r/communism • • Jul 01 '19

Brigaded Libertarians and ancaps are fucking monsters

80 Upvotes

I honestly don’t give a shit, these people are fucking monsters, there’s just nothing inside them, just sickening, brainwashed, nihilistic ghouls. I don’t know whether it’s that they worship power or desire a “cut of the pie” that bad, but these fucking disgusting swine get on their knees and bend so far for the wealthy you’d think their spines would break.

These people are just scum tbh, they’re fucking rats, they worship capitalism, if you worship capitalism you’re a fucking monster to me, capitalism is destroying this world and these bootlicking white boy fucks worship it because it gave whites a modicum of power, and that’s why these rats exist.

Edit: To all the brigading lolberts, I don’t give a flippant fuck how you feel, capitalism is killing the planet and supporting it makes you a monster or a moron in my mind, I’m not a liberal and don’t give a shit about being civil towards people I see as my enemies.


r/communism • • Nov 23 '12

Over 35% of Russians would vote for Stalin if he were still alive

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
4 Upvotes

r/communism • • Nov 27 '19

Brigaded What The Hong Kong Elections Really Show: 42% of Hong Kongers Support Beijing and Won the Popular Vote

0 Upvotes

I got this from u/Belerdorhan. Thank you so much for doing this!

A lot of people are probably thinking we did terribly in the Hong Kong elections. We got crushed! We lost hundreds of seats! Hong Kong gave massive support to the protesters!!!!!

In reality, we got 42% of the vote - the same as usual. We won 1,233,030 votes; they won 1,674,083 votes.

Four in ten Hong Kongers support the police and love China. Yes, it's disappointing that it's four in ten rather than five in ten. But these elections show that we have a large silent minority standing behind us.

Previous Election Results

Let's take a look at some previous election results:

ElectionPro-Establishment VotePro-Democratic Vote
2019 District42.157.1
2016 LegCo40.2 - 42.055.0 - 58.0
2012 LegCo42.7 - 49.350.7 - 56.2
2008 LegCo39.859.5
2004 LegCo37.462.4
2000 LegCo34.960.6
1998 LegCo30.466.4
1995 LegCo31.761.1
1991 LegCo7.961.6

All of these results are available on Wikipedia.

The pro-establishment generally wins 40% of the vote. In this election, we won about 40%, once again. We did not lose support; we got exactly the same as in 2016.

Now, you may say that we did far worse than in the 2015 district council elections when we won 55%. But in those elections, the pro-democratic side didn't bother to vote. And let's be honest, nobody believes the establishment has the support of 55% of Hong Kongers. Legislative elections are a much more accurate barometer of Hong Kong's true opinion.

Why We Lost So Many Seats - "First Past The Post"

So then why did we lose so many seats? The answer is simple - the district council elections are "First Past the Post." First Past the Post massively exaggerates the winner's seats. Here's how many seats we would have won under two different systems.

First Past the Post

There are 431 seats. Let's pretend we win 42% of the vote in every seat, and the pro-democrats win 57% of the vote in every seat. We end up with 0 seats (in reality we won 62 seats).

Proportional

There are 431 seats. Let's pretend we win 42% of the vote, and the pro-democrats win 57% of the vote. We end up with 181 seats.

Now, why are district council elections First Past the Post, rather than proportional? I don't know - probably because they don't hold much power. In any case, the important elections - the legislative elections - are proportional.

Conclusions

We have our base of 40%. After all the protests, in terms of popular support we did no worse than usual.

We have not lost support because of the protests. Sadly, we have not gained any. Interestingly, the protests have actually had zero impact on popular support for each side. Hong Kong is very polarized. To be frank, I am reminded of the extremely rigid party coalitions in American politics.

Those Hong Kongers who support the protests were always opposed to us, and I doubt any action of ours will ever gain their support. They will not be satisfied until they get independence and ethnically cleanse all mainland Chinese living in Hong Kong.

I suspect our base is very loyal and is founded upon pro-Chinese nationalism.

Finally, these election results show the inaccuracy of a lot of popular opinion polls that are done by pro-democracy NGO's or pro-riot universities. Those opinion polls showed Carrie Lam collapsing to only 20% support, or 90% of Hong Kongers opposing the police.

