r/churning • • Jan 08 '20

CSR Significant Changes

https://thepointsguy.com/news/significant-changes-confirmed-for-chases-sapphire-reserve-card/

tl;dr - annual fee increasing from $450 to $550, all card holders will get Lyft Pink access (15% discount on rides and scooter rentals) for 1 year, 10x points on lyft rides, $60 doordash credit for 2 years, doordash pass ($120 value) for 1 year

674 Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

241

u/G1Spectrum Jan 08 '20

So there are zero additional permanent benefits in response to the $100 rate increase. Could've done with an increase to 4x travel/4x dining...

55

u/gregatronn Jan 09 '20

I wonder if they'll wait to see how many people they lose and then maybe up it to 4x travel/4x dining. But then 5/24 will fuck them over because no one could re-apply.

47

u/lisatolliver Jan 09 '20

They're culling the herd.

The AF hike aims to make the heretofore unproftable card more profitable for Chase.

The introduction of DoorDash and Lyft Pink "benefits" are consolation prizes, which drive business to firms Chase has (reportedly) invested in and may increase CSR spend among those for whom those perqs are not 100% breakage.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

72

u/crackthecracker Jan 08 '20

It was fun while it lasted

5

u/valoremz Jan 11 '20

Everyone is saying they’re out. I don’t get how $100 makes people give up the entire Chase ecosystem especially those who do the trifecta with the Unlimited and Freedom. Like what are you all going to switch to instead? AMEX Platinum which is the same cost but isn’t 3x travel/dining and doesn’t have a $300 credit for ALL travel or the Gold which is 4X on dining but has endless stories of certain dining establishments and bars not counting and doesn’t have 1.5x portal redemption? I still think CSR is the best out there.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

555

u/Alcas Jan 08 '20

You son of a bitch, I’m out

15

u/Newchurnerlyfe Jan 09 '20

with all the people leaving maybe they'll let us refer?!?!?!

→ More replies (1)

42

u/Mr_Meeseeks-lookatme Jan 09 '20

Your skills are required for a job.

52

u/Immunoman33 Jan 09 '20

Mr. Meeseeks, change back the annual fee to 450$

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

290

u/rlh1271 Jan 08 '20

Out of all the chase cards I've gotten I will miss this one the most.

120

u/Newchurnerlyfe Jan 09 '20

YOU WERE THE CHOSEN ONE!!!

88

u/bc1280 Jan 09 '20

You were supposed to destroy American Express, not join them. You were supposed to bring balance to the world of churning, not leave it in darkness.

→ More replies (4)

66

u/pwo_addict Jan 08 '20

Same. I’ve kept this for a long time, they’re making that make less sense now.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/eminem30982 MMM, BBQ Jan 09 '20

It really does feel like losing someone close to you.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (2)

170

u/ktfzh64338 PDX, 14/24 Jan 08 '20

Though I'll be sad to cancel my CSR, the only silver lining I can see here is that Chase is giving me a free $60 in doordash before I cancel at my next renewal, and I don't have to pay anything in exchange for it.

19

u/mikep4 4/24 Jan 09 '20

Looks like there's an opportunity to get 2 doordash credits for one AF.

I'll have $550 AF in June, $60 from DD in 2020 and $60 in 2021. Net $550-120 = $430 Lyft pink is worthless as I'm still sitting on Uber visa local cash.

We spend about $60 per year on DD anyway, so I guess this softens the blow of the first year of higher AF while I spend down my UR. You can order pick up with DD.

51

u/ktfzh64338 PDX, 14/24 Jan 09 '20

You get the first 2020 credit as a freebie whether you pay a new AF or not, and then after that you're paying one AF for one additional $60 credit.

The $60 in 2020 shouldn't factor into your renewal calculus.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

80

u/jeogeo Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 09 '20

Q: Will there be any increase to the annual travel credit?

A: We know our cardmembers love the flexibility and ease of the $300 travel credit – and they will continue to enjoy this value.

and they will continue to enjoy this value.

LOL Thank you Catherine Hogan, President of Chase Branded Cards for telling us sheeple how to feel about your card’s value.

30

u/BrewersGuy Jan 09 '20

It's even funnier when it isn't true since it costs $100 more.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/GoBlue2006 Jan 09 '20

I guess we should say thank you they didn’t take something away by charging us more?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

378

u/RedSoxStormTrooper Jan 08 '20

$120 credit is spread amongst 2 years, so $60/year. $60 for a $100 increase is not a benefit, it's a devaluation.

229

u/mjxxyy8 Jan 08 '20

And none of the new benefits are permanent. They all have 1 or 2 yr periods.

136

u/ak3331 Jan 08 '20

If I am going to be reading into this change (and also, to be as generous as possible to Chase here), my guess is that this is how long the contracts are lasting with Lyft and DoorDash. They will probably either re-up those in two years or find new partners that are similar/equivalent in value. I would strongly guess they are not doing these year-long subscriptions and then leaving everyone out in the cold after that with an increased AF.

→ More replies (43)
→ More replies (2)

106

u/t-poke STL, LGB Jan 08 '20

And for those of us who don't regularly use DD, a $60 credit is not worth $60.

I think I'll definitely be downgrading.

27

u/lunker35 Jan 09 '20

Door Dash is my least favorite food delivery service. They bump up prices on restaurants standard prices and the restaurants do not even know it and they take the additional money. Their fees are also ridiculous. A good example I ordered Chinese last weekend. Initially was going to do it on door dash. My normal chicken dish was $15.95 on there. The restaurant has their own online ordering and it was $12.95 which was also $12.95 on Grub Hub. I checked other places and most were more money than the true menu cost. They then added a fairly significant “service charge”. The whole thing is a scam. I’ll just pickup my food.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (53)

10

u/PlaySmart5000 Jan 09 '20

Its $60 in 2020 + $60 in 2021 = $120 My AF will post in March for the increase in $100 I will still benefit $120 in DD credit plus the extra..
For now I will keep my CSR will have to reevaluate March 2021

→ More replies (5)

10

u/TNSepta JFK Jan 08 '20

It seems to suggest calendar year instead of cardmember year, so you should be able to DD this credit for 2020/2021.

