r/ffxivmeta • • Jun 12 '23

Announcement Why is /r/ffxiv set to private?

81 Upvotes

Hi friends,

You may have ended up here after noticing that /r/ffxiv is currently set to private. That's because our community is participating in a site-wide protest after reddit announced massive, unreasonable changes to their API. The changes will kill off most major 3rd party apps and significantly harm users who rely on those apps for moderation tools and accessibility features.

Over 3,000 subreddits (and counting!) have chosen to participate in this protest and after bringing the subject to our community, you all overwhelming voiced your support to participate as well.

As a result, /r/ffxiv will remain set to private until June 19th. On that day, we will reopen the subreddit in restricted mode in order to poll our community again and determine if you still wish to keep the blackout going. If the answer is yes, the subreddit will go private again for another 7 days and then we'll repeat the process.

In the meantime, we welcome you all to join our discord server! We've setup a special forum channel called #ffxiv-questions to act as a replacement for our popular Daily Questions thread. It has threaded replies for each individual question which should hopefully be a bit more familiar to those of you who prefer reddit over discord.


r/ffxivmeta • • Apr 14 '20

Feedback So what’s the point of having a discussion if mods just delete everything that isn’t fan art?

57 Upvotes

A good post with hundreds of comments. With discussions, with a way for people to vent. With tips how to play better with a specific role or job. A post with an important message.

And you delete it because OP had the idea for this post because of an experience in DF. Do you not want healthy discussions on r/ffxiv ?


r/ffxivmeta • • Jul 17 '19

About the rules Inconsistent Rules Again

57 Upvotes

I was once told to post here by a member of the mod team if I ever felt a removal was unjustified so I'm doing just that.

Earlier this image was posted to the subreddit and subsequently removed due to being too unrelated to FFXIV.

As you can see in the second link, the moderator who removed it said this Donald Duck cosplay was completely acceptable while the removed Doom Guy cosplay was not. The only difference between the two is that the Doom Guy cosplay was edited to be placed into a Doom environment with the Doom title, while Donald Duck was just a picture of gpose with a reshade mod on. Arguably the quality of the cosplay could be in question here, but that isn't the rule and mods should not be removing cosplay posts they see as inaccurate. The community can handle this with voting.

Arguably, if Doom Guy poster hadn't gone the extra mile and edited their image to fit the cosplay, their post would have remained.

This is in direct conflict with the low effort post rule. This user made the extra effort to make the rest of their image fit the cosplay they wanted to post. The subsequent removal of the mentioned post is a flagrant example of how the rules of what is and is not acceptable to post are broken and need to be reworked.

With the amount of reposting, should-be-in-daily-questions, and other similar content, it's astounding a mod would remove this post and then have the audacity to not recognize the hypocrisy the OP pointed out.


r/ffxivmeta • • Jan 04 '22

Suggestion Can we finally ban "got all my jobs to Level X!" posts?

46 Upvotes

Every expansion brings more and more of these posts about players getting their jobs to max level. They are all identical and add nothing to the subreddit in terms of discussion.


r/ffxivmeta • • Jul 21 '19

Suggestion Can we get a crackdown on masturbatory "PSAs" that literally everyone on this sub already knows?

46 Upvotes

I'm talking about threads like:
PSA - try to upgrade your gear as you level
PSA - don't be rude to people
Etc

Threads like these add nothing of value to the sub.


r/ffxivmeta • • Apr 20 '19

Discussion When your users are using the designated shitposting sub to seek actual discussion, there is a problem that absolutely, unequivocally needs to be resolved. More mods isn't that solution.

46 Upvotes

See:

https://np.reddit.com/r/ShitpostXIV/comments/bf7c9e/this_game_is_a_disaster_on_the_technical_side_of/?st=juowd2uy&sh=5057607a

Keep in mind this happens once or twice every few days.

Look. Over the last few days, the main sub has gotten some posts that have shown clear disinterest from the mod team to fix fundamental issues, along with the sub's users expressing clear dissatisfaction on the state of the sub. Don't even get me started on the travesty that is /u/Alberto-Balsalm and their general attitude.

Look. Modding is hard work. It becomes a lot harder when half the mods don't give a shit and even harder when there are severe, fundamental issues with the sub itself (95% change of a submission being downvoted instantly, which DOES influence conversation on a psychological level. Google the latter if you need to). If the current team can't cut it, you should relinquish your positions and fill a new team.

Some of the long standing issues are just that: Longstanding. Back in BETA for 2.0, downvote storms were present. You can't tell me you have something in the pipeline. You don't have to R&D for 5+ years to communicate and try things.

