r/ffxivmeta • • Jun 12 '21

Feedback I don't think the "F-U Friday" thread should be pinned

0 Upvotes

Not sure when it started happening but I noticed that the FU Friday thread is pinned now on Fridays. I get that people like/want a space to vent. That's fine; I get it. I don't think it needs to be pinned to the top of the sub, which suggests that it's an officially sanctioned thread. Let it rise and fall like any other thread based on upvotes. If it is an officially sanctioned thread, maybe it doesn't need to be. It's usually fine but it can attract trolls and negativity (partially working-as-intended) and can reflect poorly on the sub.


r/ffxivmeta • • Dec 29 '19

Suggestion Banning all Tank/Healer posts

0 Upvotes

Can we please limit them or just outright ban them? Because at this point it gets posted like several times, it's nothing new or exciting it happens all the time time. I've seen it like 8-9 times this week just from a lot of different people alone. At this point it is starting to feel like the Regalia mount or something else like that. While I don't mind people feeling good about clearing things, it's just when something is consistently posted that everyone has seen or done like a million times like that it starts to get really old.

I would also like to phrase that I wouldn't mind it if it started some ample discussion, but it really doesn't outside of congratulations... And many times people just downvote and ignore it anyway.

Edit: For clarification I meant the all Healer/Tank raid posts. The ones you see about Ridorana, Copied Factory... etc.


r/ffxivmeta • • Feb 05 '22

Suggestion “Repetitive”

3 Upvotes

So having seen 3 posts in 24 hours removed for “repetitive” (3-line journals), can we have more consistency so FFXIV has more “unique” content? I mean it’s hard because of the numbers involved, so if we just let everyone post something about the game that brings them joy, we’ll be drowning in an endless morass of the same pedestrian boring stuff over and over. To help clean up some of the other overly repetitive things, a helpful list of post types that should be removed because they show up over and over:

  1. a complete ban on generic fanart of characters, especially miquote or au ra. They all look the same, and really repetitious. Clearly, that art style has been done. So unless it’s an actual unique style (like say, ala bill sienkiewicz on the New Mutants) no more WOL fanart.

  2. no scion fanart. I feel this needs no explanation. It’s a daily occurrence.

  3. any posts about the awful changes to classes that any update brings. Yes, yes, your life is ruined because of this change, we get it, move on

  4. license issues. So common and mundane, and that’s a squeenix issue.

  5. the word “squeenix”, so plebeian.

  6. complaining about savage raid n00bs

  7. if someone wants to post a screenshot of their WOL, I feel their post history should be searched to make sure this isn’t a repeat. At least the class should differ. Two posts of the same class? One’s gotta go, repetition after all.

Adding these to the list will drastically cut down on repetitive posts.

Or, the mods could accept that given the scale of the FFXIV player base, repetition of literally every post, regardless of content, is going to happen and maybe just let people share their damned joy, because it’s not like we have a surfeit of that.


r/ffxivmeta • • Dec 05 '18

About recent changes Rule 1b

0 Upvotes

" Posts concerning public figures within the FFXIV community are exempt from this prohibition. A public figure is denoted as any figure of merit such as: Partnered streamers, partnered Youtubers, or Free Companies which actively participate in the world race scene. "

  1. This rule is obscene and is open for abuse; I've recently seen posts toward mods (who are public figures) deleted, this sets a horrendous presedence for silencing dissenting voices in the community; just because people do not agree with you does not mean it gives the mods the rights to silence them.

  2. This REEKS of a "witch hunt" mentality against raiding FCs, public figures and streamers.(which include mods; see later point)

  3. The fact that SEVERAL FC dramas have been posted on here, which have caused people who are not involved in said dramas in the FC be "witch hunted" and have been allowed by mods.

  4. Mods are public figures yet I see SEVERAL posts calling sub reddit mod behaviour called into question being deleted or causing bans to said accounts. This shows inconsistant moderation of the rule which I personally feel has become a great problem of the sub reddit.

I propose that you just just flat out remove the amendment and just do not allow any witch hunting of ANY figure of the community which is unhealthy to say the least.


r/ffxivmeta • • Oct 09 '21

Discussion r/FFXIV and Leaks

5 Upvotes

With the recent leaks circulating around, I feel like it's time to bring up a discussion of "should leaks be allowed?".

In 2015, Yoshi-P regarded leaks as "...the worst thing you can do..." according to this gamerescape interview from 2019. With the subreddit and community at large being one that usually respects the developers and their thoughts, it seems hypocritical to not respect that. If people want leaks, they can DM each other just fine, and that's their prerogative, but we should still try to keep the developers' wishes in mind with regards to the subreddit.

With the most recent leaks especially, it seems like people are using it as an excuse to dog-pile hate onto various XIV content creators, and it has amounted to nothing but speculation as to what is right or wrong or who is in the wrong. Content creators already have enough of a problem as-is with the NDA and people constantly prodding them, and now they have leakers amongst their own and a renewed vigor from the community who just want more info.

From game to game, leaking has uniformly been something rarely done with the community or developer's best interests in mind. Occasionally they can show terrible things that will happen so people can be warned, but those are exceptions to the rule and not the norm. At that, they can be handled via messages to mods to see if it's in the community's best interest to know about this information.

