r/exatheist • • Sep 04 '25

Who Are You, "Ex-Atheists"?

2 Upvotes

Atheists who studied, debated, and rejected God don’t tend to just 'swing back' without leaving behind a trail of actual argument shifts.

Most of the people I've spoken with here don’t argue like former skeptics - they argue like lifelong apologists dressing in borrowed credibility.

Someone put my mind at ease?


r/exatheist • • Dec 27 '22

Polytheism answers everything Monotheism does, without the hang-ups

0 Upvotes

I can't understand why theists are still playing around with monotheism, this comparatively new idea that started with the Aten in 18th Dynasty Egypt and has only come back more and more terribly over time, with worse and worse consequences.

Polytheism can easily address all the same questions of Monotheism, irrelevant of the God. Believe in a first cause? Could be God (which God?) or Gods. Believe nature is "perfectly" made? Could be God or Gods. Reject evolution? Could be God or Gods. Divine experience? Unless you're special pleading, it's really only Gods. Even the monotheistic scriptures reference other Gods or use the plural of the term. Questions like consciousness are answered better with multiple Gods as consciousness is not uniform, neither is nature itself. The list really goes on and on.

The catch is that polytheism doesn't have the same pitfalls as monotheism. Contradictory religious experiences? Of course, there's competing Gods. The existence of unjust and unfair suffering and misery? The Gods of Polytheism are not all knowing, all loving, all powerful, etc (neither is the monotheist God, but it CLAIMS to be). The defeat of a "chosen people"? Chosen by a different God. Different afterlife ideas or contradictory NDEs? Of course, it depends on the patron deity and path. What to do about non-believers? Who cares, we're all nonbelievers of certain paths or deities.

On top of this, polytheism doesn't have the culture-crippling ideologies that seem common to monotheism. There is no original sin, there is no need to convert or proselytize, there is no need to fear suffering for eternity, or that a loved one will, you dont need to tear down altars and idols, and so it goes on and on. Watching the debate rage exclusively between monotheism and atheism is just surreal, like watching the pot call the kettle black, imo. Like people fighting over two brands of candy, not realizing there's a ton of other, much better candy out there.


r/exatheist • • Jan 03 '21

Atheism Doesn't Exist

0 Upvotes

The Problem With Atheism

Many people believe that atheism is just the notion that there is no bearded man in the sky controlling every aspect of our lives.  If that is what you believe, you are right in your belief, but wrong about what atheism means.  

Because the prefix ‘a’ negates the word, you must first define theism to know what atheism truly is, and while many theists do believe in one or many beings outside of our experience that actively control reality, that’s not it.  

Theism is simply the belief that reality is actively being created (by whom or what, the word theism doesn’t specify).  

Therefore a true atheist believes that reality just IS, but if that were the case, nothing would ever happen.  Obviously then, as a self-proclaimed “atheist”, you don’t believe that.  What you believe is actually coherent, and deeply profound.  If only the theists understood…  On the other side of this, most of you monotheists reading this are thinking “nothing couldn’t have created everything”.  If only the atheists understood…


r/exatheist • • Dec 31 '25

Why turn to theism if not for comfort?

0 Upvotes

I consider myself to be an ex-christian, and I have a hard time understanding how an atheist could turn to theism. I guess I have a specific question for those who have turned to theism for a reason outside of emotional desperation.

I have heard the stories of atheists who didn't believe in god until they were looking for some comfort. Can anyone share their story of turning to god because they felt their atheistic beliefs proved to be wrong?

ADDITIONAL QUESTION FOR CHRISTIANS SPECIFICALLY: Why did you leap from atheism to Christianity specifically?


r/exatheist • • Jul 09 '26

Debate Thread The “problem” of evil

0 Upvotes

I haven’t debated this with a lot of people yet but the problem of evil is absolutely fake in my opinion. Any kind of suffering will be nullified in the presence of a perfect being (God) who will deliver the justice instantly (because God is out of space-time). And if there is evil and no divine justice, you can’t blame a non-existent God for it. Hence, a just God will solve the problem of evil. Does this make sense?


r/exatheist • • Feb 11 '26

Geena is not the hell that Jesus spoke of; the text was literally changed from its original context in the West.

0 Upvotes

Jesus did not preach hell, but Gehenna.

In Matthew 23:15, Jesus condemns religious leaders for making their converts “twice as much children of hell” as themselves. Here, Jesus uses “hell” (Gehenna) as a present reality, not as a future destination, suggesting that He viewed Gehenna as a condition of moral, spiritual, physical, mental, or emotional corruption that occurs in this life. This indicates that Jesus understood Gehenna more as an earthly state of separation from God's ways and its consequences, characterized by hypocrisy and spiritual blindness, than as an eternal place of punishment. Gehenna appears 12 times in the New Testament and is translated as "hell," being misinterpreted by many modern readers as a destination of torture after death.


r/exatheist • • Jan 01 '26

Before dying, the human brain has visions of the afterlife. Human beings are conditioned to believe in something, becoming beings designed to have a belief.

1 Upvotes

r/exatheist • • Sep 16 '24

Atheists are so fucking annoying

15 Upvotes

Back when I was a teenager, I used to be an atheist.

I liked Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, Sam Harris, Bill Maher,

TJ Kirk (The Amazing Atheist), Vaush,

r/atheism, and all the shitty atheist subreddits full of whiny edgelords.

It's not a coincidence that atheists became far right anti-sjw bigots.

Smug, insufferable racist, sexist, islamophobic, transphobic nazis.

It goes to show that the fundamentalists were right all along. You must believe in God in order to have morals.

You really believe those islampohobic bigots when they say we came from monkeys?

America will forever be a Christian nation! Christ is king! 🇺🇲 ✝️


r/exatheist • • Jan 26 '24

What if God is energy?

0 Upvotes

I think that with this the mystery of "Who created God?" since energy is not created or destroyed, it is only transformed.


r/exatheist • • Jan 09 '25

God can be proven mathematically, but it can also be disproven with maths?

0 Upvotes

This could set a debate or even a question based planting at the possible proofs or their debating counterparts but I wanna know something, God can be proven mathematically based on some proofs, but there is any proof that makes the opposite? Showing using maths that God can be disproven?.

Even if this set this post as bad, this question set in my head, when the Simpsons made a joke about it when they gave Flanders a math equation that showed that God doesn't exist, but, that type of equations can or could exist?

Or even, the mathematical evidence of God's existence, has been "debunked" efficiently?


r/exatheist • • Sep 14 '26

do atheists, physicalist, and naturalists seek self-annihilation?

1 Upvotes

showerthought: does anyone else feel like hardcore atheists, physicalists, and naturalists are secretly trying to cancel themselves too?

let's do a philosophical deep dive...basically the argument goes like this: if you spend all your time trying to prove god doesnt exist and that were literally just wet robots made of meat and stardust, youre not just getting rid of the big guy upstairs. youre lowkey deleting yourself too.

think about it:

- if theres no teleology or higher purpose, the universe is just rocks bouncing off each other. cool, whatever.

- but then they also reduce human consciousness to just like... brain farts and chemical reactions. free will is apparently an illusion, the "self" isnt real, youre just an NPC driven by biology.

- so if your mind is just meat machinery and your consciousness is a glitch, arent you basically arguing that you dont actually exist either?

 it feels like some weird subconscious death drive where people are so desperate to escape accountability or meaning that they celebrate being cosmic accidents destined for total oblivion. like they act stoked about being worthless dust.

if youve read nietzsche he actually had a ton to say about this exact thing ....and honestly he predicted the whole mess ...remember that famous quote from his madman about "god is dead and we killed him"?

everyone forgets the next part where the madman is like wait... how do we wash this blood off us, what water is there for us to clean ourselves? basically nietzsche was warning that you cant just cut god out of the equation without chopping off half of what makes us human. it leaves a massive vacuum.

here are a few things he pointed out:

- **the shadow of god:** he said even long after people stop believing, they keep acting like objective morals and human rights are still real things floating in the universe. once that "shadow" finally wears off completely, people are gonna realize they built their house on air and it'll mess them up.

- **the last man:** if we shrink the universe down to pure materialism, humanity shrinks too. we just become these safe, boring, totally hollow creatures who dont strive for anything great anymore. he called this the "last man" and its basically the ultimate vibe killer.