Short of it is, the quality and issues on the main sub are so severe that the Shitpost sub is being used when someone wants to have a real discussion. Something needs to be done. What we've seen from this mod team, in the last few days, indicates that you guys don't really give a shit. I kinda need you to.


r/ffxivmeta • • Jan 31 '22

Suggestion I think we need to temp ban "Lalafell in the Pool"posts

41 Upvotes

They have been getting out of hand, but this last one has an entire paragraph written out in smaller font. This is always the sign of a meme being dead-horsed.

Maybe a month long ban, to give people time to regain their god damn senses.


r/ffxivmeta • • Nov 04 '21

Discussion When are you going to ban WoW posts that doesn't serve any purpose other than shitting on WoW?

36 Upvotes

What's the point of these posts on the mainsub? They are irrelevant to XIV and I don't come to /r/ffxiv to see WoW posts

I know, WoW bad, FFIXV good, as a WoW refugee this is the best game ever etc. I just don't see why they can't be banned. I always downvote and report them because as a peasant you can't do anymore (see the rule: All content should be FFXIV-related and/or on-topic.)

And the comments are ALL about WoW. Even if someone pastes a XIV related element to the picture, or the title implies that, people are still talking about WoW. There is no discussion about XIV at all. I don't get why they are not removed. If people want to talk about WoW there are certainly better places than /r/ffxiv

And it will be just worse after EW. Cause guess nothing will happen with them


r/ffxivmeta • • Feb 01 '19

Announcement If you come across RMT ads on Reddit

33 Upvotes

We cannot control Reddit ads, so I would recommend sending a modmail to /r/reddit.com with a screenshot of the ad to report it to the admins. I'd also suggest sending us a modmail to loop us in, as the admins at times do not understand what RMT/goldspammers are and may ignore the report. If necessary I will take it to /r/ModSupport if they do ignore our reports. Sigh.

If you're not familiar with RMT, we have some info on our wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/wiki/rmt


r/ffxivmeta • • Nov 10 '21

Discussion Is there a FFXIV sub for actual game discussion?

31 Upvotes

r/ffxiv is pretty much exclusively fan art and memes at this point and it seems pretty clear that that's what people want it to be. I have completely stopped visiting the sub as a result. Is there another sub that has actual game content such as expansion discussion, news, job discussions, speculations, etc or has all of that been silo'd into discord communities?


r/ffxivmeta • • Jul 22 '21

Suggestion "Let sprouts watch cutscenes" posts

31 Upvotes

I think we've gotten enough of them in the last weeks (right now there are 2 at top).

Shouldn't they be considered repetitive posts at this point?

Cheers o/


r/ffxivmeta • • Apr 14 '20

Announcement An upcoming change to the spoiler rule

31 Upvotes

Greetings Warriors of Darkness! Rule 3 is our spoiler rule which can be summarized as:

  • Posts containing spoilers should be flagged as spoiler.

  • Titles should never contain spoilers.

  • Comments containing spoilers outside of a post flagged as a spoiler (or a different context) should be marked as a spoiler.

As FFXIV continues to expand, the number of expansions and their stories also continues to grow. This results in posts being marked as a spoiler with users often unaware of the context of this spoiler, which is an issue for players who are not caught up in the MSQ or similar story-driven content. Is the post a Heavensward spoiler? A Shadowbringers (5.0) spoiler? Or is it maybe even a patch 5.2 spoiler?

The subreddit is not exclusively for players caught up in FFXIV and we of course welcome new players as well. Thus we have seen increased demand to resolve this situation on the subreddit; so here are the changes we have prepared:

  1. The existing spoiler rule remains in place.

  2. An addendum is made to the rule: All spoiler posts must contain in the title "[Spoiler: x]" where x is the context of the spoiler.

Below (before the change) is an example of a post flagged as a spoiler with the title of:

  • Warrior of Oops

After the change it should be:

  • Warrior of Oops [Spoiler: Eden's Verse]

We are not going to heavily enforce how users word the context nor will we enforce where this text requirement goes; users are welcome to position it at the beginning or end of the post title. The context wording could be something like "Patch 5.2" or "Eden's Verse", anything to give the spoiler some context. [EDIT: You should also ensure the context wording itself is vague enough to not be a spoiler.] If a spoiler post is made without the context and brackets, it will be removed and the user asked to re-submit it with the corrected title.

Regarding comment spoilers, there are no changes to the spoiler rule for comments quite yet. We'd like to move forward on the above change and monitor the outcome from it first.

This rule change is scheduled to go live on April 20th to allow us time to answer any questions and communicate this out ahead of time. Thank you for reading and please let us know if you have any questions!


r/ffxivmeta • • Aug 06 '19

About the rules Rules Still Enforced Inconsistently

31 Upvotes

Here we are again for good ol' round two.

Prior to the rules update, I had been assured multiple times the rules were being revamped and would be more clear, more precise as to their meaning.

