r/dune • • Mar 11 '24

Dune: Part Two (2024) Chani and the Empowered Woman Stereotype in ‘Dune: Part Two’: No Family, No Faith, Just Fight. Chani's portrayal in the 'Dune' movies eliminates key roles she held in the book, reducing her agency and depth as a character.

Thumbnail
dunenewsnet.com
1 Upvotes

r/dune • • May 27 '24

Dune: Part Two (2024) Who might have played a better Chani?

0 Upvotes

I want to preface this by saying that I think Zendaya is a good actor so no hate towards her whatsoever.

I just finished watching dune pt 2 for the third time and it’s one of my all time favorite sci fi movies. But a problem I can’t seem to get over is the character Chani. First of all the chemistry between Zendaya and Chalamete is god awful. I see zero connection between these two actors. Maybe it’s the fact that she has a bf or maybe it’s Timothee’s fault or the writing idk. Was wondering if anyone might be able to diagnose why this relationship completely failed.

Another problem was Zendaya’s accent. I understand that they made a distinction between the Fremens southern and northern accents but none of the northern costars had an American accent that I remember. She just seems terribly out of place compared to her fremen costars, like Souheila Yacoub, who had the accent and honestly had a better performance. Zendaya just sticks out like a sore thumb when they’re in the same scenes.

Idk if it’s just me but Zendaya doesn’t give me a Chani vibe. I can’t tell if she’s scowling/brooding or if she’s about to cry. When I think of Chani(film series not the books) I think of a tough bad*ss fremen warrior and it might just be me but Zendaya doesn’t give off that vibe.

Again this is all just my opinion but are there any actresses who you can think of who might you think could have played a good Chani?


r/dune • • Jul 01 '24

General Discussion What are your thoughts on Earth being in Dune

7 Upvotes

Like at first I did not think Earth Was a thing in Dune Like in Star Wars where Earth does not exist But when I was Listening to the audio book of Dune Messiah Earth Is mentioned and Hitler.


r/dune • • Mar 08 '24

General Discussion Why is Dune so popular?

6 Upvotes

I'm 26 and I just heard about the Dune universe last week because of their map packs on RISK the board game. Today I just learned that Dune is one of the best-selling science fiction books of all-time.

Why? What makes it stand out compared to other science-fiction films and why after over 50 years is it still so popular?

As someone who doesn't follow sci-fi, I first assumed that the newest Dune film was a knock-off Star Wars film, as many films in the 2020's lack creativity and like to spin-off blockbuster titles... Turns out I was dead wrong. Star Wars was actually inspired by Dune, so obviously I'm quite ignorant to Dune's impact in sci-fi culture.

I'd like to understand your culture and interest better, please share your thoughts.

Thank you.


r/dune • • Nov 21 '21

Dune (2021) Dune (2021) is Very Bad

12 Upvotes

Dune (2021) is very bad in two major ways: (1) it's a bad film, (2) it doesn't understand the source material. I'm going to address these in reverse order.

When I say it doesn't understand the source material I'm not talking about missing or changing minor elements of lore. I don't think films should be held to strictly following their source material as they're their own artistic conception. However, Dune (2021) tries and fails to convey the major thematic elements of the novel in spectacular fashion.

Let's start with Paul... Paul Atreides is one of my favorite characters in all of fiction. In Dune (2021) instead of the intelligent, stoic, and strong young man in the novel we're given a finnicky, emotional, spaz in Chalamet's portrayal. There really is nothing impressive about Paul in Dune (2021) - he stammers in his words, he second guesses himself, he loses his shit like an angsty teenager, he even walks around hunched over like he's being sent to his room. The Paul Atreides of the novel is extremely disciplined in every thing he does. He's been bred and trained to be exactly this. All of his actions and words are deliberate and precisely controlled, and it is this that makes him the universe's super being. Yes the spice enhances him, but it is simply that - an enhancement, not a transformation. If you're going to become the most powerful man in the universe (the Kwisatz Haderach) then you need to be at the cutting edge in every way from day one. But Dune (2021) trades in this elitism for an everyman whiney teen of an aristocrat, which is contrary to who and what Paul is. Plus watching Chalamet drool like a drug addict every time he gets a whiff of the spice was so deflating.

There are other significant things that Dune (2021) gets wrong about Dune and the most glaring is the supernatural. To put it simply: there is no magic in Dune. The Bene Gesserit are not psychic and neither is Paul. The voice is not a super power. In Dune many of the major characters have a form of hyper-intelligence that gives them certain skills. It may be a kind of extreme intuition that helps them predict future events given the details of the current political landscape, but these are not premonitions. It may be a kind of extreme sensitivity and understanding of biology that allows them to speak in such a precise way to hack the minds of the others, but this is not a superpower. David Lynch's Dune (1984) also failed to portray these things adequately, but Dune (2021) takes Lynch's failure even further and it has a big impact. For example the scene where Jessica is psychically assisting Paul through the trial of the box is both silly and laughably subverting the entire point.

I could spend forever combing through every scene of Dune (2021) with this critique, but I don't see any need. It's just painfully obvious that Villeneuve didn't understand that extreme intelligence and discipline are the lifeblood of Dune, or at least the portrayal on screen was completely inadequate and often contradictory.

So let me change focus to how bad the filmmaking was...

Villeneuve is a great director when it comes to drama. Prisoners and Sicario are two of my favorite films. But all of his sci-fi movies (Arrival, Blade Runner 2045) have fallen completely flat with me for same reasons. They're bland, poorly written, psuedo-intellectual, pretentious garbage; and Dune (2021) is probably the worst of the three. It joins Christopher Nolan's movies (Interstellar, The Dark Knight) in being just a dumb, wanna-be profound, contrived, needlessly dark action movie. It's sci-fi for people who don't know anything about science. It's philosophy for people with a teenage understanding of philosophy. It's art for people with only the most superficial conception of art.

Dune (2021) the film itself has so many flaws, that I won't be able to address them all. Many have noted the terrible dialogue and criticized that it didn't take advantage of the poetic dialogue from the novel, which is fair, but it's ironic that the best dialogue in the movie comes when it's not trying to paraphrase the novel while avoiding sounding too much like Dune (1984). What's worse is the actors are constantly rushing through or chewing their awful lines as if they only did a single take, but it's not their faults. Overall the movie has terrible pacing and is constantly leaping from plot point to plot point like a child connecting dots on a page, and everything suffers as a result. The characters end up being mostly lifeless and every scene has so little breathing room that it's hard to take anything in. Dune (2021) ends up relying on Dune (1984) a lot as a result - for example you practically need to have seen Lynch's version of the box scene to understand the gravity of what is happening in Villeneuve's rushed and poorly developed version.

