r/editors • • 16h ago

Sunday Reel Review

1 Upvotes

This alternates Sundays with our "Reel Review."

## Would you like feedback on your reel? This is the place to do it!

**An essential point to remember**: A reel won't secure you a job any more than a business card or website will. While it might be necessary, it is not the primary means of obtaining work.

**You gain employment through a network you develop,** not via any online job site. Building a network takes time, which is advantageous, as it allows you to learn the field.

## Rules

* **Rule 1**: Submit your reel *and its running time* as a top-level comment (meaning you reply to this post directly)

* **Rule 2**: *Specify your professional experience in years* (paying taxes = years as a pro, novice).

* **Rule 3**: Explain the reason/direction behind posting your reel. Are you new? Have you been working with clients for a decade? Give us clear direction of what you want.

* **Rule 4**: You must review two other reels. **TWO**. You have five days to complete this task, responding to two different reels. **Then** edit the comment where you post your reel: and put and put the two user names.

**Acceptable platforms for posting**: Your Vimeo site or an unlisted YouTube link. If we discover a link to a channel or a video with 10k views, be aware that this thread is not intended for such content.

The moderation team will be monitoring this, and we are trying to encourage the community (that's you) to offer assistance. That's why providing two reviews is crucial.

Lastly, as someone who evaluates people's reels: If numerous motion graphics are present, I expect you to either be capable of creating them and/or offering it as a service. If color grading is a skill and you transition from Log to finished grade, that's a definite red flag.

​

***Copy/paste this section:***

* Reel Link: (don't forget the running time )

* Experience:

* Direction:

* Two reels I reviewed:


r/editors • • 4h ago Bravo

Open Source tool promo šŸ†“ Exhume - Bring FCP7 projects back from the dead

14 Upvotes

Hi All,

I've got a free and open source tool that allows you to open .fcp files without needing FCP7 installed. There is an online tool and an offline tool if you need security. Source code as well.

https://exhume.app/

If you have an issue with a project or think there should be more sequences to access, DM me or use the contact from to send me the project and I'll see what I can do.

Have fun exhuming those old projects!


r/editors • • 5h ago

Technical LG 6K vs Dell U3225QE vs ASUS OLED vs Samsung 5K — Which is best for professional editing with a MacBook Pro M4 Pro?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm looking for a professional monitor for video editing in Premiere Pro, After Effects, and Photoshop, using a MacBook Pro M4 Pro.

I'm currently trying to decide between these models:

  • LG UltraFine Evo 6K 32U990A

  • Dell UltraSharp U3225QE

  • ASUS ProArt OLED PA329CDV

  • Samsung ViewFinity S9 5K

My main priorities are excellent sharpness, color accuracy, good screen uniformity, and overall image quality as close as possible to my MacBook Pro's built-in display.

Based on your professional experience, which of these monitors would you choose?

Are there any models you would avoid due to issues with screen uniformity, calibration, reliability, or long-term performance?

I'd really appreciate any advice, especially from people who use these monitors professionally for video editing, color grading, or graphic design.

Thanks in advance!


r/editors • • 7h ago

Career Moral Conundrum: Received an offer for a Generative AI role.

8 Upvotes

I hate generative AI. For all the reasons everyone here presumably does as well.

After a year of barely paying rent and groceries, with freelance work (with a decently to strong portfolio including some television commercials), I received an offer for a company I hate that wants me to make AI slop for them and analyze it....to basically replace my job in the future. This was 7 months ago and I rejected it.

I received this offer again two weeks ago. I'm taking a look at my bank account and seeing negative money.

No comment on this post, if it even gets any, is likely going to influence my decision on whether to take this job or not, but I'm writing this up to show the strange ethical dilemma editors are currently in. No it's not the end of the world, or in perspective that big of a deal, but these companies would rather spend money racing each other to build shitty tech out of fear of being behind in this shitty AI race.


r/editors • • 9h ago

Open Source tool promo šŸ†“ Final(ish): a free, open-source Frame.io client for Android (unofficial)

1 Upvotes

Frame.io has apps for iPhone and iPad, but nothing for Android, so on an Android phone client review means the mobile website. I posted Final(ish) in October's Open Source thread; today is Free For All Day, so here it is properly.

What it does

  • Browse accounts, workspaces, projects, folders, version stacks and collections

  • Frame-accurate playback with timecode, speed, loop, real resolutions, aspect masks (2.39, 1.85, 4:5, 9:16…) and safe guides

  • Time-coded and range comments, on-frame drawings, mark as done, comment markers on the timeline

  • Status, rating and custom metadata fields; compare two versions side by side or with a wipe

  • Share links with all the settings, and next.frame.io / f.io links open straight in the app

  • Background, resumable uploads (also from the Android share sheet)

  • Offline: saved files, cached browsing, comments that sync later

  • Notifications for new comments, mentions and opened links, without any server of mine in the middle

  • Phones and tablets, works on every Frame.io plan including Free

There's a demo mode, so you can try it without an account.