But here we are, Rule 4a, the love child of the previous 4 and 9, is being used as justification to remove posts inconsistently, and frankly it looks like it's being done by the whims of the mods and nothing more. They like it? It stays up. They don't like it? Down it goes.

Let's just begin, shall we?

Now, the last time I made this thread, there was a post by a moderator that, on new content, rules get a little lax. Example:
17 Days Ago, literally just a tooltip STAYED
[18 Days ago, pretty good post, love it STAYED] (https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/comments/cfbepj/i_wasnt_expecting_something_this_hot/)
18 Days ago, one of the few "Titan Kart" posts that weren't removed STAYED
16 Days Ago, pretty decent joke REMOVED

Let's keep these in mind, shall we?

16 Hours Ago, a couple of FFXIV pieces, but not much STAYED the amount of FFXIV content in this post is extremely minimal, and is important later.
18 Hours Ago, Just a Tooltip, again STAYED keep this in mind like the popoto one.
2 Days Ago, about 50% FFXIV content in the image STAYED did pretty decently for the subreddit.
2 Days Ago, less than 50% FFXIV content in the image STAYED didn't do well, didn't touch the front page, but stayed.
3 Days Ago, Literally a Webcomic with just the FFXIV logo on it once STAYED but it was pretty popular, so mods clearly let it through, bending the rules.
3 Days Ago, GIF but little FFXIV content STAYED guess it's a little higher effort?
3 Days Ago, an image from Praetorium with a restroom sign on it STAYED that's some low effort posting. Didn't do well, so that's not an excuse.
15 Days Ago, a couple of icons on a meme template STAYED guess icons make the image. Anything is okay if we throw an icon or two on it. This one did okay, but wasn't removed. No popularity saving it, so why'd it stay?
15 Days Ago, a "Me and the boys" meme STAYED do I need to add comments here?

Let's look at some removed posts, eh?
6 Hours Ago, 4 Panel Comic w/ FFXIV content REMOVED more icons than the PC heater comic, but apparently still removed?
4 Days Ago, little FFXIV content REMOVED really not any less than that webcomic though, huh? Was doing decently well until it was removed too. Why remove it? Mods clearly bend the rules for other posts so why not this one?
4 Days Ago, more logos on a 4-panel comic REMOVED I get the black part should have been cropped, clearly a cardinal sin, but it still has more FFXIV content on it than that "Use FFXIV to warm myself" comic. The content matter and execution is exactly the same as the GIF, albeit not a GIF. So why was this removed? Well, it's at 0 points and it took the mods hours to remove it. Thought provoking, no?
6 Days Ago, no FFXIV content, just mentions REMOVED I think you get where I'm going with this.
6 Days Ago, no FFXIV content except the title REMOVED I'm a strong advocate for titles adding context. Heck, it was even doing pretty well right off the bat. Still removed though. Guess they should have added a logo somewhere? Maybe the DNC job icon on his face. That would have saved it, right? That, at least, is how it's looking.
7 Days Ago, just the DC symbol with some relating text to FFXIV REMOVED come now, 4 panel comics are clearly allowed.
7 Days Ago, Living Dead tooltip + more panels REMOVED well well well, tooltips are allowed though, right? The cookie and popoto ones stayed. I guess this was removed because they added a line of jokes after it? Woof. Guess they should have put it in the title. Titles seem to be avoided for context.
15 Days Ago, no FFXIV content, just a title for context REMOVED toss on Derplander's face and it would have been safe?

A few things should be clear by now.

  • Rule 4a is being enforced inconsistently

  • Popularity has nothing to do with a post skirting the rules.

  • A single FFXIV icon means the post is allowed.

  • Unless a mod decides it's not enough.

  • Mods are removing posts based on their own whims.

The final point is the one I want to really drive home. We've seen popular posts, not popular posts, FFXIV devoid posts, and FFXIV abundant posts all removed or kept around to no level of consistency. The mods are clearly removing content based on what they think adheres to the rules or what they like.

Rule 4a needs to go. On several of the posts that stayed you can see that, as a subreddit, we are able to decide through Reddit's voting system, what we want on the front page. It is ridiculous that the moderation team believes the community needs this level of babysitting.

Because he wanted to be tagged when I posted this: /u/Izeyashe tags don't work on text posts.

Edit: Look at this! Not a single FFXIV item in the picture! STAYED


r/ffxivmeta • • Apr 13 '23

Suggestion Modded screenshot flair needed

30 Upvotes

There have been many screenshots recently that have been heavily modded to change appearance, glamours, or quality of lighting. All of these are misleading to the flair "in-game screenshot" and often people asks questions how to obtain certain looks in game when actually it's impossible.

So I suggest adding "Modded screenshot" or something similar.


r/ffxivmeta • • Oct 24 '19

Discussion A report on Discussion, Memes, and Upvotes.