And again, people want information. I can't blame them for that. However, we should respect the developer's in this, and most, scenarios, as well as the content creators who worked really hard to get into media tours. We should stand back, listen to SE and the content creators, and wait for information to be made available.

And if we wanted to be rules-lawyery, the recent stuff surrounding the recent leaked tooltips would break r/FFXIV rule 1 ("...no name shaming...") as well as potentially reddit's rule 5 ("...don’t impersonate an individual or an entity in a misleading or deceptive manner..."). Leaking as a whole might be breaking r/FFXIV rule 2 depending on the contents of the FFXIV User Agreement and if an NDA is considered a part of the UA. Leaking does break reddit rule 7 as posting leaks (in this case, the tooltips specifically) breaks an NDA, as well as r/FFXIV rule 10 as the information may or may not be true and can be considered misleading (leaks have been wrong before, after all).


r/ffxivmeta • • May 05 '24

Discussion I Feel Like The Subreddit Is Extremely Mean And Unfair To Me

0 Upvotes

I can't even make a make a serious topic without people ignoring it and choosing to just hurt me instead by bringing up things I've done long time ago or just misinformation.

I even fix my wording to not seem...umm not sure the word but people still find a way to attack me and just call me a troll and bring up off topic things and then my thread just gets removed. It's legitimately worse there than the ffxivdiscussion. Don't know if you noticed but I just completely just opt to not talk after my post because I just get attacked from things not even related to my post if I do comment.

I often feel the moderators pick on me too by just deleting my threats with zero explanations so I can improve my wording and topics. Or maybe they delete it for my sake I'm not sure... I notice when I do report things, specifically about people posts that's just aimed to out right to hurt me it gets removed and even without me reporting they get removed when they're just attacking my character and habits so maybe I shouldn't say mods are picking on me..sorry. Since I notice they actively remove comments like that.

I don't know. I'm quite aware that my threads is a lighting rod of negativity so I often think my threads get deleted for that reason unless there is a unspoken rule to not speak about how the community could be toxic? Or my threads sound to rage click? Not sure how to end this other than it's really bothering how people are just so mean to me even when I present things people agree with.


r/ffxivmeta • • Jun 14 '18

Announcement A small change to rule 8

1 Upvotes

Today we'll be making a small adjustment to rule 8.

This change will consider screenshots of any part of patch notes as a duplicate post, provided there is already a post focused on the patch notes such as a megathread or a post linking to the patch notes. As stated in the rule, these types of posts only serve to dilute discussion, and additionally can be reasonably judged as spam.

Currently rule 8 states:

Duplicate posts made within a few hours dilute community discussion across multiple threads. In particular, official news posts are subject to removal by this rule, e.g. patch notes or server status updates.

And after the adjustment it will state:

Duplicate posts made within a few hours dilute community discussion across multiple threads. In particular, official news posts are subject to removal by this rule, e.g. patch notes (including screenshots of patch notes) or server status updates.


r/ffxivmeta • • Oct 20 '18

About the rules Inconsistent Moderation

2 Upvotes

This is the original tweet regarding this:

https://twitter.com/Sorriow/status/1053771411230257152

Thread that was allowed in question:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/comments/9puxoa/yoshida_in_soul_caliber_vi_by_cisnabalandor/

Discussion with /u/WHTMage:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/comments/9puxoa/yoshida_in_soul_caliber_vi_by_cisnabalandor/e853ulh/

Can someone clarify if these kind of posts are allowed, and why the inconsistency?


r/ffxivmeta • • Mar 15 '21

Suggestion Suggestion: Hide the downvote button

5 Upvotes

The sub has a downvote problem. There are either bots or really dedicated butts who sit in new, who downvote everything unless it falls within their own extremely narrow personal view of what they like.

This is not the purpose of downvotes, which are meant to be used on posts that break rules or are not relevant to the sub. They seek to "curate" the sub by attempting to make stuff they don't like die in new, stuff I see every day that doesn't break the subs rules. Stuff that isn't just a repetitive daily question either.

As the button is not been used for it's intended purpose, it should be hidden (sadly it can't be disabled). Stuff that is popular will still rise to the top via upvotes, but petty butts who seem to think the sub is their own personal sub and not a big ass community sub won't easily be able to try to "trim" and bully out posts they don't like. No ones idea/post that is relevant to FFXIV and not rule breaking should be sitting at nearly 10%.

It won't stop the bots made to do this stuff, but it'll discourage the ones not clever enough to employ those.


r/ffxivmeta • • Jul 28 '19

Announcement /r/ffxiv's 2019 rule refresh

7 Upvotes

Hey folks!

It's time again for a refresh of the subreddit rules. We've made these changes based on feedback and a few ideas we've had since the last refresh, as well as having some extra space the admins have recently created in this area. With more breathing room now, we've expanded some congested rules into their own rule or added a rule for the purpose of a reporting reason (such as 'incorrect flair'). In addition to the notable changes detailed below, we've made slight adjustments which make the overall rule set easier to understand in both readability and how they are enforced. Due to the rule refresh changes, the detailed rules wiki page has been significantly updated.

