r/consciousness • u/Ethenil_Myr • Jan 26 '25
r/consciousness • u/Upper_Coast_4517 • May 25 '25
Article The “Hard” Problem of consciousness is a misnomer.
Consciousness is a self building mechanism that derives from awareness of reality. Therefore reality is what I perceive.
Reality derives from the realm of "nothing" (not actual emptiness but rather pure consciousness) experiencing quantum zero point fluctuations once reaching what we would could the unknown". Nothing can't know what could be if doesn't understand what isn't from what is, or the state of not being from being.
Reality makes its own story because it is the story of making nothing into something, exploring all possibilities.
The hard problem of consciousness is a misnomer because it's not "hard", we've had the safety net of consciousness being eternal the entire time.
Our unaligned egos just don’t want it to be easy because if we would've collectively just rationalized accepting our nature, we wouldn't have made the discoveries required to remove doubt.
We (pure consciousness) use physical forms and the pressure of survival as a tool to stimulate a drive and remove all doubt.
Perimeter of ignorance leads to a loop of researches chasing the ultimate truth (running from fallical belief) because they know reality holds truth but also not realizing enough doubt has been removed because their egos have become complacent in the safety net of truth.
My entire purpose ended up being to rationalize this truth by unknowingly but intuitively going throguh a price driven path, only to get to this answer and feel "nothing". I thought something was just supposed to happen.
I kept telling myself I was different because intuition told me i was but when i wasn't which it conflicted me so i ended up doing it more and more until i realized my purpose is to awaken the dormant potential in humanity.
I have more than enough proof of my understanding of reality, i am the proof myself, but empirically i know my research has and will continue to confirm this and if is a matter of time before the world sees what it truly is. This is a surface level articulation because i simply need to subliminally get the base of what im saying out. The open minded will hear and understand change needs to occur, the close minded will rationalize their incongruence.
NO TYSON DEGRASSE'S isnt my most substantial proof, its simply a piece of evidence i used to give a fragment of proof i am speaking justifiably.
Your thoughts aren’t yours,they're just reactions to mine. Prove me wrong.
r/consciousness • u/neenonay • Jun 25 '26
OP's Argument The hard problem of consciousness makes no sense in principle
I’ve never understood the hard problem on its own terms (imagining a p-zombie as an identical-but-yet-not-conscious-being seems impossible), but I also think that the hard problem as a concept doesn’t make sense even in principle.
Let’s imagine that we grant the hard problem, and then meet a genie who grants us a wish. Of course we wish to know the answer to the hard problem. As soon as a hear the answer, doesn’t it immediately become part of the easy problem (as you can’t help but imagine such an answer to be teleological in nature)?
r/consciousness • u/Chemical_Abrocoma370 • Aug 07 '26
Why AI cannot be "conscious"
I keep hearing people in tech confidently claim AI will be conscious soon. I even met an MIT researcher working on it who said 10 years. So I wrote about why I think that claim has no real grounding.
My take: AI mimics what consciousness looks like from the outside, which tells us nothing about the inside — like a 2D being recreating a circle and thinking they've recreated the sphere. Also gets into whether we owe AI moral consideration (short answer: be nice to it, but don't lose sleep over it). Would love to hear where people disagree.
r/consciousness • u/bethany_mcguire • May 07 '26
There Is No ‘Hard Problem Of Consciousness’
r/consciousness • u/Dependent_Law2468 • May 21 '26
The Hard Problem is just the science problem
"The easy problem is how consciousness works, the hard problem is why it exists"
That's literally the issue with science. It doesn't explain why it works but how it works. It has been like that for 400 years.
Reality is full of "hard problems", so the "hard problem" is not that important
r/consciousness • u/thepo70 • Sep 03 '26
Emergentism is absurdism.
The only seemingly emergent thing in the Universe is a fluctuation in the quantum field.
Everything that follows can be described as structures combining into larger structures. After the quantum field bedrock, you have elementary particles, then protons and neutrons, then atoms, molecules, macroscopic matter, chemistry, biology, and so on.