What it can't do (yet): it uses the public Frame.io V4 API, which doesn't allow writing replies or @mentions, doesn't open review links from accounts you're not a member of (those open in the browser) and doesn't give media to the Viewer role. Legacy V3 accounts don't work. Company/Enterprise Adobe IDs may be blocked until Adobe reviews the app; personal Adobe IDs work.

Honest notes: it's unofficial and not affiliated with Adobe or Frame.io. It's AI-assisted: most of the code was written with Claude Code under my direction, with unit and screenshot tests on every push and testing on real phones. Free, no ads, no tracking, GPLv3.

Bugs: shake the phone in the app, or open an issue on GitHub. I'd especially like to hear from people who review with clients every day: what do you do on the phone that this doesn't cover?


r/editors • • 11h ago

Other How do you all hold your tongue when a client is not respectful of your time but you just need the check?

6 Upvotes

I recently did some work for a new corporate client. The communication and timing was definitely chaotic, but the pay was very good for what I actually did. Overall, I’m not in a place to reject any work right now. I’m taking other part-time work outside of the industry just to make ends meet, so any well-paying gigs within the industry I am immediately jumping on.

In the past, while maintaining professionalism and respect, I got to a point where I felt comfortable advocating for myself when necessary. This usually served me well, though it did bite me in the ass with one client who I recently found out blacklisted me after I adamantly pursued their accounting department about my invoice; they wound up paying me almost FOUR MONTHS LATE.

Anyway, I recently worked for this new client. They contacted me Friday asking me if I could work on a video over the weekend. Sure! Of course! I need the money and I’m happy to shift some plans to make it happen. The client says great let’s do it! She messages me more info and shares me on some relevant docs to get started. I follow up and say I need specific info about timeline, rate (my previous rate with them won’t apply to this work since it was a project rate) and physical logistics for getting a drive sent to me. She’s been completely radio silent since Friday night. I followed up twice yesterday, in writing and with a voicemail, asking for clarity on the plan so that I can schedule my weekend accordingly.

I have a strong feeling she’ll follow up tomorrow morning saying oh sorry stuff came up but yes we still need this video super fast! And we’ll figure out the details from there. I don’t even know what I’m asking here. I just find the ghosting so unprofessional and rude, when I was immediately communicative and down do adjust my plans to work for them. And she wasn’t the best communicator (at all, in fact she was pretty awful) when I worked with them the first time. I knew to expect this on some level, but it still feels like such a slap in the face. I’ll just have to grin and bear it (unless the ask is completely insane when we get into logistics this week). But if/when she gets back to me and says oh sorry I was busy, let’s proceed - I so badly want to tell her that I’d really appreciate some level of communication from her when she starts a conversation like that and that it felt disrespectful of my time. But I’m also skiddish from being blacklisted by this other company. Idk, this is mostly just a vent post so thank you for even reading this far if you have haha. I am seriously jaded by this field and am hoping to move into something different and more stable in time. But I have to take the work that comes in the meantime unfortunately.


r/editors • • 14h ago

Technical Multicam Audio Sync Mess Without Timecode

5 Upvotes

Hey! I'm working on a project where the audio files apparently don't have timecode. When I try syncing everything using Premiere's multicam feature, I end up with a bunch of audio clips stacked on top of each other, and it's becoming a mess trying to figure out how to sync everything properly.

What's the best way to approach this? How would you recommend handling audio sync in this situation? Should I just report to the team and let them know I'll be using camera's audio?


r/editors • • 1d ago

Technical HELP ! Trying to export a Protools AAF file from DVR and it's extremely large (188Go)

3 Upvotes

Hello, kind people of Reddit !

I'm about to start editing a multi-cam project in DVR. My sound engineer wanted to check everything would work fine when exporting an AAF file from DVR and importing it to Protools. And he was right to check because it does not work fine. DVR is generating HUGE files (188Gb) and we don't understand why

For context, I'm working with DVR Studio 21 on a MacBook Pro M1 (2020). Apple M1 processor, CPU 8 core ; GPU 8 core. RAM 8Gb
The video is about 2h long with 6 angles in the Multicam. It was recorded on an ATEM Mini Extreme ISO. and we recorded sound from external devices. The files is currently unedited, we did not create a pre-program with the ATEM this time around.
So in the DVR project there are video files from the ATEM (quite large files), audio files from the ATEM that are NOT on the timeline, and audio files recorded on a Mixpre 10.

