r/dndstories • • Jun 21 '26

Table Stories My players spent an hour editing a contract, only to get out-lawyered by a devil anyway

1.9k Upvotes

So, my party needed to get to the Plane of Air, and their only viable route was a planar portal guarded by a devil. Instead of fighting, the devil offered them a deal: he’d grant them passage if they agreed to certain conditions. The important two are:

  1. While in the Plane of Air, they had to use a specific sacrificial dagger he provided to kill exactly one Aarakocra.

  2. They could not leave the Plane of Air by any means other than the exact portal they entered through.

My players are cautious, so they spent a good 45 minutes out of game scrutinizing the contract. They wrote in a few amendments and clauses to cover their bases, feeling incredibly smug about it. The devil smiled, signed the amended contract, and ushered them through.

They did their business in the Plane of Air, found an evil Aarakocra to kill with the dagger, and immediately used revivify ​on him right after to keep their hands relatively clean. Loophole found, right? They headed back to the portal to go home.

When they arrived, a group of the devil's minions were waiting. A fight broke out. On the second round of combat, one of the devil's mages targeted the party's fighter and cast banishment.

The fighter failed the save, vanished from the Plane of Air.

The table went completely silent as it clicked. By being forcefully banished, a PC had left the Plane of Air by a means other than the portal. They were officially in breach of contract, and the devil claimed their souls on the spot.

This turned into a month-long side campaign. The players rolled up an entirely new party of characters tasked with staging a cosmic heist/rescue mission to get their original characters back from the Nine Hells.

They actually succeeded, which was awesome, and we transitioned back to the main campaign. But because they spent a month of in-game time dealing with the fallout of that contract, the main villain’s plans had advanced significantly without their interference.

Never trust a devil, even if he lets you edit the terms.


r/dndstories • • Dec 25 '20

Talking about an upcoming one shot we were gonna play in

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

r/dndstories • • May 31 '20

The ultimate dream team

Post image
874 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • Sep 18 '19

I played the long game and surprised even the DM

853 Upvotes

I'm playing a warforged arcane archer who is, essentially, fantasy Frankenstein's monster. But book inspo, rather than movies. His name is Alahan, and he's a lot of fun. I should note that my DM and players are aware of the fact that Alahan is not a traditional warforged. Rather than made of metal and living wood, he was created from various body parts. Needless to say he's grisly to look at, which is why he is so thoroughly covered. However, no one in game knows.

I describe him as wearing full body leather coverings, think the Org 13 cloaks. Under the hood he has a wooden mask, meaning nothing of his skin is revealed at any point in time. He doesn't sleep, so attempts to peak under his cloak are never really successful. He stuffs his pockets and all inside the cloak with what amounts to potpourri, always adding nice smelling plants he encounters.

Every time he meets someone new, and I do mean every time, he makes a best guess at what their race is. He then says something along the lines of, "hello fellow human, I am human." It's especially funny when this seven foot tall behemoth tells a dwarf "I am also a dwarf". Always gets a laugh from the party.

When a woman was upset because her son was taken by cultists he reached into his sleeve and pulled out a handful of dried flowers and put it in her hands. "This is a gift. Feel better." Before she can respond he holds out his hand, "I need that back now."

He's played a bit as a comic relief, who happens to be terrifyingly efficient in combat. He easily has the highest kill count in the party, which is understandable since he stands back with a heavy crossbow raining death on cultists. It's magnificent.

At one point we were asked to capture a high ranking cultist, which we did thanks to some... hilarity. In the evening we attend a celebration and feast, but Alahan isn't eating or drinking. He's simply watching, and I tell the DM that if he notices anyone looking at him he locks eyes(not that his are visible) and stares the person down until they look away. At some point he piles his plate up with food and, with all the subtlety of an orc barbarian trying to sneak, throws the plate of food over his shoulder and comments that it is 'tasty'.

I'm told that the people of the keep are well and thoroughly afraid of him at this point.

We later learn that there were unsuccessful attempts to get info from the priestess. A few more in-game days pass, and I tell the DM that Alahan waits until the priestess is alone and goes into her cell. My DM, genius that she is, plays along with this whole scene perfectly.