Those Western-backed polls are a sack of lies, as this election shows. 4 in 10 Hong Kongers support Beijing.

BONUS: check out the actual vote as well here. Pro-imperialist parties received less popular votes.


r/communism • • Dec 13 '22

Brigaded Why do so many supposed communists take reactionary, liberal positions on AI and AI art?

25 Upvotes

If you're a communist and you have a decent grasp on historical materialism, then you should understand that continued technological development, including automation and AI, is nessecery for humanity to move beyond capitalism. You should also be opposed to the existence of copyright and intellectual "property" laws for obvious reasons.

Yet many self identified communists recently are taking vocal, reactionary positions against AI art, citing a general opposition to human labor being automated as well as a belief in copyright law, two nonsensical positions for any communist to hold.

What's the deal?


r/communism • • Sep 11 '21

Brigaded Rest In Power, Chairman Gonzalo :( 1934-2021

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
0 Upvotes

r/communism • • Apr 22 '20

Yet another US lie about DPRK refuted, by their puppets no less. No signs Kim Jong Un is ill, according to South Korean intelligence .

Thumbnail
bbc.com
13 Upvotes

r/communism • • Oct 30 '19

🔒Brigaded /r/socialism mods are banning Communists: My Story.

263 Upvotes

Story time: how I got banned from /r/socialism.

TL:DR;

If you disagree with the US propaganda that "China is committing cultural genocide of Muslim Uyghurs", 2, then you will be permabanned from /r/socialism (specifically, by mods /u/107A, and /u/agnosticnixie)

Context

A lot of MLs/MLMs have been concerned over the state of /r/socialism in the last few months; we've been seeing an upward tick in defenses of western parliamentary / bourgeois democracy as being "superior" to the Cuban, USSR, Chinese, or NK models, shallow demonization of Actually-Existing-Socialist (AES) attempts (usually taking the low-effort form of "but state capitalism") and especially posts that bash the US's enemies (IE VZ/Syria/Cuba/China/Iran/Russia/Bolivia/Puerto Rico). Its not hard to see why: if you look over the mod list, there is only one mod of /r/socialism that is a Marxist-Leninist, and /r/soc otherwise has zero non-libertarian / "authoritarian" socialist mods, such as Maoists/MLMs/MTWs etc.

/u/bayarea415, the only Marxist-Leninist mod left (edit: I talked to a few more /r/soc mods, and there are more auth socs that also oppose nixie, but can't really do anything because of nixie's top spot) (and the only one who doesn't hold western biases about China), does wonderful work compiling megathreads refuting western Sinophobic propaganda, and does more than any other mod towards educating those new to socialism, and creating that necessary bridge for those to cross from social democracy, liberalism, and reactionism towards anti-imperialist / revolutionary politics.

A few of the top mods of /r/soc (nearly the entire team are Anarchists, and I don't mean to demonize all anarchists, just the ones that uncritically echo US propaganda) repeatedly remove bayarea415 from the mod-team, then re-institute them at the bottom of the modlist, after a community backlash. This happened a few months ago, then again 2 weeks ago, and almost again a few days ago. This is despite bayarea415 having most of the top posts in the last year of /r/socialism, and doing the most work in creating 101s, megathreads, and removing socdem posts.

Here's a post from /u/agnosticnixie a few days ago, one of the top mods of /r/socialism, wanting to use the same justification banning me, to remove bayarea415 from the mod team. Here's yet another instance of nixie harrassing bayarea. Nixie is also anti-Evo Morales / Bolivian Socialism (and anti-Sankara), and considers anyone who doesn't demonize China, as a "Dengist", repeating the myth that Deng turned China capitalist.

The current mods are extremely hostile towards China, and are happy to join along with Pence, Pompeo, Gamers, Murican football fans, elitist liberals, and sinophobic redditors in claiming that "China is genociding Muslims" (See my megathread, which is what caused my ban, for why this is false). This is an extremely popular opinion amongst westerners, happy to eat up unsourced articles from the guardian or independent, or NED/State department funded western academics.

