r/econmonitor • • Jun 22 '21

Research Racial Differences in Mortgage Refinancing, Distress, and Housing Wealth Accumulation during COVID-19

0 Upvotes

The COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated racial disparities in U.S. mortgage markets. Black, Hispanic, and Asian borrowers were significantly more likely than white borrowers to miss payments due to financial distress, and significantly less likely to refinance to take advantage of the large decline in interest rates spurred by the Federal Reserve’s large-scale mortgage-backed security (MBS) purchase program. The wide-scale forbearance program, introduced by the 2020 Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act, provided approximately equal payment relief to all distressed borrowers, as forbearance rates conditional on nonpayment status were roughly equal across racial/ethnic groups. However, Black and Hispanic borrowers were significantly less likely to exit forbearance and resume making payments relative to their Asian and white counterparts. Persistent differences in the ability to catch up on missed payments could worsen the already large disparity in home ownership rates across racial and ethnic groups. While the pandemic caused widespread distress in mortgage markets, strong house price appreciation in recent years, particularly in 2020, means that foreclosure risk is lower for past-due borrowers now as compared with the aftermath of the Global Financial Crisis and Great Recession. Furthermore, borrowers who have missed payments have significantly higher credit scores now than those who were distressed in the 2007–2010 period, largely due to the widespread availability of forbearance for federally backed mortgages.

/

Our analysis focuses on one particular aspect of the heterogeneity of mortgage outcomes during the pandemic: differences across racial and ethnic groups. We do this for two reasons. First, the COVID-19 virus disproportionately impacted minority communities both as a disease and as a disruptive economic force. Black and Hispanic individuals have been at elevated risks of infection, hospitalization, and death.1 In addition, minorities experienced significantly worse labor market outcomes during the pandemic. For example, the unemployment rate peaked in April 2020 at 16.7 percent for Black workers versus 14.1 percent for white workers, but even more concerning, unemployment fell far more quickly for white workers as the economy healed.2 By September 2020, the white unemployment rate had fallen by more than half to 7.0 percent, whereas in March 2021, almost a year after the pandemic started, the Black unemployment rate was still close to 10 percent.

Full Study


r/econmonitor • • Sep 13 '25

Commentary Corporate profits rest on labor’s shrinking share

Post image
123 Upvotes

Labor share and corporate profits are two sides of the same distribution. In the national accounts, if labor’s claim on value added falls, profits rise mechanically. The past few decades, especially after the new millennium, have been defined by a margin structure where labor share is compressed by globalization, technology and weaker bargaining power.

That, in turn, leaves profits structurally high relative to output.

The current configuration is unusual because profits remain elevated even with higher rates and slowing growth, which means margins are being defended at the expense of wage gains!

The tension is rather obvious: if policy or inflation pressure shifts more income toward labor, it comes directly out of earnings capacity and resets the level of sustainable profits.


r/econmonitor • • May 25 '22

Commentary The Racial Gap in Stock Market Participation

Thumbnail
stlouisfed.org
1 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Mar 15 '21

Commentary Bitcoin's buyer beware

Thumbnail economic-research.bnpparibas.com
5 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Dec 30 '20

Commentary The “She-Cession” Persists, Especially for Women of Color

Thumbnail
stlouisfed.org
14 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Nov 11 '22

Fiscal Policy US midterms: Republicans are back, (fiscal) policy impasses too

Thumbnail
allianz.com
2 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Aug 24 '20

Research The Assessment Gap: Racial Inequalities in Property Taxation

0 Upvotes

Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis

July 6, 2020

We [...] document a nationwide "assessment gap" which leads local governments to place a disproportionate fiscal burden on racial and ethnic minorities. We show that [...] black and Hispanic residents [...] face a 10-13% higher tax burden for the same bundle of public services.

  • assessment ratios are 12.7% higher for black homeowners, 9.8% higher for black or Hispanic homeowners, and just under 3% higher for other nonwhite homeowners. Given a national median effective property tax rate of approximately 1.4%, and a median home value of approximately $207,000, this translates to an additional tax burden of $300–$390 per year for black and Hispanic home-owners.

  • We show that slightly more than half of the assessment gap can be explained by between-neighborhood variation. Residential sorting by race in the U.S. means that the average black or Hispanic resident faces a different set of local attributes than a white resident does. Market prices appear to be substantially more sensitive to a wide range of observable neighborhood characteristics than assessed valuations.

