r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jan 12 '24

Video What's the point of playing Elden Ring when your RL 300 friend plays it for you?

15 Upvotes

These guys are the reason you can't bring a "cute" build into invasions and expect to win a fair amount.


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jul 02 '24

Discussion My Thoughts on the DLC: "FromSoft, please learn from this." Spoiler

0 Upvotes

People have valid criticisms, and why shouldn't they? This DLC took almost 2 1/2 years to come out. It should have been their best work yet, but sadly there's a lot wrong with it. Howvever, I'll highlight the positives first:

  1. The new weapons are quite powerful. You've got the light greatswords which can output just as much damage as regular greatswords, potentially even more with the right talismans. Milady (hate that name though) is especially noteworthy since it is the only one that can be infused with different ashes of war, and there are so many that work incredibly well with it (Wing Stance is pretty much its signature AoW, but you could use RotM for a decent dodge and counterattack, Swords Dance can combo with its moveset well, etc). Beast Claws have rather erratic swings which makes them hard to predict and are excellent for status builds, but the king of status builds is now definitely the Backhand Blades (with access to BS and SS AoWs, you have insane offensive and mobile capabilities so your opponent has to essentially chase after you). But I think the perfumer bottles have to be the apex of the new weapons. Pure elemental damage (except one), an absolutely busted AoW in RS which can nuke bosses, and the Madness, Chilling, and Poison bottles have status buildup. So you have a new weapon type that is boosted by the scorpion charms, the perfumer talisman, the physik (with the right tears), and even with the Rakshasa Armor and spell buffs. You can essentially sh*t out damage for minimal FP costs if you point RS at the ground regardless of optimization. The new weapons for sure will get nerfed; they're just THAT good.

  2. Many of the bosses are incredible. There's a reason they put a lot of them in the trailers. The ones of exceptional note have to be Rellana, Dancing Lion, Midra, and most of all: Messmer. The hype surrounding the bosses was unreal, and DAMN did they deliver on them.

  • Rellana's fight feels like a beautiful dance (her OST is even in 3/4 time like the Dancer in DS3, which is part of what makes reading her so hard; most bosses' OSTs are in 4/4 time) and we actually get to use her dual-wielded weapons like Pontiff Sulyvahn did in his boss fight.

  • The Dancing Lion was amazing as well. We all knew there would be a 2nd phase, but we didn't expect that it could change the elements it wielded in the fight. In order to beat that fight, you had to be able to adapt to the different elemental forms it used. And the remembrance giving such a great talisman is icing on the cake (you get so many storm AoWs so early in the game, and now they all just got better, particularly Storm Blade).

  • Then we've got Midra. A boss rich with frenzied flame lore (one of the most mysterious aspects of the main game we got fragments of lore on) and frenzied flame. Even though his arena is small, the true beginning of the boss fight makes that arena so memorable with the study being on fire with frenzied flame. And Midra's movements look incredible; he reminds me a lot of the ethereal lady with the basket on her head in Sekiro you could fight as a miniboss. Not to mention that the visceral feeling the cutscene elicits when he grabs the sword that's impaled in him and you already know what he's about to do but you can't look away (thank god the screen went to black during that part).

  • Finally, we've got Messmer the Impaler, the long forgotten and shunned son of Marika who served as the main weapon for the invasion on the Land of Shadow. Such a nuanced character. He both loves and despises his mother (moreso the latter), both his cutscenes are incredible (probably the best Elden Ring cutscenes aside from both of Malenia's, especially the mid-fight one: him ripping out his eye to release the base serpent is him resorting to drastic measures in an attempt to finish us off, much like Lady Maria using Cainhurst blood techniques in BB, Sister Friede's blackflame in DS3, and even Malenia herself with her scarlet rot). He lived up to the hype surrounding him for sure.

