r/cormoran_strike • • Sep 19 '25 Sipping Tea

The Hallmarked Man The Hallmarked man sucked Spoiler

22 Upvotes

This book really disappointed me. Romantic part was as expected - given the previous books events it couldn't be different. Since Robin was given a new bf in the previous book, and he was instantly introduced as a person with a problem, you could see the slightly different but still a Matthew 2.0 situation and because Robin will be in a serious and complicated relationship her potential romantic line with Strike was doomed to start like what we ended up getting here. I knew it was coming, I accepted it's unavoidable, I moved on before the last book was even published. But the rest of the book, my god. Rowling really needs to log off from Twitter and chill with the misery porn, because it is beyond. To be honest with the whole series I felt that there was an intentional part all about Rowling's holywar with both far right and far left social media. We even got a dedicated book about it. I did not mind it until the Hallmarked man, because it never overshadowed the literature part. But this book. How much more women torture should we add so the young reader would understand, how important it is to protect women? (That's 99% of Rowling's social media posts nowadays icymi). Let's make Robin pregnant, then lose the baby, and then let's she will be literally scarred inside because of the rape. More sex trafficking for the God of sex trafficking! You thought previous book was bad with the cult harvesting babies? How about a modern day Nabokov scenario except he got her pregnant, killed and hid the body in the basement's floor, the very same basement where he has a sex-slave on a chain? Decima being in love with her lost half-brother and with an incestuous child is a cherry on top of this whole thing. We get it, Joan, you are concerned about women's safety, and you don't let us fucking forget it. The worst part is that here her willing to raise awareness completely overpowered the story, because it doesn't make sense. Chloe has been plotting her escape with Tyler for years, then the whole thing was uncovered because Griff the rapist knew a complicated symbolism of her real name in the foreign language?! Strike doesn't want to press Rupert's friend who clearly knows something, and wants to focus on literally anybody else than Rupert, the person he was hired to find?! The attack on Robin in the crowd which was physically impossible, the fact that some lowlife criminals dug up about the gorilla thing (not the masons who could possibly get any info - a very low calibre scum). For someone who is spending this much time in the internet Rowling's understanding of it is as if it's like 3 websites with 100 users, so any given "Austin h" will for sure be the same person, and Instagram has no power to remove impersonators, and people are posting comment threads (?!?!) Of only fans to the dark net, and if you watch a random execution video from isis it's a big chance you will see there someone you know, and if you start googling misspelled names from UK you will get a niche old articles from Belgium. Nothing makes sense. Any given bit of the investigative part of the book ends up with understanding that absolutely everything happened because Rowling needed it to happen. Fucking weights bit, I can't, go ahead Tyler, buy a one of a kind thing with your last money and then be afraid of people seeing it forever, because mama Joan said so. I don't remember her being this sloppy, but here we are. Whatever happened to the mystery that is the case that should be investigated here, because someone bloody murdered her.


r/cormoran_strike • • Aug 27 '25

Opinion Unpopular Opinion: I HATE RYAN MURPHY & Strike and Robin are getting on my last nerves. The "will they/won't they" romantic trope me so angry at this point... Anyone else feel this?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'm exhausted & tired by the constant hot & cold romantic tension (read: nonsense) between Strike & Robin, but because of how they just cannot seem to have an adult conversation (Robin's 32 & Strike is 42 in "The Running Grave") I have come to dislike so many characters who honestly have done nothing wrong.

Right now on the hot seat is Ryan Murphy - I HATE HIM and its just not justifiable I feel. What did he do? He asked a girl he thought was great out & and actually had the balls to tell her how he felt and get into a relationship with her. That's all he's done. Even the points where Robin perceives he is perhaps acting like her ex-husband, Matthew Cunliffe - if I think about it rationally, like of course there will be some level of jealousy and ego seeing that Robin & Strike have such a close working relationship and you can tell they like being around each other. Ryan (by "The Running Grave") has quite frankly done nothing wrong & the whole Wardle telling Strike about how Ryan can be a "mean drunk" - clearly Ryan knows this and has given up alcohol. And yes there are some annoying parts about his personality, but I irrationally HATE MURPHY because he isn't Strike and now its one more hurdle (possibly the biggest) Strike has to jump through in order to get with Robin. I know JK Rowling is trying for this not to be a romantic series - but like YOU HAVE INTRODUCED THE ROMANTIC ANGLE SINCE "Cuckoo's Calling". Almost 10-11 years in the making, give the readers what they want & still keep it interesting.