14

u/robinthebank Jan 08 '20

They were very clear: $60 in 2020 and $60 in 2021.

→ More replies (21)

59

u/huck_finns Jan 09 '20

Chase, if you're gonna copy Amex, atleast upgrade the metal and design on the card.

37

u/zelegp CVG, SFO Jan 09 '20

Seriously, I miss how the CSP looked. The CSR also got crazy flimsy recently. The plastic also separates from the aluminum.

My Amex gold just feels amazing.

→ More replies (10)

11

u/Reddegeddon Jan 09 '20

I was kind of hoping the Apple Card would start a new card design/material arms race.

13

u/Limewirelord Jan 09 '20

A coworker of mine has the Apple Card and it is a solid fucking card compared to the CSR.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

169

u/Pickleballer23 Jan 08 '20

Between the cardholders who don't understand they have to "activate" the Lyft Pink membership in order to get the 15% discount, and those who forget to cancel their membership after the free year is up, I expect even fewer people will benefit from this feature than the comments suggest.

→ More replies (9)

150

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

They are trying to be like the AMEX Plat... but these new benefits aren’t as good. I wish I could opt out.

106

u/eminem30982 MMM, BBQ Jan 09 '20

I mentioned in yesterday's DD that one of the key differences for Amex Plat is that they add premium lounge access and upper tier status with Hilton and Marriott. Chase needs to add something similar if they want to compete.

33

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

Even Hyatt explorist would help those above 5/24

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (2)

68

u/thekingoftherodeo BOS, MAN Jan 09 '20

I'm not so sure they are trying to do that.

The Platinum has a very distinct target market; business travelers (5x Air Fare, heavy emphasis on lounges and various status with hotels and car rental).

The CSR is moreso geared towards a leisure traveler. Particularly an urban dwelling millennial leisure traveler with the benefits refresh.

→ More replies (28)

40

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Lol, and for the same price no less. Why would I get/keep the CSR when the Plat is the same price? Bad move.

→ More replies (12)

7

u/Agentreddit Jan 08 '20

Why can’t you opt out?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

263

u/ubermorph Jan 08 '20

The biggest benefit here is that people will drop CSR and Priority Pass lounges will get better/less crowded...

135

u/revi4000 Jan 08 '20

Or they’ll get drop CSR and get Amex Plat instead. PP lounges will continue to be crowded, AND Amex Centurion lounges will get more crowded

82

u/culdeus DFW, MAF Jan 09 '20

I mean they can't be in both places at once at least.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/Gwenavere ALB, CDG Jan 09 '20

I think there was already notable market distinction between the Plat and CSR. Plat, even after its rework, is still a benefits-first card. CSR has been a rewards-first card. In many ways CSR's real competitor has always been Amex Gold, and I think the people who were going to move to Amex Gold already have for the most part. What I expect this to do is change many people's calculus on CSP versus CSR in the Chase ecosystem.

→ More replies (9)

34

u/the8bit Jan 08 '20

Even with this change I feel like csr is way better value, with the exception of people who frequently use the amex concierge. Chase perks are so much less hassle to use too (looking at you amex travel reimbursement)

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (6)

46

u/rywe Jan 08 '20

the lounge at my home airport just "lost its contract" with Priority Pass so I don't even get that anymore

20

u/ds2686 Jan 09 '20

Experienced this in Denver with our PP restaurant in October, it sucks.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/cmw021 Jan 09 '20

My hope is enough people drop so they reconsider offering retention offers. Wishful thinking perhaps

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

73

u/mapalm Jan 08 '20 edited Jan 08 '20

Since the new AF won't kick in for existing card holders until April, it seems that for those of us who recently paid an AF, we're good to go for another year. The question of whether or not to PC/cancel won't really have to be answered until our next AF hits. For anyone who doesn't have a CSR, I'd think now is the time to get one.

EDIT: I'm seeing so many people talking about cancelling now. Why on earth would you do that? You have the $450 locked in until your next AF hits. At the very least, use the card while you can.

9

u/nohandsfootball SFO | RDU Jan 08 '20

if you PC/DG, you get a pro-rated AF refund?

9

u/mapalm Jan 08 '20

If you PC/cancel before the year is up, you would get a pro-rated refund on the AF. But why would anyone want to do that?

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (11)

148

u/vany365 Jan 08 '20 edited Jan 08 '20

Here is the Q&A portion to save you a click. What wonderful answers

Question: Why has Chase decided to increase the Sapphire Reserve card annual fee?

Answer: Sapphire Reserve was built for customers who love to experience life through travel and dining – and it continues to deliver just that. Our cardmembers are savvy and we expect they will continue to find this card rewarding for how they live their lives.

Q: Will there be any increase to the annual travel credit?

A: We know our cardmembers love the flexibility and ease of the $300 travel credit – and they will continue to enjoy this value.

Q: Are there any other changes to the earning rates for both Sapphire cards?

A: In addition to the 3x earn with Reserve and 2x earn with [the Chase Sapphire Preferred Card] on a broad definition of travel purchases, Sapphire Reserve cardmembers will now automatically earn 10x total points every time they use their card for a Lyft ride through March 2022 and Sapphire Preferred will earn 5x total points. Ultimate Rewards points have been recognized as some of the most valuable in the industry and Sapphire Reserve points are worth 50% more when redeemed for travel through Ultimate Rewards.

Q: Do Lyft gift card purchases qualify for 10x points as well?

A: Sapphire Reserve cardmembers will earn 10x total points every time they take a Lyft car, as well as when taking Lyft bike or scooter rides. Gift cards are not included at this time.