There is no short version to this story, but a good starting place is this article. Uyghur culture is thriving in XinJiang, there are over 10k mosques, enshrined religous freedom for Islam, the vast majority of Muslims in XinJiang think positively of China, the extremist elements make up only a tiny minority, and the US is pushing extremism and separatism, because a destabilized XinJiang would cause a lot of damage to the new silk road initiative, and disrupt Chinas trade west of its borders. The British, French, and US imperialist policy of pushing religious and ethnic factionalism, extremism, and then pitting them against each other (and especially against its larger enemies), is a long-perfected artform in the Middle East and Asia.

Unsurprisingly, a majority of Muslim countries support China's policies in XinJiang, and don't believe the western lies told about it. 2, 3. Supporters include Algeria, Angola, Bahrain, Belarus, Bolivia, Burkina Faso, Burma, Burundi, Cambodia, Cameroon, Comoros, Congo, Cuba, DR Congo, Egypt, Eritrea, Gabon, Kuwait, Laos, Nigeria, North Korea, Oman, Pakistan, Philippines, Qatar, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, Sudan, Syria, Tajikistan, Togo, Turkmenistan, UAE, Venezuela, Zimbabwe.

Never let people tell you that US propaganda isn't effective: in 2006, only 30% of the US population hated China. In 2019, its 60%. This sinophobia and anti-communism is so pervasive in the west, that it permeates every political trend not based on anti-imperialism. Its a repeat of cold war / red scare anti-communism, but now that the anti-communist left can no longer take aim at the USSR, they've focused on China as the primary target.

A lot of us have spent a good amount of time (see my megathreads for example ) disproving what appears to be the 6 main points of anti-China propaganda, where western anti-communists (whether they be ultralefts, liberals, socdems, anarchists, or reactionaries) all agree: "China isn't democratic / is a state capitalist dictatorship", "China is repressing Hong Kong", "China spies on its people", "China represses Muslims", "China massacred protesters at Tianenmen", "Mao killed / starved millions of people".

We also have to write about why, in recent decades, the US is starting a new cold war against China: the US empire is in decline (China's life expectancy surpassed the US in 2015, people's real wage in China has gone up 4x in the past 25 years, while the US's remains below 1973 levels, the global south is choosing China's belt and road initiative over the west's imperialist trading and funding networks, why China's one-party state is outperforming western multi-party democracies in terms of performance and public satisfaction (96% approval rating as of 2016), why the US space program is dead (except for lord elon of course) while China is launching a mars rover in 2020, etc. China is an emergent superpower, rapidly eclipsing the US, and the US has only two cards left to play: its military supremacy, and its media monopoly. The rash of anti-China sentiment is no accident; the six capitalist entities that own all media push these stories because its in their class interests to do so; because the US dollar will lose its supremacy, the rest of the world will prefer dealing with China over the US or EU, if they can only convince the world of China's "immorality" and western "moral superiority". Lots of fun reboots of cold war and orientalist attitudes going on here.

In short, its much easier for the west to make up bullshit and point fingers at its enemies, rather than own up to its decaying status as a world superpower, its massive social problems and alienation. And secondly, we have to disprove the CIA propaganda that "China is imperialist", as if what drove Maoists to liberate peasants and the poor of the world then and now, was narrow nationalism / racial supremacy, and that there is fundamentally no difference between the foreign policies of capitalist empires like the US, and socialist formations like China, Cuba, etc.

This is western chauvinists imputing the values of its own colonial powers onto those it colonized for hundreds of years (projection in psychology I think). Ultralefts also like to make it seem that all trade is inequitable, therefore, China is "imperializing" any country or people it trades with (total nonsense).

What happened

About 2 weeks ago, I made a comment in an anti-china sub-thread in /r/socialism, refuting the "China is genociding Uyghurs" propoganda here, with one of my megathreads. I post these pretty frequently, as the number of thin takes on China are pouring into /r/socialism with increasing frequency.

I was then permabanned and muted for "islamophobia / racism / colonial apologia / posting articles by conspiracy theorists" by mod /u/107A. To 107A, any opposition to the US propaganda that "China is genociding Muslims", means that you must therefore hate Muslims, since you don't agree with Mike Pence that China is genociding them. Put simply, all opinions contrary to US propaganda about Uyghur repression, is considered a "conspiracy theory", and a permabannable offense to the mods of /r/socialism.