View the rules for r/ffxiv

View the rules in more detail

The notable changes;

  • Rule 2: "Abide by specific FFXIV User Agreement topics"

  • This rule has been expanded to include how we prohibit posts advertising the buying or selling of housing.

  • This was previously documented on the detailed rules page on the subreddit wiki under "Rule 10. Avoid these restricted repetitive posts".

  • Rule 3: "Mark all spoilers"

  • This rule has been adjusted to support and encourage usage of Reddit's native spoiler system. u/AutoModerator will help out users who get the spoiler tagging a little wrong. Additionally, posts and comments using CSS spoiler tagging are automatically removed, followed by a private message from AutoMod describing how to use the new spoiler system.

  • We've also added a bit to this rule describing that posts regarding leaks and data mining should always be marked as containing spoilers.

  • How to spoiler tag text: >!Spoiler text goes here!< looks like Spoiler text goes here.

  • Rule 4: "Restricted types of posts"

  • This rule has been expanded to also cover repetitive posts, low-effort posts, and posts better suited to other subreddits.

  • This effectively merges three former rules into one; "Rule 4. Focus discussion on FFXIV", "Rule 9. No low effort joke/meme images", and "Rule 10. Avoid these restricted repetitive posts". Because of this change, rules 9 & 10 have been completely repurposed.

  • Additionally, posts which do not provide a point for discussion or contain no recognizable FFXIV content are now covered by this rule.

  • Rule 6: "Fan works must be credited to the author"

  • It is now a requirement that the artist or author name(s) must be included in the post title. Previously this could be either in the title or a comment reply on the post, but now it must be in the title.

  • We've also included how we prohibit art posts for the purpose of profit, which was previously documented on the detailed rules page on the subreddit wiki under "Rule 2. Abide by specific FFXIV User Agreement topics".

  • Rule 7: "Don't spam"

  • We've adjusted rule 7 to clarify our stance on self-promotion within the subreddit.

  • Reddit has guidelines regarding self-promotion, whereas r/ffxiv has a rule.

  • Rule 8: "Search before posting"

  • This rule now also covers reposts: "Reposts are generally acceptable given enough time has passed.".

  • This wording has been part of the rule set on r/ffxiv for a good while and was previously documented on the detailed rules page on the subreddit wiki under "Miscellaneous".

  • Rule 9: "No sexual NSFW content"

  • This is a new rule that details how we treat NSFW content.

  • This was previously documented on the detailed rules page on the subreddit wiki under "Miscellaneous".

  • Rule 10: "Misleading information"

  • The first of the new rules. This is a rule that details that spreading misleading or false information should be avoided.

  • Where a comment is found to be potentially misleading information, we may remove the comment.

  • Where a post contains potentially misleading information, we will either remove the post or flair the post indicating that it contains potentially misleading information, depending on the severity.

  • Rule 11: "Giveaways"

  • Another new rule that describes how we treat giveaways on the subreddit.

  • Giveaways generally should be conducted with "no strings attached", meaning Redditors taking part should not have to for example: Pay a fee, use a Recruit-a-Friend code, subscribe or follow social media accounts.

  • Rule 12: "Incorrect post flair"

  • Finally, this new rule allows Redditors to report posts that have an incorrect post flair and adds an extra option to the reporting dialogue when reporting a post.

  • It's a simple thing for the moderators to correct an incorrect post flair, but it was a bit too much of a hassle for readers of r/ffxiv to make us aware about it.

Rules 1 and 5, the ones about being respectful to others and posting understandable screenshots, have received minor formatting changes but their function has not changed.

Feedback is welcome on the rules. If you have any suggestions, please be sure to specify which part of the wording and what kind of adjustments could be made so we receive actionable feedback that can turn into tangible results. If we make any minor changes based on feedback, we'll edit those adjustments into this topic. Any major changes we'll announce as a meta topic as usual.

Thanks for reading!


r/ffxivmeta turned one!

r/ffxivmeta has been around for over a year now and has lead to many improvements being made on the subreddit, through your suggestions, feedback, and telling us when we've broken stuff.

There have been some concerns that we would restrict [Meta] posts from being created on r/ffxiv, but this is not something we're planning to do. Feel free to create such posts on r/ffxiv, r/ffxivmeta, or send us a modmail. If you're on our Discord server you are welcome to use the #discord-feedback channel.

Should you ever need to contact us privately, we prefer that you do so via a message to the subreddit (modmail) as opposed to sending a private message to a single moderator. That way, the entire moderation team can review the message and discuss as a team.


r/ffxivmeta • • Jun 17 '18

About the rules FFXIV mods invoke rule 1 to protect themselves from criticism even though they are public figures but allow attacks to go through on Elysium. Talk about irony.

3 Upvotes

https://imgur.com/a/iXOJOkm

The screenshots say it all.


r/ffxivmeta • • Jul 27 '18

Discussion Why are Mods still Ninja deleting posts?

3 Upvotes

i do not think there is ANY Legitimate reason for any post or comment to EVER be removed without posting a reason for it. why is this even a practice to begin with?

What this says to me is "were deleting the post because we personally dont like it, and it doesnt quite fit the narrative of our rules- so were going to bend the rules and hope you dont notice."