Alahan enters, and stands stock still, quietly saying, "when next they come to speak to you... you are going to tell them everything." It's important to note that up until this point Alahan's voice had always been friendly, even when he was talking to enemies he was currently trying to kill. Not anymore. It had gotten deeper, more serious. Gone was the inflection of the care free giant who liked flowers and weirding out peasants.

The priestess responds, "or what? What will you do?"

It's at this point that Alahan approaches. He simultaneously removes his mask and hood, and the players are paying rapt attention. Alahan has never done this before. I describe how he has ashen skin, with scar tissue lining areas where the tone doesn't match up quite right. Alahan, directly in her face, snarls, "or I will eat you alive."

Intimidate, at advantage. Nineteen on the roll, plus like... five or something? I don't recall. She rolls a two against my check. She's terrified. She then must also make a con save, which she fails, becoming sick and letting loose the scant contents of her stomach. Alahan stands back up and puts his hood and mask back on, telling her, "remember. Tell them everything." As he leaves, he says, "that cannot die which lies eternal dreaming, and with strange eons even death may die." The weird motto from Lovecraft that I decided is his like... mantra.

He goes immediately to the dwarf in charge of the fort and tells him that the priestess will talk next time they go to question her. "How did you manage that," he asks, clearly suspicious. They'd threatened her, even tortured her. This dwarf knew their prisoner wasn't going to crack easily. Alahan simply replies, "I asked nicely."

The next morning he accompanies the dwarf, along with our rogue, to speak with the prisoner. The moment Alahan walks into the room she begins to weep. The dwarf looks at me, "What did you do?!"

Alahan simply stares at her, as she sobs his little poem. He says, "I asked nicely."

And that was how I convinced everyone I was playing a comic relief character, when in fact I am playing a terrifying monster who has convinced a group of adventurers that he's harmless. I can't wait for the next session.

Edit: I got a silver badge, cool. And on my first Reddit post ever! Now... what does that mean? XD


r/dndstories • • Aug 19 '18

This made me laugh

Post image
641 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • May 01 '21

Short Story Time My friend shared this in our Discord, figured it was worth sharing here.

Thumbnail
gallery
637 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • Nov 25 '19

One Off How I got my dm to go out with me

627 Upvotes

It was the last session for the current campaign and we were all level 20, I was playing a bard and this happened:

Dm: “last chance anything else you want to do before we end this campaign for good?”

Me: “can I roll to seduce the...”

Her: “no.”

Me: “you didn’t let me finish!”

Her “....” “.............” “fine.”

Me: “can I roll to seduce the dm?” Fat ass smile on my face.

Her, poker faced: “roll.”

rolls

Nat 20

Her: “Fine, the dm accepts you proposal.”

It’s our 2 year anniversary next month. Lesson is, make sure to be a bard while playing dnd.


r/dndstories • • Jan 28 '21

Short Story Time I’m a good friend

Post image
610 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • Sep 18 '20

Table Stories I left my first group after 3 sessions due to personal reasons, and I finally found a group that would accept me, and i wanna share my story and unique character :D

Post image
529 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • Apr 01 '19

Table Stories My first experience with Adventurers League

521 Upvotes

So I went to PAX East this year and a bunch of friends and I wanted to try out d&d Adventurers League (especially me since I've been wanting to find a place to be a player where I'm currently living since I DM for both my groups). We made our characters using d&d beyond and I, who normally played casters (even my fighter was an EK), wanted to try something new and decided to make a Barbarian instead.

LONG STORY SHORT near the end of the session we were attacked by a werewolf. We were doing theater of the mind so he asked who was closest to the door, no one seemed willing so I offered since I had the most health left and I wasn't about to let our sorcerer or bard go down at the start of combat (we were all level 1). So the werewolf attacked me with a bite.

"roll a constitution saving throw" says the DM

"i rolled a 3, so 6." I say laughing because I knew what was coming, and genuinely having a good time.

"you are cursed with Lycanthropy"

"oof" goes the entire table.