- **the will to nothingness:** this is the wildest part. nietzsche thought that when people cant handle the terrifying freedom of a meaningless universe, they actually *subconsciously crave* erasing themselves. like instead of stepping up and creating their own meaning, they use science to prove were garbage. if we cant be divine, fine, well prove were worthless bags of meat just to dodge the pressure.

later on, other existential guys like camus and sartre tried to fix this. sartre was like nah, existence comes first, you make your own meaning. and camus was like okay the universe is a total void, cool, lets just rebel against it by living passionately anyway. but nietzsche probably would've roasted modern materialists who brag about being "meaningless cosmic dust." like bro youre not a brave truth seeker, youre just using science as a cheat code to duck the heavy weight of having to actually matter. anyway thoughts?


r/exatheist • • Mar 03 '23

Why I Remain an Atheist

3 Upvotes

The idea of someone who describes themself as an ex-Atheist is interesting to me. It seems to me that often times it's mentioned in an attempt to lend credibility to whatever the person ends up presenting. As if it carries the same weight as the enemy abandoning their side so they can join you - the thing(s) that changed their mind must've been truly compelling for them to have made such a change.

That analogy would work if ex-Atheists actually did present better, more compelling reasons than those presented by life-long believers. But from what I can see, it's all just the same stuff.

This got me thinking about what I would need to do or what would need to change within me so I could accept Theism, or Christianity in particular. I believe I would have to fundamentally change who I am and how I think, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, but I would say these changes would undeniably be a number of steps backwards.

I would have to effectively lower my standards for what constitutes good reason to accept the truth of a claim to the point where I'm capable of accepting anecdotal, testimonial evidence for ancient, supernatural events. I would have to make a series of unjustified assumptions about the nature of these testimonials and the alleged divine influence behind them, and I would have to ignore the fallaciousness of the various arguments used in favour of theism and Christianity, such as those found in the cosmological, teleological and moral arguments.

The main problem with this lowering of standards is that the door is now open to not only Christianity but to pretty much any other claim that is supported by principly the same basis of testimonial evidence.

Am I wrong for needing more or rather, better reasons? Do these better reasons already exist, but I'm not aware of them yet? Can you honestly say that your mind was changed for reasons that meet my current standards, or if not, how/why should I go about changing my standards to meet yours?


r/exatheist • • Jul 08 '26

None of the leading sciences leave room for atheism as a solution...

3 Upvotes

I've often been told by people claiming atheism that their belief is based on hard science, provable enquiry and objective facts.

However, none of the leading sciences leave room for this. No one has been able to refute the conclusions of the double slit experiment in physics. In mathematics, concepts like irrational numbers and the Fibonacci sequence add an inescapable mysticism to the field.

I'm beginning to feel like anyone who claims atheism on the grounds of their education hasn't had enough education...

(Side note: is this even the right sub for this rant? Apologies if not...)


r/exatheist • • Aug 22 '25

It's crazy how some atheists are just downright ignorant towards religion and don't look at the context.

Post image
19 Upvotes

Found this on TikTok. I also used to act like this towards Christianity, I was so ignorant and disrespectful 😑


r/exatheist • • May 23 '25

I converted to Islam after being raised by atheist parents ask me anything

5 Upvotes

advise fact outgoing file screw pocket unite dinosaurs sense consider

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact


r/exatheist • • Aug 30 '25

Debate Thread The largest single science-based obstacle to an "Afterlife"

1 Upvotes

The largest single science-based obstacle to an "Afterlife"

It’s not possible just to ignore this (as a lot of people do) and then suppose we are having a fully informed discussion about the topic. Nor is it sufficient to say “the evidence speaks for itself”, as interpretive layers put on top of the evidence (such as there is of it) are typically top heavy in additional, unwarranted assumptions... which is not a good process of science.

WHAT WE KNOW: There is a modest to moderate amount of circumstantial, and a limited amount of formal, (basically statistical), evidence for nonlocal information events associated wiith the psyche. This includes all anecdotal material of “veridical” experience in NDEs, telepathy, clairvoyance, remote viewing, etc.

WHAT WE DON’T KNOW: That any of this directly pertains to an “afterlife” even when it may present itself in that fashion.

WHAT WE KNOW: the psyche (dreams) is fully capable of simulating persons we know or have known, as well as creating fictitious persons we have never met, or fusing together two people we have met or may know.

WHAT WE DON’T KNOW: that any of these representations, including those in NDEs or other near-terminal visions, are actually persons or real agents separate from the perceiver.

