r/exatheist • • 16h ago

Please No Debate! Advice for belief

6 Upvotes

I have been struggling with my lack of belief for most of my life and it's recently come to a head. I don't know how to describe the last few months of my life as anything other than extremely stressful and filled with fear. I shouldn't feel this way, I am generally very happy with my family and job, and for the first time in my life I am not in survival mode.

I am 36 years old and at no point in my life that I can recall, have held any sincere belief in God or an afterlife. I grew up in a fairly religious family in the Midwest USA, have tried just about every flavor of mainstream protestantism and felt nothing despite a sincere and desperate desire to believe.

The problem for me isn't even necessarily the arguments that many naturalist/atheists have. I just feel a general lack of ability to believe even though I accept that logically and mathematically the existence of a creator is at least potentially likely. I do have mild OCD and really struggle with abstract thinking.

I have read a bit about most major religions (Judaism, Buddhism, Islam, Hinduism, ect.) and have friends that are practitioners of most of these faiths so I do understand generally what they are about. I feel like Christianity does make the most sense to me and aligns very well with my personal values/morals, and the structure of orthodoxy and Catholicism are very appealing to my OCD brain.

I'm just really exhausted from the existential dread. I feel like the stress and anxiety that builds every time I'm not actively engaged is going to put me in an early grave. I want to believe in god but I feel like I'm missing something essential here.


r/exatheist • • 3d ago

Is it wrong to just… become religious?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

I think you guys might be the most help here!


r/exatheist • • 4d ago

Ex-atheists which religion do you follow now ?

15 Upvotes

A question for all ex-atheists:

  1. Which religion do you all believe in now?

  2. What made you choose that religion?

  3. Was it personal experience or external influence ?(known people or social media)


r/exatheist • • 4d ago

Debate Thread The most ridiculous arguments for God's existence

3 Upvotes

Some arguments for the existence of God are very interesting and intuitive (say, the classical design argument discussed by Cicero and Hume), but some arguments go beyond mental gymnastics.. I feel pity for theologians sometimes.. having to produce these philosophical monstrosities to rationalize their beliefs.

Here I'll mention three arguments that I think are really the worst of the worst:

1. The ontological argument

This is the most famous one among people who engage in existential debates. The essence of the argument is this: God is defined as a perfect or inconceivably great being. Something that exists in reality is more perfect or greater than that which exists in imagination only. But if God is really perfect or inconceivably great, he must exist in reality as well. Therefore, God exists!

This argument is so ridiculous that it doesn't even merit refutation. This is the type of thing you tell your friends to make them laugh. And yet, it was seriously proposed by an important Christian saint called Anselm and later defended by Descartes. And to add insult to injury, some theologians still seriously present "refined" versions of this joke today (e.g., William Craig). If this doesn't cast doubt on their objectivity or honesty, I don't know what can.

2. The argument from desire

This argument roughly goes like this: fundamental desires always correspond to things in reality that can satisfy those desires e.g., the desire for food corresponds to real food in the world. Desire for sex corresponds to sex. But we also have fundamental desires for supernatural things, like objective purpose/meaning, an after life, divine protection, a moral authority, perfect justice, etc. Therefore, these things must exist in reality as well!

Again, this is the type of argument you present to entertain your friends and make them laugh. And yet, it was seriously proposed and defended by important Christian thinkers such as Aquinas and C. S. Lewis.

3. The argument from degrees

This argument can be summarized as follows: we usually think of many things in terms "more" and "less" (e.g., colder and hotter). A continuum is defined by its two endpoints. For example, when we say one color is lighter than another, we mean that it is closer to the extreme of pure white and further from the opposite extreme of pure black. Being itself admits of degrees of perfection. An intelligent being exists to a more perfect degree than an unintelligent one. But if these degrees of perfection pertain to being, then there must exist a best being; a source, ruler and real standard of all the perfections. But God is defined as a perfect being.. Therefore, God exists.

After laughing out loud at this argument, you are going to feel sadness and pity. Why? Because this isn't an argument presented by someone with half their brain tied behind their back like Kent Hovind or Ray Comfort. This argument is one of the big "five ways" proposed by Aquinas to prove God's existence. Even today Aquinas is considered one of the most important and significant defenders of Christianity.

I can't help but feel pity for theologians, being forced to produce these arguments due to the poverty of evidence for God's existence. And this is sad.

Anyway, do you think there are even worse arguments for God out there? I would be curious to hear it.


r/exatheist • • 9d ago

If you are a Non Believer, if so...

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

For those who identify as non-believers:

What are your current grounds for not believing in a God or any religion?

What led you to stop believing? Was it reasoning, personal experience, questioning religious teachings, or something else?

And now that you no longer believe, do you believe in anything else, or have you reached a point where you're comfortable saying, "I don't know"?

I'm genuinely interested in understanding what brought you to your current position and what you stand by today.


r/exatheist • • 11d ago

Ex-athiests, what changed your mind/converted you?

