r/fasting • • Jan 13 '20

This

Post image
8.8k Upvotes

216 comments sorted by

782

u/JustAnAce Jan 13 '20

Gain twenty lbs in six weeks and no one notices. Change your eating schedule so you're not eating at work and all of a sudden you have issues.

317

u/E1ghtbit Jan 13 '20

Yeah it's messed up. I told one other person at work how I was fasting, figured I was safe because I know he fasts, too. But he then proceeded to lecture me for 20 minutes about I was fasting "wrong," how he still eats during his fasts (?), etc. I'm no longer going to tell anyone when I fast.

188

u/be-c-c4 Jan 13 '20

Still eats during fasts? Does he not see the obvious oxymoron here?

88

u/mexicanred1 Jan 13 '20

He didn't tell you? He's fasting from chocolate!

56

u/newBreed Jan 13 '20

Does he not see the obvious oxymoron here?

He is the moron here.

29

u/Kiseido Jan 13 '20

Perhaps it's a "carb fast", avoiding any and all carbohydrates? I've seen a few people mention it, claiming it works. A family member claims to have lost about 40 pounds doing it.

103

u/GiohmsBiggestFan Jan 13 '20

That's just keto 🤷‍♂️

15

u/Kiseido Jan 13 '20

Oh no, keto is avoiding cards all the time yea?

He just did it on weekdays, still mostly keeps at it too.

61

u/DevNullSoul 37M 5'10" SW: 220 CW: 193 GW: 165 Jan 13 '20

That’s a cyclical keto diet.

11

u/Cool_underscore_mf Jan 13 '20

Which if your slamming carbs during the weekends, may be hard to maintain ketosis...

6

u/DevNullSoul 37M 5'10" SW: 220 CW: 193 GW: 165 Jan 13 '20

Depends on the goal. I usually read about it in the context of muscle building, and being very active while also supplementing MCT oil can make the transition easier, apparently.

I never tried it, and likely won’t ever, but some people swear by it and say it’s way easier/better for muscle growth than standard keto.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Kiseido Jan 13 '20

Well then, TIL

18

u/DevNullSoul 37M 5'10" SW: 220 CW: 193 GW: 165 Jan 13 '20

They have special names for everything

For people on the standard American diet, any restriction can produce results.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/cassidyconor Jan 13 '20

Well, you still need some carbs, just everybody has a limit they need to stay under to get in a state of ketosis (≈50gs a day?)

1

u/E1ghtbit Jan 14 '20

Actually he eats fruit on his fasting days. And yogurt. Probably eating 300-400 calories before dinner, and then a regular dinner. I mean, if it works for him, great.

35

u/mmmerrilliii Jan 13 '20

Haven’t you heard? It’s a new trend of fasting called “not fasting”.

19

u/stevennva Jan 13 '20

I've learned to just not talk about it unless someone asks and then I ask them if they are willing to listen and learn I will spend time with them - otherwise you are wasting your breath! The "old belief" system is STRONG and is hard to change people's minds - until they are ready

8

u/cutercottage Jan 14 '20

The first rule of fasting is don’t talk about fasting

5

u/SilverFox8188 Jan 14 '20 edited Jan 14 '20

I talk about it here and to my hubz, that's it! Everyone else is bat shit crazy. They're ok with me killing myself, by letting food run my show. However, the moment I take control and everyone is worried. Oooook!

7

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

If you or someone you know is contemplating suicide, please do not hesitate to talk to someone.

US:

Call 1-800-273-8255 or text HOME to 741-741

Non-US:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_suicide_crisis_lines


I am a bot. Feedback appreciated.

17

u/winterswithmoni Jan 13 '20

I'm convinced many people don't like to see others bettering themselves because it forces them to turn inward and reflect on their own healthy lifestyle choices, or lack thereof. They feel insecure and judged and compensate by condemning those who would dare threaten them as healthier or thinner or whatever.

11

u/The_Tenth_Dimension Jan 13 '20

This kids is what we call “gatekeeping”. Don’t do that.

7

u/Cool_underscore_mf Jan 13 '20

Main stream and alternate trends/hobbies/way of eating are always filled with "my ways the proper way, you're doing it wrong you heathen". I don't tell anyone that I fast or eat keto (because why would i do both, im sure that my kidneys will magically explode), even if they tell me they are doing either "oh cool, I've heard of that, how's it working out for you"? Is about the only indicator that you'll get from me.

2

u/Ctex1968 Jan 13 '20

Yeah I just tell them I on a diet....

1

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

Yep, a lady a work has miso soup and 2 pieces of fruit on her fasting day. She follows Michael Mosley.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '20

He probably does something like the 5:2 diet

4

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

Coworkers are honestly the worst

244

u/nobalance23 Jan 13 '20

Currently dealing with the same exact thing. People are suddenly concerned with you getting enough nutrients but didn’t care when I was eating a ton of junk with little to no nutritional value. It’s so weird

105

u/Dougalface Jan 13 '20 edited Jan 13 '20

Probably has a lot to do with prevailing social norms. It's "normal" to stuff your face with high-carb junk food. It's increasingly "normal" to be fat / obese. It's "normal" to be (sometimes wilfully) ignorant about your own health and wellbeing (and everything else).

Anyone not subscribing to this mindset of mass enslavement is an outsider; a deviant and to be treated with mistrust, suspicion, disdain and ridicule..

