I suppose the point of this post is just to give others something entertaining to read, and perhaps get some advice I can use going forward. I, A level 5 Drow wizard, was going to have 2 solo sessions and it was a great excuse to visit a nearby city that is connected to a "lave-trader" guild. (Leaving the S off for the purposes of this story)
The city, like the one I'm leaving my AFK party at for these 2 sessions, deals in open lave auctions so the locals consider it a normal part of the culture. 4 were purchased and set up with new lives previously, and with my pockets full from a successful casino heist, I set out to repeat that process here. I assumed I'd bring them back with me by the end of the 2 sessions, and we'd have 4 more NPCs at the center of tracking down family... escorting back to homeland... that sort of thing.
Things started out well and I purchased 4 laves, all with previous fighting experience and one discounted due to an almost crippling leg wound. Half of the session was spent tracking down a suitable healer, clothing, and arming these 4 individuals. As had been done in the previous city, I told the laves that although they were legally considered property in the city, they were to be paid wages and should think of themselves as hired mercenaries. There was immediate push back from them all, where 3 threatened to kill me unless I continued to spend money to keep them happy. I'm more of a glass cannon, and then find myself accompanied by 4 fighters who are pressuring me to pamper them. I rolled with it, and I'll admit it was a twist I hadn't expected! Roleplaying wasn't diffusing the situation at all. I pointed out that I had saved them from being sold to some nasty people, spent hundreds of gold to equip them, and was agreeing to pay them as mercenaries. Despite anything I said, all 4 viewed me as the cause of all their woes, and they'd let me live for now, so long as I kept paying for things. By the end of the first day, I was very certain I didn't want 3 of these 4 around anymore, and that if I left them or returned them, I would have a team of people floating around in the world dead-set to hunt me down. I decided it was them or me.
I left them sleeping at the inn to set up a trap. Gunpowder kegs in an abandoned building at the edges of town, became a meeting place where they need to wait for a contact of mine. Of the 4, the one with the injured leg hadn't repeatedly threatened to kill me, so I dropped him off at a healer's shop to spare him. With the laves inside, I fire-balled through a window and killed one of the 3 outright. The other 2 staggered out before the building collapsed, and I had to finish them off while disguised as the one cremated under the rubble. City guards and city witnesses got a good look at me in disguise and were convinced they knew who the arsonist was. Finally feeling like I wasn't being held hostage and exploited for gold, I went back to the healer. Here is where things twisted in some Very strange ways.
The healer said she heard the explosion from there, and the lave I left there magically healed his own leg (secret magic user who suffered in cage as cover?), shouted about how I was a murder, and fled out into the marketplace. I did a sort of double take on that one for not making a lot of sense, but tried to just go with it. Fast forward a little bit, I was with the city guards who had cornered this lave in an old warehouse after I included him in the frame-job as an escaped lave who set fire to the building. I had receipts and the auction confirmed the 4 laves when I minor illusioned paintings of each. Once inside, this final lave was frantically slashing and fighting any guards who got near him (had already bloodied up 2 of them). He points at me and yells that I am "the real murderer" and I set the fire (you know, the fire he never saw based on the boom he heard echo from a few blocks away). Now here is the start of when I was completely floored. The guards instantly ignore him and turn on me, and I'm restrained! Roleplayed the conversation for all I was worth, but basically the sergeant considered me a piece of trash and he "Knew" I was guilty. I kept things in-game, I really did... I did all I could to ask why in the world they were arresting me based on shouted words from who they knew was an escaped lave, as 2 of his men are bleeding out at his feet. smh. So all of my items in my bag of holding are laid out and looked through, because they're convinced there is proof somewhere in there that shows I'm a secret murderer and arsonist. They threaten to kill me, beat my character up a bit, and cause minor injuries with a knife. Finally the lave guild representative shows up, which had been foreshadowed by some guards to their sergeant "they lave guild will be here soon sir"... that sort of stuff. Honestly I thought that was meant to inform me that they were the calvary who would save me from this situation. Nope!
The lave guild representatives entered the warehouse and took over like the FBI pushing police aside in an old 90's movie. They come in with the exact same attitude. More threats, more pushing me around and trying to get me to "talk". I didn't have anything to "tell", and was never given specifics of what to tell them about. I was probably just as confused in real life as my character would have been in-world. None of this made any sense, and it took longer than it should for me to see that the DM had some motives they wanted to push on the session. While trying to talk myself out of a room full of armed city guards and lavers, it was revealed that they all knew I was guilty because I own laves in the city. Laves they sold me, in a city that is so accustomed to it that they dedicate a portion of the market district to have daily auctions... but sure, yeah... I guess I stand out as a monster. The situation really had me wondering if my character was about to be executed by the city guards and guild representatives! Finally, the only way I saved my character was to convince them that the smarter move would be to go with the escaped lave story, even if they didn't believe it. Killing me would scare away future customers once rumors spread that your lave can accuse you of something and they'll punish you for it without any evidence, and blaming escaped laves would boost public support for stronger cages and having more guards. I barely, and I stress barely, limped out of there with the guards letting me take back "most" of the contents of my bag of holding. I was told to leave the city forever and that I owe the guild a favor for letting me live.
This was maybe a third of the way into my second solo session at this point, and during a break I Really tried to think up a positive spin on all this. Finally it hit me... perhaps this was a terrible attempt to give me a larger story to work on, that being either clearing my name, eliminating the sergeant and guild representatives, or just doing some interesting quest for the guild. I started to recover from how weird (not in a good way) the past session and a half had gone so far. When I limped back to the inn, the first words that came out of the innkeeper's mouth were that I already paid for my room, but they don't want me here. I'm a lave owner and arsonist (word must travel fast across the city), and am unwelcome to stay there. Just like that, seemingly the entire city knew my face, name, and hated me for participating in the trade their city was known for. There were probably supposed to be hours left in this session 2, but I just said screw it and indicated that go to the docks and board the first ship heading out. I ended it there. What a weird set of sessions.
Now it may just be me, and readers might wonder why I've been stuck on how this went, but to me this felt like a weird way to punish me for participating in the system established by the DM. Before now, nothing like this happened, and as I mentioned earlier, we had already bought and eventually freed 4 others in another city. Did it take a solo session for the DM to reveal some hidden anger that we did that before? I just don't know, and I'm struggling to feel like I wasn't screwed over with all this (besides loot that was taken from me during my shake-down).
Have you guys dealt with sudden DM shifts like this, and if so, how did you handle it? How do you avoid feeling railroaded when the DM keeps hammering home a specific outcome, even when the justification for that outcome doesn't exist or make sense?
Thanks, and I hope my experience was at least entertaining to read.