It turns out that out of the 8 or so links posted in that megathread, they arbitrarily chose one to ban me over, with no discussion.

The Marxists in /r/socialism are held to a higher standard than the libertarians: its we who have to provide sources, links, and megathreads, while the libertarians can carelessly call the CPC genociders, racists, or "Han supremacists", with absolutely no critical analysis.

MLs are being targeted for listing facts, and one link, whether it be from a controversial voice or not, should not be the reason for bans. Anti-communists meanwhile are given free reign to shit on an entire non-Western country without any critical analysis. MLs list links, and get banned for one; other users can say the most vile things about a country, and be protected by Nixie and their gang.

If one wrong link can get you completely banned because it goes against the "China BAD" narrative, then /r/socialism is going end up like the reddit mains pretty quickly. With such a clear ideological bias against AES, /r/soc is actively in the process of ridding itself of its MLs/MLMs authoritarian communists.

The longer story

At least a year ago, a lot of us mods set up a discord for leftmods of various subreddits, not as a chat server really, but to help foster communication, to resolve beefs, and to help each other coordinate campaigns. We have members from /r/communism, /r/socialistRA, /r/shitliberalssay, /r/capitalism_in_decay, /r/communism101, /r/socialism_101, /r/paganproles, /r/moretankiechapo, /r/fullcommunism, etc. Although we routinely invite mods from /r/socialism, only a few would join or respond.

I've modded some huge subs, so I know that a lot of bans can be mistakes, and that its good to reach out in modmail to see if something occurred. I'm also very against burning bridges and demonizing an entire mod team for the mistakes of a single mod, and like to get consensus in the modmail. Many of us have debated and overturned many a ban over disagreements, and this is why a process for unbanning involving a democratic consensus is so important.

My messages to them went unanswered: here are a few of them.

I then reached out to those on that discord that were mods of /r/socialism, and /u/bayarea415 unbanned me, and I really appreciate that they put themselves out there for me. bayareas position as a mod is very tenuous there these days, (nixie has threatened to ban them several times in the last week alone), and I knew they were opposing some of the other moderators there by doing so.

Then a few days ago, I was permabanned again by /u/107A. This time I wasn't muted, so I was able to ask why. I received this in response.

An hour later, I was permabanned again (I was already so I have no idea why this was necessary).

Then I finally received this message detailing the reason for the ban:

u/parentis_shogun,

A recent post of yours contained a link that was authored by F. William Engdahl, a conspiracy theorist who’s associated with Lyndon LaRouche and his anti-Semitic cult. This is the article in question. You have posted this multiple times, after being warned not to do so. This led a number of mods to question whether or you posted this out of ignorance of its fascist connections, or knowingly, without regard for where it came from.

Because this is the second time this has happened, the mods are currently discussing whether you should be permanently or temporarily banned. If you would like to provide an explanation, we’ll take it into consideration.

Thanks and sorry for the confusion.

So now I'm also accused of being not just Islamophobic, but also having an anti-semitic source. A two-fer of racism, yay.

So it turns out the "given" reason for my ban, was that my 6th source down on the Uyghur post, was by William Engdahl, who is a former member / linked to this LaRouche person, who apparently is anti-semitic.

I let them know that I had doubts about the veracity of that anti-semitic claim for that author, my response is here. He's an anti-imperialist and anti-zionist, publishing throughout the 80s and 90s, so most anti-imperialist authors were labeled as "conspiracy theorists" for talking about the US wars for oil, or "anti-semites", for being anti-zionist. I can get into them elsewhere, as I had to do a bunch of research on this bullshit, but overall the claims are pretty dubious, even the author himself explicitly says he's not anti-semitic.

More importantly, the mods know my stances and tendency; they know I'm neither islamophobic, nor anti-semitic. This is just the justification to purge yet another authoritarian socialist from /r/soc who says positive things about China they don't like.

They then proceeded to "link me" to this author, then to various other "cancelled" authors. This is called, "Trial by association."

The screenshots for the rest of the discussion are here : 1, 2, 3


BTW, lets get into the mod who banned me, /u/107A, who thinks that China has state-sanctioned Islamophobic genocide.

