r/editors • • Sep 26 '25

Other Hot Take: It's not that big of a deal to change the music...

2 Upvotes

I get it, you've cut specifically to a track and now some things might not work quite as well or even at all anymore.

But here's my stance: Your cut should be able to stand on it's own regardless of song choice or even without music at all. It should never depend on a track (maybe in specific circumstances). On top of that, you probably shouldn't be making decisions based on the music track at the point of the process where a client/producer is hearing a music choice for the first time and speaking into it (rough cut). Make those decisions once you are past that point and on to a fine cut.

Of course if you are getting this comment deep into the post process, that can be frustrating. But I would argue that if you're running into this circumstance often, that expectations are not being set ahead of time and that more comes down to a problem with how you are communicating with your clients/producers.

This of course doesn't account for getting through multiple versions internally before a client gets eyes on it for the first time. That's just something that comes with the territory and might happen from time to time. Only thing I can think of to help with this is getting the client involved earlier in the process. That just comes down to preference.

What do you think? Is this a fair assessment?


r/editors • • Dec 04 '25

Other Rant - I can't understand why people would use Premiere professionally.

0 Upvotes

I'm just ranting here, I'm picking up a fine cut for a pilot episode from another freelance editor that quit, they were gracious enough to send all there project files over, and they used premiere for the edit.

Now I started with premiere 10 years ago, but switched to Resolve about 6 years ago, and haven't looked back since.

Due to whatever fuckery this editor did, I just cannot get the timeline to translate to Resolve, so I'm finishing in premiere, and let me just say this here and now....this feels like the most settle for less and pay for more software I have ever worked with a day in my life.

It seems as if most simple built-in functions I would use in resolve require a manual workaround in premiere that breaks if you aren't done with the edit, the behavior of certain tools like the ripple edit make absolutely no sense in premiere, for whatever reason premiere struggles to play these proxies meanwhile when I tested the footage in resolve I was getting realtime playback of ARRIRAW. Saving the project takes eons, opening the project takes eons, literally takes 4 seconds of loading between me pressing play and it actually playing. There is no reason it should use in/out points when dragging clips from the bin...makes sense to use the in/out points when dragging from the source viewer, but not the bin.

Naturally, this timeline I was given seems like an unorganized mess as I don't know what the prior editor was doing for sorting, but even then, the inability to have something like timeline colors, being able to collapse multi-wave audio into single tracks and select channels, and even the functionality of how audio tracks work in premiere is just awful compared to resolve. Yes, I know with Fairlight being a whole other software integrated into resolve makes it better, but even just functionality from the edit page in resolve makes more sense than in premiere.

Yes I will say, Premiere is okay at best for short form "I just need to get this out" content, but in a professional setting I hate it with a burning passion.

To me, Premiere is like driving the Flintstones car, it's phenomenal if you like to push, are rolling it down a hill, and like using your feet as brakes. Where as resolve is like a Jeep, a more than decent all-rounder vehicle with built in functions and behaviors you would expect.

I simply can't wrap my head around why people continue to use Premiere. Would love to hear any decent argument for people continuing to use it that doesn't include the words "Industry Standard" and "it's what I'm used to".

Rant over, thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.


r/editors • • Oct 11 '23

Other Keep up the gatekeeping!

0 Upvotes

This is a sub for professional editors. I am a big fan of gate keeping because this is sub has been flooded with questions from non pros. There’s a great sub for you over at https://reddit.com/r/VideoEditing/s/eT6rT774aI where you can learn together. Keep the posts here to professional editors. A good guide if you’re not sure is to ask yourself, do I have a boss/someone above me who is more experienced and that I learn from? If the answer is no, this isn’t the right sub for your question.

EDIT: Apparently I need to clarify. I’m talking about having a boss at the beginning of your career. When you are starting out and learning not now that you’re established with 20 years under your belt come on guys, I didn’t think I had to spell that out.


r/editors • • Dec 04 '22

Other Have you ever been hired as a token and then given no work?