You delete posts like This one

quoting the reply that was deleted for context:

Are you drawing pictures of, or baiting to pictures of a lala getting railed/railing? No? Then were good dude. my beef is plainly with the closet pedophiles who cant admit they're pedophiles, or Know they are pedophiles and use this as an outlet. Now if you are drawing, or masturbating to that kind of stuff: You're a fucking degenerate, and i hope someone puts you in jail.

What rule was used to remove this post? what rule did i break? how am i supposed to know what was done to break it?

Civility? sorry, but Degenerate is the EXACT civil descriptor for a pedophile, and hoping they are put in jail is me hoping that the law of the land is excised on them, because its illegal. that is as offensive as saying 'Heroin dealers are degenerates, and i hope they end up in jail for dealing heroin"

meanwhile posts that were plainly personal attacks, were left up:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/comments/923j83/discord_revokes_ffxiv_reddit_server_partner/e33jbzf/?st=jk448iwp&sh=2de89c80 https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/comments/923j83/discord_revokes_ffxiv_reddit_server_partner/e33u928/?st=jk4495t2&sh=88fafcc2 https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/comments/923j83/discord_revokes_ffxiv_reddit_server_partner/e33u928/?st=jk449y6l&sh=e131c28d


r/ffxivmeta • • Sep 14 '19

Announcement Rule 4a has been relaxed! Survey results inside.

8 Upvotes

Survey Results

Hi folks! We're back with the follow-up from our recent discussion & survey on rule 4a and memes. There were some good discussions and we had a bit to think about based on some comments. The survey results did make it clear this is the right direction to move in based on community input, so really it just came down to the wording of the rule. The proposed rule was indeed further relaxing the rule around memes, but some felt it was potentially unnecessarily complex.

See our full rules - We've decided to simplify the rule further which also relaxes the rules more compared to our proposed wording:

4a) All posts' content should be FFXIV-related and/or on-topic

Posts that contain little or no relevance to FFXIV are subject to removal. Posts with vague context seemingly unrelated to FFXIV are also subject to removal.

Essentially the rule is now intended for purely prohibiting off-topic posts, where in the past that was only part of the rule. As mentioned in the previous thread we've also gone ahead and added a Meme flair to allow for filtering and searching. We do ask to correctly tag your thread when it's posted with the appropriate flair and that'll help with the community overall, and for the instances where a flair is still found to be set incorrectly you can use report reason 12 which we implemented back in July.

Not directly related, we've also added an example to the existing rule 7d to provide further clarity. It's not a common rule enforcement and tends to be case-by-case, but we wanted to provide an example:

7d) Content that does not violate the other parts of this rule but can be reasonably judged as spam is subject to removal at the discretion of the moderation team. An example being a meme template that is posted excessively and continuously in a short number of days may be temporarily prohibited until such posts become less excessive.

We're human; we can and will make mistakes at times (and this can occur more during a rule change as the team adjusts). If you notice a post that was missed per the rules or something similar, just shoot us a modmail to loop us in if you've already used the report feature in past days.

We'll have this pinned into the weekday, although expect it to be unpinned temporarily during the Live Letter. These changes above have gone live as of today, enjoy!

Stay tuned for more meta posts in the near future as well as our upcoming Extra Life collaboration event.

Thanks,
/r/ffxiv mod team

[EDIT] We've also enabled the option to require Link Flair when posting, considering we already require all posts to have a flair.


r/ffxivmeta • • Jun 17 '19

Feedback Why is this allowed and tolerated by Reddit?

12 Upvotes

r/ffxivmeta • • Mar 22 '22

About the rules 4c too strict?

7 Upvotes

My meme got removed because of rule 4C. It was a meme I created specifically for FFXIV, about FFXIV, and was removed because the FFXIV part about it was subtle. The joke would work without the title or caption, and be recognized as an FFXIV meme still. It got over 3500 upvotes before being removed.

The meme in question:

/img/kvgbj6j516o81.png

https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/comments/th4sha/thomas_the_tank_engine_has_other_jobs_too/

The joke wouldn't work at all with the class icons slapped on it, and even without the title and caption, posted into an FFXIV context people would recognize and get the joke.


r/ffxivmeta • • Dec 31 '19

Announcement A big update to post flairs

3 Upvotes

A little over a week ago, I made a post detailing upcoming changes to post flairs.

The changes affect not only the available post flairs, but also the post flair filters and the subreddit rules, so this post is worth a read. In addition to the changes previously detailed in that post, we have added an [In-game Screenshot] post flair and detailed the subreddit rule changes. All the changes have been documented below.

I'll be around in the comments, answering questions about these changes.

-

Post flairs

Here are the major changes:

  • [Fanart] is now split into two post flairs.

    • [Fanart] is now [Fanart - Found/non-OC]. If you've found or paid for some great artwork, you're very welcome to share it with the subreddit using this flair! However, you must include the name of the artist in the post title or failing that a link to where you found it in a comment on the same post.

    • [Fanart - OC] has been added. OC means Original Content; Something that you've made or created and decided to share, something that is unique and new. Are you an artist sharing your gorgeous artwork, fancy cosplay, or shiny handmade trinkets with the subreddit? Awesome, you don't need to include your name in the post title or provide any links. But you must use this post flair (not the other one!) and not advertise any artwork commissioning services (For more details, read the explanation for rule 6).