Here they are banning another person from /r/socialism for "police apologia" of the Hong Kong police, and the "conspiracy theory" that the CIA pays protesters. Yet another ban issued for.... actually something that's pretty true, the NED is covertly funding the protests, many of the protest leaders are meeting with Marco Rubio and Tom Cotton, meeting with US officials like Judie Eadie. A good starter on Hong Kong is this video by anti-conquista on the Hong Kong protest movement, and who's funding it.

It should go without saying that not every protest is revolutionary: many are highly reactionary in nature (color revolutions, protests outside abortion clinics, fascist rallies. The capitalist-funded HK protests are no different: the goal is trying to make sure China's harsher financial regulations won't apply to HK capitalists, even if that means that murderers who kill their pregnant girlfriends get to walk free.

107A's post history is mostly full of anti-china garbage, their source for "China committing cultural genocide of Uyghurs", is Adrian Zenz, an anti-China researcher who's been publishing about "Chinese repression" in Tibet for years, and is the source of the 1.5 million Uyghurs in detention camps, basing his estimate on "satellite images." Check out some of the papers he's written. Interesting how using a NYTimes hack like Zenz isn't a bannable offense.

Zenz, like much of his NED/state-department funded ilk, help build the intellectual basis of support for the US's imperialist/orientalist policies. If China is committing genocide, and not simply dealing with a minority of extremists, then anything the US does against China has a moral justification.

107A is happy to post pro-HK articles from the Guardian. Using that British rag as a source, the majority of its articles being pro-empire lies, doesn't seem to bother them.

Its a lot easier to accuse someone of anti-semitism than to engage critically with an anti-zionist, and its easier to call someone an islamophobe than it is to dissect China's policies towards deradicalization of extremists in Xinjiang.


Apologies for taking yall on this ride, its a waste of pretty much everyones time, and mostly pointless bullshit. Anti-China "socialists" are a dime a dozen, its just most of them don't usually get to be top mods of socialist subreddits.

I'm gonna keep doing my work for the goals of socialism regardless, recording audiobooks and articles, making megathreads, and working on the reddit left alternative lemmy.

edit: talked to some /r/soc mods, not all of them agree with nixies policies, and there are more authsocs than just bayarea.


r/communism • • Nov 14 '12

Gaza under Israeli attack: LIVE UPDATES — RT

Thumbnail
rt.com
0 Upvotes

r/communism • • Nov 28 '12

Woman Naxal with rifle held off 250 commandos for six hours

Thumbnail
indianexpress.com
0 Upvotes

r/communism • • Jan 22 '13

Is it me, or does the Venezuelan VP look like a South American version of Joseph Stalin?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/communism • • Nov 18 '12

Che Guevara speech at UN 1964 (subtitled)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/communism • • Nov 27 '12

Stalin and Parkinson's Law of Triviality

0 Upvotes

Parkinson's Law of Triviality, also known as the "bikeshed effect", famously states that for a given group or organization a disproportionate amount of time will be spent discussing trivial or inconsequential matters. This page talks in detail about this phenomenon, but the canonical example of the law is presented as a thought experiment: imagine you go to the board of directors of some company in order to secure funds to build a multi-billion nuclear power plant. Since none of them actually know anything about nuclear power plants they'll tend to assume that someone else checked all the details about its functioning before the project got as far as it has, so the discussion might end up being surprisingly smooth. On the other hand, assume you go to the same group of people to secure funds for a small bikeshed for the company HQ. Everyone knows what a bikeshed is and even how to make one, so you'll likely end up buried in endless debates about its size, materials, color, etc. When given the chance, people like to make themselves be noticed, and the more trivial a topic is the more likely it is that everyone will be able to make their opinion known.

So, that's the bikeshed effect. My theory is that this law, perhaps slightly modified, is at work in making communist or socialist oriented debate forums seem somewhat obsessed with a small number of issues centered around Stalin and his crimes (and perhaps Mao, Pol-Pot or others, but in Western dominated forums it will usually be Stalin) and by extension the USSR (again, perhaps China or others, but usually it will be the USSR) and its crimes. Now, I'm not saying those topics are trivial in the sense of not being important, so this is not exactly like talking about bikesheds, but they are trivial in one important sense: the vast majority of people in Western countries won't know very much at all about communism or socialism, neither in theory nor about how it was put into practice in several countries throughout the decades, but there's one thing that has permeated popular culture to such an extent that pretty much everyone will have an opinion about it, being able to repeat a few common places that are accepted as a matter of fact: Stalin and/or the USSR were bad and the source of many and numerous crimes.