I thought that was cool and would be something I could either attempt to get cured or just, you know, Roll with it in the future.

But then the session comes to a close and the DM gives us the lowdown about how AL works (keeping track of your sessions, rest activities, and AL tokens to spend on magic items, as well as his DCI code). We all were awarded a wand of secrets, but then he turns to me and says

"you have to buy a potion of greater restoration, which costs 8 treasure tokens. You currently only have 2 and if you do go for it your character will forever be in treasure debt, so honestly I would just make a new character"

"oh" I went, staring into the void after hearing what he just said.

My character didn't die, he got cursed. So now he was adventurers league illegal and I couldn't play him again because if I did I would be in forever "treasure debt".

This was my first AL and my character got banned from AL.

And overall, I thought the idea of a WotC ran d&d session(s) would be cool, less personal obviously and more about the physical adventure, but not so rigid that a thing the module PUTS IN THERE could instantly ban all characters at the table forever. I get it, since dealing with Lycanthropy at a AL table wouldn't be fair to everyone else but still this could happen to anybody at any time. And the focus on mechanics over rping, which again I understand, really just isn't my thing. I feel like 70% of the fun of playing is the rp aspect. I just realized it wasn't for me.

Tl;dr: My first adventurers league game ever got me banned from AL since a werewolf infected me for protecting the party. Prob won't do Adventurers League again.


r/dndstories • • Oct 11 '20

Be a dm till be fun they said

Post image
511 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • Jun 13 '19

Converted my story to greentext format because why not lol

Post image
497 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • Mar 28 '22

I cast blindness on the closest biker

Post image
441 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • Feb 16 '20

As a bard in my latest session, I've summed up the highlight in song form.

Post image
394 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • Feb 07 '20

One Off Why You Should Pay Attention to Your Height and Weight in Character Creation

387 Upvotes

One of my first player characters I created in Pathfinder 1e was a halfling bard name Brandy. I spent hours going through the spell and feat list, meticulously planning my character's levels for future leveling up. I built him heavily as a skill junkie, with high Dex and Cha. As such, he was extremely high in many of these related skills.

When I got to the final touches, I noticed I hadn't put in a height or weight. No problem, I'll just find out what the average height of a halfling is. 3 feet? We'll make it 3'1". Weight? Eh, how about 130 lb. Sounds about right.

A couple of sessions in, someone wants to carry me and asks my weight. I reply "130." Whole table looks up.

DM: "You're a halfling, right?"

Me: "Yeah."

Another player: "What's your height?"

Me: "3'1". Why?"

DM: "Your character is super-fat."

Me: "What?! No, he's not. He's only 130."

Other player: "Yeah, and only 3 feet! What's his BMI?"

*player plugs into BMI calculator*

Other player: "Oh God. It's 66."

For reference, obesity is 30 or above. Or, another way to put it, if Brandy was 5'7", his weight would be over 430 lbs.

To make matters even better, his dexterity bonus at level 1 was +4, the highest in the group. The most obese character by far was the most acrobatic and stealthy character.

I decided to roll with it, which made roleplay even more fun:

Me: I want to acrobatics past this giant blocking the cave.

DM: "Okay. Roll for it."

Me: "I got a 24."

DM: "Okay, you pass. So...how do you do it?"

Me: "...I pinwheel and begin rolling down the corridor. Using my inertia, I roll up the side of the cave wall like a half pipe, over the giant's head, and down the other side, making a plopping sound when I land."

So yeah, make sure to pay attention to your height and weight in character creation.

I've been playing with the same group for 6 years every weekend, so I've got plenty more stories to share.


r/dndstories • • Sep 15 '22

Test your DM's patience with this Neat trick

Thumbnail
gallery
382 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • Aug 04 '20

Not a story, but just a reminder for why DMs do what they do.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
356 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • Apr 15 '19

Short one for you guys.