Now, for the negatives:

  1. There aren't enough of the new weapons to justify their existence as standalone categories. The only new type we can't put into another category is the perfume bottles (for obvious reasons). In the entirety of the DLC, we got 3 light greatswords (only 1 infusable), 3 Great Katanas (only 1 infusable), 3 Beast Claws (only 1 infusable), 2 Dryleaf Arts, 5 perfume bottles (which is more than the previous categories but not by much), 6 Throwing Weapons (which are all over the place in the equipment menu), 3 Reverse-hand Swords, and 2 Thrusting Shields. And don't even get me started on the new AoWs that are unique to those weapons; Wing Stance can only be put on the Milady, nothing else! With the dlc taking 2 1/2 years to make since the base game came out, there was so much they could have done to really expand these new weapon categories into ones that were just as large as the base game ones (WS could have been infusable on all greatswords but had a slightly slower moveset for regular greatswords, the 2 Beast Claw AoWs could have been put on Fist weapons with the exception of ones that could thrust, etc.). But it feels like they just made these new weapon categories to advertise for the release of the dlc without fully fleshing out weapons for each category. If you totaled up all the weapons in those new categories, I bet it would still be less weapons than what we have for greatswords in the main game. That's a glaring issue.

  2. Despite it being an open world, many of the areas of the DLC are devoid of anything worth getting. Just look at the southern half of the DLC map. The Cerulean Coast feels like a pit stop on the way to the Fissure, Charo's Hidden Grove has a whole lot of NOTHING, and the Jagged Peak is pretty much a stretched-out path on the way to Bayle with not much else. The 2 Finger Ruins have barely anything in them, the Hinterlands just have Marika's hair, and the Abyssal Woods is a vast majority of either nothing or some of the most frustrating enemies ever made (the only 2 things of note in those woods are Midra's Manse and the church with the Frenzy Perfume Bottle, which is only useful against other players in PvP, an experience I'm sure more than HALF the fanbase doesn't partake in). I'm not saying every single nook and cranny has to have something that makes searching it worthwhile, but there's WAY TOO MANY paths that lead to absolutely NOTHING of value. It purely just wastes large amounts of our time.

  3. Many of the bosses I didn't mention above suck, in more ways than the fights themselves.

  • First, we've got the Golden Hippo in Shadow Keep. The fight would've had much more of a wow factor had there not been so many hippos elsewhere in the dlc you can run into BEFORE this fight. "But it's bigger and it has thorns!" Yeah, but it's also in an arena a little too small for it, some of the hotboxes are janky as f*ck, and we have no idea WHY it's even there in the first place. Did it just wander into the keep and decide to stay there? Quite disappointing for what could've been a unique woodland encounter to be a boss.

  • Then we've got the 2 red bears Ralva and Rugalea. These are just reskinned Runebears with additional AoEs. I'd be much more at peace with that had they not taken the EXACT SAME MODEL and just pasted it in another location. We had enough duplicate bosses in the main game (between the drake reskins, Erdtree Avatars, and all those damn Gargoyles roaming around, and the main game caves and catacombs were just pick-an-enemy-out-of-a-hat-and-fight-it-as-the-boss-with-potential-extra-steps simulators. And their rewards for killing them aren't worth the trouble, either: everyone hates fighting Runebears.

  • Dragons, but now either undead or with fire AND lightning! Once again, reskins. The first encounter with a Ghostflame Dragon and a Jagged Peak Drake was a pleasant surprise since they aren't completely the same, but then some FromSoft intern decided to add 3 more of the undesd variant and another of the jagged peak variant fighting its ex-husband. And let's not even mention the random Ancient Dragon right before Bayle. What in the world is it even doing there?!?! And why doesn't it drop anything explaining why it was there?! It's not even a drake; the Jagged Peak is a place for Bayle and his drakes, so how the hell did that one dragon get there???

  • Dual Tree Sentinels guarding Marika's hometown. Only serve as guardians to ward off intruders; they drop nothing memorable and add nothing. Random Fallingstar Beast near the Dheo Finger Ruins; probably an outlier of a meteor shower. A random Demi Human Queen on a beach in the Cerulean Coast; not noteworthy at all aside from her drop. What is it with FromSoft and repeating bosses??

  • Romina. One of the most visually stunning fights in Elden Ring. Her fight isn't even that hard. But WHO is she and WHAT is she doing guarding a random tree?? Even her remembrance, weapon and spell don't give us much lore about her to justify why she's the guardian of such an impactul location in the DLC.