THE LARGEST FORMAL PROBLEM FROM A SCIENCE PERSPECTIVE: The idea of an afterlife essentially posits a vast “information/energy” pool operating somewhere, and yet evading so far all instrumental detection. This claim needs to be processed through some common sense logic. While it might be true to say that it is not absolutely impossible that something could be there that evades such detection, everything we have assimilated with science up to this point suggests that it would be extremely unlikely. Billions of experiencing entities, involved in structured activities, perceptions, interactions, events, is describing a whole world. It starts to become unreasonable debate to claim that such a world could be “hiding” somewhere (including the argument that it is ‘deliberately’ hiding). Our modern detection capabilities extend to extremely small fluctuations in energy and difference right down to the quantum level. That a world of such magntitude could elude our attention stretches credibility to the limit. Also, adding pseudoscience (astral bodies, etc) into the mix makes the matter worse and not better. Science has never found any evidence for any such things.

I would say this is the strongest single argument against a traditional notion of afterlife.

CAN WE FIND HOPE IN SOMETHING ELSE? Possibly. But we need to be truthful with ourselves about what we are observing in nature. In the infant to child growth process, our awareness emerges slowly. When we are sick, when we are injured, when we are anaethetised, and every single night when we sleep, we become once again less conscious. The sensible conclusion from all of this (and many other considerations I will not cover here) point to the likelihood of full consciousness being a hard-won upward emergence from much less aware or subconscious processes. The idea that we descend from some pre-existing diamond mind just isn’t supported by nature.

We appear to be local bright spots in a general twilight of consciousness. Bright spots which have taken many millions, actually billions, of years to come into focus. Again, to argue against this is effectively to take an anti—science stance on evolution and biology. Yes, consciousness may be fundamental, but what nature seems to be telling us is that it is a very basic kind of consciousness that must be fundamental, not the full pantheon of lucid mind.

What happens to these bright spots that we are, at death? Well, some things we can say for sure. The physical pattern that embodied them is lost, therefore (because of the problem I opened this post with) unless some other platform enters scientific discovery, it hardly seems likely that a full blown mind could continue, and rather that consciousness will sink back again into the pre-conscious realm from which it seems to have emerged.

And what is that? Nature in the raw. Nature as a seething system of dimly urgeful potentials struggling for wakefulness. Can the benefits of life carry over into this general subterranean layer? Does the sum of our “hard won” consciousness change it in any way?

Maybe. Maybe the darkness of the unconscious is just a little less dark because of us, but this can’t be considered a certainty. After all, nature hasn’t solved something like cancer itself, so obviously it remains either incapable (not lucid) or unmotivated (amoral) in doing so. Neither of which suggest that our influence upon it is earth shattering. To the extent cancer has been solved, or attenuated, it has been achieved by us, the local brightenings of lucid consciousness.

I would say that if you argue against this viewpoint, you are of course welcome and entitled to do so, but the burden of proof that the situation we have is too much different from what I have described lies with you, because if you are suggesting a fully lucid world of nonphysical beings living and abiding out there somewhere it’s ultimately up to you to show with reasoned argument where science is going wrong.

I maintain that science hasn’t gone wrong at all, and is functioning entirely correctly in telling us that there is zero evidence of energies or information systems divorced from the physical.


r/exatheist • • Aug 12 '25

Debate Thread The hard problem really isn’t a problem IMHO

1 Upvotes

Looking for friendly debate the hard problem is a straw man imo

I notice a lot of theists appeal to the hard problem of consciousness to justify the existence of an “immaterial” soul.

The entire problem relies on a false and misleading interpretation of Physicalism — namely that a Physicalist position can’t explain why one thing can “feel” another, and/or that two objects “touching” is not the same “feeling” as the “experience” of that touching. Sensation and experience are not the same, so says Chalmers and a bunch of idealists.

I don’t think any sort of materialist position holds that physical interactions are somehow immaterial. Nor do any materialist positions divide physical interaction from sensation, or sensation from experience. The touching is the experience.

So when Chalmers says the physicalist position has an explanatory gap — no, it doesn’t. Not internally. The other position has a gap.

So Chalmers’ argument is kind of irrational. He’s really saying he thinks that it’s a false equivalence or a presumption, but he proceeds as if it’s an obvious and self-evident explanatory gap, when really it’s a cross domain incompatibility.

He is operating on a presumption that experience is somehow immaterial, predicated on a dualist assertion that, frankly, cannot be reasonably supported unless solipsism is true.