People have praised the cinematography, but I have to disagree with this. While the movie does have some interesting visuals, overall it is colorless and bland. It might just be a matter of preference, but Villeneuve's version of minimalism often comes off to me as simpleton-ism. He is hiding a lack of visual skill by doing less with less for the sake of not being able to do more with more. He mostly uses wide-angle shots to give a false sense of grandeur to his scenes. He employs similar tricks including darkening the image and slapping on some unusual music to give people the sense that this is high art, when really it's just surface deep pretentiousness with very little artistic merit. In fact it was a bit disturbing how often the score was a complete tonal mismatch with what was going on on screen. The only place where Dune (2021) really shines over its predecessor is the action scenes, but the action was never what really made Dune great, and it's not any better than other CGI-vomit sci-fi like the more recent Star Wars and Star Trek films.

I'm droning on here, but to summarize I have to agree with Jodorowsky's prediction that this is just "industrial cinema". Villeneuve has found a crowd pleasing formula with his previous sci-fi films and Dune (2021) is simply the result of turning a crank and grinding out more movie. It's especially a problem here because what makes Dune so beloved is that it is incredibly insightful, interesting, and metered; which is everything that Dune (2021) is not.

EDIT: Thanks for all of the responses. I appreciate that we don't agree, but that opens up more opportunities to explore this. The personal attacks aren't very impressive, but of course: the salt must flow.


r/dune • • Jun 30 '25

Dune: Part Two (2024) A Dissenting Opinion on Villeneuve's Dune 2

0 Upvotes

Wow just finished watching Villeneuve's Dune 2 for the first time and I was suprised to find that I actually prefer many aspects of the 1984 version despite thinking it is an execrable film for years. I think the biggest failure of the film is Chalamet's acting. His approach reminds of certain Nicolas Cage movies where he has this dour shoe-gazing mumble most of the film and then launches into abrasive screaming to give power to certain lines. Two modes of acting. I don't think anyone can argue that the 1984 movie didn't present a one-dimensional version of Paul but at least MacLachlan had charisma and camraderie that felt authentic.

Can't stand how prescience/psychoactive experience is depicted in either of the movies. Villeneuve basically uses Paul's experience of prescience solely to forecast what new popular actress is going to be in the next movie. I don't understand how a self-respecting filmmaker can take a premise like Other Memory and turn it into such a bland cinematic experience. The idea of being adrift amongst countless previous lives feels like an opportunity that cinema could make truly disorienting and Villeneuve, like Lynch, didn't even try.

The Harkonnens were toothless and forgettable in Villeneuve's Dune. They were clowns in Lynch's version but at least their surrealist forms of torture were memorable. Villeneuve's Harkonnens victimize their nameless faceless servants and cast Zoolander looks at each other but can anyone say they felt terrifying for all of their vampiric chic? It was a mistake in some ways to make two movies because the Harkonnens just appeared to be stumbling lackeys for the entirety of Dune 2 and their deaths just felt perfunctory.

Don't understand certain changes they made like the BG being in favor of exterminating all Atreides. Yeah it has always seemed odd in the books that BG don't do more to mitigate the fall of the Atreides. But this change only adds more problems. Why even subject Paul to the pain box if he is just meant to die? Why try to surreptitiously do away with Paul and Jessica if the BG truthsayers don't care how they met their fate?

Felt like the revisionist version of Chani was an interesting idea that the filmmakers didn't really develop enough. They wanted to have it both ways and show a romantic relationship with two popular actors and also make it seem like a deep ideological wedge was being driven between the two characters that didn't exist in the book. It seems like if Chani didn't believe in the religious or ecological ends of Paul's mission then she should have moved against him in a significant way earlier in the film.

Anyway just sharing a dissenting opinion since the movie is so widely lionized.


r/dune • • Jun 13 '24

Dune: Part Two (2024) Not a fan of Chani in the new movies...

98 Upvotes

I thought part 1 was great and part 2 was over the top amazing...except for the changes to Chani's character. Great acting by Zendaya, but the character came off (to me) as whiny and unreasonable in a couple of key ways.

First, she's pissed because the Bene Gesserit have inserted a false prophecy about the Lisan al Gaib into the Fremen religion and the fundamentalist Fremen get carried away believing the lie. That's totally fair, but even after she sees first-hand that Paul really does fulfill that prophesy and all the things the Mahdi is supposed to do, she still acts like it's wrong to follow him.

Second thing is how she wants the Fremen to be self sufficient, save themselves and overthrow the Harkonens without some outsider's help. Again fair enough. So Paul joins their tribe, goes through all the rituals, learns to ride a sandworm, risks his life to fight alongside the Fremen and she's still saying he's not a "real" Fremen. Give the guy a break Chani. Not to mention, the Fremen could have defeated the Harkonens in terms of military superiority before Paul came, but they obviously needed a charismatic leader, him or someone else, to unite them and get the ball rolling. For thousands of years apparently they weren't having much luck saving themselves, but when Paul starts to have success and is actually helping her (and his adopted) people...oh no, that's not good enough for Chani...

Why in the world did Denis take the character in this direction?? Is new Chani appealing to a lot of people, like in the younger audience?


r/dune • • Sep 21 '25

General Discussion The Fremen being desert dwellers, tribal and religious doesn't make sense to me as a Saudi.

0 Upvotes

Hi,

Not taking long from your time. So in Saudi, we are divided between bedouins/nomads/desert-dwellers who are tribal, and city dwellers who carry urban last names (ie Smith) and not really tribal.

The tribal bedouins aren't really religious, they lived off camel herding and the occasional kidnapping of pilgrims on their way to Makkah. While the city dwellers are not tribal and live in houses with built mosques to worship and study in.

To us, Making the Fremen religious and tribal at the same time is, with all due respect, an oxymoron.


r/dune • • Dec 14 '23

Dune (2021) Anyone else disappointed with the combat in the Dune movie?