15

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

This enslavement runs so deep it holds true for the robotic sheep in society who live in a bubble

9

u/GroovyGrove Jan 13 '20

I enjoyed trying to take this comment literally. It could make an excellent short story.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Humans tend to stick in herds, especially "normal" humans. They feel a lack of self worth and place their identity in a leader or the herd itself. Those who have discovered or awoken to the truth of who they really are within can guide these sheep to freedom. Sheep is not to be used in a derogatory way, they are my brothers and sisters who do not yet know the infinite nature of their being, the interconnectedness that binds us together as one.

(Not sure if your comment was sarcasm or not) have a good day 😊

8

u/GroovyGrove Jan 13 '20

I appreciate that you expanded on your intention. I really meant I'd like to read a short story about a bubble-enclosed society that has designed robotic sheep to be among its various slaves. Sounds like an adventure.

4

u/FasterMotherfucker Jan 14 '20

Do androids dream of electric sheep?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Just watch the matrix 😁

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

[deleted]

9

u/Dougalface Jan 13 '20

True; although ironically I've been far less apathetic about life since I've found the way to make progress in one of the main areas that makes me detest myself..

I guess I shouldn't be too hard on her as it's generally just a "mum reflex" to want to provide for their offspring.

10

u/prettyprincess91 Jan 14 '20

I’m not sure if you would really want the alternative. Hearing for years how pretty I could be if I just lost weight, made to feel guilty whenever I enjoyed what I was eating, or being told by family members I needed to lose weight was all very unpleasant and still makes me feel horrible when I recall those memories. I knew what I looked like, I didn’t need unsolicited advice, and I still don’t.

3

u/nobalance23 Jan 14 '20

Oh I’ve been there, they aren’t saying I don’t need to lose weight they are saying that don’t really approve of fasting. I’ve had plenty of family members speak negatively about my weight.

2

u/prettyprincess91 Jan 14 '20

OP said no one said a word when she was fat

2

u/nobalance23 Jan 14 '20

Oh but you responded under my comment so I thought you were talking to me 🤔

2

u/prettyprincess91 Jan 14 '20

Indeed, sorry for the confusion. Personally, I would prefer people to STFU about what I eat unless they are cooking it themselves.

8

u/babybeehive Jan 13 '20

They don’t think it’s healthy unless you eat at every minor inkling of a rumbly tummy.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

231

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I’ve been called anorexic, self-loathing, I’m “starving myself”, mentally unstable, and in need of a good therapist because I routinely do multi-day fasts.

I’m just like “wow, assholes, thanks for the support.”

38

u/reddit-cucks-lmao Jan 13 '20

It’s just their shame. Seeing someone “normal” ie who they cannot get an excuse from makes them realise that they too could rejoin humanity. Instead they attribute it to health issues or drugs just so they can continue living the fantasy that they’re normal and healthy.

27

u/LambOfLiberty M-36 5'8" SW: 315 CW: 239 Jan 13 '20

Seriously, my family calls me fat, then when I finally lose weight they criticize my fasting

41

u/ghudson42 Jan 13 '20

You have to understand the ignorance in our culture which allows so many to become so incredibly obese. It is pervasive. Just direct some of these people to some links on the web and tell them "they probably just don't know a lot about it."

8

u/Razbonez Jan 13 '20

They honestly probably don't much about anything.

54

u/Dougalface Jan 13 '20

As others have said; f*ck them and prove them wrong by making youself better than they are*

*Assuming you're not actually anorexic, obviously :p

17

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Were you to see me on the street, nothing about me would scream “anorexic”

8

u/Dougalface Jan 13 '20

Glad to hear it :)

11

u/branluvr Jan 13 '20

Wow... You have a hard enough job counting beans when we live in a day and age of scales, and they want to call names? Just think, where will they be when they need 15 beans? They will be crying to you with fistfulls of beans.

6

u/jenflu Jan 13 '20

I don't know what this is or where this is from but it made hot broth come out of my nose

1

u/branluvr Jan 13 '20

Get ur fluids girl!

Look at the user name of the person I replied to 😉

91

u/Undercover_Metalhead Jan 13 '20 edited Jan 14 '20

“Why try to lose weight, you’ll just gain it back” was what I heard most of my life. I dropped from 240 to 170...back up to 210...and now I’m going down again...but I never gained it all back.

37

u/cygetsfit Jan 13 '20

An overall positive trajectory! You got this, friend!

176

u/928quest Jan 13 '20

My wife admitted she likes her friends better when they are fatter than her. THey are not rooting for you, they are worried you'll accomplish something they can't. I had a woman on NYE tell me that I'm going to fail and gain it all back, when I said "no, that won't happen" she walked away in a huff. The reason being is that she has failed many timers herself.

Fuck em'. Fix yourself, it'll be a wonderful accomplishment.

47

u/Dougalface Jan 13 '20

Yeah, I think there was a study done once that I couldn't possibly reference, that suggested that people were only friends with those they thought they were "superior" to in one or more aspects of their lives..

33

u/greenisbetterthan27 Jan 13 '20

I'm partly guilty of that. If others are better than you it's easier to tear them back down instead of looking at yourself honestly and becoming better yourself.

Self-sabotage is easier then self-improving.

But life becomes easier if you self-improve and harder if you self-sabotage.

