r/cormoran_strike
•
u/No_Bar7186
•
Sep 19 '25
The Hallmarked Man The Hallmarked man sucked Spoiler
This book really disappointed me. Romantic part was as expected - given the previous books events it couldn't be different. Since Robin was given a new bf in the previous book, and he was instantly introduced as a person with a problem, you could see the slightly different but still a Matthew 2.0 situation and because Robin will be in a serious and complicated relationship her potential romantic line with Strike was doomed to start like what we ended up getting here. I knew it was coming, I accepted it's unavoidable, I moved on before the last book was even published. But the rest of the book, my god. Rowling really needs to log off from Twitter and chill with the misery porn, because it is beyond. To be honest with the whole series I felt that there was an intentional part all about Rowling's holywar with both far right and far left social media. We even got a dedicated book about it. I did not mind it until the Hallmarked man, because it never overshadowed the literature part. But this book. How much more women torture should we add so the young reader would understand, how important it is to protect women? (That's 99% of Rowling's social media posts nowadays icymi). Let's make Robin pregnant, then lose the baby, and then let's she will be literally scarred inside because of the rape. More sex trafficking for the God of sex trafficking! You thought previous book was bad with the cult harvesting babies? How about a modern day Nabokov scenario except he got her pregnant, killed and hid the body in the basement's floor, the very same basement where he has a sex-slave on a chain? Decima being in love with her lost half-brother and with an incestuous child is a cherry on top of this whole thing. We get it, Joan, you are concerned about women's safety, and you don't let us fucking forget it. The worst part is that here her willing to raise awareness completely overpowered the story, because it doesn't make sense. Chloe has been plotting her escape with Tyler for years, then the whole thing was uncovered because Griff the rapist knew a complicated symbolism of her real name in the foreign language?! Strike doesn't want to press Rupert's friend who clearly knows something, and wants to focus on literally anybody else than Rupert, the person he was hired to find?! The attack on Robin in the crowd which was physically impossible, the fact that some lowlife criminals dug up about the gorilla thing (not the masons who could possibly get any info - a very low calibre scum). For someone who is spending this much time in the internet Rowling's understanding of it is as if it's like 3 websites with 100 users, so any given "Austin h" will for sure be the same person, and Instagram has no power to remove impersonators, and people are posting comment threads (?!?!) Of only fans to the dark net, and if you watch a random execution video from isis it's a big chance you will see there someone you know, and if you start googling misspelled names from UK you will get a niche old articles from Belgium. Nothing makes sense. Any given bit of the investigative part of the book ends up with understanding that absolutely everything happened because Rowling needed it to happen. Fucking weights bit, I can't, go ahead Tyler, buy a one of a kind thing with your last money and then be afraid of people seeing it forever, because mama Joan said so. I don't remember her being this sloppy, but here we are. Whatever happened to the mystery that is the case that should be investigated here, because someone bloody murdered her.