0 Upvotes

I really enjoyed the Dune movie, and thought it was a fantastic adaption from the book (At least, as fantastic as compiling a novel into 2 1/2 hours can be), however something that really bothered me was the sword combat. They fight as if they don’t have shields, where they constantly strike fast and hard, instead of being slow and strategic. I think that with some well done choreography, they could have made the scenes really special but other than the scene with Paul and Gurney training the rest of the fight scenes don’t make much sense given they use shields.


r/dune • • Sep 05 '23

Dune (2021) I think the movie(s) could have improved if they ended Dune 2021 after the murder of Leto Atreides Spoiler

0 Upvotes

A lot of people talk about the length of the movie, and obviously they can’t have a regular feature length movie without cutting serious portions from the books. But I think they could have an easier time making the movies if they had it as a trilogy.

One would be a formal introduction of the Atreides family, with all the introductions to important characters, discussions, deceit and intent. It would really highlight the characters in detail to lead up to why Leto’s demise happened despite taking careful precautions.

Two could be Paul’s journey on Arrakis, their travels into the desert and introduction into the Fremen tribes, showing his journey and development.

Last could be the final strike against the Harkonnens and ultimately the Emperor, highlighting Paul’s downfall as a leader.

It may not be the best, but I really feel like if the movie felt too bulky, instead of cutting coveted scenes between the characters, why not just split the movies further to give characters the screen time they deserve?


r/dune • • Apr 18 '24

Children of Dune Why is Shadam IV in power? And who, if anyone is above him?

0 Upvotes

If it's explained in the books then don't tell me, I'm 200 pages into Children of Dune right now.

But my only confusion so far is the hierachal nature of all the houses? Why is House Corrino the leading house? Why is Shadam IV the empower over all? Is there anyone above him? How did he come to power? Who is the Space Guild?

Again. If this gets answered later I'm Children of Dune or books 4-6 then let me know and I'll delete.

Or maybe I missed it completely in what I've already read. The hierarchy of power just hasn't clicked yet for me


r/dune • • Mar 01 '24

Dune: Part Two (2024) Dune II Movie Reaction - We got cheated [Spoilers within] Spoiler

0 Upvotes

As a fan and multi-time reader of the Dune books, I could not wait to see how the Baron's death would be visualized on the big screen. The character of Alia earning her name and legendary status in the world of Dune was something that would be so cool to see portrayed in a movie of this magnitude. You can imagine my surprise, when not only did we not see Alia (except for the flash forward/vision sequence), but the baron is instead quickly and unceremoniously dispatched by Paul. Like WTF?

I do not understand this choice at all. Alia should have been around age 5 and kicking ass on the battlefield as "Alia the Knife." We should have been treated to her mocking and scaring the shit out of the reverent mother Helen Mohiam. But no. I'm sure there is some reason for the change, but it really bugs the hell out of me that we were robbed of that scene.

There are plenty of other weird and unfortunate choices for me as well. Like, why is Jessica having full on conversations with unborn Alia? I don't remember that from the book. I remember that only happening after she's born. Before which she just had a sense of her consciousness.

Why is Stilgar dumbed down into a backwards religious zealot?

Why are there factions amongst the Fremen, where people like Stilgar are seen to be old, southern, religious dipshits? They seem to be trying to bring an awareness of the oppressive cultural aspects that the BG use to control the Fremen to the way the younger, more "cool" Fremen youth like Chani regard their way of life and the prophecies that rule them.

Why is Jessica heavily leaning on Paul's messiah status and being portrayed as a sinister and exploitative cult leader type? I understand the entire point of the BG is to subvert through religious manipulation, etc, but if anything in the first book, Paul and Jessica are treading lightly on his messiah status. They find themselves increasingly more freaked out by the reaction of the Fremen to the prophesies laid out by the Missionaria Protectiva and where things are rapidly headed. In the movie, Jessica is actively exploiting the power of the legends and leaning hard into using them to her advantage.

There are other things too, like Feud's fight scene and the reaction of Chani to Paul's plan with Princess Irulan. Like.... okay, Chani is mad as hell and storm's out? In the book she thinks it's a great strategic decision to use Irulan as a fake wife for the political advantage. Ugh.

Thoughts?


r/dune • • Mar 02 '24

Dune: Part Two (2024) Denis Villanueve has done justice to Frank Herbert’s book Dune by restoring some aspects of its Islamic and Muslim source material

0 Upvotes

Of course one of the biggest criticisms is that Muslim actors and Arab actors weren’t included to a larger degree such as why Chani wasn’t played by a Muslim actress? Stilgar should have been an older Arab actor. But then again this is far better than David Lynches version in that the references to the Islamic culture and dress was actually incorporated into this movie.

The actual book has tons of Islamic references and middle eastern references that was missing in the David Lynch version which was restored in this version. Unlike part 1 which had virtually no Arab actors there was some in the second half. The pronunciations of Arabic words were kind of off but then again as someone who knows some Arabic the language needs to be improved in Dune Messiah. But references to Islamic terms like Mahdi and Jinn was quite prominent. Especially the term Lisan Al Ghaib throughout the movie and it’s good that these references which were in the book was brought into Dune Part 1 and 2.


r/dune • • Dec 29 '24 Take My Silver

All Books Spoilers Is Dune really a warning against charismatic leaders?

0 Upvotes

Let's start weird: Is Harry Potter the villain of his books?

I read the text multiple times at various ages, starting with my early teens. It's a very important book for me. That said, looking at the text, I would say no. Paul is not the villain, unless you are a Bene Gesserit witch that is. Paul is pretty much the hero. He is literally Harry Potter. Or, to be fair, Harry Potter is him. Why? That special child born of true love, of worthy and very special parents? Both characters have a sort of 'quality' or 'power' instilled in them from birth, due to their lineage. And the Griffindor are the Atreides and the Slytherines are the Harknonnens so on and so forth. Is Harry Potter the villain?

Let's jump to another similar IP: GoT, or more correctly ASOIAF. Beloved and hated alike, it is universally known. It's clear as day, the formula repeats itself. Honorable Ned Stark and his House Atre...Stark. Their cultural themes are very different, the Atreides being more ancient greek/bullfighters, so generally a Southern European vibe and the Starks being very very Anglo Saxon/Northern (but not Viking). And the Lannisters arguably being sort of opposite culturally to the northern themed Harkonnens, their moral counterparts. Even in this very 'realpolitik' setting of ASOIAF it's hard to argue the Starks are not the good guys. Ned Stark upholds honour and truth. Justice. Their House words are literally "Winter is coming" a warning towards the absolute villain from the series (undoubtedly the Night King). Sure there is 'narrator bias' cause 'we start with the Starks and that's why we like them' but look at the text, look at the facts. Even when they go to war, they fight initially for the rightful king Stannis and then for their own independence (King in the North). They do not seek plunder, dominion over others. Of course there are people that will say that the Boltons are the good guys and the Starks are horrid and we can all understand where that is coming from.