At this point I'd rather see Strike & Robin confess that they are in love with each other & give the relationship a go. I'd rather see how their relationship pans out and how they learn that although they know each other for so long and are in love with each other - a relationship between them is no cake in the park and they'll still have to do the work and communicate with each other. I'd also rather they get together, break up, and get together again so that they come back to each other. I honestly don't want LESS DRAMA - I just want drama that makes sense for their age. They are so smart and have grown so much individually (and together as friends) - now I think its fair that Jo give us Strike & Robin the couple. Still imperfect, but figuring it out. Still scared that they will ruin the friendship they have, but together inspite of that fear because they know they are meant to be together. Like JEEZ.

I'm doing a re-read of "The Running Grave" and I'm just about to throw the book because if the 2 year timeline in between books is a fair assessment of when JK Rowling publishes - we have another 4-5 years until Book 10. I will LOSE IT if Strike & Robin are still playing around each other. I used to love the will they/won't they - but I feel like now its bordering on unrealistic notions. I also think if they got together after all of this build up, they might have a hard time going from friends to lovers because they've been so enmeshed in the friendship for so long that anything else feels weird at that point. "The Hallmarked Man" would honestly be the time when Murphy is dumped and Strike & Robin at least have a real ass conversation.


r/cormoran_strike • • Sep 12 '25

Fanworks New AI images for Book Robin and Strike!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

This time, I think I got AI to make Strike a little more accurate, looking more like Beethoven with a broke nose and more intimidating/rough face. Beardless, but unshaven, as he often is nowadays! Also, way thinner now after his healthier approach to eating and smoking habits!

This version of Robin is actually with her "Venetia Hall" disguise, and I honestly think AI nailed it on this one!


r/cormoran_strike • • Dec 22 '23

The Ink Black Heart Ink Black Heart was a failed experiment (I hope)

5 Upvotes

Normally any JK Rowling book will be read by me in days if not faster. Order of the Phoenix was read on a 3 day (trans Siberian) train ride. It took me months to plough through the Ink Blank Heart. In fact it became my airport/train ride book.

It was good enough to entertain me in an airport, or on a train, but easy to put down, almost a relief to put down.

I hope the presentation of the plot through mod chat and Twitter feeds was an experiment. You can admire JK for pushing the envelope. Being avant garde. Boldly going where no author has gone before.

Do that and you're bound to have fails. At least this book was my least favourite. I found the mod logs tedious, especially the new speak in them. Likewise all the twitter feeds with its newspeak: LOL, STFU etc. I actually preferred borkled.

It was only in the last 200 pages that the book grabbed me and became a page turner. Only when Amonie was banning people every chat and the plot finally started moving.

So while I applaud JK Rowling's adventurousness and desire to experiment; I hope she will write this off as a failed experiment.


r/cormoran_strike • • Apr 28 '25

Strike is really annoying as a person

7 Upvotes

Just finished The Silkworm for the first time (please no spoilers for the next books), and I must say — Cormoran is kinda awful as a person. Don’t get me wrong, he’s a great character and main hero, but as a person?

Throughout the whole book, he uses the people around him and barely cares about any of them:

He doesn’t care about Lucy and her kids, even though she’s probably the only relative who truly cares about him. He doesn’t even remember his nephews’ names.

He used Nina to get information and as someone to comfort him, then just ignored her.

He treats the only brother who’s interested in him like a tool — nothing personal.

Strike wasn’t exactly a perfect human being in the first book, but it was understandable — painful breakup, nowhere to live, no job, nothing. It’s hard to be a good person when your life is literally falling apart.

But in The Silkworm, you start to understand why he stayed with Charlotte for 16 years — they’re both pretty hard to be around. In The Cuckoo’s Calling, you sympathize with him because he’s clearly broken and isolated. Turns out, he’s not that alone — he just doesn’t like the people who are still around him. And that’s obviously his choice, but it definitely makes me feel less sympathetic toward him.

