state that she wants to spend them in this way. This might be the implication, and yes sometimes it’s fine to have these ideas left in the subtext, but when the only choice she makes in the whole story is to look at her family through a window (It’s the Doctor who chooses to bring them into her family’s home), it leads to a character who feels incredibly passive, which, given the mavity of her situation, is really frustrating to watch, and actively harms the story, and removes potentially very interesting drama. Even her death, which has been built up throughout the episode, is chosen for her, and any conversation they may have been had about it is made off-screen. The Doctor realises she needs to sing, which would use her last day of life, and then suddenly she’s singing. This is very sad - we know, because the Doctor and Kazran are sad. She, meanwhile, seems to feel exactly nothing about it. Again, nothing is said, nothing is expressed by her. The Doctor and Kazran choose to sacrifice her. She obliges.

I think it is best summed up by the fact she is encased in a box throughout the story. She can only do anything when someone chooses to make her. Which is a good metaphor for how the writer treats her.

It’s very frustrating. As I say, it’s otherwise a perfect episode. The Doctor and Kazran, young and old, have brilliant chemistry, and dynamic, complex feelings about each other that inform the plot in interesting ways and pull the viewer along.

It is a 7/10 episode that could be a 10 if the writer treated the women in the story like real people.

Tl;Dr: A Christmas Carol is a great story with men who are written in complex and interesting ways with a variety of emotions and history that inform the plot whereas the women are relegated to standing around and Being Desired, which brings down the quality of the episode and is also emblematic of much of Moffat’s worst habits. Imo.


r/gallifrey • • Jan 04 '24

DISCUSSION They’ve ruined the Doctor.

0 Upvotes

I’m sure I’ll get downvoted to oblivion for this, but I really hate what they’ve done with the Doctor from 13 to present day.

I fell in love with the Doctor as this 2,000+ (or 4 billion?) year old Time Lord who has saved the universe time and again, outplaying and outmaneuvering some of the most dangerous races including Daleks, Cybermen, Sontarans and so many others. The Doctor is epic, he is a force of nature. (I use “he” for convenience only.) River Song talks about him in those terms: “When you love the Doctor, it's like loving the stars themselves. You don't expect a sunset to admire you back.”

I don’t care about the Doctor’s gender, race, or orientation (to the extent that any of that even matters to a being of such vast scope and perspective). I want them to be epic. And the most recent incarnations make him so… small.

Consider:

The Doctor takes companions to keep them grounded in their humanity (for lack of a better word). Some may later go on to do important things (see Martha Jones), but during their travels everything is new, they’re basically observers – almost like take your child to work day. But 13 treats them as equals, like they’re a team of equally capable individuals. They’re not, they’re babies compared to the Doctor, but we have to pretend that a part-time warehouse worker, a retired bus driver and a probation officer have some meaningful part to play in saving the universe.

This 2,000+ year old epic character who has save the universe countless times gets hectored about pronouns by a teenager and told they can’t solve a problem because they’re (currently) “male presenting.”

Canon doesn’t mean anything anymore. No longer a Time Lord? Check. Draw impenetrable force fields with a sonic? Sure. Bi-generate so nobody has to die? You bet. Make a second tardis with a cartoon hammer? Why not? Reality is now changing on a whim to accommodate weak storytelling.

And speaking of weak storytelling – there’s so little to pull from in the dark and dangerous universe that the Doctor is reduced to battling baby-eating goblins doing song and dance numbers? So little to pull from in sci-fi that we have to move genres into fantasy?

The Doctor used to be larger than life – he was feared by the most frightening races in the universe. He mattered, and his story mattered. And they’ve turned him into an irrelevant cartoon. It makes me sad.


r/gallifrey • • Jun 01 '25

SPOILER This season was great, wtf reddit Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Creating a throwaway account just for today to say, I've been enjoying the hell out of this season and checked online for the first time after the finale, and apparently the entire show is in flames? Fans are quitting forever and everyone involved should be fired? Bullshit. All 8 episodes were good which rarely happens and the two-parter was great. Ncuti could have stayed longer but the current contract was only for two seasons; that's life sometimes. It's fine.

I never liked RTD but in the past two seasons he's seriously fixed what used to annoy me. Childish farting aliens, gone. Cheap rubber monster suits, gone. Screen time spent on family relationships with old people, reduced. Reasonably complex scifi in most episodes, check. I'm actually looking forward to more of him next season, whenever that is, which I never would have thought possible.

And people are complaining that the music was too loud? You know that's been happening for all ten+ seasons since the show returned? During 13 when they finally retired Murray and dialed it way back, people complained even more so they rehired him. If this kind of music wasn't a huge success they'd be switching composers every regeneration


r/gallifrey • • Apr 10 '25

SPOILER Based on RTD's recent comments, I am now sure that Doctor Who will be cancelled after season 2... Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Okay guys, for the last few months I have tried to be as rational when it comes to the topic of Doctor Who's possible cancellation. For the most part I've been pretty optimistic, whilst I don't think Disney will go ahead with season 3, I have always felt that the BBC will simply just continue to make the show on their own. However recently, I have seen a few reports stating that when RTD came back to Doctor Who, he was quickly made aware that they felt they couldn't continue to make and finance Doctor Who to a high quality on their own without a partner. So obviously, this concerned me a bit, but I just told myself that the BBC would find a way, either with a new partner or by just trying to continue making it on their own (even if the budget is massively reduced).

However today Russel T Davis was speaking to Newsround and was asked about the potential of a season 3, and his comments were not reassuring at all...

“I kind of know the Doctor’s reached the status of like Robin Hood. Sometimes there might be a pause, and during that pause, the viewers of Newsround now will grow up a few years and start writing stories and they’ll bring it back. So I have absolute faith that that will survive because I am living proof of it and that's what happens to good ideas. No good idea ever dies.”

I am sorry but even I as the very rational Doctor Who fan that I try do be, I am now firmly of the opinion that the BBC are looking to cancel Doctor Who after season 2. In these comments it 100% feels like that he is essentially preparing fans for the show's cancellation/second hiatus which will more than likely be announced after season 2.

He is basically saying "of course the show will come back! it might not be for another 20 years, but it will come back!"

---------------------------------------------------

I honestly feel like the Disney deal was essential for the show's continuation, and with out it the BBC doesn't see a way forward with the show unfortunately. Yes, the ratings for season 1 on BBC IPlayer were pretty decent, but the BBC is losing more and more funding every year, so even though those ratings might be decent, they might just not be nearly as decent enough where the BBC would be able to independently find the funding on their own to produce such an expensive show. Look across the BBCs portfolio, they currently have no other big budget show apart from Doctor Who, and even with that they haven't independently financed it for 3 years. And it's not just the BBC, the British television industry as a whole is suffering at the moment with inflation, energy costs, and the fiscal policy of austerity.

Perhaps there is still hope as RTD has been claiming there is (perhaps this is why as some have noted that the BBC seem to be giving it their absolute all with marketing this year) but these comments do make it sound like that he is already very aware of the fate of the show.

It's a big shame if true, because I do really think the Disney+ deal was such an incredible opportunity for Doctor Who but I do unfortunately feel like the quality just wasn't there to give it the success on Disney+ that it needed, along side RTDs misguided ideas of what will work for audiences in this modern television landscape.

As we got with the classic series, Andrew Cartmel revitalized the old show with a bold new vision, resulting in what many consider the best two seasons of the decade. Unfortunately, the shift came too late—the general public had already moved on and didn’t give it a chance. And it now seems as if we are in the same territory. But as for Doctor Who today, I feel like the Disney+ deal might've been the show's last chance and unfortunately it was a swing and a miss.

It feels like we might be in a similar place now.A break could very well do the show the world of good making room for fresh perspectives and ideas, but on the other hand, why can't the BBC just give it the "fresh vision" now? Why do the BBC keep giving away the keys to classic Doctor Who fanboys who all have a very similar and tired idea of what the show should be?


r/gallifrey • • Jun 10 '26

DISCUSSION To all the people who went after anyone saying RTDs approach was failing and was damaging to the show

0 Upvotes

We told you so.