Now back to Dune. Why isn't the series only a 100 page pamphlet warning us of 'charismatic leaders'? If that's it's intent, it could have been a 4 verse poem, with or without rhyme. So, dive in the text. What do we know? There is a Bene Gesserit breeding program running well since pretty much forever as we are concerned. Ok, those ladies clearly know something or at least hunch at something for keeping it running. So it's an objective thing which has objective value for some of the parties at least. Moving on to prescience. It doesn't seem to be a scam because the Spacing Guild uses it to travel across the stars. Fact. Let's move to the Golden Path. It seems pretty legit. It's not Leto II's hallucination because Paul Atreides, to his credit, refused to take it. But that means he SAW the Golden Path. So did Siona ages later...so that leads me to say that the Golden Path is not an ideology, it's an objective, real pathway. Like the North Star pointing north nowadays is an objective, real 'thing'. An immaterial object if you will. And further more, it is not optional.

Now a short recap of everything: we have this huge time and galaxy spanning breeding program on top of which Lady Jessica throws some old fashion *love on top of to make Paul Atreides. This is not your simple hero genesis, it's mythical hero genesis. I'm thinking the likes of Hercules, Achiles or Jesus. The breeding program plus the *love being the 'divine' part of the equation. So I'm afraid Paul is not a warning...in the books dear reader, Paul Atreides is the REAL MESSIAH. To his credit, he lashes out at least once against his mother for what they (BG breeding program) did to him, made him this superhuman he never wanted to be. He abhors the Jihad utterly and down right refuses the Golden Path. He is reluctant to kill Jamis. He is just a (very special though) boy thrown into the cruel jaws of reality. Arrakis grade reality. I don't know man, he seems pretty much a good decent fellow in my book at least...

| He is almost predestined, preordained to do what he does, to become the Messiah |

The first book at least is infused with tragedy, a sense of fate. Do you recall the scene of Duncan Idaho being drunk and rowdy, completely depressed by their household relocation? The Lady Jessica sends him swiftly to bed. Also the head of the bull that killed Leto's father in the arena. Lots of stuff the movies missed on. Heck, my main beef with Villneuve's Dune is the whole 'Atreides on Arrakis' first half of the book is just glossed over. You don't even get to see Yueh more that two times...I would have loved a lot less generic desert shots with epic music and more dramatic development. Remember Hawat vs Jessica? They almost killed each other. Due to Baron Harkonnen's brilliant but twistted mentat Peter de Vries's plotting.

So let's get to the point, I've ranted long enough. What was Frank Herbert up to?

Well, the core theme of Dune is not politics nor is it (psycho)history. It's ecology. What is ecology? It's a systems science. A discipline that focuses on studying various biological and physical systems and their interplay. Dune is a 'systems' book. The end aim of the first half of Dune is the 'Kwisatz Haderach'. Let's understand that concept. we live in an ecological system, but as humans, we are, in a way, outside that system. We can see it from 'above'. We transcended ecology. We can modify it to better or worse, according to our will. We see the interplay, we see through the matrix so to speak. We can 'choose' to extinct species (wolves in western europe), we can choose to save species. We are aware of the 'patterns' governing the world. The Kwizatz Haderach is to Humankind what humans are to the biosphere. A being that can 'see' broader patterns. He can see 'the way'. His only aim is to prevent the extinction of humankind. Initially he cares not about it, but his gift inexorably slowly pushes him towards that resolution. That drives right through the ecological theme of the book. Survival, extinction. That's why fundamentally, Frank Herbert wrote Arrakis the way it is. The most extreme environment that could still accommodate human life with little to no tech. I mean it's not Mustafar by a long shot.

So, all that being said, Paul Atreides is NOT a villain. He is a tragic figure at most, torn apart by the forces of destiny. His ancient greek lineage plays straight into this sense of tragedy. He doesn't want the Jihad, he most certainly doesn't want the Golden Path. But he wants to live. And he has no choice.

Now for the elephant in the room. Why would Frank Herbert 'bash' his own creation? Well there is a difference between the author Frank Herbert, a being of supreme power who is the demiurge of the Dune universe, and the human Frank Herbert who has to survive and eventually sell his books to a wider world. He lived and wrote in the 60', an era of decolonisation, hippies, psychedelics, rampant communism and fresh american hegemonism over the free world. Oil, spice and everything nice. An era where 'Great Houses' were no longer great, where the notion of empire war frowned upon. An era where the concept of race and racism where at the forefront. A lot of people read the book and said 'Aha the White Saviour complex' and 'Colonialist propaganda! What a fraud!'

I can imagine good ol' Frank sitting in his study pondering 'is that all there is?'

But being a hippy himself, knowing the nomenclature, he manipulated the general groupthink of the day with this notion that 'Dune is a warning against charismatic leaders'. And of course, at this level he was sincere. It can very well work that way to a superficial reader. He skillfully threw in the Kennedy example, which in that social context is valid. And probably that's why Dune wasn't canceled. Remember that.

Dune is not a book about a charismatic leader inventing some bullshit and bullshitting his way through the crowds like Hitler or Mussolini...it's a book of social engineering and systems interplay where things just happen because of cause and effect. The BG want the KH, they get him. But it's not quite what they expected. More important, when they expected. It's a world of systems and broad strokes where the INDIVIDUAL spark plays a huge role. It's a pretty good analogy of our own world, maybe one of the best in literary history.

Thanks for the read,

Log out

* - explaining the love part: it was instilled by Duke Leto I Atreides of Caladan. He is actually the 'charismatic leader' FH was warning us of...I read of his comparison of Leto and Kennedy. And again, like Ned Stark and others, he is a medieval ruler. The system is oppressive by default. But it's all we have in the Dune books. The darker the night, the brighter the stars. And in that night, Leto shines bright. Heck, it's said when he died a comet lightened the Caladan sky.


r/dune • • Jan 16 '25

All Books Spoilers Sexuality and Dune

7 Upvotes

I don’t know how to do spoilers so I’m just pushing this down.

So clearly Duncan has issues with homosexuality, but the Fremen/their descendants in the Fish Speakers accept this.

Homosexuality does not seem to be maligned in the broader Dune universe. So I’m confused as to why the Bene Gesserit and Honored Matre are exclusively focused on heterosexuality.