20

u/Dougalface Jan 13 '20

To be fair we all are. I hate myself sometimes for how resentful I am towards people I perceive as "better" than I am, and in the past I've been guilty of attempting to discourage friends from doing things I think will improve their lives (to my relative detriment in the context of what we're discussing).

Totally agree about self-improving; IME the "better" you are the more content you are and the happier you are for others.

Also, kudos for recognising that fact. It's been a startling revelation to me (pretty late in life I guess) that you can step back and objectively assess your thoughts and actions in order to make yourself a better person. While I'm late to the party I think many people go through their entire life totally oblivious to the need / ability to do this and just accept themselves as who they are; regardless of the negative impact this may have on those around them.

4

u/suzebob Jan 13 '20

Mum? Is that you?

3

u/Dougalface Jan 13 '20

Physiologically unlikely :p

12

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I had a girl in a college class say she only likes going out to bars and clubs with friends who are less attractive than her. Nobody is against most of the time and most people will be for you. But they don't want you doing better than them.

56

u/Beximus Jan 13 '20

First rule of fast club...

23

u/Secretweaver Jan 13 '20

THIS ^

Telling people is almost always a complete waste of time, and rarely will anything positive come from it. I just say "No thanks, I'm not hungry" or "I already ate" or "My stomach is upset, I don't really feel like eating right now".

10

u/la_zarzamora 5'8"/F/SW: 195/CW: 140/GW: 130 Jan 13 '20

underrated comment

186

u/afannoe Jan 13 '20

People don’t want you to lose weight. They may say with their words but not their actions. Have to fight to win

69

u/CollectedCalmAnChill Jan 13 '20

I think its a bit more complicated than that. Most people aren’t educated enough in every subject.. so when someone says “im gonna fast for —-“ they think he is being insane.

40

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I think people worry about anorexia.

63

u/NineElfJeer Jan 13 '20

I mean, I worry about anorexia on this sub all the time. I don't say anything because I don't know anyone's story, but there are some people who appear to be fasting for longer times than seems necessary for their current (seemingly low) weight.

But again, I don't know their journey, medical history, or goals, so I shut my mouth.

26

u/RedNumber_40 Jan 13 '20

I think the cases like that are pretty apparent. There was a girl here who needed to lose like 10 pounds and she wanted to do a 16 day fast. Those people tend to stick out and can be redirected to the appropriate help. But overall I’ve seen fasting done in a responsible manner on here.

34

u/take-hobbit-isengard Jan 13 '20

but also, it's easy to tell yourself you're gunna do a 16 day fast before you've started it, that's just a number in your head that you mentally masturbated yourself up to.

Once they're 3-4 days in (if they even make it that far) they start to realize just how long that is and bail.

25

u/dadelyon Jan 13 '20

"Mentally masturbated"

4

u/motherisaclownwhore Jan 13 '20

The smaller you are, the harder fasting becomes. So, they start with a random number but it's definitely malleable.

7

u/MyShout M(59) SW 268.6 CW 251.2 GW 170 Jan 13 '20 edited May 01 '20

Well, I'm not so sure that this was crazy. Maybe she just did the math. If she wanted to drop 10 pounds of fat (not just water) and assuming she burns 2000 calories a day, a 16 day fast is about what she'd need.

6

u/jolliest_elk Jan 13 '20

An acedote here. I’ve found fasting for 4+ days helps immensely with my mental health, especially anxiety. I don’t look like I need to fast — at the low-mid of the healthy weight for my height/other factors — but I sure do benefit from the practice in other ways.

7

u/Emperorerror Jan 13 '20

Should also be noted that weight loss isn't the only reason to do an extended fast.

4

u/NineElfJeer Jan 13 '20

You are absolutely right, and that's part of what I mean when I say that I don't know their story. I like the autophagy aspect of fasting, myself, but I don't think someone in a healthy weight range necessarily needs to fast for a month to reap the benefits. But since I don't know anything about the posters, I keep my mouth shut.

3

u/Emperorerror Jan 14 '20

Oh yeah, that's totally fair. I interpreted your comment as in people doing 5 day fasts, or somewhere in that realm. 30 days is definitely overboard for someone in a healthy weight range in my opinion, as well. But I'm totally in agreement that as you say, I don't know anything about the posters. And I also shouldn't claim to know more about fasting than them. Perhaps that's totally fine.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I think anorexia and bulimia is an exaggerated concern. Any time I tried anything to lose weight, which I've been fat or obese for probably 80% of my life, I would get loved bombed with "concern" that I was starving myself simply by watching what I ate. Obesity and poor habits is definitely a much more pressing health concern in America at this point.

1

u/Elan40 Jan 13 '20

Like all those poor bag a bones folks in Africa. And those are the healthy ones.

7

u/b_digital Jan 13 '20

As someone who used to react negatively to the notion of fasting and now swears by IF, I’ll say my negativity towards it was 100% projection. I was scared of the notion of what I assumed was being hungry all the time and came up with a million justifications of why it was bad for you, etc.

Granted I never outwardly said anything to anyone unless they suggested it to me first.

