r/fantasywriting • • Aug 17 '25

Appropriation? Offensive?Or am I too sensitive?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I'm working on a fantasy novel about guards working in a museum of magical objects dealing with themes of genocide, immigrants and immigration, angels, what is the meaning of success, superpowers, and a newly built hall of black magic, and it's a comedy. It's gotten excellent response at writer's circle in Minneapolis, Minnesota, New York City, and London. Everyone is rolling on the floor laughing- except the Chinese.

I thought I did all my research right. I asked Chinese co-workers for advice and advice from Chinese friends. I read many books about the bronzes. What went wrong? I am a museum guard and one of the objects that I protect is a Shang Dynasty ancient Chinese bronze that was used as a wine ewer. So I wrote a character where the bronze is an intercessor for the faithful who ancestor worship, but he is misused by a Western public into helping them get wishes. So he's sick of it and sick of being in a Western museum that doesn't get him and wants to go home. If they ask the ewer for a wish, he helps grant them, but mischievously helps them get it in a way they never intended.

A night guard wishes for super powers. So he asks the ewer, Guang. The Guang warns him to be careful. The guard isn't. He needs incense to complete the incantation but doesn't have any. He uses cigarettes instead. He gets powers but they don't work right and when they do, it's only in designated smoking areas.

My Chinese co-worker said some people are super sensitive. Don't worry, but I do. I didn't intend to be insulting.

Here's a picture of the ewer. I kind of think of him as a friend.


r/fantasywriting • • Jan 01 '25

How do I create strong female main characters?

0 Upvotes

You see I have a wee bit of a problem, I'm a guy and because of that I am perfectly equipped to write male MCs, when it comes to writing about you ladies I'm screwed : ) So is there any Gal here who can give me advice on how to write a female lead. This I would appreciate dearly. Thank you.


r/fantasywriting • • Jun 27 '26

AI tip off I've noticed.

0 Upvotes

I just received my monthly book box and the synopsis made me cringe because it contains something I've noticed as an indicator of AI use...

Elara is the MCs name. I've popped prompts into chatgpt and whatnot just to see what it spits out, out of curiosity not to actually use, and every single time the default name is Elara. It just makes me wary now. Hopefully if the author did use AI in some way, she changed things enough to make it her own and actually wrote the text herself. But it makes me feel weird reading this book now.


r/fantasywriting • • Feb 17 '25

How would slavery work in a fantasy setting? NSFW

2 Upvotes

Who Are the Slave Traders?

  • Are they a rogue group operating outside the law, or are they part of a larger, sanctioned organization?

  • Do they specialize in capturing (demi) humans, or do they deal in all kinds of slaves (humans, demi-humans, etc.)?

  • Are they motivated purely by profit, or do they have ideological reasons (e.g., hatred of demons)?

How Do They Operate?

  • Do they actively hunt for slaves, or do they wait for opportunities (like the fall of the Demon King’s castle) to capture fleeing individuals?

  • Are they well-organized with a hierarchy, or are they a loose band of opportunists?

  • Do they have connections to powerful figures (nobles, merchants, or even rival demon factions) who fund or protect them?

What Happens to the Slaves?

  • Are slaves sold at public auctions, or are transactions done in secret?

  • What kinds of buyers are there? (e.g., nobles, mages, laborers, gladiator pits)

  • Are slaves treated as property, or are there any protections (even if minimal)?

  • Do they collar or brand the slaves?

How Dangerous Are They?

  • Are they skilled fighters, or do they rely on numbers and intimidation?

  • Do they use magic or enchanted tools to subdue their captives?

  • Are they a credible threat to someone like Aria, or would she easily overpower them if not for Kael’s plan?

  • How knowledgeable are they, like do they know of the traits of each non-human species?

my story idea is as follows:

The demon king and the hero both die, the daughter of the demon king has to run away since this creates an enormous power vaccuum and with her being to young and inexperienced. becoming the next demon king isn't possible so she has to run away. i thought of using slave traders as an unique way of transport since they would easily be able to avoid border control and would be able to aquire fake documents which could prove usefull

would slavery be legal or illegal or would that depend on the country?

i would love some feedback and tips on how to handle this, it's a delicate subject, i am well aware of that but i prefer this over the hero's journey (travel, fight of problems etc) or plot (teleportation) i find this an unique and plausible explanation


r/fantasywriting • • Sep 12 '26

Calling all fantasy writers! I’m trying to write a book, but I can’t get past the world building without being stuck deleting and retyping paragraphs for weeks straight. Any ideas?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Feb 17 '25

Why don't we build our own indie publishing brand?

0 Upvotes

There's over 100k people in here. Is there any reason we cannot build and maintain our own indie publishing company separate from Amazon?

