r/computerscience • u/AFricknChickn • Jul 01 '20
Average age group of r/computerscience
I am curious who is the audience of r/computerscience. It seems like lately the upvoted content is exclusively beginner questions or posts like mine pointing out that a lot of posts are beginner questions.
Edit: okay, you caught me. This poll is far from exhaustive and perfect. I was just trying to get a rough idea of who the community is here. For better or worse, I am probably going to unsub because the only content I’ve found from this sub is intro to CS questions and I was just curious to confirm that with a poll. Not to say that such a community shouldn’t exist! It absolutely should and I wish CS students best of luck and encourage you to keep studying hard! It pays off. I’m just not interested in following the topic.
23
u/xdchan Jul 01 '20
What if you are <25 but not in college or high school? What if you are not in college or industry but self-teaching?
What if you are in a middle school? It's pretty possible for everyone to get knowledge to get employed even before entering high school.
How is that an age groups?
16
u/AFricknChickn Jul 01 '20
Lol okay, you win. I admit my poll is not exhaustive. I hope no demographics were offended by my laziness :)
7
1
6
Jul 01 '20
critical thinking like this will benefit us all in our programmatic endeavors :P
2
u/xdchan Jul 01 '20
Hahah, thanks i guess, lots of general human biology and especially neuroscience studying and internet fights made me used to pick on every detail of every word trying to analyze what person thought when wrote it :D
4
u/a_bad_programmer Jul 01 '20
I’m self learning at 27, graduated college at 21, ended up putting myself in the college => group due to lack of grouping for me
5
13
u/tulvia Jul 01 '20
Thanks for this, im unsubscribing from this sub, no wonder I am always at odds with the others here.
6
u/justACuriousAlien Jul 01 '20
Which group are you?
3
u/tulvia Jul 01 '20
Been doing this for 9 years, professionally.
5
u/codepc Jul 02 '20
It's so frustrating to constantly see "should I take calculus in highschool to prepare for CS?!" Or "please teach me basic programming" or literal memes from /r/teenagers about CS being hard. I just really really want somewhere that's actual computer science.
1
4
3
1
u/differentiated06 Jul 01 '20
So I guess my question is, what would you want to go on in here, if not beginner and study questions?
Who actually works in "computer science"? *crickets* nobody? Yeah, you work in infrastructure, or security, or customer service, or development. Is there content, beyond education, that applies to everyone?
I'm a teacher studying to take the CS exam and teach the subject to high schoolers, I've gotten some great information here. It sucks that it doesn't work for everyone, but I'm not sure what would.
4
u/AFricknChickn Jul 01 '20
I would love to see people posting research papers they found interesting and then discussion around that.
It sucks that it doesn’t work for everyone
I don’t think it sucks. I don’t think it’s intended to work for everyone :). I think this sub has its rightful place, and I’m just not the right audience. Nothing objectively wrong with it!
1
0
Jul 02 '20
[deleted]
3
u/differentiated06 Jul 02 '20
Yeah I just learned more from your reply than this whole sub so far...
Thank you for replying thoughtfully!
1
Jul 01 '20
I’m 36. I used to be great with computers when I was in high school. But that was 20 years ago. I’ve spent the next 20 years as an executive chef. I can’t/won’t do that work anymore. I’ve been researching the happiest/in demand/best paying/possibly work from home careers and every list I find has computer science on it. I feel like I’m too old to start from scratch and learn everything. What does everyone think?
2
u/AFricknChickn Jul 01 '20
Are you interested/passionate about analyzing and solving problems, unrelated to computers? I think of CS as more of a general problem solver who happens to use computers as a way of automating the solutions. There will be a lot to learn, but if you are motivated and energized by problem solving, I think it’s worth it, no matter the age!
2
2
u/kandrew313 Jul 01 '20
I can't answer the poll but I have over 10 years of industry experience and have a bachelor's in CS.
0
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
because the only content I’ve found from this sub is intro to CS questions and I was just curious to confirm that with a poll.
So you were looking for some particular age group to blame for your claim that the only questions in this sub are intro to CS questions?
2
u/AFricknChickn Jul 01 '20
I would assume there’s a strong correlation between years of experience and intro-like questions. “Age group” from my title is not really my intent. More like “years-of-experience group”? idk... I wrote the poll while browsing reddit sitting on the toilet almost immediately after waking up 😅 It was not a very effortful post.
3
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
Hmm...sounds to me more like you were trying to elevate your own status by making it seem like you are too experienced to bother with these intro questions, like I initially suspected, and were trying to justify it by making a poll about reader's experience.
If you don't like on-topic intro questions, don't answer them. If they are off-topic, mention that and don't answer them.
3
u/AFricknChickn Jul 01 '20
Sorry if I offended you or made you feel inferior. Definitely not my intention nor do I think my status is above people here. I am subscribed to other CS related subs, so thinking I’m above CS people would be a bit hypocritical 😅.
And I am definitely not saying that posts in this sub are off topic, I’m just trying to understand what exactly the topic is.
-1
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
Definitely not my intention nor do I think my status is above people here.
Any survey asking for personal data from readers would be off-topic here most likely, and some could be viewed as an attempt to disparage a group so it's discriminatory as well. If you asked how many females/blacks/IQ# there were, that could be viewed as a way to justify the claim that its because there are too many/few of X here, that the questions tend to be intro questions. So your poll seems designed to create dissent and division in a sub related to computer science topics. And what do you know? It did.
