r/civilengineering • • Sep 28 '24

Real Life There is a freeway in China that has 50 lanes that merge into 4.

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/civilengineering • • Mar 24 '25

AI doing the job of a Civil Engineer

1 Upvotes

Elon Musk recently was asked about AI and the future. He said there was a 99% chance AI was going to be doing all the work that relied on cognitive effort in the next ten years. He followed up with some mention of universal income but worried what would be the impact on society asking how will people find fulfillment.

Maybe I'm just not dialed in, but as a bridge engineer I can't see a computer taking over my job. Do you see AI being able to put you out of a job?


r/civilengineering • • Feb 09 '23

Regretting

0 Upvotes

I’m making around 90k/year after 7 years of bridge inspection experience with PE on the way in NYC While my cousin who is 10 years younger than me Graduated with computer science degree from an average college is making $250k/year

It’s a shame for me and my 7 year experience that the person who used to look up to me is making almost 3 times that me and he is 2/3 of my age

😑 sad reality of life


r/civilengineering • • Oct 11 '18

Let’s make this a Civil Engineering Sub again

1 Upvotes

I’ll be the first to admit, I creeped these parts 6 years ago (damn that’s crazy to think about) while I was in college. Looking for career advice and salary info because frankly I just didn’t know. In this day and age there is a vast amount of resources for this type of information that supersedes any of the advice for this sort of thing here.

For all the salary questions I’ll make it super simple for those looking. NO ONE here can tell you if you are getting paid fairly except you. The reason I say that is because every employer has a different need and expectation and quite frankly you have the choice to accept an offer or not. If you don’t like it, don’t accept if you do then don’t complain. The information you see on glass door/pay scale, it’s fairly accurate. Can we please move on from this?

As for career advice, I feel it is acceptable to an extent because I think every young professional goes through the same thing after college of “should I be doing this?” That said, more often than not I feel like these type of posts just turn into””should I be making more money” and ultimately this goes back to my first point.

Where are all the topics and discussion around ACTUAL engineering?! This is why I subbed and it’s turning into a bunch of college kids that think they know everything complaining about why they don’t make more money. I’m an engineer because I’m passionate about building our communities I love learning new things and helping others. I didn’t do this because I expected to make shit loads of money; that sort of information about job prospects isn’t hard to find and ultimately doesn’t need to be asked here every day.

Rant over


r/civilengineering • • 20d ago

AI Actually Impressed Me Today

0 Upvotes

I was asked my a permit reviewer to provide sanitary flow and velocity calculations for a site development I’m working to get permitted. It’s about 10 acres of apartments and townhomes, so not even close to needing more than an 8 inch pipe but I get they have to check the box.

As I sit down to pull together this busy work, I figured I would let chatGPT take a stab at pulling together an excel sheet for my site. I fed it the sanitary plan and profiles and told it to check for a template to use from other agencies (the jurisdiction doesn’t have their own spreadsheet) and what I needed to calculate. I told it to populate it with the manhole and pipe names, inverts, slopes, etc and to calculate all the velocity and flow depth parameters based on the design flow that I would enter.

I forgot to tell it that the sewer had two branches that combined at a certain point, but it figured that out on its own. The equations were set to combine those numbers independently at the right spot, and it gave notes about this happening for the reviewer.

The damn sheet was perfect. All the numbers were right. First try.

I felt a little bad contributing to the thing that will make me unemployed someday but damnit this solo engineer on a lump sum contract will take the 2 hours I saved as extra profit.


r/civilengineering • • Mar 11 '26

Real Life Sometimes “What to Do” Matters More Than “How to Do It”

0 Upvotes

Young engineers on site often try to explain to workers exactly how a task should be done. The intention is good, but many workers already have years of practical experience in the same work.

Sometimes over-explaining can create unnecessary confusion, slow down communication, or even make workers feel that their experience is not trusted. In the worst cases, it can affect coordination and delay the work.

A small suggestion for young engineers: clearly communicate what needs to be done and the expected result. When the objective is clear, experienced workers usually execute the work efficiently while engineers focus on quality and supervision.


r/civilengineering • • Jan 27 '22

Why join to complain?

67 Upvotes

I joined this sub because I am interested in civil engineering in general and I enjoy my work as a municipal civil engineer.

If you are not in to it why bother and complain here?

Most of us active here are enjoying what we do. Why would you think we can help you leave?


r/civilengineering • • Apr 05 '25

Career I(44m) strongly feel that Private Residential Development is BOOMING! We as design engineers can set our salary!

2 Upvotes

I am a 44m EIT with almost 20 years experience in the Residential Design and Land Development sector. I love waking up and going to my job. I am extremely proficient and certified in C3D and think it's the best tool for producing construction plans out there. Anyways I design my projects, from Subdivisions, Roadway and Utility Design, Extensive pipe networks, Stormwater management, permitting etc. I draft my project plans and don't have a team of my young engineers helping me. I like it this way, because I have a firm grasp on the submittal time-line, QAQC, budget management, etc. Is this typical of EIT and designers out there?


r/civilengineering • • 3d ago

Question I am quitting this field !