I guess it’s kind of a well-worn take, but just wanted to share my opinion so thanks for reading


r/cormoran_strike • • Nov 21 '23

The Running Grave Charlotte Campbell Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Spoiler alert: Was anybody else upset by Charlotte's suicide? I know I'm fairly alone with this PoV but I kinda enjoyed her. I was also horrfied by Strike's sudden callousness...especially when he reacted so differently during TB. I lost a bit of love for his character whene appeared to care so little...any normal person would feel guilty not taking the last phonecall from someone who died shortly after...especially given their history. After all, he had once admitted it was her showing up in the hospital after he lost his leg that gave hin the courage to go on. I really didn't like him much in this book.


r/cormoran_strike • • Sep 28 '25

The Hallmarked Man Recurrence of sexual assault claims being unfounded/doubted/wrong throughout series Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I really did not like that jkr included the storyline of Strike being falsely accused of sexual assault in book 8. Then I realized how often sexual assault claims are implied to be false or at the very least questionable.

The first example I can remember is in the Silkworm when Orlando says "Daniel Chard touched me" and it turns out there was nothing sexual involved. I know this is a bit different because Orlando's intention behind what she said was unclear. But jkr still chose to include that and have everyone (Strike, Robin, and Lenora) assume it was/could be sexual assault and then later have that assumption proved wrong.

Next one I remember is Troubled Blood when Wilma the social worker's daughters discuss their dad's imprisonment and state that the rape he was arrested for was a set up due to racism/fear of being caught for infidelity by his white girlfriend. It's never stated whether the allegations were true or not, but Robin thinks to herself how much she hates the idea of anyone lying about rape.

Then in book 7 Kevin is falsely accused of sexually assaulting his sisters. We have that mostly confirmed as false when Emily says Becca made her do it. Then Robin gets falsely accused of CSA by the church. I know this is part of the church's way to silence and discredit people, but jkr chose to have them do that by falsely accusing people of sexual assault.

And finally book 8 where Strike is falsely accused of sexual assault.

It seems like a theme that is becoming more and more prevalent in her books and I think it's weird that she keeps writing these scenarios where people "cry rape" and are wrong/bad people who do it (excepting Orlando).

Of course we all know the books include confirmed sexual assault as well. Primarily against Robin but also other women. However, the recurrence of people lying about sexual assault, especially in book 8 is really starting to bother me.


r/cormoran_strike • • May 05 '24

The Running Grave Did the physical description of Dr. Zhou in TRG make anyone else feel a bit uncomfortable?

9 Upvotes

From Chapter 31, when Robin first meets Dr. Zhou: "Robin assumed he was biracial because he was well over six feet tall – the Chinese men she was used to seeing in Chinatown, near the office, were generally much shorter – and he was undeniably handsome, with his slicked-back black hair and high cheekbones."

I'm of Chinese heritage, and the aside about height felt uncomfortably close to being a rather racist stereotype, which surprised me because I feel like race is generally handled quite well in the Strike series. It's probably true that on average, Asian men in Western countries are shorter than white men, but a) being half-white is no guarantee of being taller b) it just feels very superfluous. The height comment could easily have been left out — Robin could have just thought "he looked biracial, half-Chinese and half-white".

Some other points:

  • In a multiracial city like London, surely Robin isn't only seeing Chinese men in Chinatown?

  • The perceived lower average height of Chinese men is likely a combination of a) China being very poor until the recent few decades => malnutrition, and b) most of the immigrants to Western countries before the last two decades were from southern China, which has a lower average height than northern China (rather like how, as far as I'm aware, Scandinavians are tall among Europeans)

Anyway, not trying to accuse JKR of being racist, just wondering how this came across to other readers.


r/cormoran_strike • • Mar 13 '25

Opinion Am I the only one who thinks this book series gets worse by the day?

1 Upvotes

I'm probably shooting myself on the foot by saying this in here, but whatever. I'm a crime novel lover - love Agatha, love Sherlock. My friend recommended me the Strike series, and I really liked it. The first three books, that is.

I feel as though Lethal White shifted this series, and not in a good way. The books became excessively bloated, with unecessary details about the characters lives outside the cases. I mean, those scenes existed in Cuckoo's Calling and The Silkworm, but they stretched for like 30 or 45 pages, while in more recent books such as Troubled Blood or The Ink Black Heart, those scenes would take almost half of the book.