We didn't say these things because we were 'haters' or whatever other things people would accuse us of, we were being realists, and talking about genuine concerns and critiscsms

Some people on here would act so angrily against people saying the RTD2 era was a failure and that it wasn't connecting to a wide audience and that would crash the show if it doesn't, they would lash out at us for saying this, calling us all sorts and downvoting our comments to try and shut us up.. Well look where we are, the things we were saying came to pass.

Maybe in the future some people on here should be more open to other people's opinions rather than narrow mindly shutting down anything that's out of your opinion range.


r/gallifrey • • May 21 '24

SPOILER Now that The Boom is getting so much praise and positive discussion in comparison to previous new episodes, can we agree it's not just been trolls spreading negativity, and that there have been issues?

4 Upvotes

I'm just watching WhoCultures Boom Spoiler Discussion, and this is generally a channel who always looks on the bright side of Who and dismisses a lot of criticism. The video is titled 'Best Episode in YEARS' and that is very much the angle of their conversation.

Yes there are trolls and misogynists and anti-LQBTQ+ people out there, but if we can generally agree this is the best so far, then we have to agree the rest were somewhat lacking. They say in this video that this is the first time Ncuti has felt like the Doctor and I agree.

I just think it's easy to blame 'The Bad Guys' but we need to be honest about reality too. The quality of writing in this episode has shone a light on the lack of it at times in others.


r/gallifrey • • Jun 12 '26

DISCUSSION Doctor Who needs to ditch the ‘Buffy’ formula

0 Upvotes

The whole mostly standalone episodes with a couple of episodes connected to an overarching plot thing is great. We’ve had a lot of good television from that formula but it been 20 years and that’s just not how tv works in the age of streaming.

If Doctor who is rebooted they should either commit to serialisation and make tv that can be binged, or go all in on making it an anthology series with almost no connection between episodes apart from the main cast. The compromise format we have now is stale and just isn’t how casual audiences watch tv now.


r/gallifrey • • Jun 17 '22

DISCUSSION How the Timeless Child overcompensates for 50 years of white male doctors Spoiler

6 Upvotes

Let me preface by saying that making television in the era of the #metoo movement, hypercritical activism, and political, racial, and economic tension can be difficult. Writers (and showrunners) need to be more aware of casting decisions, character traits, and social movements lest they get ratio’d on social media or other platforms.

— I’m thankful for this. I want programs (especially Dr. Who) to be socially concerned and multicultural/multiethnic in nature. Great!

But it has to feel organic. It has to be well written. It can’t be cheap (take for instance, the “gay kiss” in Star Wars: ROS). Doctor Who was in a bit of a conundrum, you see— 50 years of white men playing a character that can regenerate into any race, and more recently, any sex, calls into question whether or not previous casting had a racial bias (it did).

I’m fine with a woman playing the doctor. I’m fine with Jodie Whittaker playing the doctor. I LOVE that a flamboyant person of color will soon be playing the doctor. I’m fine with Yaz, Martha, Mickey, Ryan, Bill, and every other character/casting decision the show has made.

For some reason, following the casting of Jodie Whittaker and an even more diverse supporting cast, Chris Chibnall decided it wasn’t enough. He decided to retcon Doctor Who into being politically correct via the Ruth Doctor. Functionally this is what the show wants to get across to long and short-term viewers:

“Hey ACTUALLY the Doctor was a black woman BEFORE she was a white man for 2,000~ years! And it took until 2019 for the Doctor’s DIVERSE past to be revealed to us! See how PROGRESSIVE WE ARE?”

That’s not even getting into the gross retcon the timeless child did — the doctor (being the timeless child) was ALSO originally a black little girl who then regenerates into — I shit you not — every conceivable combination of race and sex possible. This is not good writing. This is not how to be socially aware. This is not progressive. This is an ERASER.

Functionally, Chris Chibnall (a well-meaning, wealthy white man) has taken it upon himself to rewrite 50 years of television into being more diverse. I think the whole thing is silly because — well, it wasn’t diverse. It was a product of its time. Is it something you should stand by and be proud of? Not necessarily, but to pretend a 60-year-old show isn’t also a product of history is to deny history altogether. It doesn’t feel in the spirit of the show.

Tl;dr: The timeless child retcons Doctor Who into being diverse and politically correct (a bad thing) when the show could have continued being diverse and politically correct in its current state (a good thing).

Edit: People seem to think I think Chibnall made The Timeless Child to make the show more progressive — that’s not what I’m saying. Chibnall obviously thought it would be an interesting origin/plot. But while he was doing this he also retconned the shows biased casting.


r/gallifrey • • Jul 11 '24

DISCUSSION Has anyone else lost faith in RTD after Empire of Death + the Mrs Flood interview?

15 Upvotes

Hey everyone, to be honest I just kinda want to see if anyone else agrees with me and if anyone can kinda allay my concerns even slightly.

So Empire of Death was a car crash. In fact I would use much stronger language but I don't know the subreddit's opinion on swearing. It completely shook my faith and confidence in Russell, and left me feeling so sour I couldn't even put it into words.

The only copium I could huff was that maybe in Season 2, some more revelations could be made to make all the potholes and overwhelmingly bad payoffs a bit better. A return of Sutekh, another twist about Ruby's mother or her father, even the identity of Mrs Flood.

But after this recent interview where Russell has basically said he doesn't have a reason why Mrs Flood breaks the fourth wall, I'm just kinda... Done. My trust was already shattered after Empire of Death, but now it just feels like he's completely lost his edge.

I want to be excited again. And I was. The cliffhanger of Legend of Ruby Sunday is the most excited I've been for the show since World Enough and Time or even the Day of the Doctor. But it's just gone now. I don't want to get invested because the trust is gone.

I'm honestly starting to believe that Russell just doesn't care anymore, and it breaks my heart. But why else would he just not care about explanations or payoffs? Even he doesn't seem to have any answers for any of this.

Honestly I wouldn't even be surprised if the "big reveal™" is that Mrs Flood is just a little old lady with a few screws loose at this point.

Anyway, is anyone else in the same boat as me? Or can anyone offer me some words of comfort that might make me a bit more hopeful for next series?

TL;DR: Do you think Russell doesn't know what he's doing with the show anymore, or do you still have faith?


r/gallifrey • • Oct 07 '25

AUDIO DISCUSSION Why I Fell Out of Love With Big Finish (And Why It No Longer Works For Me)

4 Upvotes

If you like all Big Finish has to offer then that’s fine, this isn’t about what you should or shouldn’t enjoy.

I liked Big Finish when they first launched, but not long after I began to really dislike them, and here’s why.

In my experience, Big Finish often seems to focus more on producing a high volume of content than on carefully curating quality stories. While there are certainly some strong releases, many can feel repetitive or overly reliant on familiar formulas and nostalgic callbacks rather than bold new ideas. The writing quality can vary a lot from release to release, some stories are excellent, while others feel dull or poorly paced.

Continuity can also become overwhelming and convoluted, often expecting listeners to know decades’ worth of obscure lore, and Big Finish frequently builds an elaborate web of its own storylines and mythology on top of that. While this might appeal to dedicated long-term listeners, it can make their output difficult for newcomers to approach. Unless you’re following every series and box set, the constant crossovers, callbacks, and interconnected arcs risk feeling overwhelming and alienating, far removed from the straightforward, “jump in anywhere” spirit that has always been part of Doctor Who’s appeal.

Big Finish also has a habit of taking minor characters and building entire spin-off series around them, often stretching thin ideas into multi-box-set storylines that dilute their original charm and importance. Their pricing model often feels expensive for the inconsistent quality on offer, and the audio format itself can limit the sense of scale or atmosphere. The use of weak voice impersonators for past Doctors frequently breaks immersion, and I find to be completely disrespectful to the original actors.

Perhaps most frustratingly, they often create their own “canon,” overwriting previously established stories from officially licensed sources. A prime example is the Sixth Doctor’s regeneration, originally depicted in the BBC Books novel Spiral Scratch, which Big Finish later replaced with their own contradictory version in The Last Adventure. This approach makes their output feel less like a respectful continuation of Doctor Who and more like a competing continuity.

