r/coconutsandtreason • u/ImperatrixDemeritous • Jun 16 '21
r/coconutsandtreason • u/dubhlinn2 • Jun 16 '21
Meme I just love this shot of Nick from episode 10! šš„
r/coconutsandtreason • u/Icy-Bell7930 • Jun 09 '21
New Spoilers! Aunts at the Red Centre be like:
r/coconutsandtreason • u/IrishHeart3 • May 25 '26
The Testaments So the aunts took Becka is confirmed then?
Found this picture and it kind confirms that the aunts took her. Well, maybe the girls are not touched by the eyes then. This show makes me crazy, first the Handmaidās tale now this show. But in all honesty, I really donāt like the changes they made with the book.
The first season of the Handmaidās tale was really the book. Why couldnāt they just stay again with the book. Yes, the timeline wouldnāt make much sense but who cares, they could have gone with a wrong timelineā¦
And I also miss the spoilers from screeners or the Israeli trailer we had for the Handmaidās tale.
Credits go to someone on x.com ;)
r/coconutsandtreason • u/Enough-Reading4143 • May 20 '26
Discussion Nick is the only character who becomes MORE EVIL as seasons go by
For all of the people who think that NIck chose Gilead because he no longer had June and he had no other choice....The rebellion would have been the perfect time to get Rose and their son and take them out of Gilead. If he had stayed at the hospital with Rose when the plane blew up, Nick could have made a deal with the Americans: immunity in exchange for working with Mayday. Rose would have had to agree because she didn't have anyone else with her dad dead. He could have gotten them all out and been free. But, then he would have just been a regular guy with a family struggling to survive. He chose comfort and power over freedom and morality. Now, Rose and their baby are in the hands of the Americans anyway and they have no one.
He was involved in overthrow of the US Government. This was made clear in an earlier season. He was an eye and then a commander. He never turned in Commander Waterford for his perverted ways and instead asked for a transfer to the front. He killed a 19 year old brain damaged guardian, he had earlier shot, in cause he recovered enough to identify him. He had numerous opportunities to leave Gilead, but as we heard him tell June, he would have been an Uber driver or delivery person if not for Gilead. Choosing Gilead was his way of elevating himself in life. He made a series of choices that led to his final choice. He made his final choice joining the other commanders going to DC to discuss what actions Gilead would take after the rebellion in Boston. Somethings Nick did we liked, like helping June and providing info on Hannah, but less we forget, he even originally hid his marriage from June. The first choice he made to support Gilead in the overthrow on the US Government, he never said he regretted. June and Hannah and so many others were casualties of that choice.
r/coconutsandtreason • u/Liley91 • Jun 16 '21
Episodes One of the highlights of the episode for me : Lawrenceās face after Fred told him everything he did was to protect his family
r/coconutsandtreason • u/[deleted] • Jun 16 '21
Meme Me gleefully watching Fredās particicution
r/coconutsandtreason • u/Rachelsewsthings • Jun 07 '21
Discussion Handmaids š cannot š become š commander's š wives
For real, are we watching the same show? Where does this "Esther becomes Nick's wife" idea come from? If that was a possibility, why didn't June become Nick's wife? Handmaids are, in Gilead's eyes, unredeemable sinners, tainted women. The only other thing a handmaid can be is a slave in the colonies or dead. Let it go.
r/coconutsandtreason • u/melissliss • Jun 22 '21
Meme Joseph Fiennes is one heck of an actor
r/coconutsandtreason • u/HandmaidHaven • Apr 22 '21
New Spoilers! seen the first eight episodes of s4 as press a few weeks back. ask away!
for legal reasons, canāt say much else about myself. saw episodes in late March as press.
ask your questions, Iāll answer as much as I can.
believe me, or donāt believe me, but Iām not wasting my time proving that Iām legit lol.
why did I do this? cuz weāve been waiting two years for the season and some people just want some damn spoilers...āhandmaids always walk in twos...right?ā...no, I didnāt sign an NDA, but this community has been more family to me than my own, and itās the least I could do š¤·š½āāļø love u guys!
blessed be the spoilers š¤²š»
edited: hereās a rough outline I posted below with more information
e1 - June recovers, bonds with the young wife, itās kinda cute and protects her; Serena and Fred find out about the plane; Aunt Lydia vows to get June and Nick helps Commander Lawrence escape the death penalty; the young wife explains the commander used to have men come in and rape her, one of them finds his way to the farm (drunk) and June encourages her to kill him
e2 - June goes to jezebels to find another safe house and poisons a whole bunch of commanders; on the way back home she notices all the lights are on in the farm, Nick asks where the handmaids are and tells her heās just trying to keep her alive so June surrenders; Serena learns she is pregnant and Fred tells her to go fuck herself (basically)
e3 - june is captured by Gilead; before she goes in, Nick tells her that the wife is okay and that sheāll be too if she tells them where the handmaids are. Lydia interrupts them and June goes through really bad torture...they waterboard her and try to cut of her nail/finger (edited for clarity) so she lied about where the handmaids are hiding... after they realize that, they make her watch a commander push Beth and sienna off a building. Nick goes to Lawrence and asks for some help to get June to talk; thatās when they have that āI canāt move onā talk in his office; Lawrence brings June to a meal, pleads with her to get her to tell them where the other handmaids are and when she doesnāt cooperate shows her Hannah in the box; Hannah is so scared of June and doesnāt remember her, so June tells them where the handmaids are. When they are all captured, June is told theyāre all going to a ābreedingā colony (Juneās words), where theyāll have to participate in a monthly ceremony with commanders (and work the rest of the time). After she gets dressed, she is brought to Nick, they make out and say goodbye. On the way to the colonies they stop at train tracks and the driver has to piss so June and the handmaids tackle aunt Lydia (they donāt beat her or anything) and run to escape. For the first time, Lydia calls her āJuneā and says āDonāt do itā as she moves to hit her with her baton. As theyāre running the driver begins to shoot the handmaids (no one major gets shot tho) and just after June and Janine cross the tracks (mere seconds before the train comes), Brianna and Alma are hit by the train; Janine and June continue to run.
E4 - June/Janine escape to Chicago in a milk train and join some rebel fighters raiding the train; they arenāt sure if itās Mayday but learn it isnāt; Nick asks where June is to the Marthas, though theyāre all still upset about the deaths of the other handmaids; Rita delivers the picture of the baby to Fred (even after Serena mentions she wants nothing to do with him)
e5 - June and Janine train for a bit; when theyāre out, some guards on the street start patrolling so they hide in a store; Lydia (who has been stripped of her duties) goes to Lawrence and basically she has sources/testaments to the Winslowās disappearance, so they work together to try to get power back; at the end of this episode, June and Janine run to catch some guards, and thereās an explosion. at the end, June sees Janine get taken to get treated (but sheās ok) and Moira finds June in the rubble.
E6-Moira convinces June to leave without Hannah; on board a boat, the crew mates contemplate just handing June over if Gileadās water patrol stops them; at one point June tries to head on a boat back to Gilead to ārescue Hannahā but Moira convinces her to remain on the boat bc she really has no plan; when the boat shows up, Moira covers for June, they reach Toronto; she sees Luke and starts apologizing for not bringing Hannah back.
E7 - June adjusts to life in Canada; visits Serena and flips the fuck out on her, telling her she hates her, and sees Nichole again. She tells Luke about the time she saw Hannah at the lake house; She tells Nichole āher daddy, your first daddyā loves her; June and Luke have sex; Serena, lost without June and empty as ever, goes back to Fred
E8 - June testifies at a court proceeding to decide if the Waterfords will face charges; Lawrence confronts Lydia and gets to her admit she objects to Gilead, then tells her Janine has been re-captured and to maybe think about doing something besides hurting her/people in general (like ahem letting her escape)
r/coconutsandtreason • u/joszma • Aug 17 '19
Discussion June didnāt murder Eleanor; she respected her decision
This might be unpopular, but Iāve seen a lot of angry responses to June allowing Eleanor to die in 03x12, with some people going as far to describe it as murder, but I very much disagree with this assessment.
I live with bipolar disorder and know the pain of not living with the medication required to stay healthy when one has a mood disorder. Even properly medicated, living with the condition is fucking exhausting.
Then, added to this is the pain of living in the unrelenting nightmare that is Gilead, and, weāre it me, I would want someone to respect my decision like June did. Itās very likely Eleanor would have unintentionally disrupted the plan and gotten June, herself, Lawrence, and the Marthas executed.
So, in my āexpertā opinion, I think June made the most humane and practical decision she could in such a horrible situation.
Edit: thanks for the thoughtful replies! I should clarify that, in a perfect world, an effort should be made to help someone like Eleanor in that situation, but Gilead is obviously one of the most imperfect worlds one could imagine.
Edit 2: my first silver! Thank you, fellow coconut traitor!
r/coconutsandtreason • u/GingersaurusHex • May 20 '21
Discussion Trauma, and June as an Unreliable Narrator
One of the things I appreciated about the most recent ep was seeing an "outside" POV on June. Primarily, we see the world through her eyes. We hear her inner monologue.
In the last episode, we see June through the eyes of Moira and Luke, and June looks different from that point of view.
We've grown accustomed to thinking of June as a hardened rebel, and savvy political navigator. She's so clever! Executing a plot to get 90 kids out! Leading the Handmaids at the Farm with Mrs. Keys! Working to poison the Commanders at Jezebel's! She is a decisive leader!
In contrast, wen Moira finds her, we find June disoriented, disconnected from reality. Now, obviously, she was slightly concussed. But even outside of that, the June we see through Moira and Luke's eyes is broken, barely hanging on to reality.
I really appreciated this perspective shift, because it shows the cost of June's survival. Over the past few seasons, she's become June Osborne: Action Hero. I appreciated showing her as a only human, through the eyes of those who love her.
r/coconutsandtreason • u/DragonLass-AUS • Jun 11 '21
Discussion This show is not going to have a happy ending.
It honestly drives me crazy, people who are shipping couples or complaining about things that June is doing or complaining about the violent scenes or how June treats Luke even though she's so far into PTSD she will never really come out and whatever else. Not as much on this sub but more on the 'other' sub.
This is a dystopian world, based on one of the most depressing yet brilliant dystopian novels in literature. It's MEANT to make you shocked. The show on the whole is actually a lot less depressing than the book but it still doesn't forget its roots.
There's not going to be a happy ending here. If there was it would be a worse final season than Game of Thrones. Janine probably won't survive. June and Luke won't settle down and raise their children on a farm. I'm sure we'll see some glimpses of hope along the way. But if the show is going to Segue into The Testaments then we already know Aunt Lydia survives, Gilead is still going for quite some time and that if anything, the world of Gilead 15 years later is even more entrenched.
I'm not even sure why I'm ranting here, I just wish some people would spend more energy on enjoying the complexity of the show and less time trying to turn it into a Mills & Boon novel.
r/coconutsandtreason • u/lucypevensy • Jun 02 '21
Discussion I'm with June--why not remain angry with your abuser?
It might be the radicial feminist in me, but anger is good as a woman. It prevents you from being complacent, from accepting, from internalizing misogyny. I really relate to June's anger strongly. What happened to me didn't just occur, it was someone who did that who can be held accountable. my anger for what has happened powers me. It keeps my demands up for others to take responsibility for their mistakes. It makes sure I don't associate with those who don't keep themselves accountable.
I'm interested in know what others think. In my view, Moira's notion of moving on is admirable but not suitable to everyone and I felt it was wrong of her to try and stop June from processing trauma in a way that made her (and Emily) feel better. a bit 'wellness-y'? interested in knowing the opinions of others.
r/coconutsandtreason • u/pancake_gofer • Jun 17 '21
Discussion Tuello does not have feelings for Serena and this is why.
Tuello is an intelligence agent. His job is to find people to turn or people he can work with to undermine Gilead. He is trained in how to use people and he knows how to play on people's desires to get what he wants. That's how intelligence operates, anyway. It's "not personal". As we saw on his whiteboard, it's all about how he can get more information, turn people, and play them against each other. Look how quickly he turned on Fred when it suited the government's purposes.
He's likely spent years trying to find people in Gilead to cultivate. No wonder the US wanted those 22 women back. They're assets that've been cultivated and you need to prove to other operatives that you'll save them. Additionally, Fred was just lying in his several of his interviews and being unhelpfull, meaning Lawrence's comment about Fred's "crisis of faith" may have also not been entirely just a turn of phrase but have several other meanings.
I bet Tuello's read psychological reports on every high-level person he's met. He knows what makes Serena tic: men who seem weak and in awe of her. Serena always enjoyed playing Fred. Tuello plays into that desire, and Serena betrays herself several times to him. Sometimes he trips up and reacts, then quickly switches back to the guy who seems like he wants to get in her pants. We've all seen it. But Serena is too self absorbed to realize this and keeps betraying herself again and again.
