First off, leave if you havent played. this is going to all be spoilers for the game, and I am not even going to pretend like you can read parts without being spoiled.
I have been trying to figure out the best way to tell people about the lore of Elden Ring, and I think I am going with this for now since this is one of the biggest community hang outs for Elden Ring. I am not the most knowledgable person on the lore of Elden Ring, and I dont know everything for certain, but I also have a perspective in the lore that I think a lot of people who talk about the lore dont have. from what I have seen, there are two major paths to the lore exploration: gods arent real, and gods are real. if you are curious about this, I can explain more in a comment, but it isnt the actual lore of Elden Ring, so it will not get it own post. to simplify the two stances, those who think the gods arent real make them too ethereal and more western sky daddys while the gods are real crowd think they are more direct and capable than they really are, sometimes being the direct cause of events (which some are, but only specific gods).
I need a starting point for explaining the lore, and I decided to start with the easiest and most relatively agreed upon area of spirits, mostly because I think starting with Torrent, the first character we meet, is the best way to start this journey. my posts will be, going forward, structured with a paragraph explaining the last posts incorrect or plausable alternatives to what I presented, the topic, the main subjects, then actually exploring them, theories because of them, and ending with either a sneak preview of the next topic or asking what you want to know next. why this format? because I need to build to more controversial stuff to explain why its controversial and why I am either correct or more likely to be correct if there is no answer in game. I will reject any topics that are controversial such as the Gloam Eyed Queen, or that people are generally wrong about (im not sacrificing this post with an example) until I have the proper build up, so be aware.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
SPIRITS
starting with spirits, and specifically Torrent, what are spirits? and what are Spectral Steeds? The answer is, unfortunately, we dont know exactly. not satisfying, but there are things we do know.
first, Torrent is a Spectral Steed, something that isnt quite a spirit, isnt quite a spirit ash, and isnt quite alive. The only thing in the game that is similar are the Ancestral Spirits, beings who are not quite dead, but not alive either, though their spirits are divorced from their bodies while Torrents seems to be his body. Torrent is also summoned via a Whistle, while most other spirits are summoned via literal or metaphorical bells, and Ancestral Spirits have some kind of relation to purity (water, fire, chanting poems, etc).
so, what does that make a Spectal Steed? it is a tangible spirit that cannot be called a spirit due to religious reasons by the Erdtree faithful, they were more common in the past, and there are at least 2 we know of: Torrent and Miquellas Spectral Steed.
"A smaller version of the solemn gold armour that adorns the warhorses of the Tree Sentinels who serve the Erdtree. One of several liveries once prepared for spectral steeds, which allos Torrent, through grace, to change his appearance." -Tree Sentinel Spectral Steed Attire
"A smaller version of the sable attire used to adorn and conceal the warhorses of the Nights Cavalry. One of several liveries once prepared for spectral steeds, [...]" Funeral Night Spectral Steed Attire
"the richly ornamented white silver armour of the Carian Royal line is a one-of-a-kind item made for a certain spectral steed, once forged in the lands of the Three Sisters." -Silver of Caria Spectral Steed Attire
why cant they be called spirits horses, as the community often does? well, we need to talk about Erdtree Burial, Ancestral Spirits, and the Rune of Death, though I will only touch on the last.
Ancestral Spirits and the Ancestral Worshippers are a faction that are memed about, usually cause you have a dozen arrows sticking out of your head assuming you survived. the Ancestral Worshippers worship the antler like horns of the Ancestral Spirits, either growing them themselves or decorating themselves with those horns to venerate the Ancestral Spirits and keep them alive despite their death. more on that later.
we can fight an Ancestral Spirit and the king of the Ancestral Spirits, the Ancestor Spirit and Regal Ancestor Spirit respectively. in addition, several of the Ancestral Follower Shamans carry an Ancestral Infants Head, an item we, ourselves, can obtain. these beings are all enemies of the Erdtree, especially the Regal Ancestor Spirit, as they have found a way around death that the Erdtree does not approve of.