Thumbnail reddit.com
15 Upvotes

Asked as an agnostic -

Open to answers from any religion!

Curious what changed your mind from a firm non-believer into a believer of your faith?


r/exatheist • • 11d ago

Jesus Wasn’t Only Written About in the Bible — Ancient Non-Christian Historians Mentioned Him Too. Here’s proof that Roman and Jewish writers documented Jesus and the early Christian movement outside the Bible

Thumbnail reddit.com
9 Upvotes

1. Flavius Josephus (AD 37–c. 100) — Jewish Historian
Antiquities of the Jews, Book 20, Chapter 9, Section 1.
Josephus mentions James, identifying him as the brother of “Jesus, who was called Christ.”
He also discusses Jesus in Book 18, Chapter 3, Section 3, although parts of that passage are disputed as possible later Christian additions.
2. Tacitus (AD 56–c. 120) — Roman Historian
Annals, Book 15, Section 44.
Tacitus records that Christus was executed under Pontius Pilate during Emperor Tiberius’s reign and describes Nero’s persecution of Christians.
3. Pliny the Younger (AD 61–c. 113) — Roman Governor
Letters, Book 10, Letter 96.
Pliny reports that early Christians gathered and sang hymns to Christ “as to a god.”
4. Suetonius (c. AD 69–after 122) — Roman Historian
Life of Nero, Section 16.
Suetonius records the punishment of Christians under Nero. His reference to “Chrestus” in Life of Claudius 25.4 may refer to Christ, although scholars debate this.
The historical takeaway:
These non-Christian sources independently attest to aspects of Jesus’ historical existence and the early Christian movement, though they do not independently verify every Gospel claim.
Jesus was not merely a figure discussed in Scripture. He was also mentioned in the wider historical record of the Roman world.
If Jesus was only a fictional character, why did Roman and Jewish historians write about Him and His followers?


r/exatheist • • 12d ago

The Penrose Number: Does the Universe’s Fine-Tuning Make Atheism an Absurd Position?”

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/exatheist • • 13d ago

Please No Debate! 'Free Will' are just two words

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/exatheist • • 13d ago

Former Atheists and Converts

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/exatheist • • 14d ago

Please No Debate! I feel like the God is evil argument is useless to the main subject

12 Upvotes

for context im agnostic. I spend a lot of time around my atheist friends, and while their points are valid and I'm not expecting them to have well thought out arguments (not because I don't think they're intelligent they just don't care about religion as a whole so they don't really look into it), a lot of their arguments boil down to "God is evil" or "God did this one thing in the bible i didn't like, or I deem morally wrong," which is fine, but I don't think that's what people should really be focusing on

God being good/evil doesn't mean he's not real
God, if he is real, is not obligated to make us comfortable. I think the question *should* stay focused on whether God is real or not; once we figure that out without a doubt, then we can start judging his character


r/exatheist • • 14d ago

Debate Thread It's difficult to believe in God when He remains silent and hidden.

16 Upvotes

it seems there is little evidence that demonstrates God's existence. Why should I believe He is true?


r/exatheist • • 17d ago

Why aren't you an atheist anymore(to all the ex-atheists)?

18 Upvotes

What changed your opinon? Was it an experience, more reading, actually rethinking and questioning the existence of God rather than just denying it, or else?

I used to be an atheist, I belived there was no God, now I'm agnostic because I believe that God's existence is fundamentally unknowable to us(just my opinon).

What about you?


r/exatheist • • 18d ago

Nothing Buttery

3 Upvotes

Hello to everyone.

After a bizarre panic attack six months ago, I dedicated my time to researching my beliefs in a far more detailed manner than I had ever done before.

I was raised, and still am Christian, but I have no trouble inhabiting the emotional or rational states that other beliefs require. I can switch between them, and it is eye-opening, but it makes decisions difficult. I have both perspectives and trouble sticking to one.

Which brings me to this: After six months, I am struggling to find a way in which materialist secularism, when properly inhabited, is not a completely radical change compared to what we see it as currently.

Take morality, for example. I've read Parfit, Baidou, Korsgaard, Blackburn, Murdoch, Foot, Mackie, ​Dewey, Ayer, Moore, Rawls, etc.

If I am rejecting God, for the epistemic reasons most do, half of these rely on methods that are not empirically testable and derive from starting assumptions that are similarly assertive.

The rest are so easily manipulated that the simplest of madmen could rot the entirety of mankind with a few clever twists of intent and technical jargon, making our modern grasp of morality pretty ineffective.

To avoid this, it seems to make most sense to take an Anscombe route, but even more radical. If we are rejecting the supernatural for epistemic justifications, why do I incessantly see the basics of human morality held onto and venerated rather than critiqued into oblivion with the same veracity that is supplied to religion?

If I am going to value epistemic truth above all else, if there is nothing buttery about us animals, why is morality not happenstance? Why must what happened be what must happen? Why can't our bronze-age conceptions ​​​of ethics be as ancient as our gods?

