SPOILERS AHEAD FOR WICKER
Hello! I watched wicker a little while ago and I have some notes. This review may be a bit long and painful for some to read but hopefully not too bad.
So WHY do women like wicker so much?
**It’s largely because it’s a female power fantasy that objectifies the male lead and gives him no depth or human desire.** He’s her personal sex object, fix it device, “human” shield for protection, and arm candy to make other women envious.
It’s a movie that allows women to objectify men and reduce them down not to a complex person with desires, feelings, needs, aspirations etc but to a tool whose only purpose is to serve the female protagonist.
If you’ve read this far and disagree, please, I invite you, think of the most romantic lines in the movie “you’re the reason I live and breathe” “I was made for you,” “my love doesn’t require a promise”, why does he do chores? Oh “hes” (and by “he” I mean “it”) just “makes him happy” to do them. I invite you to reverse those scenes genderwise, now SHES the wicker woman, with all the same motivations (or lack there of) as the wicker man…
How does it sound? How does it feel? Like a poorly written male sex fantasy doesn’t it? Still don’t believe me? Ask yourself; if the roles were reversed if it would be interpreted as sexist by critics (I’ll save you the time the answer is yes) don’t believe me? Examine the feminist critiques of movies like “ ex machina” or “her”; while I agree both of those movies are far from perfect, they largely end as cautionary tales of man’s fantasies regarding women that end poorly for the male characters in them. Now imagine how sexist those movies would be if they had an ending similar to wicker with the two characters happily ever after.
Let’s go deeper; she sets him on fire, an act of homicidal abuse based on her own paranoia and willingness to trust the word of people who hate her instead of an object that is MAGICALLY BOUND TO LOVE HER AND HER OWNLY AND HAS SAID AS MUCH.
And the result? Is she punished for hurting the “man” she claims to love? Does he leave and never come back because no deserves to have that kind of devotion met with suspicion and violence? Nope, he comes back, loves her the same, she gets a wicker baby as a reward and the butch gets attacked by a wicker woman, implying that if a man should want the same thing that she does, he should ALSO be attacked.
Again ladies; let’s just reverse the tropes to see how it looks. Can you think of any mainstream films that commit this many objectifications of us while STILL ending happy and positive for the protagonist? There were a couple I found that were contenders, but they were either cautionary tales/Satirization of men’s fantasies (ruby sparks, her, ex machina, stepford wives) or pathetically poor performing as far as popularity (mannequin, weird science)
All and all it was a fun movie, I’m not here to trash it by any means, but it’s 🌽. And that’s fine! I like 🌽 we all do! But Ironically, acknowledging that’s what it is actually gives it greater depth as art; the movie really doesn’t do anything as far as exploring subversive themes, it’s just sexist in a way that is usually reserved for 🌽 but from the female perspective which again is totally fine, no reason not to enjoy it. But when we pretend like it’s a romance story that’s when it becomes sexist; it isn’t, he isn’t a person, he doesn’t have agency, he’s not compelled by anything approaching human connection or attraction, he doesn’t point out anything about her that makes her special to him, he is not a “he”, he is an “it”, the only romance in this movie would be the implication that it’s ok for women to love themselves and prioritize their own happiness. It is NOT a romance between two people with agency.
So did I hate the movie? No I loved it It actually depicts flat out what a lot of romantic movies are guilty of in one way or another which is making the male romantic leads shallow in some capacity while calling it love. It’s like a distillation of that trope and in my mind is brilliant and should be shown perhaps in college film courses for that reason.
Hope this hasn’t been too unpleasant for you all, do you agree? Disagree? I’d like to hear your thoughts.