    • Both of these post flairs can of course be filtered. We're very aware that some readers of the subreddit don't mind OC art at all, but would prefer to not see art that someone has discovered or paid for.

  • [Event] type post flairs have been updated.

    • Currently [Event] is used for all manner of events, official and unofficial, in-game and IRL. We've expanded the event type post flairs to make it more obvious what kind of event a post is about.

    • [in-game Event] has been added. Putting on a show, celebrating Starlight with other players, cheering on fellow crafters? Use this flair!

    • Along with this new post flair, existing event type post flairs have been renamed: [Event] > [Event - Expo/Meetup], [E3] > [Event - E3], [PAX] > [Event - PAX], [Fanfest] > [Event - Fanfest]. Note: Those last three are automatically assigned.

  • [Discussion] type post flairs have been updated.

    • [Theorycraft] is now [End-game Discussion].

    • [Lore] is now [Lore Discussion].

  • The intended usage of each post flair is now detailed on the flairs wiki page.

  • Post flair is now a requirement when submitting using the new version of Reddit.

There are some minor changes too:

  • [Question] has a different colour to distinguish it from [Discussion] type posts.

  • [Media] is now [Video].

  • [Screenshot] is now [Image].

  • [In-game Screenshot] has been added. Thanks u/

  • [Sale] is now available to all instead of being mod-only.

In summary, here are the old flairs compared to the new flairs, grouped by colour.

Old:

[News], [Interview]
[Discussion], [Question]
[Lore], [Theorycraft]
[Event], [E3], [PAX], [Fanfest]
[Guide]
[Media], [Fanart], [Screenshot]
[Comedy], [Meme], [Fluff]
[Tech Support]
[Meta]
[Sale]

New:

[News], [Interview]
[Discussion], [End-game Discussion], [Lore Discussion]
[Question]
[Guide]
[In-game Event], [Event - Expo/Meetup], [Event - E3], [Event - PAX], [Event - Fanfest]
[Video], [Image], [In-game screenshot], [Fanart - OC], [Fanart - Found/non-OC]
[Comedy], [Meme], [Fluff]
[Tech Support]
[Meta]
[Sale]

So, what about those other flairs I've seen?

There are a couple of other flairs that haven't been mentioned in the changes and it's not really documented anywhere what they're for. So here goes:

  • [Fluff] - This applies to any post that doesn't invite a whole lot of discussion and doesn't really fit into any of the other available post flairs.

  • [Meta] - This is for discussion about the actual subreddit, such as changes you'd like to see. And not for in-game meta discussion, such as how much DPS different healers should be doing.

  • :moogle: - This post flair is applied to all of the weekly threads and the daily questions & FAQ thread. It's an easy way to search for those types of posts and allows us to distinguish them from other posts.

Note: All post flairs are now explained on this wiki page.

Post filters

Of course, these changes mean that the post filters that are available on the desktop version of Reddit need updating.

We know that the solution to filtering posts using Reddit's legacy search system or CSS hacks isn't great, but unfortunately it's the best we can do. We've been pestering the Reddit Admins about a native post filter system just a little, a tiny bit, a really small amount. Recently they announced upcoming changes to native post filters, but disappointingly these only apply to the new version of Reddit and are simply a new iteration of the post flairs widget; the only benefit this provides over the existing widget is keeping subreddit styling instead of taking you to a search page when you click on a post flair.

Because of the post flair changes detailed above, the legacy search & CSS hack post flair filters we provide have been updated. Here's a quick comparison between the old and the new.

Old:

News			Shows: [News], [Interview]
Major Events		Shows: [Event], [Fanfest], [PAX], [E3]
Lore & Theorycraft	Shows: [Lore], [Theorycraft]
Weekly Threads		Shows: [Weekly Thread]
Hide Filler		Hides: [Media], [Screenshot], [Fanart], [Fluff], [Comedy]
Hide Media		Hides: [Media], [Screenshot], [Fanart]
Hide Fanart		Hides: [Fanart]
Hide Questions		Hides: [Question]
Hide Memes              Hides: [Meme]
(more)		        Links to wiki page

New:

News                  Shows: [News], [Interview]
Discussions           Shows: [Discussion], [End-game Discussion], [Lore Discussion], [Guide]
Events                Shows: [In-game Event], [Event - Expo/Meetup], and the E3/PAX/Fanfest flairs
Media                 Shows: [Video], [Image], [In-game screenshot], [Fanart - OC], [Fanart - Found/non-OC]
Jokes n' Memes        Shows: [Comedy], [Meme]
Weekly Threads        Shows: [Weekly Thread]
Hide Filler           Hides: [Video], [Image], [In-game screenshot], [Fanart - OC], [Fanart - Found/non-OC], [Comedy], [Meme], [Fluff]
Hide non-OC Fanart    Hides: [Fanart - Found/non-OC]
(more)                Links to wiki page

Changes to the rules

Because the fanart post flair has changed, the subreddit rules have been updated, specifically rule 6a.

Old rule:

When posting content including commissioned, drawn or discovered fanworks, the author/artist must be credited with their name(s) included in the title.