0 Upvotes

I got hired as an official part-time guy (hourly) for a "proudly female-owned company." I'm the token dude in my department, which is otherwise all-F. Most of the company is.

Five months, no work. I'm officially in their books, but they've delegated nothing to me and I've yet to be paid for anything.

My supervisor doesn't check in. Once conversation since hiring, when I reached out to say 'remember me?' She gave some excuses as to why it's slow. Since then, nothing.

I've been wondering if this is just a ruse. A ploy to appear they are equal opportunity. I'd seen this happen before. A TV company I worked at once. All-F crew. Producers, story writers, editors, etc. The executive producer hired a M once in a while, then fired him after 3 weeks, always with the excuse "he couldn't do the work." Everybody knew about this. But the show was very profitable, so she got what she wanted.

There's nothing I can do about this, but I'd love to know if there are similar stories.

Can't wait to see this post get flagged and downvoted for its scandalizing topic!

EDIT: sorry, forgot to mention, this is a remote gig, I don't go into this place; I get work from other clients as a freelancer.


r/editors • • Aug 14 '16

Still the best trailer of all time

Thumbnail
youtu.be
129 Upvotes

r/editors • • May 13 '25

Technical 📣 The Invisible Shift in Post

0 Upvotes

Something’s happening in post-production, and it’s bigger than any codec update or software release.

Today I’m posting the first installment of a 6-part series on the next evolution of post-production for film and television.

Ever since the Writers and Actors strikes of 2023, there’s been a profound shift happening across the entire industry, and post is no exception. With the rise of AI, automation, and interconnected tools, the way we work is evolving fast. And yet, so many of the systems we rely on still feel stuck in another era.

That’s why I wrote this series: to look at where we’ve been, what’s changing, and how we, as editors, assistants, and creative professionals, must adapt.

I believe we’re experiencing a shift even more transformative than the move from film to digital. What’s happening now is fundamentally reshaping how we work, how we collaborate, and what it means to be “post.”

Part 1: “You Can Feel It, Can’t You?”

You can feel it, can’t you?

Something’s shifting in the air. Not just another software update or codec change, but something deeper. Foundational. You may not be able to name it yet, but your gut knows: the ground under post-production is moving.

Maybe it's the growing buzz about AI tools. Or the way people are suddenly talking about automation. Or the assistant editor you just chatted with who’s using Notion, Zapier, and ChatGPT like it’s second nature.

Whatever it is the way we work, (at least for the last 30 years), is being quietly, but radically, redefined.

As someone who came up in the days of film bins, grease pencils, and ¾-inch tape, and later helped usher in digital editing with Avid, I’ve lived through a tectonic shift before. This feels a lot like that. The only difference? This one’s going to happen faster. Much faster. And it’s going to be a lot bigger.

This time it’s not just about switching from analog to digital. It’s about rethinking how the entire post-production process flows, from dailies to delivery, powered by automation, AI, and tools that work with you instead of locking you into rigid pipelines.

And no, it doesn’t mean we’re replacing humans. It means the tools are finally evolving to support the way humans actually work in this creative, chaotic, deadline-driven world.

But here’s the thing: most of the editing tools we still rely on, Avid, Premiere, Resolve, were never built with this kind of openness in mind. They’re brilliant in many ways, but they’re also fortresses. Closed systems. 

If you’ve ever tried to automate even a simple task across them, you know the pain: XML exports, folder watching, fragile plug-ins, or expensive developer-only SDKs.

And yet… outside the editing room, the rest of the software world has been quietly reinventing itself around APIs, automation, and no-code platforms. 

Tools like Make (dot com) and n8n are letting creators and businesses stitch together complex workflows without writing code. 

AI agents are surfacing metadata, writing summaries, analyzing footage. Cloud services are talking to each other natively.

It’s as if we’ve been editing in a bunker while the rest of the world rebuilt the internet.