For me, all of these reasons add up to one thing, Big Finish ultimately lost the magic that once made them exciting, and instead became something I abhor. Not every unanswered question or unexplored moment needs to be fleshed out, explained, or given a backstory. Sometimes mystery is more powerful than explanation. Big Finish doesn’t need to fill in every gap. It’s this relentless urge to over-explain and expand that really ticks me off.


r/gallifrey • • Dec 28 '24

DISCUSSION 20 Years Later, Doctor Who Is Still Stuck in 2005. Why it desperately needs a fresh take…

0 Upvotes

Doctor Who used to be a show that felt fresh and exciting, something that could reinvent itself every time it changed direction. But after 20 years of Russell T Davies (RTD) at the helm, it’s become painfully obvious that the show is stuck in the past. The same writers (Moffat especially) and producers who brought Doctor Who back to life in 2005 are still in charge today, and it shows. The problem isn’t just that the show’s formula feels outdated—it’s that it’s been stuck on repeat for far too long. It’s like we’re still living in 2005, and that’s a major issue.

When Doctor Who returned in 2005, RTD gave it a much-needed jolt. The writing was fresh, the characters were engaging, and the show managed to blend big sci-fi ideas with personal, emotional stories. It was exactly what the show needed. But fast forward two decades, and that same creative team, still writing the same types of stories, just isn’t cutting it anymore. Everything feels like it's coming from the same playbook: the same pacing, the same set designs, the same plot twists. Even the dialogue is starting to feel like a tired rehash. The show just doesn't feel alive or inventive like it used to.

The bigger issue, though, is that Doctor Who isn’t keeping up with the way TV is evolving. The world of television has changed—narrative complexity, high production values, and new forms of storytelling are the norm now. And Doctor Who has been left behind. It still feels like it’s working from a formula that might have worked in 2005 but now just feels outdated. It's stuck in a loop of familiar patterns that make the show feel predictable and stale. The emotional beats, while still there, are almost too predictable. You know exactly when the big moment of sentimentality is coming, and it doesn’t hit the way it used to.

It’s not just about the writing either. The biggest problem is the lack of fresh perspectives. RTD has been steering the ship for so long that the creative team has become a closed circle of yes-men. Anyone who’s critical of the show gets brushed off, and the interviews always carry this air of smugness. It’s clear RTD isn’t listening to the kind of criticism that might actually push the show forward. The reality is, TV is more competitive than ever, and Doctor Who just doesn’t seem to be keeping up with the times.

This isn’t about dismissing RTD’s contribution—he brought the show back when it needed him, and that’s a huge achievement. But the reality is, Doctor Who needs new blood. It needs someone who can bring a fresh perspective, someone who can think outside the box and push the boundaries of what the show can be. Just as it would have been a mistake for the same writers who worked on the show in the ’80s to take over in 2005, it’s equally a mistake to let the same creative team stay in charge now.

Even after RTD originally left, Doctor Who felt like it was just being passed around the same small, tight-knit circle of "classic - Doctor Who pals," with Steven Moffat and Chris Chibnall taking the reins. While both brought their own spin to the show, it never felt like it broke free from that insular creative bubble. Now, with Russell T Davies returning, there's a real fear that the same thing will happen again with someone like Pete McTighe (War Between the Land and Sea) who’s closely tied to that same inner circle.

The show needs to evolve. It needs new voices, new ideas, and a willingness to try something bold. Until that happens, Doctor Who will continue to feel like a show that’s stuck in a time warp—repeating the same old patterns, unable to break free. And that’s a real shame for a show that was once so full of possibility. I feel like the BBC have got in their heads that's a way to bring in new audiences is to just throw lots of change at us (new Doctor, new companion, new Tardis, new title sequence) - but why don't they put more focus on their creative team) for a show that's all about change there doesn't actually seem to be that much change at all...change on the surface? Sure, but change underneath, absolutely not - and it's really hurting the show.

This isn’t about saying Doctor Who should abandon what makes Doctor Who the show we all love - far from it. The show still has so much potential and a rich history to build on. But it’s clear it needs to evolve in the same way it did in 2005. Back then, the series was reinvigorated with fresh ideas, new energy, and a perspective that understood what modern TV was doing. That kind of reinvention is what’s needed again. Doctor Who isn’t broken, but it’s stuck in a creative rut (something the creative team seem very unaware of). A new approach, with new voices at the helm, could help it grow into something that feels as vital and exciting as it did when it first returned.


r/gallifrey • • May 27 '26

DISCUSSION Why I prefer RTD2 over the Chibnall era

7 Upvotes

TLDR; I think that Chibnall era Who is unambitious and generic DW for DW fans while RTD2 attempted something different even if it failed.

Whether you like what the show has been doing for the past eight years or not, there is pretty conclusive evidence to suggest that it didn’t end up working for casual fans nearly as much as its built-in audience. Despite the vocal minority online, series 11 had a lot of goodwill and came out of the gate very successfully (in sheer numbers, there was more interests in it than any series since Matt Smith was in the show) but this interest quickly declined and the show never really recovered. In some sense, series 11 might have been the public giving Doctor Who its last chance.

The problems with the Chibnall era are vast and complicated imo but the most damning is that I think it’s a boring version of the show. S11 is an incredibly safe, paint-by-numbers season that offers little in the way of risky and exciting choices. The prestige drama aesthetic feels bland, the stories themselves are good enough but nothing the show hasn’t done before and the core characters aren’t as colourful as had become expected for DW ensembles. S12 feels much the same with the same issues but is even more insular looking as a desperate attempt to recreate what people remember about RTD1 (surprise Master reveals, fob watches, Judoon, John Barrowman, 2006 Cybermen) while also diving headfirst into lore and headcanon. S13 obviously made the best of a bad situation but, by this point, the show was so entangled in its own mythos and lore (all of which I just found quite uninteresting) and was no doubt impenetrable to anybody who wasn’t already prepared to give it the time of day.

RTD2, on the other hand, is not so generic. Whether you think it is successful in its attempts or not, I feel it would be a hard sell to claim that the two seasons with Ncuti Gatwa in the role are bland and comparable to any other era. The idea of leaning further into a fantasy aesthetic with gods and monsters could have made for a unique chapter in the modern show’s history and the one and done episodes (Dot and Bubble, 73 Yards, The Story and the Engine) all offer incredibly interesting concepts that wildly oscillate between tones and styles. There is plenty here that could have worked and the reasons why it doesn’t are, again, all rather complex and interrelated.

Despite not being able to see it through (whether that be for external reasons or simply incompetence), I believe that Russell had a vision for 2020s Doctor Who that was unlike what anybody else would have done with the show. Chibnall’s vision, whether you liked it or not, was deeply rooted in traditionalism and sticking to what works and that’s why I didn’t enjoy it as much.


r/gallifrey • • Jun 28 '22

EDITORIAL The Timeless Child is Like Being of the O Blood Type, being a Baby on a Doorstep, and is about Injecting Angst Back into the Show

0 Upvotes

Regarding the Timeless Child making the Doctor too special…

Consider a child with a Group O blood type. When they’re very young someone in their family needs a blood transfusion and no one matches so their parents consent to using the child’s O blood to save the other family member. This is a biological quirk. It’s a physical aspect to this child that is used in a medical procedure. Having this Group O blood doesn’t make the child inherently good or extra special as a person. Any notion of moral good or bad can only be applied to the parents in this case as they’re the ones making an informed choice.

Now if that child grows up and when in their 20s, decides for themselves to donate blood – of their own free will – then that individual can have a moral assessment applied because at that point it would be from their own choices and not a choice thrust upon them from another.

It’s the same with the Doctor. Being the Timeless Child and having certain biological properties means nothing to them as a person. It doesn’t make them special, or a chosen one. All it means is that they have a certain biological aspect to them, but that doesn’t inform their perspective on the world or create predestination.

