r/exjew • • Feb 14 '25

Casual Conversation Trump is Moshiach

Post image
2 Upvotes

Anyone else notice how Trump is revered within the orthodox community? He does not share any of their personal values. He’s a philandering serial sexual predator. Pro-choice. Making fun of people and steamrolling anyone or anything that disagrees with him or slights him in any manner seems counter to Torah moral values. Racists and antisemites find him appealing - that should give pause to any thinking person with values.

Listen, personally I like a lot of what he did in the past and continues to do presently, but I also recognize that his sexually deviant behavior is not very much different than that of Bill Clinton.

This worship of Trump eminating from the orthodox Jewish community seems strange and hypocritical.

End of rant.


r/exjew • • Feb 25 '26

Blog Dear god he’s a fucking idiot!!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Dec 25 '21

Image Do jews have a special god who looks out for them? NSFW

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Dec 20 '25

Update I did it (re: protest)

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

I did the protest. Felt like I made an impact. And got (predictably) bombarded with hate by students and passerby.... and.... in quiet winks, nods and even vocal support, lots and lots of thank yous. I would certainly say a resounding success. Thanks to all for input.

Also there was another poster moderator asked me to crop out of the photo as per discussion rules. I will state that I think that rule enables harm. Of course I am unsure if even discussion of the rule itself may trigger mods.


r/exjew • • Dec 31 '24

My Story 19 ex frum joining the IDF and making aliyah

0 Upvotes

I cannot imagine a possible future in which I would accept either sacrificing my allegiance to my people, or by living in a cultural bubble of those who believe in the Torah. I do not believe in God, the idea of one confuses me. Where is God? What is he? Is he on some kiseh rachamim putting on tefillin or is he without a place like the Rambam and a couple of midrashim say. Something that is not physical does not exist outside the mind.

Judaism is to me, one of the most internally inconsistent religions, but this may be coming from a place of bias, as it is the one I’ve studied in the most depth. Anyone can clearly see the shift from anthropomorphic corporeal God from the times of the Gemora to the universalist God of platonism and the philosophers. If it were possible for me to continue living a frum life, I would absolutely. But it is not.

I’m joining the IDF in February, I’ve prepared my draft. I want to be Israeli, I’m willing to forget every bit of diasporic identification with my community and take up a new identity. My kids might end up as Tomers, but I’ll take what I can get.

I despise Israel, socio-culturally speaking, nearly every segment of the country is fucked in it’s own respectively frustrating way. Israeli intelligentsia is self loathing and would probably apologize if the EU and the Palestinians made death camps. Masoritim believe in a creator of a universe who commanded them to do a set of laws which are honestly not even that difficult, and will not bring themselves to collect the effort of fulfilling them for eternal paradise. The settler movement has some soul and core, but is messianic and fundamentally religious.

I am a genuine Zionist, in its legitimate definition, sans the theosis of the military that Israelis love for some reason. I’m coming to Israel, with barely any money, without any financial support whatsoever from my parents or siblings, to live in shitty arrangements and to live in a country where I hardly speak the language. I can’t imagine that I could be classified as anything but a Zionist. But I’m scared, I am a hardworker, I am capable of being one if need be. But I probably do not have enough money to afford the first eight weeks in the country before my draft starts. I’m working before I arrive, but in between tickets, a place to stay and so on. I will probably have to go hungry. I’ll accept it, I’ll take it like a man. What else can I do? I have no other option. It’s either I go to the IDF or there is no more me. I’ve quit smoking and nicotine, it is simply not economical. I’m scared, if this doesn’t work out I will return home like a defeated dog.

But there is much beauty in Israel, I will be able to be my first ancestor who was a Jewish soldier in a Jewish army for the first time in 2,000 years. Sabras are beautiful, the national language is the crowning accomplishment of our nation. Israelis are an ingenious and intelligent people. The Mediterranean to me is God as much as Hashem is to some masoritim. I phenotypically fit in, I am not a minority. The culture is solidarity based, there isn’t this toxic American dream culture. I could see myself spending the rest of my life in that country. In fact, I can see myself doing that nowhere else.