Like I totally understand from a breeding perspective. But just as sex does not exclusively equal breeding, why wouldn’t each faction have men or women conditioned to same sex manipulation if it could result in power play? Clearly homosexuality is a regular human occurrence in the Dune universe. It just seems strange that neither faction would train not just women but also men to act as controllers of current political/power issues.

I know these are women-focused power bases, but with all the emphasis on breeding could they not create men and women suited to homosexual political machinations? Surely organizations with such power over breeding could produce men who could seduce other men but also be controlled. They could have a certain amount of Bene Gesserit training to be useful but have some sort of Voice trigger that brings them back into control.

I understand the fear of another KH but like…there are gay politicians you’d want to take control of.

Maybe I’m just looking too deep into this lol


r/dune • • Jun 12 '25

Dune (novel) Paul IS a Hero in Dune and labelling him a Villain is lame and not justified Spoiler

2 Upvotes

When discussing Paul's role in the Jihad a pretty common and widespread opinion almost always comes up: Paul had a choice when he saw his visions for the first time ( while awake of course earlier he saw glimpses of visions in his dreams) in the tent or at some later points before the ,,point of no return". I would like to explore my problems with this sentiment, because the text is pretty contradictory to this view in my opinion. Huge spoilers ahead for Dune and perhaps some minor ones for later books.... This will be a long so please bear with me.

Firstly, let's start by how Herbert describes Paul's ability:

,,Abruptly, as though he had found a necessary key, Paul's mind climbed another notch in awareness. He felt himself clinging to this new level, clutching at a precarious hold and peering about. It was as though he existed within a globe with avenues radiating away in all directions . . . yet this only approximated the sensation. He remembered once seeing a gauze kerchief blowing in the wind and now he sensed the future as though it twisted across some surface as undulant and impermanent as that of the windblown kerchief. He saw people. He felt the heat and cold of uncounted probabilities. He knew names and places, experienced emotions without number, reviewed data of innumerable unexplored crannies. There was time to probe and test and taste, but no time to shape. The thing was a spectrum of possibilities from the most remote past to the most remote future--from the most probable to the most improbable". This is what his prescience allows him to see, he can see possibilities, and not only that, but also how probable they are. He sees tremendeous ammount of paths in the future and in the past aswell. Also it is also said that he only sees bits and pieces of this futures: ,, The awareness conveyed both reassurance and alarm--so many places on that other kind of terrain dipped or turned out of his sight."

This is crucial to my argument, so we will come back to this in a moment. So onto the actual argument: one of the most stated opinion in these discussions is this: Paul could have chosen the Guild(or Baron(about him later:)) route because he saw this as a possibility. I have a few problems with this statement: just earlier in this chapter we learn about Harkonnens in Atreides uniform raiding a Guild bank:

,,... the Guild Bank has been sacked." Carthag! Jessica thought. That was a Harkonnen hotbed. "They're Sardaukar," the voice said. "Watch out for Sardaukar in Atreides uniforms. They're . . . " A roaring filled the speaker, then silence. "Try the other bands," Paul said. "Do you realize what that means?" Jessica asked. "I expected it. They want the Guild to blame us for destruction of their bank. With the Guild against us, we're trapped on Arrakis."

This pretty much sets up this path as impossible. Why would the Guild believe them over the Harkkonens when all evidence points to the Atreides House? I would consider into this the possibly many eyewitnesses and also the fact that it wouldnt make sense for the profit oriented Guild to take a risk and siding with a destroyed House with pretty much no power left at this point when against them stands the Emperor and the old-new rulers of Arrakis, the Harkonnens (and without evidence of fraud pretty much all of the other Great Houses) . Also lets not forget that Paul doesnt have anything to prove with that House Atreides was not involved in the bank sacking. It would be his word against everyone else and it would be pretty hard to believe in such an unbalanced scenario that the Guildsmen would even start to think about sheltering him or letting him join them.(This is the biggest problem if he could reach the Guild and meet their men but of course first he would have to escape from the desert which is an other big problem on its own of which I will talk about later. So back to the Guild: Up to the fifth book( I havent read the last one yet) we dont really see anything to suggest that prescience is wrong. There are many blindspots, which it cant see but essentially it isnt false, the broad strokes are seen perfectly clear. So by this sentiment I cannot go by the fact: Its stated that Paul saw this path as a real possibility. This must mean that in-universe there could be actually a way to achieve the Guild version of the future. Either Frank Herbert literally forgot what he wrote earlier or Paul could actually reach the Guild somehow. But we can reconcile this because as I cited earlier, Paul saw possibilities: Possibilities with various degree of probability from the least likely to the most likely. This is the most important thing to remember. So in short, there could have been a really really slim chance that somehow he could escape the desert and somehow convince the Guild to even negotiate with him. But this chance seems small because it seems pretty hard to achive it with Paul's visions being mostly patchy at this point so there is no surefire way of Paul knowing how to survive. It would really be a gamble to find a way he can navigate this path with and for what? Its an undiseriable outcome for him and he would need to take a huge risk while almost certainly dying along the way.

But then one might ask: There is an option with the Baron. We dont know what lays along this path so I wouldnt speculate on this, but it is certain that it made Paul disgusted. But even if we forget about the murder of Leto, his father and the butchering of the whole House Atreides and say that this is a possible way of surviving for Paul,then there are big problems with this still: We pretty much see that the Harkonnen thopters shoot at anything that moves.

,, An orange glare burst above the silhouette and a line of brilliant purple cut downward toward the glare. Another line of purple! And another upthrusting orange glare! It was like an ancient naval battle, remembered shellfire, and the sight held them staring. "Pillars of fire," Paul whispered. A ring of red eyes lifted over the distant rock. Lines of purple laced the sky. "Jetflares and lasguns," Jessica said. The dust-reddened first moon of Arrakis lifted above the horizon to their left and they saw a storm trail there--a ribbon of movement over the desert. "It must be Harkonnen 'thopters hunting us," Paul said. "The way they're cutting up the desert . . . it's as though they were making certain they stamped out whatever's there . . . the way you'd stamp out a nest of insects."

And currently Paul and Jessica are out in the open and the only way they could go without exposing themselfs to thopter fire is pretty much to the south along the rock formations in the direction of the fremen. So even if he choses the Baron or the Guild path he has to get out of the desert while being hunted by Harkonnen thopters who shoot at anything that moves and wouldnt really stop to negotiate with Paul. He would be annihilated from the sky when the Harkonnen mercenaries are not even in hearing distance.Aaand he would need to navigate the open desert back to Arakeen while also avoiding all the sandworms, which he only just barely could do when later he was moving towards the fremen and he also only needed to cross a small open distance relative to the distance to Arakeen aaaand the fremen basically had to saved him with calling the worm on their tail with a thumper.

