r/defi • u/chainglance_cm • 5h ago
Discussion Are DeFi token buybacks worth it: what Hyperliquid gets right and pump.fun doesn’t
Hyperliquid’s buybacks beat its unlocks by about $59M. Pump.fun’s barely broke even.
A buyback is the crypto version of a company buying its own stock. Fewer tokens floating around, more value per token, in theory. But a buyback only helps if supply actually shrinks.
Take pump.fun. Over the last 30 days, it spent about $20.3M buying back PUMP. In the same window, its monthly team and investor unlock hit, worth about $19.9M.
The buyback barely kept up. Almost every dollar spent buying PUMP got cancelled out by new tokens hitting the market. It’s like bailing water out of a boat with a hole in it and calling it a “water removal program.”
Compare that with Hyperliquid. About $70.4M went to HYPE buybacks, against roughly $11.8M of unlocked team tokens. That’s a buyback that actually shrinks supply. Same idea, very different boat.
Beyond the numbers, it also matters where the bought tokens go and who controls the program.
Lighter burns the LIT it buys back in batches, so it’s gone for good. Jupiter puts half its revenue into buying JUP, but the tokens sit in a trust, about 176M JUP as of mid-October. Held tokens can still be used later. Burned ones can’t.
On control, Hyperliquid’s buybacks run automatically from its fees. Aave’s were run by a committee and were paused in April 2026 after an exploit hit its markets. Just like that, the buying stopped. Turns out “permanent” had an off switch.
So the quick check:
How much gets bought back each month? (DefiLlama, or the buyback wallet onchain)
How much unlocks or gets emitted each month? (DefiLlama or Tokenomist)
Are the bought tokens burned or parked?
Is the program automatic or switchable?
If buybacks beat new supply, the tokens get burned, and the program runs on its own, that’s real value going to holders. Anything less, discount it.
Buybacks aren’t a scam, by the way. When they outpace dilution, they’re one of the most direct ways a token captures revenue.
Do you check unlocks before buying a token for its buybacks, or is that a new one?