r/coconutsandtreason • • May 31 '25

Discussion The Notorious Big ‘Winners’ Line - spoilers if you really haven’t watched yet…

0 Upvotes

I have said this in so many threads I felt I needed to just put it out there once and for all!

The winners comment Nick made was totally unnecessary. It was enough that Nick chose to be on the plane, even if he was the best guy in the universe (which he’s not but it’s hyperbole).

June would not have killed Nick if he wasn’t on the plane. He chose to affiliate with Gilead for too long, maybe it was to save his own ass maybe not, but either way Mayday was gonna make a play for Gilead and he was caught in the crossfire.

It would’ve been a beautiful ending if they let him pass with us thinking maybe he’s a bit good. They don’t have to smack us in the face with that before they off the guy. It felt very untrue to his character. It was a tragic ending and I wish they would’ve trusted the audience to accept the tragic ending that it really was, because we all know Nick had good qualities. If Serena Joy is redeemable, he certainly was. But, just like Lawrence, he was in the wrong place at the wrong time and nothing except if maybe Hannah was in that plane, would have caused June to stop it. She needed those commanders (not Nick) very dead. I didn’t disagree with his ending but I hated that line, the unsaid aspects of the scene were enough.


r/coconutsandtreason • • May 03 '25

Discussion Low Stake Conspiracy : Nicky.

9 Upvotes

I haven’t watched S6 yet but it seems like Nick is still in the wrong side of history and from the little I see here and in the other subs (and apparently even on Facebook) it seems like Nicky’s fan club is out of control.

So what if in reality, THT’s discussion boards are crawling with MAGA bots trying to groom women for the Project 2025?

I take comfort in this thought becsause it is really fucking scary seen women apologising for a man who actively works for Gilead in any way he can.


r/coconutsandtreason • • May 25 '25

Discussion Theory on the finale

0 Upvotes

So this is how Nick will be resurrected. Serena will lead a service, and will state the following incantation in High Gileadian:

Zyhys oñoso jehikagon Aeksiot epi, se gis hen syndrorro jemagon
“We ask the Lord to shine his light, and lead a soul out of darkness.”

Zyhys perzys stepagon Aeksio Oño jorepi, se morghultas lys qelitsos sikagon.
“We beg the Lord to share his fire, and light a candle that has gone out.”

Hen syndrorro, oños. Hen ñuqir, perzys. Hen morghot, glaeson.
“From darkness, light. From ashes, fire. From death, life.”

Unfortunately, a sacrifice will be necessary. Who that sacrifice is is unclear.

From thence Nick shall return, the Eyebrow who is promised, to redeem Gilead, and to seek vengeance on those who brought his untimely and unjust death


r/coconutsandtreason • • Jun 16 '21

Discussion What is wrong with Luke? SPOILERS ABOUND

1 Upvotes

Did I miss something? At the end of Season 4, Episode 10, Luke seemed to react with horror when June arrived home with blood on her face after savaging Commander Fred.

WTF is wrong with that man?

His beloved June was kidnapped, their child was literally ripped out of her arms, and she was turned into a handmaid, to be raped, beaten and tortured by Gilead authorities. And now Luke is appalled that his "sweet little Junie" wants revenge?

WHO DOES HE THINK SHE IS??

And why can't he accept her for the strong, angry, vengeful woman she's become? Is it that easy to forgive others when it's not you who was so horribly brutalized? What, let's forget all that and move on to a brighter day?

Does Luke honestly believe they can ever be the people they once were? That their lives can be put back together again just the way they were so he can play "happy family"?

I hope I'm wrong. I hope I misread that final scene with the two of them. Please tell me if I've misinterpreted their relationship!


r/coconutsandtreason • • Jun 17 '21

Meme Asexuality is not being able to watch any of the kisses without being repulsed, but gleefully watching Fred get ripped limb from limb by the women who's lives he destroyed.

0 Upvotes

r/coconutsandtreason • • May 07 '26

Discussion J’abandonne la série The Testaments…

5 Upvotes

Je n’arrive pas à croire que j’écris ça sachant qu’à la base, j’ai commencé à regarder la série The Handmaid’s Tale (sans grande conviction) pour me mettre à jour et comprendre le lore de The Testaments.

Eh bien, je suis déçue par TT, je trouve ça lent, long, ennuyeux… je ne suis pas convaincue par les acteurs, actrices, l’intrigue pour l’instant c’est pas trop ça.

Je sais qu’il faut que je fasse mon deuil de THT qui est selon moi une masterpiece mais je n’arrive pas à passer à autre chose. Et le plus dur, je crois, c’est de voir que la saga ne suit absolument pas le bouquin. Daisy n’est pas Nichole, ce qui je trouve n’apporte rien d’intéressant.