When trying to export (audio only, "export video" is unchecked), I use the Protools preset > individual clips.
Format : Wave
Codec : Linear PCM
Render full extent is checked but the file size doesn't change if left unchecked
Channels : same as source
Bit Depth : 32 (it is the only thing that currently changes the file size, from 188 to 141 and 94 Go ; my sound engineer tells me it needs to be 32)
Render one track per channel is checked

I've also flattened all the tracks on the Multicam timeline (has not changed anything)

i am at a complete loss. I am not a professional editor so I have been researching like crazy, trying to understand the problem and I fear I cannot figure it out on my own. my sound engineer doesn't really know DVR so he's lost as well

does anyone have any idea why DVR is generating such large files and what I can do to reduce them significantly?


r/editors • • 1d ago

Other When your parents watch your edits

29 Upvotes

I’m a little older now, but whenever I used to show my parents my cuts, the first thing they’d ask isā€¦ā€œDid you pick the music?!ā€. To which I’d answer ā€œwell, yeaā€ or ā€œnot this oneā€ or ā€œkinda, it was scoredā€, but moreover ā€œhow is that relevant???ā€. It always struck me as such a strange thing to focus on.

I’m wondering, what are the weird responses you’ll often get when showing your work to a parent or loved one?


r/editors • • 1d ago

Technical What software do you think Planet Money’s Jack Corbett uses?

0 Upvotes

He makes those great videos with a green screen and all of the graphic effects on top—Do you think he is just working purely in Adobe Photoshop? What would you use to get that kind of effect?


r/editors • • 1d ago

Technical PSA You can now run FCP7 on Apple Silicon from a Virtual Intel Machine

31 Upvotes

If you have the need to jump into an old FCP7 project for any reason, you can run it on Apple Silicon using this virtual machine.

https://github.com/nfzerox/VirtualIntelMacOnAppleSilicon

Installation is painless. There is even a helpful menubar that lets you download the FCP software (you will need a Final Cut Studio serial). Tested it out on my M4 Mac Mini and it ran decently enough for basic stuff. You can mount any attached drive although be warned it will eject it from your main machine.

UPDATE:

I've found the USB connection on hard drives to be flaky. Better to just share the drive and connect is as a network drive on the virtual mac, and don't have to worry about it ejecting on your primary system.


r/editors • • 2d ago

Technical Best way to label reshoots/pickups when setting up metadata?

7 Upvotes

Working as the editor for a small indie short, and just got some footage back from a reshoot they did. I have to make dailies and label everything for the data burn-in, but was curious what the best practices are for labeling reshoots/pickups.

For context, this was scene 9. I have shots labeled 9A, 9B, etc., and don't want to get the old stuff mixed in with the new stuff. I feel like I'll get a couple of "you know the footage so what does it matter" comments, but just to avoid confusion, I'd like them to be separate. My gut feeling (based mostly on the options available to our AC in ZoeLog) is that these should be R9A, R9B, etc., but I'm not sure if this is correct.


r/editors • • 2d ago

Other [Black Friday] Adobe Creative Cloud Pro is 50% off for the first year

69 Upvotes

I've posted this here the last few years, Adobe's annual Black Friday sale is here, and each year everyone replies that the thread was helpful, so here it is again!

Adobe Creative Cloud Pro is 50% off your first year @ $29.99/month.

Student is 50% off as well.

Promo ends Ends Nov 27.

If you’re on a current contract/plan you can chat in and ask for the promo.

Be persistent and firm and get them to switch you to this offer.

Most of us are all locked into the Adobe train, so might as well cut costs where we can. Save that $$$!

---

Here's last years thread, there's a ton of great tips in here for existing users and how to ask for your account to be adjusted to the promo.

https://www.reddit.com/r/editors/comments/1ow2e8p/black_friday_adobe_creative_cloud_pro_is_2999month/


r/editors • • 3d ago

Humor Light a candle for me

4 Upvotes

I’m on the 14th ā€œFinal versionā€ of a video because premiere has decided to not understand my audio set up.

Technical details:
Rode pro. Two microphones with split audio, recording through black magic app on iphone.

When I put it into premiere I selected 2 stereo instead of 2 mono channels for the audio. Lesson learned.

Premiere has decided my main dialogue channel only works about 80% of the time. At random. Fine in the viewer, just broken after export.

I have I THINK exported enough versions that I can cobble together the sections that exported correctly from multiple videos.

