r/flicks • • Aug 26 '24

Unpopular opinion: I don't like any of the Alien sequels, even Aliens

4 Upvotes

The original film for me is an absolute masterpiece of horror, and I grew up in the 90s. I know that everyone seems to love the sequel, Aliens, which I do think is a fine film. However, I could never get over how "easy" it became to suddenly kill the Xenomorphs. In the 1st film, the alien is a horrifying, almost omnipotent entity. It even seems to be bigger than any of the aliens that appear in Aliens (or the sequels). So, to see Ripley and the marines casually knock out 4-5 aliens at a time with just a few short bursts of their weapons, always killed the film for me.

It would be like seeing Danny Glover in "Predator 2" kill 3-4 Predators at a time with just a simple bullet to the chest. For me, it destroyed the mystique of the creature. This is why I always skip the sequels. For me, Ripley's fate at the end of Alien is in my imagination.

****My rating of the "core" series:
Alien - A +
Aliens - B
Alien 3 - C
Alien Resurrection - D
Alien: Romulus - B


r/flicks • • Oct 09 '24

The Oppenheimer score was overdone. Chris Nolan scored that movie to death

8 Upvotes

The movie was drowning in that score and I know everyone worships the score so I’m in the minority here but I absolutely hated it. A film’s score should not be used to replace amazing writing and acting, see: No Country for Old Men. Just my opinion of course but everyone seems to disagree with me on this. Did anyone else hate the score?


r/flicks • • Jan 13 '23

I feel like I'm in a super minority here but Everything Everywhere All At Once really wasn't that great to me.

144 Upvotes

I mean it was okay but its Wiki page had a line that compared to movies like The Godfather which I think is insane. It wasn't actually a direct comparison, they just mentioned that one of the sites had it ranked higher than Godfather for a time, or something like that. You can check the Wiki page yourself, I don't intend to take anything purposely out of context. Just speaking from rough memory.

So about the movie, like it seemed really reminiscent of the MCU type movies, which are movies I emphatically dislike, all round. The whole thing about parallel universes, I mean it's not like we haven't seen the idea before and everyone says that it was so well done in this one, but I don't know to me it still seemed as though everything was kind of all over the place. It was a little confusing and hard to follow because of how many things were happening at once and how much is like, thrown at you.

It just didn't hit me. Maybe all of its themes and deeper messages and what not flew over my head, but the thing is that isn't something that happens to me that often. I watch movies/stories all the time. If it was, I would be honest. But it's not really. I generally am able to understand and appreciate movies from vastly different genres and types quite easily and for what they are, rather than what I want them to be. But I don't really know what else to say. It just didn't hit me. It was kind of a bore to watch to be honest, especially in the latter half.

As a contrast, a movie that I very recently watched was the original Blade Runner from the 80s and I truly think that movie was one of the greatest ever made in the history of cinema. I like sci-fi and I liked Blade Runner so much and I was able to watch it and appreciate it as a story movie. Not a movie that has to dazzle you every few minutes with some crazy sci-fi stuff, special effects or just amazing CGI. I mean it was from the 80s. Just the writing, the acting and even the scenes from that movie were amazing for the 80s. Like tears lost in rain... That was such a moving speech/monologue. The philosophical themes that were explored I felt were very interesting and very deep. You know things like what it means to be alive or to have a soul, slavery of mind/body and things of that nature. Even the sequel was excellent.

So I don't know, maybe EEAAO is just not my type. I mean everyone has certain types, right? Strange as it sounds I feel... guilty (for lack of a better word) for not liking, like I'm doing something wrong. Just a way of explaining I don't literally feel guilty but like I just meant it because UNIVERSALLY everyone seems to say this is the greatest movie ever made.

On a positive note though I must say I really did like the scene with the rocks. For some reason I found myself quite attracted to that scene and I really cannot explain why. I just found it interesting and cool for some reason. That was about the main thing that stuck out to me.


r/flicks • • May 14 '22

Regardless of how people feel about the movie, It's undeniable that The Batman is the most faithful live action adaptation of the character.