"Ancetral Spirits exist as a phenomenon beyond the purview of the Erdtree. Life sprouts from death, as it does from birth. such is the way of the living." -Remembrance of the Regal Ancestor
"Item cut from the horns of the Regal Ancestor Spirit. [...]. A number of new growths bud from the antler like horns of the fallen king, each glowing with light. Thus does new life grow from death, and from death, one obtains power." -Ancestral Spirits Horn
"Worn by ancestral follower shamans. Horns with buds that also shine are ideal ceremonial items for ancestral worship." -Shining Horn Headband
"Skull of a very young ancestral spirit. just think how many sproutings it might bear. use[d] to spray spirit vapor inflicting magic damage. the vapor becomes a temporary geyser which deals continuous damage to everything it touches until it disappears." -Ancestral infants Head
the Ancestral Spirits are interacted with via a specific ceremony, and clearly have a physical and spiritual body in one. the Regal Ancestor Spirit quite literally fades into nothing and returns to a physical body during its fight to change position in its arena via possessing a spirit in the arena and unpossessing (thus killing) whatever spirit it possessed previously. we can touch it, just as torrent can touch us, it can bleed, just as torrent can bleed, and it uses localized spirit springs to launch itself in the air or suspend its time in the air, which torrent can use spirit springs to get vertical height even if he cant summon them like the Ancestor Spirits can.
this means that Torrent and the Spectral Steeds are probably decendants of the Ancestral Spirits, or may even be Ancestral Spirits who arent dead yet. My opinion is the former, since Torrents horns are 4 horns that have no buds and dont glow, while even the infants head has 2 glowing buds before it even has horns, but I simply dont know.
so what makes Ancestral Spirits heretical, but not spectral steeds who were brought into the army as late as the shattering wars midpoint? well, thats why I need to touch on the Rune of Death and Erdtree burial.
The Elden Ring contains the power to control how the world functions so long as that concept is part of the Elden Ring. it can be modified and have pieces pulled out, such as the Rune of Death.
"The forbidden shadow, plucked from the Golden Order upon its creation..." -Enia on burning the Erdtree
Marika had decided that those who serve her should not die. 'but OP, it says "YOU DIED" every time I die, and I kill a lot of things!' You are half correct. technically, nobody dies under the Erdtrees watch, yet death is still a thing in the Lands between. this is where Erdtree Burial comes in.
generally you are born, you live a life, and you die, and your spirit and body remain as one unless someone does something with it (more on this later). Marika, after removing the Rune of Death and entrusting it to someone, needed something to solve the issue of aging. this resulted in Erdtree burial where ones body (and soul) are set to rest in the roots of the Erdtree (maybe), where the body decomposes and the Erdtree takes their soul to reincarnate them... somehow.
its unclear exactly how reincarnation works, but essentially Erdtree burial allowed people to return forever more, probably through rebirth, meaning people having insane lifespans probably comes from this fact. there are people who lived through Marikas ascension, and while the timeline is confusing, that was at minimum an Age ago, or 1000 years as we hear an age refered to every time its said, of which the Shattering War was an Age, so 1000 years minimum, likely more. in anycase, people were around during that time, and are still around to this day, grace being the thing that is reviving them via the Erdtree and Erdtree burial practices, though its not confirmed who is in game if any of the characters we meet are from this early era, though it is likely Godfrey is one of these people, as well as his Crucible Knights.
They also needed to protect these places since it wasnt an instant transfer of the soul, as there were guardians required for these, such as Gravekeepers (duelists who were removed from the Colliseums) and the Erdtree Burial Watchdogs with their minions of Imps. This is the proper way to be reborn beneath the Erdtree and in the host of the Golden Order, which is why the Ancestral Spirits are heretical and why they work outside the purview of the Erdtree.
"The Symbol of an underground gravekeepers station." -Rotten Gravekeepers Cloak
"Stone greatsword wielded by Erdtree Burial Watchdogs. Though decorated with the watchman's eye, the pupil was taken by graverobbers and is now hollow, leaving this sword a mere lump of stone.*" -*Watchdogs Greatsword
"Large stone staff embedded with glintstone. Wielded by Erdtree Burial Watchdogs who protect catacombs. The Watchdogs, battered and broken over their lengthy tenure, rule the catacombs and are even said to command the imps." -Watchdogs Staff
so, if this is how people are supposed to be reborn, what are spirit ashes? Why would people let these things exist if reincarnation through the Erdtree is the proper method?
