r/fantasywriting • • May 11 '25

Help me choose a book cover! [aimed at older teens and YA]

Thumbnail
gallery
457 Upvotes

A simple synopsis: A dystopian fantasy in the far future where a monster hive mind has overrun most of the world, while an empire steadily loses ground over a 7000 year war. It’s got comedy in too though. And magic. Cos magic cool. Feature post-human horror and real-to-doctrine military engagements.


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 03 '25

How would you kill a god?

424 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Nov 09 '24

LOTR doesn't "start with action," why does modern fantasy?

391 Upvotes

Most of the fantasy stories I've read recently start with some exciting hook. But the Fellowship of the Ring begins with a 20 page prologue about Hobbits, pipe-weed, the Shire, and how Bilbo found the Ring. Then the first chapter starts with mild action: the anticipation of Bilbo's birthday, which is not particularly thrilling.

I feel like what I think of as "modern fantasy" would start the story with Bilbo hiding from his friends, or even with Frodo running from the black rider:

Frodo heard the shrieks as he lay facedown in the damp dirt. He had been pursued by a strange dark horseman ever since Gandalf, a peculiar old wizard, had told Frodo to leave with Bilbo's favorite golden ring.

Tolkien once said that he really enjoyed history, and he wrote LOTR partly just to write the history of his Middle Earth. Still it became probably the most iconic fantasy series that I know of.

So why does it feel like new fantasy has to be so fast-paced? Are readers less patient? Is the fantasy genre so flooded that writers have to grab attention quickly, and can't rely on a reader's inherent interest? Was Tolkien's world just so much better than everyone else that he could afford to move the story slower and focus more on the world itself? I see commonly see reviewers criticizing extensive world-building explanations, but I recall a part in LOTR that takes at least an entire page just to describe a tree and how old it was. Where is the middle ground for writers who enjoy building the environment, as Tolkien built the Shire and Hobbits, before diving into the action?


r/fantasywriting • • Aug 10 '25

why fantasy genre is hated by intellectuals

345 Upvotes

why is the fantasy and scifi genre constantly snubbed by most literary awards? ive read that it's escapism and that most fantasy writers suck. y'all got a different take?


r/fantasywriting • • Jan 29 '22

What abilities would a creature like this have?

Post image
320 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • 27d ago

Can we PLEASE let villans just be straight up psychopaths… I BEG.

273 Upvotes

That‘s all I have to say.

EDIT: I love all the different points of views here!!


r/fantasywriting • • Jun 29 '25

If a big wolf was intelligent enough to wield weapons and wanted to use one, what would be the best weapon choice for it?

Post image
248 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • May 14 '25

Which book cover? (again) [aimed at YA/teens]

Post image
212 Upvotes

Yahoo! Hello again everyone, first of all thank you for the frankly overwhelming engagement with the last post I made! Your collective enthusiasm is very flattering. With your input changes have been made and 2 cover concepts remain. HELP ME CHOOSE -b


r/fantasywriting • • Feb 25 '25

At what point do you lose respect for an author outside of illegal crap?

205 Upvotes

I'll go first; when they ruin their story by playing into what they want or what the fans want

*Edit since it wasn't clear but basically, I hate it when the author decides to sacrifice good writing for the sake of their personal interests or fan service*


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 12 '26

What is the worst fantasy book you ever read? The one so bad you want to delete it from your memory.

194 Upvotes

We all read a lot of fantasy books, and it's sure we didn't love them all. At some point, we all wasted our time on a story that was just that bad.

What's the one fantasy book that was so bad you wish you could delete it from your memory?


r/fantasywriting • • Apr 02 '26

Do you still use em dashes in your writing?

