r/communism101 • • Apr 05 '20

How can I convince someone Elon Musk is not 'the good billionaire'?

2.1k Upvotes

I have a friend totally absorbed in the Elon Musk cult, and I'm trying to convince him otherwise.


r/communism101 • • Jul 30 '20

I’m tired of hiding the fact that I’m a communist

1.2k Upvotes

(I posted this in another subreddit but I wanna post it here too)

I live in Miami, Florida. Because of the diaspora, we have a lot of Cubans here who hate communism and other leftist ideologies, and these people have instilled strong anti-communist sentient in their children. This sucks because it means all these 1st and 2nd generation kids walk around condemning our ideology without knowing a damn thing about it. It’s pure ignorance and often they refuse to educate themselves on topic. They’ve all just accepted this bullshit red scare propaganda. This means I’m the only communist i know in real life, all my friends who espouse the ideology I only know through twitter. Funny thing is whenever I bring up communist ideas (without mentioning that they’re part of our ideology) they strongly agree with them. So I can’t openly identify as communist unless I want to lose all my friends and my girlfriend. I’m tired of hiding it and I need to say it loud and proud somewhere or else I’m gonna lose my shit. I AM A COMMUNIST. I LOVE THE BEAUTIFUL IDEAS WE COMMIT TO. I’ve been a communist since I first got into politics when I was 14 years old. I have a hammer and sickle tattooed on me. I will never falter in my belief that better things are possible. Thank you for reading this comrades, and for my fellow commie American Redditors, our revolution will come! let us fight for it!


r/communism101 • • Apr 25 '21

Why do people blindly accept that communism doesn’t work, while also finding it perfect reasonable that capitalist states must fight to “stop the spread of communism”?

825 Upvotes

Even before I started looking into Marx and communism, I never understood this. If you believe communism doesn’t work, then don’t you also believe that it will collapse in on itself and fail to overtake our “much stronger capitalist nation”? Why do people believe that communism doesn’t work, while also supporting capitalist states attacking communist nations? Seems like a huge double standard to me, never supported it, even before I looked into communism.


r/communism101 • • Sep 04 '19

My Mom (From Venezuela) Hates Chavez and Maduro. I Now Know Why.

784 Upvotes

My mom was educated in a Catholic all girls school. Her brothers and father went to a Jesuit school. Her father was a pharmacist, and her brother owns a tractor business. She had a maid in the house when 40% of Venezuelans were below the poverty line.

Now I know why she hates Maduro.


r/communism101 • • Feb 21 '19

Are we fucking with Bernie

712 Upvotes

You will get canned as a soc dem and part of the left wing of capital if you are constantly talking up Sanders, but I feel he has helped raise class consciousness in the United States and that is unequivocally a good thing for the working class. A lot of time and energy gets wasted on elections that would be better used elsewhere, but I think it is obvious that it’d be a better thing for him to be in power then the current white supremacist regime. Is it a waste of time to be concerned with elections in general? Do you think a Sanders presidency would be advantageous for the actual revolution or is accelerationism a serious strategy?


r/communism101 • • Mar 27 '19

A Thank You To All Communist Educators On This Sub

702 Upvotes

This sub exists to help clarify facts regarding Communism, to fight lies spread by the rich and self-serving, and to help fellow workers find their way towards a bright alternative future. To all those working at these goals I thank you for your service. I thank you for your aid to the cause, and I thank you for helping our fellow workers find their way.

People come here curious and/or confused--lost in a sea of lies and chaos. You help to bring them to the realizations we all know as fact that guide us from this haze. Thank you.


r/communism101 • • May 08 '19

How impressive is it when a COMMUNIST wins a US election

673 Upvotes

r/communism101 • • Dec 21 '18

Counter-arguments to common capitalist economic arguments

664 Upvotes

Hey, everyone! So in an attempt to help fellow comrades in potential debates and address the concerns of supporters of capitalism, I've tried to compile a list of pro-capitalist arguments that have been made to me and why they're not valid.

Introduction: You need money to make money

First, let's establish what capitalism is and isn't. In any society, it's economic organization can be described by the way it produces goods and distributes resources. In particular, we can describe it by the relationship between different classes in society.

Under capitalism, there is something called capital. It's an umbrella term that includes but is not limited to factories, land, houses, and other forms of infrastructure that is privately owned. There are people who own capital, for example, a factory owner, and people who sell their labor for a wage. Workers go to the factory to work for the factory owner -- for instance, they take pieces of wood and make it into a chair. Say that each chair sells for $100. The factory owner takes a cut of the $100, say $70, and gives the $30 to the workers to pay their wages.