0 Upvotes

For the longest time I've always felt like directors never liked or respected the source material. Tim Burton famously claimed he never read it, Nolan was forced to read it, Snyder was obsessed with one elseworld story. Although the Burton's aesthetic sensibilities helped him forge a very unique version of Gotham, a respectable contribution to the Batman mythos and so far the best adaptation of Batman to date. Reeves on the other hand is an actual fan of the character and an equally good if not a better craftsman than Burton.

Thus he was able to get all the elements right: Fantastic visuals and an imaginative Gotham, a noir story with a detective Batman, his psychological struggle, having a strict no kill rule, him being a symbol of hope and fantastic hand to hand action.

I think the biggest contribution from Reeves is washing away all the misconceptions from the Nolan trilogy which has quite frankly been a stain on the franchise. Yes, I consider him worse than Snyder, at least he gave Batman a great costume and combat skills. His arrogant "realistic" aka unimaginative take on the character convinced lot of people that you need to drastically change stuff from the source material to make a good movie(ironically what he created was overrated trash). It's clear he thought he was above the source material. Reeves has thoroughly trounced that belief. If some like Reeves, a far better visual storyteller than Nolan, can create what is arguably the greatest or at least one of the greatest comicbook movies of all time by being faithful to the source material then it shouldn't be a problem to anyone else.


r/flicks • • Dec 20 '21

Spirited Away: This film is so gosh dang charming that you don't realize how meandering and empty the actual plot actually is

0 Upvotes

Finally got around to watching this. Its an extremely charming movie full of wonderful characters and is brimming with creativity and life.

The problem is that all of that distracts you from how paper thin the actual plot is! Like for a movie that is widely claimed to be a work of genius and considered to be one of the greatest animated flicks of all time you would think they might have put a bit more effort into making a coherent plot.

Shen doesn't really do much of anything to actually rescue her parents other than charm various people into giving her various magical amulets just by being her cute self. And Ubaba's twin sister turns from a mean old hag who curses a baby into a kindly old grandma in an instant. It was weird and confusing to me.

It was really just various weird adventures Shen went on loosely tied together by her trying to save her parents except that nothing she did actually helped to save her parents!

anyway, the movie is still great and I thoroughly enjoyed it and recommend it. But the plot is paper thin at best.


r/flicks • • Feb 03 '25

Good films about being trans?

0 Upvotes

I recently watched Emilia Perez, and it was... not good, to say the least. So, r/flicks, can I have good trans movies to get the bad taste out of my mouth?


r/flicks • • Jun 20 '23

Actors You Hate For No Reason.

28 Upvotes

Tom Hardy for me.

The guys just comes off as a try-hard, scenery-chewing, "real thespian" type. "look at me! i'm acting!. there's something about the way he acts that I just never buy into his characters.

are there any actors you just don't like for petty or little to no reason?


r/flicks • • Jun 10 '22

Unpopular Opinion: The Batman isn't just best adaptation of Batman but it's also the first "true" live action adaptation of the character.

35 Upvotes

Now, this might seem a bit harsh but imo the previous iterations were Batmen in name alone. This was a result of either not caring about the source material(Burton) or only reading one or two comics to gain some basic knowledge on the lore(Snyder, Nolan).

For far too long Batman himself had been sidelined in favour of his villains. As though, the filmmakers didn't see anything interesting in Batman himself but rather were interested in the world of Batman or in Nolan's case using the IP to write his own Bond-in-Batsuit fanfiction(and unsurprisingly the quality of his writing was also something you'd expect on fanfiction.net). In comes Matt Reeves, not only a genuinely talented writer director but also someone who has obviously read a stack of Batman comics.

And you immediately notice this with the beautiful opening narration taken straight out of comics like year one. It's not just the opening narration but the fact that the entire film focuses on Batman's POV which is the approach that a vast majority of Batman comics utilise. Not just that, it's the first film to properly approach the troubled psyche of the character. Crime fighting to him isn't just a hobby that he can't wait to get out of like in Nolan films but a genuine obsession born out of childhood trauma. This is the man you'd expect to stay up all night, typing away at his computer still in his sweaty suit, his hairstill a mess from wearing that cowl and eyes red from his lack of sleep. Someone who dresses as a Bat up to punch criminals all night is most definitely a deeply troubled man and this is the first Batman film that actually seems to understand that facet of the character. You can genuinely feel this character is pushing himself to his phyiscal limits.