Id only 10% of worked together we'd be able to do it. It will be hard, tedious, and thankless at times but the alternative is we simply allow Amazon and other publishers to continue raking us over the hot coals while we do both but complain.


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 30 '24

Help, accidentally made my fantasy race a racist stereotype.

161 Upvotes

Title mainly for attention. So I'm currently writing a fantasy series pilot and wanted to add a crime family and i ran my idea past a few friends and they pointed out that i may have accidentally made them anti-semtic . I'm trying to bring in a many of the standard fantasy races as i can and revamp them for my world and so i thought about making the crime family halfings/hobbits who considered 2nd class citizens in the old empire due to there rejection of organized religion and now that the old empire is gone some of the bigger families have become very wealthy as they had a head start on the magical boom that came after the fall. The first of theses families the main character will meet is a crime family, run by a younger halfing women who acts like a philanthropist but actually runs a crime empire. So how can i keep the core of the idea without it being offensive or should i just change it up completely

Update 1. Enough of people here disagree with the connection or think its very circumtansional. So I'll continue to write this minor subplot while trying to keep in mind not to stray any closer to tropes. Thanks for the help


r/fantasywriting • • Dec 26 '23

Does beings born with magic discriminating against humans who acquire magic later in life sound like a good metaphor for transphobia?

1 Upvotes

I'm writing a fantasy story (that's a mixture between urban fantasy and portal fantasy) that talks about discrimination-both through metaphors and real-world examples. The biggest example for literal discrimination is that the main hero in it is autistic, which causes him to be bullied and lonely. The biggest example for literal discrimination is that there's an evil necromancer who wants to wipe out all humans without supernatural traits (in JK Rowling's words, "muggles", but my world has its own term for them) because of his prejudice against said group of humans.

I was originally thinking that all mythical beings should be born with their supernatural powers to make discrimination against them be more like racism or homophobia, but then I remembered how in Norse Mythology Odin only became a wizard later in life and wondered how I was therefore supposed to portray discrimination against wizards in this setting.

I recently got thinking that maybe I could have mythical beings born with supernatural traits would discriminate against those who acquire supernatural traits later in life in a manner similar to transphobia. Think of it like this: TERFs would argue that transgender women are not female because they were not born female. Similarly, certain mythical beings would discriminate against humans who acquire mythical traits later in life because they were not born mythical.

In case you were wondering how someone would become mythical in my setting, I was thinking it could be by learning magic words, getting magical artifacts, making a pact with another mythical being (like a deal with the devil type situation), eating part of a mythical being, or a mythical being accidentally giving a human their magic (like by bleeding on them or a possession gone wrong), conducting a ritual, gaining the favour of a mythical being (like a paladin) or being cursed or enchanted.

What do you think? Do you think this makes sense or should I just stick with the idea that the only way to be mythical is to be born mythical?


r/fantasywriting • • Sep 01 '24

I want to create a mute character in my book but I want to be as pc as possible

0 Upvotes

Hey! I’m writing a fantasy book set in the earlier years, and my character is from a tribe that have an oath to silence, so communicate with signs. I’m planning on having them be quite animated with facial expressions and to learn and describe BSL. I want to make sure they’re included but that I’m not being offensive or incorrect. Do you guys have any advice on this type of character please? :)


r/fantasywriting • • Mar 02 '25

Could a storu be good without a villian?

1 Upvotes

In my story,they go questing bcs they want to explore and stuff. so theres not really villian in it,other than their being evil kingdoms that might try and kidnap them when passing thru their territory. overall,theirs not really gonna be a mian villian that directrly trys to stop/kill them.

advice?


r/fantasywriting • • Feb 03 '25

Ideas for writing

2 Upvotes

I am currently writing a book and need a vew ideas. I would love it if you could comment what things you love the most in fantasy books or what you would love to see in a book. Please dont delete my post. :) What things do you love in Fantasy?


r/fantasywriting • • Jun 18 '25

book??

0 Upvotes

if i started writing a wlw enemies to lovers fantasy book with family feuding and backstabbing with elves and royalty would anyone read it?? i’ve been thinking about writing it and just wondered…


r/fantasywriting • • Apr 17 '25

I’m writing a gay fantasy romance with a merman prince and a human warrior—what tropes do you love in M/M fantasy?

1 Upvotes

I’m deep into writing a novel about a love story between a sea prince and a land warrior, with magical kingdoms, harp songs that open portals, and a looming war with dark forces. I'm mixing emotional trials with epic fantasy vibes.

Curious—what kind of tropes or story beats you love in M/M fantasy romance? I want to make sure I’m hitting the right notes for readers. (Happy to share a sample or scene if anyone’s interested!)


r/fantasywriting • • Feb 28 '24

How do you feel about using AI to help with writing?