Q: Will a free membership or Lyft Pink discount be available in 2021?

A: Sapphire Reserve cardmembers can activate their membership in the Lyft app by March 2022 to enjoy a complimentary year of Lyft Pink, currently valued at $239.

Q: Are DoorDash credits broken into monthly installments or will all $60 be available immediately?

A: Starting January 12, Sapphire Reserve cardmembers will automatically earn statement credits of up to $60 in 2020 and $60 in 2021 on DoorDash purchases, no activation required. This is not an installment, these credits will be available immediately.

Q: Will DoorDash credits be applied based on the purchase date or post date?

A: The credits will be awarded when the transaction is posted. This is similar to the Sapphire Reserve annual travel credit.

Q: Will DoorDash credits be issued after the first two years?

A: Cardmembers will be able to enjoy the statement credits through the end of 2021.

Q: Are all DoorDash and Lyft benefits available to existing cardholders?

A: Benefits will be available to existing as well as new customers.

Update 1/8/20: Chase has addressed several more questions, including:

Q: Will customers earn 3x points on DoorDash orders?

A: Yes, customers will earn 3 points per dollar spent on orders placed via DoorDash.

Q: Will there be any change to the fee for authorized users?

A: No, there won’t be any change to the authorized user fee.

Q: Will statement credits apply to Lyft rides outside the U.S.?

A: Lyft credits will only be available for rides within the United States.

Edit: tried to make it more pretty with formatting

173

u/churny_els Jan 08 '20

Travel credit answer in my favorite

211

u/vany365 Jan 08 '20

the first answer is my personal favorite.

why did the fee go up? *ignores the question and says our customers are great.

LMAO

→ More replies (3)

61

u/JunahCg Jan 08 '20

I love it. I know it ain't fooling anyone, but the implication they like a credit of $300 better than a credit of a bigger amount is so fucking cute.

29

u/derek_ow Jan 08 '20

Honestly kind of disgusting

→ More replies (1)

148

u/churnosaurus_rex RAR, RRR Jan 08 '20

Answer: Sapphire Reserve was built for customers who love to experience life through travel and dining

"So here, have some credits to eat at home."

24

u/the8bit Jan 08 '20

Door dash and similar is actually pretty useful at times while traveling. I used it in Tokyo when we wanted to take a breather one night and I use it a lot when business travelling.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

58

u/KaWhyNotTho Jan 08 '20

James Franco asked more ballsy questions to Kim Jong-un in 'The Interview'.

Grow some balls, TPG.

28

u/PerfectNemesis Jan 09 '20

TPG is a shill who kisses ass for lucrative kickbacks from card companies...

19

u/DevChatt Jan 08 '20

The did not answer the first two questions at all , just diverted them

40

u/mistsoalar Jan 08 '20

Q: {{ show_question(i) }}

A: {{ ignore_question(); praise_product(Math.random()) }}

→ More replies (23)

208

u/magomra Jan 08 '20

I'm out.

80

u/thesmash Jan 08 '20

I was going to PC my CSP to a CSR but I think it’s gonna be a hard pass for me with these changes.

21

u/JeromePowellsEarhair Jan 08 '20

I was just considering CSP or CSR, went into Chase last Friday and told them I wanted CSP and the clerk said that was a good choice and I could think about upgrading in the future.

Was already happy with the CSP and probably would have been pretty pissed to have this CSR thing dumped on me two days later.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

62

u/ktfzh64338 PDX, 14/24 Jan 08 '20

I'm hoping enough of you cancel before my August renewal that chase relents and starts offering retention :)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

197

u/scap3y Jan 08 '20

IMO, DoorDash and all such delivery services are absolute garbage. The restaurants increase their prices (often by as much as 30%) to offset the fees charged by the service and then there is the extra fees tacked on for the customer.

I have not used Lyft before (between 2 Platinums, I get by fine with Uber) so can't really comment on how good their Pink service is.

TLDR: with these changes, CSR will become a no-go for many people in this sub.

17

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

I use both DoorDash and Lyft and I'm still thinking about dropping down to a CSP come August (my renewal date). I never used Lyft Pink, but if it's free I'll get it and try it out.

I was already using my CSR less even before these changes because I've been building up MR. I've kept the CSR for the $300 travel credit and non-Amex purchases, but with these changes I'll probably consider downgrading to a CSP.

→ More replies (5)

56

u/ekaceerf Jan 08 '20

That extra fee increases is usually by door dash. The restaurant doesn't get that money.

67

u/gilbyrocks Jan 08 '20

I think they’re saying restaurants increase their menu prices for the app to overcome the fees the restaurant has to pay to use the service.

So customers often pay increased menu prices, plus delivery fees, plus order fees, plus tip.

OR - are you suggesting the delivery service changes the menu prices and pockets the money?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

11

u/AWildSpicyBoii Jan 09 '20

I did GrubHub with my friends, got taco Bell.

My portion was like 20 bucks for something that would be 11 dollars. F that, just order pizza and tip the delivery dude.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Yup. I ordered a single coke with a delivery order, and it was $6. I thought it was a bit high, but maybe a really large cup, or a 2 liter maybe.

Nope. A single can.

23

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Wait up - you ordered a coke to be delivered to you and the total was $6 or you ordered coke and other stuff and just the coke cost $6?

That's crazy. I've seen some ridiculous prices from delivery services before, but I have yet to encounter $6 coke.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/AtOurGates Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 09 '20

An even bigger "fuck you" to rural customers.

Neither DoorDash nor Lyft is available in my home town. I might be able to get some value from the Lyft credits when I travel, if their Pink service is, you know, not awful - but I'm having a hard time imagining using DoorDash on vacation.

I'm looking for reasons to keep this card, and just not finding them.