The only thing that makes the Doctor “special,” is that – like already established in the show’s history – no matter what incarnation (pre or post Hartnell), the Doctor will always choose to be an adventurer that helps people; that the being which calls themselves the Doctor chooses to generally be morally good and as evident by the previous incarnations, always has and always will. Ultimately it is the Doctor’s own choice. Being the Timeless Child didn’t make the Doctor leave Gallifrey, or have Four decide not to kill the Daleks, or have Eleven become a war monger. That was still the Doctor’s choices in the moment which informs the character as they are now. The same way that the Group O child can only be assessed when they personally and of their own will decide to make choices.

(Just before its stated that “the difference is the Timeless Child is a singular being, and the analogy doesn’t hold weight because there are many Group O blood type individuals in our society” : Currently, its unknown exactly how many individuals in the Timeless Child’s species there are. There may be millions. While this is headcanon…that is partially the point. Many claim the Timeless Child retcon removes all headcanon and creates a fixed origin, which isn’t true. It’s easy to headcanon the Timeless Child as one of many that happened to break into the main universe or was forced there – again something not said, ergo, another mystery to add to the origin.)

Regarding The Timeless Child removing mystery from the show…

Going back to the analogy of a child, consider a baby on a doorstep. The baby is brought to a hospital and tests reveal that baby is Japanese, and has Group O blood. That’s all you know about the baby. Where in Japan? Unknown. Who is their family? Unknown. Why were they brought to this doorstep? Unknown. Did something happen to their parents? Unknown. Does any of it matter? Unknown.

Now consider another individual. One that you sit down with and they tell you that they’re from the US. They lived their life there, disliked it, dropped out of university (though they can’t tell you why exactly), and then went around adventuring. They show you pictures of several adventures and provide you with certain reasons to the choices they’ve made in life. They don’t remember much about their family anymore, but they can show you the town they grew up in and they state if you go there now, you’ll see exactly why they left – that the place has always been the same. You’ll understand exactly what their childhood was like.

Then think about a combination. A baby that was left on a doorstep, was determined to be Japanese and Group O. You’re speaking to them later in life – when they’re in their 40s. They can show you adventures, tell you about all the things they’ve done, tell you how they left their 9-5 job and went off. They also say that, sadly, amnesia and memory loss results in their time from being a child into being a young adult is lost on them. They don’t know what they did. They have a strange photo and they look about 20 in it, but who the other people in the photo are, they can’t say. They don’t know their birth parents (they were never found) and they have no information on where they were born. They don’t even know if the village they were born in or anyone in it still exists. They don’t know what that place was like. They don’t know if anything was passed onto them.

While Person #2 does have mystery to them – why exactly they made certain choices is ambiguous – they’re much easier to know and get a full picture on than Persons #1 and 3. Person #1 has barely any information on them and who they truly are and where they truly came from is anyone’s guess. Person #3 has aspects of their life that is known, but splotches of it are entirely enigmatic. They could’ve been anyone in that time, unless they remember its an entire two decades of unknown acts. For the Doctor, much of the show has treated them as Person #2.

While the show may not have revealed superfluous details such as why exactly they left Gallifrey (bored at school, President’s daughter, searching for the meaning of good…anyone’s guess) the simple fact that they did leave remains fixed. As does the fact that they were at school, as does the inner workings of Gallifrey’s society and viewers even see first-hand what the Doctor dislikes about. The major aspects of the Doctor’s history is known, and has been known. Now, with the Timeless Child, the viewer no longer even knowns if the Child left their home of their own free will, if it was thrust upon them, if they were also bored, etc.

One thing to consider is that this in and of itself is working under a retcon. For quite a bit the Doctor was truly a mystery. When Hartnell came on screen who the Doctor truly wasn’t known. Talking to people at the time, sometimes they thought he was a future human, or another creature, or any number of things. He was a mysterious, cryptic character with no known history. Now the show’s been brought back to that state. Yet again, viewers don’t know what the Doctor’s species actually is. “The Timeless Child” is a label given by Tecteun, not a classification of their true origin. The Doctor’s society, world, reality, what made them leave, how they left, etc. all remains a mystery. The Timeless Child pulls everything back to the Season 1 days and makes it so that less is known about the Doctor’s actual past because now viewers don’t even know what the Doctor’s original universe was like. Gallifrey and Gallifrey politics were set and have been set for several decades now. Viewers were made fully aware of what Gallifrey was like for the Doctor. Now, yet again, the Doctor’s true home is a giant question mark.

Regarding the Timeless Child adding nothing to the character…

This also ties into the return of Gallifrey in many ways. With the Doctor no longer having killed his own people, the edge and angst the Doctor had was stripped away. Moffat went down the road of asking the “Am I a good person?” question as the start of a new arc for the Doctor, but subsequently answered that question himself. By the time the Twelfth Doctor’s time was over, the show seemed to be ending as well. Moffat wrapped up the Doctor’s emotional issues and cleared away any sense of weight that the Doctor had. It essentially ended and wrapped a bow on the dramatic aspects of the character.

The result was pretty clear: A Thirteenth Doctor that was happy-go-lucky, but also lacking in character complexity and moral evaluation. Because the Doctor as a character no longer had anything keeping them in check. The weight of the Time War was off them, so they didn’t have an edge or sadness to help them gain perspective, and they already went through the “Good person?” arc so going through it again would have been redundant. It created a cardboard cutout of a character. One who could only function on the surface level because having layers and emotional complexity would be rather hard to create convincingly without the viewers asking “Why? Gallifrey’s back, they made peace with themselves, etc.” The Doctor should be rather secure and cheerful…which Thirteen is, but it also means Thirteen doesn’t stand up as a dramatic, multilayered lead.

The Timeless Child re-injects angst. It allows the Doctor to question themselves again and have more dread/emotional issues. “Where are my people? Are they safe? Did they die? Did I lose another home? Was this other place my home at all? Do I have parents? Am I anything truly or am I just a guinea pig? Can or will someone ever answer this?” Adding in that underlying worry brings the Doctor closer to how they were in Series 1, following the Time War and having that emotional weight. But this time it’s focused on a different core emotional issue and is more about exploring the Doctor’s place in this particular universe. Having these issues gives new emotional layers and is something that RTD can potentially explore in his seasons (the same way Moffat utilized RTD’s Time War angst to push Eleven in a certain direction). Bluntly, it gives the Doctor something to be upset about which in turn allows for more dramatic perspectives to develop again as well as to draw the Doctor into self-examination of where they belong.

Edit: Thanks for the award!


r/gallifrey • • Jan 27 '24

DISCUSSION Chris Eccleston is the best doctor. [Prove me wrong]

0 Upvotes

He had such great stories. They felt like top tier television even today. The chemistry between actors, the tensions. But mostly, the themes. The doctor on a spaceship in the future with robots forcing humankind to do big brother and countdown for fear of death?! I've never seen doctor who be that cool since.

Don't get me wrong, I love Capaldi, Tennant and Smith. But that first season was otherworldly. It seems that after that the show slowly went downhill, and it was still great, but when Chibnall hit, the show seemed to nose dive majorly and still hasn't recovered.

The 60th specials were good, but not a return to form, people say it's good because it wraps up the convolution of the past but all I can see is extra loopholes. The doctor now has a forcefield? So why did he let Clara die? Or anyone that has been hit by a particle beam? Or the addition that the Tardis removes itself when it senses danger... So why did it let the master turn it into a paradox machine?

The Christmas episode was okay but does any of this sound familiar? New doctor, aliens invade on a ship on Xmas above earth. RTD just copied his own homework and made it worse. The bigeneration is just a rip off of his earlier work. Plus instead of a cool sword fighting scene we got a cringe-fest Disney musical and him literally just pulling a ladder with magic gloves that are never actually explained as if this is Peter pan.

I know the bigeneration was a previous episode, but I don't see remixing previous works in a worse way as commendable, think about it... Doctor goes to fight aliens, then at the end of the episode the doctor splits into two. I'm talking about Tennants first episode. If you remember he got his hand cut off which led to a cool storyline with him ending up as two entities.

