r/excoc • • 6d ago

Weekly Self-Promotion Mega Thread

2 Upvotes

Want to share your latest Blog Post, Podcast, Video Essay, or Zoom Link?

Post it here!


r/excoc • • 1d ago

Restorationist Narrative Makes No Historical Sense

24 Upvotes

I just want to take a moment to establish the Church of Christ narrative, because honestly, in my opinion, it’s just as silly as the Mormon story.
So you’re telling me that Jesus Christ died on the cross for everyone’s sins, rose on the third day, and then we had the era of the apostles and the events described in the Book of Acts. But after the apostles died, everything suddenly fell apart. The Church fell into complete disarray, true Christianity disappeared, and then, somehow, a few people in Kentucky and Tennessee in the 1800s finally figured out the truth after reading the Bible?
That doesn’t make any sense to me. None of it does. It’s an incredibly convoluted story that relies on a lot of coincidences. It essentially suggests that nearly every Christian who came after the apostles was somehow a fake Christian.
But when you actually study Christian history, you encounter people who were clearly sincere in their convictions, even though they weren’t members of the Churches of Christ. Think about early Christian martyrs like Blandina, who endured repeated torture rather than renounce her faith. Think about the countless Christians throughout history who suffered and died because of their belief in Jesus, including Christians persecuted under communist regimes.
And we’re supposed to believe that all these people were somehow following a false version of Christianity, while the Churches of Christ finally came along in the 19th century and recovered the truth?
I just find that narrative incredibly difficult to take seriously.
TL;DR: The Church of Christ restorationist narrative suggests that Christianity essentially lost the truth after the apostles died and didn’t recover it until the 19th century. That requires dismissing centuries of sincere Christians, including people who suffered and died for their faith. I find that historical explanation incredibly unconvincing.


r/excoc • • 1d ago

Cessasionalism

5 Upvotes

Since the COC is cessasionalist, why worship? The whole theology falls apart if god on longer interacts with the world. Make it make sense.


r/excoc • • 1d ago

Some variant of McKeanism (ICOC, ICC, RCW, AWSOM, all splits) College work

3 Upvotes

I work at a college and we have a large RCW following. Is there any way I can perhaps help students that are being recruited?


r/excoc • • 1d ago

BRUCE DICKINSON Says 'All Religions Were Created By Man': Organized Religion Is 'About Control', Not About 'Individual Enlightenment'

Thumbnail
blabbermouth.net
12 Upvotes

Really couldn’t have said it any better.


r/excoc • • 1d ago

Well, it finally happened.

34 Upvotes

I’ve been in a new round of deconstruction since early August this year and I had a feeling it might end up here. Whatever belief I still had in Christianity actually imploded yesterday; I have some spirituality that was outside/parallel to my Christian practice still, but I’m religiously agnostic at this point.

It’s still a lot to wrap my mind around, but I also think I’ve probably been here for a little while and was just in denial about it. This is… more honest to myself, in a way.


r/excoc • • 2d ago

The Butts

7 Upvotes

I saw a post a few days ago about the Butts. Sheila was a rep, now a mayor. I've been around them in church. They'd come to meetings at our church way back in the 80s. Jeremy the son preached my dad's funeral 3 years ago. I don't think Sheila is well-liked. ETA Stan Butt jr had DUI charges


r/excoc • • 2d ago

A letter from a member of the Church

12 Upvotes

So for people that don't know about my situation in the church (I am currently PIMO, physically in, mentally out) this is the same person that was from my other post about being pressured to give to the church. You can find it on my profile if you want.

Anyway, tonight church service I was approached by this person (we will call them C) before service began. C talked to me about how I was missing from Sunday night services (I work on Sunday nights) and talked about how he missed me. This is kind enough, but then C handed me the letter.
I had gotten nothing before this and I was so curious. So as the hymns were sung I opened the envelope and while my brother preached a devotional I read it. Here are a few points and I would like to know whether this is manipulative or something else.

Firstly it begins stating that it hopes I am well and that I am missed during Sunday nights.
Then it talks about his story as a young adult and how he felt like he didn't fit it and he understood (apparently) what I was going through.
He started comparing his "Falling away" point to my current situation and on how Satan isolated him.
Anyway he randomly made a point about how they dated someone outside of the church once. the HORROR!
Basically he is noticing that I am missing one service I am being missed. Once again he knows I work on Sunday nights. But also the note contained his number (which for obvious reasons won't be here) and stated for me to call or text there if I need anything.
I don't see much wrong about this at first, but I just feel as if it feels that missing one service is treated as such a big deal. I understand wanting to reach out but this much on falling away simply because I miss one service a week just seems weird. Or am I looking too much into this?


r/excoc • • 2d ago

What in the absolute fuck just came across my feed?

Thumbnail facebook.com
8 Upvotes

r/excoc • • 2d ago

Click Tracks?