  • And lastly, the greatest disappointment of a final boss of all time: Radahn + feeble, femboy simp god Miquella. We'll start with the fight. It sucks. That horizontal slash-slash combo into the criss-cross slash comes out at lightning speed, and unless you have almost perfect reflexes and dodge in juuuust the right direction (assuming you don't use Quickstep or Bloodhound's Step, and no, RotM doesn't work on it), you are going to get hit by one of the first 2 slashes and get anywhere between 1/3 - 2/3 of your health chunked away. But phase 2 is where the real bullsht occurs. Flashbangs that drop FPS so much they make Bloodborne look like it runs in 60 FPS, those ridiculous clones that can get you stunlocked into a big hit if you aren't careful, light beams after every fcking swing and sometimes random light beams in places you try to dodge to that get you rollcaught and stunlocked into a hit that spells death, and way too many AoEs that draw out the battle because there are few to no available openings to attack.

Now, for the lore:

THIS is what made Miquella abandon everything for?? Not him trying to cure his sister's affliction due to the meddling of an Outer God, not him trying to revive the soul of his older dead brother Godwyn using the Eclipse as a potential solution dismantle, not him trying to dismantle the Golden Order and replace the Erdtree with the Haligtree to create a just, kind and balanced world in the Lands Between; just a B plot of some vow between him and one of his relatives that had no buildup in the base game and felt like it was shoehorned in in the last moments of production?! And before anyone argues that it makes sense and there's no way Godwyn could have been it, FromSoft could have made it possible: we never got to find out if the Eclipse would have worked to revive Godwyn (even if his soul was put into a different body). It's not like they haven't had crazy explanations before, but all the lore we got in the main game pointed to Miquella reviving Godwyn, and instead, all we got was...that. It feels cheap. It feels rotten and unfair to the fans who were hoping for a true clash between a long lost demigod (Godwyn) and the Tarnished, or a battle between the Tarnished and the mad demigod that embarked on this long-*ss journey (Miquella). The anticipation to truly fight either Godwyn or Miquella had been in the minds of the fanbase for 2 1/2 years. When Malenia's opening cutscene plays, we get the sense that Miquella is truly someone to be feared if a great, renowned warrior like Malenia sings his praises to us and is WILLING to wage wars to help her brother in his endeavors. In one of the rare lore fragments we get from direct mentions of Miquella in the main game, Malenia mentions "he's the most fearsome Empyrean of them all." Even if there wasn't any chance of us fighting a revived Godwyn, everything pointed us to a 1v1 confrontation with Miquella, this demigod that could "shrive clean the hearts of men," potentially cure the plagues of Scarlet Rot and Deathblight, and single-handedly dismantle the corrupt Golden Order and rebuild the entire system in the Lands Between. Overall, this DLC has some great highs, but unfortunately, the lows are some of the lowest in the history of the Souls franchise.


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jul 20 '24

Shadow of the Erdtree Alright I have to say it: Fromsoft is just really bad at balance

14 Upvotes

It's been six games now: how is it that Fromsoft is STILL struggling with the basic concepts of game balance?

Obviously you can never fully balance everything, but playing through this Elden Ring DLC really reminded me of how comical their attempts at balance can often be. 9/10 of the new spells in the DLC are just not great. At all. Several of the ashes of war are in the same boat. They added a whole ass omen-style transformation, and it only lets you do a hilariously weak headbutt attack?

Then there's the design-style balancing that isn't related to raw stats. They give you a weapon that strikes enemies with a bolt of lightning to reduce their lightning resistance. What does it scale with? Arcane. Faith builds get way more incantations, but they all suck. Sorcery builds get far fewer, but they're all super good.

Rain of Fire is so, so, so terrible that I'm genuinely stuck staring at the screen wondering how a developer who is paid real world money could add this to a game. Divine Bird Feathers is in the same boat. Don't even get me started on the bugs, with many items in the DLC getting no boosts that they categorically should (like Miquella's orbital death laser getting no boost from... the Miquella incantation boosting seal. Jesus.)Here's the thing, I don't know about you guys, but I'm not going to still be playing this game when all the patches finally roll around to fix it all. Elden Ring has a replay-ability issue IMO, but even if it didn't, it's not some live service title that is designed to keep you around for several weeks and then months. My first playthrough was made worse by the fact that I'd get these weapons and spells, try to use them, and then go "oh, that was a waste of time..."