So what do we have left if we take these out? Mostly non interesting cases, horrendously slow pacing, and plot twists that don't work anymore, because they are spliced up in 100 pages. I mean, in Lethal White, the murder only happens in the middle of the book! In Troubled Blood, it happened like 40 years ago! I'm sorry, those are not that interesting to read, because they are not quick paced, witty or have any urgency to them.

The Ink Black Heart and The Running Grave legit read as Rowling just writing for the sake of it, without having anything meaninful to say. She just wants to play with the characters she created (that are amazing, don't get me wrong), but she doesn't want to give them anything interesting to work with.


r/cormoran_strike • • Jan 05 '24

Opinion I think we lost momentum…(Spoilers)

0 Upvotes

I don’t know why but Ink Black Heart and The Running Grave, despite having its moments, felt like a drag or everything happening all at once and pacing was off. Robin’s gradual progression to being a “true” detective is being burdened with an unrealistic amount of PTSD.

In first books she was trying to solve the cases with her mind, or took proportional physical risks compared to these books. To show the stakes are high, Rowling keeps making the situations ridiculously dangerous, which cheapens the thrill.

Robin’s parents being concerned is OBVIOUSLY right. At this point even I’m concerned. She seems to be dedicated, halfway earned Strike’s respect, but will-they-won’t-they and the fact that absurd amount of trauma happens to her as a plot point, forgotten the next page just kills the momentum for me.

Remember she got into a bloody fight at the end of Ink Black Heart? Me neither. Because she just got locked in a barrel in this one. Keeps insisting she’s fine :(


r/cormoran_strike • • Nov 30 '25

Book Discussion Unpopular opinion: Matth isn’t actually the villain

0 Upvotes

Edit: This is just a discussion about the series; be mature, the characters are fictional. Personal attacks or questions like “why are you reading the series if you hate it?” will result in a block.

I know most people hate Matthew because he cheated on Robin — and yes, he was wrong. But rereading the series, I realized that everything we know about him comes entirely through Robin’s perspective. She only shows him in negative moments, already filtered through her frustration and disappointment. Basically, we readers only know Matthew through her eyes, which are far from objective.

At the same time, Robin never fully acknowledges her own thoughts about the relationship and keeps going with him, then moves on to Murphy and repeats the exact same patterns. It’s easy to empathize with her, especially if you’ve been cheated on, but the truth is that Robin was waiting for something to blow up because she wanted to end the relationship she just didn’t want to be the one to say “it’s over.”

And here’s the part most people ignore: Matth also has a positive side. The fact that he stayed by her after the trauma in college, even though their relationship was already over, wasn’t an act of control or self-importance. It was simply loyalty and genuine care for who she used to be not romance, but humanity.

Yes, their dynamic couldn’t go back to what it once was. Yes, the relationship was already damaged. But that doesn’t make Matth the antagonist of the story. It makes him an imperfect person in an imperfect relationship, stuck in a narrative told by someone who could no longer see him clearly.


r/cormoran_strike • • Sep 28 '23

Book Discussion Strike&Robin

3 Upvotes

I don't know if this is unpopular opinion, but am i the only one who doesn't want Strike and Robin together? Like, i feel that their relationship would be ruined really quick and i think they are perfect as best friends. Also, don't forget that jkr is TERRIBLE at writing romance )) so a deeply emotional relationship between strike and robin would bring the end of the series and the agency they have built


r/cormoran_strike • • Jun 05 '24

Why JKR use the first name "Joan" as the name of the "mother" of Strike ?

1 Upvotes

I notice this thing since a few months ago... And I wonder why JKR used her name to name one of the character who is like a mother for Strike ?

Do you think there is a reason ? :-)

I'm curious about your view on this point !

PS : English is not my mother tongue so sorry if my writing is not completely correct :-)


r/cormoran_strike • • Feb 28 '24

Strellacott Why can’t R & S be just friends?

0 Upvotes

I read so many posts cheering for Robin and Strike to date, marry, etc… and even some claiming he is not good enough for her. But has anyone considered that man and women are capable of being just friends?


r/cormoran_strike • • Jun 15 '26

Book 9 - Sleep Tight, Evangeline With the new header, I feel like I've finally solved the whole thing haha

9 Upvotes

I think I've got it all figured out haha.