340 Upvotes

> Playing 5e

> Champion accidentally kills bad guy that we were going to interrogate

> Party revives bad guy with 1 HP

> "That was a warning murder!"


r/dndstories • • Dec 15 '19

The Worse Player I Have Ever Known

339 Upvotes

This is the story of a player I met online, this is a fairly recent story and as far as I know this player is still active. We met on Roll20 and used Discord to talk to each other. Note, if you meet a guy that fits the following story please post a reply.

Our story begins when I was starting out as a DM on Roll20, the year was 2019 early spring. The game was slowly taking form, I had accepted at least five player applications, I don't recall all of them but there was one player who stood out. He didn't have a concept on his application, so when I contacted him through Discord I asked what it was, where the nightmare began.

His Discord handle was "Darthblooded27", he had this personality where you thought he was shy. He had a soft voice, and seemed nice.

I asked him "So whats your character?"

Darth said "I want to be an albino tiefling bard who got kicked out for being a tiefling" or something along the lines. I thought the albino bit would be interesting although a little strange.

What really put me off was when he interrupted me to ask "Do you allow romance?"

I answered yes and he went on to explain "I wanted you to create a girlfriend for my character, I hoped you could create her like this." He then proceeded to copy and past a photo and text from GoogleDocs. He sent both to me and I was in shock. The his request was most likely fetish fueled, his description if not mocking real romance made it apparent he had not experienced any. At least that was my take on it. I will post the image and text below:

darthblooded27 02/05/2019

My character wants to find a red-haired human woman as a lover/wife later on. Here's what my character is looking for. Her age is 30. She's 5.7 with red blood color hair long with emerald green eyes, has a cute face with freckles, she has a huge chest (m-cup) , a huge hips and butt (that can knock down tables or chairs when she walks/chair would get stuck when she sits) . but no man would take her cause of her weight ( 308 lb). She has an older brother who's a smith/warrior with a sister in law who's a cleric, and two nieces and one mother who's a famers daughter and father who's a former paladin . She works at a store ( dm could change or edit it ) Her personality she is kind, sweet, funny, and a little hard, and care about her family and wants to be love, and hopes to get married. She also likes magic and gifts, and flowers and other pretty things, and like woman things My character would to meet her in a tavern.

I read the story knowing full well I wouldn't accept this, I rather not have the DM job turn into a position to satisfiy peoples desires. As I read through I saw the last bit "My character would meet her in a tavern"

I asked what this meant and he said "My character hasn't met her yet, I wanted you to role play it."

To deify the chances of the game just to find his sexually fantasy in a tavern where the games focus was dungeons and dragons. I could feel my forehead bulge with how much disgust I felt. So I explained to him that romance is allowed but you have to really find it. It can't just be pre-ordered like a toy. He said he understood but he didn't.

Our game began, and I soon realized that he found his character more important than others. He interrupted others for his own to speak or just to inform the group he was tying his shoe. this was our first session and already we were having problems. The players came across a tavern on the journey and the first thing he asks is "DM, do I see anyone who fits my preferences?"

I began rubbing the sides of my head, attempting to keep some form of composure. I said he saw a girl with red hair, he asked if there was anything else about her. I said no and he left it at that. I knew then he wasn't a good fit and kicked him.

Months passed and I thought I saw the last of him. Until I met him in another game. I had applied to this one on Roll20, the title was "Rise Of Monsters" and the DM was new. He was a good guy who was trying out 5e for the first time. When I joined and saw Darth in the group I immediately told the DM about him while in chat with the whole group.

Darth said "I am sorry, I have changed for the better. Please forgive my past actions." he didn't change. At the time I believed him, but I soon came to know the other players in the group. Some left the group so the DM always had to bring in more people. What was interesting was they all knew Darth from other games. I asked them about Darth, how he acted in other games. They all said the same about his personality.

"He likes to roleplay, but he got kicked for interrupting"

"He was a huge pervert who had sex with everything."

"He played an albino tiefling bard who had this girlfriend npc."

With the information I had gathered from the other players I learned Darth had been apart of and kicked from twelve different games prior to joining the Rise of Monsters game. He had been kicked from all of them.

I warned the DM about his behavior, but sense the DM was a nice guy he said "I want to give him a chance."