What's the consequence of this? The consequence is that people will disproportionately ask about Stalin (just search how many times people have submitted questions about him here), because they already know a bit about that, or, more importantly, will systematically try to derail every conversation about any topic towards Stalin and its supposed crimes, because then they'll be able to effectively make their voice count ("aha! finally, this I know about!"). The thing is, of course, they won't really know much about it, since the very reason they will consistently raise those points comes from the fact the shallowness of their knowledge. How many times have you seen someone repeat a rehashed summary of a Wikipedia page as if it were a striking new revelation? How many times have you asked someone for sources or details about their knowledge just to be presented with something to the effect of "well I don't really know much about this to be honest"? How many times have you seen threads with intriguing or deep questions languish with a few comments while the Stalin thread next door was going through the roof?

I like to think of r/communism as the anti-bikeshed subreddit. By forbidding trivial attacks against any strand of communism (per Parkinson's Law a lot of them tend to be directed against a very small number of things, but we have absolutely kicked out people lashing against pretty much every tendency there is) we have managed to substantially elevate the level of discourse, forcing people out of their comfort zone both in what they read about and in the way they have to criticize others.

Now that you know, hopefully you'll be able to recognize Parkinson's Law in action. Do something to stop its pernicious effect, either in others or in yourself!


r/communism • • Nov 15 '12

Remember when SRS said not supporting Obama was privileged behavior? Well, I wonder how they feel about Obama saying he isn't going to push for gay rights anymore.

Thumbnail
mtv.com
0 Upvotes

r/communism • • Dec 02 '12

Shocking Maoist Conspiracy Against R/Anarchism Exposed!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/communism • • Jan 27 '13

Marxist Criticism of the CPUSA

Thumbnail
gonzotimes.com
0 Upvotes

r/communism • • Oct 30 '23

Brigaded The demonization of Stalin is about hiding his great contributions to revolutionary theory

Thumbnail
rainershea.substack.com
41 Upvotes

To reclaim our heroes


r/communism • • Jan 28 '13

Selective Leninism: a senile disorder of revisionism

0 Upvotes

Note: I have decided to translate this from the spanish original because of a recent debate in our subreddit where one comrade mentioned Lenin's Left-wing communism book and the way it tends to be used by certain segments of the communist movement. I basically agree with the text, but I don't mean to attack anyone directly with this since I don't even know much about the particular context of the debate I'm referring to. I have tried to give some additional information (see the footnotes) where I felt it would be needed by non-Spaniards, and the translation is probably shitty but you'll have to take what you are given (if someone really feels like correcting the text to make it more idiomatic feel free to send me a PM though).


Selective Leninism: a senile disorder of revisionism

The first time I read "Left-wing communism: an infantile disorder" I was just a teenager. For that reason, a few days ago I decided that I should read it again. Maybe I didn't understand it properly back in the day, maybe it will make me reassess my ideas, I thought. And given the quotes that the revisionists like to decontextualize and throw around I ended up thinking that, perhaps, right after reading the last page I would become a "walking dead"[1] and would beg, powerless to stop myself, to be admitted in CCOO[2], all the while justifying the infamous governance pact between PSOE[3] and IU[4] in Andalucia[5]. Surprisingly enough, that was not the case.

Lenin wrote this interesting pamphlet in 1920. In 1969, a Danny Cohn-Bendit (who, apparently, had a great time going through college) wrote an abomination as reply with the title "Leftism: remedy for the senile disorder of Leninism". Time puts everyone in its place: Cohn-Bendit is currently a member of the European Parliament who campaigned for a "Yes" to the European Constitution, that is, for a "Yes" to the disorder (senile or not) of capitalism.