Any advice? I’m not looking for any other options.


r/exjew • • Oct 20 '26

Venting/Rant Male Masturbation Is a Sin, but Female Masturbation Is Permitted? NSFW

2 Upvotes

Male Masturbation Is Sinful, Yet Female Masturbation Is Encouraged?
This is genuinely one of the top three reasons I decided to leave Orthodox Judaism and go off the derech. The enormous double standard surrounding male and female sexuality has caused me more anger, humiliation, and emotional pain than I can properly explain. And the more I learn about it, the more ridiculous and unfair it feels. Let me explain. A female friend of mine attended an Orthodox seminary after graduating from college, when she was already in her twenties. During a private conversation, she shared something with me that honestly left me speechless and shook me to my core. According to her, she was explicitly taught that female masturbation was permissible, including watching pornography to achieve an orgasm. Yes, you read that correctly. Crazy right? This wasn’t some random conversation between friends or advice she found online. She told me this was guidance she received while attending an actual seminary as an adult woman! And then there’s the subject of which is also not something talked about at all. adult sex toys, such as vibrators, and other ways women can explore sexual pleasure. Because women aren’t subject to the same prohibition against hotza’at zera levatala (wasting seed), the halachic discussion surrounding female masturbation and the use of sex toys can be very different from what men are commonly taught to believe. Now compare that to the message men receive in yeshiva. We’re repeatedly taught that male masturbation is an incredibly serious sin. We’re warned about the spiritual consequences, told to suppress perfectly natural sexual desires, and made to feel enormous guilt and shame for something millions of people experience as a normal part of their sexuality. But here’s what they conveniently DON’T explain in yeshiva: masturbation isn’t treated the same way for women under Jewish law! So let me get this straight. A woman can receive religious guidance that permits her to masturbate, use adult sex toys, and explore her own sexual pleasure, and even watch pornography which I personally find disgusting industry and habit 🤢. while a man is told that achieving an orgasm through masturbation is an incredibly serious spiritual offense? The woman gets a discussion about sexual pleasure, and the man gets a lecture about wasting seed? How is that remotely fair? And before anyone misunderstands my point, I have absolutely NO problem with women enjoying their sexuality. In fact, I’m genuinely happy that women can receive more guidance about their bodies and sexual pleasure. I wish everyone were afforded that same understanding. My problem isn’t that women have this freedom. My problem is that men are made to feel ashamed for wanting the same freedom!!!!. That’s what makes me so incredibly angry. I cannot describe how much emotional pain these teachings caused me and many others alike. The constant guilt, the humiliation, the feeling that my own perfectly natural sexual desires were something shameful or spiritually disgusting. At times, I genuinely felt like I was living in chains. And then discovering that women could receive such different guidance felt like an absolute SLAP in the face. Why was I made to feel so terrible about my own body? Why wasn’t this difference openly explained in yeshiva? And why should a man have to carry such an enormous burden of religious guilt for seeking the same sexual pleasure that a woman may be permitted and even encouraged to experience? I understand that Orthodox Judaism has different halachic obligations for men and women. I know the traditional prohibition against wasting seed is specifically associated with men. But explaining the technical religious reasoning doesn’t magically erase the emotional damage these teachings can cause. And to be clear, I’m not claiming every seminary encourages pornography or teaches the same things my friend was taught. I recognize that the majority Orthodox authorities agree with pornography, and sex toys for woman although it’s kept very secret and hush hush probably because if men would find out they would be upset. But the underlying difference in how male and female masturbation are treated and viewed in the orthodox community and law is exactly what I’m criticizing. This is one of the biggest reasons I eventually went OTD. It wasn’t simply about wanting permission to masturbate. It was about being tired of feeling ashamed of my own humanity. I genuinely felt like I was living in chains, and the anger and hurt these teachings caused me are difficult to put into words. Please don’t interpret this as hatred of religious people. I’m expressing genuine frustration about something that caused me years of pain and contributed significantly to my decision to leave religious observance. I’m especially interested in hearing from former yeshiva students and women who attended Orthodox seminaries.For the men and ladies here, were you ever taught about the differences on halachic ruling? did the religious guilt surrounding masturbation affect you as deeply as it affected me? Because I seriously cannot be the only person who finds this double standard both frustrating and incredibly unfair.


