r/fea • • May 11 '26

ANSYS or NX (SimCenter 3D)

0 Upvotes

Asking the professionals out there what their preference is for FEM SW.

Our company uses ANSYS and the price gouging is getting out of hand. However I know the capabilities and I've seen the warts. Primarily using

Static structural, transient, harmonic, random vibe & motion.

The other option is SC3D.

Where do you stand?

235 votes, May 13 '26
181 ANSYS Mechanical
54 SimCenter 3D Structural

r/fea • • Mar 17 '26

Looking for experienced FE Analyst for help - full remote

1 Upvotes

Hello

I had a quick look at the subreddit's guidelines and rules I could find and am under the impression I am not infringing any rules by posting this here. If I do, feel free to let me know and point me to where I should post this instead.

I am an engineer with 10 years of experience and am working on a little side-project which requires some finite elements analysis. I have however absolutely no experience in that field at all. So I am looking for someone with industry experience who could help me with the first analysis to have a decent proof of concept. This is a small full remote side-gig you can fulfill during your free time and which is paid. My target budget would be 300 USD.

I am working on footwear and would like to get feedback on the internal structure I have in mind of that footwear. Some questions I am seeking answers on:

  • are some shapes of that structure inside the footwear more resistant than others under load?

  • How does the footwear behave under shear?

  • What internal structure would give the best resistance?

  • Can we layer some of these structures?

  • Is the material I have in mind the most suited or should I switch?

  • What about manufacturability?

  • etc...

The way I see this unfold:

  1. We have a first call where I explain you more about how I see things and give you all the needed technical details you may need

  2. You work on the FEA and are free to ask me any questions you may have

  3. Once finished we discuss the results of what you found. It should cover the different cases we discussed in phase #1

  4. if phase #1 upto phase #3 went well, we can reiterate and extend this work if needed. Conditions will then be rediscussed to see on whether we should do this per project/hour/something else.

Send me a DM if this may interest you.

Thanks


EDIT: I received quite some private messages from people from the US, India and Europe. Currently a suitable candidate has been found. The scope has been clarified, discussed and agreed upon by the both of us. I therefor currently put this vacancy on hold.

Thank you


r/fea • • May 28 '21

Check this FEA blog for FEA Topics

Thumbnail
graspengineering.com
0 Upvotes

r/fea • • Aug 04 '19

Subsonic flow simulation through a wind tunnel - ANSYS Fluent (CFD)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/fea • • May 21 '25

How Visualization Options can change Results in CAE

0 Upvotes

I had created a couple of videos about how the difference in the problem statement will affect the results of the FE analysis. We talk about Boundary conditions, Mesh density, Element types, Material type and behavior, and Contacts.
But in fact, there are a couple of additional things that can change the result representations and numbers, as well as visual pictures. And they can do it even for the same data from one result file.

Now I'll talk about visualization options. We can show raw, unaveraged data, and it will be different from the averaged picture that we look at and analyze in most cases. The type and algorithms of result averaging also have a big influence.
It's deep question, with roots in the FEM theory. So in the next couple of videos, I will try to show some examples and explain it in a simplified way.

So today we will take a short look at some visualization options in #Ansys #Mechanical (Workbench)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fG2lzymfzR0

And also talk about some options that can be helpful in analyzing the adequacy of your FE calculation.


r/fea • • Dec 18 '22

Mechanical Analysis of I-Beam using Onscale

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/fea • • Jun 16 '26

Are you all using LLMs / agents for FEA or CFD?