While not forgetting that his vision is really muddy at this point and there are uncertainities almost at every corner, this would be a nearly impossible task. Taking any other option than the fremen path is not an option really, this way being the most secure and the only likely mostly safe path(to not die lol) with the Mahdi myth being the thing that would grant Paul and Jessica protection among the fremen.

But couldnt he later choose another direcion? Not really, after the night in the tent Duncan appears and Paul meets with Kynes. And it couldnt even be said that he starts by default positioning himself as a Messiah: firstly he tries to make a deal with Kynes: in exchange for the fremen providing proof of the Emperor's involvement in the attack he promises that he would make Arrakis green, speeding up Kynes's already existing plan. This way he could present the evidence to the Landsraad which would likely unite the other Houses against the Emperor because that's really the Landsraad's purpouse: to oppose the Emperor and prevent him from taking absolute power to himself:

"The Emperor will put a Harkonnen back in power here," Paul said. "Perhaps even Beast Rabban. Let him. Once he has involved himself beyond escaping his guilt, let the Emperor face the possibility of a Bill of Particulars laid before the Landsraad. Let him answer there where--" "Paul!" Jessica said. "Granted that the Landsraad High Council accepts your case," Kynes said, "there could be only one outcome: general warfare between the Imperium and the Great Houses." "Chaos," Jessica said. "But I'd present my case to the Emperor," Paul said, "and give him an alternative to chaos." Jessica spoke in a dry tone: "Blackmail?" "One of the tools of statecraft, as you've said yourself," Paul said, and Jessica heard the bitterness in his voice. "The Emperor has no sons, only daughters." "You'd aim for the throne?" Jessica asked. "The Emperor will not risk having the Imperium shattered by total war," Paul said. "Planets blasted, disorder everywhere--he'll not risk that."

This way Paul wouldnt become a messiah and he would not lead the Jihad. But of course life is a bitch, the Harkonnens storm the hideout forcing Paul to flee again this time with thopter and because they are chased by enemy aircrafts he cant escape anywhere he likes. When they're on foot again they are now much deeper in the desert, so my point about them escaping from the desert being a really slim chance then now converges to zero.

So why couldn't he choose another path when he finally meets the fremen? Its pretty straightfoward because some of the more conservative fremen(namely Jamis) almost try to kill him and his mother the moment they meet:

"Get their water," the man calling out of the night had said. And Paul fought down his fear, glanced at his mother. His trained eyes saw her readiness for battle, the waiting whipsnap of her muscles."

And then a little later they're certainly want to dispose of Jessica:

"It is well that you see the reason," Stilgar said. "We cannot dally here to test you, woman. Do you understand? We'd not want your shade to plague us. I will take the boy-man, your son, and he shall have my countenance, sanctuary in my tribe. But for you, woman--you understand there is nothing personal in this? It is the rule, Istislah, in the general interest. Is that not enough?"

After this moment Jessica overpowers Stilgar and basically the whole group finds themselfs in a stalemate. Jessica and Paul are much stronger and skilled than the fremen, but against all of them there they would stand no chance while being this outnumbered. Jessica notices this and starts to present herself and Paul as the people or gods fulfilling the prophecy that has been planted by the Bene Gesserit long time ago amongst the people of the desert:

,,Jessica recalled a chart Kynes had shown her while arranging emergency escape routes. How long ago it seemed. There had been a place called "Sietch Tabr" on the chart and beside it the notation: "Stilgar." "Perhaps when we get to Sietch Tabr," she said. The revelation shook him, and Jessica thought: If only he knew the tricks we use! She must've been good, that Bene Gesserit of the Missionaria Protectiva. These Fremen are beautifully prepared to believe in us."

Jessica recites prophecies and teachings of the fremen and says things that from the perspective of the fremen she couldn't possibly know. Therefore the fremen can really start to believe that they are the chosen one of their beliefs.
She does this because she knows the only way they can survive among them is by playing the messiah role otherwise her and Paul would probably be killed or left to die in the desert. And what does Paul do? Surely he starts to play into it aswell... But no he doesnt do this. We see that Jessica reaffirms time and time again that her and her son are special ones, she can easily do this knowing the machinations of the Missonaria Protectiva. She has all of the fremen in the palm of her hands and she could freely manipulate them as she sees fit.

Paul doesnt say anything that could suggest that he is the Lisan al Gaib! (up to the point of time skip into the third part of Dune, i mean the book) Not once. Yet this is brought up time and time again: he manipulated the fremen using religion to serve his own needs. But there isnt any evidence in the text for this. As I said he doesnt play into it until much later and at this point the only thing he could do probably is to expose her Mother as a liar. One option is that with this he sentences himself and her mother to death. But even if he chooses to do this I doubt this would have much effect as we see all throughout the book how easily the fremen believe anything in accordance to their messiah myth. For example even Kynes who is mostly science oriented( well, he is a scientist duh) and treats myths as myths, starts to have some doubts that the prophecies actually might be true, and it really didnt take anything for him to start almost believing, only Paul and his father being decent and honorable rulers were enough. Which after 80 years of Harkonnen rule probably was impossible for the fremen to imagine as a possibility. The marginalized and opressed fremen were ready to belive in anything thrown at them.

And then the fight with Jamis happens and after:

,,Somewhere ahead of him on this path, the fanatic hordes cut their gory path across the universe in his name. The green and black Atreides banner would become a symbol of terror. Wild legions would charge into battle screaming their war cry: "Muad'Dib!" It must not be, he thought. I cannot let it happen. But he could feel the demanding race consciousness within him, his own terrible purpose, and he knew that no small thing could deflect the juggernaut. It was gathering weight and momentum. If he died this instant, the thing would go on through his mother and his unborn sister. Nothing less than the deaths of all the troop gathered here and now--himself and his mother included--could stop the thing."

And then he contemplates even this option while everyone is involved with ritual he seems distracted and not conciously there in the moment:

,, To Paul, the sound was like moments ticking away. He could feel time flowing through him, the instants never to be recaptured. He sensed a need for decision, but felt powerless to move"

And then bsically he says its because of his mother that his fate has become innevitable:

,,Paul sat silently in the darkness, a single stark thought dominating his awareness: My mother is my enemy. She does not know it, but she is. She is bringing the jihad. She bore me; she trained me. She is my enemy."