Dualist arguments always resolve in panpsychism. There is literally no other answer, unless you invent a pile of unsubstantiated and unverifiable assumptions to force it to work.

All things being equal, the simplest explanation is the correct one — when two things touch, they really “touch,” and the sensation and experience of touching really is the touching.

No, there is not a distinction between before, during, and after. There’s no actual separation between “events.” The fact people cannot describe it exactly should not be surprising, for several reasons.

Imagine you were co-moving with a windowless train. Your friend is inside the train but can’t see out. The train enters a tunnel, you can no longer see it. Your friend has no idea she entered a tunnel at all because there are no windows. The tunnel has 1000 different exits. Which exit will it take?

The train never changes, but you have no ability to see what happened inside, and you can only guess. If you go investigate the tunnel you can learn all of its switches. But the person in the train can never learn the switches because they are inside it. They can only articulate that they were on the train.

Now: this is where the argument about the hard problem arises, because this looks like a sequential, computational model. But note I am only referencing the experience. The question is not the design of the switches — the easy problem really is easy. The point is, the person on the train cannot ever see the switches. The big question is who or what is changing the switches? I know what I believe, and that’s not really the point of the discussion here…

The point is, there is the appearance of asymmetry, but there is not asymmetry except for subjective perspective. The qualia are tied exactly to each subjective frame, and only to their subjective frame, but the qualia arise from the interaction of all parts.

The quality of being “in the train” is not identical to the quality of being “outside the train.” The quality of the tunnel is not identical to either. Yet, the state of every frame of reference engages with the others — the quality of each influence the quality of the others, but with different loci.

If “things” (minds included) can “sense” each other and interact, then all of the material, mind included, is necessarily tangible. Tangibility here means that the qualities — qualia — affect each other.

There is no moment at which a singular quale can be isolated apart from its influence on other qualia, and the influence of other qualia on it.

Qualia only exist insofar as they are the nodal intersection of yet more and other qualia.

Stated another way, qualia cannot be said to exist apart from their interaction with other things that themselves have qualitative qualities that also arise from interaction. Tangibility.

I would argue that consciousness itself cannot be distinguished from qualia, and thus cannot be distinguished from fundamental tangibility.

The “what it is like”ness of any given “event” is a composite interaction of qualia — of tangible material. And since the entirety of existence is in motion (tangible interaction), no two “events” are ever identical.

This grape has entirely different but related qualia to the next grape, but the grape and the experience of it is never the same from grape to grape. Each “grape eating event” is unique, despite broad qualitative similarities, because the composition of any given grape is more or less the same type of quality-bearing tangible material.

If the grape itself doesn’t have tangible qualities that you, the subject experiencing its own qualia of eating that grape that is not identical to any other persons qualia would be of eating that same grape, then from what does the qualia of the grape arise? If it’s not from the grape, then all of this is a simulation and that’s the end of the discussion. But if the subjective experience of that grape does in fact arise from an actual grape, then the grape must have qualia itself that interacts with the qualia that I have/am. And I am made of that grape, in part, after I eat it. So if I have qualia and I am composed of the materiality of the grape, then material that makes up the grape necessarily has qualia of its own because how else could my body be able to use grape parts to build my sensory and cognitive and locomotor apparatus?

If you can taste a grape, you can also feel your own thoughts, and you can also feel the feeling of feeling your own thoughts. Because it is necessarily all tangible.

“Sensing” (being sensate) is tangible things interacting with my tangible body. “Having the sense of sensation” is what we call awareness. Having the sense of having awareness (the sense of sensation) is what we call “subjective experience.” Having the sense of having subjective experience is memory. Having the sense of remembering having the sense of experience is metacognition.

It’s just a loop of tangible things.

Tangibility is the only necessary factor to explain physical consciousness.

It makes sense. Cells themselves, including prokaryotes, seem to exhibit conscious behaviour on their own. Viruses do not, because they do not metabolize.

The hard problem exists in reverse for idealists — there has to be a way to explain how consciousness at our scale can induce movement and action in our bodies.

NDE idealists have another challenge, to explain how a body reanimates and why the soul didn’t move on.

Far simpler is to envision the cells doing it in the first place. We are a “song” all the cells are singing, together, in a sense.

There’s also research coming out showing that the persistent background noise floor in our bodies is what our consciousness is, and the part we’ve been looking at is really just the attentional process, which is louder and more obvious.

When you then consider the issue of memory transfer in transplant patients, it starts to paint a very clear picture that cellular consciousness underlies all of this.

Dualism never really entered the conversation until Descartes. And Descartes only really gets serious consideration because of Christian apologetics.

The hard problem only exists in dualist metaphysics and ontology. It’s likely an unsurpassable problem. And that means dualism is wrong.

Nondualism and monism are absolutely valid. Nondualism is a term that comes with a specific frame, like “theism” (the claim) and “atheism” (the rejection of that claim) which have been reversed where theism is basically treated as the non-claim position. Nondualism is the default — dualism is the claim.

Just like atheists have no need to defend the valid, default position against a specious claim requiring evidence, nondualists have no need to defend their position against the specious claim that is dualism.

Show me a disembodied soul, and I’ll eat my hat.

Before Cartesian dualism, the discussion of consciousness was significantly different. In the Christian systems that most western discourse in this area is based out of, “the Holy Spirit” is a metaphysical assertion for the agency of god in this objective world, which is itself just a reframing of Stoic metaphysics and the pneuma, or animating force. Various animistic philosophies rule elsewhere. Followed by forcible expansion of western ideology.

All of which is to say — dualism is the weird thing that requires proof. Dualism is an article of faith. Dualism has zero support of any kind whatsoever.

It is neither logically consistent with reality nor is it supported by any observations. At all.

The way this works is not much different than how guitar pedals work.

The first problem is that most descriptions of neural processes use circuitry as an analogy, specifically the idea of a switch being closed as the model for how stimuli are “transferred” from point A to point B. A stimulus happens, the switch is flipped to “on,” the signal moves through a series of tunnels, and arrives at the brain where…???

But that’s not what’s really going on. Not even close.

Electrical circuits go from off to on, but the human body is always “on.” What we call “rest state” of the activation potential is not “off.” If we used circuitry analogies properly, the switch is always closed. What happens is a surge in power in an already-active and powered circuit.

So it’s basically how an electric guitar works. You plug it in, and let’s say you have a set of guitar pedals. The whole system is already powered. There is a “noise floor” because the system is already powered, and strumming the guitar generates a field alteration.

The entire line from the guitar, down the cable, through the pedal, into the amp, out the speaker, is like a single neural chain. A constant field exists between Point A and Point B. It is not a series of tunnels, it’s a field with a series of modulators. When the guitar is strummed, the entire field changes. When a pedal is pressed, the field modulates. This field change is channeled around the neurons through specific steps that alter that field, bidirectionally.

Compare the sound of the amplified guitar, with pedals altering its field, versus the “actual” sound of the unamplified electric guitar.

What you’re doing here is considering “how does an unamplified guitar EVER result in the amplified guitar sound?” And where synapses and neural processing are concerned, you’re presenting guitar pedals without power and being like “huh?!?”

The powering of the guitar-system results in something much more, and much more complex and varied, than the unpowered constituent parts would ever suggest. Our bodies are similar — we only exist powered “on,” and “on” is the rest state of the system. The signals we’re talking about here are “overpowering” (activation) and “under powering” (inhibition) of that “on” state. But at no point are we ever “off.”

So where the hard problem is concerned, part of the problem here is just how poorly the “easy problem” is presented. The entire analogy is more or less wrong, so it’s a kind of strawman.

At no point, ever, is there an “off” state.

Whilst the hard problem suggests that we struggle to say how subjective experience arises, it operates on a presumption that there is an “off” state — and there isn’t.

If the personality of your parents exists in you, it got there from an egg and a sperm — and both were “on” already before “you” ever appeared. There is no “off” state, so a circuitry model based on switches closing will never be an accurate description.

So that is why IMHO the hard problem is a strawman


r/exatheist • • Dec 31 '25

Getting the elephant out of the room, Christianity is incompatible with LGBTQIAPN movements. Like liberalism and progressivism, we always hear that the state is secular, but religion is not secular. Faith does not need to adapt to the secular world.

0 Upvotes

r/exatheist • • Jan 03 '26

Old Testament texts about wars and murders should be interpreted as passages about spiritual battles, not literally, even though orthodox tradition generally sees them that way. So why do some atheists insist on saying the opposite? It's not a criticism or anything, I just find it funny. Even when e

0 Upvotes

, aware of the patristic tradition that interprets the acts of a "bloodthirsty God" simply as types and prophetic symbols of Christ, the war against the Canaanites being a mere symbol of our spiritual war

Link https://www.oca.org/reflections/fr.-lawrence-farley/the-god-of-joshua


r/exatheist • • Feb 24 '23

"YoU cAnT pRoVe A nEgAtIvE!!!!"