I'm not seeing any grounding. Without God, I see animals. I see nature. And I see our skills being as equal to the particular skills of shrimp or koalas. ​If humans are not overly special, which I would be willing to accept, why must our morality be any different?

Why do tears track truth that goes beyond anything but mere occurence? Even a Foot-esque declaration of objective suffering can be reasonably argued out of: e.g. complicate what suffering is, obscure how it is universally applied, scrutinize its obligatory power.

If God is unscientific, then sure. Let it be. But why isn't everything else stripped of its metaphysics naturally contingent as well? Why are there golden idols that get free passes? If it is truth above all comfort, why has it stopped?

Has anyone else felt this way? Or am I creating a supposed hypocrisy that is not there to help strengthen my beliefs?

Let me know. Thanks for reading. ​


r/exatheist • • 18d ago

Debate Thread Grew up religious but I'm turned skeptical

0 Upvotes

I always had many spiritual experiences that led me to believe in God and I still believes, however as I got older (I'm 30) I realized that the only thing that matters in life is making money.

Being religious is in most cases waste of time and money and the more religious people are more broken as it's virtually impossible as an adult to have a functional life and be religious, by religious I mean attending a church, doing service, paying tithing etc. My life got way better when I quitted religion, my friends that grew up with me went the way of "thrusting God and all things will be fine" and they are all screwed, that's one of the biggest bullshit that's taught.

So I'm in a weird position that I still believe in God but almost everything if not everything that's taught about God by the churches is actual bullshit and then even tho as o described I had spiritual experiences I live in a weird secular spot because religion is not something to trust.

From all groups I have studied the jews are the most based ones that actual understand how to play the game, the Christians (the group I grew up) are the most brainwashed and manipulated by man made doctrines.


r/exatheist • • 18d ago

Is secularism (or religious neutrality) the religion that underpins political and capitalist violence?

0 Upvotes

I would like to clarify that this post was not written using AI, so I apologize for its imperfection and I remain available for any clarification necessary to understand my thinking.

Western European countries are among the few countries in the world that aim to be religiously neutral, therefore without religious authority, not only over citizens, but more curiously, even over the functioning of society (commercial code and financial relations, penal code, civil code, etc.).

I therefore wonder if the absence of religion, formerly Catholicism, does not in fact guarantee all rights to money, which thus takes full power?


r/exatheist • • 20d ago

Please No Debate! Shouldn’t All Christian Denominations Humble Themselves, Reason Together, and Seek One Biblical Truth?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

The goal is not merely to belong to one denomination, but to be united in the truth of God and Jesus Christ.
1. Jesus prayed that all believers would be one
John 17:20–23 (KJV)
"Neither pray I for these alone, but for them also which shall believe on me through their word;
That they all may be one; as thou, Father, art in me, and I in thee, that they also may be one in us: that the world may believe that thou hast sent me."


r/exatheist • • 21d ago

Ancient Atheists

Thumbnail
substack.com
8 Upvotes

Atheism is often associated with the modern world, particularly with the rise of science, the Enlightenment, and the growing separation between religion and public life. It is easy to imagine that people in ancient societies simply accepted the existence of gods and that questioning religious belief was something that came much later. In Battling the Gods: Atheism in the Ancient World, Tim Whitmarsh challenges this familiar picture. He shows that atheistic ideas were already being discussed in ancient Greece, and that some thinkers questioned the existence of gods, challenged traditional religious stories, and tried to explain religion through human experience rather than divine influence.


r/exatheist • • 21d ago

Please No Debate! People who have been in multiple religions before reaching your current beliefs, what made you arrive at your current belief.

10 Upvotes

r/exatheist • • 22d ago

Should I be an atheist?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/exatheist • • 27d ago

Debate Thread Why there must be a Supreme Being

7 Upvotes

Premise 1: Everything that begins to exist has a cause. (out of nothing, nothing comes)

Premise 2: The universe began to exist. (The Second Law of Thermodynamics and The BGV theorem)

Conclusion 1: Therefore, the universe has a cause.

Premise 3: As the cause of space, time, and matter, this cause must exist independently of them—making it changeless, timeless, spaceless, and immaterial. (The Law of Transcendent Causation)

Premise 4: A cause can produce an effect either through a mechanical, automatic process (scientific laws) or through an intentional choice (agent causation). (The Exhaustive Distinction of Causation)

Premise 5: An automatic, timeless cause must have its effect present eternally; it cannot sit idle and suddenly produce a new effect at a specific point in time. (The Law of Simultaneous Impersonal Causation)

Premise 6: The universe is not eternal but had a beginning in time. (The Law of Non-Contradiction)

Final Conclusion: Therefore, the universe must have a cause that is a personal agent.


r/exatheist • • 27d ago

Does anyone else have a devout friend that actually enjoys having religious conversations with you?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/exatheist • • 29d ago

Understanding The Trinity

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes