r/exjew • • Oct 09 '23

Thoughts/Reflection What Jewish Children Need to Hear About The Israel-Hamas Conflict

194 Upvotes

This post is for anyone whose inner child is a bit anxious and needs updated beliefs about war after religious deconstruction.

  • You are not responsible for this war in any way.

  • The people responsible for terror are terrorists. We cannot control others’ behavior by 'sinning' or not ‘sinning’.

  • Wars and international affairs are extremely complex. Rabbis and Jewish adults may not have the expertise necessary to truly understand the intricacies just because of their faith, even if they speak very confidently. They are biased anyway and likely do not have all the details. (No one really has all the details).

  • Humans are incapable of knowing exactly why things happen. Be wary of people who claim to know why ‘god’ did something. This is delusional and arrogant.

  • Prayer does not do anything besides offer comfort and an illusion of control for people who want to feel like they are doing something about the situation.

  • There is no god in the sky causing this war. But if there were, he would be a cruel deity for causing so much human suffering. You do NOT have to thank someone who is harming you or others. You do NOT have to love a parent-figure who is so cruel. This would be Stockholm Syndrome.

  • War is horrific and bad. You don’t have to find reasons why it’s a good thing. That’s called mental gymnastics, dear. Adults do that to try to make sense of things but it's not healthy.

  • Suffering from war and other terrible things is not necessarily meaningful nor inspirational. It’s suffering. It doesn’t offer a ‘kapara’ for sins and it doesn’t spare someone from suffering in hell after death either. (I don’t believe hell is real anyway).

  • Jews will find all sorts of miracles in this war. This is called mental filtering, they will ignore all the horrific events and focus on the three stories where someone was saved or only lost one leg instead of two. Sometimes missiles hit people, and sometimes they don’t. These aren’t miracles.

  • This war is NOT gog umagog and it doesn’t mean a messiah is coming or anything like that. Wars happen. And all other religions’ claims for the end of the world and messiahs turned out to be false. This is a cult tactic and isn’t any more real in Judaism.

  • You can care about friends and family in Israel. You can also have empathy for Palestinian women, children, and men who aren’t interested or participating in Hamas’ violence.

  • Although you may share an ethnicity and background with Israelis, you are not god’s people or any other kind of special group. You’re all the same status as humans of other countries and ethnicities. You are still not responsible for them. The country is responsible for protecting its people. And parents are responsible for moving their families to a country that isn’t a war zone, if they so choose.

  • You do NOT have to watch gruesome videos or hear all the updates on this war or any other wars/tragedies.


r/exjew • • Jun 30 '20

Anecdote I do appreciate my friends being sensitive, lol

Post image
184 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Jun 02 '21

Venting/Rant I don't want Judaism dead. I just want the frum cult dead.

175 Upvotes

Saw some frummies saying that if you criticize the cult, you're an antisemite and hate Jews and/or Judaism. I want to be very clear: I don't hate Judaism or Jews (I'm a Jew; pretty stupid of me to hate myself).

I don't care if you believe the Torah was given to Moshe at haar Sinai, or if you believe that God gave Torah she-ba'al-pe and it's recorded in Shas. I don't care if you keep Shabbos, or kashrus, or you're shomer negiah, or you're machmir on yoshon, or any of that stuff.

I do care, however, if you treat everyone who leaves your community like absolute shit. If you threaten them, or burn down their houses, or slash their tires because they said something that made you upset (such as "God not real" or "The Rebbe is a punk-ass bitch," which is a statement I stand behind)

I care if you permanently stunt your children's education by making sure that they never learn science or algebra.

I care if you refuse to speak to anyone outside your community because it might lead to intermarriage (or worse: mixed dancing).

I care if you prevent your children from becoming well-adjusted members of society by making sure they never speak to anyone outside of their community (e.g. by making sure they're only fluent in a language no one else speaks).

I care if you refuse to report child molesters to the police because you're supposedly required to deal with these things internally.

I care if you have a dozen children that you can't afford to take care of, perpetuating a multi-generational cycle of extreme poverty, and expect the taxpayer to pay for it (in a society in which birth control is readily available).