It's not like they have any real receipts to show that this scaredy-cat approach to balance is working. There's still certain things from the DLC that are hilariously busted. This has been the case in the base game and pretty much every Souls game before it. If you know you're still gonna fuck up a bunch of things, making them outrageously strong compared to the competition, why be so reserved to make things useful? You might as well focus on making everything feel viable as a baseline.


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jul 16 '24

Lore Miquella is the definition of some characters are better left alone

0 Upvotes

Base Miquella for me was the most mysterious and intriguing character Fromsoft has created. From his lore, the things he created and established that can directly and directly affect the player, you can feel his impact, narrative-wise and gameplay wise. He was "everywhere" in the base game yet we didn't get to meet him and instead we found him as an unresponsive "husk"- we were not even sure if he was dead or alive. For me, Basegame!Miquella was the perfect example of a character that was better left alone because a large part of his charm came from how mysterious and intriguing his character was. Honestly, it was nigh-impossible for Fromsoft to meet the expectations the players had for Miquella because of how he was mysteriously established he was in the base game.

Saying that, I think what disappointed the lore fans the most was that Miquella never addressed the things he was directly connected to in the base game: no Mention of Malenia aside from that "my loyal blade" remark when he was literally Malenia's world in the base game, no Haligtree mentioned, no Castle Sol/Godwyn line. If Miquella was supposed to be the central character of the DLC, players would of course expect that these things would be addressed as they were what tied him to the base game, and the root of many lore theories, and maybe even him having an active role a la Melina or something.

In hindsight, I'm glad Velka wasn't given the "spotlight" in a DLC or she might've gotten Miquella'd, too. Sadly, she is once again alone on my list of "most intriguing character Fromsoft has ever created".


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jul 19 '24

Lore Elden Ring lore feels like the writers just threw in what they thought was cool Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Anyone else get this feeling? There's just so much random stuff both in base game and DLC that doesn't get any clarification or tie into the overarching story/lore all that much. Briar Sorceries/Blood Star, the soulless demigods, Faram Azula, the Land of Reeds, demihumans, Castle Sol... we get all this stuff while not getting many answers about story-relevant characters, like Miquella, Godwyn, Melina, or Torrent.

This might be a hot take, but I'm getting tired of the constant mysteries and gaps in FromSoft lore, and Elden Ring is the biggest offender because there's just so much stuff that doesn't matter at all by the end. I like bits of worldbuilding and lore, but moderation is king and many times there's no real reason for all the obfuscation considering there are still many characters alive who saw the Lands Between in their full glory.

This design philosophy carries over to the weapons, spells, and bosses too - at least half of the spells in base game and SotE look really pretty but are either extremely niche or basically useless (Rain of Fire, Founding Rain of Stars, Rotten Butterflies, Divine Bird Feathers, anything with a long windup...). So many bosses have the barest fragments of lore explaining their existence, some of them are outright reskins, many bosses that do feel lore relevant lack Remembrances or intro cutscenes. It just reaches a point where it feels lazy, like they stuffed all of their ideas into the game.


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jun 27 '24

Discussion I think DLC is undercooked because Bandai Namco desperately wanted Q2 release

31 Upvotes

The DLC was amazing, no doubt, one of the best expansions to any game ever.

However, it does feel a bit undercooked with respect to lore, large swathes of empty area, and the fact that such huge revelations about lore are not even referred to by anyone in the base game.

I think the DLC, which already took 2 years, was rushed as Bandai Namco would've wanted it to go out in before Q2 end (June-end) for earnings purposes.

For its March earnings, Bandai reported a decline in profits, so it couldn't have delayed the DLC anymore. At least on the sales front it does look the bet paid off with 5+ million copies sold already in less than a week.


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Aug 28 '26

Discussion Dark Souls 3 is Easier Than Elden Ring with Video Evidence

40 Upvotes

Dark Souls 3 - 4 minutes

Elden Ring - 4 Hours


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jun 28 '24

Discussion DLC feels unfinished. Spoiler

200 Upvotes

I liked the DLC, I think balance wise it’s fine and the bosses are the high points of the expansion. However, I’m having a hard time accepting the lack of enemy varieties and enemies doing random stuff in the DLC. I think Miyazaki meant to say the volume, not the size, of the DLC is comparable to Limgrave (with the exception of unique bosses, of which there are far more in the DLC).

The DLC map is almost the size of the base game, but there are only a handful of new enemy types and variations introduced across the whole map. This results in some areas being either criminally empty or filled with tons of reused enemies, to the extent that it makes the recycled content in the base game feel like nothing. I swear, in every different region, there are either bloodfiends, stone birds, or shadowy peasants. And they were just... kinda there.

A lot of my favorite moments in Elden Ring were the unique encounters you come across by accident all over the map. Misbegotten clans ambushing a caravan in Weeping Peninsula, singing bats luring you into their nest in Liurnia, a village in Altus where the female inhabitants skinned all the male inhabitants, miners worshipping a falling star beast... the list goes on. I’m aware these things still exist in DLC but they’re far more rare.

To me, these are the environmental storytelling moments that are so memorable and have become so synonymous with Elden Ring. Also gameplay-wise, it allows for unique encounters as the game stages you to face multiple enemy types at once in different scenarios.


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jan 22 '25

Consort Radahn is a top 5 fromsoft boss

14 Upvotes

Just my opinion.

Now I really like the Miquella lore in the dlc, and don't mind Radahn being the final boss, so maybe that changes things. But I'm strictly going to talk about the fight gameplay and presentation-wise.

Gameplay:
I really like PCR's flow. His moves are not the most unique visually per se, but the fluidity of the animations plus their timings just feels incredibly fun to me. Plus, as time has gone on and as I've discovered new ways to deal with this moves by strafing or running, it feels even more fun to deal with them. Yes I'm kinda disappointed that jumping wasn't utilized more, but still the variety of ways you can deal with them is quite engaging. I don't feel like the light pillars are that much of a detraction and rather feel like the added precision they add to the moves make them more fun imho. And most importantly, the flow he has to his moves, for me, is only matched by Messmer in SOTE. The pace at which his moves come out, the back-and-forth, the timings to dodge, all come together to create one of the most fun and thrilling few minutes that Fromsoft has ever provided me.

Presentation:
Purely subjective but PCR's presentation is my personal favorite in the series besides Gael and Elden Beast. Firstly I love how the arena looks. The divine gate and the mangled corpses on the ground feels thematically perfect, since divine gates is where all the mess of Elden Ring's lore started proper and the corpses make you feel like both you and Miquella are fighting for a new age build on the deaths of countless people, despite both having "noble" intentions Then the 2nd phase makes it even better imho, with the sky darkening, and it getting contrasted with the glowing aura of miquella and the golden aftershow of the attacks. All coupled with the OST which is imho the best track from has put out till date. Yes, Bayle is more thrilling and Midra is cooler, but the grandness of PCR just edges it out for me personally.

These are just few reasons why I personally love this boss so much and put him alongside the likes of Messmer, Malenia, Gael and ALLMIND.


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Dec 15 '24

Elden Ring Night Reign explained by The Magic School Bus

0 Upvotes

r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jun 28 '24

Spoiler I hate the DLC ending

31 Upvotes

I hate everything about it, absolutly everything.

I hate that Radhan is back

I hate that we are killing him for no god dawm reason

I hate that we are killing Miquella for no reason

I hate that we killed Leda and she didn't even say shit about Miquella lore-wise

I hate that we don't have a choice

I hate that stupid gank fight that you randomly get one shot and the summons don't even aggro half the time

I hate that in the DLC trailer leda talks about "the beginning" where is that dialogue line? She just dies

I hate that Miquella is a very important figure, that has a lot of influence, and then absolutely nothing happens and he just dies

I hate that we fight peak Radhan and he isn't even that crazy. Base game Radhan is 10x better

I hate that he is human size now and the camera is STILL DOGSHIT

I hate the first phase

I hate the second phase

Did I mention that I hate it?