169 Upvotes

I've seen videos on TikTok and have had friends tell me about the unspoken AI rules, like how it commonly uses the rule of three, em dashes, or 'that's not _, that's _!'. So I have been extremely cautious about using any of these AI tell-tales. However, before generative AI was mainstreamed, so to speak, I frequently used em dashes and the rule of three in my writing, and it's almost ingrained in my writing style. Can I still get away with using this stuff without being persecuted for using AI to write for me?


r/fantasywriting • • Jun 16 '26

How much should I charge for character illustrations?

Thumbnail
gallery
161 Upvotes

Hey all!

I've been a book cover artist & designer for over 14 years and got into digital painting a couple of years ago. Lately, I've been getting queries for character illustrations, but I'm not aware of the industry standards for that as majority of my work has been book covers.

I'd love to know how much you paid for your character art and what the current rates are.

Sharing some of my work here for quality reference.

Thank you!


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 30 '24

Help, accidentally made my fantasy race a racist stereotype.

161 Upvotes

Title mainly for attention. So I'm currently writing a fantasy series pilot and wanted to add a crime family and i ran my idea past a few friends and they pointed out that i may have accidentally made them anti-semtic . I'm trying to bring in a many of the standard fantasy races as i can and revamp them for my world and so i thought about making the crime family halfings/hobbits who considered 2nd class citizens in the old empire due to there rejection of organized religion and now that the old empire is gone some of the bigger families have become very wealthy as they had a head start on the magical boom that came after the fall. The first of theses families the main character will meet is a crime family, run by a younger halfing women who acts like a philanthropist but actually runs a crime empire. So how can i keep the core of the idea without it being offensive or should i just change it up completely

Update 1. Enough of people here disagree with the connection or think its very circumtansional. So I'll continue to write this minor subplot while trying to keep in mind not to stray any closer to tropes. Thanks for the help


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 07 '26

Any tips for writing an Hero Universe but for Novels

Thumbnail
gallery
159 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Sep 25 '26

I have finally completed my shifter bestiary. What do you think? Which is your fav?

Thumbnail
gallery
156 Upvotes

So I have finally done it. (well, 99% done)

I have finally (almost) finished with my bestiary (of sorts) for my first ever attempt at a fantasy novel. Right now it is a 9 book saga in my outline, but i wanna try to condense the story into 7 books instead. As I write every new chapter, we'll see.

Anyways, my novel is about a human girl from earth who gets trapped on an alien planet and on this planet everyone is a shifter of sorts. And here is my list of all my humanoid shifters. Some are inspired by already existing fantasy creatures from different cultures, but most I have made up all by myself. What do y'all think of my lineup? Are there any shifters you're excited to read about?

P.S. There are 8 continents in total in my world and every book will explore a different continent with all of the different shifter countries.

P.P.S. continents are called kingdoms in my book. Real world example: The kingdom of Asia includes countries like Japan or Thailand.

*not my art btw

The Runaki (rune-nah-kee) Kingdom
The Mari Olu (maah-ree oh-lou) Kingdom
The West Faeryn (west fae-rin) Kingdom
The East Faeryn (east fae-rin) Kingdom
The Kharuun (kah-roon) Kingdom
The Maeisia (may-ee-zhee-uh) Kingdom
The Ehlari (eh-larr-ree) Kingdom
The Nohtai (no-tie) Kingdom

Here are the countries within each Continent/Kingdom.

*The Kingdom of the Runaki (rune-nah-kee) contains countries that are the only non-shifters in my world but they still have other abilities. 
[contains 8 countries]
*Nullasha (null-ahh-sha) - they control blood as defense and attack + other abilities.
*Zemiyizan (zem-me-yee-zahn) - voodooist inspired race with a mix of both Haitian & Taino influences.
*Alchemist - will have middle eastern influences in my book
*Elenati (el-lee-nah-tea) - basically elementalist - they control all 4 elements + has weather powers like storm from xmen
*Titans - basically giants (they usually keep out of any conflict with other nations)
*Astrolos - has celestial and astroplane-like powers - similarish powers to an anodite from ben 10 [emphasis on the ish]
*Griots (gree-oh) - inspired by west african influences. Their voices are hypnotic & they are the ancient & modern historical record keepers of my world
*Mogin (moe-gin) basically dwarfs but with additional powers - super speed like dash from the incredibles & a seismic punch, etc.
***Witches exist in my world, but they are not treated the same as a real country within the Runaki kingdom/continent for plot reasons.***