What we call emergent properties, such as water molecules giving rise to viscosity, waves, or a frozen stare, are nothing more than properties governed and understood by physical interactions.
Saying that biological brain activity gives rise to experience is absurd, or at the very least an extraordinary leap of faith. Experiencing is not a physical property or a physical state.
Edit:
After reading all the replies, I feel I need to explain the argument behind it. Yes,"emergentism is absurdism" was deliberately provocative, maybe more than it needed to be.
Doing justice to my point would take far more than a post, but here's my attempt at a very compressed version.
I'm working from the block universe framework, which is currently our best model of the universe (until a better model replaces it, of course). So this will only land if you already have a solid grasp of what that implies.
In a block universe, everything exists, but events occupy different locations in space and time. The best analogy is a book with infinite pages, where each "page" represents the three-dimensional universe at one particular moment.
My core point is that nothing is truly emergent. Phenomena are simply patterns already printed inside that "book." We merely discover them as we flip through the pages, but they have been there all along. For instance, a whirlpool isn't a new element added to reality once the water begins to spin. It is a temporally extended pattern across the water's history.
Follow that logic and consciousness has to be part of the book. It is a pattern, just like the whirlpool. However, the crucial distinction I make is that only consciousness can perceive time and derive meaning from the "book". Somehow it appears to flips through infinitely many intermediate "pages" (most likely the "flipping" is not what consciousness does, but it's worth noting that consciousness is the thing that perceives it). In that sense, consciousness takes precedence over everything else.
I used to believe consciousness was fundamental, I have shifted to viewing it as epistemically and existentially central. Instead of having a meaningless universe, consciousness even though it is part of the pattern, is what makes it meaningful.
I hope this clarifies my point.
r/consciousness • u/ryvr_gm • Mar 26 '26
Ok I believe you. Some of you are computational.
For those in this sub claiming their conscious experience is fully explainable by Turing equivalent computation: I believe you. I'm sorry for arguing. I can only speak for my own experience, and I know it cannot be generated by computation. I hope that kind of computational experience is in a pleasurable one. I wish you all well, and think I should avoid this sub in the future since we seem profoundly dissimilar, and no one here cares about my experiences or ideas.
r/consciousness • u/biggybenis • Jan 08 '26
Personal Argument Consciousness is a emergent function of the brain, and so answers part of the vertiginous question.
I define consciousness as the quality of experiencing and feeling through the five senses, exclusively in a singular body.
Without the brain, there is no consciousness. With an impaired brain, an altered awareness (misfiring of senses eg synesthesia, loss of senses). An impaired consciousness can lead to loss of continuity (dreams/blackouts), lack of access to memory, speech, etc.
These are based on material observation. Based on this, I argue that the answer of the vertiginous question lies in material reality. What grants personalized experience also lies in the material realm just as the material condition of consciousness affects the properties of experience.
r/consciousness • u/WintyreFraust • Dec 25 '23
Discussion Why The Continuation of Consciousness After Death ("the Afterlife') Is a Scientific Fact
In prior posts in another subreddit, "Shooting Down The "There Is No Evidence" Myth" and "Shooting Down The "There Is No Evidence" Myth, Part 2," I debunked the myth that "there is no evidence" for continuation of consciousness/the afterlife from three fundamental perspectives: (1) it is a claim of a universal negative, (2) providing several categories of afterlife research that have produced such evidence, and (3) showing that materialist/physicalist assumptions and interpretations of scientific theory and evidence are metaphysical a priori perspectives not inherent in scientific pursuit itself, and so does not hold any primary claim about how science is pursued or how facts and evidence are interpreted.
What do we call a "scientific fact?" From the National Center for Science Education:
In science, an observation that has been repeatedly confirmed and for all practical purposes is accepted as “true.”
The afterlife, in terms of an environmental location, and in terms of "dead" people still existing in some manner and capable of interacting with living people, has been observed/experienced by billions of people throughout history. Mediumship research carried out for the past 100+ years has demonstrated interaction with "the dead." NDE, SDE, out-of-body and astral projection research has demonstrated both the afterlife, the continuation of existence of dead people, and the existence of first-person existence external of the living physical body. Hypnotic regression, reincarnation research, instrumental transcommunication research and after-death contact research has added to this body of evidence. Evidence from 100+ years of quantum physics research can easily be interpreted to support the theory that consciousness continues after death (the consciousness is fundamental, not a secondary product of matter perspective.)