This is the fundamental relation in capitalism. There are owners and workers, i.e. the bourgeoisie and the proletariat. The workers labor and produce something in a factory, and the owners, who already have money, factories, or land take a cut of the profits. Note that the owners could only make money as owners because they already have capital, in other words, you need money to make money.

Under this definition of capitalism, this relation between owners and workers has only existed for a couple hundred years. It is not the process of trading goods or buying things.

What's wrong with that?

The core issue at stake here is that the workers are doing the actual labor while the owner makes money simply because they own the factory. The owner produced next to nothing on their own. If all the workers one day disappeared, the owners would not be able to produce anything -- the machines and tools wouldn't operate themselves and the owner would have an empty factory. On the other hand, if all the owners disappeared and no one was informed about it, the workers could still run the factory as usual. The manager would still supervise production and the workers would still come everyday and produce goods and services.

So this begs the question, why do we need owners in the first place? If we can get along fine without the owners, why do they get a cut (in practice it's more than just a cut of the profits, it's a gross majority)? Why does the owner get a cut simply because they have more money? Moreover, if we don't need the owners, why do they get to make all the decisions? Why can't workers run things democratically amongst themselves? This is the core of socialist ideology.

Now you might say, wait a minute, a lot of times the owners are the managers! They actually come to the company and are involved in the day to day activities. And you'd be right in that not all owners are leeches who sit back and collect dividend checks. We think the business owners that work should be paid for the actual work they did in the day to day activities of the company, not the paper that entitles them to a cut of the workers' labor. If a business owner really does play an integral role in the day to day workings of a company, then surely they will still be compensated more than fairly if the workplace was democratic and everyone had an equal say.

Now, of course, you might not be satisfied with just this. There are, of course, many concerns to be addressed, and the remaining sections will do just that.

Capitalism fosters innovation, or your iPhone was made under capitalism

As we've established before, capitalism has existed for only a few hundred years. Innovation and geniuses have existed long before then. Moreover, these people did not create what they created with a profit motive in mind. Mozart and Beethoven didn't write world class music to be rich, in fact, they were dirt broke for most of their lives and never received significant pay for the symphonies and pieces they wrote. Additionally, Edward Jenner, who developed a smallpox vaccine, and Jonas Salk, who developed a polio vaccine, did not patent their work, instead allowing it to be produced cheaply so that it could reach and save the lives of millions. Salk famously said that "there is no patent. Could you patent the sun?" In more recent times, wildly successful companies like Microsoft and Apple got their big break by stealing from others, not innovating themselves. Apple is credited for introducing the modern GUI to the world, but it was developed by Xerox's Palo Alto Research Center, which Steve Jobs stole the idea from. Microsoft, in turn, stole the idea from Jobs to create Windows. In their earlier days, Microsoft's flagship operating system, DOS, was bought by Bill Gates from a small programmer.

Well what about your iPhone? Surely that was made under capitalism, right? Or at the very least, it couldn't have been created if not for the incentive structures under capitalism. As it turns out, although it is a good product, much of the technology that made the iPhone possible was developed in the public sector.

Even if capitalism did create the iPhone, there's a pretty succinct quote to counter the argument -- "It’s okay to resist capitalism on an iPhone. The feudal lord who owned the pitchforks the peasants killed him with probably observed the irony too."

Additionally, as /u/iamwhiskerbiscuit said,

It's often said by capitalists that financial incentive is necessary for innovation. On the surface, this is true, since few people are willing or able to work for nothing. However, this assertion presuposes that only businesses are capable of providing financial icentives for innovation. However, any government is capable of providing financial icentives. It's called pay. Our government paid scientists to create the atomic bomb (aka the greatest technological marvel of the 20th century). We paid scientists to create the ebola vaccine. And we can pay scientists and engineers to do anything that a private company would use them for.

I end this section with the (sarcastic) quote -- "I'll never understand how the wheel was invented without a market incentive."

Well shouldn't business owners be rewarded for their financial risk?

The argument is that people who spend money in capital stand to risk losing their money if their business fails while since the workers don't own the business and won't go down with the ship. Therefore, the cut of the profits (and the income inequality) the owners take is justified because they are being rewarded for the financial risk they undertook.

The problem with this is that the only risk the owners take is the risk of becoming a worker, or becoming like one of the people you employ and exploit. They will be no worse than the workers if their business fails. You might say, well, they might go bankrupt or be thrown into crippling debt. For every one business owner who loses their money, millions more workers live in poverty or debt every day. Why does the possibility of an owner becoming poor outweigh the reality of the destitute living conditions of millions of workers?