30 Upvotes

The Daily Discussion Prompt Trial

About two weeks ago, we trialed a Daily Discussion Prompt daily post. Our intent was to encourage more discussion on the subreddit and to see if our subscribers would enjoy some general discussion prompts that weren't necessarily related to current news and content. I came up with some fluffy questions and paired them with an anecdote, then sat back to see how people responded. And the results were extremely interesting:

The thing that really interested me was the ratio to karma to comments. As of the moment I'm writing this post, here is the upvote/comment ratio for each post:

  • Tuesday - 9 karma, 56 comments = 0.16 karma per comment

  • Monday - 27 karma, 42 comments = 0.64 karma per comment

  • Sunday - 15 karma, 71 comments = 0.21 karma per comment

  • Saturday - 13 karma, 66 comments = 0.19 karma per comment

  • Friday - 17 karma, 27 comments = 0.63 karma per comment

  • Thursday - 12 karma, 51 comments = 0.24 karma per comment

  • Wednesday 15 karma, 46 comments = 0.33 karma per comment

Or in total: 108 karma, 359 comments = 0.3 karma per comment

Now, this doesn't take into account the fact that users can only upvote or downvote once, while they can comment as many times as they want. There's also some bias due to the threads being distinguished by a mod, and that the subject matter was opinions and fluff rather than something more engaging like theorycrafting (this is something I would change if we turned the discussion prompts into a regular feature).

Because I only did seven daily discussion prompts, I decided that we needed to look at a larger data pool to come to a conclusion. For that purpose I (foolishly) manually gathered data on seven days worth of Discussion tagged posts, alongside News posts and the often contested Meme and Fanart tags.

In Comparison: News VS Discussion VS Memes VS Fan Art

In this link you can find my terrible spreadsheet containing the data I used to get the resulting numbers. But for those of you who don't want to load a google spreadsheet, here's a chart of the results:

PostsKarmaCommentsKarma per PostComm. per PostKarma per Comm.
News63,5912,178598.53631.65
Discussion1122,6665,11923.8145.710.53
Memes3916,3112,623418.2467.266.22
Fan Art3915,345979393.4725.1115.68

Disclaimer: The above data doesn't include posts which were removed for rule violations.

As we can see, the ratio of karma per comment on Discussion tagged posts is shockingly low in comparison to News, Memes, and Fanart. While it's no surprise that News generates a higher ratio of comments per post than anything else, I was very surprised to see that Memes are in second place while Discussion is in third. Memes even generate more karma than Fanart posts. Fanart itself generates the lowest number of comments while also generating a high karma ratio per comment.

Here are some more interesting data points on Discussion posts in specific:

  • Out of 112 Discussion posts, 9 had generated more than one hundred karma.

  • Out of 112 Discussion posts, 12 had more karma than comments.

  • Out of 112 Discussion posts, 57 had zero karma.

  • Out of 57 Discussion posts with zero karma, 20 had more than twenty five comments.

Can we use this data to draw a conclusion?

There's a common argument, not only in this subreddit, but across fandom-based subreddits in general, that memes and fanart drown out serious discussion.

Admittedly, the pool of data is small; if this was a proper study with web scraping rather than me just copy-pastaing a weeks worth of tags into a spreadsheet and adding it up manually, we would also be comparing Questions, Screenshots, stickied daily threads, and every other tag over the past several months. This was also a week with a liveletter, which will skew the data compared to slow news weeks.

But when we look at the data I did gather, we notice that Discussion posts do not generate karma, even when users are engaging with those posts. In contrast, Memes generate both a respectable number of karma and comments, while Fanart generates karma while not being as engaging as Memes. News posts generate a pretty health karma to comment ratio.

So why does Discussion wallow at the bottom of the front page, even while people are engaging and commenting on it? I can't say for sure, but I have some ideas. After trialing the Daily Discussion Prompt, I don't feel it's necessary to add it as a permanent feature; plenty of perfectly good discussion posts arise naturally on a daily basis. The problem is... people don't seem to upvote discussion. Perhaps the ratio is so bad because people are downvoting discussion they disagree with? Or maybe users who read and comment simply forget to upvote the post after they've contributed to it?

I feel the key aspect here is that discussion posts lack visual content.

Visual content is easy to engage with. When you're redditing from your toilet, scrolling down the front page looking for entertainment, it's so easy to click on an image, look at it for a few seconds, chuckle, and then press the updoot button. The average user probably won't have any qualms about upvoting a well-drawn piece of fanart even if they have nothing to say about it. Memes are especially relatable; they're easy to make and easy to share. There's an extremely interesting book titled Memes in Digital Culture that I'd recommend for anyone interested in why memes become viral. Discussion, on the other hand, requires time to read the post and time to write a response. Because Discussion posts demand more effort to engage with, the silent majority of lurkers will just scroll past them without interacting at all.