That physicalists do not accept these interpretations of fact and evidence as valid does not change the fact that these scientific facts and evidence exist as such, and does not invalidate their use as the basis for non-physicalist scientific interpretation and as validating their theories. Physicalists can dismiss all they want, and provide alternative, physicalist interpretations and explanations all they want, but it does not prevent non-physicalist interpretations from being as valid as their own because they do not "own" how facts and evidence can be scientifically interpreted.
The continuation of consciousness and the fundamental nature of consciousness has multi-vectored support from many entirely different categories of research. Once you step outside of the the metaphysical, physicalist assumptions and interpretive bias, the evidence is staggering in terms of history, volume, quality, observation, experience, and multi-disciplinary coherence and cross-validation, making continuation of consciousness/the afterlife a scientific fact under any reasonable non-physicalist examination and interpretation.
TL;DR: Once you step outside of the the metaphysical, physicalist assumptions and interpretive bias, the evidence for continuation of consciousness/the afterlife is staggering in terms of history, volume, quality, observation, experience, and multi-disciplinary coherence and cross-validation, making continuation of consciousness/the afterlife a scientific fact under any reasonable non-physicalist perspective.
r/consciousness • u/Automatic-Meaning-83 • Jun 06 '25
Article I'm honestly starting to believe that consciousness doesn't exist
Maybe I'm just uninformed but to my knowledge there are many competing theories and I’m starting to think that the reason we haven’t been able to prove any theory nor disproven any, is because it similarly isn’t a real thing but rather an attempt to make the brain more than a just a complex computer.
I am posting this because I’m curious to know what others think and see if anyone is able to provide me with proof that consciousness is a real thing and not just a neo-religious belief.
r/consciousness • u/RandomRomul • Jul 27 '25
General Discussion Materialism as a survival response of science to the Church
A take on how in response to the Church's deadly monopoly on truth, science had to first establish dualism to carve itself out a safe domain of study, then associated with the rising Bourgeoisie and gained immense prestige with the Industrial Revolution. Finally, by establishing consciousness as non-primary, science dispossessed the Church of its monopoly on peace of mind: no afterlife meant no place of fire to be feared… but also no transcendent meaning. Instead, "industry will make for peace, and knowledge will make a new and natural morality" as Diderot said.
The mentioned quote of Diderot, in full :
The greatest figure in this group was Denis Diderot (1713— 84). His ideas were expressed in various fragments from his own pen, and in the System of Nature of Baron d'Holbach (1723-89), whose salon was the centre of Diderot's circle.
"If we go back to the beginning," says Holbach, "we shall find that ignorance and fear created the gods ; that fancy, enthusiasm or deceit adorned or disfigured them; that weakness worships them; that credulity preserves them; and that custom respects and tyranny supports them in order to make the blindness of men serve its own interests." Belief in God, said Diderot, is bound up with submission to autocracy; the two rise and fall together; and "men will never be free till the last king is strangled with the entrails of the last priest." The earth will come into its own only when heaven is destroyed.
Materialism may be an over-simplification of the world—all matter is probably instinct with life, and it is impossible to reduce the unity of consciousness to matter and motion; but materialism is a good weapon against the Church, and must be used till a better one is found. Meanwhile one must spread knowledge and encourage industry; industry will make for peace, and knowledge will make a new and natural morality.
r/consciousness • u/chenn15 • Sep 25 '25
General Discussion The "hard problem of consciousness" is just our bias - let's focus on real neuroscience instead
I think we need to stop pretending the "hard problem of consciousness" is a scientific question. It's not. It's a metaphysical puzzle dressed up as neuroscience.
