r/fantanoforever • u/MayNStuff • Jun 17 '25
I don't think Fantano understands the criticism Sabrina Carpenter's album cover got
Fantano's video on the Sabrina Carpenter album cover controversy, in my opinion, completely missed the point of why a lot of feminists are disappointed. And I think even people that disagree with the backlash should be able to see that.
I'm a fan of Sabrina Carpenter, and I do not have a problem with her or any female artist exploring their sexuality, even the really provocative stuff. That said, I did have a negative reaction to the new album cover. Not because of the sex part, but because, as a woman, I'm getting kind of tired of women being portrayed like this over and over again. The red pill stuff is as popular as ever, and it feels like everyday there's some new publicity stunt from a female celebrity profiting off of porn-brained men (Bonnie Blue, Sydney Sweeney etc.) and it's getting kind of repetitive. Sabrina's a massively influential figure at the moment, and I do think that having that much influence over the culture comes with it a responsibility to not contribute to harmful attitudes towards marginalised groups.
Saying the album cover is feminist because "well she's a woman and she chose to make it" is kind of like saying Hooters is feminist because the waitresses choose to work there. Like individually, there's nothing wrong with it, but it speaks to a larger problem in the culture. It's not like the same market really exists with the genders reversed. And when a big public figure, who could've chosen to portray themselves in any way and has way more influence than any random individual woman, makes this kind of choice, I think they are worthy of criticism
I do not agree with the people slut-shaming Sabrina. But I think other pop stars have done a better job at portraying female sexuality in a way that is subversive and even empowering (Megan Thee Stallion, Lady Gaga etc.). Sabrina's not necessarily obligated to do that, but I think it's disappointing that she doesn't. That's it.
Fantano talking like anyone who hates the cover is either slut-shaming or a "fake femist" is incredibly reductive, and it makes me think he really doesn't understand feminist issues at all.
Rant over.