0 Upvotes

Edit: Thanks everyone for your input! You all reaffirmed what I was already feeling—it doesn’t feel right to use AI for this. It’ll be better for me in the long run to make sure anything I write comes from my own head.

I’ve been working on my fantasy world and series off and on for years. About 2 years ago I really dug in and made some amazing progress.

Then I got a job writing and after spending all day writing for other people, it was hard to focus on my own work.

Then AI came out and my organization had me use it to increase inefficiency. Now when I use AI to help write at work, it’s more like I have it write a paragraph about a topic then extract/come up with a sentence from that paragraph.

Or I have it help me come up with ideas, finish sentences, fill in descriptor words I struggle to choose. I don’t wholly rely on it, but it increases my efficiency a ton.

I want to start working on my series again and know AI would be helpful. But it feels like that work is my baby, and it wouldn’t be right somehow…

Then I worry I’ve become too reliant on AI given how much I use it for work.

What’re your thoughts on using AI in fantasy writing?


r/fantasywriting • • Apr 20 '26

Does my male character come across as selfish? NSFW

0 Upvotes

I'm trying to write a sex scene in my WIP (between two characters who have sex for the first time -- the female's a virgin), and my beta reader noted that not even once during that scene did the male character wonder what his partner likes, whether she likes the same things as his previous partners.

Do you agree? Does he come across as selfish? Should I add in the scene him asking her what she likes? I don't think I've ever seen that in any sex scene.


r/fantasywriting • • Jan 23 '25

Help

2 Upvotes

I need some motivation. I love my novel but I don’t think the characters have anything to them it’s my first real novel and I used ai to write a few chapters and if I’m publishing it I know I can’t do that I’m thinking of just starting from scratch and rewriting the whole thing. Has anyone ever don’t this. Of course a lot of my writing is salvageable but I feel like the story just doesn’t make sense and it’s needs a new beginning middle end I took a break from writing and now coming back to it nothing makes sense. Don’t get me wrong I’m super proud of myself for writing 60k words and I could just go back and edit everything but I just don’t feel like what I’ve been writing works with the book. So can I just start from scratch?


r/fantasywriting • • Jan 13 '26

I used AI to write my book... But not in the way you think

0 Upvotes

So the title is maybe a little bit ragebait. I don't like using AI to write stuff for you to go publish under your own name. That's just me. But two months ago I got into a writing slump. So, what did I do, I made 5 songs using AI as if they were sung by the bard in my story. They were all about events that happen in the book; The fall of a city etc.

It got me out of the slump and actually motivated me to the point I got to release it this week! Anyone else with weird ways to motivate themselves?


r/fantasywriting • • Dec 01 '24

Is freshly 18 and late 16 a weird age gap?

0 Upvotes

I have these two characters and it makes sense for one of them to be older due to their status in the world and for the younger one to be younger because of the pre-established world building, but like the younger one is like five months away from turning 17 and the other one had suspectedly *just* turned 18. So is that a bad age gap?


r/fantasywriting • • Jun 29 '26

Starting a new prequel series for a project I am working on, looking for feedback

Post image
0 Upvotes

#worldbuilding #fantasy


r/fantasywriting • • Jan 21 '25

I need help writing a fantasy book

0 Upvotes

Hey I'm writing a fantasy book based on dnd, and I need help finding a plot, I have the characters at the ready so, please help


r/fantasywriting • • Jan 04 '25

When you're researching mental illnesses for your book and recognize the symptoms.

0 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • May 13 '24

What should my fantasy world look like since it's techically been 500 years since the industrial

0 Upvotes

I've run about 5 dnd campaigns in the same setting and realize the industrial revolution was 2 campaigns ago. With a few century gap between each campaign

Here's how the timeline went

Players encounter the dude who discovers Ichor the blood of godlike beings who died and became mountains which acts as my oil stand in. When they met him he had created prototype Autocarts (cars), Airships, Robots, projectors and coined the term Artificer. He got funding from an evil king with aspirations for world domination. that campaign crashed and burned so said evil king was steamrolled by the next big bad for the next campaign

Said big bad was a dark lord who took over the world for 300 years, put a stop to any technology that will threaten his power guns and automatons were out entertainment and waste disposal are in. He was dethroned and the following regime was much more friendly to technology and by the time the campaign started we had things like payphones and trains with a generally wild west vibe about the place.

World's threatened by an apocalypsed the people trying ro case it reveal the sky is fake the their concept of "the world" was just one continent. Incidently the most advanced nation outside the false sky is the ancient Egypt stand in so the revolution started very insular.