That is... complicated. it being complicated is why I started with the easier Ancestral Spirits as well, as they are much simpler.
-----------------------------------------------------
The Callers of Spirits, and the Death of the Demigods
so, I need to establish something really really important: we dont kill the second demigod, or even the third if you count Ranni. Godwyn was the FIRST DEMIGOD TO DIE, as we all know, which made Those Who Live in Death as the Golden Order knows them, but he wasnt the only one to die, and especially not that night.
while I will go into more details about the Night of Black Knives multiple times in parts for Great Runes, the Carians, Ranni, Godwyn, the Numen, and probably others, I need to clarify something about it now: Godwyn was not the only demigod to die that day, he was the only acknowledged demigod to die that day.
"... the mausoleum prowls. cradling the soulless demigod. O Marika, Queen Eternal. [He] is your unwanted child" -Church of Pilgrimage Spirit (slightly mistranslated, English needed a gender japanese did not need for the bastard child)
"the mausoleum is where teh bodies of soulless demigods are lain to rest, and these soldiers followed their masters into Death by severing their own heads from their bodies." -Mausoleum Soldier Ashes
"Lhutel sacrificed her life so that in Death she could continue to protect a soulless demigod until their revival, earning her the hero's honour of Erdtree Burial." -Lhutel the Headless
spirits have more or less always been around, but they were relatively rare or mostly idle inside their bodies. Tibia Mariners were the ones who went around collecting the dead spirits and leading them... somewhere, Helphen probably, since Helphen is related to the mariners, the Helphen Steeple was made to commemorate and represent the Helphen tree (steeple is a representation of a tree, dont worry about it right now), and really spirits only came out when really distressed or when called upon by Spirit Callers like the Spirit Caller snails and Roderika. long story short, as this is more of a Those Who Live in Death thing, Spirits are rare occurances that dont really do much.
Then Godwyn was slain using a portion of a portion of a portion of the Rune of Death embedded into his body which caused his soul (and only his soul) to die, but his body to live. Godwyn is a seperate topic, but his burial into the roots of the Erdtree beneath the trunk (supposedly) resulted in deathroot spreading and Spirits being able to reclaim their bodies as Those Who Live in Death.
Those Who Live in Death ARE NOT spirits, but spirits ARE Those Who Live in Death, much like how a square is a rectangle but a rectangle is not a square. so why bring up the soulless demigods? because the soulless demigods spirits were slain and cannot reincarnate in the traditional sense of Erdtree Burial or even normal burial methods that Mariners would collect the souls of later. this is important because the story of Those Who Live in Death is a different topic I have to address here.
Godwyn, the dead demigods of the night of Black Knives, and anyone killed by a black knife before the Rune of Deaths second sealing within the flesh of Maliketh cannot ressurect by any means, nor can they die. while Spirits existed before this point, possessing ones body could not happen, instead manifesting as the Mausoleum Soldiers, Footsoldiers, and Knights do as tangible spirits. We know this because Mariners are Spirit Callers, Spirit Caller Snails exist and are found in places the Erdtree does not touch or cannot stand, and Spirit Callers like Roderika seem to have little to do with the Erdtree and somewhat defy it without opposing it.
Spirit Callers are also... not enemies of the Erdtree. We know this because Mausoleum Soldiers and Knights can still get an Erdtree burial, despite it being purely ceremonial and not functional because, well, they are literally walking around elsewhere like Lhutel. it is very likely that Tibia Mariners secretly handle surface burials and such for the Erdtree, seen as they are in some kind of sensitive areas, but Deathbirds and Deathrite Birds are enemies of the Erdtree since they practice a different kind of burial practice to put souls to rest (related to Helphen, dont ask yet).
Roderika is also a Spirit Caller, since she can speak to the spirits via Grave Glovewart and Ghost Glovewart, and is taught by Hewg who knew a Spirit Caller who could tune spirits. we are not getting into the implications that Roderika looks kinda like Marika, that Hewg literally only talks about Marika and Roderika, and Marika possibly being a Spirit Caller. That is for the post I do about the family tree, which will take a while since the bush is really entangled and hard to think about.
what you do need to know is that Spirit Ashes are a practice held by the Hornsent (to some extent via revered spirit ashes being Tutelary Deities, or spirits that kept homes/land in shape), the Erdtree (as spirit ashes are both buried and used to some extent as seen by the Banished Knights and their commanders), the Deathrite Birds, and some others. Spirits manifesting to protect, uphold, or otherwise keep a place or person safe is not a bad practice even to the Erdtree and the Golden Order.