New rule:

When posting content including discovered, commissioned, or other types of non-original content (non-OC) fanworks, the author/artist must be credited with their name(s) in the post title.

The detailed description of this rule has also been updated on the rules wiki page:

When posting content including discovered, commissioned, or other types of non-original content (non-OC) fanworks the author/artist must be credited in the post title. This must be the author/artists's name(s). When this isn't possible, a link to where you found the content is required in a comment on the same post. This could be a link to their website, profile, social media post. The appropriate post flair [Fanart - Found/non-OC] must also be used.

When posting original content and you are the author/artist, you are not required to credit yourself in the post title but are required to use the appropriate post flair [Fanart - OC].


r/ffxivmeta • • May 08 '19

Announcement Please give a warm welcome to these new moderators! And other things of note as we prepare for Shadowbringers.

3 Upvotes

New Moderators

Please join me in welcoming the following new moderators to the /r/ffxiv mod team! They've been around a little bit already and we're finally making the post to announce them. This and many other things have been in preparation for the influx of activity that Shadowbringers will bring.

Moderator Applications

Moderator applications remain open and we're still seeking applicants active in EU time zones to help cover gaps. If you're interested in joining our volunteer mod team, apply here.

New Spoiler Formatting

As recently announced, we've moved to a new spoiler formatting system for comments. This Friday AutoModerator will begin reminding anyone who uses the old system on how to use this new system. Read the linked post for more details; in summary the new format is:

>!This is a spoiler!<

Contests

In the near future, we'll be holding some sweet contests for the subreddit including a banner contest. Keep an eye out soon for a sticky post; we're currently thinking the timing will be around of end of this month. There'll be some nice prizes for these contests!

T-shirt Spam Rings

A reminder that the t-shirt spam rings are still ongoing and to report any you see. Read the linked post for full information that provides examples of what to look for.

More Automation

Our /u/FFXIV_Sidebar bot has been handling a number of automations already, including updating the sidebar with Lodestone news and server status. Ever since the redesign was rolled out by the admins, it's been a struggle to maintain essentially two sites. Without boring you with the details, we'll be rolling out more automation in the near future. If you are actually interested in the details, there are some information in this post that was written for moderators to read.


We'll have a number of meta posts before Shadowbringers on the above and other topics, so keep an eye out as we continue to prepare the subreddit for the expansion!


r/ffxivmeta • • Jul 13 '19

Discussion Let's talk about Eorzean HQ (Formerly known as The Moogle Post)

16 Upvotes

Hey folks,

The subreddit moderation team wants to talk with you about Eorzean HQ, formerly known as The Moogle Post.

UPDATE: Following the feedback on this post, the crossposted version of this post, and threats of legal action against r/ffxiv from Eorzean HQ staff, Eorzean HQ and The Moogle Post will continue to be banned from r/ffxiv.

Why?

Eorzean HQ is a fan made monthly issue magazine, also known for guides & HQ Shade (Formerly MoogleShade). The group behind the magazine recently rebranded from The Moogle Post, following on from the allegations levied against the former editor-in-chief, OldBear Stormborn, almost exactly one year ago.

Eorzean HQ approached us about being unbanned from the subreddit three months ago (before the rebrand occurred) and they have assured us that OldBear is no longer associated with Eorzean HQ in any way such as retaining control of social media accounts, websites, or exerting any influence on Eorzean HQ.

Allegations?

The former editor-in-chief was accused of sexual harassment and blackmail by a dozen women. You can read more about the allegations via this PC Gamer article or this Massively Overpowered article. As part of these allegations, a social media account was created by the women but later abandoned then taken over by OldBear who also created a now-defunct website.

Subsequently, the women created the Phoenix Down Initiative. Also shared were audio tapes from the women describing the allegations which are still available to listen to at https://anonymousjanes.wordpress.com/

As a response to the allegations and outcry from the community, The Moogle Post was banned from r/ffxiv.

Here are a couple of Reddit posts on r/ffxiv about the situation:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/comments/8u2u92/why_tmp_seems_to_be_sending_mixed_messages_about/

https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/comments/8snl92/the_inevitable_what_allegations_against_the/

So...

Should Eorzean HQ be unbanned from r/ffxiv?

In this instance, the r/ffxiv community is to decide if Eorzean HQ should be allowed to share their content here. Let us know what you think in the comments.

Here's a link to Eorzean HQ, https://www.eorzeanhq.com/


r/ffxivmeta • • Jan 16 '19

Discussion Spoilers in BLU topic titles

2 Upvotes

Understanding that the quantity of posts will die down over time, the subreddit has been unusable for someone who doesn't want the specifics of how to learn every single spell spoon-fed to them. Half the allure of BLU was meant to be figuring out where to learn the spells.

In short, I guess my request is that rule 3 be more strictly enforced, especially in regards to content where that's kind of the point. I obviously don't mind the well-marked guides for people who want them; let those of us who don't have the ability to browse as well.


r/ffxivmeta • • Apr 20 '18

Announcement Changes to Rule 1 are now live

3 Upvotes

The changes to rule 1 are now live. We know this took a lot longer than it should have. We had a couple real life emergencies among some of the senior moderators which I will not go into details about here to respect their privacy. We're going to make some changes involving the /r/ffxiv moderator team shortly to help mitigate some of these issues in the future so please keep an eye out for that coming soon.