r/exjew • • Mar 05 '26

Satire The real Gadol Hador

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Jun 12 '22

Thoughts/Reflection Can you rate this interaction I had with a convert on Judaism subreddit

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Jan 28 '23

Question/Discussion Op-Ed Reminds us that Jews don't have monopoly on suffering

5 Upvotes

I think this op-ed is on point. They don't even tackle the fact that the Orthodox and Israel largely have become oppressive in how they relate to others: they are homophobic, transphobic, xenophobic, misogynistic, racist, Islamophobic, etc. in different ways. Treating gentiles, tenants, Palestinians, Africans, African Americans, travelers, converts to Judaism, women, LGBT people and others like shit.

Jews do not have a monopoly on persecution and atrocities.

For one group, for one person, to claim that the hate and violence towards them is more important than another’s, only encourages more acts of violence against others, including Black people, Asians, Hispanics, Muslims, LGBTQ+, trans-gender and Native Americans. This list is not all-inclusive.

https://www.courier-journal.com/story/opinion/2023/01/27/holocaust-remembrance-dayis-a-time-to-remember-more-than-one-atrocity/69832129007/


r/exjew • • Mar 22 '25

Question/Discussion Why do my parents think another holocaust will happen in the uk? NSFW

4 Upvotes

I had a conversation with my mom about her famillys time in Yemen. I already knew the history, i knew that some jews were forced out whioe others left voluntarily, but i wanted to hear her perspective and see if she had any additional insight. She said the yemenites moved to israel because they wanted to go to eretz yisroel, the holy land and pray in jerusalem, and everyone wants to move to israel.

I asked her what do you mean everyone wants to move to israel. So she said we're jews, we belong in Israel, i said just because one's jewish it dosen't make them israeli or middle Eastern, just like how If your Indian, chinease, ethiopian, all these places have jews that are not ethnic to the middle east.

My dad looked very concerned and said "what are you talking about? Who's been giving you this information? All jews come from israel" and my mom said "well if there is a holocaust in Britain we're going to have to move to israel". I laughed and told here there isn't going to be a holocaust in Britain. She said "how do you know? You even have to hide your magen david in london or someone could beat you up, there could be a holocaust" I told her people can beat you up for wearing a magin david anywhere, there isnt going to be a holocaust.

Then my dad who I consider to be well educated looked at me dead in the eye and said "you dont know that, even the non jews are saying there could be a holocaust here". So I said, fine if there's another holocaust we will move.

My mom asked me where i would move to so the first country off the top of my head was Spain and she laughed in my face.

She replied "do you know how antisemitic Spain is, they literally murder jews for being jewish!" I told her israel is not the only country where jews can go. Her response was "well all jews come from israel so yes they do".

I told my dad there isnt a jewish gene, he said there is. I argued that you can't genetically tell if someone's jewish, he said yes you can. I said "oh yeah? What's the genome sequence?" He got quiet. I explained you can check if someone's middle Eastern, aisian through a blood test, but you can't tell if someone is jewish, because it's a religion, not an ethnicity, so you can't tell people from all over the globe that they belong in a country because of what they beleive in.

Why do they think another holocaust is going to happen and israel is the only safe place in the world for jews to be ?


r/exjew • • Aug 20 '25

Thoughts/Reflection Jewish or Christian ridiculousness

0 Upvotes

I had an atheist mindset in the past and I used to love when I would tell religious people I wasn’t religious anymore and they would be like “WeLL tHe Christians BaSe their Religion OfF of us So we’re RiGht” like trying to clock me.

like oh no baby I don’t subscribe to ANY organized religion, I think they’re all a construct. And they would be speechless. Like this isn’t “which religion is correct porn”, I went completely off script. They are so used these fake convos of people being seduced by other religions as if people always convert to Christianity over Judaism. How about none?

