r/fantanoforever • • Oct 22 '26

Subreddit Rules Rule 2 Reminder

97 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

Polite reminder that rule 2 exists, which is to specify the album/artist name when making a post if either is not on the album and/or photo. This has been a problem that has been popping up more than we would like, as of late. Even if the album or artist is well known, please do not assume that everyone will know who they are/what the album is. Having the name helps the discussion by allowing people who dont know these artists or albums to find them easily so they can start listening to them.

Thank you.


r/fantanoforever • • Sep 23 '26

Subreddit Rules Rule Updates and State of the Subreddit

79 Upvotes

Hi all!

Over the past couple of years, the content on this subreddit has changed - often to the detriment to the quality of the forum. Over the past couple of days, the mod group have discussed freshening up our guidance on a range of topics, to respond to these changes. In effort to improve the subreddit, we have updated our rules on politics, drama, AI, and low effort posting.

Fundamentally, this is a music subreddit about a music reviewer. We want to maintain the best parts of discussion we see on this forum, and try and reduce the worst parts. The intention of the updated guidance is to do exactly that. To be precise - we want to reduce the amount of Fauxmoi discussion posts here. There are other subreddits for that discussion.

There have also been some changes to the types of posts that are allowed - requirements around body text as well as post flairs have been turned on, as well as the introduction of bot bouncer to reduce bots on the subreddit.

If anyone has any further suggestions for improving this community please reach out!


r/fantanoforever • • 8h ago

Discussion Albums you think should get a Shaggs' "Philosophy of the World" style reappraisal?

Post image
103 Upvotes

A.k.a the albums that are so astonishingly bad that they sort of wrap around to being avant-garde in their own right and therefore becoming unironically good or most commonly absolutely hilarious?

17 by The Island Boys is an album I think exemplifies this archetype. If you haven't heard the experimental-psychedelic-progressive-free-rap crown jewel that is [Head](https://youtu.be/50gldPTaxGs) then 1. I give condolences and 2. An urge to immediately listen to it in full.


r/fantanoforever • • 2h ago

Discussion Proud of y’all

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 11h ago

Discussion Honest question: is there a WORSE review than this?

Post image
140 Upvotes

Seriously

This is not only an AWFUL take (90’s STP is GOATed) but it was apparently written by a sociopathic asshole.

Any contenders?


r/fantanoforever • • 13h ago

Discussion What’s your opinion on Björk?

Post image
122 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 3h ago

Discussion Albums where if the b-sides/unreleased tracks were added would rip ass?

10 Upvotes

Well I should mention I already dig these albums but I do see big missed opportunities!

The first one that comes to mind is WEEZER - Red Album.

Seriously if PIG was included and one of the weaker songs cut this would even eclipse white for me. PIG! What a song.

Another one that comes to mind is Animal Collective - Strawberry Jam. Songs like Safer and Street Flash would have made this great album even more legendary if added.

And of course I would be remiss not to mention PAVEMENT - Brighten the Corners. Their REAL smash hit song 'Harness Your Hopes' was left off. But not just that... cherry area, no tan lines. They could have made such a more dynamic and fun album instead of getting bogged down in that mid tempo jam slop that (while still cool) does somewhat hamper the record (which I do think if they had gotten the tracklist better could have been arguably their BEST album).

Anymore ?


r/fantanoforever • • 8h ago

Discussion Thoughts on the Butthole Surfers?

21 Upvotes

They just dropped a documentary this year and an album they didn't get to release back in the day (it's the same as it's prior record, just four new songs and they pulled the shitty Kid Rock song)

I think they're alright personally, with Rembrandt Pussyhorse being my favorite record of theirs. I found them through Pepper which is still my favorite song of theirs.


r/fantanoforever • • 14h ago

Recommendations Electronic, Trip-Hop, Neo-Psychedelia album recommendations?