4 Upvotes

Pitch pipes help find the starting note for a song. Could you get away with using a click track to help keep the tempo? Or is that too much like an instrument.


r/excoc • • 2d ago

Golden Compass

4 Upvotes

Hey yall, new here, but I have to ask:

Anyone remember when the Golden Compass movie came out? I had a flashback recently and asked my mom if she remembered when people at our church were protesting it for being anti-Christian- (not) shockingly, she didn’t remember lollllll. But I do!!! Weird times….
Anyone else experience that in the church they grew up in? Or any other stupid media restrictions that make you laugh looking back?


r/excoc • • 2d ago

Did Anyone Else Grow Up Afraid That God Was Going to Punish Them for Every Little Mistake?

37 Upvotes

Did anyone else experience this kind of fear because of what they were taught growing up in the Church of Christ?
I remember one time my dad took me into his room, and I won’t get into all the details, but he told me that he had to punish me because God was angry with him for not punishing me. Experiences like that really affected how I viewed God.
I would sometimes be afraid to say or do the wrong thing, give in to temptation, or make even the smallest mistake because I thought God was going to turn everyone against me. I worried that He would ruin my grades, ruin my life, make people hate me, or somehow hurt me because I had done something wrong. It felt like one little mistake could cause God to punish me.
I also had a friend who seemed to experience the same kind of fear. She would talk about God being hurt, and I remember being so afraid of hurting God myself because I was scared that He would hurt me in return.
Looking back, I wonder how much of this fear came from the way we were taught to understand God. Did anyone else grow up feeling like God was constantly waiting for you to make a mistake so He could punish you?


r/excoc • • 3d ago

Ex-Churches of Christ (Mainline) feeling lost after leaving

13 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I am a long time lurker on this thread and I was wondering if anyone has felt similarly. I feel so lost regarding religion after leaving the COC. I know that I don’t want to go back, but I don’t want to completely leave organized religion behind. I left COC almost 8 years ago when I left for college and have done a lot of healing since then, but I still find myself struggling with what I believe and where to go after leaving. I was wondering if anyone else feels the same way and I was wondering how you found a way to work through the struggle. Idk if this makes sense bc I am writing this very hastily and I’m not sure how to properly explain my feelings.


r/excoc • • 3d ago

Ex-Churches of Christ (Mainline) Neurodivergence and deconversion

11 Upvotes

This is a topic I’ve been thinking about lately. I’ve started investigating a bit, and there does seem to be a little research into this area. It appears likely that people who are neurodivergent are more likely to de-convert from Christianity. There are any number of reasons that are more common for people who are neurodivergent (autism, ADHD, OCD) including valuing consistency in what is being taught, whether that is the consistency of the scripture itself or consistency in how church members live their lives versus what is being taught on Sunday. Another reason involves the challenges of the sensory experience of being in churches and large crowds and loud noises. As well as the expectation to socialize and relate in particular ways with other church members.

I’m wondering if this is something anyone here has thought about or feels is related to their own conversion. I do feel it is relevant from myself. I was a very principled child and obsessively focused on religion and doing the right thing from a very young age. And honestly, it was that very sincere devotion and obsession that ultimately led me away from the church of Christ. The more I studied scripture, the more inconsistencies within it and the less support I found for Church of Christ beliefs in particular. I truly believed that we should follow the Bible rather than tradition which led me into question a lot of of the traditions of the Church of Christ , though the leaders would deny they are traditions.

I also took very seriously the plight of the unsaved and could not understand why everyone wasn’t out there evangelizing all of the time. This led me to do calculations on the number of people who would likely be saved for all time, and if you only allow for church of Christ members, and then the Jewish nation of the Old Testament, the number is minuscule, which seemed very inconsistent with a loving God who went to the trouble of sending his son to die on the cross. Ultimately what the church taught me about loving my neighbor and wanting everyone to be safe lead me to realize that the church was unnecessarily damning people and leading me to behave in ways that were not conducive to my own spiritual growth or the spiritual growth of others. I was obsessing about being perfect and right rather than focusing on being a Love and Grace Filled person who could offer that in my relationships with others. My heart was in the right place, but I was tangled up in perfectionism and judgment.

I have since given up trying to figure out if there is a God, Jesus is divine, or if there is anything compelling to follow in scripture. I now focus on practices that I have experienced as being life-giving and spiritually identifying. I lean into Buddhist practices these days. I also attend a very liberal denomination where I know LGBTQ+ family members are welcome, and I feel like I am being surrounded by people really living out lives of compassion and reflection.


r/excoc • • 3d ago

debating the values of COC

15 Upvotes

hello everyone, i've been going to a church of Christ and at first everyone was super nice and welcoming. (they still are) however, i started going to their bible study serious and it felt more like a Q&A asking me questions like am i apart of the dark or light. i've been going to church for years, but i never experience something like this. i felt like i had to say the right things. i'm unsure of what to do because everyone is super nice but the bible studies are what rubs me the wrong way.


r/excoc • • 4d ago

Ex-Non-Instrumental Churches of Christ Y'all see the frankly insane takes on this post?