Also I love that Jews think that they’re one of the big three religions when I see people talk about religious groups YALL not even part of the convo. It’s always Christianity, Islam, and Hindu/Buddhism. No one is even talking about you babe xo.


r/exjew • • Jan 13 '26

Question/Discussion Do u think if there is an afterlife and god and it’s not Jewish god or Judiasm, god will punish Jews for worshiping false religion?

1 Upvotes

And all their things they consider mitzvot like kashrut is actually animal abuse and will be punished


r/exjew • • Jan 04 '25

Question/Discussion Joining The US military

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone there was a post last week about a person joining the IDF and personally I think it’s an awful idea even if you are patriotic as they treat you like shit and pay you peanuts. The only reason I would join is due to religious sentiments and feelings and I obviously don’t have many of those. But when I started researching joining the US army it looks like a pretty good deal - you get decent pay, good benefits and you don’t have to pay much rent. You get to make new friends and also have a sense of belonging. It’s also super cool and though you may not see a lot of action you get deployed in other countries and get a good workout. Has anyone here joined the military or ever considered doing this??


r/exjew • • Dec 16 '23

Thoughts/Reflection The name is misleading

0 Upvotes

In my opinion it should be exreligiousjew as there’s no such thing as an exjew, our tribe doesn’t have an exit option, we should be proud Jews even though we don’t follow our ancient laws anymore.


r/exjew • • Aug 27 '21

Not an ex-jew myself, but I thought you guys may want to check this out. In Judaism, MGM is more important than believing in their god or living in community 😶

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Jun 17 '24

Question/Discussion Do you find the Anti-Messianic Jewish sentiment strange?

0 Upvotes

I used to be "terrified" of those that were syncretizing Judaism and Christianity together when I was faithful. Viewing them as cynical converters. Now, that may be true of some, I don't think that's true of all. I have Christian relatives and because I'm Jewish there's been an exchange of religious beliefs among us. At least as someone who has read a good chunk of the New Testament I can say that it's a deeply Jewish work which strangely enough is most similar to the Talmud. Both grew out of Roman Era Judaism. The things the Rabbis care about, Oral Law, the Messiah and the Afterlife are described at length in the New Testament and not in the Old Testament. This is not to say I am a Christian nor do I wish to come off as a proselytizer. For various reasons I think both Gentile Christians might want to add more Jewish things to their religion and various Jews are enamored with Christianity and wish to make a syncretic religion.

I don't find Messianic Passovers as antisemitic nor cultural appropriation. In fact, the more Gentiles adopt our practices the more they will understand us and hate us less.

I have already written at length in other posts on my profile debunking the notion that Orthodox Judaism is unitarian. So on that basis alone a Jew cannot reject Christian claims without also having to reject Orthodox Jewish claims, chiefly chassidic branches. https://themarginaliareview.com/jesus-h-as-in-hasidic-christ-by-allan-nadler/ https://merrimackvalleyhavurah.wordpress.com/2017/08/07/christological-statements-in-the-zohar/ https://forward.com/opinion/176972/how-the-trinity-impacted-judaism-via-kabbalah/ http://davidblumenthal.org/Trinity.html https://www.zohar.com/zohar/Ha'azinu/chapters/30 https://www.kotzkblog.com/2021/01/310-how-tzadik-is-depicted-in-some.html In addition the claim against Islam/Christianity on a Prophet that says things the contradicts older prophet books does not hold if one accepts Ezekiel as canonical.


r/exjew • • Apr 23 '23

Advice/Help why should I not convert?

1 Upvotes

As I've been exploring my faith and beliefs, I've started to have doubts about Islam. One of the main reasons for my doubt is the lack of evidence for the claims of Torah and Bible corruption and prophecy. Without any concrete evidence to support these claims, it's hard for me to fully accept them as truth.