Edit: after beating my head against radhan again, I kinda like the fight actually. But they 100% have to tone down the "lightning" damage, and the visual effects, had to use 3 defensive talismans to be able to beat him solo.

I stand by all the rest I said tho


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jun 20 '24

Discussion Seeing the Full Boss fight is is more stupid 💀💀 Spoiler

0 Upvotes

What the fuck Fromsoft? That's it? That's the Final boss of the DLC? lmao

What's the fucking point of Radahn? We are Literally there, we can be Miquella's Consort King to usher his new Age Of Compassion, but Miquella assumed that we would want the Golder Order to continue 💀💀💀 Like bitch did you just assume what I want?

We literally can have the Age of Stars or Frenzied Flame ending, yet we can't have Age of Compassion because Miquella thought we were upholding The Golden Order? 💀💀💀 Sorry not sorry but Fromsoftware dropped the ball hard with this one.

Such a massive disappointment to one of the most intriguing character they have ever made 💀💀


r/eldenringdiscussion • • May 03 '25

Oh boy… I’m gonna get hated for this Spoiler

62 Upvotes

r/eldenringdiscussion • • May 19 '22

Video I THROW STONES AT FACE - SirBleedington

0 Upvotes

r/eldenringdiscussion • • Aug 20 '24

Discussion miquella's charm isn't evil

28 Upvotes

"maybe that's kind miquella's love. love for the unloved. love to banish the pain.

kindly miquella will help us forget." - Sir Moore

the charm is a kindness. it frees you from painful memories (moore), cures mental disorders like paranoia, anxiety, and depression (moore, leda), and keeps you from tendencies that lead to the destruction of yourself or others (thiollier, ansbach, hornsent). and it leaves you with your personality intact, so it isn't really brainwashing.

yes, for those like ansbach it removes free will. the free will that allows you to hurt others, like, for instance, being the lead commander of a blood murder cult. is that kind of free will really worth having in the world of elden ring?

in a world full of pain, evil, and suffering at every turn like elden ring's, miquella's charm is a far better cure for the state of the world than the flame of chaos or whatever else you might go for.


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jul 06 '24

Discussion Elden Ring wants average players to win by trading damage and split aggro Spoiler

0 Upvotes

This issue is at the core of the discussion about difficulty. DS3 wanted the average player who manages to complete the game to do so primarily by figuring out the boss moveset.

Doing that is still important in Elden Ring. But the average player that manages to complete the game is no longer meant to 100 % or even 80 % figure out the moveset of a boss. Instead, he is supposed to either trade damage with OP weapons and ashes of war and/or to use summons or co-op and split aggro to win.

Of course you CAN still beat bosses 1v1 melee solo. But doing so - for man bosses - either requires a large time investment or great skill (and/or a lot of souls experience), all of which the average player is not expected to have.


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jun 29 '24

Cry i feel so empty Spoiler

0 Upvotes

elden ring is my favorite game of all time i have over 5,600 hours on this game (ik im a loser 🥲) and im primarily a pvp player but ive still beaten the game over 40 times. ive been looking forward to the dlc for months now and it just wasn't what i was expecting i feel like it was rushed and there were hardly any cutscenes and i guess the story just doesn't feel right ending that way (and there was no choice to side with miquella which i think is super sad and it seemed like they cut an alternate ending like this last second but i made another post in this subreddit about that) when i watched that dlc ending cutscene for the first time it was so disappointing and so was the final boss being radahn. knowing this is probably the end of the story for the elden ring universe and we likely wont get a sequel or another dlc is just so sad to me. its like there's nothing more to be hyped about or look forward to and it just didn't have the perfect ending i wanted it to. 😔


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Aug 29 '24

Discussion Is it just me or is the complaint about delayed attacks just lazy and illogical?