The worst thing that happens is that the former business owner has to suffer the humiliation of working at McDonald's. How could they possibly bear the indignation of walking among us filthy, crude, unwashed masses as equals?

Moreover, why should taking a risk necessarily be rewarded? Compulsive gamblers aren't entitled to winnings because they take risks all the time. That same logic could be used to argue that slave owners took a great financial risk by buying slaves, so abolishing slavery would be punishing the risk they took.

Finally, it should be obvious but needs to be said that if the gallant, risk taking owner's business fails, the workers are also out of a job. and possibly didn't even get paid their salary before the business went under. One could argue that the workers could just find another job, and that's exactly the concern addressed in the next part.

Doesn't competition between capitalists forces them to stop exploiting workers or why don't you just find a better job?

These two go hand in hand. The first argument says that capitalists have to try to offer workers better wages and conditions because workers will just find another job that pays better. The latter argues that because of competition for workers, workers should just find a better paying job.

Although it sounds good on paper, this simply is not the case. In the early days of capitalism, workers worked for 12 hour days in horrific conditions. There were no "better" factory jobs to turn to, because all of them paid the same terrible wages in dangerous factories. Working conditions and wages didn't improve then because of the Invisible Hand of the Free MarketTM, they did because of government regulations, unions, and other forms of pushback from workers.

And in what universe do you live where capitalists compete for workers? Workers compete for jobs, not the other way around. If you could just walk out and find another job, why is unemployment an issue? Why is it so devastating to be laid off? There is a reserve army of labor that capitalists take advantage of. A common tactic is to simply threaten to replace workers by hiring the unemployed who are willing to work for less. Today, capitalists in the United States often threaten to fire American workers by replacing them with cheap migrant labor or moving their production overseas.

Why don't you start your own business?

Well, as we've shown already, under capitalism, you need money to make money. If you're a worker who's just been laid off, chances are it's not realistic to just start a business because you don't have the money. If you somehow already did, then I would ask why you sold your labor for a wage all this time and didn't start a business sooner.

Don't the rich capitalists create jobs?

Even arguing under capitalist economic theory, it's consumer demand that causes business owners to produce more to increase the supply. This consumer demand comes from the consumption wants and needs of the people. On top of that, it's worth reiterating that capitalists need workers, but the workers don't need capitalists. If all the workers disappeared, who's going to operate the machinery? If the capitalists disappeared, workers could come to work and go about their business. You might say that workers need supervisors and managers, but unless the manager actually owns the business, managers are workers themselves who sell their skills for a wage.

Aren't you just devaluing intellectual work and idolizing physical labor?

No, we value intellectual work. We understand that there is a need for non-physical labor. For example, accountants, supervisors, and managers are needed. If you support a planned economy, we will obviously need people who can plan what to produce, how to produce it, and how much to produce, which isn't physical labor. The important point is that we think these people should be paid for the work they do, not because of some claim of ownership. In some cases, owners actually are the managers or supervisors, but they should be paid for their work as a manager, not because their initial lump sum of cash snowballed as the business grew.

But I don't feel exploited as a worker

In that case, good for you. But your experiences aren't universal, and just because you're happy with your position in life doesn't mean you can expect everyone else to be. Someone with a cushy job in a middle class neighborhood can be a worker who's happy with where they are, but that doesn't mean they should expect destitute factory workers making $2 an hour to feel unexploited too.

What about the common people who invest in companies or make money off private property to retire?

In theory, yes, we are opposed to anyone who makes money through money. However, we do believe in social policies provide for those in need and cannot work, i.e. the elderly, sick, or disabled. In addition, we are much more interested in the 8 people who have as much wealth as 50% of the world's population than common people who try to invest in real estate or companies.

The difference is that these common people still work full time jobs and invest to pad their income or retire. I don't blame working people for doing what they can to make ends meet -- they won't help anyone by going into poverty. As the saying goes, "there is no ethical consumption under capitalism," which means that no matter where you get something from, someone is being exploited somewhere along the line.

I do think, however, that their private ownership must be abolished eventually. That doesn't mean that I want to kick them out in the cold. Billionaires Made So Much Money Last Year They Could End Extreme Poverty Seven Times. Under capitalism today, one third of all food produced is wasted, and it could feed the hungry four times over. The redistribution of wealth and resources that we hope to reclaim from the elite 1% is more than enough to provide for the needs of the workers who invest and the workers who are deep in poverty. We're not interested in having common people fight over who gets the crumbs; we're interested in the ones who make off with the whole loaf.