EDIT: To be fair, the one thing I really like about the CSR is that its Priority Pass card still offers non-lounge dining credits. I know I'm in the minority, but depending on your normal travel patterns, it's definitely possible to get a few hundred $$s worth of value from that alone. Donno if it'd tip the scales for me, but that's the biggest tangable benefit I'd miss if I dropped the CSR and just kept the Amex plat.

EDIT: Said CSP, meant CSR.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/orcinovein Jan 09 '20

CSR provides dashpass which eliminates the delivery fee.

3

u/benjamingolub Jan 09 '20

I took a look at my last 10 or so orders from DoorDash. The prices DoorDash were EXACTLY the same as the prices on the companies menu.

These changes are a win for me. I’m excited.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

50

u/amdinizo Jan 09 '20

This is the world we live in. All of the cards are seeing their anual fee go up $129 is the new $95. $250 is the new $195. And now $550 is the new high tier fee. Amex led and everyone else followed =\

4

u/cld8 Jan 11 '20

CSR used to have an effective annual fee of $150. That was just barely higher than most airline credit cards ($95 or $129 or whatever). It wasn't a premium card for a premium market. They are trying to change that by culling the herd.

48

u/redditgirl1 Jan 08 '20

If we already have the csr and the annual fee renews before April, do we get all the new benefits for the old fee? And then we will start paying the new fee in 2021?

25

u/Lurkolantern Jan 08 '20

I believe so. My CSR renews every Feb, so in Jan 2021 I’ll race to spend the $300 travel credit and $60 door dash credit before pc’ing to a freedom card.

→ More replies (23)

15

u/twarihay Jan 08 '20

It seems so

→ More replies (9)

46

u/k_dubious Jan 08 '20

Welp, I guess it’s time to PC mine and get an Amex Platinum instead. $550 is too much to justify putting up with the shitty Priority Pass lounge selection.

42

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

I have both CSR and Amex Platinum. Keep in mind that AMEX Platinum’s Priority Pass removed restaurants whereas CSR PP still includes them.

22

u/Elasion Jan 09 '20

How do you find the travel credit on the Plat? My only issue with Plat (and Gold) it is that its for "incidentals" and they patched all the routes to just buy airline gift cards.

Really feel like the *new* CSR AF is $250 b/c that $300 Travel Credit is so easy to use, whereas the Plats seems difficult.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/ColCrabs Jan 09 '20

I haven’t really seen it addressed at all but another negative to this is that these benefits are useless outside of North America.

Neither Lyft nor DoorDash operate outside of the US and Canada and even in Canada they’re in limited locations.

→ More replies (7)

89

u/coffeeconcierge Jan 08 '20

I’m gonna be keeping a close eye on my lyft booking prices (with CSR) vs my wife’s (no CSR) to the same destinations at the same time.

I could see lyft algorithmically detecting a CSR payment method and surcharging a typical booking by 15%.

But maybe I should take off my tinfoil hat...

Also curious if those who use both uber and lyft will still be making their booking decisions solely on price alone? I think lyft is relying on people being too lazy to check both and crunch the numbers.

54

u/Y50-70 Jan 08 '20

This has a huge flaw in that if two people put in the same route from the same location, both apps will frequently make the price higher for the 2nd/3rd...etc person to put in the route in a short time.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/JoeTony6 Jan 08 '20

I once noticed pricing differences between a Chase Visa and Citi MC before in one of the ride share apps. Believe the Visa was the significantly cheaper one.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/athrowawayaccountfor Jan 09 '20

Work pays for it regardless for me. Lyft has travel partners in Delta, Hilton, and Jet Blue (I think), so Lyft was always my go to anyway. I'll pocket this difference and happily place that towards the $100 increase.

→ More replies (10)

17

u/tfurgeson23 Jan 08 '20

I’ll be curious to see if the discounted Lyft rides stack with other promotional offers. They’ve been pretty liberal in past year with offering 25-50% off rides sporadically.

19

u/Stockholm_Syndrome Jan 08 '20

With both Uber and Lyft scrambling to achieve profitability now that they are both public companies, I can't imagine that you can rely on that being around for much longer

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Elasion Jan 09 '20

I swear my Sophomore year Lyft gave me 25% off for 2 weeks, but would renew it every 2 weeks so it was just continuous the entire year.Even right now I have 10% off Uber and 25% off Lyft.

They all are only active like Monday - Friday so I think they try and game you so when you go out Friday night and try to get a ride home at 1am its now Saturday and expired.

→ More replies (4)

32

u/BirdToTheWise Jan 08 '20

I was planning on applying for the CSR. Should I do so before the January 12th date to lock in $450 fee for the first year?

18

u/mehertz Jan 08 '20

Yes. I'm advising one of my friends to do the same

→ More replies (2)

32

u/natran1 Jan 08 '20

Not worth it and not renewing.

45

u/jasonf_00 Jan 08 '20

Well this sucks. DoorDash and Lyft aren’t even offered in my area (not that I have need for either one) and the only place I’d use Lyft is out of the U.S. which apparently isn’t covered.

I’ll probably cash in my accrued points and jump ship elsewhere :(

11

u/william_fontaine Jan 08 '20

That's what I wasn't sure of - do the UR points need to be spent before canceling the card, otherwise you lose them?

26

u/Gwenavere ALB, CDG Jan 08 '20 edited Jan 08 '20

Yes. You need to have an active UR-earning credit card to keep a UR point balance. This would be the Freedom, Freedom Unlimited (note that these cannot transfer UR points to travel partners), any flavor of Sapphire, or Ink on the business side. If you just want to keep your UR point balance for potential future use, just downgrade the CSR to a Freedom, Freedom Unlimited, or the base no annual fee Sapphire card until you open another premium UR earning card in the future.

→ More replies (9)

100

u/ak3331 Jan 08 '20 edited Jan 08 '20

Honestly one of the wackiest parts of this whole thing is that the CSP is gaining a pretty large benefit (2 years of DashPass - valued @ $120 a year) for no AF increase. So I guess a straight upgrade, and a good thing to consider for those who are considering downgrading from CSR if the Lyft Pink/Credits aren't your thing.

Edit: as /u/dannydealguru notes, you will also get 5x UR points on Lyft rides (along with a lot of the Freedom/Ink lines), which isn't as great as 10x as CSR, but still an upgrade for no change in AF.

10

u/dannydealguru Jan 08 '20

and 5X on Lyft rides, along with Freedom and Ink cards.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[deleted]

29

u/KateMonster11 Jan 08 '20

Don't value them very high, the "savings" of $5/order is really more like "only paying $5 more than takeout" so if you don't use it already it will still be cheaper to go get the food yourself.

10

u/Citizen51 Jan 08 '20

The Dash Pass doesn't even kick in until $12 worth of food in an order. That's a lot when you're ordering from almost exclusively fast food restaurants.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

108

u/CarlFriedrichGauss Jan 08 '20

Awesome, can't wait to not use the Doordash and Lyft credits because those are not two services I ever use!

→ More replies (1)

27

u/andrewmine Jan 08 '20

Is it just me or has this change/timing aligned with the time people who got CSR when it came out were getting ready to cancel/downgrade and apply again. This all seems to have been planned well ahead

16

u/nohandsfootball SFO | RDU Jan 08 '20

CSR dropped in like... July/August? This timing definitely benefits those who signed up six months after launch more than those who signed up right at launch.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

[deleted]

7

u/churningpanda Jan 09 '20

And in-branch 100k offer ended on 3/11, AF charged on 4/1.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/caxplrr Jan 09 '20

Sounds like a free $60 in DoorDash credits this month before I downgrade in a few weeks! Wonder if we’ll keep the Lyft Pink post-downgrade as well.

I sometimes wonder if everyone else just spends a ton more on food delivery and ride share than i do, I’m way far off from breaking even on the fee increase based on current spend.

6

u/BrewersGuy Jan 09 '20

Yeah so this is a dumbass question but I think I've used doordash once. Does "door dash credit" actually mean free food or is it $60 toward some fee specifically just for their service, and not the food? Like I said I don't use it but if it's free food I might as well.

8

u/caxplrr Jan 09 '20

I had assumed free food since they're throwing in dashpass (free delivery). I'm planning to burn the $60 on food pickup personally, so worst case I'll find out next week. Hopefully Chase does release the T&Cs soon, as that'll have everything in it

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/pratnala Jan 09 '20

Time to look at the US Bank Altitude

5

u/p00pey EWR, JFK Jan 09 '20

have it, love it. Especially when I'm traveling overseas which is quit often. EVERYONE, including restaurants, take apple pay. 4.5% FTW...

→ More replies (6)

22

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

I was going to upgrade my CSP to CSR this year but this easily makes that a no-go.

I live in a major city but still don't use ride sharing much. If it was straight up credits, like the Uber credits on Platinum, that'd be WAY better for my use vs. a 1 year membership for a service that get's 15% off rides.

Same w/ Door Dash, at least the Gold gets you a full $120 a year, not just $60.

For those who'd use the Lyft service, and bank on the points, this is OK I guess. And good for them. But I feel the card really lost it's universal appeal, which sucks. It's really narrowed itself down to a specific audience.

3

u/gregatronn Jan 09 '20

I live in a major city but still don't use ride sharing much. If it was straight up credits, like the Uber credits on Platinum, that'd be WAY better for my use vs. a 1 year membership for a service that get's 15% off rides.

You now get a total of 10x UR (+7 using lyft) combined with the 15%.

Same w/ Door Dash, at least the Gold gets you a full $120 a year, not just $60.

You can do the $60 in two purchases along with getting the free delivery.

With Gold you get $10/month so you are always spending more just to get the credit. With the Platinum (I have this and a CSR), the Uber credit is $15 a month (35 in December) for the full $200.

I prefer Chase's way. I use the $300 travel waiver in the first two months of the years. With Uber, I need to ride (eats is too expensive) at least once or twice. And in Dec since it's $35, def need to use it more than twice on an average ride.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

22

u/mistsoalar Jan 09 '20

I was hoping full Visa Infinite features come to CSR. Especially flight discounts for companions.

But I realized that I don't have a companion and downgraded CSR back in 2018.

31

u/count-mein Jan 09 '20

Have not see anyone mention this critical point.

Delivered food is not good. It is warm at best, hamburger buns and fries are soggy from steam, and cheese which is supposed to be melted un-melts.

It is more money for worse tasting, generally unhealthy food.

38

u/Happyxix Jan 09 '20

See you are getting burgers. Get delivery Chinese food, Indian food (none of the fried stuff), Ethiopian food, etc and it is absolutely fine.

Basically for Western food my rule of thumb is: if it is not pizza, don't get it delivered.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/BetaState Jan 09 '20

I checked out the Doordash website yesterday and it looks like most restaurants also have an option for pickup as well. I'm hoping to just use the credit to go out to eat once or twice for free by using the "pickup" option and just dining in.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/_neminem Jan 09 '20

Way worse for the environment, too. That was one thing I hadn't considered, until I saw it pointed out elsewhere - they're encouraging/basically forcing millions of people who might otherwise not have, to landfill tons of plastic to get this benefit (which they didn't ask for) out of the card.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/wiivile JFK, EWR Jan 08 '20

between 15% off lyft rides and 10x points, what is the math that works out to regarding overall discount?

fwiw, i've never used lyft. do they have similar market presence to uber? including international?

if doordash pass is anything like postmates pass, i'm not impressed... you can get free delivery using tons of easily accessible coupon codes, then they sneak in 'service fees'.

22

u/scap3y Jan 08 '20

do they have similar market presence to uber?

In short, no: https://www.lyft.com/rider/cities

including international?