And because as I said earlier in my essay we are given no reason to doubt the trutfullhness of prescience in the books we could pretty much state that yes, after this moment the Jihad was fully set in stone.(although I belive in the Duniverse somekind of Jihad was innevitable even if Paul wasnt even born. But this is entirelly another question and both supporting and contradicting evidence could be found to this question in the text.)

So lets summarize: Paul was in the tent. Basically all options likely resulted in death. Yeah we can say that he could just die then and there, but would it be sane to think this was a sensible choice for him when so much of the paths leading to the future he couldnt see in their entirety therefore believing that he can simultaniously survive and avoid the road to the Jihad?? Is this really why we should morally judge Paul? Because as a 15 years old teenager he wanted to live after the butchering of his father? Yes he had revenge in him. He wanted to get revenge but is that while we should cast him as a villain because he wanted revenge on the objectively complete scumbags who killed his father?Aside from this though we can see that he always prioritized the greater good over revenge ( which is further strongly supported by reading Messiah and Children of Dune) his primary motivation being surviving. Yes he had vengefullness but who wouldnt in a situation like this? I would argue that if he only wanted his revenge he could also get it by the Baron route(and with some reach even the Guild one but this later one would be entirely speculation not supported by any text) so chosing the fremen way in my opinion is much more of a survival issue than a revenge issue.

This post has already been really long so i wouldnt want to start this debate here also.

Soooo: after choosing to survive he tries to avoid the path leading to the Jihad actively and doesnt inserts himself as a messiah until only after the Jihad became innevitable and literally does this because he thinks he can atleast controll it somewhat this way. In the third part: The Prophet we see that he is constantly looking for ways out of the Jihad, CLosing my argument I would say Paul literally did nothing wrong and what he did was completely reasonable logically and emotionally aswell but unfortunately he was trapped by powers beyond his controll, which resulted in tragedy for him and the entire known universe.

Perhaps it was needed for the survival of the human race, Perhaps it was not...

Edit: I know this is a divesive topic. But i provided evidence from the text which in my opinion supported my argument. Its great to disagree on matters because then we can have debates and discussions where we could learn new things, get to know new perspectives. But then please do engage in a conversation and provide evidence from the book. Because downvoting me to shit doesnt excactly prove anything. I want to have a discussion about this. But this way this is just frustrating....

Edit 2: Yes calling him a hero is probably not accurate. I would have liked to argue that morally he is not responsible. But i agree that by the consequences we cant really call him a hero.

Edit 3: please provide a quote or paragraph if you so vehemently disagree with me. Don't say Paul baad. Show me in the text which part would suggest this. So far no commenter has done this.


r/dune • • Mar 19 '24

Dune: Part Two (2024) Any other book readers disappointed by Dune: Part 2?

0 Upvotes

They just changed too much. Im not talking about small things like using atomics instead of a lasgun, which is fine since they never explained the interaction between lasguns and shields in the movies. But they just changed the world of Dune too much: From Fremen customs (being ok with marrying multiple women), to completely messing up Stilgar's arc (from Leader to father to tragic religious zealot), to how Paul and his "choices" are portrayed.

Also, I get that they rushed the timeline to not have toddler Alia jumping around and killing the Baron on screen, but it makes the whole story kinda rushed when you know it all happens in less than 7 months.

Ffs, people in my theater laughed at Paul being called Abomination, which shows how badly they explained the implications, and what's happening inside of Paul (and Alia) at the moment.

Anyways, I really like Villeneuve's movies and loved Dune part one even with the changes they made to that one, but part 2 was a letdown in how they capture the story and its characters.


r/dune • • Mar 27 '24

General Discussion Herbert Undermines His Own Message Spoiler

1 Upvotes

There are two ways Herbert undermines his own stated message in the Dune series. The first one (I see there are some Reddit threads discussing this) is his warning against charismatic leaders and the second is the evil of colonialism.

The big takeaway from Dune and especially Messiah is that following charismatic leaders leads to death and destruction. Yet, we are also lead to believe that humanity would have been doomed (I've still only read the first 3 books so I don't claim to be an expert but that's my understanding) if Paul hadn't started down his Golden Path. So, did the charismatic leader save humanity or didn't he?

Second of all, this story is supposed to be a subversion of the "white savior" narrative and of course it is but it's not an anti-colonial message. As soon as the oppressed people were liberated, they went on a galactic jihad killing 61 billion people. Most of those people would've been much better off if the Freman had remained oppressed under the iron fist of the Harkonens. This includes many of the Freman as we hear about time and time again in Children of Dune.

To be clear, these paradoxes (and others I'm sure) are actually the reason Dune is so popular. He created a universe so lifelike he was unable to fully control it and it ends up contradicting the artist himself making a richer more vibrant world filled with uncertainty and energy.


r/dune • • Mar 09 '25

Children of Dune Is it just me, or is Children of Dune riddled with plot holes? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I’m pretty close to the end of re-reading this book for the first time since the ‘90s, and I’m remembering now why I noped out of the series on this book the last time. It could be that I’m missing something (a definite possibility), but it just seems to me like this book is filled with plot holes that just don’t make any sense. In the order in which I noticed them:

  1. The plot to kill the twins with the Laza tigers. It seems like this particular plot was to have the twins wear a set of robes and then walk outside their sietch to get eaten by the tigers who’ve been conditioned to attack children wearing those robes. But this plot seems like it could have been prevented quite easily in so many ways. First, no one ever expresses any motivation that the twins might have to wear the robes—they’re mentioned by Alia’s people as being an apparently harmless gift, but it seems pretty easy for the twins to just, you know, never put the robes on. And second, when the tigers attack, they’re doing it at a time that the twins have snuck out of the sietch without authorization.

So what was the plan here for House Corrino? A successful plot seems to hinge on a lot of total chance, and it only worked because the twins themselves wanted to fake Leto’s death. They didn’t have to participate at all.

2) Somehow both Jessica and Alia are in contact with all the naibs at both Jacurutu and Shuloch, but they’re supposed to be on opposite sides of an Atreides civil war. It’s not at all clear to me how this plotting and counter plotting is supposed to have worked—like whose side is Namri ultimately on? And so far it’s just not being made clear what any of this was meant to accomplish and towards whose ends besides Leto. All the other characters’ plans are just profoundly sketchy.

3) In the previous book, Alia had powers of prescience, perhaps not on par with Paul’s but still substantial. Yet in this book, those powers have somehow completely disappeared. How does she not suspect that Leto was still alive, or that her brother is the preacher? How is she caught off-guard by Jessica’s response to the assassination attempt?