But the factories/apartments/farmland belong to the owners! You can't just take that!

That same nonsense logic has been used to justify things like feudalism and slavery. The slaves who escaped their masters have to be returned because they're the property of their owners! You can't liberate the slaves and take the plantations away, that'll be stealing property! Would you use that logic to oppose the Haitian slave revolt?

Oh, but the king and the nobles and the church own all of Europe! Not the filthy peasants! They're not allowed to own land. And yet revolutionaries still beheaded the feudal lords and kings and seized their property to establish what we today call capitalism.

You see, that's just the way the world works

That's essentially a might makes right argument that, like the previous argument, can justify any organization. If workers being exploited by capitalists is just how the world works, then when the rich moan at how revolutionaries confiscated their wealth and property, they can just turn around and tell the disgruntled bourgeoisie that this is just how the world works. And if the existence of oppressors is how the world works, then it could also be said that the oppressed rising up to overthrow their oppressors is just how the world works.

Upcoming topics

I have tried to cover as many pro-capitalist talking points as possible, but there are far more out there. I will continue to update this document as I go, but here are some upcoming topics I plan to add but found the time to yet:

  • Capitalism is the best we have..

  • Capitalism rewards hard work

  • It boils down to equality of opportunity versus equality of outcome

  • The rich make better financial decisions than the poor

  • "Gommiez killed trillions"

  • Market incentives will force capitalists to do good

  • Introducing more competitors will drive prices down

If you're interested in contributing, please add the pro-capitalist argument and its refutation in a comment and if it's good, I'll be sure to add it and credit you!


r/communism101 • • Nov 05 '20

Hello everyone, I am a trans girl, and I am relatively new to communism

644 Upvotes

Earlier this year (February), I came out as trans, and I made a support group, and now have a safety net of people I can be myself around. Another thing that has occured, is that now that I am no longer in a state of trans denial, I am no longer driven to conservative ideas or even the right anymore. Ever since months ago, I've been drifting left, and this is probably the biggest political change I have experienced. I've recently opened up to the idea of communism, and consider myself to be a communist, however I'm not too well versed in theory beyond basics. Although I am aware of the resources available to me to learn more, where exactly would be a good place to start?


r/communism101 • • Jun 08 '21

Communism is being turned into aesthetics and niches on social media platforms. What can we do about it without sounding arrogant?

624 Upvotes

This problem has been circling my mind for a while but after Grimes’ (Elon Musk’s wife) tik tok video about “AI communism” I think the left needs to tackle the way that communism is being used by the rich to turn it into a niche subculture. This is so that it will become a sort of “edgy” thing and therefore keep these ideas from becoming mainstream and further alienate the working class from it. At the moment this problem might not seem big but soon, if you tell someone you’re a communist they’ll assume you’re some sort of social reject and move on. How do we stop this without sounding arrogant? I ask this because, surely, it will seem arrogant to be telling people “no you can’t represent communism in this way” etc etc. Sorry if this idea is odd or you guys don’t feel that it is that much of a problem, it’s just that the fetishisation of communism on social media is infuriating and it’s being used as a tool of the rich to just assign someone with “alternative culture” to refrain the ideas from being mainstream instead of it being looked at as a genuine political ideology that can be realised.


r/communism101 • • Jun 01 '20

Is America Fascist?

608 Upvotes

r/communism101 • • Nov 16 '20

How do you not get depressed as a socialist?

576 Upvotes

Hi, everyone the title asks my question. I am a Marxist Leninist and very active on this sub, so I am using an alt account because I'm somewhat embarrassed by the question.

Regardless, I am always slipping into wishful thinking and a ponderance of what the world is/could be and it makes me horribly depressed. How do you guys solve this? What do you do to help yourself?


r/communism101 • • May 10 '20

Am i so paranoid?

571 Upvotes

Recently i realized the more i read about marxism and the more i learn about capitalism. I sense that capitalist propaganda is everywhere. Literally everywhere. I see propaganda wherever i look, in ads, social media, even reddit. I quit from some of subreddits just because of this. I want to know if you guys see these things this way too or am i so paranoid?


r/communism101 • • Dec 20 '20

Brigaded Who the hell is Vaush and why nobody likes him???

564 Upvotes

I'm Brazilian, so i started recently to interact in the english left side of internet. Who is he and why is he so hated???


r/communism101 • • Mar 01 '20

Allied forces knew about Holocaust two years before of concentration camps.