I've been looking into modern Orthodox Judaism and Judaism more broadly, and I find it appealing for several reasons. One thing that stands out to me is the emphasis on questioning and debate within the Jewish community. It's refreshing to see a religion that encourages critical thinking and questioning instead of blind acceptance.

I've also been drawn to Judaism because of the supportive and welcoming community I've encountered. Everyone I've met has been kind and accepting, and I feel like I could really fit in and find my place in the Jewish community.

Another thing that appeals to me about Judaism is the absence of the concept of eternal hell. The idea of eternal punishment has always troubled me, and it's comforting to know that Judaism doesn't hold this belief.

Finally, I appreciate that Judaism doesn't actively seek converts. It feels less pushy and more respectful of individual choice and autonomy. Additionally, Judaism is the founder of the Abrahamic religions, which gives it a sense of historical and spiritual significance.

Overall, I'm finding that Judaism has a good structure and offers a lot of what I'm looking for in a religion. I'm excited to continue exploring and learning more about this faith.


r/exjew • • Nov 15 '22

Question/Discussion Ex male Jews of Reddit, have you managed to restore your foreskin and how?

1 Upvotes

It should go without saying that if God/YHWH did not want humanity to have foreskin, it could’ve been well within His powers to make it so that humans are born without them to begin with. While it can be surmised that circumcision might have served a practical purpose once upon a time, nowadays such tampering with an integral part of our anatomy should rightfully be condemned.


r/exjew • • Sep 14 '26

Meme Happy holidays from the Rebbe!

Post image
8 Upvotes

Thought this is fitting. Judaism does have a Santa Claus!


r/exjew • • Oct 01 '25

Question/Discussion How is Yom Kippur not child abuse?

14 Upvotes

You’re telling me 12 year old little girls can go 25 hours without water, food? Does that not sound literally insane?

Hey. I love my child. I can’t wait to make them either

  1. sleep for 25 hours in an attempt to escape the severe hunger, nausea, lethargy, headache, and boredom Or

  2. go to synagogue for hours where they will sit and stare at a book while starving for 25 hours

Side note: it was thinking about my own hypothetical child fasting that started my Ex-Jew journey. I simply could not fathom putting someone I love through hell.

Any parent who rationalizes it as “my little girl actually WANTED to fast” is a moron.

Why is this legal?

EDIT: took out the “deodorant, showers, tech and handwashing” because people were intentionally dodging my point. Yes, it is a crime to kick your child in the head. Yes, it is a crime to subject someone to bodily harm. Yes, in certain states it is a crime to convince someone to harm themselves. This is not a different scenario.


r/exjew • • Jan 24 '26

Thoughts/Reflection How do conservative and reform disregard verses in Torah that have very strict punishments for breaking law

1 Upvotes

Like Torah verse directly says u have to be killed if break Shabbat and it’s in Ten Commandments like I don’t understand how they can overlook the importance of that unless they don’t find it divine they just do out tradition but I feel like if u asked conservative or reform do u think Torah is from god they’d say yes


r/exjew • • 25d ago

Thoughts/Reflection Returning to "God" (sorta)

1 Upvotes

For the past 3 months I have been returning to God. Not the God we were raised to believe in, who cared about all the little things we did at every moment, but the concept of God as the divinity that gives existence to the human condition and to reality as we know it. The indescribable, unknowable force that embeds itself in our consciousness and in everything we perceive.

I’ve been doing it through the lens of Jewish faith, at my own pace and discretion. It came about unexpectedly, since I became an agnostic about 15 years ago (I’m 43 now). It was sparked by inspiring stories about Rebbe Nachman and some of his principles that friends shared with me, even non-religious friends. It started because I’m so far past any feelings of guilt or shame, or needing to be right about things, that I’m comfortable defining what I want to practice and believe on my own terms.