Where I felt Messiah dealt quite deftly with the intricacies of trying to develop a plot against a being who can see the future (after all, both Paul and Guid Navigators have powers of prescience), in this book all of that seems to have gone out the window.

To these plot holes I’d add that this book is also starting to show some signs of the weakness of Dune’s world building. The imperium is supposed to contain thousands of planets and billions of people, so how is it that the same handful of planets and great houses seem to be the only ones that matter? Alia has an ancestral memory that stretches back to the dawn of humanity, so how is it that she gets possessed by the Baron and not like Genghis Khan or any of her other hundreds of thousands of ancestors? To rule a planet in a feudal system, the Atreides must have had hundreds if not thousands of vassal families, and why do we never learn about any other major or minor house besides Atreides, Corrino, and Harkonnen? Surely there’s at least ONE other house (or planet, or organization besides the Tleilaxu, Bene Gesserit, and Ixians) that has a role to play in the history of the Imperium.

Anyone else feel this way?


r/dune • • Apr 03 '24

Dune (novel) All the ways that the Fremen are not oppressed Spoiler

443 Upvotes

One of the great simplifications of the adaptations of Dune has been to sell the Fremen as oppressed. The truth painted in the book is much different. One of the biggest twists of the novel is finding out that the Fremen are the most powerful faction on Arrakis. Some quick talking points:

- The Fremen are right where they want to be. They are not driven into the deep desert by Imperial forces, they are there by choice. The entire planet is desert and they pay to have their portion of it kept private so they can gather spice and worship the worms.

- The Fremen pay more in spice bribes than the Emperor has in available funds. When Shaddam brings his battle palace to Arrakis the Guild is still enforcing the surveillance blackout on behalf of the Fremen. It is the Fremen who have the upper hand with their smuggler fleet.

- The majority of Fremen live in the South far away from Imperial influence. Life for the average Fremen consists of farming or industry inside a massive mountain city. He has multiple wives and children, with a large extended family in seitch. He has a good coffee service to serve guests and a choice of foods including ripe melons and fresh vegetables. If something goes wrong with one of his wives he can take his water to another tribe by hopping a worm to the next plantation and earning his way. He knows only stories of Harkonnen rule from smugglers because he never needs to go north into the cities.

- The Fremen have complete sovereignty over Arrakis. They allow the Imperial fiefdom so they can gain access to the benefits of the Imperial economy through smuggling. They isolate the Imperial forces to the north while they hide their numbers in the south. Again, even when the Emperor comes in force he doesn't get the kind of access the Fremen have.

- The Fremen weren't interested in a political struggle for the planet. They were an ecological power, focused on the terraforming of the planet. It was only once Paul came along and started pulling prophetic strings that they were interested in flexing their muscle against the Landsraad.


r/dune • • Mar 21 '24

General Discussion Why is spice important for space travel?

0 Upvotes

i've never read the books, but I've only watched the movies. Why is spice so important for space travel and what does it do for the ship or whoever is running the ship?


r/dune • • Nov 07 '21

Dune (2021) I just watched the movie. Anyone else a bit... disappointed? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I just watched the movie and I'm a little... disappointed. From the lack of character development in key characters, namely Thufir Hawat and Yueh, to how they skipped a good bit of the political intrigue (the dinner was my favorite part of the book!), to the lack of explanation of key plot points, and even some of the casting! They didn't even highlight the harsh conditions of Arrakis and ignored water discipline!

The completely skipped Thufur Hawats character, to the point that I can't see them including his role in the second movie either. And Yueh's conditioning and training in the BG ways was just... never explained. I imagine this made things very confusing to people who haven't read the book.

They just cut most of the scenes including alliances and political intrigue such as the dinner or Duke Leto's explanation to Paul. While I can understand that they had to cut something, it makes the whole plot rather... bland. They just sort of said "the emperor's a jealous man" and that was the entire reasoning for the massive campaign against the Atriedes.

They never explained the Ornithopter, most of the equipment, lasguns, or a lot of other important items. As mentioned earlier, they also didn't explain a lot of the behind the scenes strategy and political drama.

I hate Thufir Hawats casting. His character could not plausibly survive the initial invasion, and he really doesn't give off the atmosphere of a leader or important character. And while Chani's casting was alright, she does not at all look dehydrated or elvish as described in the book. And it was a bit odd that they made Kynes a woman, I just don't understand why. I'm not all that opposed, but it didn't seem to fit Kynses character in the book.

They never really highlighted the harsh conditions of Arrakis, or the importance of the stillsuits. Sure it was mentioned, but even the fremen hardly wear their masks and they changed Kynes dying in the dessert completely.

All that said, I still like to movie, but I don't really think it lived up to all the hype I heard about it. It felt like they didn't do enough explaining for people new to Dune, and it didn't follow the book closely enough to please Dune fanatics.


r/dune • • Oct 31 '21

Dune (1984) Unpopular/minority opinion: I like Lynch's version better

1 Upvotes

DV version is a masterpiece. And having red this sub and seeing how much I missed, I went back and watched it a second time in IMAX. Sadly, it doesn't get me where I wish I would. There's just too much left out and it feels smaller than I want it to; detailed, beautiful, but so much missing. I'm not hating on it, so please don't get me wrong. I've loved all three versions, but for me, the decisions that Lynch used to guide us (the viewer) play out better than DV's version (for me). I stand by ready to rescind this view if Part II somehow fills these gaps.

I think (my opinion here, don't kill me) is that for almost all of us, *this film is a supplication to the book*. Imagine if you'd never read any of the books, nor seen any other versions of the story. I think you're missing a lot.


r/dune • • Jun 30 '23

General Discussion The inconsistent accents for the movie are really killing my immersion

2 Upvotes

It may seem like such a small detail, but I find myself not being able to slip into this beautifully shot world because there’s so many small elements that work against my suspension of disbelief.

Zendaya speaking in an American accent while being a born and raised arraki fremen just feels jarring. Especially when her fellow fremen are speaking in more eastern accents. To that same point, timothee chalamet speaking in his actual voice also feels wrong? I really wish he’d been made to do an accent matching Paul’s mother.

While these points seem super nitpicky (specifically Paul’s voice lol), I do think it encapsulates the first movie’s biggest issue, and that’s the fact that the world doesn’t feel lived in (and by extension, believable).

Hoping there’s enough to work with in the second movie so that these details don’t stick out too much.