This is also the first film where Batman was finally allowed to be a detective. Gone are the days where the villains had magic clairvoyance and omniscience(Ledger's Joker) and the hero had magic technology(Bale's bullet finger print). None of that comically poor, plothole ridden writing that we saw in those Nolan films. We now had a believable and intriguing cat and mouse game between Batman and one of his villains. This was a proper detective noir film in the same vein as Se7en and Zodiac. It was so refreshing to see Batman threading clues and being a hardass in a crime scene.

I could on and on, while other interpretations with the exception of Nolan had gotten a few things right about Batman, this had almost everything. Great fight style like in BvS? Yep this one had it. A unique, hellish vision of Gotham like Burton? Yep this movie had it. Batman making his own suit and tech which we never saw in any live action film? Yep this movie had it. Most of all Batman being symbol of hope despite all the depressing shit happening around him, something that other films again ignored? Yep this film absolutely had it.

So if you're wondering why comic book fans who have been reading years worth of stories involving the character put this above every other adaptation, these are the reasons. Reeves understood the project and paid the utmost respect to the source material. As result, the broader audience got to experience a true to source Batman story for the first time in the big screen. Now, if Reeves can adapt characters like Robin, Mister Freeze and Poison ivy then this might be the greatest adaptation of Batman we've had bar none(yes even better than the animated series).


r/flicks • • Jan 20 '23

It’s weird that people find Licorice Pizza pedophilic

0 Upvotes

Without jumping too far into a spoilers, the movie is about a relationship between a 15 year old boy and a 25 year old girl. The boy is extremely charismatic and the girl is a normal, somewhat lost, mid-20s.

The dynamic between the duo is playful and hinges on the fact that he’s 15 going on 40 and she’s 25 going on 16. They’re somehow both normal and abnormal.

Their relationship isn’t romantic, to be clear, despite the boys greatest efforts. The girl recognizes the strangeness of their friendship, but also recognizes that there’s an undeniable chemistry between the two and for that reason she can’t just stop being friends with him.

Okay, now for the spoilers…

The movie is split into what I can only describe as episodes, that mostly revolve around their friendship being tested by her romantic suitors. Each of these scenarios are strange, oftentimes due to their own age gap, but ultimately result in the two coming back together.

The end of the film is controversial and I think for good reason, but I also think it’s largely misinterpreted. The boy kisses the girl and they literally run away together. There’s a strange moment where she says “I love you.” But I think this description doesn’t do the scene justice. It’s strange in a way that, frankly, I’m not sure it actually happened. And if it did, I’m still not positive the “I love you” was intended in a romantic sense.

In fact, I will go so far as to suggest that perhaps the movie is playing with our own expectations of relationships of two characters of different genders. Are we the problem for assuming this is a romantic relationship? Is the movie actually about a friendship but our own expectations led us to believe it was non-platonic? I’m not sure and I’m curious what others think.

Either way, I think this movie will be looked back on in a very positive light in ten years.


r/flicks • • Jan 08 '26

Why is Avatar seemingly the only movie where people accuse it of being "just this other story but in a different setting"

0 Upvotes

I find it really strange that whenever Avatar gets brought up you immediately get a ton of people shouting about how "It's just Dances with Wolves but in space!", as if that's at all unique to that movie. Pretty much every single movie in existence is a retelling of an older story. You don't see people saying "Oh it's just The Odyssey but in a different setting!" for every adventure movie that comes out. You don't see people being shocked when a new superhero movie comes out and it's yet again about a villain wanting to destroy the world. So why is Avatar constantly singled out for this rather meaningless criticism?

I have no real horse in this race. I think they're fine movies, decent popcorn entertainment. I'm just confused by the discourse surrounding these movies.