Should something be done about it?

Ever since the rules on low-effort content were relaxed to allow memes, the r/ffxiv moderators have been monitoring the situation closely. As we can see from the data above, memes are popular and engaging, generate discussion, and don't seem to take any real estate away from News posts. What can be done when even the devs are making meme templates?

We still get complaints about the overabundance of Memes and Fanart, and the fact that serious Discussion posts never gain traction. While it is possible for us to make restrictions on Memes and Fanart, or ban them from the subreddit outright, there's no guarantee that this will suddenly make Discussion posts more popular.

Some subreddits have discussion-only days where visual content posts are banned. While this might make Discussion posts more visible on the front page, will it mean those threads will get more comments and upvotes than they already do? Other subreddits disable the downvote button to prevent undue karma loss, but this is only possible in certain browser configurations, and doesn't stop people from maliciously downvoting in retaliation for the button being gone.

We are certainly always welcome to ideas and opinions, but as far as we can tell... the best way we can promote Discussion on the subreddit without removing or restricting non-discussion content is by reminding everyone to upvote it.

TL;DR

If you like Discussion posts, upvote them.

Also use tag filters.


r/ffxivmeta • • Jan 29 '23

Feedback Would you guys consider limiting Non-OC / Found OC art like how some other subreddits do?

29 Upvotes

Let me preface this by saying I'm not an artist. I'm just an average user of the sub. I do not have an a-artist's mindset to bring to this discussion. Just an observer's.

Something like "Non-OC content only allowed on X day. Must include artist source. Users are limited to Y amount of Non-OC posts a day." I feel like it floods the reddit with a lot of artwork. At the moment I believe the artist source is required and I think just about everyone who posts non-OC art does a good job at following that rule. However, that said I think adding a few more rules might make finding discussions easier.

I just think it's a bit much when one specific user(s) can post Non-OC on a daily basis. Especially whenever it's clearly for karma farming purposes.

I primarily think that posting art from another person doesn't provide much in the way of discussion. If artists want to have their artwork posted they'll probably post where they would like it, especially since some artists do not like having their artwork reposted. Again, I'm not an artist so I can't speak for them but we have a "OC" tag for when they would like to.

I don't think Non-OC content should be completely banned, just limited to a specific day of the week with some regulations on how often you can post non-OC content that day would be nice. I believe the main final fantasy sub recently implemented a rule like this due to a feedback poll they did.

What are your thoughts on the matter? Also I apologize for any typos within this long post.


r/ffxivmeta • • Jun 12 '19

Announcement [META] Subreddit plans around the Shadowbringers launch

27 Upvotes

Launch Plans

I hope that everyone is looking forward to the Shadowbringers launch at the end of this month! In preparation, we wanted to present what the subreddit plans are for the launch period.

  • Daily questions megathread: As usual, this daily thread remains pinned in the first spot.

  • Shadowbringers megathread: This will be a pinned thread that is rotated daily (day 1, day 2, etc) as a general-purpose thread for the expansion. This thread does not restrict any other threads from being posted, so general Shadowbringers posts can still be made if they meet the standard rules.

  • Character creation (Viera/Hrothgar) megathread: A megathread for all character creation screenshots, especially for Viera & Hrothgar. Character creation screenshots are restricted to only this thread. This will be linked to from the megathread mentioned above.

As a reminder, Reddit limits subreddits to only 2 pinned post so we've chosen the two above for that. The body of the Shadowbringers megathread will contain a link to other important threads, informational updates (such as our friend Raubahn EX if necessary), and a reminder of spoiler formatting. We can create additional megathreads as needed, but we're trying to stay somewhat light on the megathreads so the subreddit flows naturally. Feedback is welcome on the above.

Spoilers

Just the typical reminder regarding rule 3 that spoilers are required to be tagged. No spoilers in thread titles. Any threads that contain spoilers in the body should be marked as "spoiler" with the spoiler button on Reddit.

Any spoilers in a comment (unless the thread is marked as a spoiler and the context is the same) should be formatted with our new system:

>!Dwarves are delicious food!<

Dwarves are delicious food

We recommend testing the spoiler formatting, as any improperly formatted spoilers will be removed (no spaces should be next to the ! at the start/end). If you see any spoilers not marked as such, be sure to report them for us to review ASAP.

Shadowbringers

I hope everyone is excited for the upcoming expansion!


As just a reminder, we have our subreddit redesign contest open until the 19th. Win some neat prizes!


r/ffxivmeta • • May 05 '18

Feedback Final Fantasy XIV Modding Discussion in Regards to /r/ffxiv - We want YOUR feedback

26 Upvotes

Hey /r/ffxiv!