This series is for the curious. The editors and assistants who sense the change but want someone who speaks their language to help them navigate it. 

We’ll look at how we got here, why our tools are the way they are, and what’s opening up now that could radically transform how we work, collaborate, and create.

Don’t worry, this isn’t a doomsday forecast or some breathless tech evangelism. 

It’s a flashlight.

Because if you’ve ever thought, “There has to be a better way to do this,” you were right.

And the better way is here.

Let me know what you think. Are you feeling this shift in your own workflows? I’d love to hear from others in the trenches.

👉 Part 2 drops soon. Follow or connect to stay in the loop.


r/editors • • Apr 17 '25

Humor Taping Nigel - Ricky Gervais tortures his editor behind the scenes of Extras Season 1 (link in comments) NSFW

3 Upvotes

As an editor who's worked with my fair share of bastards this plays like an especially grim kind of horror. Would any of you put up with this to edit The Office/Extras?


r/editors • • Aug 28 '26

Technical Is Media Composer 2024 the worst version ever built?

0 Upvotes

I've been an editor for almost 20 years, and this is such a horrible version. I'm stunned at the idiocy it took to make this version. Everything is worse in this version. I'd almost rather use Premiere (I've actually been using it much more, even though Premiere is absolute garbage, yet it does some things well).

List of my main issues:

The Segment Mode Arrow (yellow arrow) doesn't work the same anymore, moves the whole timeline instead of being able to swap 2 segments like it did for literally 2 decades.

The corners of bins are almost impossible to grab now, used to be easy, now you need to grab one pixel to resize.

Automatically shoving bins in other bins, I never asked for this and it's annoying as fuck.

Title tool doesn't work anymore. I'm on a cutting edge mac with tons of RAM, yet it says my system doesn't have enough memory to run fucking title tool. WTF

I can't make my Project window smaller than a specific size, this was never the case before.

They changed the layout of the mixer window, so now when I select the hamburger to use the dropdown to select "set pan/gain" I have to scroll down to select it. I use this feature dozens of times a day, and it's adding wasted time to my edit.

I'm sure there's more issues, here's what's coming to mind at the moment. It's clear that the developers of Media Composer DO NOT ACTUALLY USE MEDIA COMPOSER.


r/editors • • Apr 16 '25

Technical Feeling Stuck After Switching to Mac for Editing

3 Upvotes

I’ve been editing on Windows only for almost 3 years, and I recently got a new MacBook with the M4 Pro to improve my workflow and speed up things like rendering and exporting. It’s a big upgrade, and I was really excited about it at first.

But now it’s been over a week, and I still haven’t started editing on the Mac. The truth is… I’m kinda stuck. I feel a bit nervous about switching because I’ve gotten so used to editing on Windows, and I’m worried that trying to adjust to macOS might slow me down or break my rhythm.

I know it might sound silly—after all, it’s just another operating system—but when you’re used to working fast and efficiently, even small changes in shortcuts, layout, or how things work can throw you off.

So I just wanted to share what I’m going through with you guys. Has anyone here made the switch from Windows to Mac for editing? How was the transition for you? Any tips, advice, or words of encouragement would mean a lot!


r/editors • • Sep 25 '14

Hitler Discovers Final Cut Pro X

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/editors • • Dec 13 '22

Other Any recommendation for AI video editing systems?

0 Upvotes

I am working on more marketing creatives that I can handle and wonder if there are any recommended solutions for video generators. Basically I feed the software the script and it churns out a montage of broll that visualizes the scripts. Most of these videos range from 1-2 min.

I don't expect a finished product but at least a good enough rough edit that can be polished by me. Thanks!


r/editors • • Dec 13 '23

Other If I give you 10M$ will you still edit ?

0 Upvotes

** Honest answer only !


r/editors • • Aug 25 '24

Other Why does the industry not use Premier?

0 Upvotes

I really don't understand why Premier Pro isn't the industry-standard editing platform. Avid is completely unintuitive at every stage of the post-production process. I might be biased because I have been using Premiere for years but surely I'm not the only one who thinks this right??


r/editors • • May 31 '23

Business Question As an intern at a film Agency company, can I refuse to edit a video (aftermovie & interviews) if it’s filmed really bad?

4 Upvotes

The shots that were filmed are all very bad filmed at my opinion and the other editors think the same. The shots are very shaky and has a low frame rate so making a slowmotion edit is also no option. But I started with the edit but I can’t seem to get really far because of lack of inspiration and creativity because it’s filmed this way. But the problem is that my intern boss filmed it. What do you think? Can I refuse to edit the video any further?


r/editors • • 19d ago

Business Question You think big companies want to replace you with artifical intelligence ?

5 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/generativeAI/comments/1xh0s5u/what_to_use_to_turn_city_photos_into_video/

no - it's EVERYONE - you think that Mr. Spydervenom is a big company ? He is a little guy, and he is one of millions of people that want to do this. And YOUR only answer to him is - "hey buddy, why don't you just employ a video professional to do it for you ?". He says it's for professional projects. But he can't do what YOU can - and he would rather be DEAD than employ you. Welcome to real life. It's not just big companies - it's EVERYONE.

bob


r/editors • • Oct 22 '21

Other ripped from the headlines - Daily Mail on the Alec Baldwin shooting (nothing about Alec Baldwin)

0 Upvotes

"The workers had been complaining about the fact they had to stay overnight in Albuquerque - an hour's drive from the set - and not Sante Fe because production wouldn't pay for their hotels, according to sources cited by The Los Angeles Times and multiple social media posts by film and TV insiders. When they turned up to set to clear their things on Thursday, they found they'd been replaced by locals. It begs the question of who those local workers were, what their training was and to what extent did they check the weapon before handing it to Baldwin, loaded with a live round. Deadline also cites an unnamed source who said a gun had gone off 'in a cabin' while someone was holding it in a cabin. 'A gun had two misfires in a closed cabin. They just fired loud pops - a person was just holding it in their hands and it went off,' they said. "

So if some of you morons think that things will "change" in the film and TV industry - it never changes. There is always abuse, and this is LONG before the tragedy of the horrible shooting of the DP and the director. The bosses couldn't really care less - they want to make money. You can strike all you want - it will always be the same game. It's been that way long before I got into our industry, and of course, this is more horrible than anything I ever went thru. But it's the same game. How can we save money, screw the crew, so we keep all the money. Welcome to the entertainment industry, kids. This incident may change the use of "blanks" forever - but it won't change how our industry works. We are in SHOW BUSINESS.

Bob


r/editors • • Feb 24 '25

Business Question is this the end of Hollywood ?

15 Upvotes

Michael Cioni knows more than most of us, and has known more than most of us for a long time.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xJByD5mAQqA


r/editors • • Jul 04 '25

Technical Which software is leading ?

0 Upvotes

There are a lot of people talking about premier pro and davinci resolve. I still feel that one using both is the name of the game. You have serious upside with little odds. No matter how much of a pain in you a**. But still both are great in their own places.


r/editors • • Sep 03 '18

Why does Premiere let you delete in-out?

1 Upvotes

Why oh why.

What possible reason would i have for wanting to delete everything in between my in and out points on the timeline? Some "features" Premiere has I just don't understand.

This has fucked me so many times and never once have I actually wanted to do this. If I want to delete a massive chunk of my edit I'll add edit, select, delete thankyouverymuch.

EDIT: Just to be clear I'm not accidentally hitting delete, I'm accidentally not selecting the clip properly before I hit delete. This, coupled with the fact that it deletes in-out off screen and gives you no indication is what annoys me. As others have pointed out ; or "lift" was the key to press to do this, but recent versions of Premiere made it so delete does it too, making ; pointless.


r/editors • • Jan 23 '26

Technical [AI assistance] What helpful scripts did you create to assist in your workflow?