That is why Spirits are not seen as repulsive by the Golden Order, but Those Who Live in Death are seen as vile. it is most clearly spelled out in the Grave and Ghost Glovewarts.
"the art of strengthinging ashes is known as spirit tuning. only a spirit tuner may perform this deed." -Grave Glovewart (1)
"Spirit tuning is not merely the simple act of imbuing strength. it is an art that lies somewhere between tuning an instrument and conducting a conversation, leaving both parties enriched." -Grave Glovewart (2-9)
"ashes which keep their renown even after death cannot be strengthened by merely corporeal glovewart." -Ghost Glovewart (1-9)
"Since times of old, large glovewarts were used to comfort heroic spirits. givien in tribute to those who died the most glorious of deaths, in hope their stories would become legend." -Great Grave Glovewart/Great Ghost Glovewart
this means that spirits we pick up without names are people who died whose stories were not remembered or whose stories havent yet become a mainstream legend like king arthur or something. meanwhile, those who have renown like the named ashes such as Lhutel need the Ghost Glovewart instead, since their tales are still widely enough known to the Lands between. this certainly doesnt have any dire consequences to the lore (Caarman).
regardless, there is a bit of an issue with this whole set up, as well as a small lie I told: Farum Azula has the living dead before Those Who Live in Death.
This is a problem for the Ancient Dragons, as they had a whole mausoleum dedicated to a dragon (unspecified, but considering that Placidusax seemed to rule from there, there is a good chance its his god), and beastmen were enshrined there all over the place. now, imagine this: a guy with the Rune of Death shows up (for reasons I will get into in either Malikeths post or the Godskin post), vibes for a bit, gets attacked and has part of his rune stolen, freaks out, and suddenly the dead start waking up and vibing, what do you do?
I cannot think of any of the undead Beastmen being near living beastmen besides the ones that are hung... and I wonder why they were hung.
--------------------------------------------------
The Tarnished Spirit Caller
so, we know that the Spirits are quite strange in Elden Ring, that they cant really leave their body unless something happens to the body or the soul is called away from it by something, and that only specific people can hear spirits.
Roderika can spirit tune, Hewg refers to her as a Spirit Tuner, which seems to be a special kind of Spirit Caller. But she isnt the only tarnished who can do that. It seems that no one can really interact with the Spirits without either knowing the spirit, being a spirit caller, or revering the spirit in some way.
which begs the quesiton of why the player tarnished can understand spirits. the Church of Pilgrimage spirit, the Dragonbarrow spirit, the spirit in the ashen capital, and so many others... how can we hear them? I can already hear people saying "its the best way to explain the lore!", and I dont disagree, thats what I thought until I realized that the Tarnished we play as also understands fingers, but thats for when we talk about fingers.
you see, the spirits we talk to could be explained away as just a way to learn lore, or that anyone can talk to spirits and only special Spirit Tuners (who are somehow different than Spirit Callers like the fricken snakes and commanders and albanurics) can actually make them stronger, but that isnt really true. First off, no one else seems to know of good portions of history or lore that certain spirits talk about, since D should know about the Deathtouched Catacombs having deathroot in it, and its his job to collect it, but he ignores a spirit talking about Deathroot in the Deathtouched Catacombs hes supposed to guard and only talks about a Mariner he is afraid to fight alone, warning us against it as well.
there is even the ghost in the Volcano Manor who DOES speak with a voice actor, meaning the other ghosts just didnt have voice actors. we hear him, but no one else does, something this ghost in particular takes offense towards since he REALLY wants Rykard dead. this means we, the Tarnished, can hear and understand the Spirits beyond just lore, but if you still dont believe me, then fine, lets get something other than a spirit in the world, and something that cant be disputed: the Chrysalids Memento.