Some of you may have noticed lately that a number of posts have gone up advocating the use of mods soley for cosmetic purposes. For example, texture mods, minor model edits, imports from non-FFXIV sources etc.

We'd like to discuss this with the subreddit before making any final decisions. Behind the scenes, we've spoken about it and agreed that mods that are client-side only and essentially invisible to everyone else (much like the use of ACT) should be okay to be discussed.

This would mean people are welcome to post pictures and information related to any mods for FFXIV - with a few specific exceptions mainly items that are available via Mog Station or may potentially be available via MS in the future (e.g. NPC gear, mounts, etc).

"But why is this okay? Isn't it against FFXIV's own ToS?"

Yes, it is 100% against the ToS of FFXIV to mod your game. But we also allow threads on datamining. And the usage of ACT. This is why we want the opinions of more than just a couple of green-named people behind closed doors. If there is demand for modding discussion, it's fair that like we allow ACT/Datamining discussion, we also allow modding discussion.

We will not however allow discussion on how to mod or change the game's files including links to website/Discord servers etc that promote this.

We were going to make this decision ourselves and as such, edited Rule 2 to read as follows:

The FFXIV User Agreement should be observed when posting.

  • a) Content promoting tools or software that alters the way the game fundamentally plays is not allowed.

  • b) Discussion on modded cosmetic items and datamining is allowed to be posted as long as the mods do not add items for purchase (now or potentially) via Mog Station.

  • c) Discussion on datamining is allowed but sharing of music (files or videos) is prohibited.

A more in-depth discussion was edited into the wiki page for the subreddit rules:

We will enforce or remove breeches of the following

  • Discussion of third-party tools that alter the way the game is played at a level that affects the game's fundamental systems. This includes but is not limited to Botting, Hacking tools (camera hacks, etc), server emulation and Real Money Trading (both for gil and selling of content like Savage or Ultimate).

  • Datamining of music files. This was requested by Final Fantasy XIV's sound director Masayoshi Soken himself and we wish to respect that. Come patch day, there are plenty of other places to find the music, don't ask about it here.

  • Mod discussion that allows players access to content currently available on Mog Station or content that has potential to appear on Mog Station in the future. This mainly applies to gear sets (NPCs, Seasonal gear, etc) but could expand over time.

  • Links to sites or Discord servers etc that discuss and endorse modding. Keep it at a purely admiration level and nothing more.

We will NOT remove or enforce breeches of the following

  • Datamining outside of music files. Typically on a patch day, a new thread will go up and certain users will sift through a patch the moment it's out for information on gear, enemies, achievements, items, etc. Aside from the aforementioned music restriction, we allow datamining discussion.

  • Mod discussion of a cosmetic level. The modding community for Final Fantasy XIV is booming and more and more mods are becoming available. This includes gear mods, character mods, and minion mods.

None of this is set in stone yet however, and we want your feedback. Let us know how you think we should stand on this matter in the comments and we'll use your feedback to make a decision.


r/ffxivmeta • • May 21 '19

Announcement Let's talk about low-effort posts

25 Upvotes

Hey folks,

The moderation team is planning to make some substantial changes to the rule set on r/ffxiv. We occasionally refresh the rules to ensure they are appropriate for the future of the subreddit. We'll be making an announcement when we push these changes soon, but before then we want to have a discussion about low-effort posts on r/ffxiv and welcome any feedback you'd like to give us.

As part of this refresh we are looking to make significant changes to rules 9 & 10, which currently state:

9. No low effort joke/meme images

Unoriginal or low-effort meme images are prohibited. Low-effort general "shitposts" are subject to removal.

Fanart and webcomics about FFXIV are allowed.


10. Avoid these restricted repetitive posts

Some posts reposted for months become trite, and are subject to removal. They include:

a) Questions covered in our Definitive FAQ belong only in the question megathread

b) Belong in their relevant subreddit only: FC/LS/static recruiting (/r/ffxivrecruitment), Recruit a Friend recruiting (/r/ffxivraf), game/item key trading/begging (/r/gametrade, /r/GiftofGames), house selling/buying

c) Prohibited due to overuse: mass mount screenshots, PF screenshots

The proposed change is to have a rule covering any type of post reasonably judged as being low-effort or from our list of prohibited repetitive topics covered in the Definitive FAQ. This combines rules 9 & 10 into a single rule.

What this change could look like, when we update rule 9 and combine it with rule 10:

9. Avoid low-effort/repetitive posts

Posts reasonably judged as being low effort, repetitive, or trite are subject to removal.

We realise it's hard to pin down exactly what constitutes low-effort due to differing opinions of where the line should be drawn so we will include many examples on what would be considered low-effort on our detailed rules page found on the subreddit wiki.