Only other country where Lyft is available is Canada.

16

u/wiivile JFK, EWR Jan 08 '20

haha, that sucks. i thought the CSR was supposed to appeal to international travelers? the only time i use Uber is when i'm in an international unfamiliar city where i don't speak the language...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/tfurgeson23 Jan 08 '20

I’m not a fan of DoorDash. Maybe I’m naive and all other courier platforms do this as well, but often doordash menu price is greater than calling directly to allow stores to recoup the fee which doordash keeps on every order.

14

u/t-poke STL, LGB Jan 08 '20

They all do it, which is why a $10 credit isn't actually worth $10 if you're paying inflated prices on the app.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/nohandsfootball SFO | RDU Jan 09 '20

DoorDash also got caught stealing the tips from its delivery people. Another shitty tech company being subsidized by VC that will struggle to turn a profit post-IPO

27

u/franch Jan 08 '20

far weaker than uber internationally, as in.... it doesn't exist.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/GoBlue2006 Jan 08 '20

I think it’s $150 in Lyft rides

My math is Net fee increase of 40 (I’ll count the door dash 60) $150 of Lyft would result in a 15% discount of of $22.50 for a new ride total of 127.50. On that you earn 1275 UR which at 1.5cpp is about $19.12

Edit - for the full $100 increase it would be 375 in pre discounted Lyft rides using same steps above

16

u/deltahedge0 PHL, 8/24 Jan 09 '20

Really you’d want to look at the incremental benefit, or 7X UR. If you value UR points at $0.015/pt and are looking for break even for the increase excluding the other benefits, you’d need to take ~$418 worth of prebenefit rides.

418 x .15 = $62.7 of cost saves

418 x .85 = $355.3 of costs incurred

7 incremental UR x $0.015 value on portal = $0.105 UR value earned/dollar spent at Uber

355.3 costs x $0.105 = ~$37.3 UR value earned

$62.7 cost saves + $37.3 UR value earned = $100

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

45

u/SpecialGuestDJ Jan 08 '20

Reading the room here and from yesterday's discussion, I find it hard to believe that Chase has missed this much on market expectations. I believe they have some ulterior motives here:

  1. Promote DoorDash as a vested interested moving into IPO

  2. Promote Lyft with a bonused increase because this is pennies on the dollar - the average lift ride is $13 in the US, which is the only place that the bonus applies.

  3. Push card holders to cancel/PC to decrease the 300$ travel credit liability

39

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

market expectations

You think the churning sub’s DD thread is representative of their target market?

34

u/nohandsfootball SFO | RDU Jan 09 '20

I think there's something to the idea that if this sub has trouble justifying the increased AF, that the average consumer will have even more trouble justifying it.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/SpecialGuestDJ Jan 09 '20

/u/nohandsfootball did a great job clarifying my sentiment. The comments on TPG and DOC also express the same. Some DOC commenters are stating the a BofA cashback card is a better value now (which is laughable).

→ More replies (7)

18

u/Latito17 SEA, 11/24 Jan 09 '20

I'd like to go against the grain here and say that while this isn't welcome news, I'm still keeping the card. If you redeem 62k points through portal it's worth it over CSP / INK. Obviously that doesn't apply to everyone, but for those who do it would be dumb to move on.

You still get primary rental car insurance. Still get pretty good trip delay / cancel / interrupt insurance. Still get PP with restaurants. Can those be found elsewhere, of course - but in totality it's still a keeper for me. Just not as good as before. The Lyft and DD stuff is... Lacking. I'm curious what the arrangement is with those companies because I'd certainly prefer an extra $100 travel credit.

I'll pay my next AF in Aug and evaluate the situation in summer 2021.

→ More replies (13)

16

u/JackedAF Jan 09 '20

CSR is my daily driver for most things, especially dining. $150 AF for trip delay insurance, travel insurance, car rental insurance, and roadside assistance was great.

Amex cards dont provide me with too much value since they arent accepted in most places i go, and i only travel about once a year, not enough to justify amex plat.

Gonna be tough finding a replacement

4

u/SolomonGrumpy Jan 09 '20

CSP offers a lesser version of the travel Bennie's and I think has primary rental car coverage. That's my move.

→ More replies (7)

15

u/iletired Jan 08 '20

As pointless and worthless some of these changes are, we can at least be thankful the Doordash is $60 flat a year, rather than $5 a month or $30 biannually. Not great, but at least there is more time to spread it out, or spend it all before PCing. Not that I really like these changes though.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/mikep4 4/24 Jan 09 '20

If anyone is new to lyft, link your Lyft acct to Delta/Hilton for those points in addition to CSR 10x.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/itsmychurn DRY, FLY Jan 08 '20

So, $625 with an AU?

49

u/lenin1991 HOT, DOG Jan 08 '20

I'll answer using Chase-speak from the rep quoted in the article:

We know our cardmembers love the benefits that authorized users receive – and they will continue to enjoy this value.

12

u/trickedx5 Jan 08 '20

Shit. I’m CSR committed for life. I have 1.3 million points and no sign of slow down even after multiple vacations this year.

3

u/Alqotastic JFK, DOG Jan 08 '20

Why CSR and not just Chase? If these benefits suck for you (they do for me), just use a CSP or CIP. They’re v similar. I’m assuming you transfer points instead of use the portal at 1.5. If you do use the portal, do the math on increased fee vs. 1.25 redemption w CIP.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

6

u/wiivile JFK, EWR Jan 08 '20

i PC'd on 1/1, i guess i should consider myself lucky. i don't see how they can charge me a $550 fee for at least a year, even if the AF hits after 4/1 (it usually takes a few months for the fee to hit after a PC due to laws about allowing you time to reject the terms of the new card)

→ More replies (13)

6

u/zelegp CVG, SFO Jan 08 '20

What a bummer. I never use Lyft. Never use door dash. These aren’t very useful to me.