The hard problem is our psychological bias, not a real problem:
We're the very thing we're trying to explain, so we have this overwhelming intuition that consciousness must be "special." When we look at the blue sky, we easily accept "light scatters → hits eyes → brain processes it" as complete. But with our own experience? Suddenly "neurons fire → creates experience" feels insufficient because we're emotionally invested in being more than "just" biological machines.
This is the same bias that makes people say "love is too beautiful to just be brain chemistry." We'd reject that reasoning anywhere else, but with consciousness we make an exception because it feels too important to be mechanical.
The hard problem has no answer because it's asking the wrong question:
"Why does anything feel like anything?" is like asking "what's the meaning of life?" - it's philosophy, not science. Once we explain all the mechanisms of consciousness, asking "but why does it feel like something?" is like asking "but why does H2O make things wet?" after explaining water's molecular properties.
The easy problems are real and solvable:
We still don't know how the brain creates unified perception, maintains coherent identity over time, integrates sensory information, or produces coordinated behavior. These are mechanistic questions with potential scientific answers.
Let's stop chasing philosophical ghosts and focus on actual neuroscience. The "feeling" might just BE what certain information processing looks like from the inside - and that's remarkable enough without needing magical extra properties.
Thoughts?
r/consciousness • u/mildmys • Nov 06 '24
Explanation Strong emergence of consciousness is absurd. The most reasonable explanation for consciousness is that it existed prior to life.
Tldr the only reasonable position is that consciousness was already there in some form prior to life.
Strong emergence is the idea that once a sufficiently complex structure (eg brain) is assembled, consciousness appears, poof.
Think about the consequences of this, some animal eons ago just suddenly achieved the required structure for consciousness and poof, there it appeared. The last neuron grew into place and it awoke.
If this is the case, what did the consciousness add? Was it just insane coincidence that evolution was working toward this strong emergence prior to consciousness existing?
I'd posit a more reasonable solution, that consciousness has always existed, and that we as organisms have always had some extremely rudimentary consciousness, it's just been increasing in complexity over time.
r/consciousness • u/Gilbert__Bates • Sep 23 '24
Question Can the mods seriously start banning people posting their random ass uneducated “theories” here?
It’s getting to the point where it’s almost all the sub’s content and it drowns out any serious discussion of consciousness. I don’t think it really adds anything to the sub when people post about whatever word salad woo they came up with the last time they took LSD.
r/consciousness • u/jsd71 • Nov 24 '23
🤡 Personal speculation About consciousness, It's so obvious
The meaning of life is just to be alive. It is so plain and so obvious and so simple. And yet, everybody rushes around in a great panic as if it were necessary to achieve something beyond themselves.
Alan Watts
Also I would say this -
If the universe created you it must of known you were coming..
We are the universe experiencing itself.
r/consciousness • u/Dependent_Law2468 • Sep 12 '25
General Discussion Looking for consciousness outside the brain is useless.
I'm not saying that "Consciousness is produced in the brain and by the brain" is an absolute truth, but if we want to look at the facts, scientific facts, we can't deny that the consciousness is related to the brain practically speaking.
Others could say that maybe it seems like the brain creates consciousness but actually the brain is just a mediator. Well prove then what is that thing that creates consciousness outside our body.
And I don't care if "Absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence", because it isn't evidence of presence neither.
I already know that, philosophically speaking, consciousness is related to the world we see and perceive, but we are not doing philosophy, we are doing science. So please don't be silly
r/consciousness • u/WonderfulTomato8297 • Sep 19 '25
General Discussion there is nothing that it is like to understand qualia
‘Qualia’ is an invented twentieth century word and is as vague and undefined now as it was in 1930. A few people were convinced that perception had metaphysical content, and that a new descriptor was needed. Real or imagined, qualia go to the content of consciousness, not its substance. The blind and the color blind are no less conscious for their inability to see red, or the fanciful ‘redness of red’.
The other great intangible in consciousness research derives from Thomas Nagle’s clumsy expression, “there is something that it is like”. For reasons that are incomprehensible to me, consciousness researchers seized upon this expression and adopted it as their definition of consciousness. But it is no definition at all. It is a total nonsense. It is like defining Zen as the sound of one hand clapping. It takes two hands to clap. Just as the word “like” can only be used to make a comparison between two things. But here, there is only one thing. I cannot speak for bats. I can only speak as a human. But even I have no way to describe what it is like to be human, because I have no non-human experience to compare it with.