8 Upvotes

I can prove there's no square-circles in the 3rd dimension by using logic alone.

I can prove there's no boxes under by bed by taking a picture under there.

I can prove I don't have the flu with nasal swabs.

I can prove there's no invisible teapot in space because teapots are definitionally material so must be visible, because no astronaut has brought up and released such a teapot (which again can't even logically exist to begin), because there's no reason to believe it - it hasn't been experienced in all times and cultures, it doesn't answer questions about the nature of reality, it's a complete flase equivalency to gods.

Don't fall for this "you can't prove a negative" bullshit, it's just a way for people to hold their faith without needing evidence and reason for it.


r/exatheist • • Sep 14 '24

Let's try a little atheist logic

5 Upvotes

Can God make a round square?

a round square is logically invalid. Stapling God or anything else to it doesn't change the fact

Can God create a rock he cannot lift?

do people not understand that a rock or stone by definition has a boundary and is therefore finite?


r/exatheist • • Apr 24 '26

I left atheism because I noticed a lot of Atheists were "worshipping" Bernie Sanders around 10 years ago. Has anyone else had a similar experience?

0 Upvotes

They were no better than fundamentalists. Saying Bernie could magically solve all the problems in America in a snap with no real evidence. And then it got to the point that questioning his motives resulted in exile.

Makes me think that humans are "programmed" to worship a higher power, so I might as well embrace it instead of foolishly denying.


r/exatheist • • Jan 01 '23

What's the best name for the narrative specially designed to make atheists of us all?

2 Upvotes
149 votes, Jan 04 '23
75 materialism
13 physicalism
22 naturalism
14 truth
15 I don't like being questioned. I'm only here for distance and irritation
10 other specified in the comments below

r/exatheist • • Jan 24 '26

Do you believe that religious people should rebel against far-right governments and oppose them? Society is changing more and more; we are moving towards fascism. I think that, regardless of your religion, it is time to stand up, or should we wait cautiously for the next steps?

2 Upvotes

r/exatheist • • Mar 17 '23

Babies popping in and out of existence

1 Upvotes

Hello ex-atheists! I know alot of you aren't Muslim, but please read on, I'm sure you'll relate to what I have to say.

So, one thing I noticed in the Qur'an is how God continually tells us to reflect on human embrology and the stages of human development from "a disdained liquid" (semen) to a fully functional 5ft+ concious, sentient being. God also reminds us in the Qur'an to reflect upon natural signs (sun/moon, orderdness of celestial bodies, rain, and so on) and reflect upon their consistency. Most of you are aware of this as the fine tuning and design arguments.

A common atheist contention is the following,

"Well, we can see how people would find the phenomenon of fetus development fascinating in the 6th century, but now we know about chromosomes, DNA, fertilization, etc. Although we do find it extraordinary, nothing supernatural is at play here, only the laws of chemistry acting the way they should."

Although atheists aren't aware of this, what they are implicitly implying by employing these sorts of arguments is that because of the fact that what us theists find fascinating are natural phenomenon that take STAGES to fully manifest, and the fact that they follow an ordered predictable law, makes the notion of God doing these things unintelligible. Rather, they say, it seems as if these things happen JUST BECAUSE THATS HOW IT'S SUPPOSED TO HAPPEN. "Well of course, a sperm and an egg make a baby, what else are they supposed to do". But this is inconsistent and hypocritical.

I tell you that if there were a universe in which babies popped in and out of existence and human population increased not by sexual intercourse (a process which has several steps), but by spontaneous generation of babies out of thin air, atheists would still not believe in the supernatural. Rather, in such a universe, they'd want babies to come about in a different, less random way for them to be convinced of God. I hope I'm making sense.

BECAUSE biology has laws and predictable steps (technically chemistry), atheists think that them attributing these laws and their consequences to the laws themselves will solve the issue of the existence of God. But that's a cop out. If there were no constants in physics and chemistry, and things popped in and out of existence, atheists would claim that spontaneous generation was "JUST HOW THINGS ARE" and would require some orderdness in the laws of biochemistry to be convinced of God.