EDIT: I should clarify that I don't mean Avatar is the only movie that gets compared to other movies, I mean it seems to be the only one where the comparison is used to dismiss the movie's quality.


r/flicks • • Jul 26 '24

Can anyone recommend a rom/com that’s not about privileged white people?

2 Upvotes

I am an action, horror, art film guy. But nothing gets me sobbing like a good, romantic comedy.

I just watched “Somethings Gotta Give” with Jack Nicholson and Diane Lane, and while their chemistry is undeniable (I laughed, I cried) it’s just really hard to root for people who are a bunch of narcissistic successful assholes. Is there a romcom for us normal folk who can’t get off to Paris on a whim? What would you recommend?


r/flicks • • Jan 30 '25

What’s a movie where the humor has just aged badly.

0 Upvotes

This came up as I rewatched Hot Shots Part Deux - as goofy a movie as you can get and just dumb fun. But the torture scene was just… painful - and not because it was a torture scene :). Making fun of middle eastern folks like that was just super cringe.

I haven’t tried it but I also hear that the Austin powers movies just aren’t funny anymore, but I remember that as a hoot (at least the first one was)

What else has gone sour over time?


r/flicks • • Feb 19 '24

I saw Barbie again and it's even funnier the second time Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Hey all. This movie is just hilarious.

How many movie and pop culture references did you pick up on? Of course it starts with 2001: A Space Odyssey. You can see The Matrix - both the first one and Reloaded (when Barbie gets chased through the office, plus the infinite hallway).

That whole scene where they plot to take Barbie Land back from the Kens, when they play the Matchbox Twenty song (Push) is really funny. You can see the Kens riding imaginary horses (Monty Python and the Holy Grail), callouts to the Godfather, etc.

What other references did you see?

Additionally, it was worth it to see America Ferrera's rant, explaining to Barbie how hard it is to be a woman. I'm a man but, yes, I get it!

Kudos to Greta Gerwig and Noam Baumbach for such a clever script, and all the actors!


r/flicks • • Mar 05 '19

My Opinion of The Last Jedi (from someone who hasn't seen the Original Trilogy or Prequels)

15 Upvotes

Hello all, as you have seen I'm somewhat of a unicorn in this world as I haven't seen the Original Trilogy of Star Wars or the Prequel Trilogy (which I've heard is absolutely horrendous). The reason being my parents were never really huge fans of the films and never compelled us to watch them. I've gotten so far without watching them that I plan on finally seeing them once I get my own house with a cinema setup to experience them in their true glory.

When Disney started with the sequel trilogy however I did go to see Episode 7 and 8 with friends simply due to them being such a landmark of cinema and I wanted to be a part of the generation that watched them.

Episode 7 as much as I could tell was very similar to A New Hope (even though I haven't seen it it's practically impossible not to know the plot). But visually it was impressive and exciting in parts and I was interested to see where Episode 8 would take the story.

But man, I am still baffled at how the critics praised Episode 8 (91% on RT and an 85 on Metacritic!). From those scores it sounded like it was to be one of the best films of the decade and I was genuinely excited to see it. After watching it I was really shocked. I thought it was half parts boring (an extended space chase which could have been much more exciting, and that goddamn island) and the other half complete cringe-pipe bursting plotlines and characters (why is a film called Star Wars spending half an hour on a casino planet and spewing preachy nonsense about how animals should be free). The humour was so cheesy and felt really out of place in the film which started off with an interesting darker tone from the previous flick.

It doesn't help that some of the characters were really difficult to like, and that some of the actors can't act very well or overplay their roles.

I've never been invested in the OT characters so I wasn't too bothered about how they were treated in this new trilogy. I honestly believe if this wasn't a Star Wars film but a Sci-Fi film of a new franchise it would have been received much more harshly.

To make it more clear, apparently The Last Jedi was on par with, or close to, other films that year such as Logan, Dunkirk, Blade Runner 2049, Good Time and so on.

Just thought you would be interested in hearing from someone who has no vested interest in these films. What are your thoughts?