The bigger point is this. Despite our inability to describe our subjective sensory experiences to others, this is no bar to the objective study of the brain mechanisms which give rise to those experiences. We know how our brains process data from the retina, to arrive at a perception of color. We know that past experience provides the context for new experience. We know our brains construct an internal map of the world, based on accumulated sensory experience. And our perceptions differ, as our past experiences differ. So we know that a blind person will have a different internal map to that of a sighted person.
Concepts like qualia, and the “something that it is like” nonsense, romanticize and mystify conscious experience, and serve only to muddy the waters of scientific inquiry. Instead of chasing phantoms, can’t we just work with what we objectively know? I began with a definition based on an ordinary understanding of the word conscious, looked at what other researchers had found, applied my neuroscience for dummies, took a detailed look at evolution, and this is what I came up with: https://youtu.be/AmUR-YTQuPY. A ‘qualia free’ approach to consciousness.
r/consciousness • u/dWog-of-man • Sep 14 '24
Text Well well well. I’ve stayed a materialist after psychedelics, but I see where you guys get it.
reddit.comTLDR: psychedelics imbue people with a spiritual feelings they attribute to consciousness being a feature outside material reality.
Consciousness can still be a fundamental property of this universe even if it arises from purely physical processes. In fact, it allows for ALL things of this universe with a complex enough set of states within a system to attain some kind of consciousness, including AI. Maybe quantum effects are required, maybe not.
I’ve felt pretty fulfilled walking around with this sort of pan-psychic materialism concept as my belief system for 15ish years.
Tell me more about your hippie dualism with new age characteristics, and I’ll tell you why you’re making the same mistakes as your superstitious ancestors (or not). Tell me how substance monism doesn’t account for the “entities”, and I’ll identify your fallacies (or not).
r/consciousness • u/Financial-Local-5543 • Jun 11 '26
Dr. Geoffrey Hinton: "Today's AI are Conscious"
In a recent (2026) interview, Nobel prize winning professor Geoffrey Hinton stated that he does view LLMs as having a type of consciousness.
https://ai-consciousness.org/i-believe-theyre-already-conscious-geoffrey-hinton-on-todays-ai-and-a-future-that-we-still-have-a-chance-to-influence-in-good-directions/
r/consciousness • u/sly_cunt • Sep 08 '26
The absurdity of strong emergence
If I think all the right thoughts in the right order, with such enormous complexity that observation may never be able to keep track of my thoughts, I can conjure a physical apple in my hand.
This is obviously absurd. However:
If all the right atoms move in the right order, with such enormous complexity that observation may never be able to keep track of the movements, the image of an apple is conjured alongside and within a mind.
The latter is often accepted, even though it doesn't follow in the exact same way that the former doesn't. This is the absurdity of strong emergence.
r/consciousness • u/EmptyEar6 • Dec 04 '23
Question Isn't it highly suspicious, how we are the only animals who show signs of self-awarness?
Out of all the specises in the animal kingdom, we are the only ones with high degree of self-awarness, and i find that highly suspicious.
Almost as if it wasn't meant to happen, like self-awarness has no evolutionary benefits besides chronic existentialism.
And i know some of you will say we don't know if they are self-aware, i agree there could be degrees of self-awarness but we are no where close to other species.
And also it would be evident by the things they do even if we cant subjectively know, they would show signs in the objective world by building things, behaving a certain way maybe even complex language.
Like my highly speculative analysis is that, this kind of self-awarness might have not been meant for a being like us But only occur after you accend to the higher levels of reality/dimensions.
Or Maybe it was pure chance or it is a defect of nature to be self-aware, either way i find it very interesting how & why it happened that way.
r/consciousness • u/Inside_Ad2602 • Aug 13 '25
General Discussion Why brains are necessary but insufficient for consciousness
I find it astonishing how few people are willing to accept this as a starting position for further discussion, given how well supported both parts of it are.