/r/ffxiv rules page

/r/ffxiv extended rules


The new rules are as follows:

Posts (including screenshots of chat logs) about a specific bad encounter with other players, such as in Duty Finder, are prohibited. FFXIV is an exceptionally popular MMORPG and the game is no stranger to having a wide variety of players who may clash in personality, skill or attitude. Note that this rule does not prohibit discussing the state of the overall playerbase or your stance on FFXIV, be it negative or positive (as long as such a discussion is kept civil).

Posts concerning public figures within the FFXIV community are exempt from this prohibition. A public figure is denoted as any figure of merit such as: Partnered streamers, partnered Youtubers, or Free Companies which actively participate in the world race scene. Such posts must;

  • Not go against rule 1a (Personal attacks, harassment, and hate speech).

  • Not go against Reddit's content policy, e.g. containing personal and confidential information.

  • Provide publicly accessible proof within a reasonable doubt. Rumours and second hand information are not sufficient proof to call out a community member.

  • Be approved by the /r/ffxiv moderation team via moderator mail (modmail).

  • Modmail cannot be deleted or edited so all discussion about whether provided proof is sufficient will always be present to the entirety of the mod team rather than a select few.

  • Only moderator-approved posts and their associated comment sections are exempt from Rule 1b. Unapproved posts and comments on unrelated posts remain prohibited.



r/ffxivmeta • • May 21 '19

Announcement Let's talk about low-effort posts

25 Upvotes

Hey folks,

The moderation team is planning to make some substantial changes to the rule set on r/ffxiv. We occasionally refresh the rules to ensure they are appropriate for the future of the subreddit. We'll be making an announcement when we push these changes soon, but before then we want to have a discussion about low-effort posts on r/ffxiv and welcome any feedback you'd like to give us.

As part of this refresh we are looking to make significant changes to rules 9 & 10, which currently state:

9. No low effort joke/meme images

Unoriginal or low-effort meme images are prohibited. Low-effort general "shitposts" are subject to removal.

Fanart and webcomics about FFXIV are allowed.


10. Avoid these restricted repetitive posts

Some posts reposted for months become trite, and are subject to removal. They include:

a) Questions covered in our Definitive FAQ belong only in the question megathread

b) Belong in their relevant subreddit only: FC/LS/static recruiting (/r/ffxivrecruitment), Recruit a Friend recruiting (/r/ffxivraf), game/item key trading/begging (/r/gametrade, /r/GiftofGames), house selling/buying

c) Prohibited due to overuse: mass mount screenshots, PF screenshots

The proposed change is to have a rule covering any type of post reasonably judged as being low-effort or from our list of prohibited repetitive topics covered in the Definitive FAQ. This combines rules 9 & 10 into a single rule.

What this change could look like, when we update rule 9 and combine it with rule 10:

9. Avoid low-effort/repetitive posts

Posts reasonably judged as being low effort, repetitive, or trite are subject to removal.

We realise it's hard to pin down exactly what constitutes low-effort due to differing opinions of where the line should be drawn so we will include many examples on what would be considered low-effort on our detailed rules page found on the subreddit wiki.

For 9a, the examples would include and aren't limited to;

  • Party Finder screenshots

  • Mass mount screenshots

  • A screenshot of a single mount is not a mass mount screenshot!

  • RNG posts

  • Posts that are simply "Hey look at this loot roll/token number/cactpot outcome/materia success/gathering misses/general luck I got"

  • Ban complaint posts

  • Posts that only serve to reassure OP that their ban wasn't justified and the comments are always the same; asking for the rest of the story and OP never delivers anyway.

In cases where posts that would normally go against this new rule, but are pretty popular or exceptional, we may make an exception and indicate as such by appending the post's flair with "Exempt from rule 9".


Our stance on memes

To ensure that the focus of the subreddit is primarily on FFXIV, we currently restrict low-effort memes. There is a popular misconception that memes are outright banned on r/ffxiv, which has arisen from popular memes being removed in the past for running afoul of other subreddit rules when they've become spammy & repetitive.

But what counts as being a low-effort meme post on r/ffxiv?

Low-effort meme posts are those which have little or no relevance to FFXIV ignoring the title of the post, are an image macro (a simple image with added text), or are cross-posted from elsewhere on Reddit.

For example, a little over a year ago static meme posts were making the rounds and we began removing them once they became too spammy.

Consistency, consistency, CONSISTENCY!

However, our enforcement of this "anti-meme" rule in the past has been unfairly harsh. We've recently lightened the enforcement of rule 9 and you may have noticed this change in the type of posts that have appeared on the front page of r/ffxiv.


Tell us what you think

What do you think of the proposed updates to rule 9, detailed above?

Do the examples of low-effort posts for a) seem appropriate?

Regarding memes, should enforcement of the rule be relaxed further?


r/ffxivmeta • • May 02 '18

Suggestion A few suggestions

1 Upvotes

First suggestion: Add a lore thread to the weekly megathreads.

I sent this one in a mod mail before, just reiterating it here for record purposes.