Edit: If you don't want to debate, or just want to get personal because you woke up on the wrong side of the bed, I urge you to go elsewhere... No one is forcing you to comment or read this.


r/gallifrey • • Jan 11 '25

DISCUSSION Fans of Color - Which Era Feels Most Reductive?

0 Upvotes

A few days ago I asked female fans the same question and wanted to ask other fans of color which era of the program felt most reductive to them?

With the Classic era, Phillip Hinchcliffe's tenure has severely rascit undertones with the The Doctor's uncharacteristically classist attitudes and overall negative depiction of Leela as a "savage".


r/gallifrey • • Sep 26 '25 I’ll Drink to That

DISCUSSION How Quiet the Fanbase is Shows How the RTD2 era Didn't Connect With People

3 Upvotes

What the title says.

You would swear the show had aired years ago and hasn't had anything new out since, not 4 months.

But I think it shows that the RTD2 era didn't connect with people, or interest them enough to actually talk about it and be excited about it...

The majority of the talk since the last season has been if the show will come back or not, and if DW having a break would actually be a good thing (which is very telling about the quality of the show recently in of itself).

I think making the show full of niche interests, no matter how much people virtue signal online about how that's good, has had a poor effect on the show, most people simply won't connect to those niche things, so become less invested in the show.

The show needs to be made for a broad audience again, make a show most people can actually connect with..which means ignoring the virtue signallers online who demand the opposite who think everything should cater minority interests, and maybe people will actually care and get invested in the show again.


r/gallifrey • • Oct 20 '20

DISCUSSION Does anyone else just... Not watch Doctor Who?

0 Upvotes

Now I know how that sounds.

I've got a bit of a craving to watch some Doctor Who again, and I'd be lying if I said I didn't like the show. But in a similar vein, I'd say I love The Simpsons, it's probably my favourite TV show, and I love being subscribed to /r/TheSimpsons. However, I don't watch The Simpsons. That is I will watch Seasons 1-12 ad nauseum, but I'm not ever going to bother watching a new episode as it airs, because it's not a good show that I care for anymore. That sentiment is very prevelent in /r/TheSimpsons, and I was wondering how similarly it might be here.

The first five and a half/six seasons of NuWho are delightful for the most part. But I'd rather treat it like The Simpsons and just disregard everything that follows.

Is anyone here like that? When was the moment the show ended for you? For me it was when I saw news articles congratulating Jenna Louise Coleman (Who I loved in Emmerdale) for being the longest serving companion, and all I could think was "Who the fuck is that?!" despite seeing every episode by that point.

During season 7, I remember feeling unable to watch the show in the living room, because I didn't want to be seen watching something so bad. I'd rather be watching porn with my parents, it would be better. Then Deep Breath was probably the worst episodes of television I'd ever seen.

I've never watched seasons 9 and 10. Then Whitaker came out, awesome, and Chibnall, a new showrunner, really exciting. And it was bad. Never watched anything after her first season. I'm not intending to watch any more until there's a new showrunner or it's cancelled (Possible. The most recent episode was the least watched/lowest rated episode of New Who so far. Lower rated than the last episodes of Old Who as it was cancelled so. About a third as many viewers as some of Tennant's specials. A lot of pressure to defund the BBC. etc etc)

I love the premise of the show, and the fact you have no required set, props (Or one at most), characters/actors, settings, styles or genres... So I don't know why these guys just can't seem to write something.


r/gallifrey • • May 23 '25

SPOILER Having the Doctor (a genocide survivor) currently played by Ncuti Gatwa (another genocide survivor), torture another genocide survivor was certainly a choice Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I want to like the Interstellar Song Contest and I think it was very fun and strong at the first half, but man the more I think about the episode the more it upsets me. It really feels like hardly any thought was put into the implications of its attempted allegory. Chibnall era tier political commentary, arguably worse.

I get the Doctor can relapse but the episode doesn't treat it as such. It treats it like a little small oopsie at the end. The Doctor almost seems pleased with how he handled the situation. It's just...so out of character, especially because he doesn't even try and ask Kid why he's doing what he's doing or give him a chance at all.

I like getting a darker side of the Doctor but this felt like dark for the sake of dark. There was no substance behind this or genuine thought put into it, and I don't mean to get into conspiracy adjacent thinking here but I can't help but wonder what Ncuti thinks of that scene, beyond what he likely has to say for promo reasons.

I'm just baffled at how quickly this episode fell apart after such a strong start.


r/gallifrey • • Sep 07 '25

DISCUSSION The 'Yaas Queeeen' Tone helped Kill the New Era

0 Upvotes

What the title says.

While that tone works for the kind of people who are terminally on twitter/tumblr/reddit, who go around saying that 'DW is so gay' and DW is 'for the gays' and thinking anything that has happened in DW can be read as being something gay, I don't think it works for the wider general audience..

And of course those who go around saying that on social media are just a small vocal minority, and it bears no truth to reality, as the reality is the vast majority of the audience are straight, that's the statistics.

I think RTD and his team have bought into the idea that DW social media groups are a true representation of the wider audience/population, which it isn't..and so they catered the show to that group thinking everyone would love it..

Truth is though lgpt interests and world is a niche thing, one that the majority of the audience are not part of (while obviously supporting it), so if you are making a blockbuster show that needs to attract a wider ranging audience it's probably best to actually make a show that is geared towards that audience and not gear the show to a niche style and niche interests.

I think RTD and his team lost sight of this, which is odd as they understood this in their first era.. Perhaps they got to big for their boots and pushed things further thinking everyone would love it, and well it didn't work... don't be surprised when you take a big show and make it niche orientated that the general audience then find it less interesting and you lose them.

Its a Sin and Years and Years and shows like that are the perfect place to explore niche interests and stories, because they can be smaller shows that don't need to attract the widest possible audience, DW does need to and needs to be made accordingly.


r/gallifrey • • Feb 11 '24

DISCUSSION When was peak Who?

0 Upvotes

EDIT: why the negative 'community karma' ? I don't mind, it's just virtual numbers...but the comments are going well, respectful discussion with bits of agreement and polite disagreement. If you vehemently disagree, feel free to post your thoughts, I'd be happy to reply if I see it.

---------

I love the modern Series 1-6, and some of 7. I began to check out in the Clara age, her character always rubbed me the wrong way, she's irritating & unwatchable but became such a focal point of Series 7B and the first two Capaldi years. It's as if Moffat fell in love with that character, and painfully wanted us to join him. Capaldi's Doctor I couldn't connect with either, grating voice. Sadly while I was looking forward to a female Doctor, Jodie's era was the worst so far. Such a dive in quality from that peak 2005-2011 period! During that peak-era all the Doctors, companions, antagonists & support cast are highly-watchable: with clever script, humorous gags, thrilling drama, decent action and interesting sci-fi ideas.

I recently rewatched to make sure...yep, still fantastic!

The rest...still meh. The dialogue is often terrible: far too 'knowing' and self-reverentially meta. Just doesn't feel natural.

Classic Who is too dated for me personally, tho' has some nifty ideas and often strong dialogue.

Which eras are your idea of absolute peak Who? And if you've watched them all, which is the nadir?


r/gallifrey • • Jun 24 '25

DISCUSSION Who the hell signed off on the script for The Caretaker?

0 Upvotes

Whilst not a bad episode in the sense of it being exceptionally weak or full of stuff that didn't make sense, the way The Doctor is portrayed here seems awful.

He takes an extremely negative view of Danny based on relatively little information. He mistakes him for a PE teacher repeatedly, tells Clara she's making a mistake dating him and tries to set her up with a white teacher who looks a lot like 11 did and generally treats him with a lot of suspicion. Although a lot of this is supposedly based on his previous career as a soldier, it's a little uncomfortable given that he's black.