I care if you create an entire generation of ignoramuses who completely oblivious to anything going on outside of their tiny little bubble (especially when all of them can vote). (see my story at the bottom of this post)

I don't want to kill Judaism; it can continue happily on its merry way without any complaint from me. But this whole fucking isolationist culture has to die. Maybe the whole "we stick to our own" mentality was helpful in the stetl, but right here, right now, you're hurting people and you need to stop.

I think one of the scariest things I've ever seen was this American Haredi olah in Israel being asked who she was going to vote for and she said "Oh, I don't know. My rebbe hasn't said yet." And the guy asked her "Well are you leaning towards anybody?" and she says "No. I just do what my rebbe tells me." He asked her a couple more questions about the election, but her answer was always some variation of "I have no idea what's going on. My rebbe just tells me what to do and I do it."

That kind of isolationist, brainwashing shit is fucking evil. Any belief system that robs people of their individuality like that is a cult, straight-up, and it needs to die.


r/exjew • • May 11 '20

Meme 😆

Post image
168 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Oct 11 '26

Crazy Torah Teachings Here is a small sample of my Lubavitch Chosson class curriculum, detailing the need to ask a Rav to change sex positions and think of the Rebbe while banging.

Post image
165 Upvotes

This was taught to me about 2 weeks before my wedding. The curriculum is from Lemaan Yilmedu, a mainstream Lubavitch halacha program in crown heights. This was the beginning of the end for me.

The fact that people are ok with this is just absolutely wild to me.


r/exjew • • May 29 '21

Meme What leaving Orthodoxy is like

Post image
163 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Jul 29 '19

Meme 😂🤣😂

Post image
162 Upvotes

r/exjew • • May 28 '20

Meme Who cuts bagels like that 🤣

Post image
156 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Apr 07 '25

Thoughts/Reflection Fascism has infiltrated Orthodox Jewish culture (Ashkenaz) and it’s sad.

145 Upvotes

The longer I live here, the more I realize just how delusional and out of touch a lot of people in this community are regarding other minorities. The fact that so many people here voted for Trump and wear it on their sleeves like they did some great Mitzva makes me sick. The logic behind this is the following; Own the libs, get more funding for yeshivas, get rid of the immigrants and Am Yisrael Chai.

People here hate “woke ppl” more than they care about the actual Torah. Now we all know, the Torah isn’t exactly too egalitarian either but at least it’s not inherently political. If anything, the rampant right wing lunacy here is starting to resemble the evangelicalists. Everything from the racism, sexism, Islamophobia, transphobia are all products of the rise American Conservativism in the Trump Era. I think it’s reactionary, the fear of progress.

Some personal examples; My brother and a bunch of boys in his Yeshiva bought literal Afro wigs for Purim specifically to mock black people and wear blackness as a costume. In my sister’s bais yaakov, a bunch of girls did black face. Also my sister’s friend is in a situationship with a literal Nazi! It’s fucking weird. Don’t even get me started on the amount of MuskMobiles I’m seeing in my neighborhood! (which is a predominantly Jewish neighborhood). Btw HOW do people here still support Musk?? It’s a total oxymoron and the cognitive dissonance is through the roofs.

wtf is happening here…I swear if our great great grandparents all saw what the community is here today, they’d be rolling in their graves.

Though it makes me happy to remember that this particular sect of Judaism is extremelyyyy fringe compared to the rest of the world. I’m happy to know that most Jews aren’t like this (they’re not orthodox). It just sucks to be surrounded by this insanity all the time. It’s weird having to explain to people that I wasn’t raised Evangelical or Mormon when I share the kind of things I grew up on. People are genuinely surprised to hear that this kind of ignorance comes from a Jewish community, despite being victims of Fascism ourselves.

Anyway thanks for coming to my Ted talk, imma go finish my not so kosher l’pesach cheeseburger. ✌️


r/exjew • • Feb 19 '20

Meme Me right after having my bar mitzvah

Post image
143 Upvotes

r/exjew • • May 03 '24

Casual Conversation the” gift “ my mom got me😑🤦‍♀️

Post image
141 Upvotes

Context: ive been dating my non jewish bf for a year… my mom knows this , has met him etc.. she went to a chabbad shul and borrowed this book for me 🙄 i never asked for this bs.


r/exjew • • Feb 13 '24

Meme any day now...

