I'm going to say that I enjoyed this, pretty much. But I'm not going to recommend it - at least not yet.
Dune Messiah is, of course, the sequel to Dune. Set some 12 years later, Paul and his Fremen rule the galaxy - though there are still plots against Paul's rule. Without spoiling the story, that is all I'm going to say of it. The unfortunate thing here, and why I'm not recommending this yet, is because of one reason:
It's too damn short.
Dune Messiah was never a long book - compared to the rest of Frank's Dune books it looks quite out of place, about half the size of the others. It also does not seem to have any sort of cliffhangers which would allow the story to be broken into two parts, unlike Dune which is split into three "books" (and did so successfully for it's set of graphic novels). Instead, when this book ends, I was left thinking "is that it?".
As such, I can't help but say that, unless you want this right now, wait for the box set of parts 1 and 2.
BUT - and I capitalise that to give it emphasis - there's still a lot to like here, and still some to dislike. I always try to comment on the cover and here I should say I'm not a fan, but that's me. With the Dune comics I always tried to get covers that appeal to me (and there are so many dark covers - why?!?). Here we simply have Paul. Give me landscapes, mystery, intrigue.
The finish of the book itself - its not as big as the Dune graphic novels, but still has some impressive visuals beneath the dust jacket - an explosion in what I feel is either the stone burner or the moon crashing down, and contrasts between the sea and desert. We have some sketches of pages, abd the usual forewords and bios of everyone involved. I just wish that Brian would write some new forewords, I'm pretty sure I've read these ones before.
On to the meat of the product, Dune Nessiah itself then... or Dune Messiah part 1 of 2. As I say, there doesn't seem to be a cliffhanger here. I am not as familiar with Dune Messiah as I am with Dune but, by and large, everything does seem accurate, though I feel we are lacking a large amount of subtext. For instance, when Paul commands Korba to pretend to be him and lead today's prayer, I seem to remember Paul giving a brief lesson to the others present (which may have only been Stilgar) about the role of religious figureheads. I could be mistaken. Yet here, it is just about entirely at the level of what is needed to advance the plot. But still, it is unquestionably Dune Messiah and I can't put my finger on any inaccuracies.
Much like the Baron Harkonnen, I like a good villain, and Dune Messiah has four of them. Individually theyre not as appealing as the Baron but the early chapter with the four of them conspiring was something I ate right up. We also have a bonus in the form of an opening chapter involving Bronso, a character who writes many of the passages between chapters which I don't think is in the original book but was released elsewhere (if anyone can recall where this was released please tell me), and serves as a useful device to frame the story, as it were.
Art is handled by a different artist this time, Michael Shelfer, who previously illustrated some of the Dune: House Harkonnen comics. And I have to say, the results are mixed. The original Dune graphic novels had a flatter, more static and, dare I say, muted look. Initially I found book 1 of Dune disappointing because of this, but books 2 and 3 the art style grew into them. They were detailed and rich, even if the designs felt unimaginative at times and the characters simply posed.
Here, the artwork is more fluid, rounded, and less detailed. It is more dynamic, definitely. I think I've said this before about how the Dune prelude comics evolved but it feels at times like a 90s cartoon. Characters can have exaggerated features, such as the wizened Mohiam and the oafish disguises worn by Scytale. When this is detailed it is a delight, with Arrakeen's dustry streets, but other times it feels indistinct.
I will say that the Navigator Edric is a joy to behold, a creature seemingly composed entirely of the orange spice gas, he appears so alien and yet familiar. This book now seems to have moved to the comics' look for the Dune world - as such the fleeting glimpses we saw in the original graphic novels of what I thought were insectoid Navigators have been replaced by the haunting ghouls of the comics.
In conclusion, the artwork is mostly on point - there were a few panels where it didn't work for me, but not many. The story seems to be the Dune Messiah I remember, but - I think - lacking a lot of the subtext. But I wish there was more, and I came away with a general feeling of "and then?". The end didn't so much as leave me hankering for the next one as it did leave me frustrated at its incompleteness. As such, unless you want to buy them individually or cannot wait, I'd recommend waiting for the inevitable box set.