3 Upvotes

Hi - curious how folks here are using LLMs in their workflows when doing FEA or other computational analysis. First off do you have access to these tools at work and if so how do you use them?


r/fea • • Aug 04 '26

Built an FE solver that runs in a browser tab because I was tired of dongles and five-figure quotes — beta is open

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/fea • • Feb 18 '25

Anyone with fea memes over here? I want to know what you guys are on about

1 Upvotes

r/fea • • Apr 20 '22

could anyone help me with question 2? I’ve tried but I couldn’t get the answer

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/fea • • May 04 '20

Check out this amazing site

Thumbnail simukationscience.net
0 Upvotes

r/fea • • Jul 25 '26

FEA, CFD FREELANCE

0 Upvotes

I have worked in structural, modal, thermal, shock, static and transient analysis, cfds, conjugate heat transfers, natural, forced convection cooling simulations for defence and nuclear components. Please let me know if any opportunities are available. Thank you


r/fea • • May 06 '25

What is the meaning of elastic and plastic in FEA?

1 Upvotes

I think it means that there is no yield point provided in an elastic simulation. So the specimen returns to it’s original configuration no matter how much stress it is given. Plastic has all the parameters, right?

I’m working with elastic plastic (EL) and perfectly plastic (PL) models so wanted to get a better understanding of what is happening.

Any insights are greatly appreciated.


r/fea • • Feb 05 '26

Watch This Before Running Your First ANSYS Simulation!

0 Upvotes

If you’re just starting with ANSYS and don’t know where to begin, this video is for you. In this tutorial, I walk through a complete ANSYS simulation from scratch. You’ll see the full workflow clearly, so you can understand how ANSYS actually works.

🎥 Watch it on my YouTube channel, FEAMaster
https://youtu.be/I07-CVhrfUA


r/fea • • Jun 07 '26

dynamic fea?

0 Upvotes

soo if i want to make an fea to something that isn't fixed but is moving what to do? like a rocket engine it have the engine non lenier force and the drag non lenier force

asking for a friend 🙏🏻✌️


r/fea • • Sep 05 '26

“How to model daily-life mechanical/automotive parts in SolidWorks and analyze with ANSYS FEA?"

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m working on a project to strengthen my skills in CAD and FEA for my career in automotive engineering. I want to design and analyze simple 3D models of objects we see in daily life (mechanical or automotive parts) using a vernier caliper for measurements, model them in SolidWorks, and then run ANSYS simulations with FEA calculations.

Could you please help me with:

  1. Examples of objects (either household mechanical parts like chair legs, hinges, or fan blades OR automotive parts like brake pedals, clutch levers, or suspension arms) that are practical, easy to measure, and good for FEA projects.

  2. Research papers, theses, or project reports where similar parts were modeled and analyzed in ANSYS.

  3. Step-by-step workflows or tutorials (measurement → CAD modeling → ANSYS simulation → GD&T application).

  4. Links to resources (websites, YouTube tutorials, Reddit discussions, and Academia.edu papers) that explain such projects in detail so I can replicate them myself.

My goal is to practice with accessible objects at home while building skills that directly connect to automotive engineering. Any guidance, papers, or project references would be super helpful!


r/fea • • May 28 '25

Help

2 Upvotes

Need to Submit my Project on wing structure analysis using Abaqus tomorrow and have nothing ready yet, need some help or someone can share any projects they made so that i can get an idea. Thanks


r/fea • • Nov 16 '24

Can anyone tell me how to download hypermesh for free

0 Upvotes

I want to make my final year project design of contactless gear transmission with magnetic gear in hypermesh so how can i download hypermesh for free or it has the student versuon for it


r/fea • • Nov 25 '24

Help me in a project of Simulating crack propagation

0 Upvotes

Simulating Crack Propagation in 2D

Use the Phase Field Method to simulate crack initiation and propagation in a rectangular plate under tensile load.

Implement energy minimization for the crack growth using FEniCS.

Output results showing the crack path and stress distribution.