Je ne suis pas une grand lectrice mais rien que pour apprécier l’oeuvre, j’ai envie de lire les deux livres pour rester sur le propos original.

Je suis la seule à penser ça ou d’autres ressentent la même chose que moi ?


r/coconutsandtreason • • Nov 02 '22

Episodes That was disgusting

1 Upvotes

Okay..maybe I'm being totally naïve here but..the rabid Canadians thing just doesn't ring true for me. First of all, that's not how most of the Canadians I've ever met would be, including those I met while visiting the country. Secondly, they all know what the Americans who are refugees there have been through. It's just not ringing true for me. The US? Yeah, I could totally see that happening, particularly with a few choice groups. I guess there are always going to be a small population being noisy over the majority too. That was just so incredibly ugly at the end.


r/coconutsandtreason • • May 20 '25

Episodes What a mess.

57 Upvotes

The cringe-tastic Taylor Swift intro, the weak sauce grenades / smoke flashes that were supposed to scare off commanders that have actual machine guns, the American CIA being unable to figure out on their own that the secret commander meeting location was in GASP D.C. of all places, the lack of literally any security whatsoever for a flight FULL of commanders, the uncreative and unimaginative degradation and destruction of Nick’s character in three episodes or less, and finally killing off a character that is clearly alive in The Testaments book…what a messy, cheesy end to an incredible series.

I know there’s still an episode left but as far as I’m concerned if Nick doesn’t descend down in a parachute or if he didn’t employ a stunt/body double ahead of time, I’m just going to pretend the series ended with June and Serena on the train with Billie Eilish at the end of season 5. Much better ending. Let anything that happened after that (aside from Lydia’s awakening) be a nightmare.

And for all of the “Nick changed…” people, why YES he did with full thanks to the lackluster and underwhelming writing of this season. Who made these horrid decisions and WHY. Why did so many other characters get to be redeemable but not him? What was any of it for? Why put so much effort into the Nick and June love story while also showing how Luke and June were growing apart just to kill off the guy she really loves??

The first and second season are MASTERPIECES and this one feels like a high school film project trying to improv their way to a B-.

Dumb. I have a headache lol

ETA: I’ve watched this series 5+ times and have been eagerly awaiting this type of rebellion for years so realize that I am grieving 😂


r/coconutsandtreason • • May 25 '25

New Spoilers! Has This Conversation About Nick Happened Yet In Season 6

3 Upvotes

I know almost everyone hates Nick here, so you can skip this post if it rubs you off the wrong way. Yes, the writing is bad this season, with a lot of "....see what we actually meant to show was..."

TVLINE | No spoilers here, but before the series ends, a character tells June that Nick would’ve chosen her if he ever truly had a choice. I’m interested in what you think of that.

Max: His relationship to June is the only sunshine in his life, and it’s his motive for everything. And so, I think that’s absolutely right.

I'm forgetting some of the stuff from the series. Who said this?

If it hasn't, I suppose it's going to come from a surprising character, probably Serena.


r/coconutsandtreason • • May 22 '25

Shipping Ode to Osblaine

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/coconutsandtreason • • Apr 16 '25

Discussion Maybe I’m naive?

0 Upvotes

I love this show. I love the complexity. However, I do not see how this could actually happen. How could “Gilead” take over SO MUCH of the USA? I don’t feel like this would actually succeed and even if it did, it feels like it would take decades to clean up the water/food/establish protocol. Am I just naive?


r/coconutsandtreason • • Jun 27 '26

The Testaments I think the girls were a bit dramatic when Daisy told them the men had pubic hair

4 Upvotes

I know they're not suppose to think about their bodies or any one elses but obviously they know about pubic hair since they have it themselves, so why should it be a surprise that boys would have it too


r/coconutsandtreason • • Jul 10 '19

I can take the violence, the bloodshed, hell even the ceremonies...

4 Upvotes

But dear God that Aunt Lydia make out scene was the first time I couldn’t watch, holy shit that was brutal


r/coconutsandtreason • • Jul 31 '19

I don't even care that I keep posting about Nick's absence. I'm angry redditing...