Tuello is bummed she's not redeemable and thus can't be an intelligence asset because she's shown she cannot be trusted or coerced. The look he gives her in S4E10 is that of pity and disgust because he's definitely spent years learning about her and trying to turn her, he's gotten her to Canada, and it hasn't worked. It's starting to look obvious he blew it with her, and I think he's experiencing the feelings of years of work all going down the drain.
This also explains why he didn't blow up at June when she went to where he lived. He knows not to betray his feelings too much. He's also probably burnt out and conflicted because he's spent all this time trying to turn Serena against Fred and Gilead so he can make a writer a propaganda tool, but Serena's shown that she's gonna ride that immunity agreement to Hell and back and undermine his cause by embracing the nutjobs.
Look how he seemed to relish turning Fred over. I bet he'll relish the US requisitioning Serena's baby and trading her to Gilead in exchange for more intelligence operatives after he's used her for information and tricked her into outing herself as a Gilead propaganda spreader. Maybe he uses her to infiltrate the Gilead propaganda machine in Canada. Either way she loves the attention and is definitely lining her own grave for when she's outlived her usefulness.
I bet Tuello recruits June to "Mayday". He's totally using her. I bet he knows exactly what happened in the forest--he is CIA after all. Moreover, it was in no man's land/Gilead so there's no legal repercussions in perfect CIA fashion, and there's so many ways June can be willfully pushed towards being in the Resistance. She's also ruthless like Tuello and has useful Gilead connections. She only needs a push. Honestly, I bet Tuello IS "Mayday". It definitely has US government funding.
TL,DR;
Tuello is a pragmatic intelligence agent trying to cultivate assets and use people. He's playing into their own desires to get information and throwing out the trash once he gets what he needs or better. Look how he just discarded Fred and tricked Fred into thinking he was worth more. Notice Serena thinks she's worth a lot to him, too, just like Fred thought. His look in S4E10 was the look of a guy who realized all the years of work cultivating this asset is going down the drain because Serena is a self-serving flip-flopper. Imagine spending a year or more trying to pull something off in your job only for it to blow up in your face. That's his feeling right now.
Tuello's using June, too, and is gonna make her an operative. She's proven her worth as a link to inside Gilead and she is ruthless like him. Moreover, she also has something more: she can't be turned because she's fanatical. I bet Tuello IS Mayday. It's definitely funded by the US government.
r/coconutsandtreason • u/No_Self_5939 • Apr 24 '26
Discussion Is Shaunammite lowkey the most interesting character of the show?
I thought she was a hardcore Gilead fundamentalist but I guess she just wants the best life possible for a woman in Gilead. She doesnāt want to reform the system, she just wants the most power in the system. Everyone in this show is either a cartoon villain or acts like a love sick puppy. You can tell she loves her friends but ultimately wants the best marriage possible.
r/coconutsandtreason • u/VioletandAmelia • Sep 15 '22
Discussion This was more fucking disturbing than seeing Fred's š body
r/coconutsandtreason • u/agirlhasnoname2026 • May 25 '26
Episodes Nick was driving the damn car when the Commanders planned the whole handmaid system.
On that scene I always thought "oh poor Nick, he has to listen to this bullshit". Pretty goggles are so real. He literally listened to how the coup was going to be done! He probably had the most information/leverage of any the "little people".
I'm only now realizing he could've gone to the authorities and prevent the killing of the Congress. Fuck Nick
r/coconutsandtreason • u/GeorgieH26 • Feb 14 '25
Discussion This quote of Offredās seems especially relevant right nowā¦
āNow I'm awake to the world. I was asleep before. That's how we let it happen. When they slaughtered Congress, we didn't wake up. When they blamed terrorists and suspended the constitution, we didn't wake up then, either. Nothing changes instantaneously. In a gradually heating bathtub, you'd be boiled to death before you knew it.ā
Iām not American but from across the pond, this is how 2025 looks over there to me.
r/coconutsandtreason • u/TVorDie • May 14 '25
Discussion Serena's "she's a person speech"
Serena's speech to Wharton when she is presented with a handmaid is, of course, a direct callback to 5.07 ("No Man's Land"). I thought it might be interesting to look at both texts.
Here's how it went in No Man's Land:
Serena: And when she could no longer hide him, she built for him an arc of bulrushes and placed this child therein. Maybe Iām the arc, June. Maybe Iām the vessel. I carried my baby. I delivered him, and I held him. Maybe thatās all that was meant for me in this life. Maybe itās Godās will.
June: Godās will? A vessel. Thatās what you thought I was. What we were, who we were, where we came from, what we wanted, none of that mattered to you. To any of you.
Serena: Iām so sorry.
June: I donāt care that youāre sorry. We mattered. We wereāwe areāpeople. We have lives. And thatās why Iām gonna save yours, Serena. Because this isnāt Gilead, and I am not you.
And here's what Serena said in 6.08:
Wharton: She will help us fulfill our duty to God, to bear fruit and multiply as our sacred vessel.
Serena: Sheās not a vessel; sheās a human being.
I actually (unironically) love this. Serena learned what June had been trying to teach her. She grew. It wouldn't be much for most people, but it's a whole lot for Serena.
r/coconutsandtreason • u/Melairia • Jul 17 '24
MOD POST /r/Coconutsandtreason is BACK!
Hey everyone,
A lot of you probably noticed the subreddit was recently banned due to inactive moderation as we are between seasons right now.
I got a message notifying me the subreddit has been restored! Thank you all for bringing this to my attention.
Praised be, we're back!!
I'll update this post after I get home from work, just wanted to get this out there for anyone wondering what happened š
UPDATE
I want everyone to be aware of Reddit's current policy on subreddit moderation. You should know this information in case you are a moderator of your own subreddits as well.
Here's what happened:
Sometime last month (June 2024), /r/coconutsandtreason was banned due to lack of moderation, I was not notified via PM nor was I notified via modmail.
1 week later, /u/Electronic_Beat3653 created this post on /r/TheHandmaidsTale asking what happened to the sub.
One of the moderators on our team noticed the post and contacted me through our mod chat to get me aware of the situation.
I checked mod log of the subreddit, and there hadn't been any messages or reports in the last 7 months.
I submitted a request at https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/requests/new?ticket_form_id=360001103212 because that seemed to be the answer to my question? It was not. I did not receive any response at any point through this process the last 3 weeks.
I went to /r/redditrequest to look up their process. I messaged the mods first, but only received responses from their bot.
I read the sidebar and submitted a post, but my post was automatically removed because I was the head moderator of the subreddit. One of the other mods of THT offered to submit the post, and they did but it too was removed because it had not yet been 30 days.
I didn't know what to do after that so I messaged the moderators again, and yet again received a message only from their bot, not addressing my questions.
Then I messaged each of their mods individually (do not recommend, please use modmail when you can), and I never heard back from them.
A week later, yes a WEEK LATER! I finally got a PM that the subreddit has been restored. No further information provided. But we're back!
As you can see, there were A LOT of steps involved trying to get the subreddit back.
Here's what I've learned:
Moderators now have an active/inactive status. This status is determined based off moderator activity over the last 90 days. This means mods need to come in to perform mod actions more than once or twice a year, even during off-seasons for a subreddit like ours. EVEN if there are not any reports as well, we have to go in and manually approve approve posts to count as a moderator action.
After a certain period of time, if no mod actions are taken for a subreddit, it will eventually be BANNED (which is what happened here).
If you are the head moderator of a subreddit and it has been banned due to unmoderation, good luck getting it back in a timely manner.
What does this mean for our subreddit going forward?
I'll be updating the mod list, removing mods I have not heard from and adding new ones that have expressed interest in helping to moderate the subreddit
For the mods that are here, we are all going to work hard to get our active status back
We'll probably schedule a re-watch of the series before the new season comes out, maybe we can do 1 season a month?
TL;DR If you're a moderator on any subreddit, make sure you stay active or else it will be a huge pain getting your subreddit unbanned.
r/coconutsandtreason • u/AngelSucked • Aug 14 '19
"I'm Emily... Ofglen..."
I say this all the time, but I'll say it again: I loved Gilmore Girls, but never thought Rory Gilmore would be my favorite actress on THT (in a cast of wonderful actresses).
Her kindness and welcome to Rita, her realization Rita didn't know her real name of Emily, and the subtle distaste of having to say, "Ofglen," but she did it anyway, so Rita would know who she was. And then Rita's happiness and hug, and Emily's hug back. That hug shows Emily has been able to heal some since last we saw here, able to enjoy empathy and physical affection again to an extent. And then Emily introducing Rita and Luke, because she knows how important they may be to one another because of June, and both need a friend.
Bledel knocked it out of the park in one scene.
And Amanda Brugel? Damn! She deserves her own OP.
r/coconutsandtreason • u/chksbjhde763 • Nov 10 '22