Kingdom of the Mari Olu (maah-ree oh-lou) are sea shifters
[14 countries]
*Wata (aka mami & papi watas) west african folklore & they are similar to a mermaid  but with different abilities
*Jengu (jeng-goo) - Cameroonian folklore & are also similar to a mermaid but has the power to travel oceans in various worlds in my book.
*Siren - you know what this is
*Scorrois (Score-roast - but don’t pronounce the T) - Half human & half lionfish
*Quorzoa (kwor-zoh-uh) - half human & half jellyfish
*Launix (Lawn-nix) - half human & half blue dragon sea slug 
*Raylunin (ray-loo-ninn) - stingray hybrid
*Ekoris (e-kore-iss [like in kiss]) - human/seahorse mix
*Cecaelia (sei-kay-lee-uh) - basically Ursula
*Encantados - Brazilian + Portuguese folklore and are a dolphin people inspired by the Boto Encantados. But I am using the word Encantado to describe just my dolphin people.
*Samebito (sah-may-bee-toe) - japanese folklore and are shark people hybrids
*Taniwha (tah-nee-fah) yes its an f sound in the maori language - these are sea serpent lizard type creatures that also has a human form in my world
*Paoximei (pow-shee-may) - it's a serpent dragon-like flying lizard half human thing that I made up with Chinese influences. (I'm working with an artist on what it should look like. Wish me luck they can capture the image in my head)
*The Abyssal are my made up and very down deep sea creatures - they do have a human form but they almost never transform into it. They prefer their full creature form. They are also seen as otherworldly from all of their other humanoid sea creatures. They also sometimes get mistaken for an Adaro.
***The Adaro (Melanesian mythology) are not considered a country of people in my world because an Adaro is what a sea creature turns into when they turn evil and like it. They no longer can transform into their original creature form and they stay an Adaro forever. (or do they? Wink wink)

West Faeryn (fae-rin) Kingdom - insect shapeshifters
[10 countries]
*Tacaanbé (tuh-khan-bae) - are a tarantula hawk & Australian tiger beetle + humanoid mix creature (can’t wait till i get an artist to draw what's inside my head. I’m excited for this one)
*Chrysalie (chris-suh-lie) - will be my moth-like people & and will have west african influences but this is my made up creature.
*Yumboes - (yum-bows) Senegalese folklore and are similar to fairies
*Fairies - i don’t need to explain them but they will have polynesian influences. (i got plans for them)
*Serif’s - are going to be an insect plant fusion type of people. Similar to one of those flower looking mantasis and other bugs, but humanoid.
*Ekahgen (E-Kah-gin) - Praying Mantis people inspired by the Ikaggen (eye kag-gen) mythology from the san people of south africa
*Iridessym (ear-ri-dess-sim) - dragonfly people
*Scarabos (Scare-rob-boast [without the t] [inspired by the word scarab]) - Horned dung beetle people - they’re hella strong in my story. They can out punch anyone. Don’t piss them off.
*Aragumo (r-ruh-goo-moe) - spider people
*Nektaree (neck-tar-ree) - bee people