Thumbnail reddit.com
15 Upvotes

r/excoc • • 4d ago

Custom Christian Churches That Accept Mormon Baptisms But NOT Mine?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/excoc • • 4d ago

Ex-Churches of Christ (Mainline) MIL Post

Post image
10 Upvotes

So I left the CoC around this time last year as I had been with my faith and the teachings of the CoC versus history and science. Changed my faith and they were pissed to be understated. On top of that my dad was a minister my entire life growing up. We don’t talk about my faith ever, but due to circumstances I still have to take my wife who is a member to church on Sundays. Now from the outside, I see so many people that I used to like and I see the posts that they do (mainly politics) saying you can’t be a Christian and vote Democrat. You can’t be a Christian and not support Israel. Just vile hatred stuff. How did anyone ever think this way?


r/excoc • • 4d ago

Is the Church of Christ considered evangelical?

18 Upvotes

I’ve noticed that Churches of Christ are sometimes lumped in with evangelical denominations and movements, but I’m not entirely sure whether that’s an accurate classification. Having grown up in the Church of Christ, I’ve always viewed it as somewhat distinct from mainstream evangelicalism, at least in terms of theology, history, and church structure.
I’m curious how others would classify it. Is the Church of Christ technically evangelical, or is it better understood as a separate Restoration Movement tradition?


r/excoc • • 5d ago

I think the wife's cult finally noticed

9 Upvotes

So as most you know I'm a devout charismatic who compromises with my wife. So I have to PIMO on Sundays. Not fun not easy but there it is my charismatic churches during the week and the cult on Sundays.

So I do my best to stay invisible, keep my head down and not inner act. Then last Sunday I heard something and I realized what the preacher was saying today he said it again and this time it was more clear. The preacher has kept pointing out that the cult is losing numbers and its to the point that it scares him apparently they were at 250 before covid since then they now average 180 and that just dropped by four aa recently these four members passed away. Just an observation. I mean a big part of healing is recognizing the issue. I'm not at all confident that this will be different than other cases. It's just I happen to catch that realization in real time the preacher knows he is shrinking and so far his remedy is still what I have seen before putting the future and hope into the youth which almost always fails because thank God younger people think for themselves.


r/excoc • • 5d ago

A podcast

0 Upvotes

I just pitched the idea of a podcast to my uncle... kind of knowing my background.. what kind of things would be most beneficial for others?

What kind of format, guest speakers, excoc people, topics, anything.

Not set in stone but... his website revamp is getting him excited.


r/excoc • • 6d ago

The COC I Attend

15 Upvotes

So I’m ex coc. Deconstructed, disfellowshipped, disillusioned. But I’m still a Christian (if a little hesitant to say that without qualification)

When I started looking for another church to attend, I tried a few community churches and mainline churches. The community churches seemed to have just as many problems as the COC, just with fog machines and more casual dress. At the end of the day, they still think people who disagree with them will burn forever; their definitions of who disagrees with them is just much broader than the COC, but that’s not saying much.

I then tried out mainline Protestant churches like the UMC and the Episcopal church, but the ones close to me are either caught up in denominational drama or dwindling to nothing, and I feel like my family needs something more stable atm. One church, for example, lets another church use their building and meets at night with a supply priest with a handful of people. I love the liturgy, but it’s hard being the only family with children.

I really dig the PCUSA, but it’s kind of the same situation.

Anyways, there is a COC up the road in another city, and they seem to be COC in name only. They worship without instruments and take the Lord’s Supper every week, but the minister rarely gives an invitation, talks about baptism in a different way than what I’m used to, and the church openly works with other denominations. Most of the people I talk to are either ex coc or not even coc at all. And I haven’t detected any of the COC attitude in any of the leaders or members.

Most importantly, for me, is that I’ve made a lot of friends here, and they share the same experiences as me with deconstruction and our families reaction to it.

If this church doesn’t work out, I don’t see myself ever going to another COC. But this seems like a diamond in the rough, and people seem genuinely happy and healthy, and they give so much back to the community. I’m sure they aren’t perfect, but it seems less toxic than a lot of the community churches or other “denominations” most people attend in my area.

I know a lot of people couldn’t go to a COC like this, and I totally get that. And I know many people here are no longer Christian at all, and I totally get that too. I don’t think the God I believe in would blame you for that either with what you’ve experienced. But I thought this might be helpful/ encouraging for someone who was having trouble finding some kind of spiritual community. I wouldn’t recommend you try out COCs until you find one like this. I wouldn’t want to put you in danger. But if you happen upon one through research or recommendation, then it might work like it has for me so far.

I might make a post next month saying how horrible it is, but it’s been a few years, and things have been steady so far.


r/excoc • • 6d ago

Bachelor’s degree rates

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/excoc • • 6d ago

We lost our daughter to the International Christian Church.

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/excoc • • 6d ago

Exvangelical Thoughts - pt. 12 [OC]

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes