r/counterfactuals • • May 10 '15

In a world where Santa Clause is real, which country has the best economy?

10 Upvotes

Santa Clause is a magical being in a non-magical world. He gives gifts to people who are nice and celebrate Christmas. While naughty people get coal in their stocking. He is also capable of granting Christmas wishes/ miracles.


r/counterfactuals • • Feb 12 '13

In a world where the US is not run by a two party system, what are the major political parties?

9 Upvotes

Imagine that the US was not set up with the winner-take-all electoral system it has today, but with a system which makes third parties viable. What would the political spectrum look like? What would be a governing coalition?


r/counterfactuals • • Aug 30 '14

What if everyone had a primary and secondary spouse?

8 Upvotes

Imagine a world in which everyone had two spouses, a primary one whom they lived with, had children with, etc. and a secondary one whom they went on dates with, had sex with, etc. Your secondary spouse would have a primary spouse of their own. The spouses could be either men or women. It would also be customary to be godparents to your second spouse's children. Property inheritance would go to your primary spouse and your children with that person.

In this world, it would be perfectly acceptable to be seen in public with your second spouse, so it wouldn't be scandalous like having a mistress or paramour. Let's say that it would be taboo to try to have more than one of each, and anyone who tried would be seen akin to an adulterer.

How would this effect our lives? Would there be less infidelity? If politicians had two spouses, would there be as many sex scandals? Imagine if Monica Lewinsky had been Bill Clinton's second wife! Would there be fewer wars due to there being more connections through marriage?


r/counterfactuals • • Feb 07 '13

In a world without the 17th century revolutions in science and philosophy, is the "west" still dominant globally?

8 Upvotes

The 17th century was utterly revolutionary for European society. At the conclusion of the 30 years war in 1648, Europe was exhausted by religious wars, economically drained, and looked to be headed for another downturn comparable to the plague-induced 14th century stagnation or the feudal bloodshed of the post-Carolingian world. But instead, great men like Descartes, Newton, Locke, Smith (and countless others!) rescued Europe. The revolutions in science and philosophy arguably laid the groundwork for European domination of the rest of the old world (the "east").

Feel free to disagree with the argument. But if you think it has merit, let's talk about what happens instead. What does a stagnating Europe, or even a Europe sliding backwards, look like? Presumably that gives Indian, Oriental, and (yes!) African power space to continue flourishing. Can they use that space to dominate the world the way Europeans would do in our time line? Why or why not?

P.S. Zvika, in the thread on /r/althistory we mentioned that this subreddit could take a more "serious" tack to differentiate itself from /r/HistoricalWhatIf. This is what those sorts of questions would look like.


r/counterfactuals • • Mar 30 '13

Marshal Tukhachevsky, the man who could have been the Soviet Union's Napoleon

7 Upvotes

He was a brilliant military mind who was promoted to Marshall when he was barely into his 40s, despite having the guts to oppose Stalin more then once. For that tenacity he was executed in the Great Purge. But what if he had fulfilled Stalin's paranoid fears and successfully staged a coup, seizing the reigns of power on the eve of World War Two? I try to address that possibility here.


r/counterfactuals • • Mar 13 '13

Marconi is a fraud, radio revealed to be a hoax: trained carrier pigeons used in plot publicly executed.

7 Upvotes

Complicated wireless transmission just doesn't work in the world. Unless relying on light semaphore, all fast communication relies on wires. How does this impact daily life, warfare, politics? How is music, ideas, news, disseminated? How does communication work before the advent of the internet?


r/counterfactuals • • Feb 20 '13

Potatoes don't grow well outside the Andes

7 Upvotes

How does this change the economic, agricultural, and culinary face of Europe, not to mention the rest of the world? Are there other new world crops, or currently underutilized old world ones, that could fill a similar niche?


r/counterfactuals • • Jun 03 '15

What if the internet started to become popular and available in the 60's

6 Upvotes

r/counterfactuals • • Dec 10 '14

In a world where a small but not insignificant percentage of the population is immortal, what forms of heredity exist or have existed in the royal families of the world?

6 Upvotes

Clarifying assumptions:

  • Immortal people can still be killed, but will not age and die.

  • Immortality can be sought or transmitted but the percentage of immortal world population remains roughly constant through the combination of non-age-related mortality and failure to attain immortality.


r/counterfactuals • • Aug 26 '14

What if a benevolent alien species arrived at the start of WW2?

6 Upvotes

Suppose that an alien ship appeared over the German Reichstag building on Sept. 4th, 1939 and made an offer to the German government:

  1. All of the people of Germany would be taken to an Earth-like planet in another stellar system. There would be ready-made cities there at the same level of technological development as Germany at that time. They would have an entire planet of Lebensraum. The aliens promise that the evacuation can be completed within a month.

  2. The vacated German territory would be divided as follows: All territory east of the Oder-Neiße River, including Königsberg, would be given to Poland, Austria would be given to the Romani people, and the remainder (the same borders as modern Germany) would be given to the Jewish people.

Let's suppose that the aliens look human and speak fluent German and possibly other Earth languages. Let's also suppose that their contact with Earth is minimal, they leave as soon as this mission is complete, and that no technology is left behind. Let's suppose that their technology is so advanced that humans wouldn't be able to replicate just by glimpsing it.

Would Hitler agree to this? Would the prospect of an entire German-only planet be too much to pass up, or would giving up his beloved Germany be too much to ask?

With Germany becoming a Jewish homeland, what would happen to Palestine after the mandate ends in 1948? Would there be two Israels, one in the Middle East and one in Europe? Would they be united as one political entity in two territories, or would they be two separate countries? Or, would the Jewish people pick only one as their new homeland? How would their relations with other countries be?

Would the Soviet Union invade Western Europe? Would the League of Nations establish the new Jewish and Romani homelands as mandates under their protection for a time (i.e. until their governments and militaries are established)?

Without German scientists (Von Braun, et al.) how would technological development proceed? Would we be less advanced than in OTL? How would technology proceed on the German world?

If Hitler refuses the offer, and the timeline of WW2 is otherwise the same, how would knowledge that extraterrestrials exist shape the next few decades, even without further contact?


r/counterfactuals • • Feb 10 '14

What would the world, society, and civilization at large be like if human beings did not have to sleep?

6 Upvotes

Its said that we spend nearly one third of our lives asleep. Imagine if humans had no need to sleep. I'm not saying we would never be in/or want a relaxed state or to be in or desire a state of leisure, but what if we had no mental/physiological/physical need to be unconscious for 1/3 of our existence? How would this effect humanity and our way of life as a civilization?


r/counterfactuals • • Feb 22 '13

In a world where the Library of Alexandria never burned to the ground, where would we be today technologically?

6 Upvotes

r/counterfactuals • • Feb 05 '13

In a world where wolves were never domesticated into dogs, what would Man's Best Friend be?

6 Upvotes

r/counterfactuals • • Feb 05 '13

In a world where the Archduke of Austria-Hungary was never assassinated in Sarajevo, igniting World War One, which country would be the first to the moon?

6 Upvotes

If Gavrilo Princip hadn't succeeded in shooting the heir to the throne of Austria-Hungary, and World War One never occurred (assume that it wasn't simply set off by a later trigger), what would drive the space race? Who would be the competitors? Who would be the victor? And why?


r/counterfactuals • • Apr 30 '16

If Germany would have won World War I, then how successful would post-World War I German colonization in Eastern Europe have been?

5 Upvotes

Any thoughts on this?

Also, for the record, I am primarily talking about relatively sparsely populated Eastern European territories here (and if these relatively sparsely populated Eastern European territories have a history of ethnic German rule--such as Latvia and Estonia--then they work even better here).


r/counterfactuals • • Mar 24 '13

What if the Columbian expedition was a complete failure?

5 Upvotes

I attempt to answer that question in this post. Tell me what you think.


r/counterfactuals • • Feb 09 '13

In a world where coal doesn't burn, would we have ever experienced the Industrial Revolution?

5 Upvotes

Coal and steam engines were paramount and essential to the beginnings of the English Industrial Revolution, which laid the way for other nations to follow. If coal was chemically different enough that it didn't burn, that route to non-muscle power would be closed. Would the Revolution still be possible? What might it have looked like?


r/counterfactuals • • Feb 05 '13

In a world without Judaism, what would be the dominant religions of today?

5 Upvotes

No Judaism, no Christianity, no Islam, none of the Abrahamic faiths. Moses dropped a tablet, tripped on it, and parted his skull from his shoulders on the way down the mountain, and the Israelites wandered the desert for the rest of their lives. What fills the gaps? Would the world of today be any more peaceful without the seemingly endless friction between these faiths?


r/counterfactuals • • Oct 09 '16

Plausibility Check: A German-Russian Alliance Starting From the Early 1890s and a Subsequent Partition of Austria-Hungary

4 Upvotes

Basically, what I am thinking of is this--if German Kaiser Wilhelm II, for whatever reason (such as an extremely severe head injury), gets a personality change shortly before he becomes the German Kaiser in 1888, would this series of events be plausible? :

-1890: German Kaiser Wilhelm II renews the Reinsurance Treaty with Russia and, to put the icing on the cake, offers to throw Austria-Hungary under the bus and to ally with Russia. Russia accepts this German offer due to its belief that Germany can be a good partner for partitioning Austria-Hungary between the two of them in the future.

