r/excoc • u/Nearby-Tension3515 • 1d ago
Restorationist Narrative Makes No Historical Sense
I just want to take a moment to establish the Church of Christ narrative, because honestly, in my opinion, it’s just as silly as the Mormon story.
So you’re telling me that Jesus Christ died on the cross for everyone’s sins, rose on the third day, and then we had the era of the apostles and the events described in the Book of Acts. But after the apostles died, everything suddenly fell apart. The Church fell into complete disarray, true Christianity disappeared, and then, somehow, a few people in Kentucky and Tennessee in the 1800s finally figured out the truth after reading the Bible?
That doesn’t make any sense to me. None of it does. It’s an incredibly convoluted story that relies on a lot of coincidences. It essentially suggests that nearly every Christian who came after the apostles was somehow a fake Christian.
But when you actually study Christian history, you encounter people who were clearly sincere in their convictions, even though they weren’t members of the Churches of Christ. Think about early Christian martyrs like Blandina, who endured repeated torture rather than renounce her faith. Think about the countless Christians throughout history who suffered and died because of their belief in Jesus, including Christians persecuted under communist regimes.
And we’re supposed to believe that all these people were somehow following a false version of Christianity, while the Churches of Christ finally came along in the 19th century and recovered the truth?
I just find that narrative incredibly difficult to take seriously.
TL;DR: The Church of Christ restorationist narrative suggests that Christianity essentially lost the truth after the apostles died and didn’t recover it until the 19th century. That requires dismissing centuries of sincere Christians, including people who suffered and died for their faith. I find that historical explanation incredibly unconvincing.