The whole thing about him being a soldier as a point of contention for The Doctor also makes very little sense. I know he doesn't like guns or violence, but he's never really taken a negative view on soldiers who aren't blindly committing war crimes. He was happy to furnish Churchill with spacefaring spitfires, help UNIT out even after they genocided a cave full of Silurians, treated Anglican Marines with pity mixed with a little bit of mockery etc. But with Danny, he seems to be acting as though a guy who was mostly doing humanitarian work with the army is some bloodsoaked butcher.


r/gallifrey • • Jun 09 '24

SPOILER The Problem with Queer Romance in Doctor Who Spoiler

88 Upvotes

I'll preface this by saying that I myself am bisexual, so my complaint about the queer romance in last night's Doctor Who is not motivated by any sort of "anti-woke" criticism. I think it's great that the Doctor gets to have romantic stories with men as well as women (and this incarnation seems much more interested in men). I want to see more of it!

Unfortunately, I didn't think the queer romance in "Rogue" really worked. Not because of its queerness, but because it felt forced and underdeveloped in a way that gave the sense the writers were looking to prove a point, rather than tell a love story.

The Doctor meets Rogue in the first ten minutes of the episode and by halfway through is already head-over-heels in love with him. By the end of the episode, Rogue has been banished to another dimension and the Doctor is left heartbroken. But I, the viewer, wasn't.

Compare this with Ninerose/Tenrose, which was quite a slow burn, and also ended with a separation where both lovers were separated (seemingly) forever by one being banished to another universe. That is a well-known and widely-beloved tragic storyline, because we had two whole series of romantic buildup before that crushing blow.

Now, you can debate how much Tenrose works for you as a ship, as I know a lot of fans hated it at the time and still hate it. I am personally indifferent to it on the whole. But I remember even at ten years old watching it and being devastated by "Doomsday". Even on rewatch and knowing it turns out alright, it's still a terribly sad way to part the Doctor from his love interest, because we know Rose, and we want her to be happy.

This episode takes place over 45 minutes of watchtime, so we don't get that slow-burn or buildup. The Doctor falls in love immediately and loses his love, and while for some that might be enough to get the waterworks going (and more power to them), for me as a viewer, I was more upset at the thought of losing Ruby - a character I actually know - than Rogue - a character I just met.

It's far more comparable to "The Girl in the Fireplace" (also from Series 2, funnily enough), in which the Doctor falls head-over-heels in love with Madame de Pompadour, only to lose her at the end of the episode. This episode is a heterosexual romance, but it suffers from the same issue: the romance just isn't convincing, because it develops in the space of a single episode, and while the ending is sad (maybe even sadder, in fact, because Reinette is dead and there is no coming back, unlike Rogue), it isn't as devastating as the ending of "Doomsday", because we barely know Reinette.

I would love to see the show explore more queer romance stories and I think it's fantastic that we finally have an incarnation of the Doctor that can openly love men (something not even the Thirteenth Doctor was allowed to do), but it has to be something that is well-written and develops over time. This just felt like a misfire to me.

I am convinced that the episode's screenwriters, producers and showrunners were focused more on writing a story that says "Yeah, the Doctor is gay now, get over it" than setting up a convincing queer love story.

I am all for Doctor Who exploring new territory, but not in a way that feels calculated to piss off that section of the fanbase that will never be happy with progressive change. I want a queer romance that matches Tenrose or Twelve/Clara, something that is given space to breathe and allowed to develop over time. 45 minutes just doesn't cut it.

So, yes, queer romance please. But allot it the same amount of time as past heterosexual romance, or don't do it at all.


r/gallifrey • • Sep 21 '26

REVIEW Just finished Power of the Doctor, and I'm completely infuriated.

7 Upvotes

Oh boy... here we go.

Before I start this post - my intention is not to disrespect anyone's opinions or preferences on what they like from their Who episodes. This is all my personal opinion, based on what I personally fell in love with the show for, and that may very well oppose your own. I am passionate about this subject but mean no malice or disrespect to anyone who's opinions differ.

That being said.....

What the fuck did I just watch? Like, seriously? Okay, granted, Chibnall's era wasn't brilliant - we all know that. But, the finale for any doctor is SO important, and I genuinely feel this was the worst written, least "important-feeling" and least sensical episode of the Chibnall era. Not to mention, 13's final moments feel genuinely emotionless for me, which is a huge difference from nearly every other regeneration scene filling me with emotion - whether that be epicness from Eccleston's, sadness with Tennant's, nostalgia and reminiscence with Smith's, or the pure reverence I felt seeing Capaldi let go, after what felt like he just finally made sense of his eternally confused, almost frustrated genius.

(Side point: watching 12's regeneration again after watching 13's time, I immediately miss the almost-empty majesty and choral notes of Murray Gold's musical writing for the show. I hate the spectral, meaningless musical scoring for 13's era.)

Okay, so, from the beginning.

Firstly, the train scene was cool - but feels like way too cool an idea to just use for an almost-throwaway opening. Dan leaving so soon and with so little fanfare felt really rushed - like they just wanted some artificial heartache to keep people interested. It feels like, apart from introducing the Cybermasters as a villain again, the first 10 minutes could have been cut from the episode and very few people would have noticed.

Tegan and Ace being back felt like PURE fan service. Fan service that is well inter-linked to the plot and serves a genuine purpose is cool - but this? It felt cheap. Fine, Kate's in-universe answer does make sense, it feels like they're there for a reason, which is a good start... but that good start is where it ends. Their characters only add another reason to insert Baker and McCoy into this episode, so any sincerity added by bringing them back falls really flat.

So, let me try work this next bit out. The master is in league with both the Cybermen and the Daleks - one of which wants to turn the earth into a Cyberfactory, and the other wants to completely melt the planet with volcanoes? Aren't the Daleks more than powerful enough to bring a couple of ships and blast earth to smithereens with a few laser beams? And, why would the Cybermen be okay with the planet being turned into a lava-filled mess if they wanted to build a factory there?

Anyway... onto the next confusing bit. The Master kills the top seismologists to keep the Volcano scheme under wraps, fine. But, what is the significance that most of the plot that takes place in 1916? Okay, he cosplays as Rasputin, a fun idea on the surface - but, like... why? Why can't he transport the Cyberplanet with the Qurunx on it to 2022? What specific reason do the writers have here to split the plot across 2022 and 1916? And, I'm also failing to see the continuity between which happened first for the Master's Timeline. Usually, if a plot is split between two timezones, it either means the Doctor and her enemy's timelines are out of sync - making for some clever "timey-wimey" writing to make it's way in (not seen here), or it is at least explained (even if it's eventual) which happens first and last for all parties involved. But, here, the master suddenly goes from classy Seismologist to beardy Rasputin - in a way that feels completely disconnected. They almost feel like two stories. For most of this episode, I was under the impression that the Master was experiencing two different stories from his perspective but one from the Doctor's; and I still can't tell how I should interpret it all. It seems shocking given how much dialogue here is "hello, I am this character and here is what I can see/what is happening in front of me", yet there are still such confusing discrepancies left woefully unexplained.

So, the master gets captured by UNIT only to get rescued by Cybermen that he brings in via Ace via the shrunk-down version of Ashad. This, again, seems like such precious runtime wasted, as the only reason he didn't have access to shrunken Ashad was he decided to gift it to Ace - which is obviously the only way the writers could manage to shoehorn her in (apart from the paintings, and lets also ignore that rather pointless, immediately-forgotten subplot). So, why didn't he use the technology at his advantage to accomplish his goals anyway? Some say villainous theatrics - which, on one hand, I understand; and is definitely on-brand for the master - but his usual villainous theatrics don't include pointless roundabout plot threads that end in an "aha!" moment that could have been done completely without said plot thread. It makes him seem weirdly stupid given his (often well-portrayed) infinite genius.

So, now the Master wants to do a forced regeneration on the Doctor. Okay, where the flying fuck is the sense in this? It doesn't even make two of him, because his body is out of action afterward. We have already seen the fact he can either turn every human on earth, or even every timelord in the Vicinity into him like Simm's master did in Tennant's era. But, here, instead he chooses to nearly sacrifice his original body to take over the Doctor's one body. He could literally have her imprisoned/killed and just pretend to be her? Or, better yet, duplicate his consciousness into her and have two of him present? Or, better yet yet, he could re-enact his plan from Season 4 and just copy every Human into himself again. Furthermore, this specific plan here requires him to harness the power of an entire fucking planet powered by a sentient ball of electricity (a WOEFULLY underdeveloped idea given how cool it sounds, and how good the VFX were for the Qurunx) - when his previous plan in Season 4 required one human-made machine with some extra tinkering. Why would he enact this plan, with so much less benefit, and that takes so much more power and planning? It baffles me.