2

u/Kielo1 Jan 13 '20

Congratulations on the hard work!! And weight loss. Can I ask you a question? How do you approach someone who I guess is obese? We have a daughter of a close acquaintance, long time friends. My wife works with the young lady I’m talking about. This girl was a cheerleader in high school and college and was into competitive cheer in her childhood and teens. So she had a gymnast body. She is 29 today, and from the time she was 20-21 she started putting on weight. She carries like an additional 70-80 pounds on her. She is a beautiful girl, but she will not lose the weight or never has she even intimated her weight was an issue. She’s been trying to get pregnant and can’t. So what the hell do you say? Your comment was, no one said a word when you were overweight, but what would you have thought if they did? Would you suddenly put down the Ho-Ho’s, and hug their neck and say, “thank you for slapping me into reality?” Or would you have been offended? So how do you say to someone like I just described.... that they should lose weight? She has an overweight mother and grandmother, and apparently the weight is just fine with her. She’s is super social and hangs out with her old cheerleading friends from college. How do you approach someone like this? Like you used to be? She does Orange Theory with my wife and out scores her every time. (Age difference of course) but she is convince her lifestyle in healthy- ish... but definitely OK.

31

u/NineElfJeer Jan 13 '20

I understand your point, but I think you've missed the original point: OP is wishing that people around them would shut up as they did when she was unhealthy, not wishing they'd spoken up when she was unhealthy.

Unless asked directly, we shouldn't be commenting (or worse, advising) on other people's weight/perceived health.

54

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

It’s none of your business and you don’t say shit.

5

u/zesty_mordant Jan 13 '20

Living up to your name I see

24

u/DuckyDoodleDandy Jan 13 '20

Women trying to get pregnant should not fast. And unless she is risking her life/health, it isn’t any of your business.

We all grow/change at different rates. Just because you are successfully losing weight doesn’t mean you need to force others to do so.

If otters are curious and ask, share. But please don’t badger or bully others.

6

u/Legitconfusedaf Jan 13 '20

To add: women can struggle with fertility for a number of reasons. I am not a doctor but I also don’t think an extra 70 lbs would prevent her from getting pregnant, although I guess it depends on the person.

2

u/DuckyDoodleDandy Jan 14 '20

If that is the case, her doctor should tell her that. Since it isn’t life & death, it’s not anyone’s business but her own. (Edit) sorry I misread that as 70 lbs WOULD cause infertility.

1

u/Threkids3 Jan 13 '20

I am not sure but ever time I hit 135 I got pregnant. Lol

9

u/NineElfJeer Jan 13 '20

The topic tends to make people squirrelly.

6

u/eckokittenbliss Jan 13 '20

I think you have missed the entire point of the post.

You shouldn't say a thing. Not if someone is overweight or losing weight. It's not your business.

Even less so when they are an acquaintance and not even a close relative situation.

4

u/LaNaca8919 Jan 13 '20

Unless she asks for advice I wouldn't say anything. I have a friend with the same problem she just started losing weight. She would always make fun of me for having monthly periods when she only had 3 or less a year and I would just say "I'm cool with it because I might want children in future." I was kind of trying to maybe get her to check herself out but she never did until she got a husband and started trying for kids. Btw I was told I wouldn't be able to have kids because of my weight and irregular periods. And I fixed it by eating healthy and exercising. So yeah I know how it feels getting told that. Either they take the advice or theyre in denial. We lose weight when we're ready.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Everyone is so sensitive.

I say tell her upfront that she is growing a unhealthy amount of weight and then drop it and let her deal with it. At least show that you notice and are at least a little concerned.

I never would have lost the 150ibs I had if it wasn't for someone telling me harshly that I was disgustingly fat and I needed to lose weight or be dropped.

Maybe all she needs is kick in the gut to get her to wake up and if no one gives it to her then she will gain more weight and eventually become bed ridden.

Idk why everyone says it is not your business. Of course it isn't, but damn at least say something instead of acting like it is ok.

You should not have even ASKED what to do here cause you already know what everyone will tell you. People are so sensitive now and they will trash on anyone who gives unsolicited advice that might save someone but who are we to say? We just fast. We know how this shit works, or maybe you guys are all hyping up yourselves for lasting 10 hours without stuffing your faces with twinkies and and calling that "fasting"

7

u/eckokittenbliss Jan 13 '20

That is absurd. Telling someone they are fat is not helpful and just makes you a dick. Do you think they don't realize it? Lol

People are different and maybe you didn't realize being fat was an issue until someone told you and that helped you but that's not how most people operate. Look in any weight loss community and it's full of discussions where people have been told quite harshly their whole life that they were fat and yet they never changed. No one is going to change until they are ready to.

A better way to reach out would be to invite people to try healthy foods, to go do something active, discuss your own lifestyle and see if they get interested and reach out.

That's the entire fucking point of this post though lol like it's annoying as hell when people don't mind their own business and try to tell you jack about your body/health/diet. It doesn't matter if we are fat or thin or stuffing our face or fasting. It's not their business. Seriously people hear I was fasting and they were all like omg you are anorexic and gonna die and so unhealthy!

No one knows what's someone has going on in their life. She may have started a healthy diet and is making changes but doesn't tell a family friend or strangers lol

People are so rude lol

3

u/lupuscapabilis Jan 13 '20

I think the way you see this as such a hard and fast rule is absurd. I was gaining a lot of weight in college and like most people, I was able to justify it to myself and think I was hardly gaining weight at all. I looked in the mirror and thought I looked fine. I thought I felt fine.

It wasn't until one of my best friends said to me out of nowhere "dude, you're getting fat," that it shocked me into awareness and made me change all my habits. I'm very thankful he said that. No one else would. I wasn't ready to change at the time... because I thought there was no reason to change. I was "totally healthy."