The players beat the big bads once and for all. However this caused issues due to all those political issues that had to wait til the gates of hell weren't wide open and demons were fucking everything up, the world not really knowing how to handle peace having been fighting the forces of darkness since time immemorial, and the several formerly isolationist nations interacting and finding that other nations had different beliefs and gods then them. World War 1 baby! We got planes, submarines and magic warcrimes.

That wound down 7 years before the current campaign began and theyve basically been in the wilderness for months with me only now realizing I have no idea what civilized society even looks like now with everything that's happened XP anyone have any pointers?


r/fantasywriting • • May 04 '25

Beta readers needed

0 Upvotes

Hi all! So I had several Beta readers read my final book draft, all who have loved it so far. They gave me some minor feedback (lags, confsions, tempo etc) and told me it was already well written etc. But they were people who were friends, family etc and although I asked for them to be completely neutral, I cannot be sure they are. It seems TOO positive.
They all received a questionnaire from me and they filled it out after reading.
Now, I am ready to have a few people I do not know read it.
I have an NDA to sign, and I think I am over my fear of someone "stealing" my concept etc. as tht was why I turned to friends/family.
Anyway, I need 3 or 4 beta readers. I have obviously posted it here, but is there someplace I should post it for betas or are there people in this Group that would read it? It is 261 pages (as a .pdf). I was hoping I could find 3 or 4 that could give me feedback by mid May or so before I travel and can update the book during that time.
I am not sure if this is allowed, but to get an idea of the book, here is the website www.quantumseasons.com

If links etc aren't allowed I apologize- just wanted any potential beta readers to know the story a bit before they decide to read or not. THANK YOU!


r/fantasywriting • • Jun 10 '26

I'm making a Dungeons and Dragons inspired team and I'm looking for a 7th member ideas

0 Upvotes

Hey guys!

I'm writing a fantasy story that's heavy inspired, if not outright using, Dungeons and Dragons. I think we know the set up by now: a team of adventurers set out on a world full of monsters, aliens, dark overlords, evil wizards and whatever you can throw in and test their mettle against such foes. I've played the game for years and so I'm using those mechanics to create the characters. I have six confirmed heroes in the party ranging from a barbarian gladiator, a wizard swordswoman, a hulking robot, a vampiric slasher, an arcane gunslinger and a plucky ninja warlock.

I'm the kind of guy who flip flops on ideas all the time. And this seventh character is no exception. I want to get some suggestions from the cool writers and folks of the world to help me out.

So far I got final characters. Like all my characters I'm using dnd as a bases, classes and stuff like that. Some of these guys do have classes, some don't and I can make them up on the fly. That's what writers do we improvise this stuff.

The first one is a kobold, the small dragon like creature who is on the same pare as goblins if not lower on the monster scale. Hunted by everything bigger than them, kobolds learn very quickly to adapt to any situation. The kobold character choose to try and be a knight, as in the classic helmet with the ploom feather sticking out, the visor that either gets stuck or is too loose, and an incredibly massive ego to boot. Yeah, he's made to be the comic relief character who believes he's more important than he truly is. And what knight would he be if he didn't have a trusty steed, in this case its a fantasy version of a big drooling mastiff who doesn't always do as his rider tells him to do.

Most of my options are knight themed, thinking it would fit well with the esthetic of the world. Take the bardic knight for instance, with the classic set up of a knight loke the armor and helmet but with a loot as well. The idea of him being a spy could work. Going from kingdom to kingdom, learning all he can while in the day he poses as a traveling minstrel, singing of epic battles, great dragons, and seduction of fair maidens. There's also a more bounty hunter like knight, similar to Boba Fett from Star Wars. A helmeted hunter who can track down any man or monster, combing the long range tactics of firearms while being an excellent sword fighter. Plus for fun, I would imagine his voice as something like Boba's, specifically Don Francks from the Christmas Special.

Then there is the witch hunter or the monster hunter. A dude in a long armored coat and a big brimmed hat, wielding both magic, steel and gunpowder to eliminate the forces ofdarkness. Enough said on that front.

Last option was a bit of a surprise to me after watching a viking show, the classic lightbulb moment. Imagine a warrior from the Northlands, the Viklands in my world, where the ice and snow are as treacherous as the beasts that roam them, where the water is as cold as you can imagine. These Northlanders have become a viking like society, relying on raiding other coastline villages and storming ships fifty times bigger their their vessels. Relying only on their wit and their cold ferocity.

But those are just my suggestions. If any of these appeal to you, maybe help out by going to the poll up above. Like I said i flip flop on my ideas and would appreciate whatever you guys suggest. If you've made it this far, then your a cool person! Hope you keep writing!

53 votes, Jun 17 '26
13 kobold knight
8 bardic knight
3 bounty hunter
16 witch hunter/monster hunter
6 Northland raider
7 suggestions in the comments