Bijou's child is Cormoran's child - she lied to him. It's a clear parallel to Strike's own story. He grew up with a chaotic mother, and Bijou is chaotic too. Robin has reproductive difficulties, so she may not be able to have children. The relationship between Strike and Bijou was casual, and the pregnancy was accidental, which makes the parallel even stronger. I think Strike and Robin will end up raising his and Bijou's child after something happens to Bijou. This would allow him to understand his father better and would probably lead to a reconciliation with him.
Also, the new header that is located opposite the hotel where Bijou obtained Strike's DNA is probably a clue that Bijou actually knows he is the father and will be able to prove it.
What do you think?

upd: I was pointed to the part of the Chapter 78, where it says that Bijou forwarded the test results to Strike. While those results could theoretically have been forged as well, that largely undermines my theory.

Thanks to everyone who debated the issue respectfully. As for those who downvoted me simply for having an opinion and were rude about it, I wish you a good day.


r/cormoran_strike • • Feb 12 '24

General Re. "Take aways," Is Mexican food not a thing in England?

2 Upvotes

I mean, obviously, probably not a lot of Mexican immigrants in England just due to proximity, but here in the US, Mexican/Tex Mex is a MAJOR food staple!

Food is such a running theme in the novels - Curry anyone? Singapore noodles, perhaps? And after making a full taco bash* for Super Bowl tonight, I realized I have never heard even a passing reference to tacos 🌮

*Flank steak marinated in chimichurri

Ground, seasoned taco meat

Queso

Cilantro lime rice

Guacamole

Flour tortillas

Tortilla chips

Cilantro salsa

Esquites


r/cormoran_strike • • Jun 18 '26

The Hallmarked Man Ottelie being Strike's daughter (no jokes or hate)

0 Upvotes

Bijou's reasoning for wanting Strike to take the test was that Honbold wouldn't do it because he thought the child wasn't his. He'd only do it if she took him to court. She begs Strike to do it, saying that if Honbold sees proof that it isn't Strike's, then he'll accept the daughter is his, because probably then he'd do the paternity test himself.

But her reasoning for wanting Strike's sample doesn't make sense. She tells Strike she wants it to prove to Honbold that the child isn't Strike's, but since she and Strike met in secret, she could have well taken any man's sample and sent to Honbold the negative claiming it had been Strike's.

So maybe we can conclude that she never actually proved to Honbold that the child wasn't Strike's. Because, since she met Strike in secret and Honbold never knew they'd met, why would Honbold trust that the negative result she'd sent him was Strike's? She probably never sent that to Honbold.

Bijou actually needed Strike's sample so she'd have a "positive" since Strike is the father.

Which is also likely what she did when she sent Strike the result: someone else's negative.

And then when she did show some random's negative result to Honbold, when he finally accepted doing the test, she probably used Strike's positive sample to convince him Ottelie was in fact his. But this is the part that gets trickier, as Honbold is a smart man and would want to do it directly at a clinic.

Or perhaps it was all a lie she had told Strike and she herself didn't know who of the two was the father. She'd certainly hadn't been able to get pregnant through Honbold so far through their affair (probably cause he'd been taking that drug that lowered his sperm count), and she was kinda smitten with Strike at first, thinking he was attractive and famous, and Ilsa did tell Robin that Bijou really did fancy Corm.

Bijou either thought Strike would make a good "baby-daddy" or she used his sperm from the condom so she could indeed pass off Strike's child as Honbold's, but it ended up backfiring.

Maybe indeed Bijou herself just didn't know who the father was and needed Strike's sample to make sure he wasn't the father.

But I still think, as several others in this community have pointed out, that the way Strike and Bijou took the samples wasn't random, maybe JKR is either trying to confuse us or is already giving us signs something else is to come.

Thoughts?


r/cormoran_strike • • Aug 15 '25

TV Series Why so moody Robin

0 Upvotes

In the Ink Black Heart TV series, did someone steal Robin's happiness? So many chances for a small smile, a little chuckle but so... emotionless? even some genuine emotion when she sees the glass door and realises that it is for real, where's the emotion?

I love Holliday Grainger, but something did not sit right with me in the TV Series. Please be more human in The running grave, love.