You really shouldn't propagate this idea that telling someone they're fat is always wrong. Should a stranger say that to you? No, of course not. But a friend might just save your life by saying it.

1

u/prettyprincess91 Jan 14 '20

Agreed, nobody wants unsolicited advice. I still seethe with rage when I remember all the times my family “cared” about me by telling me how fat I was. If your intention is to be an asshole and get someone to hate you, sure, but otherwise don’t do it.

41

u/One_Percent_Kid Jan 13 '20

I do bulk and cut cycles. When I'm bulking no one blinks an eye at me for eating a 44oz ~3500 calorie steak with 3 baked potatoes, sour cream, butter, bacon and cheese in one sitting.

When I'm cutting, and I don't eat for 36-48 hours at a time, people suddenly think I have a "problem".

My dad has been following this exact cycle for over 20 years, and he's healthy as a horse.

39

u/val_nar Jan 13 '20

“BuT YoU nEeD tO EaT 3 mEalS a DaY” this is my favourite line people give me 🙄

38

u/Dougalface Jan 13 '20

Yeah, for whater reason my mum just wants to keep feeding me up when I'm back home. Evidently she prefers the high liklihood of my early death from diabetes / heart disease / various other obesity-related health issues to the tiny, tiny chance that I'll physically waste away to nothingness having lost half my body mass to "fad diets"...

To be fair, as much as she tries and always wants to "help", so far she's done a cracking job of offering me all manner of foods I can't / don't want to eat (due to food intolerances or diet preferences) and has eaten lots of high-carb comfort food in front of me :(

Just strenthens my resolve to continue tbh and prove her wrong.. 4.5 days into my fast and I'm developing a real feeling of empowerment and a real "f*ck you" attitude.

As sad is it is to say so, it never pays to rely on anyone else or give a toss what they think.

19

u/Dougalface Jan 13 '20

Further, just got back today and received a sharp gasp of horror in response to my revelation that I've not eaten for nearly five days... :p

Sad thing is she's got to be well into obesity territory and has problems with her knees (no doubt exacerbated by her weight) - I'd love her to try some of this stuff as I think it'd be so good for her and make her so much happier (and longer-lived). However, just like me until the past few years she'd rather prop herself up on a short-term crutch of binging on carb and fat-laden processed food.. although she's perfectly capable of cooking herself healthy meals. I think she's just given up (a feeling I can well relate to) which is a real shame.

I guess it's a trait that runs in our family; we all have our crutches in one way or another. I'm just working hard to get rid of one of mine..

31

u/Picsonly25 Jan 13 '20

Yes omg my mom said I was starving myself.. mama I’m 30 pounds overweight I have plenty

6

u/elzabeto Jan 14 '20

Haha same, she was so mad at me for apparently "starving" myself

46

u/lotus425 Jan 13 '20

The food industry and big pharmaceutical companies encourage eating and consuming . Fasting is bad for business

17

u/Dougalface Jan 13 '20

Yup. You pay for the crap that makes you ill, then pay for the "remedy". Paralleled with mental health as well IMO.

5

u/T4nkcommander Jan 13 '20

The mental health side of the scheme is especially sad/infuriating, because oftentimes they'll diagnose someone, remove their legal rights to make their own decisions, and effectively gain control of that individual for the rest of their lives, keeping them in a never-ending loop of 'treatment'.

It is only marginally better for the rest of the medical industry because we have the chance to wisen up and opt out.

16

u/TikiUtah Jan 13 '20

I’ve been doing 16:8 IF for several years but started doing 2-3 24 hour fast a week about six months ago. Just last week after fasting for three days my wife gets all concerned if I am starving and damaging my health. I replied to her “look at me, does it look like I am wasting away?” I’m 5’ 7” and 240 pounds.

25

u/Uchigatan Jan 13 '20

I KNOW REALLY

EVERYONE IS SO SCARED OF THIS SHIT LIKE MY ORGANS ARE THANKING ME STFU

54

u/livluvlaflrn3 Jan 13 '20

It’s not at all socially acceptable to comment when a fat or obese person is overeating. However it’s completely socially acceptable to comment when someone skips a meal. It’s also unheard of for most people to even conceive of fasting for multiple days.

I don’t agree with most of the comments in this thread. People aren’t out to get you. They’re commenting on unusual behavior. There have been many times I’d have liked to comment on a friend’s poor eating habits but could never do something like that at work. The risk is too high of insulting the person.

23

u/JonasLuks Jan 13 '20

You should be higher for the first paragraph only. Call someone too skinny? It's all good. Someone doesn't eat at your designated feeding windows? They must be out of their mind. Call someone fat? Oh, hell no! How dare you!

On the other hand, I somewhat disagree with the second paragraph - people aren't ACTIVELY out to get you. But they will happily prod you if they happen to find you balancing on the edge. So the other comments are somewhat right (though it's not as bad as some comments would have you believe).

7

u/Thaurwen Jan 13 '20

Honestly it depends on the person. Some people will be supportive, some people will think it's strange but not care, some people will think that because it's strange it's dangerous and that they're attempting to help you, some people are bitter for whatever reason and don't want others to succeed. The people we surround ourselves with make a huge difference on the amount and type of support we receive.

I will say that the people who are drawn to and stick with fasting are some of the most dedicated, disciplined people I've ever spoken to. They have to be, to overcome their addicted bodies' demands for fat, sugar, and salt at all hours of the day. Hunger can be very difficult to work past but they do. And that has to transfer over in some way to dealing with social pressure.

Some people may be driven by eating disorders, but most people I see on this subreddit, and on plenty of forums, do IF because it works for them and they find it easy to maintain a healthy lifestyle. So many people post pics of huge meals showing they are getting in the necessary nutrients. Broadly there's a focus on health, which differentiates the IF community from pro-ED groups.

10

u/CanadianAndroid Jan 13 '20

Drink your face of for 3 years and nobody says a thing.

Eat a processed sandwich instead of organic and everyone loses their mind!

3

u/some_lost_time Jan 13 '20

You have a much different group of friends than me. If anyone that knows me seen eating organic, vegetarian meals that m they would definitely say something. I'd be labeled a cityiot, yuppy or liberal tree hugger.

8

u/mcraleigh Jan 13 '20

Maybe people didn’t want to hurt your feelings or make you feel bad about yourself by fat-shaming you and at the same time cared about you and worried you were unhealthy but kept quiet since they loved you. Now that you are losing weight they just don’t want you to go too far too fast since they know you can lose but are less afraid of your feelings being hurt as you proved you are interested in losing weight.

11

u/Dooman92 Jan 13 '20 edited Jan 14 '20

Could be worse you could be fasting and vegan lol. I guess I’m just a glutton for punishment.

2

u/IvoryNage ADF Faster Jan 14 '20

At first I read this as 'gluten for punishment' and was like Woah! Vegan fasting AND gluten free?!

Then I realized it meant glutton. XD

1

u/LotusBeauty28 Jan 13 '20

😂😂😂

8

u/rosiesmam Jan 13 '20

We all started fasting at work!!!

26

u/planko13 Jan 13 '20

I’m convinced that this is a symptom of elitism around people who are a healthy weight.

Without fasting it takes a tremendous effort to lose weight. Months of perfect behavior, meal planning, and exercise with a religious devotion. The only way these people are successful is if they basically dedicate their lives to it.

Cut to the asshole (me) who loses 30 lbs like it was nothing, lands dead center in ideal BMI, and feels great. It upsets these folks that i only exercise occasionally (1-2 times a week), relentlessly makes fun of crossfit, and never passes on mexican. I am not worthy of being affiliated with the previous group.

Therefore I am unhealthy, even though my medical number are perfect (just a few years ago they were borderline on a lot of bad things).

15

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I mean if you're relentlessly making fun of someone else's routine for staying healthy (crossfit), that's also a problem and I can see why they'd be upset.

4

u/planko13 Jan 14 '20 edited Jan 14 '20

I mean, you’re not wrong.

But to be fair in this instance the folks I am making fun of crossfit with people that do not attend crossfit and usually are making fun of it too. I would never criticize someone directly for finding an exercise routine that works for them, no matter how many times they tell me they are in crossfit.

1

u/prettyprincess91 Jan 14 '20

Yeah, I wouldn’t want to spend time with you if you made fun of my hobbies. It’s a dick move.

4

u/planko13 Jan 14 '20

I wouldn’t want to spend time with you if you didn’t make fun of my hobbies. That sounds incredibly boring.

3

u/prettyprincess91 Jan 14 '20

Cool, let’s not be friends

3

u/paradoxic_al Jan 13 '20

I think you have a real point here.

7

u/stevennva Jan 13 '20

It’s crazy!! I have people try to tell me that I’m all wrong and I calmly tell them “when the student is ready the teacher will appear”

7

u/Talnix Jan 13 '20

Hot take: I don’t think people give their (unsolicited) opinion on fasting bc they are concerned for your health, it’s an opportunity for them to flex their ‘food/health’ knowledge and somewhat shame the person fasting

6

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

“Haters gonna hate?”

6

u/FailedPhdCandidate Jan 13 '20

When my wife was bigger one of her friends literally told her, “But there’s less of you to love.” She stopped seeing her after that.

6

u/Threkids3 Jan 13 '20

Bitch comment. Not a friend

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I do not understand why people feel the need to tear others down to make themselves feel better. I am sure I never will.

Glad your wife is at a healthier weight. I hope you are both happier because of it. Good luck.

6

u/LambOfLiberty M-36 5'8" SW: 315 CW: 239 Jan 13 '20

I’m on day 8, finally my family understands...when I started fasting a year or so ago my mom was so worried she came to my work to check on me...

6

u/Teosto Jan 13 '20

Couldn't say it better than that.

One day a few years back when me and the wife were visiting my mom and my mom asked if I want some cake with my black coffee and I told them I don't want to eat anything today that black coffee alone is fine. Both were horrified and told me I would die. At that point I didn't want to tell them it was 6th and the last day of fasting.

Since then I've told them both that I've done a bit longer than one day fasts. They don't like the idea but are not protesting against it either.

6

u/Ctex1968 Jan 13 '20

In 2008 I lost 40 lbs in 2 months and my coworkers thought I had cancer....even tho I told them I was fine...

6

u/asolidfiver Jan 14 '20

Someone at work was very concerned that I was eating too much hummus... and she eats McDonald’s at least 4 times a week. Don’t worry about my hummus, Karen.