That being the case, I'll adapt the ingenious title of this traitor, since revisionism's senile disorder is "strangely" selective when it must quote Lenin. "Oddly enough", past sentences are only quoted when they can be used to justify present treasons. Page 44 is quoted, where Lenin talks about the necessity of working with the reactionary trade unions. Also quoted is page 52, where Lenin demands from its followers that they participate in bourgeois parliamentary elections, or page 90, where Lenin calls on his followers to support the English socialdemocrats of the Second International (Labour). And, naturally, as one young member of UJCE[6] told me, those of us that won't adapt our political reality to these quotes are not "actual Leninists". Such cruelty!

"Oddly enough", page 12 is never quoted nor must our reality be adapted to it, a page where Lenin talks about "combining legal and illegal activities", of getting rid of the reformists as "bourgeois agents" embedded inside the workers movement and of firmly denying any "pacifist illusions". Neither is quoted nor, again, must our reality be adapted to page 20, where Lenin defends the 1905 tactic used by russian revolutionaries: boycott to the bourgeois parliamentary elections. Such a coincidence!

We are unable to find them quoting or adapting their reality to page 43, where Lenin talks of a "ruthless struggle" to kick the opportunist leaders off the parties and trade unions. Or page 52, where Lenin talks about how the bolsheviks must not "go down" to the level of consciousness of the masses, being their duty to tell them the "bitter truth". Or page 58, where Lenin explicitly says that electoral abstention is "not always a mistake", since "the conditions for a boycott can be met". Or page 62, where Lenin asks for an "uncompromising and violent" criticism of those left-wing leaders that do not use parliament in a revolutionary way, that is, with the objective of attacking and destroying that institution, going as far as asking for the substitution of those leaders and their expulsion from the Party. Or page 73, where he again talks about establishing a never ending struggle against the opportunist leadership of the working class parties.

On the other hand, since pages 44, 52 and 90 are so important for revisionists, they should be able to explain to me why page 96 is at the same time so unimportant, where Lenin suggests the "transformation of a strike in an armed insurrection", and talks about the soviets as the "gravediggers of bourgeois parliamentarism". They seem to pay no attention to page 97, where Lenin explains how the Third International defeated the Second even though the latter was much larger in size; or take page 106, where the independence of Ireland against British imperialism is defended; or page 109, where Lenin states that the attacks on bolshevism by the bourgeois press did nothing but benefit the bolsheviks; page 123, too, where Lenin even agrees with Bordiga on the question of the purge of the reformist "social-traitors" from the left-wing parties.

Of course, I harbor no hope my UJCE friend, who took away my "Leninist card" (a deeply troubling incident), will read beyond what his decontextualized training manuals present him, the entire passages where Lenin clearly explains what he is against: he's not against alternative unions, which did not exist at the time, but against the "councils" or "worker unions" proposed by the german-dutch left (page 40), against the "new artificial forms of organization" created by them (page 44); or those passages where Lenin explains what he means with "reactionary trade unions": a tendency to be non-political, a certain inertness, etc (page 41). That means, I don't expect my friend to understand that Lenin was not talking about "professional union workers"[7] or the "pensionazo"[8] agreement, for the very simple reason that Lenin didn't know about these phenomenons. It remains to be seen whether Lenin would consider CCOO a "reactionary trade union" (not so much because of the reactionary part, since that seems pretty clear, but because of the trade union part) or simply an integral part of the bourgeois State apparatus.

I'm also not holding my breath waiting for my friend to understand than when Lenin was calling on his followers to work with the trade unions it was because that's "where the masses are" (page 45), with no less than 7 million affiliates in England as of 1920. For the sake of comparison, today the Spanish masses not only are not in CCOO in such numbers, but they in fact tend to even resent the organization.

I feel unable to explain to other friends of mine, this time from the PCPE[9] and Izquierda Anticapitalista[10], that while Lenin indeed talked about working from within the bourgeois parliament (page 53), a party that receives 20,000 votes won't get anything done unless it's based on a country with a million voters.

But "An infantile disorder" isn't Lenin's only book. All my friends, especially the revisionist ones, so faithful to that book and its pages 44, 52 and 90, oddly enough always forget to quote Lenin's "Lecture on the 1905 revolution", where he said that the development of the revolution "inevitably leads to armed struggle". Or his article "Revolutionary army and revolutionary government" (July 1905) where he says that "the revolutionary army is needed because great historical issues can be resolved only by force".