1 Upvotes

Wondering how everybody has been using ChatGPT / Gemini etc to help them in their workflow?

Using ChatGPT, I just made a script that watches a local folder, locally runs Whisper to transcribe and translate videos and audio files, outputting an English .srt - even if the original audio is in a foreign language. It then creates a readable PDF (longer paragraphs), so I can quickly read what's being said in the video.

This is handy for a project in which I expect to have lots of archival footage.

Going through Premiere, exporting transcriptions, translating them would've been too much clicking on my part.

Curious about your usage!


r/editors • • Sep 18 '26

Business Question In 1977, no one wanted to employ me

0 Upvotes

so I used the Yellow Pages, to call every sound company listed, to ask if they would be willing to employ me, and when everyone said NO, I started to call lighting companies, and ask if they would give me a chance to work for them. And one company - See Factor, said that a big sound company from the UK was opening in Newburgh, NY, called TASCO sound, and they might have an opportunity - so I called them (in a 914 area code - because I lived in a 718 area code) - and I spoke with Peter Alexander, and told them that I wanted to work. And he told me to come up for an interview. And my father drove me up from Flushing Queens to Newburgh NY to Steward Airport, for my interview, and I was employed (I would use another word other than employed, but warnings come up on Reddit). This was for the KISS ALIVE tour in 1977. My first opportunity for being employed.

Today, I saw this -

https://www.reddit.com/r/UrbanHell/comments/1wjt3nj/newburgh_new_york/

I had no car. I used to hitch hike to get from the room upstairs in a bar, to get to Stewart Airport to get to work, where I learned how to make XLR connectors, and blow up a lot of equipment. And now I was with Kiss, and the opening act was Cheap Trick, and my friend Chris Roe was with Aerosmith, and we made $90 a week. And we were happy.

You want a balanced life ?

bob


r/editors • • Sep 20 '24

Other Avid in 2024?

3 Upvotes

Does anyone here use avid, if so is it any good? I’ve been using Vegas for a long time now and I’ve been thinking about switching to a more professional editor in order to get hired, I been looking at avid but if anyone have suggestions other than premiere pro let me know


r/editors • • Nov 22 '23

Business Question oh - I will be banned from this forum for this !

0 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/RealEstatePhotography/comments/17xmxf2/youre_not_getting_any_work_because_someone_whos/

I used to hire professional photographers to shoot my installs for promotional stuff. But the industry has changed, and I went from a Nikon, to a Canon, to my iPhone. Who needs to hire a professional photographer ! (and I am not good - not even a little - but I can get my point across).

what this Reddit post shows, is what has happened to the pro audio industry, and the pro photography industry. Are there still hi end audio studios - of course there are - but very few. Are there still high end photographers - of course there are ! - but very few.

We are not seeing this in the YouTube/Instagram/TikTok business - people that can barely make a living - but keep striving - and then there is "us" - the high end professional market.

How long can we maintain this ? Well - when we are dealing with multi million dollar budgets for a major feature film (just like a new audio project for Taylor Swift) - there will be big money available to the high end guys - but what about the vast majority of the market.

How many "professional" still photographers will be around in 2032 ? (you mean - you actually pay people to take pictures for you ? ").

Bob


r/editors • • Oct 10 '24

Other how to succeed in life

13 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/SipsTea/comments/1g0r8e7/this_kid_saw_an_opportunity/

Reddit always has crap that shows up, without me requesting it, or looking for it. This showed up. I was very moved by this post. I hate kids - but this kid was me. I knew nothing about AVID. But there it was - an AVID in Boxes. Back at the beginning. I said "S#$% - I bet I can make this work" -

and here we are in 2024.

Your opportunities ? You are the one that makes it happen - it's not going to happen on "StaffMeUp" or "Fiver".

bob

edit - ps - I just read the comments "this is totally fake" - well, in my case, it was a bunch of boxes just sitting there - it was not moving. I made it happen.