0 Upvotes

As a structural engineer, if this is actually real and not some kind of joke, I'm seriously considering quitting my profession.

Jokes aside, this is genuinely alarming. Structural engineering is not something you can approach with guesswork, shortcuts, or a complete disregard for basic engineering principles. Every structural element has a purpose, and every design decision must be supported by proper calculations, engineering standards, and safety considerations.

If what we're seeing in this video is actually being implemented in a real structure, it could have extremely serious consequences. Depending on the structural configuration and the loads involved, this could compromise the building's structural integrity, potentially leading to severe damage, partial or even total structural failure, and, worst of all, loss of human lives.

Buildings are designed to protect people, not put them at risk. Structural safety is not optional, and engineering mistakes are not always visible until it's too late.

I really hope this is staged or taken out of context, because if it's not, this is beyond concerning.


r/civilengineering • • Mar 15 '24

How long would it take someone of average intelligence and no college education to learn to do your job?

0 Upvotes

r/civilengineering • • Mar 18 '22

Stop using excel

0 Upvotes

Seriously, stop using excel for design calculations, especially ones you submit for review. I get that it's practically free and easy to use, but please, choose a better tool.

We have so many Frankenstein excel calculations here I'm sick of it.

I want to start a movement for structural calculations to use software that has symbolic notation, like Mathcad. It's so much easier and efficient to follow logic. These programs keeps track of unit conversions and they practically scream at you if you make a mistake.

Maybe I'm getting old, but I just cant do it any more. There is an elegance to a Mathcad style calculation. You can actually print it out and read it. Excel is like printing out a black box. You have to open the excel file to do a review, plus its very difficult to track reviews and corrections as part of a QA/QC process. I've seen spreadsheets try to look like a handcalc, why then even bother using excel??

Excel serves a purpose, its great for manipulating large amounts of data or preforming calculations on a large scale (multiple locations or components), but its often far too unwieldy for straightforward structural design applications and it gets out of hand really, really quickly.


r/civilengineering • • Oct 07 '23

Can my kitchen countertop hold this load?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hello to the civil Engg committee . I am setting up a 10 gallon tank on the kitchen countertop in my apartment. My question is , from an engineering POV, will my kitchen top be able to support the load (1/3rd of the tank is in the overhang) . Looks like a granite top with a plywood base. I also have a 5 gallon at the other end of the kitchen top.


r/civilengineering • • Jan 09 '26

Career As the USA becomes more concerning - options to move & work in the EU?

0 Upvotes

As an American-born person of color, due to recent National developments I’m feeling less and less safe in my own country. I never wanted to move before, but I did a study abroad at the University of Amsterdam during my college years that I thoroughly enjoyed.

I am a civil engineer with my BSE and 5 years of work experience out of college, with 5 years of both AutoCAD and Revit experience. I have not yet taken the FE exam, nor the PE exam. I am under 30 but turning 30 this year, so I still have a lot of years to offer a company (or city, if it were public work). I primarily speak English, with only rudimentary understanding of both Spanish & Dutch.

What are the odds anyone in the EU countries would want to hire me? Also, is there any point in doing the FE & PE exams, before moving to an EU country? Or in that case should I just wait, and take whatever test they’d have me take over there?


r/civilengineering • • Nov 04 '19

Why is this community so toxic?

2 Upvotes

It may be inflammatory, but I feel like it needs to be stated. I'm a freshman at a decent engineering college pursuing a degree in Civil Engineering, and I, at one point, looked forward to entering this profession. But now, all I can worry about is whether or not I'll like my job or if I can really handle all the stress involved with deadlines, budgets, and etc in the face of "low" pay. I mean, seriously, why is it that a great deal of the users on this page are pushing people away from a career that they are not personally satisfied in? Furthermore, for those of you who are doomsayers for the CE profession, just leave the field if you're that dissatisfied with your job. It's silly to go onto a prospective CE's post and spread all these concerns and persuade him/her to choose a completely different field just because of a personal vendetta with the field. What is happening to the state of this subreddit, and where all the happy and fulfilled CE's at?


r/civilengineering • • Jun 07 '25

Career WHAT DO I NEED TO DO TO BECOME A TOP WATER RESOURCE ENGINEER?

1 Upvotes

So I want like all the advice I can get from basically the water resource engineers in here stuffs like the challenges you faced, what made you stand out, why you love what you, what it takes to become an OG in this aspect of civil engineering, I really love this field and also planning on getting my MSc in it so I'm trying to prepare myself for it and I feel I'll get the best answers from here because the best civil engineers are here!


r/civilengineering • • May 24 '26

Career How do I enjoy civil engineering?