As time passed I noticed Darth's behavior, he didn't role play really. He merely introduce himself and didn't bother to interact with the party any further. He seemed more focused on moving the plot then anything else. I questioned why, and I got my answer as soon as we entered a tavern. The DM described Darth's npc as soon as we entered the. I want to make it clear that everyone in the group knew Darth from some other game. He always played the same character, with the same npc girlfriend. So when we saw this npc we all knew what was about to happen.

He entered the tavern more focused on the npc then the mission. He performed a song, he flirted, and did his best to woe this npc. At some point they went up stairs and had intercourse. During all of that the party was trying to carry on with the plot but he wouldn't shut up. He brought up how his pc was playing Deathlock, or how he wants the DM to describe her reactions to the song.

After that encounter the game progressed, he dragged the npc with him so she was now on our adventures. This was the DM fault as I said before he was new but I will get into his story another time. I will just say that Darth continued to have intimate moments with the npc but then turn around and flirt with other npc.

Out of game he even bragged about how his character had sex with two dragons so they wouldn't kill him or the party, or how he walked back into a city where the bbeg ruled and said "You promised me p**** and I'm gonna get it."

I eventually left, half because of him and the other half was because of me. The game just became a total mess and I didn't want to have to deal with the DM or Darth.

I kept in contact with the people in the group. Funny enough the group ended the campaign because of Darth. The DM ran an encounter with vampire spawn who bit the gf npc. Darth threw a fit and started complaining when the other players suggested putting her to rest. After that Darth began crying to the DM, calling him in the middle of the day to cry about how "You need to fix this!" and how "They can't kill her!"

I did ask him at one point why the npc, he came up with the excuse that "It is to honor my dead girlfriend." If that is the case than I would have made her sound less like a fetish and more like a person. I think he made it up just to avoid admitting she was her sexually fantasy.

I have yet to see Darth again, but I feel like he is still out there. Beware of this player, and if you know of a person similar please post a reply.


r/dndstories • • Feb 22 '21

Short Story Time How a Player Destroyed an Entire Town with a Level 1 Spell

335 Upvotes

Background: A Level 2 party of 5 is investigating a string of disappearances in an industrializing town. They discover that a druid is kidnapping factory workers, and sacrificing them into a volcanic pit in order to trigger a volcanic eruption to destroy the town and its factories. The volcano has already received multiple sacrifices and is on the verge of erupting.

Combat begins, and the boss is standing directly next to the sacrificial lava pit. He takes his turn, and uses it to throw another sacrifice into the pit, and he wildshapes into a direwolf.

The Sorcerer takes her turn, and runs up next to the boss, and says "I cast thunderwave to knock him into the lava pit." The spell is already cast in roll20, and the damage has been rolled. There's no going back.

The boss rolls the con save... 5. The boss is knocked back ten feet, right past the ledge and into the pit of fire. The boss rolls a dex save to grab the ledge... 4. Regretting the fact that I didn't give any legendary resistances to this low level boss, I roll the lava damage... 66. The boss is instantly killed, even with the extra wildshape hit points.

"Do you have any idea what you've just done?" I say to the player, as the realization hits her. The party is panicking as I describe that the entire cavern begins to rumble.

The eruption begins, and the party manages to narrowly escape the collapsing cave, and sprint to the town below, and evacuate it just minutes before the lava flow engulfs the town. Looking over the destroyed town, an NPC companion asks the Sorcerer what happened.

"He uh, fell in." She says.

Blissfully ignorant, the NPC doesn't question her further, thinking her to be a hero for assisting in the evacuation.

TL;DR: Sorcerer stops volcanic sacrifice ritual by thunderwaving the baddie... into the sacrifice pool. Volcano erupts, town is destroyed


r/dndstories • • Sep 14 '20

i thought this perfectly shows the dnd experience

Post image
328 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • Mar 23 '20

Series Death Offers A Game For Your Life, You Decide On Dungeons And Dragons

Post image
325 Upvotes

r/dndstories • • Feb 28 '19

Short Story Time I can tell a story through a meme right? That’s allowed?

Post image
325 Upvotes