Post image
43 Upvotes

Bocanada has been one of my most played albums since the last 4 months. What i especially love about it is how it blends 3 of my favourite genres ever (but especially being majorly electronic, which is my favourite genre of music ever, accompanied by it's subgenres) in such a diverse yet cohesive album. However, this is really the only album that comes to mind when i think of these 3 genres togheter, and that's the problem. If anyone has any recommendations for similar sounds, especially electronic or neo-psych, i would LOVE it.


r/fantanoforever • • 12h ago

Discussion Worst Thing You Can Say: Day 35

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 23h ago

JOKE Fantano in GTA VI?

Post image
145 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 1d ago

Discussion what are some great artists with terrible fans?

Post image
251 Upvotes

I love Twenty One Pilots but man, admitting you’re a fan of them to people is essentially putting a target on you because a majority of their fanbase is completely psycho


r/fantanoforever • • 7h ago

Discussion What is a song that makes you cry but in a good way?

5 Upvotes

I mean songs about forgiveness and acceptance and making peace. For me it's tracks like Headlights by Eminem, It's okay to Cry by Sophie. I'd love to know more songs that hit in the feels like that.


r/fantanoforever • • 5h ago

Discussion Cool music Lost Media???

2 Upvotes

I dont know any


r/fantanoforever • • 9h ago

Discussion Say something positive about Wild Mood Swings

4 Upvotes

I think it was Robert trying to channel Mellon Collie in his own band and at times he failed misserably, but I think it has peak songs lke Want, Club America, This is a lie and Jupiter Crash


r/fantanoforever • • 1d ago

Discussion What bands have their "best" song on a poor/weak album?

Post image
243 Upvotes

In your opinion.

CCR has "Have You Ever Seen the Rain" on Pendulum, which is one of, if not their best song on a pretty poor album.


r/fantanoforever • • 1d ago

Discussion What is the best self-produced album?

Post image
124 Upvotes

Either produced solely by the artist or by a band member. There's nothing wrong with outside producers, and their contributions have created some of the best records ever put on needle, but I especially gravitate towards self-produced albums. It's the perfect representation of an artist's sound, uncorrupted, and I respect those artists for their dedication to the craft.

For me, it's Heaven or Las Vegas - Robin was a genius behind the boards. It's a huge honour to be told by Eno that you don't need his help. Technically, though, it was probably Boston's debut. Tom was on another level.


r/fantanoforever • • 1d ago

Discussion Solo albums that are as good as their band’s albums?

55 Upvotes

What are some solo albums, or true side projects, where the album rivals the quality of the better or best of the more-famous band they came from?

Not talking about Rod Stewart or Michael Jackson here who were bigger solo, but more like Lindsey Buckingham, George Harrison, or Hot Tuna, etc.


r/fantanoforever • • 1d ago

Discussion “Buttrock” songs that are exceptional compositionally?

Post image
132 Upvotes

This baby is a banger.

What are your choices?


r/fantanoforever • • 3h ago

Recommendations Give me some other songs that were made legendary/iconic cause of a live performance?

0 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 10h ago

Recommendations Looking for additional songs that fit into this playlist I’ve made that retains the overall feel.

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Please be specific about recommendations, Including artist and song title. Or recommend full projects as well. Thanks!


r/fantanoforever • • 1d ago

Discussion Really powerful essay about the new PISS album

Thumbnail
pastemagazine.com
88 Upvotes

Checked it out since Fantano gave the album such a high score (still need to listen) and it’s definitely worth a read


r/fantanoforever • • 1d ago

Discussion Kid Rocks new album isn't just the worst album of the year it's the worst album of the last decade ain't nobody listening to Kid Pedophile except MAGA dumbasses

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 16h ago

Discussion What Independent Bands/Artist you want more people to know? (repost, because I forgot to mention by Indie, I meant Independent. That's all on me)

Post image
4 Upvotes

The band in the photo are The Dassins. They're a British Indie Rock Band. They make really catchy songs, but also do great covers