0 Upvotes

But also, can we come up with some sort of hashtag on Twitter or something to let the writers who hang out there know that we desperately need to see Nick in this show?! I mean, it's not like they can change this season, but could it inform them that we expect more in S4 or something? I know they're free to do what they want and all, but it just seems so irresponsible to write storylines and then not follow through on them. And to make us buy into a relationship and then just drop the ball on it completely. Hulu teased a bunch of Nick and June stuff on their insta page early in the season. Why!!?!?!?!?!?


r/coconutsandtreason • • Nov 11 '22

Theories I think NICK AND JUNE the END GAME

7 Upvotes

.. he has officially sacrificed a lot for her and he’s willing to do anything to protect her. He has done more for her than LUKE..


r/coconutsandtreason • • Jun 16 '21

Discussion I did not like that at all

8 Upvotes

No. So Fred obviously would have been killed by Gilead. June could have let that play out and still been able to have a life with Nichole and Luke. She did not have to do that and she did not have to rob Nichole of her presence in her life and she has destroyed Luke. She has absolutely let the bastards grind her down. I really am not sure I can continue to watch this show at this point. I’m not really excited to root for her.


r/coconutsandtreason • • Sep 14 '22

New Spoilers! First two episodes Frustrated with June

4 Upvotes

I was not a fan of June's revenge last season. Let Gilead kill Fred they consider him a traitor. I mean this is not just having a revenge fantasy, this is knowing you tore someone apart and you think it's awesome. Also, and I know it's true to her character but June never thinks about consequences, when you poke Serena, you put your child at risk. I hate Serena but when Hannah was there at the end, next to her in June's face for the world to see, I didn't feel sorry for June at all. I felt sorry for Luke. I used to root for June but now I really watch for anybody but June. I love Janine, Moira, Luke, Nick I'm fascinated by Commander Lawrence and Aunt Lydia


r/coconutsandtreason • • Aug 16 '19

Am I the only one who hated the finale??

0 Upvotes

Put aside my distain for how the Serena story went down, the whole great escape was so ridiculous, it’s both infuriating and laughable.


r/coconutsandtreason • • May 25 '25

Discussion Season 6 "Betrayal."

0 Upvotes

If you are someone who always hated Nick then this post isn't for you, thank you.

What the writers did this season has been unconscionable. How you can change a character in 3 episodes to try and make him a monster is insane to me. Also forgive me, I only finally saw the episode Saturday night.

I feared they were going to go this route the last few episodes but dang, wtf. Maybe they think they can gaslight the average person, but alot of us have rewatched the show 10 plus times. The directors said they just decided this season to kill Nick and turn him, which is completely obvious because it makes no sense and in some scenes is actual comical. Like him telling Lawrence, " You finally decided to join the winning team," , Nick never would have said that alone to Lawrence, egregious.

Nick has so much potential as a character like in the books which is what they seemed to be going for in seasons 1 through at least 4 and maybe 5.

We saw him:

He became an eye to help the handmaid's from being attacked by the commanders and reports commander Guthrie for sleeping with his handmaid.

He passed the handmaid's letters out to Luke of his own free volition.

Then he helped June numerous times which people criticize as not being for the cause:

Like helping June and Nicole escapand holding Fred at gunpoint, then being punished by Fred by being promoted a commander, which he knew Nick would hate.

Becomes a double agent.

Helping June kill Fred and saving Luke and Moira and on and on the list goes.

Why the show didn't continue on with making him part of Mayday is nonsensical to me. It feels like they made June the villian. I always stuck up for her but now I look at her as the monster she always was. 3 episodes back he was pleading for her help him and looked lost after all the people he killed for her and she seemed like she could care less.

She is the abuser in the end. They took a feminist icon and made her a monster. I hope she explains to Holly how she killed her father. He wasn't anything like Fred, Putnam or Wharton, who took pleasure in their positions and in their cruelty. To conflate the to is beyond incomprehensible to me.

This show was not a love letter to all the fans, only to the Nick haters..

Ps: I am a feminist for context and being one doesn't mean I hate men. My husband is a feminist too.


r/coconutsandtreason • • May 25 '25

Discussion I just saw on tiktok that said June could be delirious on the closet floor at the waterfords after reading that quote on the floor board.

6 Upvotes

How would you feel if this were true?


r/coconutsandtreason • • May 20 '25

Discussion PLEASE SEND OSBLAINE FIC RECS

0 Upvotes

I need some copium. 🥺


r/coconutsandtreason • • May 12 '25

Discussion Think about this Twitter thread if you believe that Nick and June together romantically is a good ending

Thumbnail
tumblr.com
21 Upvotes

r/coconutsandtreason • • Aug 13 '19

Its finale day. Blessed be the fruit.

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/coconutsandtreason • • Jun 16 '21

Discussion Nick's look

0 Upvotes

That moment between Nick and June... I saw him still love her, deliver what she wants, but also walk away from her, and close a door between them, just as Luke will in a few scenes. He accepts and understands her blood lust, but he cant be part of it after this.


r/coconutsandtreason • • May 20 '25

Theories So stoked about Serena

1 Upvotes

I’m cautiously optimistic that Serena will make it out of the show alive and that she and June will have a chance ti grow their friendship and resistance allyship into The Testaments. That’s much more than I had dared hope for them.