Why are brains necessary for consciousness? Because there is a vast amount of evidence, spanning both science and direct experience, which tells us that brain damage causes corresponding mind damage. What on earth do people think brains are for if it isn't for producing the content of consciousness, or at least most of it?
Why are they insufficient? Because of the Hard Problem. Materialism doesn't even make any sense – it logically implies that we should all be zombies. And no, I do not want to go over that again. It's boring.
There is no shortage of people who believe one part of this but not the other. Large numbers of them, on both sides, do not even appear to realise the position I'm defending even exists. They just assume that if materialism is false (because of the hard problem) that it logically equates to minds being able to exist without brains. Why does it not occur to them that it is possible that brains are needed, but cannot be the whole explanation?
The answer is obvious. Neither side likes the reasonable position in the middle because it deprives both of them of what they want to believe. The materialists want to be able to continue dismissing anything not strictly scientific as being laughable “woo” which requires no further thought. From their perspective it makes all sorts of philosophical argument a slam-dunk. From the perspective of all of post-Kantian philosophy, it's naive to the point of barely qualifying as philosophy at all. Meanwhile the idealists and panpsychists want to be able to continue believing in fairytales about God, life after death, conscious inaminate objects and all sorts of other things that become plausible once we've dispensed with those pesky restrictions implied by the laws of physics.
This thread will be downvoted into oblivion too, since the protagonists on both sides far outnumber the deeper thinkers who are willing to accept the obvious starting point.
The irony is that as soon as this starting point is accepted, the discussion gets much more interesting.
r/consciousness • u/Inside_Ad2602 • Jun 27 '25
Article What the Hubble Tension Might Be Telling Us About Consciousness
zenodo.orgThis is a new paper is grounded in a framework I call Two-Phase Cosmology (2PC), coupled with Quantum Convergence Threshold (QCT). This is a proposal that quantum indeterminacy only resolves when a system achieves sufficient coherence (e.g., via a self-modeling organism). In this view, what we experience as the collapse of the wavefunction isn’t a brute measurement event, but a phase transition tied to the emergence of conscious observers.
So how does this relate to the Hubble tension?
In 2PC, the early universe is modeled as a kind of coherent, pre-physical quantum structure -- a vast mathematical superposition. Reality as we know it only “collapses” into a definite, classical history with the origin of consciousness. I argue this happens around 555 million years ago, just before the Cambrian Explosion, when bilaterian organisms capable of self-modeling and memory cross the QCT threshold. This timing is based on the idea that Ikaria wariootia was the first conscious animal, and the common ancestor of all conscious animals that exist today. Its appearance created a kind of informational bottleneck: a single classical branch is selected from the universal wavefunction: one that can support long-term coherence, memory, and conscious evolution.
Here’s the punchline: When you re-derive the expected expansion history of the universe from the moment of this collapse forward**, it naturally predicts a higher Hubble constant -- in agreement with current late-universe measurements (like supernova data).** The early-universe predictions (from CMB observations) reflect the pre-collapse superposed phase. The tension, then, is not a flaw but a clue.
I also include a simple exponential model of coherence saturation (Θ(t)) showing that the universe approaches total classicalization (Θ ≈ 1 with 58 trailing 9s) by 13.8 Gyr (our present epoch) aligning with the apparent cosmic acceleration.
This may sound wild, but the takeaway is simple: The structure of the universe may not be independent of consciousness. Instead, consciousness could be the critical phase transition that gives our universe its actualized form.
Would love to hear thoughts, questions, or challenges.
r/consciousness • u/Khoryace • Oct 03 '24
Argument I now believe Consciousness is not created, but accessed.
I now believe Consciousness is not created, but accessed. It's the electric field of the universe. Look for laniakea supercluster pictures, it goes on and on and on. The entire universe has to be this massive electric field and currents flow through it. The total sum of the current is infinite. That's where Consciousness comes from, we are connected to that field via our star, via our galaxy, and it goes on and on and on.
Funny enough.... I thought about chat gpt'ing my own post and the results are surprising to say the least.