5

u/xJwad Jan 13 '20

Sounds about right😂 keep up the good work! Haters gonna hate

5

u/teacatten Jan 13 '20

Omgoodness... my husband calls it my starving diet...

5

u/damnsonwhatsthat Jan 13 '20

Damn. I lost 100 pounds and found out that someone asked my brother if I was sick cause I was losing weight (someone in my workplace. Didn't even know my brother knew people from there).

5

u/frecklesxmcgee Jan 14 '20

Whenever I talk about what I’m doing to try to lose weight suddenly everyone becomes an expert nutritionist and tells me I’m trying to lose too much weight (I’m a 5’1”F CW: 148 GW:120) and I’m not eating right by fasting blah blah. My New Years resolution is to not only lose the weight but to not talk to anyone about it in my real life.

4

u/Deadagger Jan 13 '20

Never have I seen something so relatable in my life lmao, I lost 25kg(60lbs) and now my entire family is telling me how I’m so thin and they think I got depressed and shit cause I also left my beard.

4

u/udonowho Jan 13 '20

I don’t call it fasting anymore to avoid judgement. I either say it’s timed eating or I say I’m not hungry or I already ate. People have too many opinions about how you should lose weight. It’s really no one’s business.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Especially since they won’t be doing the work to lose it like come on.

4

u/Ctex1968 Jan 13 '20

It’s the America way...If your not FAT something’s wrong!!!

4

u/Ranger1837 losing weight faster Jan 14 '20

I'm lucky. My family is supportive no matter what I try. Sometimes they'll try it themselves. I think they consider me the smartest one in the family, so they defer to me. They understand I've researched it. And I'm able to articulate that knowledge to them.

But I also think they are just hoping it will finally work. They want me to get married and have kids, so the sooner I'm in shape and dating the better.

4

u/yudhiesh Jan 15 '20

I dealt with the same thing and funny enough it was from those who were mostly overweight or obese. I felt as though they didn't like seeing me change for the better.

4

u/backsails Jan 19 '20

My best friend was super against the idea of IF once I opened up to her about it. We had so many debates that I ended up making a powerpoint, not to convince her, but just to talk to her about it in a well-informed manner. Once I told her I made this powerpoint, she didn’t even want to see it then (she was tired of arguing with me), and ever since, we’ve just dropped the subject.

When we hang out, she sees me eat and make healthier choices when I do, and that’s enough for her. If I’m in a fasting window I just tell her I already ate/I’m not hungry (which are not lies).

Essentially we’ve agreed to live and let live. She was mostly just concerned I would develop an ED.

Thing is, I already have an ED, expect I was seriously overeating, instead of the other way around. IF helps a lot. It forces me to have more discipline and self-control and those are exactly what I was lacking.

3

u/emberfox67 Jan 13 '20

Hell yes. I finally got healthy after spending my entire childhood overweight, and all of my family asked if I was eating and if I needed money for food because I looked sick.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Pace yourself! Keep it going! Congratulations

3

u/Antelope46 Jan 13 '20

So weird! Sorry to hear about the lack of support of the friends/family of people in this thread :-(

3

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

This is why I don't say anything when I'm fasting!!

3

u/rende Jan 13 '20

Theyre all brainwashed to eat atleast three times a day. And they tell you just move harder.

3

u/LaNaca8919 Jan 13 '20

I lost a lot weight before fasting and ate a lot (I would work out a lot) and people still said I did coke or just ate salad.

3

u/jbartnick Jan 13 '20

Wreck your health any other way than OMAD and no one cares. Tell people you lost 20lbs on OMAD and IM and friends and family become concerned.

3

u/Gargudo Jan 13 '20

So true! Just keep on doing what makes you feel happy and healthy.

3

u/12weeksTia Jan 14 '20

This lady is my kindred. All kinds of people are worried about me getting "too small" but not a soul was every worried about me getting too big. Honest to God could still lose 50lbs and be on the heavy side of healthy and yet people are worried.

3

u/botsfor_dayz Jan 14 '20

anyone else get accused of having an eating disorder because of their fasting lifestyle?

4

u/IvoryNage ADF Faster Jan 14 '20

Yes, ironically by my boyfriend who also fasts. But he does intermittent fasting whereas I occasionally do a 48hr fast which concerns him.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

Educate him

4

u/IvoryNage ADF Faster Jan 14 '20

I did. He supports my fasting (as well he should since he's the one who got me started XD) but was worried about doing too many 48 hour fasts.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

I mean educate him further into extended water fasting. My own was uncomfortable with it until I shared some of the Dr. Fung stuff. All that is peer reviewed and very credible.

3

u/SilverFox8188 Jan 14 '20

Ain't that some shit? Join a gym, love it and go 5-6 days a week..."You're becoming obsessive!" Damn right I am! Better than obsessing over food and slowly killing myself.

3

u/krissykat55 Jan 14 '20

Silence is golden. Screw what anyone else thinks - none of their damn business.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

Lol...and why I don’t tell anyone around me I am fasting. If they offer food more than once, I’m good saying, “no thank you, means no.” 💛

3

u/Daster01 Mar 28 '20

Sounds like america

3

u/Phat-daddyo Feb 28 '22

Exactly! I was over 500lbs, pre-diabetic, with COPD, Blood pressure through the roof and no concerns from my adult obese children over my health. Upon learning I was fasting to improve my health my youngest “woke” son strongly disapproved arguing that I might “hurt” myself. Almost 300 lbs lost, no more COPD, no more BP meds, perfect blood tests, and unlimited energy and activities and he still is dubious. What the actual!