So, fine, he takes over the Doctor's body in an attempt to besmirch her name. That goal in itself is quite well written and believable for an aspiration of the master, in all fairness. I still have no idea why specifically this had to happen in 1916 - and even if there was some lore reason that I missed for it - the world then has 108 years to remember the fact there was a second moon over the earth before the Earth gets destroyed in 2022. Why set up such a grand and obvious plan 108 years before the Earth gets destroyed, anyway? Why not have it all take place in either 1916 or 2022?

That aside, I think the AI hologram idea for the Doctor was quite clever. Watching both 9 and 10 make a hologram of themselves for both Rose and Martha always left me wondering "why doesn't he react to their questions like an AI copy of himself to help them out?" - so it's nice to see that realised here. I also think it's a nice touch that the interface maps itself to Tegan and Ace's specific doctors, even if I think their overall involvement in the plot is shallow and insignificant to the overall script's progression. However, if we're honest, the plans to take down the Dalek's seismic machines and the Cybermen's conversion process were both pretty fucking dumb. "Disconnect one wire and watch all the Cybermen around you die!" is so fucking weak.

And, the same could be said for how the forced regeneration of the doctor is so woefully explained. What even was the plan? Use the sonic like a fucking Harry Potter wand to whisk up the regeneration energy from the Cybermasters to "undo" the process? How does undo-ing it even work? It is branded as a "complete cellular overhaul", and it's implied that the manifestation of her old consciousnesses are all somewhat ethereal/purely mental or ideological, so how does that work as a good enough template to just whisk her back into being herself again? Surely, if anything (and being extremely generous), it would urge her on to become the 14th doctor and not just stay the 13th? I literally couldn't understand how this happened any less.

That being said, the Hologram trick using the Fugitive doctor, a face that the Master nor the Cybermasters would recognise it quite clever, and felt like a small, small sliver of the genius writing of Doctor who between season 1 and 6.

And what is the deal with Vinder being back? Was it meant to be some nostalgia trip referencing the same season? I don't see how he has any meaningful addition to the plot apart from being another pair of hands when the plot needs one. "Oh, who else can we grab from 13's run to help - oh yeah, let's get Grey Worm with dreads back, he was always the most memorable and charismatic character". It just feels so shallow. I was so confused from everything else when he entered the episode that it was only near the end I even clocked him, and though "wait... why is he even here again?".

This brings us to another thing I don't understand. So, the master is wounded in Russia in 1916, and the Doctor yoinks his TARDIS to 2022 whilst linking it to her own. Okay, cool. But... basically just after the Doctor leaves his TARDIS, he is randomly teleported into it with no explanation. Like... across space and through 108 years, he is just randomly plonked in it. Now, it is stated that his Type 75 TARDIS is more powerful than the Doctor's Type 40, so one could theorise that his Psychic link to his TARDIS was what pulled him back into it? But, why wouldn't the Master's TARDIS pull him in WHILST the Doctor is inside it so he has a better chance at stopping her? It all just makes no sense. I imagine the script saying "The MASTER is teleported from 1916 into his TARDIS in 2022", and just moving on like nothing happened. It's shockingly bad, but people seem to no notice this because "Master dances to Rasputin song haha funny".

(In fairness, that was funny, but not enough to distract me from all the plotholes and unexplained contradictions.)

So, the day is saved, monsters unsatisfyingly beaten and the Master SOMEHOW, very very cheaply can confront the Doctor upon the Cyberplanet. Can I just say, this is THE CHEAPEST death of any Doctor to date. It feels completely completely completely meaningless. 9 died to save Rose with a symbolic kiss, literally sucking the entire power of time itself to save her. 10 died saving Wilfred Mott, an old, insignificant man with nearly no time left anyway purely because he is a beautiful soul. 11 died after spending 900 fucking years looking after kids on a Christmas village, before the lost timelords themselves gave him more regenerations for their selfish gain, at his benefit. 12 died after spending god knows how long trying to salvage what was left of Bill Potts after going arguably mad trying to save Clara out of his toxic dependance on her Genius.

13 dies from the master using a fucking TV remote to control a flailing laser of a competely unexplained and underdeveloped electricity being thing after being randomly teleport 108 years to his TARDIS, JUST so he can enact this awfully-planned plot thread. It falls less than flat. It's completely completely meaningless.

And, to be honest, this lack of meaning carries on through the ending. Her and Yaz' relationship is left Aloof and awkward like usual. She legitamately holds her face for about half a second as her closest thing to any affection - even now she's got NO time left, she doesn't let herself feel or enact anything physical toward Yaz, nor validate Yaz' desires to do so either. The purely visual aspect of them sat on top of the TARDIS is cute, but it kind of ends there.

And, then... no big speech. No parading around the TARDIS with a beautiful, empty, poignant choral arrangement like 12 had. No crying in denial like 10 had, no scared and confused companion like 9 or 11 had. The only line worth remembering was "Tag, you're it."; which, I did like; but in comparison - I remember nearly every word of every pre-regeneration monologue (*insert joke about not forgetting a line of this*). It just feels totally, totally meaningless. The score is as big, clumsy, and focusless as it always has been (at least it's devoid of the "Chibnall Sad Noise"), the final words from 13 are weak and unmemorable, and the whole thing is such a huge let-down.

What confuses me even more is many, MANY people enjoyed this. From the reception I can see online, it's possible to theorise that more people enjoyed 13's ending than enjoyed either 10's or 11's, which both had me in fucking bits after watching. To see critics give it such a high rating is also genuinely baffling - it's like they're watching purely on spectacle, whilst giving no credence to the magic held within the sensical writing, focused plots, and pure distilled essence with in the musical writing of the RTD1 and Moffat eras of Doctor Who. I'm convinced most of these TV Critics are judging it as a "TV Episode", but not as a "Doctor Who Episode". Any fan from 2005 knows how genuinely Magic Who can be - it's not the VFX, it's not how many plots you can fit into one episode, it's not the fan service you get by meaninglessly crowbarring old characters in. It's the complex but explainable plots, careful pacing, somehow finding meaning in a small story in beautiful contrast to how big the Universe is made to feel, the memorable and chilling music work of Murray Gold.... this finale is just the epitome of how the Chibnall Era might have been good Telly, but was not good Doctor Who.

Anyway..... massive rant over. I would love to hear any thoughts you guys have. Anything that I've missed that makes any points of mine invalid - anything you noticed that you either liked or disliked. In a way, I want to be proven wrong that this episode was just pure dross. But, I just want to hear anyone else add to the discussion. I'm so passionate about this show, and I was umm-ing and ahh-ing through all 3 seasons of Whittaker's era, but this just sealed the deal in such a huge way for me.

Please, anything you have to say in response; whether you agree or disagree with me, or a bit of both on certain points, I want to hear it.


r/gallifrey • • May 20 '25

SPOILER Captain Poppy is The Doctor - Theory Explained Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I can't take credit for this, but I recently stumbled upon a theory regarding how the Doctor's origins may be explained in season 2, and guys, it makes that much sense, I can 100% see it being what occurs in the series finale.

Okay, so in Space Babies we were introduced to the parthenogenesis machine which was used to create the babies. Well, like many others, my theory is that it will be revealed that The Rani is behind this "programme" to grow babies. But it will turn out that they're not babies, but instead baby time-lords which The Rani is using to bring Time-Lords back from extinction - and perhaps this is what Wish World is - New Gallifrey, and all of the space babies are being displaced around Wish World to be raised and eventually become the new generation of Time-Lords.

But this is where things get more interesting, especially in regards to Captain Poppy.

Obviously, the machine/computer also went a bit out of control and created the boogeyman, because as The Doctor puts it, the machine/computer saw that "babies need fiction, they need stories, they need monsters"....But what if the machine also saw that the babies need a hero, who would eventually be able to stop the Boogeyman.