550 Upvotes

Allied forces knew about Holocaust two years before discovery of concentration camps

Now, due to the opening of World War II and Holocaust archives, that the United States and its allies have suppressed themselves against Nazi war criminals involved in death camps, an end of focus not fostering anti-communist sentiments in Germany. I think it is quite safe now to say that a nation created on slavery, genocide and racial segregation was not so disturbed by the Nazis. It is not scary to have entered the war late.


r/communism101 • • Apr 12 '20

Juche AMA

525 Upvotes

Hello, former national communications director for the KFAUSA here, and close friend and comrade of Juche Gang's Shane Pick. Noticed a thread a few days ago asking questions about Juche, so I'm putting up an AMA thread. Ask away.


r/communism101 • • Aug 24 '21

Brigaded Am I (an american) the target of a massive propaganda campaign?

517 Upvotes

I suddenly feel extremely silly. Like really. My entire life, communism bad, capitalism good. Of course the latter, I questioned, perhaps not intensely enough. But my understanding of history I generally have thought were pretty accurate. I understood the ussr to be a dictatorship with Lenin and stalin to be evil heads who slaughtered millions. North Korea a police state that worships its dear leader, even the dead president. China an evil dictatorship, past and present. From Mao to Xi. Cuba and Venezuela failed states. Afghanistan - an Islamic stronghold the u.s. tried to save from commie occupation.

Guys what in the actual fuck. Is basically none of this true?? Why am I just now reading about the opposing views to what I've been taught. I recently watched a video on a guy pointing out the great things that Mao, stalin, Lenin, che, Maduro, Chavez, Deng, the Kim's, and many others have done. And was serious. This shook me to my core and thus my research began. I guess my main question, and I understand I have much to read, is has the American public been lied to on a massive scale for a century just to smear communism. It sounds fuxking asinine. It really does


r/communism101 • • Jun 20 '20

I feel like I’m too stupid to read theory.

506 Upvotes

Every time I try to read theory I fee like I can’t understand what it means at all. I just finished wage labour and capital and it was good, but I still feel like I can’t fully grasp the meaning. I’ve been a communist for around three years and I understand the basic tenants, I just can’t explain them.


r/communism101 • • Sep 19 '20

Should I be proud to have the last name Castro?

503 Upvotes

all my life I’ve had to endure aggression from my peers about how my “grandpa” killed millions of people along with profiling at airports :/ I’ve come to learn more about the Cuban Revolution from a non western perspective but still can’t decide whether or not to embrace my last name.....


r/communism101 • • Nov 10 '20

Is a revolution in our lifetime possible?

499 Upvotes

I'm relatively new to communism. I've been reading some theory and history and from what I understand, the only way to achieve the society we desire, a true society for the people, is through revolution. I just really don't see that happening. Half of America openly supports Trump and most of the other half is satisfied with Biden. Propoganda is incredibly effective. Capitalists hold a lot of power. I already suffer from serious anxiety and depression, which I've come to realize stems from capitalism and the idea of working for 40+ years for the profits of others. Why should I continue reading political theory which in the end makes me feel hopeless? Most people oppose socialism. I'd be happier reading fiction. Is this a fight worth fighting? Sorry I'm kinda drunk lmao.


r/communism101 • • Jul 28 '19

how to stay sane as a communist

498 Upvotes

I feel guilty about not spending every waking hour I have not building a revolution. I want to drop out of school for being a physicist because I don't see how that could aid in revolution. It's also really lonely on a personal level like being an effeminate gay communist does not bode well socially even though I try to bite my tongue about feeling crushed by capitalism when meeting people. idk how do you all manage it without feeling burnt out and isolated


r/communism101 • • Jan 27 '21

How do you cope living in this unfair capitalistic world?

487 Upvotes

For a long time now i have felt that the world could be so much better, and that a lot of immoral actions are stimulated in this society. Seeing fascist parties rising in my country, i dont see such a bright future in front of me. Im afraid things will get much worse. Im trying to educate myself to eventually contribute to spreading communist ideas. But now i feel so meaningless. I feel hopeless. There is nothing i can do, and there is so much to be done.


r/communism101 • • Feb 16 '21

Communism can save the planet

483 Upvotes

I've been thinking that achieving a clean energy economy and a circular, sustainable economy is more likely in a communist society than a capitalist one. What do you guys think?


r/communism101 • • Nov 14 '19

Have difficulties reading Marx, Lenin, or other communist works? Try these podcasts.

480 Upvotes

r/communism101 • • Feb 17 '20

I'm an activist in the Philippine communist movement! AMA!

471 Upvotes

I'm the Red Cebuano and I'm here to answer your questions on the Philippine communist revolution!