My AF hits 2/1 so I guess I have that going for me.

Here I was thinking that MAYBE an increase to $550 might increase travel or dining earn to 4x or maybe toss a grocery bonus in there.

6

u/joe-movie SLC Jan 09 '20

I do believe that the value for new applications and an upgrade to the CSR for one year is still worth it for those considering it. While no longer as lucrative, you'll still come out ahead, assuming you use the travel credit twice for a single AF. Keeping it longer...well, lots of analysis in here already on that.

6

u/UrbanEngineer 1/24 Jan 09 '20

While Amex had Triple dip season before, now the CSR may be a target card to open in late December too, if these credits reset on the calendar year. Before it was all Card year with the CSR. Now there are ideal opening times.

28

u/thesmash Jan 08 '20

The logic behind adding Lyft/Doordash stinks of people in a big city like NYC where Chase’s HQ is located. I use Lyfts and DoorDash occasionally but it’s hardly a part of my regular life to value these memberships and credits. But what do I know, I’m just a plain old Midwesterner.

42

u/nohandsfootball SFO | RDU Jan 08 '20

someone yesterday pointed out that JP Morgan is apparently part of the DoorDash IPO team, soooo.... there's that.

29

u/crackthecracker Jan 08 '20

I hope they get burned on both ends of the deal then

10

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

I live in a big city and still don't think those benefits are worth it for me.

The thing is, they just cut out their universal appeal and that sucks.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/hbkmog Jan 08 '20

Big city in mid west or south? yes.

But big city like NYC where public transportation is faster and more convenient and food is available within walk distance? Not really.

It only targets people with certain life style.

7

u/rockinghigh Jan 09 '20

If you can afford CSR you probably use Uber/Lyft occasionally. They do millions of rides every week in NYC.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/hythloth Jan 08 '20

Welp, guess i'm not PC'ing from the CSP to the CSR this summer... may even ditch the CSP all together

17

u/Bubba_Junior Jan 08 '20

Still could be worth it if you have alot of UR to use up for the 1.5X

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/earthisdoomed Jan 08 '20

Definitely a devaluation. Wonder if they will offer an increased SUB to go with the relaunch.

5

u/Amex_Fangirl Jan 08 '20

Will statement credits apply to Lyft rides outside the U.S.

What is this Lyft statement credit TPG was talking about in the Q&A section? I only saw Lyft Pink membership and 10x points in Lyft website.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/littyboy Jan 08 '20

So essentially come 2021, you’re paying $100 more to have the opportunity to get 10 pts per $ spent on lyft rides. This is how I’m reading it? Which sucks ass

8

u/ktfzh64338 PDX, 14/24 Jan 08 '20

Even the 10x sunsets in March 2022.

7

u/littyboy Jan 09 '20

Damn they did us dirty on this card.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Quirlie Jan 08 '20

I would've been fine with the rumored dine-in credit instead of this...

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Aldoogie Jan 09 '20

....google searches for “WTF is LyftPink?”

14

u/Hungry_Radio Jan 08 '20

To bring some positivity to this thread (not that the people who can't use the new benefits are wrong to be bummed) this looks like an upgrade to me.

I use Doordash so the credit is no issue, and I'd happily pay $40 for a year's worth of Dashpass and Lyft Pink. Priority pickup at the airport could potentially be really sweet.

18

u/churnosaurus_rex RAR, RRR Jan 08 '20

I use Doordash

Why?

20

u/Hungry_Radio Jan 09 '20

Because I don't want to go pick up the food I'm ordering.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/SecurityFailure Jan 08 '20

As one who is going stop using Uber Visa, I thought of getting this as I travel 2-3x year (international and domestic).

Would this still even be worth it or are there other options that outweigh this new plan?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/kzaow Jan 08 '20

My CSP anniversary is up today and I tried calling to upgrade to the CSR before the 12th. They only allow you to upgrade after the 12th. RIP

7

u/fuzzyblanket1995 Jan 09 '20

Really not happy about these new "benefits." As someone who has literally never used Lyft or Doordash, this won't benefit me at all. If they had to increase the fee, I wish they would have upped the travel credit from $300 to $400 or something else that's more closely related to travel since this card is primarily for travel.

7

u/dasarp Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 11 '20

Really sucks, but if you spend more than $13k per year on Travel + Dining (airfare, hotels, cars/ride share, restaurants), this card is probably still worth it. That’s not accounting for benefits like Priority Pass and Door Dash credit.

I’m assuming that if you don’t have this card you can still get 2.5% on travel & dining with low or no fee cards (eg leveraging BofA Preferred Rewards or just CSP). CSR effectively gives you 4.5% back on travel/dining (3x points, all redeemable at 1.5x), so ~2% better than low/no-fee alternatives.

Annual fee is effectively $250 now ($550-$300 annual travel credit). That puts the break even travel/dining expense at $12.5k annual spending. If you value the Priority Pass, Door Dash credit, etc; or assume that your alternate travel/dining card also has some annual fee (eg. $95 for CSP), the required annual travel/dining expense to come out ahead goes down.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/a300zx4pak Jan 09 '20

I find it hilarious that thousands of churners are upset about this. Most of us have probably used Chase for tens of thousands of dollars of free travel. A $100 increase with those added benefits isn't the end of the world, although YMMV of course. Personally, I'm keeping the card for now.

P.S. My Doordash pass is good until the end of 2021, essentially 2 years.

9

u/relxp Jan 09 '20

I can understand Chase wants to make CSR more profitable, but I think Lyft/DoorDash are too niche to bump the AF another $100. I feel like the changes would be more balanced if they increased the travel credit to even $325 and increased 3X to 4X. I suspect they would still be doing really well.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

Say it louder for those in the back

6

u/terranwolf Jan 08 '20

I feel like this should have been set up for a separate card altogether. Getting something out of the Lyft and Doordash benefits will be difficult if you don’t live in an urban enough area.