To be clear, for as long as I’ve been agnostic (and for a while before that, atheist), I was still connected to the community. My wife remained “religious” (although daily modern). My kids go to Jewish school. We kept some form of Shabbat: we ate Shabbat meals, put away our devices and TVs, and didn’t drive. But we all turned on lights (not my wife), and I would often use my phone or do work after the kids went to bed. My family eats dairy out, but on my own time I kept no kosher at all (pork and shellfish were fair game, and my favorites).

I haven’t had any non-kosher meat or shellfish in almost 3 months. I still like it, but after a long time I felt like I was hiding things from my kids, and that got old. I also started to redefine what I wanted to connect with in spiritual practice through the lens of Judaism, and I decided that for now I can give it up.

I started to think about spirituality through the lens of personal sacrifice, in addition to the connection to the Higher Force beyond consciousness and unity, which I began connecting with a few years back outside the context of Judaism, closer to Buddhism.

Recently I’ve been regaining interest in Jewish texts and ideas and trying to understand them through a new lens with new interpretations. When I was reading Parshat Bereshit a few weeks back, I began to re-read the creation story as the dawn of human consciousness. I thought of Gan Eden as the pure spiritual place of “just being,” without needing to work or worry. The ultimate “present moment.” I thought of the snake as the intrusive thoughts that pull us out of this place.

I started to think about “The World to Come” as the future version of myself. Perhaps even the moment of death and the ultimate coming to terms with my existence and how I lived my life. The absence of regret and fear.

I reached out to the Rabbi of my shul and hope to start learning Rebbe Nachman with him (I haven’t learned any Jewish texts in many, many years). I’ve toyed with the idea of putting on tefillin and saying Shema. I’m not quite there yet, and I haven’t worn tefillin for most of my adult life.

Through these ideas I’ve started to ponder what it might mean to “love God” vs. “fear God” and to build a practice around that love. But I’ve also wondered if some people aren’t capable of existing in that space, and if maybe, for some, fearing God is a necessary form of practice and connection (unfortunately). It’s made me think that the Torah stories relating to commandments and fear are human expressions of this need in some individuals, and thus part of “God,” since God is in fact the whole of human consciousness and experience.

Anyway, I share all this not to preach, but to offer a framework that is working for me in this season of life that may resonate with some of you or point to possibilities.


r/exjew • • Jul 19 '24

Question/Discussion Should I sue my rabbi? for mutilating me against my will at birth?

0 Upvotes

I do not talk to my mom or dad anymore.

Should I sue my parents and mohel for mutilating me at birth?

I don't want the money either, I want my foreskin back. I think they should have to pay to get it re attached.


r/exjew • • Apr 02 '23

Question/Discussion Seriously Ex Chabadnikim could you have not seen the whole concept of Jews possessing a נפש אלוקית whilst non Jews only have a נפש בהמית was utter bs. Whilst you were in Chabad ?

2 Upvotes

The most disgusting thing that Chabad teaches is that Jews have a נפש אלוקית . Whilst non Jews lack it, and have only a נפש בהמית.

In other words only Jews are able to capture and understand the divine which is utter horseshite. Since there are more non Jewish people who are deeply devoted and religious than Jews.

However could you not see the contradiction whilst you were in Chabad?

As why did Schnereeson pioneer and come up with the concept of שליחות. In that the Chabadnik needs now to go to the “lost sheep of Israel “ by trying to encourage religious observance among them. With sometimes rebuff or no success from secular Jews.

So if you have to do שליחות.

Does not that prove that the whole idea of Jews being in possession of נפש אלוקית as according to the Chabad holy book Tanya is utter tripe. As you would not have to be almost practically begging secular Jewish men to wear Tefflin for a few mins. They all would have been doing it anyhow without no prompt. Since it’s within their nature, but in reality they do not. Well because the concept is bs .

But how did you as former Chabadnikm not see the idea for being bullshit ?


r/exjew • • Oct 09 '25

Crazy Torah Teachings Yikes

Post image
0 Upvotes

"intellectually accepted the 'basic claims of Orthodox Judaism'" my ass