"Faintly visible spirits try to convey somehing, but their voices cannot be heard." -Chrysalids Memento
Hewg saw in Roderikas eyes that she was a Spirit Tuner, and that she could speak with the spirits. as we spoke of in Torrents section, he is called a Spectral Steed because it is sacrilege to call him a spirit steed. the Spirit Caller Snails are all in hiding, and typically seen with a lot of Spirits, which is a form of rebirth naturally given to them that the Erdtree would be forced to despise due to Erdtree Burial and the similarities to Ancestral Spirits. Roderika is a Spirit Caller, one who inherited the traits strongly enough for Hewg to recognize and knowlegeable enough despite not being one himself to guide her as a Spirit Tuner, the approved version of Spirit Calling without a bell, and she helps us upgrade spirit ashes via spirit tuning.
but we speak to several spirits, know that some are trying to speak, see them all over the place (which, presumably, is what makes Mausoleum guards so terrifying, they kill you without you even knowing where they are), but we are not strong enough to actually tune the spirits ourselves, or even summon them without a bell. the Player Tarnished is related to a spirit caller, which is important for several whacky theories I will get into later in this series, but it is important for anyone who looks at the lore of Elden Ring.
the Tarnished is a lot more interesting and a lot more of a character than people realize. finding the Player Tarnisheds vague origin and relations will be important to uncovering the truth of Elden Rings past and message, even if it is open ended enough to allow us to picture anything we want.
----------------------------------------------------------------
theories of mine
spirits, spirit calculus (which is a topic better explained when talking about Rauh), spirit ashes, spectral steeds, and Those Who Live in Death are a strange basis that need to be understood to actually understand certain aspects of the lore. Tibia Mariners are some of the oldest caretakers of spirits, predating the Erdtree and probably even Helphen, and maybe even earlier than that, but its hard to know.
as this is without a lot of the context needed, there is really only one theory I can share, since its context is mostly here already. the renowned spirits, the ones with names, are more important to the story than people realize. the Stormhawk King, for whom we cannot use and can give to Nepheli Loux, is a direly important character to the story, one I think some people partially noticed without actually noticing, like Nameless Singer in her video about Nightreigns lore being more important to Elden Rings lore than people realize.
I will be using Night Reign for certain lore aspects, but those come later, mostly in relation to the god: the Night, the Nox, the Carians, the Astrologers, and Witches, but it is important to know that the Birdman had his people wiped out and unable to fly like they used to. the Stormhawks, similarly, have lost the Storm they are most known for, are found in the Mountaintops of the giants, their king was slain, and Deenh supported his allies with a cry that helped his allies (like a certain other birdman whose cry aides his allies).
"Spirit of a fierce hawk that faithfully rendered lifelong service to the old king of stormviel long ago, when the true storm raged. its cries embolden its fellows in battle, and the tempestuous winds that encircle it shred through foes." -Stormhawk Deenh
"Ashes of a hawk revered by all others as sovereign back in the days when Stormveils winds still raged like no other. this ancient monarch is proud however, refusing to answer anyones summons." -The Stormhawk King
be prepared for future posts, not all, but ones related to the Night, the Scadulands, and the Nox to include a lot of Nightreign lore.
----------------------------------------------
what do you think? how accurate is this so far? what questions do you have?
I am not perfect, and while I know a decent amount, there are somethings that I will say that go against community opinion. I have reasons for saying what I do, though, as well as evidence to back up my claim more than just item descriptions or enviornmental story telling. I take into account enemy placement, item locations, and even story telling practices to understand certain aspects of the story of Elden Ring, such as the fact George and Miyazaki worked on it together, so you need to account for BOTH writers, not just one or the other.
I also take into account something I dont think many people do unless they talk about specifically Marika, Ranni, and Miquella for some reason: motivation. im not talking overall motivation, im talking specific events, like Radhan attacking the capital of Lyndell (and oh, I have a lot to talk about that, but Radhan is a long ways out, since I need to establish a lot to get there), since its a lot more complicated than people understand when they take into account the timeline and the actions going on at each point in it.
finally, what should I cover next: Elden Lord Placidusax; the Demihumans; the Land of Lakes; distant lands like the land of Reeds; the Hornsent and their culture.
and if you are curious about the series title name, its because Hewg is the key to understanding the Tarnshed we play as role in the story of Elden Ring.