I saw this suggestion hours ago and my ego forbade this solution. Surely I could find a fix that wouldn’t require exporting the audio and re-importing it! I have no pride any more.

I’ve been full time for two years. Been editing for at least 7 part time. I thought I was past this. I also thought I had the final version four hours ago. I might have figured it out now… or I might be about to start another attempt.


r/editors • • 3d ago

Technical How to understand sound effects?

1 Upvotes

I've been doing photography professional for 5 years and got into video a year ago mostly shooting Ads and interviews for commercial clients. I went freelance recently, and I'm getting gigs doing DJ events at clubs in my area, doing my first aftermovie on Saturday. My video work is nothing special, and I have a lot to learn. One thing I really need to figure out is sound design with sound effects, and I'm really struggling.

I have a subscription to Envato, so I have a large enough library to access, but I don't even know what to look up.

I found this video on youtube as an example of kinda what I'm going for https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qkLTZrr22lA has very cool sound effects in the first half of the video, between transitions and all the editing, this is my goal post to get to.

Would love advice on how to approach sound design.


r/editors • • 3d ago

Technical Installer files for Media Encoder 2023?

5 Upvotes

Does anyone have the mac (.dmg) installation files for Adobe Media Encoder 2023? I have Premiere 2023 (23.4.0) installed but not the compatible Media Encoder. The CC app/Adobe's website no longer provides this version. In the past I've gotten old download files from the Adobe support chat, but now the AI chat is useless and it disconnects me before connecting to a human agent.

Edit: I got through to a human agent but he just told me anything pre-2025 is discontinued :/

Thank you!


r/editors • • 3d ago

Technical Starting again with new kit?

7 Upvotes

My husband (not on Reddit) is a video editor in the UK. He's an older guy (knocking 60) and has been doing it professionally (as a one-man band) for many, many years. He's been using Premiere on a Mac ever since Media 100 became obsolete.
Anyway, his Mac has just conked out and it seems to be terminal. Seeing as he's going to have to replace, he was thinking that he may be a bit behind the times with the kit (hardware/software) that's out there. So Redditeditors, if you were in this situation, what would you go for? Funds are not unlimited! Thanks on his behalf.

EDIT thanks for the hardware suggestions, also looking to hear about alternatives to Premiere.


r/editors • • 3d ago

Technical Wireless ANC headphones…?

1 Upvotes

Hi folks,

Did a search on the sub and didn’t see anything specific and recent enough to not ask this again.

I’m in the market for a new pair of headphones. I’m one of these laptop cafe editors. Been doing it professionally for 3 years and have a good amount of work. Edit a lot of long form content for YouTubers, documentaries, some commercial and reels for socials, lots to music, lots of dialogue, pretty involved and synch is important.

Noise cancelling is important to me as I’m often working in cafes and places w other noise around me. For the past few years I’ve been working w AirPod pro 2’s and honestly they have been awesome. Essentially unnoticeable latency, the noise cancelling is effective, and they do exactly what I need them to. My issue is ear fatigue. After a while they get annoying in the ear and a whole day w them in is exhausting and kind of gross. I’d love to retire them to podcast listening only.

I think it’s time to invest in some proper fuggin CANS. I’m curious what people here are using? I understand the proper pro’s will likely tell me to get open back wired headphones and buy a second monitor and get a studio (and that is absolutely goals) but for now - for us cafe editors - what are you people using?

I’m looking at the Sony xm6 which happen to be on sale in Canada rn. They’ve got pretty great seeming EQing in the app and can be used wired so they seem like a decent option and are much cheaper than the AirPod max 2’s. I figure I could work mostly wireless and then when I need to dial in extremely fine synch, I can plug them in. Anyone else using these to edit?

I also edit in Davinci studio mainly and know there’s a way to adjust it so the program adjusts for the latency if using Bluetooth…

Anyway, tldr: anyone here using wireless Bluetooth ANC headphones to edit video? In cafes, in public places editing on laptop style? If so what are you using and how well do they work? Or should I just give up on this idea and keep using my AirPod pro OR just buy a pair of wired non ANC headphones?

Oh and budget range id like to spend under 500 CAD.

And for the mods I’m running an m1 MacBook Pro, 32gb ram, Davinci studio, runs great for my needs!

Thanks and all due respect to all of you!


r/editors • • 3d ago

Career Working between countries?

1 Upvotes

I’m not an editor but in audio post, but this also applies to editors as well.

