I [22F] recently had a short interaction with a guy [23M] on Instagram, and I'm curious to know how other people would interpret this situation and what they would do in my position.
For some context, he was already in my Instagram mutuals because we went to the same school. He was my senior, although I didn't actually know him back then. So when he replied to one of my stories, I recognised that we had a school connection, which made me a little more comfortable replying.
This was actually the first time I've ever replied to a guy who approached me on Instagram. Usually, I either don't reply at all or end up blocking them because I'm generally quite cautious about these interactions. I don't casually entertain conversations with random guys or any guy for that matter.
We ended up having a pretty flirty conversation. He complimented me, said he was flirting "only with me, apparently," ofc I do not believe that and eventually he suggested that we meet for coffee. I found him nice, and honestly, I was starting to feel a little attracted to him. We also had a few things in common and the conversation felt quite natural.
We spoke for only a day, though. I didn't really carry the conversation forward because I've lately been quite busy with work, and I want to put most of my attention and energy into that. I also didn't give him my number because I am not comfortable doing so. We left things on a positive note and said we might catch up sometime.
However, recently I came across some of his Instagram activity. I noticed that just a couple of days before he flirted with me, he had commented "single?" under another girl's post. She replied something along the lines of (basically dismissing his attempt). A few days later, I noticed another comment from him on her post calling her "sweetheart". Also the girl is someone random, from a different state so guessing not someone he knows and she does acknowledge his comments but she doesn't even follow him back.
Now, I obviously don't know him well enough to judge his entire personality or intentions. Maybe he's naturally flirty, maybe he enjoys attention, or maybe there's more context I'm unaware of. But the timing of these interactions, especially alongside him telling me he was flirting "only with me," has made me question how genuine that conversation was.
I think what makes me particularly conscious about this is that I know how common casual flirting has become. Both guys and girls can talk to multiple people, flirt, and keep conversations going without necessarily having any particular intentions. There's nothing inherently wrong with that when everyone is on the same page, but I'm personally quite wary of getting involved in something where I might misunderstand someone's intentions or end up being just another person they're casually flirting with.
I'm not expecting exclusivity from someone I've spoken to for a day. I barely know him, and he is obviously free to interact with whoever he wants. But I do value intentionality. I'd rather get to know someone who is genuinely interested than feel like I'm one of several people they're casually trying their luck with.
The funny thing is that I was genuinely finding him attractive before I saw all this. Now I feel like that attraction has almost disappeared. It's strange how quickly your perception of someone can change based on what you discover about them.
I'm also at a point in my life where I want to focus on my work and career, so I don't want to invest time or emotions into something unless there's a genuine reason to.
But a part of me is still curious about him. I don't know whether I should completely leave it at that or whether I'm being too quick to dismiss someone I barely know.
Towards end of our convo I let him know that I think he's cute but he seems like the type to flirt with every other girl. He didn't dismiss that, just said he knows why I'd think that and I'll have to meet him to find out.
So I'd really like opinions on a few things:
Am I reading too much into his Instagram activity?
Is this just normal, harmless flirting, especially when two people aren't dating or exclusive?
Would this put you off someone you were beginning to like?
Am I being overly cautious because I'm not used to these kinds of interactions?
Is it unreasonable to want someone who doesn't seem to flirt with multiple women online?
Would you approach him again if you were in my position, or would you leave things as they are?
He had suggested meeting for coffee. Would you actually go on the date and get to know him before forming an opinion, or would this behaviour already be enough to put you off?
How do you distinguish someone who is genuinely interested in pursuing you from someone who casually flirts with several people just for attention? What behaviours or signs would you look for?
I guess I'm also wondering how much weight I should give to his Instagram activity when I've only spoken to him for a day. Part of me is still curious about him, but another part doesn't want to entertain something that might not be intentional.
I'd genuinely appreciate honest opinions, even if you think I'm overthinking this. I'm not looking for people to simply validate my reaction; I'd actually like to understand how others would approach this, especially those who've experienced modern dating and the talking stage.
TL;DR: I [22F] had a brief but flirty interaction with a guy [23M] on Instagram and was starting to find him attractive. However, I later noticed him flirting with other women online just days before our conversation. Am I overthinking his behaviour, or would this put you off too? Would you give him a chance over coffee or leave it at that?