5

u/Reneeisme Jan 13 '20

Maybe this will get down voted to hell, but I don't really see the point in this statement. I mean, I can relate to the feeling that it's insulting for people to assume this thing you do with knowledge and care, for the betterment of your health, is crazy and dangerous and done out of ignorance. Of course that's difficult to deal with. But people said plenty about it when she was 300 lbs. Just not to her face. They didn't lecture her about it, because it's assumed any reasonably intelligent adult knows being that heavy and eating crap is really bad for you. They didn't feel the need to pile on. They still cared that she was that big, and they still speculated about what she was doing to her health. People who know and care about you will always do that.

Fasting is a whole different thing. There's no assumption that everyone knows about muscle atrophy, heart damage and other possible consequences of long term fasting done wrong. There's a very real (whether we like it or not) possibility of embracing a fasting lifestyle being, or becoming, part of disordered eating, and again, not something there's an assumption that everyone knows. Their comments are out of legitimate and reasonable concern.

I don't personally feel the need to hear it, so I don't share the information that I'm fasting very often. But the concern people express when I have to share it is heartfelt, and I don't view it as a negative thing. They care about me and don't want me to hurt myself.

1

u/diarrheaisnice Jan 13 '20

Thank you for this comment. I developed anorexia thanks to IF and more people should be aware of the dangers of it. 1 in 4 people who diet end up developing an eating disorder. I struggle to get even 300 calories in me a day. My brain, heart and other internal organs are suffering for it. I went from 175 to 115 in 2016 and I haven’t been the same since. I know it’s not like this for everyone, I have psychological issues that make my ED worse, that being said it’s still a major feat to lose that much weight and you should always consult with a medical professional before attempting to lose weight.

2

u/w8cycle Jan 13 '20

Amen, sister.

2

u/kmartimcfli Jan 13 '20

My mother was always this way until she dropped 60 lbs....gained it all back and guess what....she's right back to preaching anytime anyone in her life changes their eating habits or losses weight and telling me and my siblings and other families members we should all just be happy with ourselves. Like hello, I remember who u were 5 years ago when you were taking care of yourself stop!

2

u/chricky333 Jan 13 '20

Great job on the weight loss and great post!!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

That’s because people don’t want to be labeled a fat bully because so many have got behind body positivity and shit like “fat is beautiful”.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '20

I just tell people at work “No thanks, I’m not hungry.”

2

u/ypiyales Jan 13 '20

I always talk about thisssssssssssssss so true

1

u/BillMPE Jan 13 '20

To hell with those people.

1

u/TioPuerco Jan 13 '20

There's always that someone who doesn't want to see someone else succeed. Well done!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I get the same talk too lol

1

u/junkandother Jan 13 '20

Wow. Well said.

1

u/Puppywanton Jan 13 '20

Yeah no, people judge, they’re just socially conditioned to not say anything about someone else’s food because it’s rude.

1

u/firstlady_j Jan 13 '20

😂🤣😂 do you

1

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

Right?

1

u/Rc2photo Jan 14 '20

True. 🙄🙄

1

u/dawnnie413 Jan 14 '20

Amazing, isn't it?

1

u/dwhylton1 Jan 14 '20

Congratulations on your awesome success you can do it OMAD is the answer you are beautiful

1

u/AdrianS74 Jan 14 '20

Story of my life

1

u/annewhite10 Jan 17 '20

I think it’s important that you recognize that many people voicing “concern” may be either willfully or subconsciously sabotaging you. Protect yourself against this possibility, as they may start trying even harder. They’re used to viewing you a certain way, and likely feeling better about themselves as a result. You’re threatening their world because you’re improving yours; and becoming a threat to how they view theirs.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '20

fr why are ppl so afraid of being healthy and making educated choices?

1

u/rumplestilskin98765 Jul 14 '22

Isn’t it wild???

0

u/fathusky2341 Jan 24 '20

Just lower your calories no point in fasting

4

u/FrostyFathom Jan 30 '20

You’re on the wrong subreddit.. there are TONS of benefits. Most people on here have done the research.

2

u/fathusky2341 Jan 30 '20

Like what

5

u/FrostyFathom Jan 30 '20

Speaking from personal experience I struggled to lose weight while exercising and counting calories. It just want working in the way I felt it should. I switched to intermittent fasting and was able to drop 59+ lbs in 6 months to nearly my goal weight for the year. There is a lot of science to it that I have spent countless hours going through and while yes, part of it is the fact that by reducing the amount of hours you eat in you will indeed be eating less calories and snacking less.. so you’ve got a point in the whole.. eat less thing. Absolutely valid. But also, by eating only in a small window it allows your body to run off of only stored energy/fat for a majority of the day. Also if you work out in a fasted state it targets the small pockets of fat in your muscles leading to more defined muscles. Usually to burn this you’d have to have SUPER intense workouts and a very clean diet if not fasting. I don’t know how much of the research is legitimate as I tend to be cautious of all health related research. However I can say intermittent fasting worked for me when other things such as calorie counting failed. I also appreciate that you were looking for knowledge and not just on here trolling.. so I take back my downvote and replace it with an upvote.

-3

u/Frakhtal098 Jan 13 '20

Am I gonna be the one to drop the r/thathappened on your asses?