They obsessively insist on not radicalising their speech to avoid "scaring people away" and to attract more members, but in doing so they forget, also a strange coincidence, the 1919 article "A great beginning", where Lenin says: "the mobilisation of Communists for the war helped us in this respect: the cowards and scoundrels fled from the Party's ranks. Good riddance!"

They condemn violence and love quiet strolls (also known as demonstrations), casually forgetting Lenin's article "Fear of the collapse of the the old and the fight for the new", published by Pravda on December 1917, where he says: "those who are scared by the class struggle at its highest pitch when it turns into civil war, the only war that is legitimate, just and sacred—not in the clerical but in the human sense—the sacred war of the oppressed to overthrow the oppressors and liberate the working people from all oppression", adding for good measure Marx's remark about violence always being the midwife of the old society.

Alas, I should probably stop here since I know this will be for nothing. What we must do is create new slogans and new analysis based on our particular social reality, and it would be dogmatic to keep unearthing Lenin's quotes to show anything other than the incoherence of those that try to put themselves "out of harm's way" by such unearthing. The point is that I feel unable to accomplish these four simple things:

  • To stop these people from cherry-picking quotes according to their dogmatic interests or, worse, to justify the most abhorrent political and trade union treasons.

  • To make these people understand that the the social context of a message must be decoded together with that message, and that this message can only be understood together with its context; that to pretend that Lenin would say today the same things that a century ago is to make him an idiot.

  • To make these people see that, even in his own social context, Lenin was not a god and thus could make mistakes.

  • And, as for myself, I feel unable to be so naive as to believe for a second that behind all the scare quotes around the "coincidences" that I have mentioned hide the traces of a ideological struggle, because I know too well that the only thing that hides in there is the ambition of a few traitors that only want to live comfortably in the apparatus of their party or their "trade union".


1: in English in the original.

2: "Comisiones Obreras", the largest union in Spain, with ties to the Communist Party and somewhat notorious for its revisionist politics.

3: Partido Socialista Obrero Español, the largest socialdemocratic party in Spain

4: Izquierda Unida, a "united front" style party led by the Communist Party

5: PSOE and IU agreed to form a government in Andalucia last year, their votes added up surpassing the winner of the elections the right-wing Partido Popular

6: Unión Juventudes Comunistas de España, the youth wing of the Communist Party

7: "liberados" in Spanish, people working for a union as their full time job

8: a reform of the old age pension laws agreed by the State and the major unions

9: Partido Comunista de los Pueblos de España, the Spanish equivalent to the KKE that split from the Communist Party about 30 years ago

10: Izquierda Anticapitalista, a Trotskyist splinter group from IU


r/communism • • Nov 16 '12

Support the workers of Walmart.

Thumbnail
salon.com
2 Upvotes

r/communism • • Nov 15 '12

Stop Israel’s war on Gaza | Fight Back!

Thumbnail
fightbacknews.org
0 Upvotes

r/communism • • Dec 03 '12

In honor of recent events, I'm personally declaring this week Anti-American Week. I'll begin with An Unpatriotic History of World War 2

Thumbnail
worldsocialism.org
0 Upvotes

r/communism • • Jan 31 '13

Which modern-era films are most interesting to a Marxist?

0 Upvotes

As an arbitrary point to mark the 'modern era', let's say any work produced after 1980.

I'd discuss examples here, but I don't know of many, and of those I do know, I have little interesting to offer up. I'm interested in hearing discussion of modern films which present Marxist themes or may be interesting to Marxists, though.


r/communism • • Jan 27 '13

Reminder: Please click on the "New" tab to view threads that were downvoted yesterday.

0 Upvotes

There are some pretty good ones, and we wouldn't want them to get skipped over just because of a silly invasion.


r/communism • • Nov 27 '12

Turkish Maoists - Imgur

Thumbnail
imgur.com
1 Upvotes

r/communism • • Dec 06 '22

Long live Lenin, long live Mao Zedong! - Chant Finnish maoists counter-protesting against the fascist protest in Helsinki

Thumbnail
iltalehti.fi
1 Upvotes

r/communism • • Nov 14 '12

Counter-propaganda propaganda: "40 Helpful Tips For Anti-Communists."

Thumbnail
kasamaproject.org
0 Upvotes