East Faeryn (fae-rin) Kingdom - They have NON insect, animal or plant shifting abilities. They shift into non living hybrid things of this world.
[10 countries]
*Āinakahi (eye-nuh-kah-he) - dryad inspired (tree-like people) but will have polynesian influences
*Banshees - you know what these are. Boo
*Nunnehi - native american folklore influenced and can appear as invisible
*Aluxes - mayan folklore influenced and in my book are notorious for getting peace treaties signed between warring countries
*Naiads - european folklore influenced and are like water nymphs
*Menehune’s - hawaiian/polynesian folklore influenced and are the best builders and the most developed nation in my universe
*Curupira - brazilian folklore inspired and are great trackers/hunters (will be calling them something else in my book though because I've changed too much of their core lore. Don’t have a name yet - any ideas)
*Yakshini - (men are called yaksha’s) indian folklore influenced and are the most populated nation & tend to stay out of wars as they are naturally peaceful people like the airbenders in avatar
*Ashinté (ash-shin-tay) - has volcanic powers
*Bouldahvi (Boul-dah-vee [like in boulder]) are rock people

Kharuun (kah-roon) Kingdom - are all were-people that are all giant sized shifter versions of a real animal irl & made up animals I created
[11 countries]
*Were Dragon
*Were hyena
*Were Momoqui (mo-mo-kee) a made up animal in my book that these were-creatures are based off of
***I have ideas for the other 9 were-countries for a total of 11, but I haven't 100% decided yet what the other were-creatures are, so I won't name them here.***

Maeisia (may-ee-zhee-uh) Kingdom - These are all the snowy mountain countries hybrids.
[7 countries]
*Bizzarkyn (biz-zar-kin) loosely inspired by Jotun/frost giants but will be furrier in their creature form in my book. They gotta stay warm in a forever winter continent/kingdom.
*Migoi (me-goy) - Basically a yeti/abominable snowman but from Tibetan and Nepali folklore
*Tibex (tie-becks) - inspired by the ibex goat/rams that climb on the side of mountains to lick salt. (look it up, they are real. lol) but they are humanoid in my world.
*Durekei (dur-reh-kay [dur as in duracell]) - ice powered people
*Nemanay (knee-muh-nay) Their powers & look are inspired by seals & nematodes. They are the heavy-set tanks in my world. Usually tall and hefty people.
*Caimanie (kay-mon-knee) - alligator hybrids - they will have an urban fantasy aesthetic within their clothing and they will still have human-like faces when they transform
*Tariaksuq (tar-e-ack-sook) Inuit folklore influenced. They let you see what you want to see but it may or may not be real.

Ehlari (eh-larr-ree) Kingdom - These are all my winged shifter people 
[8 countries]
*Vespera (vess-spare-ruh) - bat winged ehlari
*Dyveryn or Dyverin (die-vare-rin) = dragon winged Ehlari 
*Sorengyl (soarin-guy-uhl [like the ending sound in argyle]) - swimming bird-like Ehlari
*phoenix (i’m thinking about changing this to something else but not sure yet.)
*Taozaiye (tao-zai-ye [like in yeet but without the “T”]) - they have a metallic organic metal type of wing
*Arodile (arrow-dial) - albatross/vulture mixed wings and inspired power set
*Seraphi (sara-fie [like in the word fight]) - tri-angel winged Ehlari. So 3 sets of wings and each set has a different use.
*Lilum (Lil-lum) are my angel winged Ehlari and have 1 sets of wings

Nohtai (no-tie) Kingdom -  these are human and animal shapeshifters that shift into realistic 
versions of people and animals and many.
[smallest continent with only 2 countries in it]
*Biomorphs - human shapeshifters. They will have south american features in my story
*Nuhual (Nuh-while) - animal shapeshifter. Think beastboy from teen tians but without the green skin. And this word is from Mexican & South American folklore.

So. Which kingdom and/or country are you excited to read about? You can ask follow up questions if you want.


r/fantasywriting • • 22d ago Bravo

I've spoken to 300 writers about how they make money.

150 Upvotes

I've spoken to 300 writers about how they make money and the clearest takeaway from all these conversations is that the idea of the "full-time writer" living off book royalties or longform features rarely matches reality.

Writing alone rarely pays a consistent living wage, so people find different compromises to keep going. When I look through all these interviews, there are seven main pathways that keep showing up.