EDIT: Just to add I value all of your opinions and have been reading every response. Keep in mind it's just a discussion...


r/flicks • • Aug 01 '24

If not Ben Kingsley, who else could of played Gandhi?

0 Upvotes

Question, who else do you think could of played Gandhi if not Ben Kingsley?

I must looking up the casting for this project, it was crazy. Apparently, Attenborough considered a ling actors of actors that lated from the 1960s to 1980s, ranging from Alex Guiness, Anthony Hopkins, Dustin Hoffman, Al Pacino, Marlon Brando, Peter Falk, Albert Finney, Peter Sellers, Tom Courtney, & John Hurt.

Before Richard Attenborough got involved, David Lean wanted to make a film on Gandhi and hoped to cast Alec Guinness. However, Lean abandoned the project in favor of Lawrence Of Arabia. When Attenborough got involved in the 1960s, he too also considered Alec Guinness, however, Guinness told Attenborough, ""I'm too old too old too old too grey-eyed too heavy and just plain too old." Attenborough persevered. The film would focus on Gandhi as an old man, he argued, so really age was not a factor. Guinness stood firm. "Incidentally," he added, "this is the fourth time I've been asked - no, maybe fifth - to play Gandhi."

Anthony Hopkins was a funny story in this. In the 1970s i think, Attenborough offered him the lead role, when Hopkins called his father and told him the news, His Father replied, "Oh, it's a Comedy then, is it". John Hurt screen tested the role, but decided to not take the role, when he saw his screen test and felt he look "Utterly Ridiculous".

Dustin Hoffman expressed interest in the role, but was offered Tootsie and decided to take that role.

On the other choices "Some of the casting options in the Gandhi files make for comical reading. Albert Finney turned down the part, in rather gruff terms," writes Independent.ie. "Marlon Brando, fresh from playing the - bald, it's true, but - monstrously large Colonel Kurtz in Apocalypse Now, was proposed for the role of the starving leader. Dustin Hoffman ditto, as well as Al Pacino. Peter Falk - aka Columbo - came up, and so did, in the words of Attenborough, 'Peter Sellers (bless him)'."

"It may be unfair to laugh at these suggestions," The Daily Telegraph comments. "On the other hand, each of them conjures such a radically different Gandhi that to imagine them in the role is to create a mental comic strip of improbable casting - Michael Corleone as Gandhi, anyone? Lenny Bruce? Inspector Clouseau?"

Godfather as Gandhi, anyone? - Telegraph India

Overall, I am glad Ben Kinglsey got the role of Gandhi and I think that was once-in-a-lifetime Casting, but I just can't wonder what if another person played the role of Gandhi.

Who else do you think could of played Gandhi if not Ben Kingsley?


r/flicks • • Oct 02 '24

Megalopolis was...AWESOME!

21 Upvotes

So I saw Megalopolis tonight. For starters, it's definitely a tribute to Fritz Lang's Metropolis. Just like that silent epic, this film is a political essay. You don't have to follow politics closely in order to see the parallels to what is occuring in the United States. There is also the same plea for the elimination of polarization and coming together for the sake of posterity. The message is clear but, sometimes, the narrative is muddled. I think the film is filled with visual splendor. There are times when they complement the characters beautifully. Specifically, I refer to the moments when Cesar is utilizing his imagination. I will admit I was a bit confused about if he actually possessed the power to manipulate time. I suppose the answer is deliberately meant to remain a mystery and I complement Coppola for as much. Films don't have to constantly hold your hand. Regarding the performances, the major players are excellent. Adam Driver has once again proven that he's one of the most gifted actors of his generation. His character is an odd ball artist living within himself but Driver rarely gives into the temptation of being hammy. Shia Le Boeuf serves as the main antagonist and it's quite obvious who he modeled his performance after: Rich kid, narcissistic, immature, and becoming the face of a populist movement. Lawrence Fishburne is the film's narrator and primary assistant of Driver's Cesar and he's a welcome presence. He is a guide to all the madness but thankfully, he doesn't spell everything out. Coppola trusts the audience to do the thinking. Also, I should mention that there are homages to other films such as The Night of The Hunter, Vertigo, and even the RKO Studio Logo.