Does anyone here physically freelance between different countries? I’m an Aussie living and working in London, and I’m due to get ILR status next month, meaning I can leave the country for up to two years at a time and still have the right to keep living and working in the UK. Seeing work is a bit thin on the ground here, as a business strategy going forward, I’m considering being willing to fly to Sydney for a contract gig, and when that’s up, I either stick around for more work if they offer it, or I fly back to the UK. Obviously the gig length and pay has to outweigh the outlay of a Ā£1k ($2k AUD) return flight, and I reckon I could crash with family.


r/editors • • 4d ago

Technical do somebody know if is it possible to save audio damaged by a phone's noise reduction?

2 Upvotes

Hey, I recorded a video with a Boya BY-M1 lav mic (fur windshield) plugged into a Samsung A14 (with default camera app), but the phone seems to have applied a brutal noise-removal effect that affected the voice quality.

- The same mic works fine on my samsung A12, which is why I came to this "bad noise removal" conclusion.

- It sounds like when you remove a copyrighted song on a youtube video while keeping the voice...

- I tried Adobe Podcast Enhance, but it only removed the background noise and kept the voice as is

Is some kind of restoration possible, or is re-recording the only fix?

Short clip if needed:
wav download: https://www.swisstransfer.com/dl/01a1c638-a65b-7115-9d0b-f306939c5329
youtube unlisted: https://youtu.be/YbLcBeUO3h4


r/editors • • 4d ago

Technical Auto-color match on Premiere v27?

7 Upvotes

The Lumetri Color panel is replaced by the new Color mode. The Lumetri panel had an "auto color match" thingy, but I can't find it now.

I'm not sure if it's been replaced or renamed or outright removed? Any other solution?

Edit: Apparently I need to add this info:

System specs: 14700k, RTX 4080 Software specs: Premiere v27 Footage specs: 1080p footage that was graded and exported


r/editors • • 4d ago

Did you know that /r/editors has a discord?

0 Upvotes

TL: DR - How do I get you (yes, you) involved?

Obligatory mention. Here's the link of the official Discord of r/editors with 1,000 members, including a number of professionals cutting films, tv shows and more.

It's for both professionals and aspiring professionals.

IT WILL NOT HELP YOU MAGICALLY GET A JOB. THERE IS NO MYTHICAL WEBSITE YOU DON'T KNOW ABOUT either.

It requires verification (any of these will work: (Reddit/youtube/facebook/IG/Github/spotify/Steam/xbox).

Again: Discord Link here

Once you verify there are 15+ channels, including ones based on:

  • Type of work (color, sound, audio)

  • Software specific (Adobe, Apple, Avid, BMD)

  • Quality of life (Show off your work, scream room, live tech help)

  • and more.

What I'm trying to do? Get an engaged community outside of Reddit. I'm trying to figure out what works and what doesn't.

  • It could be a Friday Lunch

  • a virtual happy hour

  • a game night 2x a month

  • a virtual User Group event…

…but I'd like to know what you've seen that's engaging…and that gets you interacting with Discord

To me: Reddit is great for threaded conversations, Discord is great for live interactions.

(by the way, my biggest Discord tip is to mute a new server right away. That really helps notifications from becoming overwhelming.)

And yes, I'm happy to help anyone who feels that this is a new/strange domain or feels lost there. I go all the way back to IRC days.


r/editors • • 5d ago

Technical up to date premiere course for pro editors

12 Upvotes

These days I am mostly editing in Avid, but premiere still accounts for about a tenth of my income. The thing is, I got a wake up call watching a demo of the new color page/ updates for 27, and I realized that the premiere I knew pretty well 10 years ago is a completely different beast now. I urgently need to update my knowledge of premiere if I want to keep accepting jobs on that system.

But where do you go for something like that? All tutorials I find are aimed at absolute beginners and content creators. That has always been a premiere problem, but 10 years ago you still had books like 'the cool stuff in Premiere pro', explaining pro/broadcast workflows for the program. Does anything like this still exists?


r/editors • • 6d ago

Career Working through new horizons

8 Upvotes

I've been an "editor" for about a year and a half at this point, by the tax return standard anyways, and the type of questions I've asked seemed to chafe at the edges of an established world of editors. I've had a lot of folks scoff at workloads and say that I'm being taken advantage of. That seems to be coming from a higher paid, now more scarce crowd whose work is quickly disappearing.

It seems a lot of the remaining work in this industry is all commercial, now heavily moving towards socials/YouTube. Personally that's all I've ever known. Since I've been a guppie I've identified a lot of desirable brands to work for, brands whose ads still have a strong sheen of quality, and all the work in between. I've worked with enough people to see a few who are exceedingly compensated in this space.

So the question of whether one can "make it" or not is answered. I'm watching people do it right now. So what are your tips for this space that continues to take up the pie? Does anyone have tips for newer editors who are rising through this avenue of the business? What works and what doesn't?