Just beat Dead Island 2 and for a TLDR; it's good. solid gameplay, fun loop, interesting enemies, and characters who grew on me. But the story was so damn cookie cutter I could tell what was going to happen and where, not to mention the wasted potential that was the Umen or whatever it was. lots of buildup and talk of 'destiny' for absolute bupkis.
I LOVED how resources and money stayed useful throughout the game, I was constantly thinking about 'what do I sell, what do I keep, what do I scrap' for materials to keep my best gear in top shape. I liked how I could keep broken stuff and repair it good as new, though it felt like all the melee weapons went into 3 categories: Bonk (good for stagger, but they weren't as fun to use as the others) Poke (the spear executions were great fun, but I didn't use them much because they are single target damage and you're constantly swarmed by enemies so not as useful) and Slash (my favorite because swords are cooler than anything else and that is a fact, found them to be the most useful because the big ones had large sweeps that did solid damage and the smaller ones were fast as hell and did great damage)
though you can upgrade and craft weapons to suit what YOU want to play with which is honestly great. loved the progression from random kitchen knives, shovels, nail guns and whatever you could get, to swords, axes, rifles, and legitimate weapons. it was great!
I don't like how the Fury was so... samey for all the slayers. I remember in the first game each character got their own rage, one of them got a gun, another pulled a really cool knife, etc. I feel like a lot of the characters in this one just aren't that different in terms of playstyle or gameplay. though the skill cards were fun to mess with and fit a playstyle I liked (lots of blocking and countering for me) and I adored the artwork.
the writing for the POV characters though... not something I really cared for for the most part. I went with Ryan, and while some of his quips about being a stripper were funny, most of the time it was very 'MCU' writing, and not even REAL MCU writing, but the kind people put in skits to make fun of the writing. can't go 5 minutes without some joke or quip or whatever. and while it's not BAD, I do think it got a bit tedious and can only imagine doing a new game plus.
locations were fun and varied, would have preferred more to each area though. maybe a film set that's a comedy or something, a house that had a weeb or someone obsessed with a specific culture (Canadian would be hilarious), something that differentiated them from just 'rich person lived here'. though the areas are detailed enough that you won't really get bored and some of the side characters are endearing, like the cowboy actor or the bobcat kids.
for the side quests, I swear some of them feel like they were written by angry boomers. the first lost and found I did one seemed particularly mean spirited, a girl in her late teens early 20's (a kid for christ's sake) got arrested for fighting off a zombie and got eaten by her friend while BEGGING for someone to help her. I get that it's a 'tragic' thing but fuck that felt really mean spirited. the rest of them though were either endearing or amusing enough (the god's and whiskey guy's quest was just fun, ripping through a house party like that).
overall: good game. need to replay the first one, but yeah. good game. very solid, and I'm certain is a lot more fun with friends.