Let me inform that I have studied one course of computational techniques in undergraduate. Other than that I do not have more experience of FEA. I need to do this for my graduate program application but I am not sure how do I approach this. I have very less idea. But with the help of ChatGPT and study papers, I thing I can pull this up. So if anybody has any idea how can I approach, please let me know. I am a beginner, please do not discourage me.


r/fea • • Dec 10 '24

Composites

0 Upvotes

Hello!! I'm planning to work on PLA and PLF composites but I'm kinda sceptical that it'll work, can anyone help me with knowing if it's possible and what are the refrences??


r/fea • • Jun 12 '20

If you multiply with the test function from the right instead of from the left then I think that there's something wrong with you.

0 Upvotes

r/fea • • Feb 26 '26

New to FEA

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, im currently writing a report on Joining of Thermosetting Polymers: Comparative Evaluation of Load Transfer in Fastened and Adhesively Bonded Thermoset Composites and I made an fea for mechanically fastening composites specifically CFRP/Vinyl ester with titanium bolts. I used a with a shear load of 1KN. This is how it came out. I was wondering if anyone could analyze and explain what they see here to me so I can be as descriptive as possible in my report. Thank you!


r/fea • • May 19 '25

I hope people in here see the truth and can resonate with me

0 Upvotes

I don’t know how else to say it, and I hope I can resonate with some of the engineers here.

I want to take Ansys Workbench as a example. It looks clean on the surface, but it hides everything that matters: You don’t see the face IDs you’re applying pressure to. You don’t know if your BCs actually matched. You can get completely invalid results, and it still “looks fine” with some BS rainbow plots. There’s zero guidance, no validation, no way to trust what you just solved. It’s not transparent, it’s not intuitive, it’s not smart, and it’s definitely not trustworthy.

And the worst part? Many students, friends I know of, including my FSAE team don’t even know it. They are still putting their entire CAD model straight to Ansys WB, and when i mention you have to simplify your model, validate every face and load direction manually, mesh quality check, check element type, overconstraint and underconstrain checks, etc. After I said all they said they either say: "Na that's too much" or "wait, hell you talking about?" or "I mean the simulation ran." Then I see them run it, get a rainbow stress plot, and move on, and never question if the result they got are real or BS.

And I talked to many professors who are in the engineering industry, and almost all of them told me the same thing: "All GUIs are BS. No one serious uses them. Everything are done through scripting." Because GUI-based simulation hides everything critical. You can’t see the face IDs, can’t validate boundary conditions, can’t control element types, and can’t debug what’s happening underneath. Scripting gives control, traceability, and precision. Industry are interacting with the solver directly, using MAPDL, Abaqus scripting, OpenFOAM(maybe), even writing their own meshers and pipelines just to bypass the GUI entirely. The GUI might look clean, but for any high-stakes work like aerospace, defense, automotive, or failure validation, it’s actively avoided, but as all engineering major, who want to write scripts?

And in order to get the right result in GUI you really have to know how these software behave and how FEA works fundamentally. However, even if you do it would take a lot of effort to change the setting, to automate in these software, because they really won't let you, since they are profiting off of billion dollar of license fee and one time scripts, validator. So they just decide to train engineers to follow steps, click buttons, get something out, and never to question.

I was pissed from day one. From 1980 to today, these software in the engineering industry did not change a bit, the UI sucks, the workflow sucks, the thousand of button, like every single engineer sort of just accept the fate that this is what i have to endure, this is engineering, it suppose to suck, there's no easy way. Honestly these people are the reason why engineering sucks, because they don't innovate, they follow.

And I genuinely believe it’s possible to build a GUI that’s intuitive, let you automate your workflows, and transparent about everything it’s doing. I’m building one right now. It’s still early, I need more time, probably get it done by this summer, and once i finished it may not be perfect, but i believe for sure it will can compete with workbench.

If anything I’ve said resonates with you, and you care about this mission, and want to be part of it, or like to contribute, I hope we can talk. Because I believe, as every engineer should, our job isn’t to blindly follow broken systems just because they “work.”


r/fea • • Sep 07 '19

Elementos finitos - Ansys workbench: Práctica 16

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes