r/dune • • 6h ago

General Discussion Just watched dune 1 and 2 anyone else notice a serious change in tone.

0 Upvotes

just rewatched Dune 1 and 2 and I realized that while the first one felt much more mystic and operatic, the second one had a different feel one thing that stuck out to me was the comedy it was only about 5 or so hokes throughout the second one but when watching them back to back it was really noticeable. did anyone have a similar feeling, please share what kind of tonal feeling you got from the 2 remakes


r/dune • • 14h ago

Fan Art / Project Fan-made Dune Trailer on Roblox

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/dune • • 16h ago

Dune: Part Three (2026) Dune Part 3 IMAX 70mm Tix

13 Upvotes

Please remove if this post is not allowed.

I have 2 tickets for Dune Part 3 at the IMAX 70mm Regal Mall of Georgia for Saturday December 19th at 7pm. Unfortunately I likely will be unable to attend due to unavoidable conflict, but hoping there’s someone out there that would be open to trading their tickets for a different showtime, either earlier in the day or a different day.

If interested please let me know!


r/dune • • 16h ago

General Discussion Did Shaddam Era Ix have Pyons?

0 Upvotes

My rough understanding of the Faufreluches is that pyons are manual laborers, bound to the land they work and form the lowest rung besides maula; criminal pyons are made into maula.

The curious thing about Ix is that they have Suboid labor to build ships. Naturally, Ix probably doesn't have agriculture for pyons as with most worlds; there'd have to be programmers, soldiers, etc. who'd probably be Bondsmen.

Ship breakers, ie recycling ships for parts due to the hazards involved, might be pyons, as Suboids are considered practically non-intelligent.

Do any Dune works shed light on this?


r/dune • • 18h ago

General Discussion Frank Herbert on Prophecy Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Im new to this page but thought I would post on here to see what people thought. A lot of people in videos including Frank Herbert himself I believe have talked about Dune being a warning against prophecy and charismatic leaders and that the Missionaria Protectiva is a self fulfilling mechanism that essentially only works because of propaganda. But doesn't the golden path and the role Paul and Leto play in it sorta disprove this? From what's in the books the path seems to be very specific and dependent on a saviour. How can dune be both a warning against prophecy but also very dependent on one to save it's universe? IMO this opinion needs to be a bit more nuanced. I think even if that's what Frank Herbert intended I think he probably got sucked into the troupe and ended up writing something that was dependent on a saviour prophecy not warning against one. But I could be wrong and I'm interested in hearing other people's' opinion about it.


r/dune • • 22h ago

Dune: Part Three (2026) Understanding the Dune Part 3 opening sequence

39 Upvotes

Coming from a complete Dune beginner, having only watched the first two Dune films and consumed no other Dune content, I’m confused on how the Holtzman shields work for this opening battle. Would the incoming fire not be rendered ineffective by the shields of the Fremen troops and ships? The machine gun laser thing doesn’t seem like the slow moving projectiles that can pass through the shields. Are the projectiles just too big and powerful for personal body shields to withstand? Is it that the Fremen don’t have shields, but if so why not? They’re not on arrakis where they have sandworms that their shields can attract.

I’m just trying to understand how this scene works when I thought ranged combat was rendered moot a long time ago.


r/dune • • 23h ago

Fan Art / Project Arrakis, Me, Pastel Sticks

Post image
461 Upvotes

my first time trying pastels and im proud of it!


r/dune • • 1d ago

I Made This [I made my own Gom Jabbar ]

Thumbnail
gallery
680 Upvotes

r/dune • • 1d ago

General Discussion I don’t think I can dislike Paul Atreides.

83 Upvotes

From the beginning (Dune P1) I understood Paul as somebody who was going to defy his destined faith (terrible purpose) and carve his own path, even when I knew that he was going to be a villain (spoiled). I watched Dune 2 for the first time in the re-release, and it couldn’t change my mind. Seeing his rise to stardom, seeing his trials and tribulations (Gom Jabbar, Jamis, Feyd-Rautha) and seeing his ability to galvanize people, I still wanted to ROOT for Paul. For even his fate as a villain, didn’t stop me from liking him. Sometimes I feel like I want to cry when I try to read Dune, because I can never fully be “against” Paul. In the Dune P3 trailer when Paul says “I can’t see what’s ahead” it’s like a metaphor saying he has fully escaped the grasp of the Bene Gesserict. Paul is an animal, not by desperation, but by choice, similar to the Harkkonnen. Was there any other path? Was he always destined for the desolation of war, suffering and death? This is a paraphrase of two of the most famous quotes: “Control the spice, control the universe, and to control the universe, is to control Arrakis, and to control the Arrakis, is to control the Fremen. Are the Fremen only destined for subjugation and horror? Paul goes by many names, the Duke of Arrakis, the Lisan Al-Gaib, the Kwisatz Haderach, Madhi, Muad’Dib, Usul, and now the Padishah Emperor. To me, they’re all different people. In the quest for identity throughout the movies for Paul, I can’t really grasp who he is? if Paul has already died, who am I watching in Dune Part 3? a quote from Chani “you will never lose me, Paul Atriedes, not as long as you stay who you are.” Two more quotes that stuck with me: He was a man who believed in the rules of the heart, but the heart is not meant to rule; in other words, your father was a weak man.” and “Your father never started a war.” I hope you guys can clear up my logic and help me


r/dune • • 1d ago

Dune (1984) 1984 version- didn't they know the Reverend Mother was psychic?

0 Upvotes

At the beginning of David Lynch's version of Dune, before talking with the Emperor one of the Navigator's attendants says "the Bene Gesseret witch must leave"- but even in another room she 'hears' everything that's said anyway.

Did the Navigator or his attendants not know she could do this? Seems if they did there'd be no point in telling her to take a hike.


r/dune • • 1d ago

Children of Dune How did he take over?

5 Upvotes

HEAVY SPOILERS FOR CHILDREN OF DUNE AHEAD!

Okay so I've been reading through the books, and am most of the way through God Emperor, and there's a plot hole that's been bothering me. So from the literal beginning of the books we've heard about the Bene Gesserit's Kwizatz Haderach being a male Reverend Mother who gets the memories of the males and the females, and yet Alia, despite not being the Kwizatz Haderach, not only gets the memories of the males, but Baron Harkonen is able to take over when she becomes abomination. How?


r/dune • • 1d ago

Fan Art / Project "We are Harkonnens." — Bearing the bloodline together. (Commissioned from Bling Bling, Digital illustration)

Thumbnail
gallery
199 Upvotes

“Seeing the narrow path ahead, and sharing the heavy burden of prescience.”

My Dune: Part Two commission! Recreating the Water of Life awakening scene in the South, featuring Paul and his twin sister, Ariste, with Lady Jessica watching from the shadows.

P.S. Look closely — i also hid a little desert mouse (Muad'Dib) in the artwork as an Easter egg!

(Just to clarify — I’m not sure if she can be classified as a completely original character. Ariste is originally based on the alternate timeline from Dune: Awakening. I simply took that premise and put my own twist on it by turning her and Paul into fraternal twins!)


r/dune • • 1d ago

General Discussion How was the Fremen population affected by the Jihad? Spoiler

125 Upvotes

In the first book, I believe the Fremen population is estimated to be around 10–15 million, although the actual number could be higher. The Jihad lasts for over 12 years in the books (19 years in the movies). Even with control of the Spacing Guild, it still took that long to conquer the known universe.

I also think it's reasonable to assume that the Fremen weren't the only fighting force supporting Paul. There were likely other forces and populations under his control contributing to the war effort. Even so, the Fremen must have taken a significant hit to their fighting-age population.


r/dune • • 1d ago

Dune: Part Two (2024) How do they transport large numbers of people on a sandworm all at once?

62 Upvotes

Hello! Sorry if this is a dumb question, but ever since my first watch of the movies, I’ve always wondered about the logistics behind sandworm travel.

​I’ve seen both films countless times now, in fact, I just walked out of a theater double-feature 30 minutes ago! I brought my friend along for his first viewing, and he ended up asking the exact same question.

​I haven't read the books (if that wasn't obvious by now), so I’d love to hear your theories, lore explanations, or actual facts from Frank Herbert's writing. That would be splendid!


r/dune • • 1d ago

General Discussion How do you deal with the repetitive metaphysical stuff in the books? (I need advice on reading the books 🙏🏻)

0 Upvotes

Hey guys!

I really enjoy the Dune universe, but sometimes I find the books very difficult to read.

I'm specifically talking about those long, strange, repetitive, almost metaphysical and mystical passages describing the characters' inner experiences.

At first, I tried to approach these passages as some kind of meditative experience, rather than something I had to fully understand. And honestly, that worked for a while. But sometimes they just feel too nonsensical, surreal and (what is the worst) repetitive to the point where I lose track of what's going on and become bored.

Has anyone else felt this way? Did rereading the books and paying a lot of attention help you make sense of these passages, or is that slightly surreal feeling just part of the Dune experience?

I am now finishing Children of Dune.

Thank you!


r/dune • • 1d ago

Fan Art / Project ECLIPSE - by me, created in Krita

Post image
855 Upvotes

I just love the design approach to the costumes of the movies. Especially the sardaukar and harkonnen-soldiers. They have such a gritty realistic space vibe about them. And of course the Eclipse- Scene from PART 2 is one of the best movie-opening-sequences I have ever seen (on any standpoint: sound design, cinematography, special effects, practical effects, COSTUMES and and and!)


r/dune • • 1d ago

Merchandise Dune Messiah graphic novel book 1 - my review

9 Upvotes

I'm going to say that I enjoyed this, pretty much. But I'm not going to recommend it - at least not yet.

Dune Messiah is, of course, the sequel to Dune. Set some 12 years later, Paul and his Fremen rule the galaxy - though there are still plots against Paul's rule. Without spoiling the story, that is all I'm going to say of it. The unfortunate thing here, and why I'm not recommending this yet, is because of one reason:

It's too damn short.

Dune Messiah was never a long book - compared to the rest of Frank's Dune books it looks quite out of place, about half the size of the others. It also does not seem to have any sort of cliffhangers which would allow the story to be broken into two parts, unlike Dune which is split into three "books" (and did so successfully for it's set of graphic novels). Instead, when this book ends, I was left thinking "is that it?".

As such, I can't help but say that, unless you want this right now, wait for the box set of parts 1 and 2.

BUT - and I capitalise that to give it emphasis - there's still a lot to like here, and still some to dislike. I always try to comment on the cover and here I should say I'm not a fan, but that's me. With the Dune comics I always tried to get covers that appeal to me (and there are so many dark covers - why?!?). Here we simply have Paul. Give me landscapes, mystery, intrigue.

The finish of the book itself - its not as big as the Dune graphic novels, but still has some impressive visuals beneath the dust jacket - an explosion in what I feel is either the stone burner or the moon crashing down, and contrasts between the sea and desert. We have some sketches of pages, abd the usual forewords and bios of everyone involved. I just wish that Brian would write some new forewords, I'm pretty sure I've read these ones before.

On to the meat of the product, Dune Nessiah itself then... or Dune Messiah part 1 of 2. As I say, there doesn't seem to be a cliffhanger here. I am not as familiar with Dune Messiah as I am with Dune but, by and large, everything does seem accurate, though I feel we are lacking a large amount of subtext. For instance, when Paul commands Korba to pretend to be him and lead today's prayer, I seem to remember Paul giving a brief lesson to the others present (which may have only been Stilgar) about the role of religious figureheads. I could be mistaken. Yet here, it is just about entirely at the level of what is needed to advance the plot. But still, it is unquestionably Dune Messiah and I can't put my finger on any inaccuracies.

Much like the Baron Harkonnen, I like a good villain, and Dune Messiah has four of them. Individually theyre not as appealing as the Baron but the early chapter with the four of them conspiring was something I ate right up. We also have a bonus in the form of an opening chapter involving Bronso, a character who writes many of the passages between chapters which I don't think is in the original book but was released elsewhere (if anyone can recall where this was released please tell me), and serves as a useful device to frame the story, as it were.

Art is handled by a different artist this time, Michael Shelfer, who previously illustrated some of the Dune: House Harkonnen comics. And I have to say, the results are mixed. The original Dune graphic novels had a flatter, more static and, dare I say, muted look. Initially I found book 1 of Dune disappointing because of this, but books 2 and 3 the art style grew into them. They were detailed and rich, even if the designs felt unimaginative at times and the characters simply posed.

Here, the artwork is more fluid, rounded, and less detailed. It is more dynamic, definitely. I think I've said this before about how the Dune prelude comics evolved but it feels at times like a 90s cartoon. Characters can have exaggerated features, such as the wizened Mohiam and the oafish disguises worn by Scytale. When this is detailed it is a delight, with Arrakeen's dustry streets, but other times it feels indistinct.

I will say that the Navigator Edric is a joy to behold, a creature seemingly composed entirely of the orange spice gas, he appears so alien and yet familiar. This book now seems to have moved to the comics' look for the Dune world - as such the fleeting glimpses we saw in the original graphic novels of what I thought were insectoid Navigators have been replaced by the haunting ghouls of the comics.

In conclusion, the artwork is mostly on point - there were a few panels where it didn't work for me, but not many. The story seems to be the Dune Messiah I remember, but - I think - lacking a lot of the subtext. But I wish there was more, and I came away with a general feeling of "and then?". The end didn't so much as leave me hankering for the next one as it did leave me frustrated at its incompleteness. As such, unless you want to buy them individually or cannot wait, I'd recommend waiting for the inevitable box set.


r/dune • • 1d ago

Dune: Part Three (2026) How much do you think Irulan’s storyline will change in Dune 3? Spoiler

28 Upvotes

(Spoilers ahead!)
Irulan isn’t a main character in the books, but she’s still essential to the plot, even after Dune Messiah. However, after seeing the children all grown up in the trailer, I’m wondering what her role will be in the movie. Will she only be involved in the conspiracy against Paul?
I also read that Zendaya and Florence Pugh have quite a few scenes together in the movie, but how would that work if Chani runs away from Paul at the end of Part Two? The two of them shouldn’t really have any interactions.
I feel like the story is going to change quite a bit compared to the book, and that the trailer isn’t just trying to mislead us.
So maybe Irulan won’t even make it to the end of the movie? But if that’s the case, any future adaptations by a different director would have to change quite a bit too.


r/dune • • 2d ago

Fan Art / Project Baron Harkonnen fanart, Me, Ps+Rebelle

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

I hope you like it guys!


r/dune • • 2d ago

Dune (2021) Dune Re-release Bonus footage

109 Upvotes

I've got tickets for both the releases next week!!! It'll be the first time I'm watching it in theaters and the first time my friend has ever watched it. I was wondering if anyone who's seen it knows if the Bonus footage that has scenes from Part 3 is shown before or after the movie (And which one? Both Part 1 and Part 2?) Thanks !


r/dune • • 2d ago

Dune: Part Three (2026) The Art and Soul of Dune: Part Three Legacy Edition, now on Kickstarter. Available for non-US people.

25 Upvotes

r/dune • • 2d ago

Dune (novel) How reliable is Suk Imperial Conditioning, really?

101 Upvotes

I'm reading the first book because I want to finish it and the second novel before the next movie comes out.

I'm really enjoying the book so far, but I was pretty disappointed by the revelation of how Dr. Yueh's conditioning was broken. It basically seems like the good old "kidnap someone's loved one and use them as leverage" strategy. Am I missing something here? Given how the book has been building up its world, I found the explanation surprisingly simplistic.

I wouldn't normally mind a simple explanation in an otherwise great book. It happens from time to time. But I feel like this is too big of a plot point to hinge on something so straightforward.

How am I supposed to believe that Hawat, Jessica, Paul, and Leto never even considered the possibility of Yueh betraying them? (To be fair to Jessica, she does consider it, but quickly dismisses the idea)

And why does everyone in the Dune universe place so much trust in Suk conditioning if it can be broken by one of the oldest blackmail tactics in the book?


r/dune • • 2d ago

General Discussion Christmas gifts for my Dune-loving partner

25 Upvotes

Please remove this if it's not allowed, but I'm thinking of Christmas gifts for my partner who loves the Dune series. I was originally looking for a first-edition, but, that doesn't look like it's gonna be happening any time soon 😭 so now I'm looking for other ideas. Unfortunately, he already has the Dune lego set, too. What would you guys want to see under the tree this year?


r/dune • • 3d ago

Dune (novel) Where the Hell is Thufir after the harkonnen attack?

Post image
97 Upvotes

Okay so after the Harkonnen attack, Thufir says that he and his troopers are 200km south east of arrakeen and north of the shield wall sieches. The issue i have with that is that, according to the map, Arrakeen is already at the south edge of the imperial basin, and there don’t appear to be any sieches immediately south of it. The only way i see where thufir could be 200km from Arrakeen and north of any sieches is if he is where i‘ve drawn him on the map, but it seems like a massive stretch to call that SOUTH-east when it‘s barely south of it, and, since we‘re looking at the north pole and it‘s clockwise, shouldn‘t it be south west?