For 9a, the examples would include and aren't limited to;

  • Party Finder screenshots

  • Mass mount screenshots

  • A screenshot of a single mount is not a mass mount screenshot!

  • RNG posts

  • Posts that are simply "Hey look at this loot roll/token number/cactpot outcome/materia success/gathering misses/general luck I got"

  • Ban complaint posts

  • Posts that only serve to reassure OP that their ban wasn't justified and the comments are always the same; asking for the rest of the story and OP never delivers anyway.

In cases where posts that would normally go against this new rule, but are pretty popular or exceptional, we may make an exception and indicate as such by appending the post's flair with "Exempt from rule 9".


Our stance on memes

To ensure that the focus of the subreddit is primarily on FFXIV, we currently restrict low-effort memes. There is a popular misconception that memes are outright banned on r/ffxiv, which has arisen from popular memes being removed in the past for running afoul of other subreddit rules when they've become spammy & repetitive.

But what counts as being a low-effort meme post on r/ffxiv?

Low-effort meme posts are those which have little or no relevance to FFXIV ignoring the title of the post, are an image macro (a simple image with added text), or are cross-posted from elsewhere on Reddit.

For example, a little over a year ago static meme posts were making the rounds and we began removing them once they became too spammy.

Consistency, consistency, CONSISTENCY!

However, our enforcement of this "anti-meme" rule in the past has been unfairly harsh. We've recently lightened the enforcement of rule 9 and you may have noticed this change in the type of posts that have appeared on the front page of r/ffxiv.


Tell us what you think

What do you think of the proposed updates to rule 9, detailed above?

Do the examples of low-effort posts for a) seem appropriate?

Regarding memes, should enforcement of the rule be relaxed further?


r/ffxivmeta • • Jun 03 '20

Suggestion Allow and support player feedback/job how to threads

23 Upvotes

Howdy, I've been advocating a lot of change regarding the communities perspective on player initiated feedback and reverting back from a splintered community as a result.

One of the major elements lacking in the main sub, r/ffxiv , is player feedback and how to's. Right now there is a pretty hostile culture regarding any time a player gives feedback and it is automatically perceived as 'toxic' or 'harassment'.

This is demonstrated here by this thread in regards to players having issues and being met with hostility in the worst way while trying to provide feedback to players.

I feel, in part, this can helped by the main sub allowing such of how to videos or dialogue that expressly and constructively provides information such as 'how to play your job/role', job/role feedback Q's and A's threads, allow for the promotion of information to help players improve playing their job/role.

I believe the community in general is friendly and helpful, but there does remain elements that people have certain misconceptions about what is and what isn't.

For example, what is: Players are required to know how to play their jobs if they want to do hard content (Savage/Extremes)

What isn't: Players believe that simply 'playing to have fun' is sufficient enough for the same content and that no one should tell them how to play, yet be statistically unable to do the content.

Basically, the promotion of helping players play their role/job OPTIMALLY should be encouraged and doing so in the main sub will help reduce the need for so many splintered spinoff subs.

Feedback should be friendly, constructive, and accurate. Anything else, with anger or hostility, is not feedback.


r/ffxivmeta • • Sep 26 '19

About the rules A reminder on "Bot Complaint" posts

23 Upvotes

Over the past several weeks we've noticed an increase in the number of "Bot Complaint" posts we've had to remove under Rule 4b. The relevant text of Rule 4b specific to bot complaint posts currently reads:

Repetitive posts will be removed where the content is;

Bot complaint posts

  • r/ffxiv is not affiliated with Square Enix customer support. Any suspected RMT activity should be reported to the Special Task Force (STF). A report can be sent via the system menu: [System Menu] -> [Support Desk] -> [Contact Us] -> [Report Cheating]. Any RMT advertisements in the chat log can reported by right-clicking the character name and in the menu select: [Report] -> [Report RMT Activity].

The removals are often followed by modmails where the posters express frustration over the removal reason. Because of this, we want to remind everyone why the rule exists, and open up discussion on the rule and the problem with bots in general.

Bot Complaint posts are removed because they are repetitive.

This is the primary reason why bot posts are removed. A majority of the posts we deal with go something like "I'm mad because this bot is ruining my game!" or "Look at how strange these kooky bots are acting!" Because we get so many bot complaint posts per day, and because the comments on those posts are often trite and repetitive, we remove them with the same vigor that we remove RNG posts and mass mount screenshots.

Bot Complaint posts are removed to prevent other rule violations.

The second reason we remove bot posts is because many bot posts inadvertently violate rules 1b and 2a: name-shaming, and the discussion and advertisement of third-party tools and services that alter fundamental game play.

In one example, it's not uncommon for a player to get falsely accused of botting simply because they're mindlessly running between gathering nodes or clicking on a housing plot while watching Netflix on their second monitor.