6

u/Citizen51 Jan 08 '20

Dash Pass really sucks because you have to order $12 worth of food to get the discount and that can be hard to do with the mostly fast food options on Door Dash. Further the discount only applies to certain restaurants (granted this list is pretty long). Also if the driver sucks and takes super long (my most recent order took an extra hour longer than promised) you have no recourse, can't change your tip or get any acknowledgement from customer service that there was a problem.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/BigSexyTolo Jan 09 '20

I was hoping for a more honest report from Tye Points Guy. Unfortunately Chase is a sponsor or something like that, so I doubt they’ll report exactly how they feel

6

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

This isn't an upgrade at all, it's a straight downgrade.

6

u/SwindlerSam Jan 09 '20

what's the move now for primary travel/dining card? CSR was my daily driver..

→ More replies (2)

3

u/mikep4 4/24 Jan 13 '20

CSR annual fee is still $450 on the chase.com site if anyone wants to go for it. Take a screen shot of the offer.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

Fuck that, I'm out. Adding perks I will never use to justify raising prices is a deal breaker. It's like Amazon raising the cost of prime because they have a shitty video service I don't use.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Darhol Jan 09 '20

As an expat churner, this is disappointing since it's impossible to get value out of these other "benefits," similar to the Uber credits on the Amex plat

PP has been great in the international airports and I relied on this for primary car rental insurance so I'll have to look at an alternative for that membership. Just paid my AF in December, so hopefully there'll be some positive changes or a new product before my AF hits again

6

u/triplebe4m Jan 09 '20

I own a car and I cook my own food. Guess I'm cancelling.

6

u/ftm2000 Jan 09 '20

CSR is supposed to be a “travel card”. WTF doordash has to do with travel? It kind of makes sense on the Amex Gold but not CSR. And we have to pay higher AF for this AWESOME benefit!

4

u/datboy_lk Jan 08 '20

One day I’m going learn to stop procrastinating. Should’ve PC when I had the chance .

4

u/henh2o Jan 08 '20

Time to either transfer all my points into Hyatt or cash out of UR. CSR is dead

4

u/Alexhasskills Jan 08 '20

One more year at the current, price.....out after that.

4

u/007meow Jan 09 '20

CSR looks like it’s about to get replaced by CIP + CIC for me.

4

u/IAmTooLateToTheParty Jan 09 '20

I just got a mailer from Amex Plat with the 100k offer - time to say bye from my P2 and possibly change my plans for 5/24 with lot more Cheese Italian Pizza sprinkled in.

4

u/Imallvol7 Jan 09 '20

I'm really confused now. Its effectively $250 a year now. I use the freedom , freedom unlimited and reserve combo for everything. Is there something better? I dont care about lounges and spend about $1000 a month dining out and try to max out 5% categories on freedom?

4

u/JoeyJoeJoeShabadooSr Jan 13 '20

I live in NYC. I also use Citibike fairly frequently, and have an annual membership. This is actually huge for me. That Lyft Pink thing also includes free Citibike rentals for a year. It's $170 through the Citibike app, only $100 here.

I'm a pretty niche user, but I'm psyched for this!

EDIT: It's only 3 free rides per month. I am significantly less excited than I was a minute ago.

6

u/BrandedBro Jan 08 '20

Where on my Chase account (website or app) can I check when my renewal date is? Would like to avoid the $100 increase fee for this year...

13

u/maveryc Jan 08 '20

I searched my CSR transactions for the word “fee.” It keeps 24 months of history, so you should be able to see 2 charges.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/TwelveBall Jan 09 '20

I blame TPG.

2

u/Biged123z DCA, IAD Jan 15 '20

If you spend more than $420 on lyft a year this change is actually really worth it And honestly $420 is less than $10 a month. I calculated I would get $280 value from this change.

You get about 24% off what you would normally get pay before the CSR change because of the 15% and the 10x points (+7! From base) I calculated this by 15% + 9%. The 7 points at 1.5cpp gives 10.5% off the 85% you pay, so about 9% (exactly 8.925%). So 420*.24=$100.80

In 2019, I spent about $1700 on lyft. I live in a dense city and am car free so I use lyft a lot, especially when I go out. I also travel once a month or so for work and pay using my cards and get reimbursed later.

I would estimate half of that is personal rides. The lyft pink and 7 additional points will gain me about $280 (i didn’t count the 15% discount on my biz rides) I calculated by 1700*.08925 (value of points after discount) + 850*.15 (savings on personal rides) = $279.225

2

u/twi5t3d SJC, SFO Jan 17 '20

If anyone is able to get a retention offer, please post or PM me, thanks!

2

u/Shmokesshweed Jan 17 '20

"Here's all the shit new perks. Btw, pay us $100 more next year."

Hahaha like hell I'm keeping this card.

2

u/kharn4ge Jan 18 '20

My renewal is August 2020 so I'll be charged the $550 this year...

My plan is to:

- pre-book as much of my flights with my UR points

- use up all the $60 doordash credit

- and then downgrade to CSP before the renewal hits

Anyone else doing something similar?

→ More replies (5)

2

u/ski_m73 Jan 21 '20

Just did an analysis two weeks ago on my spending over the last two years and decided that I was going to upgrade my CSP to CSR. Called Chase this morning and she said the fee is now $550. I don't know how I missed this. May still be worth it considering all of the travel I have planned for the year, but its too close to call. Going to hold off...bummer...

2

u/Orome2 Jan 24 '20

I know this is a couple weeks old, but I just saw the thread. As someone that travels frequently for work and uses CSR to book travel plans, these changes sadden me. Is there a good alternative for the frequent traveler (not necessarily churning then downgrading)?

Plus priority pass was a perk that I used frequently, but in the airport where I have most layovers in (Denver) Timberline just ended their partnership with priority pass meaning there are no clubs in Denver.