So, did it live up to the hype? I personally kept my expectations high but not unrealistic. I had a feeling some of it may be sour and there are few too many times when I wish Frank would hold back regarding the visuals. Though obviously not an original concept, this film is still a breath of fresh air regarding major Hollywood filmmaking. This is big budget spectacle that isn't some pre-established franchise. I enjoyed myself and I say, Bravo Francis. You did a hell of a job.

Lastly, a question for group: Did you hear a lot of inappropriate laughter from the audience? The film does feature comedy but unfortunately, this is the first time I have ever experienced so many bad laughs for a contemporary film. I was baffled and annoyed by these vulgar reactions. I was strongly tempted to yell, "What the fuck is so funny?".


r/flicks • • Feb 11 '24

I feel like Jaws isn't talked about enough anymore.

26 Upvotes

Omg sorry I ruined everyone's day lol


r/flicks • • Apr 26 '24

We need to talk about, "Full Metal Jacket" (1987).

2 Upvotes

I recently saw the 1987 war film, "Full metal Jacket". I went in with no expectations; I had no idea what it might be like. I just wanted to check it out.

To say the least, I was absolutely blown away.

So the film treats about a soldier nicknamed Joker. It follows his military journey across two different stages.

The first part of the film shows his and his comrades' training under an abusive drill sergeant. Joker is promoted to squad leader after he says he does not believe in the Virgin Mary and that he won't say anything else, because whatever answer he gives it will be wrong. Joker also befriends a fat guy called Pyle. Unfortunately, Pyle suffers a mental breakdown, which leads to a tragedy.

In the second part of the film, Joker is seen while serving in Vietnam. He is a military correspondent, and gets to witness all the brutality of the war.

Like, what a great movie that is. Brilliant directing, acting, cinematography. I think it may actually be one of the best war movies of all time?

I especially have to mention the actor who played the Drill Sergeant in the movie. He did such a good job! Who said that? Who the FUCK said that?.

I like the scene at the end which shows the Marines singing, "M-I-C, K-E-Y, M-O-U-S-E!".

I was wondering, has anybody else here actually seen this movie? What do you think about it?

I can't believe no one is talking about that movie.


r/flicks • • Jan 04 '23

"Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery" is an electrifying improvement...

5 Upvotes

Writer/director Rian Johnson has created a superior followup to “Knives Out”, and Daniel Craig’s Benoit Blanc certainly has what it takes to lead a few more of these films. Hopefully future entries in this series will drop the unnecessary “Knives Out” subtitle in favor of “A Benoit Blanc Mystery.” I understand why the parent film’s subtitle was needed this time, but I’m hoping Rian Johnson’s Benoit Blanc might someday earn the same brand-name recognition as Sherlock Holmes, Hercule Poirot, Miss Marple, or at the very least, Frank Columbo.

With fewer characters, a smartly-sequestered setting, and a ticking clock, “Glass Onion” runs a lot swifter than “Knives Out”, despite its slightly longer running time of 139 minutes. This “Onion” is well worth slicing into.

https://musingsofamiddleagedgeek.blog/2023/01/04/glass-onion-a-knives-out-mystery-is-an-electrifying-improvement/


r/flicks • • Feb 21 '25

Why is The Shawshank Redemption #1 on IMDB

1 Upvotes

For as long as I can remember, shawshank redemption has the highest rated movie on IMDB. Don't get me wrong.It's a great film, but is it really number one? Is it really the greatest film of all time? I always wondered why not Casablanca, or the Wizard of Oz, or Citizen Kane? There are plenty of other serious contenders for this title. Why this one?