In the case of the second, players posting screenshots of bots might forget to censor out the name of a RMT website, or the screenshot might reveal a new game exploit or bot program that unsavory players will rush to download.

We don't know how the Square Enix Special Task Force operates.

A major complaint about botting is the feeling that Square Enix allows bots to operate freely and does nothing to mitigate them. Players often use the in-game report function to report a bot, only to see that same bot continue to operate for weeks after. The Lodestone regularly reports mass-purges of accounts involved in RMT.

The truth is, we know very little about the methods the Special Task Force uses to combat RMT, and will likely never know. Some players believe that the Special Task Force allows reported bots to continue operating in order to track the movement of gil between accounts, with the intent of using collected data to patch out exploits and prevent credit card fraud.

"But I wasn't complaining, my bot post was supposed to be funny!"

Yes it was hilarious.

As funny as your post was, we still had to remove it because of the reasons explained above. We intend to change the wording of rule 4b to say something like "any post depicting bots as the focus will be removed", so it refers to all screenshots and videos with bots as the subject, not just angry ones.

"But bots are ruining our experience and making us mad!"

Yeah, we actually agree with you here. We freakin' hate bots. Bots have been a bane on this game since 2.0; They ruin dungeon runs, they steal our houses, they drive up marketboard prices, and their faces break our immersion.

But RMT bots are legion; with every bot taken down, another dozen are created to take its place. This is the case in all popular online games where players are naive enough to give their credit card information to a shady website promising character boosts and in-game currency. The bot problem will likely never go away until Yoshi-P gives up and drops another moon to shut down the game forever.

It's frustrating that we scream and shake our fists at Square Enix for allowing the bot problem to persist, only for it to seem like our complaints are falling on deaf ears. But r/ffxiv is unaffiliated with Square Enix; we must ask you to continue directing your complaints and reports through official channels. Square Enix SHOULD be told how botting is affecting you personally; you are their customer, and you have a right to complain about the product you're paying for. Using the in-game report function is the most direct way to get the message across. We also suggest using the Official Forums and the Square Enix Social Media Support Pilot Program.

Bot Complaint posts will remain subject to removal, but we're open to discussion.

And this post is the place to discuss it.

Share your thoughts, but tread carefully; we will have to remove any comments that violate rules 1b or 2a (as mentioned above).


r/ffxivmeta • • Sep 25 '21

Discussion Why are the low effort WOW circlejerk post still alowed

22 Upvotes

You know the post Im talking about, it's becoming tiresome to check the sub and have post with people bitching about x thing WOW did or didnt and everybody patting their backs.

And dont tell me that's because discussion because most comments are posting the actual facts and calling out the op (or memeing wowbadffgood blah).

I can't even filter them out thanks to the many flairs each poster uses.

In a unrelated note, there's a poster that in less than 2 hours made 4 different art posts without participating in comments whatsoever.


r/ffxivmeta • • Jul 26 '18

Discussion Being volunteers does not excuse you for not being responsibility for a community you claim for

22 Upvotes

A Person posted "Not a surprise the mods here are terrible at moderating and turn a blind eye on a lot of things."

Which I agree, on top of not looking in to controversial topics, they follow majority comments blindly to come to a conclusion.

A Mod responded "We're all volunteers here and we do the best we can in our free time. If you have any concerns about a specific mod action, feel free to shoot us a modmail. Or if it's about the bigger picture of things, stop on by /r/ffxivmeta."

That does not excuse you from your responsibility, if you are okay with toxicity running around, you shouldn't be upset about repercussion, at least get a Mod that cares about controlling the toxicity in the community like others subs I am in and have shown as an example, they are volunteers as well.

Just a side note, Stan started Discord with the FFX|V fan base, it is embarrassing that they had to take it away from the largest FFX|V community.


r/ffxivmeta • • Jul 31 '25

Suggestion Any possibility to getting a pinned post/addition to the FAQ answering 'is FFXIV dead/ worth getting into in 2025'?

21 Upvotes

I think this sub is a good resource for new/aspirational players, but nearly every single day for the past few weeks there has been a post saying 'is it still worth getting into FFXIV/is FFXIV too dead to start playing now', prompting the exact same replies from people. Responses to these posts have, at least to my observation, been getting more frustrated/annoyed, to no fault of the original poster, but simply because this topic has been done to death and feels entirely superfluous.

I don't think this is a bad question to ask, but it does reach a point where it feels ridiculous that it has become a daily reoccurence, if people asking this aren't even scrolling down to see recent posts.

Is there any way we could get a pinned post summarising common player responses to this question? I understand that acknowledging it may seem hostile in of itself, but it seems to be causing unneccessary annoyance at this point.