2 send holders 100%. 4 send less than half. 1 sends a big fat $0. Rest only pay you if you stake.
Everyone screenshots the revenue leaderboard. Almost nobody checks the column next to it.
So I did.
DefiLlama tracks revenue (what a protocol keeps) and holders revenue (what actually reaches the token).
I also subtracted token unlocks where the data exists. Here's the top 10 for the last 30 days.
1. Hyperliquid (HYPE)
$69.3M revenue, $69.3M to holders. 100%.
About $12.5M of team tokens unlocked this month, and the buybacks still cleared that easily. Hyperliquid is the benchmark everyone else gets compared to.
2. pump.fun (PUMP)
$48M revenue, $21.3M to holders. About 44%.
Then its monthly team and investor unlock hit, worth about $23M. So the buybacks didn't even cover the new supply. Holders spent the month running to stand still.
Note: pump.fun's buybacks are funded by all of its products, so I compared them against its total revenue. Look at the pump.fun row alone and you'll see a higher percentage.
3. Papertrade (PAPER)
$32.7M revenue, $30M to holders. About 92%.
Great number, with a catch: it's paid in USDC to PAPER stakers only. If you're just holding, your share is $0. It's a dividend with a "members only" sign on the door.
4. Collector Crypt (CARDS)
$14.5M revenue, $0.4M to holders. About 3%.
It does run a buyback, which is why this one surprised me most. Having a buyback and having a meaningful buyback are two different things.
5. Sky (SKY)
$13.3M revenue, $5.5M to holders. About 41%.
Part of that is buybacks and part is staking rewards, so how much you see depends on whether you stake.
6. World Liberty Financial (WLFI)
$10.7M revenue, $0 to holders.
Top 10 by revenue, bottom of the list for holders.
7. Uniswap (UNI)
$8.1M revenue, $8.1M to holders. 100%.
Every dollar Uniswap keeps goes to buying back and burning UNI. But users paid $73.8M in fees, and most of that went to LPs. Holders get all of the revenue, which works out to about 11% of the fees.
8. Aero (AERO)
$7.3M of its $7.6M revenue goes to stakers. About 96%.
But since the new system went live on October 22, LPs have claimed about $6.5M in fresh AERO rewards. That cancels out most of it. You're getting paid with one hand and diluted with the other.
9. Jupiter (JUP)
$6.2M revenue, $2.3M to holders. About 37%.
Half of Jupiter's revenue buys JUP, but the tokens go into a trust instead of getting burned. As of mid-October, it was holding about 176M JUP. Held tokens can still be used later. Burned ones can't.
10. Lighter (LIT)
$5.4M revenue, $4.4M to holders. About 81%.
Fees fund daily buybacks, and the bought LIT gets burned in batches, so it's gone for good. A big unlock is due in December, though, so next month's math could look different.
Rule of thumb: holders revenue minus dilution. Positive means you're getting paid to hold. Negative means you're paying to hold (roughly speaking).
A couple of disclaimers: Numbers may have small discrepancies obv. Also, DefiLlama doesn't track unlocks for Papertrade, Collector Crypt or World Liberty Financial, so treat their numbers as best case.
I also skipped stablecoin issuers, chains, and anything without a token. Four of the top earners don't even have one.
So the takeaway is: a protocol making money and a token paying you are two separate questions.
Before you hold something for its revenue, check how much actually reaches you, whether you have to stake to get it, and whether unlocks are eating it.
Which one surprised you?