1
1
1
u/headless_catman Jul 02 '20
For me I started off working as a telecommunications technician, then moved to school for networking, then switched to programming because I enjoyed it more. Currently getting my A+ certification and just gonna work my way up that way since the local CS programs (as well as the local college) are not that good. I have profs that can't answer basic questions.. Regular profs are being fired after not actually having their credentials.. Just done with the institution. Doing online certifications (Harvard has some decent free ones for Python, Gaming and AI).
Still new, just turned 30 and am loving it. Always had a passion for computers so not sure why I didn't go down this route earlier in life. Oh well, never too late!
1
u/MrEdinLaw Jul 02 '20
I'm 24 but I finished college and work for nearly 2 years. Where dafuq do I belong?
1
1
0
-2
u/lorisaurus Jul 01 '20
It's kind of funny that you are complaining about beginner questions but your only academic category is "college", ha ha.
-2
-29
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
Wrong sub.
18
u/3z3ki3l Jul 01 '20
It would be wayy harder to find the average age of /r/computerscience subscribers using a different sub...
-12
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20 edited Jul 01 '20
Why would someone need to know the average age of readers of this sub? How does that relate to the academics of computer science? It seems the only point would to create a bias against certain readers of a certain age.
4
u/3z3ki3l Jul 01 '20
Uh... how does it not? It directly informs readers of this sub what stage of life their peers here are in. Pretty useful if you’re trying to judge literally anything you read here.
-4
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
Pretty useful if you’re trying to judge literally anything you read here.
The sub's rules, as far as I understand them, isn't that anything that is "pretty useful" is allowed, only if it's related to the academics of computer science.
5
u/3z3ki3l Jul 01 '20
Luckily for everyone here then this sub is moderated by people, not if statements.
Also being able to understand the utility of edge cases is going to get you pretty far in your career, so ya might wanna get used to that.
-1
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
You're just trying to justify off-topic posts with an overstretched analogy. What's next, a poll asking readers what programmers had for lunch, because someone is curious about it? That would also be just as off-topic.
2
u/3z3ki3l Jul 01 '20 edited Jul 01 '20
Except not because...
It directly informs readers of this sub what stage of life their peers here are in.
Also that wasn’t an analogy, I was being very literal. If you can’t understand why this edge case is useful here, you’re going to have problems down the road.
Edit: And you know why I’m comfortable saying “down the road”? Because someone did a survey on the average age of readers of this subreddit, and it turns out most of them have yet to progress very far in their careers. Pretty useful already.
1
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
It's not an edge case, you are using the term incorrectly.
1
u/3z3ki3l Jul 01 '20
Sure thing bud. Now address the relevant parts of the comment.
→ More replies (0)8
Jul 01 '20
And why is that?
-8
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
The question isn't related to computer science in any way, it's a survey question about the age of readers of the forum. From my understanding it's against the rules.
4
Jul 01 '20
Yes...which relates to CS. I don't understand your perspective.
-4
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
Imagine if the question was related to how many readers are minorities instead of age? Maybe that will help you understand my perspective.
3
Jul 01 '20
Are you saying that question is similar to the one presented or are you saying that would be a better question to ask?
0
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
Similar to the one in the survey. You could gather a lot of useful information regarding reader's age, race, salary, skill level and a whole host of interesting things, but they'd have nothing to do with the top of academics of computer science.
5
Jul 01 '20
I'd wager that information is relevant if someone was trying to get an idea on what kind of sub that this is. People tend to engage more if they feel surrounded by likeminded individuals.
2
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
It's a poll, and not everyone will vote, or vote honestly so the results are meaningless anyway, plus it has nothing to do with the academics of computer science. It only has something to do with the readers of this sub.
2
1
Jul 01 '20
Are they going to go to a survey sub and ask the age groups of this sub from that one? What?
3
u/xdchan Jul 01 '20
Dude just don't, it's not an ad, it's not a meme or something, just a small survey asking about members of this sub.
I'm very toxic, but fuck, you are even worse then Me.
1
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
I understand what it is, it's just not allowed according to the rules as it has nothing to do with the academics of computer science.
1
u/Double-Let8318 Jul 01 '20
Bro chill its just a survey post just like Stackoverflow's dev survey. If you don't like it you can hide the post.
0
u/xdchan Jul 01 '20
But research is allowed
1
u/SftwEngr Jul 01 '20
Research regarding computer science topics, not computer scientists. and their age/race/salary/gender/eye color, etc.
4
0
Jul 01 '20
[deleted]
9
u/AFricknChickn Jul 01 '20
Good point! I admit I put very low effort into making this poll. As someone in this position, which option did you choose?
1
u/zomatoto Jul 01 '20
Hey, a frickin chicken, like you said, this sub is for cs college students. What did you expect and what did you want it to be?
0
Jul 01 '20
[deleted]
1
u/drcopus Jul 02 '20
Same here - what level of university are you in and how much time do you spend on your job?
5
0
7
50
u/gordon-freeman-0354 Jul 01 '20 edited Jul 31 '20
the "computer science" subreddits on reddit really are not visited by people actually interested in the field. r/compsci is a little bit better than this one but still these subreddits are not moderated strictly enough. part of the reason is that unlike say maths or physics there is a huge audience interested in computer science(actually software engineering) without really being interested in the theoretical parts of it. and as a result serious people are turned away from these subreddits.
but people have also pointed out in the past that there are topic specific subreddits on the site with many decent people like r/algorithms for theoretical computer science(some people use r/math only). r/gamedev r/osdev r/roguelikedev r/emudev r/proceduralgeneration for interesting software engineering, r/crypto r/reverseengineering r/securityctf etc for security. there are a handful of machine learning, computer vision, reinforcement learning subreddits.