The first is the day job shield. Authors like Victor Beigelman at Meta or Dan Tovrov in corporate copywriting earn six-figure salaries with benefits, which removes the financial pressure from their fiction. The trade-off is time and energy, but it protects the work from having to pay the bills. As Ashley Hutson told me about keeping her day job as a state prison secretary while earning $1,000 to $2,000 a year from her writing, "Pretending to be a normal person every day and participating in society via a regular job is good for me, I think. There’s something to be said for keeping the juice to oneself."

Then there’s commercial client work. Writers like Ben Westhoff and Shelby Chambers charge corporate rates, thousands a month or hundreds an hour, ghostwriting executive books and handling brand messaging to subsidize their own reporting. 

Direct reader support is another route. Michael J. Sullivan has brought in over $2.1 million on Kickstarter for his fantasy novels, and Freddie deBoer makes roughly $300,000 a year on Substack. The main catch is that you’re effectively running a small media business, and maintaining that direct relationship requires showing up consistently.

Traditional book publishing remains the dream for many, but the payout schedule often surprises debut authors. A headline $100,000 advance sounds nice, but once it gets split across four installments over three or four years, and you subtract 15% for an agent and roughly 30% for taxes, you might net less than $15,000 in year one. When you factor in paying out of pocket for things like independent fact-checking or legal review, even a solid advance usually works out to be barely a salary.

Freelance journalism is another grind entirely. Unlike book advances, freelance assignments offer quicker turnover, but the baseline numbers have barely moved in decades. Rates usually hover between fifty cents and two dollars a word, while prestige outlets often pay flat fees around $300 for deeply personal essays. As Hermione Hoby put it simply after spending weeks on a heavily researched piece that ended up paying below minimum wage hourly, "Prestige don’t pay! At least not financially."

Some writers treat their work as a doorway to film and television, using essays and novels as intellectual property. Jeff Maysh has had dozens of projects in development and will happily take $100 for a literary journal piece just to keep the film rights, telling me, "I don’t really worry about the word rate, all I demand is 100% of the ancillary rights." But option fees are often modest, and projects frequently sit in development limbo for years without ever making it to the screen.

A lot of authors also rely on academia. Teaching positions offer reliable health insurance, steady routines, and paid summers. The catch is that academic work can eat into writing time just as much as an office job, and the tenure track is increasingly scarce. Still, the baseline makes a massive difference, as Nicholas Montemarano admitted: "In one year of teaching, I earn as much as I have in the past 25+ years as a writer."

Most writers aren't locked into just one of these models forever. They drift between them, leaning on a day job for a few years, taking commercial gigs when cash is tight, or living off a fellowship while finishing a manuscript. Longevity usually comes down to finding whichever compromise keeps your life afloat without draining the energy you need for the work that matters to you.


r/fantasywriting • • 7d ago

A Fable I Made up

Post image
127 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Sep 17 '26

Have a character who needs to hide his eyes at all times, looking for alternatives to a blindfold.

126 Upvotes

I have a character who has very visually distinct eyes that would serve as a way to identify him should anyone see him. I considered having him use a thin blindfold, but thought that would be too obviously weird. does anyone have any ideas on how he could conceal his eyes and still be able to see?

Edit for context: The character is a minor nobleman. the world has a level of technology equivalent to the 1400's. the setting is high magic but there is no illusion magic.


r/fantasywriting • • Feb 28 '25

Fantasy turns into horror!

Post image
126 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Oct 25 '25

8 Writing Tips That Actually Help

113 Upvotes

I’ve been collecting small but powerful writing lessons that improved my stories — the kind that Reddit writers actually use, not the textbook stuff.

Here’s a list that might help someone stuck, or maybe remind you of something you already know.

1. Readers Follow People, Not Plots

Great stories are about characters who choose, not plots that happen.
If you’re ever stuck, ask: what would my character do right now — not what should happen next?

2. Write Like You Talk (At First)

If your story sounds stiff, pretend you’re telling it to a friend out loud.
Then fix the grammar later. The honesty in your voice will stay even after the edits.