-1890s: Germany strengthens its alliance with Italy (the Triple Alliance now becomes the Dual Alliance due to Austria-Hungary being thrown under the bus by Germany and thus being kicked out of this alliance) and its secret alliance with Romania. Sometime afterwards, both Russia and Romania formally join the Dual Alliance (of Germany and Italy) and thus transform it into the Quadruple Alliance (of Germany, Italy, Russia, and Romania).

-1903: After a successful pro-Russian coup in Serbia, Serbia joins the Quadruple Alliance and thus transforms it into the Quintuple Alliance (also known as the Central Powers Alliance).

-1917: Franz Joseph, the monarch of Austria-Hungary, passes away and is succeeded by his nephew Franz Ferdinand (who isn't assassinated in Sarajevo in 1914 in this TL). After the Auslgeich (Austro-Hungarian Union) collapses shortly afterwards and Austria-Hungary descends into civil war as a result of Hungary's attempt to secede, the Quintuple Alliance immediately seize their chance and invade Austria-Hungary (after staging some fake Austrian border attacks similar to what Nazi Germany did in regards to Poland in 1939 in our TL, of course).

While both Britain and France are extremely angry at this move on the part of the Quintuple Alliance, they don't actually do anything meaningful in response to this due to their belief that they cannot defeat such an extremely powerful alliance.

-1918: The Quintuple Alliance finishes (successfully) militarily crushing Austria-Hungary--forcing Franz Ferdinand to surrender to the Quintuple Alliance.

Afterwards, the Quintuple Alliance imposes this peace deal:

-Germany annexes (German) Austria, Bohemia, Moravia, and maybe northern Slovenia as well. -Russia annexes Galicia and either annexes or puppetizes Slovakia. -Italy annexes Trentino, South Tyrol (for defensive purposes), the Istrian Peninsula (including Trieste, of course), Fiume (Rijeka), and Dalmatia. -Romania annexes Transylvania and any other Romanian-majority parts of Austria-Hungary. -Serbia annexes Vojvodina, Bosnia, Croatia (minus Dalmatia and the Istrian Peninsula, of course), and either all of Slovenia (minus the Istrian Peninsula, of course) or only southern Slovenia (if Germany annexes northern Slovenia, that is). -The Hungarian separatists are allowed to remain in power if they agreed to transform Hungary into a neutral state (through a treaty--as was the case for Belgium) through which both the German bloc (Germany, Italy, and Romania) and the Russian bloc (Russia, Slovakia, and Serbia) have a freedom of passage (as well as to all of Hungary's territorial losses, of course). If the Hungarian separatists refuse to agree to all of these terms, then the Quintuple Alliance forcibly removes them from power in Hungary and imposes a new, more pliant Hungarian leadership who is willing to agree to all of these terms. (Indeed, having Hungary as a neutral state with freedom of passage for everyone would make it easier for Germans to access Romania and make it easier for Russians to access Serbia.)

Indeed, how exactly does all of that sound? :)

Also, how exactly does my scenario here sound in general? :)


r/counterfactuals • • Feb 04 '16

U.S. President James Garfield survives; does Garfield veto *all* forms of the Chinese Exclusion Act that reach his desk afterwards?

4 Upvotes

Frankly, I am curious if a surviving U.S. President James Garfield would have been less willing to compromise with the anti-Chinese immigration politicians than U.S. President Chester Arthur was in real life.

Indeed, any thoughts on this?


r/counterfactuals • • Mar 31 '15

1945 Election

4 Upvotes

If for whatever reason Winston Churchill had won a second term in the 1945 election instead of Clement Atlee winning his first, how does the current UK differ from our own?


r/counterfactuals • • May 15 '14

What if Woodrow Wilson had helped Ho Chi Minh's request for independence from France?

4 Upvotes

r/counterfactuals • • Apr 17 '14

How would things been different if we were in orbit with another planet that had evolved similarly to Earth?

4 Upvotes

r/counterfactuals • • Feb 27 '13

Balkanized China

4 Upvotes

Let's say in a parallel to the Roman Empire, after the collapse of the Jin or Sui or Tang dynasty, China never unfragments. We look at maybe 1400 years of local Chinese polities struggling and vying for power amongst each other, warring over splits in Buddhism and Daoism, against (brief) occupations from Steppe invaders and Muslim incursions.

What do we see around 1900? Does this rivalry spur innovation and outward expansion? How is Japan? Korea? The East Indies? What of the Manchu, Mongolia, and Siberia? Are sailors from Guangzhou discovering Australia and Madagascar, and clashing with the Dutch and Portuguese at sea?


r/counterfactuals • • Feb 22 '13

In a world where the Indians beat the Americans to Mars, will it be enough of a kick in the pants to restart the Space Race?

4 Upvotes