18 Upvotes

There are plenty of attacks that can be annoying and difficult to deal with, we all know this but to say that delayed attacks are somehow a problem is crazy. It’s like people want to be able to just panic roll their way through the game with little to no need to take the time to learn a boss fight. If it’s really that hard for you, just pick up a shield dude. They’re in the game for a reason or use a summon to pull agro. You can’t complain about the difficulty of something if you’re going to deliberately ignore so many tools and mechanics in the game that are there to help you with the very things that you are struggling with. This annoys the piss out of me.


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jul 23 '24

Discussion Lack of depth in Elden ring

1 Upvotes

Am I just missing the depth when interacting with Elden ring bosses?

I love most of them, but I personally think there is a lack of interaction during the fight, in addition to the cutscenes... for example, Romina, the saint of Broto from the DLC. She doesn't even say a single sentence, it could just be a "bloom in the scarlet rot..." that would make the fight deeper, but that doesn't happen

just like Radahn not saying anything (and don't get me started on how controlled he was), I miss something like Lothric talking to Lorian during the battle, I think this adds a lot of depth to the fight, it doesn't just seem like something mechanical, but rather a real interaction between two extremely powerful beings


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jul 22 '25

New Honest Bow build gets rid of griefers 😍

0 Upvotes

These people were standing there when I invaded going through the game griefing ME😡 So I had to show them the honest new Bow build that people have been cooking up lately 😩


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Aug 27 '26

Video Message to all blues

0 Upvotes

r/eldenringdiscussion • • May 22 '25

Why are PvPers “sweats” while PvEers are the “casuals”

12 Upvotes

Everytime I go into a discussion on Co-op vs PvP, I see the discussion almost immediately devolve into PvEers calling PvPErs “sweats”, “tryhards”, and actual murderers. Why? PvP/PvE aren’t exclusively casual or competitive. Speedrunners try to kill a boss or do challenge runs and it’s cool and fun, but the second an invader shows up in a game, suddenly it’s EVO? People can’t invade for fun for a little bit after work/school? It’s usually the Gankers that are sweating like crazy, mashing AoWs like their life actually depends on it. Hosts will sit on top of impossible-to-get-to places to farm reds. But it’s the Bad Red Man that’s a tryhard? Why? Yeah there’s sweaty reds, but generalizing every invader into that tier is just stupid imo


r/eldenringdiscussion • • Jun 21 '26

Meme Every conversation I have when I ask about Total Attack Power

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/eldenringdiscussion • • Aug 13 '24

Discussion Promised Consort is the pinnacle of Elden Ring boss design Spoiler

0 Upvotes

And by that, I mean that it's the extreme logical endpoint of many of Elden Ring's design choices.

It's not the first boss to force players to use certain builds, it's just far more egregious than the others. Malenia practically required frost pots and/or Bloodhound's Step to survive and many of the base game final bosses were immune/resistant to status effects and Holy damage. Some builds were insanely underpowered for the amount of time and Souls you had to pour into building them.

Miquella also isn't the only boss to teleport around and do massively flashy attacks. Romina is off the ground for half the fight, often forcing you to spend precious stamina chasing her. Maliketh bounces from pillar to pillar with his only saving grace being the item to parry him. Placidusax is better than some, but you still spend over half the fight just running to get in range of him. Fire Giant's flashy attacks would cover massive areas of the battlefield with little warning to dodge.

And finally, the messy lore. Argue about Godwyn's death all you like, but the fact that they set up a connection between Miquella and Godwyn in the base game and then didn't even so much as drop one line explaining it felt lazy. And maybe I'm just cynical, but seeing how patchwork and full of holes this lore was makes me look back at all the other unanswered questions and lore tidbits with skepticism. Stuff like the Gloam-eyed Queen, Godskins, Elemer of the Briar/the Blood Star, and the mummified giants of Nokstella that forged the Fingerslayer Blade. Were they really well thought out to make us ask questions? Or did they just throw half-complete bits of lore from the writer's notebooks at the game without bothering to finish them, knowing that players would try to fill in the blanks?

Regardless, the final boss of SotE just feels like the logical extreme of many of Elden Ring's existing flaws. As somebody who used to defend FromSoft at every turn, I'm just left with a sour taste in my mouth now.