r/flicks • • Feb 17 '25

I couldn’t finish The Bikeriders because Austin Butler was too handsome

0 Upvotes

Title says it all. I overall enjoyed the movie, but my god was Austin Butler miscast. He’s way too modern handsome and skinny to be believable as a fist fighting mid century biker. Usually it’s pretty hard to take me out of a movie, but I just didn’t buy any of it. Kinda encapsulated to me how crappy casting has been for leading men in the last few years. There’s not a lot of room for rough around the edges type. IMO Sebastian Stan would have been a good fit for that role


r/flicks • • Feb 14 '26

A Mumbai gangster got his nickname "Ustara" (razor blade) because his knife work was so precise that doctors couldn't believe the surgical nature of the cuts

7 Upvotes

Hussain Sheikh operated in Mumbai's underworld in the 1980s-90s. After a particularly brutal fight where his blade work was extremely precise, he earned the nickname "Ustara" - meaning barber's razor.

Despite this reputation, he reportedly: 1/ dressed simply 2/ spoke politely 3/ remained calm in confrontations 4/ neighbors thought he was an accountant

He was the only major gangster who refused to join Dawood Ibrahim's cartel, and was eventually eliminated along with his partner (who had tried to assassinate Dawood at a cricket match).

An Indian film ( O Romeo )about him just released. His daughter sued claiming it defames him. Court dismissed her case.


r/flicks • • Feb 02 '25

Superbad or Pineapple Express?

0 Upvotes

Which film do lean more towards??


r/flicks • • Apr 05 '26

The Super Mario Galaxy Movie: The most audience-insulting cash-grab in recent memory

0 Upvotes

There are 1.36 billion reasons why The Super Mario Galaxy Movie needs to exist, none of which are good on any creative or entertainment level. Look, I get that big-budget IP movies like this is designed to make money. But this is easily the most audience-insulting cash-grab in recent memory. F1: The Movie and Jurassic World Rebirth are masterpieces compared to this.

On every single conceivable creative level, this is a depressing rock bottom for what movies can be in 2026. Comparing it to rock bottom is an insult to rocks and bottoms. At least rocks can make me feel something after I hit my head against them, unlike this dumpster fire I just watched.

The first movie is far from accomplished, but it at least had moments of imagination, like the linking of the ‘real’ world with the Mushroom Kingdom via warp pipe and funny visual gags with the penguins from the Snow Kingdom. This movie, by dispiriting contrast, is a 98-minute sugar rush of non-stop action set pieces, all of which are stuffed with Easter eggs from various Mario games. It’s almost like the movie is desperately asking us, ‘are you having fun yet?!?’

While there’s a plot in the most threadbare definition of the word - Mario and gang need to save Rosalina from Bowser and Bowser Jr. - there’s no semblance of an actual story to be found. Any hints of a potential storyline - like the father-son story with the Bowsers - are almost immediately dropped in favour of more ‘remember this level/power up/monster from the video games?!?’. What’s doubly baffling about this pandering approach is how the movie moves so quickly that there’s no room for audiences to appreciate anything.

By trying to appeal to Mario fans’ nostalgia in such a nakedly embarrassing way, all the characters are effectively sidelined. Every single speaking character has no more than a handful of lines, and those that made the cut are pure exposition or dumb jokes with no punchline. Why this movie even bothered to expand its voice cast to include Brie Larson, Glen Powell, Donald Glover, and Benny Safdie escapes me because the script might as well be non-existent. The Super Mario Galaxy Movie could’ve been a literal wordless movie and still had the same effect. Kudos to the whole voice cast for what must’ve been the easiest job of their whole careers.

Young kids are obviously the main audience for The Super Mario Galaxy Movie, but the emptiness of all the visual chaos is so dire that we need to have a serious intervention on the quality of content we serve them. Kids may not understand the nuance or subtext of something like Ratatouille, but at least that movie doesn’t insult their intelligence. Hell, even Zootopia 2 had some kind of family-friendly moral message about tolerance. This, on the other hand, is the purest distillation of ‘minimal effort’ in the form an overwhelmingly colourful pile of brain rot that’s as insulting as it is lazy, almost like the filmmakers are outright disdainful of their young audience.

Please read the rest of my review here as the rest is too unwieldy to copy + paste: https://panoramafilmthoughts.substack.com/p/the-super-mario-galaxy-movie

Thanks!