Right now we have

Monday: Server Discussion
Tuesday: Raid Day Tuesday
Wednesday: Crafting / Market Discussion
Thursday: Throwback Thursday
Friday: Victory Friday

Out of those I noticed Raid Tuesday and Throwback Thursday are far less active, as raid discussion tends to happen in standalone threads and questions go to the daily questions thread, I was thinking either of them could be replaced by a lore discussion day where people can discuss and answer lore related questions with more ease.

Second suggestion: replace /r/FFXIVDadjokes with /r/ShitpostXIV, the first sub is pretty dead, while the second is active and (hopefully) having it listed there would decrease the amount of low effort posts in /r/ffxiv.

Third: The weekly happenings listed in the daily questions thread is very very very outdated. CT Sundays has little reason to exist now that we have alliance roulette, Coil Wednesday has little point when people do it unsynced in PF now (and most of them are solo/duo able) and Frontlines queue issues will be solved when they make FL rotate daily.

I could use some input for weekly happenings replacements, but right now things like an Astralagos day or Feast Practice day for GARO stuff could be listed there.


r/ffxivmeta • • Sep 20 '18

About the rules Can we actually get some consistent enforcement of rule 1?

6 Upvotes

From this thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/comments/9hbt7g/o12s_down/e6avzhj/

Specifically, this part:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/wiki/rules

Posts concerning public figures within the FFXIV community are exempt from this prohibition. A public figure is denoted as any figure of merit such as: Partnered streamers, partnered Youtubers, or Free Companies which actively participate in the world race scene. Such posts must;

Not go against rule 1a (Personal attacks, harassment, and hate speech). Not go against Reddit's content policy, e.g. containing personal and confidential information. Provide publicly accessible proof within a reasonable doubt. Rumours and second hand information are not sufficient proof to call out a community member. Be approved by the /r/ffxiv moderation team via moderator mail (modmail). Modmail cannot be deleted or edited so all discussion about whether provided proof is sufficient will always be present to the entirety of the mod team rather than a select few. Only moderator-approved posts and their associated comment sections are exempt from Rule 1b. Unapproved posts and comments on unrelated posts remain prohibited.

No proof was posted whatsoever and if i'm honest I very much doubt the comment in question was pre-approved by a mod - and if it was, again, no proof was posted and I would have to question this moderators objectivity here.

This has happened a number of times - particularly in the World First threads - all designed to just shit on someone when they've done something good or to just flat out shit on raiding FC's - which seems to be the in thing on the subreddit in recent years.

Furthermore, one of the /r/ffxiv mods posts in the comment chain - ignoring his duty to moderate the thread and remove the comments that broke the rules - and then tries to act like he did nothing wrong. This is absolutely unacceptable. And by some weird coincidence, I start getting accused of hiding RMT'ers by a boyfriend of another mod.

This absolutely is not the behaviour the community expects from the moderators. Rules should not be applied depending on who posts or who gets witchhunted. The rules are the rules. Please stick to them and enforce them universally.


r/ffxivmeta • • Aug 26 '19

Discussion [META] Let's chat about memes and rule 4a

11 Upvotes

Howdy! Last month we released our rules refresh and since that time we've received some feedback around rule 4a which does prohibit certain meme images such as various examples included in the quoted text below. Although the rules do not prohibit all memes (and the rules refresh did relax on that matter based on the adjustments to 4a and the old rule 9), we wanted to chat with the community about memes overall and suggest a proposal on 4a. We also have a survey so we can better understand the community at large.

The proposal is a change to rule 4a for the purpose of further relaxing on meme images and bringing more clarity to this rule. In addition, the mod team has also been considering a meme link flair for the purpose of filtering. While not in place yet, the new proposed rule would be:

4a) All posts' content should be FFXIV-related and/or contain recognizable FFXIV content.

Posts that contain little or no relevance to FFXIV are subject to removal. Posts with vague context seemingly unrelated to FFXIV are also subject to removal.

In the case of images or videos, we consider the content without captions (i.e. - the title of the Reddit post, any captions or text added to the image or video itself) to decide if a post is related. In the case of memes or joke images, we require them to be wholly recognizable as being a "FFXIV meme". If you remove the text and the title from the post, it must be recognizably about FFXIV. Unspecific generic memes are subject to removal. Examples below:

  • Screenshot of the game on one panel with screenshot of the common meme in another is also okay to post. Example #3

  • Screenshot of any meme or non-FFXIV media with game or skill icons placed on the meme is okay to post as well. Example #4 | Example #5

  • Screenshot of any meme or non-FFXIV media but with FFXIV text only is not allowed due to it lacking any identifiable FFXIV elements. Example #6

  • Screenshot of any meme or non-FFXIV media and no FFXIV text but with thread title reflecting the game is also not allowed due to it lacking any identifiable FFXIV elements. Example #7 titled 'When the Blood Lily gets nourished'

Take the survey here

Your constructive feedback on this matter would be much appreciated! We're interested to hear what you think about the direction this could take the subreddit in, or if you have any suggestions around the proposed rule wording. In a couple of weeks we'll have follow-up post also including the survey results.

We hope everyone has been enjoying Shadowbringers! I know I've been looking forward to patch 5.1.
-The /r/ffxiv mod team

[UPDATE] Survey results have been made public. Stay tuned for our follow-up post!