r/cormoran_strike • u/Matilda-17 • 7h ago
Character analysis/observation Robin’s secretiveness
Like everyone else, I’m very glad that Robin will apparently finally start dealing with some of her pathological mental stuff in the 9th book.
Looking back, there’s some things that long pre-date any of her recent traumas, or even the oldest trauma, that almost break the suspension of disbelief. What I have the biggest issue with is that Robin was so secretive about her desire to be involved in criminal investigation, that even her boyfriend/fiancé and her mother were unaware. I find the “oh but her brothers made fun of her!” excuse to be weak. You’re telling me that two teenager in their last years of school before university, never had a “what do you want to do as a career? What do you want to study and why?” conversation? Matthew is quite justified in being disbelieving when Robin asserts that she ALWAYS wanted to be a detective, since before they’d even started dating… she’d just never mentioned this. In 9 years. That is weird! It’s bizarrely secretive and private, especially with someone she’s building a life with. Same with Linda—they seemed pretty close, before the Strike situation started driving them apart; its hard to think that Robin signed up for her university course in psychology without ever confessing to her mom what she was hoping to do with it after. Again, the idea that Linda never asked, so, what do you think you’ll do after uni? Whats the plan with the psych degree? is ludicrous. As is the idea that Robin would be afraid that her mother would make fun of her. And her dad? The one who knows Robin well enough to get her in that pro driving course? She never told him her hopes? It’s really at odds with the “nice happy family” vibe that they’ve got going on, that they basically don’t know this fundamental truth about their only daughter—because she didn’t feel comfortable telling them. It doesn’t mesh with what we’ve seen of their characters to date. Also, perhaps little-girl Robin was cowed by her rowdy brothers being mean, but adult Robin more than holds her own in that group and it’s really difficult to buy that she was so abashed by them that it stuck forever.
Anyway I know it was for convenient plot reasons but it’s so unbelievable that it bugs me every time and it makes me take MATTHEW’S side, which is intolerable. How dare he be right?!