So what if the machine created the Doctor in the form of Captain Poppy, a hero that was super smart and super kind, the perfect hero figure not just for the babies, but for the entire universe.

And then what if somehow, later on in life, Captain Poppy found herself alone and abandoned on the other side of a wormhole, only to be discovered by a traveller who would save the child but then later on discover the special abilities of the child, and use those special abilities to enhance the rest of her own race and create the time-lord - and somehow this child would find its way back to the Space Babies station to defeat the Boogeyman and save the day.

Yes, Captain Poppy is the Timeless Child. Captain Poppy is the Doctor.


r/gallifrey • • Mar 07 '26

EDITORIAL TWBTLATS was tap water.

0 Upvotes

Now a few months ago, I made a post saying I was reading TWBTLATS. Most because they were making sexy Sea Devils https://www.reddit.com/r/gallifrey/comments/1oofs9z/why_are_the_new_sea_devils_doing_sexy_dimorphism/

So I was wanting to like it expecting to hate it. But honestly, it felt like Chibnall's Who than RTD. Mostly kinda dull with some elements of gobsmacking dumbness to shock you every so often.

Ok 1st things 1st. I can't stand Barclay, he is such a weed, he is like Toby McGuire's Spiderman before he becomes spiderman. Half his screen time is him stuttering, rambeling etc. Which is fine when he is the ambrassador but he is like that with his ex wife and daughter. Russell Tovey looks like a bouncer, boxer gangster. He looks tough, but his character is such a wuss. Is that intentional? Because no one ever mentions that he looks tough or big. He's meant to be the recptionist no a soilder. Yes I know big tough guys have feelings too. But he's sad and vulnerable all the time. Its weirdly jaring. But even if he was played by Orlando Bloom, he'd still be annoying. He's like Adric grown up.

His wife and daughter, I simpley don't care. At all. Why in these things dose ot always have to be an ex wife? Why can't it be his mother or brother for a change? Dose he need a family? Can't he be a loner?

UNIT. I've said before that I am sick of UNIT. Also ironically UNIT changes every 3 years, it has a new version. UNIT is like Amy in a Pontaff written Sonic game. UNIT in RTD1 were army guys with some high tech stuff. In Moffatt they more technology si-fi. CC makes them border line sequestrated and RTD2 turns them into Perry the Platapus meets Sarah Jane Adventures.

Now they are trying to turn them into Torchwood. Not helped by the creature in the tank being like the 456. Kate having a toyboy is just silly. Why is he so obesseed with her? If they killed Kate, I might have cared but when its him well I don't. Also are we meant to like Kate after she blackmails her Dr into being her drug mule? Or when she threatens to start an inserection againist the elected goverment? Or when she threatens to shoot a man for littering. That is just laughable,

Which brings us to the politics and messaging. Its moronic. Like I figured out what would happen before it did. Like that glass of water scene, who didn't see that coming from a mileaway? But all these experts and dipolmats can't? Even that makes no sense. Human beings have never been able to drink from a river ever. You can drink white moving water from a stream up a mountian. But even in the Roman era if you drunk from the Thames you'd get cholera. That's making a point about vergiterianism by trying to make a tiger eat grass. We can't drink from rivers for the same reason a tiger can't eat grass.

Also since most people don't know who the Sea Devils are, then the polution is careless not malicious. Its not an attack. So the Sea Devils' cliam is dumb. Its like compering my letting my dog poop in my neighbours garden, vs me throwing a brick at their window. Also what is all this rubbish that the Sea Devils saying 'fish are our brothers'? What do they eat? Sea weed? Fish eat other fish. Finding Nemo has a more realistic understanding of how the ocean works. Plus if they want eat our dogs, then they kinda lost the argument on being hippy dippies. Also why do people get mad about the Vietnamese ambassador line? People in Vietnam eat dogs in real life. The Indians think its disgusting that we eat cows and the Isrealis and Arabs think the same about eating pigs. Or the French think eating snails and frogs is normal. People eat different things around the world. Its not the complicated. Not to mention they started melting the ice caps 1st, so they don't get to play the victim, for the same reason Russia can't play the victim in the Ukranian War.

I hate the term'homo aqua' its makes 0 sense. Its embrassing and makes RTD and Pete McTighe look like idiots. They couldn't have just called them Ocenians or Aquerians or Neroans (from the Greek for water) or even Mizu the Japanese word for water. But they wanted to sound sicentifical (sic), so are just making fools of themselves. Also why did the ditch the Sea Devils voice? That was the best part, it was so bad ass. Even Warriors of the Deep and Legend remmbered to keep that.

Now I was dreading that they were going to do sexy dymorphism with the Sea Devils. Turns out I was half wrong. The beaky ones and the human looking ones are different sub speices. But they still have captain wet blanket fall in love with Salt and kiss it. I can't believe it. I can't believe they actually did that. Its so embrassing. Why is Salt in love with him? Why dose Salt have a personality transplant in episode 4? She is throwing bricks at windows and giggleing and screaming. She says she hates humans in 1-3 then she in 4 she makes out that she is like a priosner of the Sea Devils. But then she is back to being their ambassador in ep 5? Its so inconsistent.

Also the Sea Devils have no culture like at all. Like how is it that the Silurians in 1970 felt more like a real society than the Sea Devils do here? Like the Silurians talk to each other, they argue and disagree. You have the pro peace, the pro war and the por war but more cautious one. How is it that the keep screwing this up? Why do they have human faces now? If the answer is 'well audiances can't relate to non human looking beings' that is garbage. Did you cry more when Bambi's mother got shot or when Scar murders Mufasa or when Tadashi the big bro gets blown up in Big Hero 6? Or did you cry more when Marley dies in Marley and Me or when Old Yeller is killed vs Julia Roberts dying of plot diviceities in Oscarbait movie of the the week?

Talk about renforcing the prejudice its meant to be aganist. It be like if they made a movie about a white supermisist lady who is racist aganist Middle Eastners and but then she marries Izzat al-Douri https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/oct/29/izzat-ibrahim-al-douri-obituary

The pacing in this is terrible. It takes forever for anything to happen. Also there is no war. Like at all no battles nothing. Remmberance of the Daleks had battles in 1988. Why can't this?

Not to metion the humans creating a virus that kills most the Sea Devils is such a cheat. Why are UNIT so useless? Was giving it to Barclay and having it pass from him to Salt really the only way that could have been acheived? Given that she is an out cast? They couldn't have captured one and infected them that way? Also if the Sea Devils are able to just magic all the garbage out of the water, why didn't they do that before and just keep doing it until mankind burries it in the desert or something. How could they not check to see if that guy had a bomb? Why do the Sea Devils go back to chatting after the terrorist attack on them? Also that plot point of the terminally ill man on a kamekazi mission is a steal from Voyage of the Damned.

The dialouge is so bad in places. Like a gay joke about homo aqua, the rusty joke 'change the name of the planet to Ocean' made my laugh out loud at how silly it was. Also why is Barclay bone dry after coming out of the water? What is this Jaws the Revenge?

That being said, I did enjoy ep 4 the most. Mostly because that is were all the insanity happens, like Salt screaming and breaking windows. Its like RTD and Pete McTighe have reached this point and gone. 'Well most of it has been the conferance room and the hotel, its all a bit dull. Lets have some fun. Lets have Salt escape from her cage by opening the door from the inside, lets have her smash windows and act like Arial in the 2nd act of the Little Mermaid.'

Also since Barclay is half French, if this was a Moffat script that French general would turn out to be his granny or something. Also why no cummpance for our three baddies? You could have had them drown when the tank bursts at the end. Rather this half hearted cut away prophacy thing. If they are going to get away Scott free don't include that.

Now there were things I did unironically like. I liked General Austin Pierce he was cool. The human ambassador is kinda fun. Also that MCUNIT tower never shown once.

I can't say I hated it, but most is just well tap water. Just not memerable, other than the loony parts like Kate drawing a gun on a litter bug. But most is just so blase.

Also why did not one ever say 'nothing in the world can stop me now'? Come on that's an open goal