I’m only about halfway through the story, but during my time spent, I’ve come to the conclusion that Dead Island is better. Maybe it’s nostalgia speaking, and I don’t think DI2 is bad by any means, but I just have a stronger preference for DI1. I was never really a fan of carrying around a bajillion weapons, and even in DI2, there’s so much to keep track of. Also, most zombies in DI2 are just variants of walkers or runners, and I think there was a lot more creativity with the enemies in DI1 and Riptide.
I’ll never forget the time that my Mom’s brother accompanied me to purchase DI1 for Xbox 360 when I was 14 and I was at Target with him, his wife, and my cousins, just because I needed an adult with me due to my age and the game’s rating. I had heard a bit about Dead Island before that, but I wasn’t sure what the game was like, and I got my chance when I saw it in the shelves at Target.