  • We show that the remaining 5–6 percentage points of inequality persists even within very small geography. We hypothesize that the main channel for this effect is racial differentials in property tax appeals. We use administrative data from Cook County, the second largest county in the US, to demonstrate that such racial differentials can exist: in Cook County, minority residents are 1% less likely to appeal; are 2% less likely to win an appeal; and conditional on success, receive a 2–3% smaller reduction.


r/econmonitor • • Aug 24 '20

Commentary Spotlight: Black Workers at Risk for 'Last Hired, First Fired'

3 Upvotes

Dallas Fed

Second Quarter 2020

The COVID–19-induced global economic downturn shuttered businesses that have begun slowly reopening and reassessing whether to recall laid-off employees.

If these firms use job seniority as a criterion for returning to work, individuals most recently hired may be at greater risk of prolonged unemployment. In the U.S., black unemployment rates have spiked much more than white jobless rates during recessions.

Black unemployment rates tend to more slowly recede, a phenomenon encapsulated in the phrase “last hired, first fired.”

  • High Unemployment Legacy
    Despite the passage of time and the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which banned employment discrimination based on sex, race, religion and national origin, blacks still suffer more adverse labor market outcomes, including higher unemployment, than whites. This gap widens during recessions.

  • For example, black “prime-age” workers (ages 25–54) experienced declining employment rates associated with the Great Recession (2007–09) two months sooner and 15 months longer than did whites. In the aftermath of that downturn, black employment rates dropped to a low of 66.7 percent in October 2011, while the low for whites, 76.5, percent occurred in July 2010. Moreover, it took blacks longer to find new jobs than whites afterward.

  • History Repeating Itself?
    The benefit that blacks received from the tight labor market in recent years may dissipate as the economy falters. Measures to slow the spread of COVID–19 “paused” many businesses or left them with reduced staffing, often favoring the retention of employees who can work from home.

  • A Dallas Fed study found that only 38.8 percent of full-time U.S. workers had remote-compatible jobs, compared with 37.3 percent in Texas. Within the state, 33 percent of blacks hold jobs suitable for working from home, compared with 47 percent of whites.

  • The data indicate individuals in occupations such as food preparation, personal care, operators, fabricators and sales—representing 57.1 percent of new black hires—may be at particular risk because of an inability to telecommute. Additionally, underrepresentation of black hires in managerial and professional roles—18 percent compared with 26 percent for the overall population—indicates another vulnerability.

  • Thus, the current economic situation may offer a test of the last hired, first fired phenomenon.


r/econmonitor • • Oct 26 '21

Data Release Median weekly earnings were $916 for women in third quarter 2021, 83.3 percent of men's earnings

Thumbnail
bls.gov
3 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Aug 24 '20

Data Release Recent Trends in Wealth-Holding by Race and Ethnicity: Evidence from the Survey of Consumer Finances

0 Upvotes

Federal Reserve

September 27, 2017

Data from the Survey of Consumer Finances (SCF) show that wealth rose for families in all race and ethnicity groups between 2013 and 2016. The long-standing and substantial wealth disparities between families of different racial and ethnic groups, however, have changed little in the past few years.

  • In 2016, white families had the highest level of both median and mean family wealth: $171,000 and $933,700, respectively (figure 1). Black and Hispanic families have considerably less wealth than white families. Black families' median and mean net worth is less than 15 percent that of white families, at $17,600 and $138,200, respectively. Hispanic families' median and mean net worth was $20,700 and $191,200, respectively.

  • Wealth tends to increase with income because of higher levels of saving among higher-income families, and because of the feedback effect on higher incomes from the returns generated by accumulated assets. In 2016, both median and mean incomes are higher for white families than for all other groups of families ($61,200 and $123,400, respectively). Median and mean incomes are considerably lower for black and Hispanic families, whose median incomes are $35,400 and $38,500, respectively.

  • Although most families do have some wealth, the number with zero or negative net worth (having debts that exceed assets) is nontrivial and varies by race/ethnicity. Nearly one in five black households has zero or negative net worth. The share of white households without any wealth is considerably smaller, at 9 percent.


r/econmonitor • • Sep 30 '21

Emerging Markets India: a small fiscal consolidation

Thumbnail economic-research.bnpparibas.com
0 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Nov 20 '21

Inflation Are Accelerating Wage Gains the Next Inflation Risk?

Thumbnail
southstatecorrespondent.com
21 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Sep 09 '20

Speeches Testimony by Sheila Clark before the Committee on Financial Services; Diversity and Inclusion

1 Upvotes

Source: Federal Reserve

  • The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (Board) is deeply committed to an inclusive workplace and a diverse workforce, as well as to fostering diversity in our own procurement practices and those at the institutions we regulate. Diverse perspectives inspire the best ideas, lead to the best decisions, and advance the Federal Reserve's mission in service to the public. We continue to work toward increasing diversity and inclusion at all levels of the Board; promoting fair inclusion and utilization of minority- and women-owned businesses in the Board's procurement process; and supporting transparency and awareness of diversity policies and practices at regulated institutions.

  • The Board established its Office of Diversity and Inclusion (ODI) in January 2011 to promote diversity and inclusion throughout the Board, the Federal Reserve System, and in the financial services industry. ODI works closely with OMWI directors at the 12 Reserve Banks, recognizing that the commitment of the Board on these important issues is shared by the Banks and their leaderships. ODI administers and directs the Board's Equal Employment Opportunity compliance policies and programs and includes the Office of Minority and Women Inclusion. ODI also works to assess the Board's diversity policies, programs, and performance to determine progress and increase transparency. ODI's ongoing efforts to foster an informed dialogue on diversity best practices include participation in Equal Employment Opportunity Commission technical workshops, attendance at conferences and events held by professional organizations, and participation in financial industry groups addressing diversity issues.

  • In 2019, there were 19 appointments to the official staff, of which five were minorities (26 percent) and six were women (32 percent). Currently, there are six female division directors, of which one is African American. Eight division directors are male, of which one is Hispanic. In addition, there are three African Americans, one Hispanic, and three females who serve as deputy directors of their respective divisions.

  • The Federal Reserve System focuses considerable time and attention on increasing racial and ethnic, gender, and sectoral diversity among Reserve Bank and Branch directors. This focus on diversity stems from our belief that these boards function more effectively when they are constituted in a manner that encourages a variety of perspectives and viewpoints. The Board works in close partnership with each Reserve Bank's senior leaders to ensure the composition of Reserve Bank and Branch boards reflect the communities in which they serve. Information on racial and ethnic, gender, and sectoral characteristics of the boards of directors are updated annually and posted on our website.

  • Identification of minority- and women-owned businesses for the Board's capital projects is critical, and we align minority- and women-owned businesses with prime contractors for subcontracting opportunities, when possible. The Board has made significant progress in the inclusion of minority-owned and women-owned businesses in the Board's acquisition process. For example, 2019 contracts awarded to minority- and women- owned businesses increased 9 percent over 2018. This was due, in part, to outreach engagements that focused on forging partnerships with minority- and women-owned businesses, creating a database of diverse suppliers, and ensuring their capabilities to offer goods and services are aligned with the Board's needs. In 2019, the Board paid over 14 percent (over $40 million) of all goods and services contracts to minority- and women-owned businesses.

  • The Board has engaged in a wide range of community outreach events to increase financial literacy and help students explore the field of economics. For example, we facilitate financial literacy activities aimed at minorities and women through the Board's Federal Reserve Outreach Program (FedEd). This program is conducted by research assistants who work with local District of Columbia, Maryland, and Virginia schools with predominantly minority and female populations. As part of the Fed Challenge Program we are increasing outreach to historically Black colleges and universities (HBCUs) and Hispanic Serving Institutions, and strengthening our support of the American Economic Association (AEA) Summer Mentoring Pipeline Conference.


r/econmonitor • • Dec 02 '22

Commentary New Analysis Finds LGBTQ+ Households Trail in Income and Wealth

Thumbnail
stlouisfed.org
0 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Jan 19 '22

Commentary Staff Pick: Black-Owned Banks May Gain from Social Change

Thumbnail
stlouisfed.org
3 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Jan 20 '22

Commentary Will Cryptocurrencies Take Over the World?: Part I: Are Cryptocurrencies Really "Money"? (Wells Fargo)

Thumbnail
wellsfargo.bluematrix.com
3 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Aug 24 '20

Other Racial Equity Primer

3 Upvotes

Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco

June 12, 2020

At the San Francisco Fed, racial equity is core to our values and mission. We put together this racial equity primer to help develop a shared vocabulary and guide discussions.

  • What is racial equity?
    In our work, racial equity means just and fair inclusion in an economy in which all can participate, prosper, and reach their full potential. We will know we have achieved racial equity when race no longer predicts life outcomes.

  • Racial equity is central to the SF Fed’s mission
    At the San Francisco Fed, we cannot ignore racial inequities. People of color are projected to become the majority of the U.S. labor force in the coming decades. Overlooking and undervaluing economic contributions of people of color will limit the full potential of our economy. In other words, achieving racial equity fits into the Federal Reserve’s mandate for maximum employment, which is central to our mission.

  • Racism past and present shapes economic opportunity
    Racial disparities are not simply a matter of individual choice and behavior. They are a product of a complex and often invisible history that has limited options and opportunities based on race. Many forms of racism, past and present, shape who benefits from economic opportunity.

  • “Race-neutral” is not enough
    Research makes clear that anti-Black racism is particularly harmful in the United States. While most explicitly racist laws and policies have been overturned or replaced, modern “race-neutral” laws, policies, and practices are not enough to reverse the legacy of explicitly racist policies. They fail to acknowledge that communities of color, particularly Black communities, have a different starting line and continue to face ongoing discrimination.

  • Aren’t the poorer outcomes we see among Black people a class issue not a race issue?
    As summed up recently by Angela Glover Blackwell on KQED’s Forum, “Many people of color are poor because of their race and ethnicity.” Disadvantage can occur for people across multiple forms of identity (e.g., class, gender, or sexual orientation). But race cuts across every identity group and compounds the challenges people face. People of color experience overlapping forms of discrimination, which often leads to stark racial disparities, even within other identity groups. For example, single white women with a bachelor’s degree have seven times the wealth of single black women with a bachelor’s degree. In other words, white people facing many disadvantages would be even worse off if they were not white.


r/econmonitor • • Apr 08 '21

Commentary Lazard: Outlook on the United States (April 2021)

Thumbnail lazardassetmanagement.com
0 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Mar 05 '23

Fed Is the Fed Chasing Rainbows and Unicorns?

Thumbnail
southstateduncanwilliams.com
0 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Jan 07 '23

Commentary Keeping it real

Thumbnail economics.cibccm.com
0 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Jun 22 '21

Research The Paycheck Protection Program: Conditional Success or Unconditional Failure?

0 Upvotes

The Paycheck Protection Program: Conditional Success or Unconditional Failure?

The Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) managed by the U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA) was a key provision of the law. It sought to stabilize small business finances and maintain employment. The CARES Act and a companion measure, the Health Care Enhancement Act, provided $669 billion in assistance. Two initial rounds of PPP fund disbursement were completed in swift succession, with more than 90 percent of these funds provided by the first week of May 2020.

This article, based on my working paper, explores two questions. First, how well-targeted were the initial PPP funds to local areas experiencing the greatest labor market stress? Second, did the extent of PPP funding help reduce local unemployment rates during 2020?

The answer to the first question—did the funds aid most-stressed areas—appears to be “no,” and to the second question—reducing local unemployment rates—a qualified “yes.”

/

PPP Sought to Provide Rapid Relief to Small Businesses

For a program of its size and complexity, the implementation of the PPP was remarkably rapid. Just days after the CARES Act became law, the SBA published borrower guidelines. They explained the application process, loan terms and conditions for possible loan forgiveness.

Two-year loans were available at 1 percent interest and could be obtained through the existing network for SBA 7(a) loans—the primary assistance program for small businesses. Lenders were federally insured depository institutions and participating Farm Credit System institutions.

Almost $500 billion of the PPP loan disbursements appeared on the banks’ quarterly regulatory filings (call reports) as of June 30, 2020, with negligible amounts funneled through other institutions. Thus, the banking system provides a nearly comprehensive means of looking at the program.

/

PPP Loans Didn’t Necessarily Flow to Counties Hardest Hit by Unemployment

Commercial banks reported their total PPP lending in call reports. While the precise location of bank PPP lending is unknown, it can be estimated by assuming that lending is distributed across counties in proportion to a bank’s county-level deposits.

The preponderance of PPP loans per job lost was uneven—greater in the relatively sparsely populated areas of the Mountain West and relatively less in more populous areas of California, the Northeast and the Midwest (Chart 3). All were among the hardest hit by the initial surge in unemployment.

/

The PPP Aided Labor Market Recovery

Did counties that received relatively large infusions of PPP loans subsequently experience faster labor market recoveries? My work studies the responses of county unemployment rates between May and September 2020 and finds that the answer depends on the approach chosen to investigate this question. Assuming that all county unemployment rates respond to PPP infusions in the same fashion, those with larger PPP loan concentrations appear to have experienced slightly higher subsequent unemployment rates.

However, once unemployment rate responses are allowed to vary by their demographic and banking characteristics, the answer changes. Counties with higher PPP loan infusions experienced faster subsequent unemployment rate declines particularly where banks had high levels of liquidity before the recession began and where there were relatively small but well-educated populations.

Economically, the program may have been quite expensive: On average, spending an extra $50,000 per job lost during the initial surge in unemployment could lower subsequent unemployment rates by 0.2 percent.

Full Article

Full Working Paper


r/econmonitor • • Apr 19 '22

Commentary Diversity & Inclusion: A Tale of Two Economies, Part I (Wells Fargo)

Thumbnail
wellsfargo.bluematrix.com
0 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Nov 13 '21

Europe IP drops very modestly in September to suggest continued sideways trend

Thumbnail uk.daiwacm.com
0 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • Jun 18 '21

Data Release Consumer prices increase 5.0 percent for the year ended May 2021

Thumbnail
bls.gov
0 Upvotes

r/econmonitor • • May 08 '22

Other Is There a Racial Gap in School District Spending?

Thumbnail
stlouisfed.org
9 Upvotes