3. Read Bad Writing

You’ll learn what not to do faster than you think. Every confusing paragraph or flat dialogue you notice teaches you something your brain quietly remembers.

4. Motivation Is Overrated

You don’t need the “muse.” You need momentum.
Even a single line per day adds up — especially on bad days.

5. Earn Trust Before Sharing Work

If you post in writing subs, don’t just drop your story link.
Comment on others’ work, offer a thought, and join discussions.
People remember names that help, not names that promote.

6. Observe Before Posting

Every subreddit has its rhythm. Spend a few days watching what gets upvoted — tone, length, even title style. It helps more than you think.

7. Make Your Title Count

Posts that work usually:

  • Ask a question

  • Use numbers or lists

  • Promise something useful

Example:

8. Be Kind to Yourself

Your first draft is you telling yourself the story.
The second is where you tell it to the world. Don’t rush that step.

What’s your piece of writing advice that actually changed how you write?


r/fantasywriting • • Jul 21 '25

Do you think this stands out for a book cover? I painted it myself.

Post image
103 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Aug 08 '26

I’m really frustrated by homogenization in literature.

90 Upvotes

I’m going to say this the best I can, I find it kind of hard to organize these thoughts. I feel like there was a shift that changed peoples’ understanding of fantasy & science fiction. Star Wars, Indiana Jones, & D&D were all popular in the 70s, 80s, & still are today. All of them were intended as pastiches of media the creators enjoyed. Star Wars was riffing on westerns, samurai movies, & Flash Gordon serials, Indiana Jones was James Bond & Doc Savage, and D&D was the works of Robert E Howard, Jack Vance, Fritz Leiber, etc. People grew up enjoying these IPs, but somewhere along the way the literature they were inspired by became forgotten. An overwhelming amount of fiction seems more interested in homogenized, easy to understand fantasy worlds that make sure modern sensibilities & demographics are included than trying to make a genuinely interesting & strange world. Science fiction has especially suffered from these homogenized worlds, as not many IPs have seemed all that interested in genuinely exploring science, leading to anything that has outer space or futuristic tech as “sci-fi” even if there’s no science. I recognize that there are plenty of indie works which don’t suffer from these problems, but this is something I’ve been thinking a lot about & needed to get out.


r/fantasywriting • • Sep 26 '26

Fantasy tropes that aren't talked about enough

85 Upvotes

What do think about tropes in fantasy that are rarely used? Can you think of any tropes that you would like to see more in fantasy literature and media in general?


r/fantasywriting • • Aug 08 '26

I'm looking for a critique on the first few chapters of my illustrated novella, The Benefits of Blindness. (New Weird Fantasy, 8,000 words)

Thumbnail
gallery
80 Upvotes

I'm looking for a critique on the first few chapters of my illustrated novella, The Benefits of Blindness. The narrative takes place in a world in which giant insects exist and are used by humans for a variety of productive purposes such as war, entertainment, transportation, industry and an array of others. All the aforementioned creatures exist on one isolated island, the control of which is maintained by a single organization, The Oroboro Exchange Cartel. Our narrative follows an orphaned cabin boy from the day he is taken from his ship and pulled into the hierarchy of the cartel. I'm interested in a general critique, as well as, if possible, specific feedback on the voice (can you sense it?), the prose (do you find it fits the setting?), any thoughts regarding the protagonist, Stokley Faruthian (do you get a sense of him?), the feel of the world itself as it's quite strange, and any thoughts you might be willing to share on the illustrations and their fit with the feel and voice of the story. Lastly, as a hypothetical fantasy reader, based on the excerpt, would this spark your interest in continuing to read. The specific excerpt is the prologue and first two chapters of a ten chapter first volume, which is part of a larger series, obviously.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1cdotINeD49ZnDmM4PWbKharCei6xPVOb8yd07NSYAkE/edit?usp=sharing