8 Upvotes

I’m 19, I failed my first semester of civil engineering and now I’m redoing my first year part time. I hated what I did. My parents forced me to go into civil engineering because my dad has a construction management company and I just hate it a lot. My dad constantly says I’m not good at all in civil yet he forced me to pursue the major, I failed design classes in my high school in which we learned how to use AutoCAD, I was just not meant for this

I’m good at math. I got a 86 in Linear algebra, 80 in calc I and 88 in calc II but unfortunately civil engineering has little math which isn’t what I’m happy about. Also the pay isn’t that good. I guess the only parts of civil engineering id be interested in is hydraulics and structural but even then there is no money. I just want to do a lot of math for engineering applications.

My school offers a one year internship after finishing your third year. The average salary for a civil engineering intern is 51k but I feel like that’s if you worked in the public sector. Other engineering majors like electrical, computer, or chemical get paid over 60k and it just bothers me because I feel that ill get ridiculed


r/civilengineering • • Mar 12 '25

Question Honest opinions about veteran owned, minority owned, women owned USA federal contracting preference programs.

2 Upvotes

I support these programs in theory, but I have seen so much questionable work and ethical practices relating to these programs that they need to be overhauled.

I recently worked on a project that was contracted to a veteran owned buisness, only to find out that the veteran owner was the 95yr old step dad of the guy who runs the buisness. I have also seen a "minority" owned buisness that was operated by a guy who had the last name Ortega, but he spoke zero Spanish and had blue eyes. He said he applied to be a minority owned buisness and was accepted with very few questions.

And don't get me started about the quality of work that I've seen from some of these contractors.

We definitely need to overhaul these programs so that they actually help the people who they are intended on helping and not become a fraud scheme like what I have seen. I was hoping that DOGE would investigate these programs and report to congress but they seem more into the slash and burn everything rather than targeted cuts.

Be honest, how many of your have seen fraud or what I call "fraud lite" with these federal contracting preference programs?

Like I said i fully support the theory of these programs but in practice I find the taxpayers are paying more for low quality work. What should be done to reform these programs?


r/civilengineering • • Aug 07 '24

Question CE EIT in Atlanta, underpaid?

1 Upvotes

Just got my performance review and I'm feeling pretty salty. Been in land development for almost 6 years, top engineer in the office with killer Civil 3D skills. I've been killing it, bringing in tons of business, and working insane hours. Went from $88k/year to $92k/year, which is a measly 4% raise. Expected more like 10% given my performance and the fact that I'm basically running the show. Boss hinted at no more money unless I get my PE, which is fair, but still stings. Am I being a greedy jerk or is this bullshit? Any advice?


r/civilengineering • • Mar 13 '26

Wage increase for FE passed?

0 Upvotes

I have not yet passed my fe, but have a full time job. When I started, they started me at a lower wage because I hadn't passed my fe. I was told if I had my fe, I would have started at 68k. I started at 65k.

End of last year we got a pay raise (essentially a cost of living increase), so now I'm at 67k.

If pass my fe, would it be reasonable to expect that 3k increase, or would I bump up to the 68k, or something different?

Assuming I pass the fe in May (doubtful), I will have been at this job for 9 months.

I know this is just speculation, I'm just curious what you guys think.

Edit: Because some are misunderstanding....I applied to the job because it didn't require me having the FE. There was no "I got lucky". I applied to jobs that didn't initially require it.


r/civilengineering • • May 04 '26

5 Acre discrepancy - Earth vs Actual, is this normal or should I get a Survey.

1 Upvotes

I'm actively looking to purchase a house its a 39.5 acre lot on riverfront so I'm not sure if that will affect the measurements. I measured from middle of the river and also the middle of the road on google earth and I'm getting a 4 acre discrepancy, should I get a survey? This is around a $50,000 difference in value. I measured 4 other lots around and they were all +/- .5 acres.


r/civilengineering • • Feb 23 '23

Fix potholes in only minutes!!!

0 Upvotes

r/civilengineering • • Aug 23 '25

Education Is Civil Engineering worth it?

0 Upvotes

I'm 18, and I'm going to start university in 2 days. My major is Civil Engineering. Before I wanted to be an architect, but I heard it’s really not worth it in hindsight. I heard the workload is very heavy, the classes get difficult, the deadlines are harsh, and on top of that, architects are often underpaid—if they even find work to begin with that is.

I LOVE MATH, and I heard Civil Engineering is quite prestigious in the field and generally pays well. So far, all I’ve heard is that it’s in demand, which is good, but I also hear that it’s not the best-paying career considering the amount of work. I’m starting to feel anxious about sticking to this path. Is there anyone who can clarify weather or not i was lied to into choosing the major or give me some guidance?


r/civilengineering • • May 08 '24

Question Who has the right of way?

Post image
0 Upvotes