Just because there is a need to portray a strong woman, does not mean she becomes devoid of emotion, you know what I mean? Did anyone else feel the same?


r/cormoran_strike • • Sep 09 '25

Fanworks Books-Faithful Cormoran Blue Strike and Robin Venetia Ellacott!

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Just this. I was messing around with AI, and I have always thought that, while lovely and extremely talented actors, Tom Burke and Holly Grainger are not exactly what I imagined for Strike and Robin. Especially Tom, who is way too traditionally handsome to portray Strike accurately.

So, messing a little with Ai generators, I tried to see if they could take book descriptions and make more reliable portraits of the characters. WAS NOT DISAPPOINTED!


r/cormoran_strike • • May 28 '24

Book Discussion Does anyone think JK Rowling emphasizes ‘beauty’ or ‘lack of beauty’ a bit too much in the series? Or am I just self-projecting & overthinking this?

Post image
18 Upvotes

Now hear me out - I love JK Rowling’s writing & I’m not trying to bash her by any means. But I’m re-reading the series & in my opinion the ‘looks’ of her characters are always emphasized the most, to the point that Strike & Robin (and other characters) pass really condescending judgements within their inner monologue about certain characters.

Like for instance Charlotte’s extreme beauty & Matthew’s classic handsomeness - it’s always noted upon in the books & made into such huge deals. It’s kind of like why? Especially in a world that is becoming so much more accepting of the way everyone looks. Strike’s unconventional attractiveness is always commented on & Robin’s more girl-next-door looks are mentioned again & again. Even when the other supporting characters are mentioned - I get describing their physical attributes to allow us readers to picture the characters in our head, but like it’s routinely mentioned thereafter…. It’s a little weird to me.

Is this just a me thing (apologies if it is & I’m totally missing the point of the prose) - but do you guys think JK Rowling does this too much within her writing? Idk if this post even makes sense, but sometimes it makes me uncomfortable because she does so often. I also get that IN REAL LIFE - we think, comment, & judge people on how they look & present themselves - but I’ve never caught myself constantly doing this in real life at every turn or every time I meet someone…. Or maybe I’m not realizing it?

Am I just self-projecting here & over-thinking this?


r/cormoran_strike • • Oct 05 '23

The Running Grave Honest criticism Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I love the series. I just like each book a little less than the previous. The all powerful Rowling needs an editor that isn’t afraid to take a hard trim to her over-indulgences. The books are unnecessarily long mostly due to her need to reiterate the personal history of every character in the next.


r/cormoran_strike • • Sep 11 '25

The Hallmarked Man Unpopular opinion Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I wouldn't mind Strike and Robin having kids, one way or another. Just because some people prefer and/or are "childfree", doesn't mean Robin and Strike have to be. I believe Robin seriously doesn't know when she says she doesn't know if she wants it. Probably not with Ryan anyway. I believe Strike doesn't want them right now but I also believe he would be the first one to step up (like Ted and Joan) if needed (there are already lots of babies in the series). I wouldn't even mind Bijou's baby being Strike's because reality is often messy (Leda - Jonny). Also kids aren't always a "decision" in a vacuum, but in a plethora of different circumstances. I also don't care about "representation" of childfree couples, everyone - JKR included - can write what they want and as I didn't mind her HP families I would personally like kids in the context of Strike series. No kids and/or deciding not to have them would be okay too but I'm annoyed by constant remarks I see in forums as if that's the consensus.


r/cormoran_strike • • Mar 16 '25

Book Discussion The green dress

2 Upvotes

Not sure if it had been said before, but I think JK might have been going for the coloring of Robin, as in Batman and Robin. Robin’s signature costume had red and green (also some yellow), so by giving Robin a green dress, strike (Batman) kind of appoints Robin to be his official ‘Robin’, as in partner/sidekick. Now she got both the green and the red due to her strawberry blond hair, completing the look.


r/cormoran_strike • • Oct 03 '25

Book Discussion What's with JKR's obsession with Strike's bathroom habits?

0 Upvotes

I've noticed in THM that we are frequently told when Strike takes a pee. I can't remember if this is the case in the previous novels, but I find it strange. We don't learn about Robin's trips to relieve herself. Has anyone else noticed this?