Post image
140 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Jan 01 '21

Casual Conversation Left religion a year ago. Tonight I made and enjoyed my first cheeseburger. I have so many years to make up now.

Post image
138 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Mar 23 '20

Image A house of worship that values loyalty over safety is definitely a cult

Post image
138 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Sep 13 '22

Venting/Rant Rabbi laughed at me when I told him my husband is abusive

134 Upvotes

My husband is giving me a gett on Friday. I recently had my first baby and I’m extremely overwhelmed. The rabbi overseeing our gett called me today to get my full name and explain the process. He began with “I understand where your husband is coming from…” then proceeded to try to rationalise why agreeing to the gett is a good thing.

What if you become an agunah!!!! Gasp!! I lost my faith in the beit din and rabbis long ago. I don’t think I even had it to begin with. I don’t care about the gett nor about becoming an agunah. The ketubah has been null in my eyes since my husband began mistreating me. All these institutions are failed systems filled with demons.

In the duration of the call, this rabbi laughed at me while I told him my husband abused me, called me extremely emotional (just like all abused women who just gave birth, right?), and told me not to air my grievances during the gett process.

I told this misogynistic dumdum cult leader that I don’t see how this system is in my best interests as he claimed, and if anything it hurts women more. So now im gonna be a single mom ever since my husband decided to become haredi and the Jewish court failed in its duty, reflecting their responsibility onto the US legal system.

The longer I stay in frumkeit the more and more darker it becomes. I’m fully disgusted at this rabbi, at my soon to be ex, my in laws, the kiruv rabbis who rushed me into this hell, and the community that is either silent or maintains the dysfunctional status quo.

F all of them!!!!


r/exjew • • Mar 27 '20

Meme All the Jews be like...

Post image
134 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Jul 08 '20

Meme I didn't ask for this tho

Post image
132 Upvotes

r/exjew • • May 07 '23

Humor/Comedy Off The Derech son attends major family Simcha

Post image
131 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Jun 26 '21

Little Victories I always dread shabbos, I'm stuck at home with my family and it sucks, but today I snuck out, hopped on my bike in teaneck NJ, and 3 hours later after enjoying pride weekend in NYC find myself in Brooklyn. Most amazing time of my life!

Post image
131 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Feb 22 '26

Little Victories Fresh produce is one of my favorite treif foods.

Post image
130 Upvotes

r/exjew • • May 28 '20

Meme Piggy-back ride

Post image
127 Upvotes

r/exjew • • May 15 '26

Question/Discussion Frum women silencing other women

124 Upvotes

There's a Facebook group I'm in called Jewish women talk about intimacy. I've talked about it here. At this point in my life, it's mildly entertaining but often times validates why I left.

Some poor woman posted the other day that she has suffered infertility, miscarriages, and a stillborn, and that she and her husband "crossed the line" (she didn't say what that meant; but that they missed each other and wanted to connect) while she was a niddah after her recent loss. Most everyone was supportive, telling her to be gentle on herself, that she shouldn't feel guilty, etc. Somebody commented that this was exactly what is wrong with the niddah laws, the mental damage done in a situation where the entire rest of the world would seek comfort from their spouse, but you can't even touch. A wholllllllle bunch of women either liked that comment or supported it with their own comments, they were all agreeing. Someone even said this is why people go OTD, because of this bullshit created by rabbis. Lots of comments like that.

Well! The admin, Chana Carlebach, promoter of this "awesome mitzvah" and "hashem knows what's best for us", wasn't having any of it. She came and said that this is all against halacha and tried to shut it down. Then she deleted that one girl's comment and all.the ones that followed, basically sanitizing the comment thread. Then she made her own separate post essentially saying this is a safe space for women and their beliefs basically as long as you don't contradict Torah. As long as you dont contradict her Chabad version of Torah. Feel bad for anyone who is her kallah student.

The only thing worse than rabbis oppressing women, is women oppressing women.


r/exjew • • Mar 26 '23

Image This is ChatGPT responding to a prompt asking it to explain nuclear fusion in yeshivish terms

Post image
119 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Mar 21 '20

Meme All my family be like

Post image
118 Upvotes

r/exjew • • Aug 02 '19

Satire Every religious war ever...

Post image
118 Upvotes