r/churning • u/ubersuer • Aug 02 '14
Please stop misusing the term "churning"...
I casually read this subreddit, and I consistently see people in here referring to signing up for credit cards to get a signup bonus as "churning". This is not churning. It's just signing up for credit cards. Churning is specifically signing up for the same credit card over and over and repeatedly getting the bonus. This is distinct from just signing up for a credit card, an app-o-rama, etc.
The reason this is important is the new people to this game are getting different definitions than the experienced ones. When these new people eventually move to Flyertalk or similar sites, as I see many of them do, they're speaking a different language, which causes confusion and frustration to both sides.
14
u/mackstann Aug 02 '14
Unfortunately, the name of this subreddit reinforces this misnomer. Due to that, it's going to be tough to combat.
5
u/doktaj Aug 02 '14
It used to only be only about churning, but it has changed into a credit card rewards subreddit.
4
u/Ghostofazombie Aug 02 '14
It's probably unstoppable as long as /r/personalfinance is still a default sub. In some ways that's probably good, for instance now we can just talk about credit cards without having to make the same points over and over again to correct the /r/frugal cultists who are also on PF.
2
u/doktaj Aug 02 '14
I don't have a problem with being the "rewards" sub as well as churning, it just means I only have one sub to follow. But I do agree that there is often a decent but of miscommunication because of people using vocab incorrectly.
1
19
4
u/wallTHING Aug 02 '14 edited Aug 02 '14
No way around it. Yes, I do believe people should corrected in the terms they use because they'll just sound like an ass. However, I have seen multiple posts on this sub over the last year or so asking about making an MS sub and it gets stomped out. I know just an MS sub wouldn't solve the problem being talked about here, but it seems a lot of people want this sub cleaned up and used mostly for discussion of just churning. Only issue with that is this sub would almost die because of that. It is pretty established which cards are churnable and that doesn't change very often. This sub would be filled with "here's how I cancelled and resigned to receive xxxxx for the 4th time" posts; not a lot of substance there.
With MS being the ongoing struggle people have, having those posts in here is beneficial for everyone. Its a place where people can check without spending the hours sifting through FT (which I recommend everyone should do at least once anyway). And an AoR in technically unrelated to churning in the fact that you can do an AoR and never churn any of those cards, but its in the wiki.
Tl;dr yes people should be corrected in their terminology, but this sub has become more than just churning and, since an MS sub would just about kill this one, I'm fine with the way it is.
Edi: And just for clarification, I understand that just signing up for credit cards desn't fall under the MS category either and would potentially be better suited for /r/personalfinance. However in some of these threads about just signing up for credit cards we end up with some pretty good conversation.
4
u/screwthat4u Aug 02 '14
The problem is that there are few if any churnable credit cards nowadays. You must wait for months if not years between getting the same card in some cases
5
u/shinypenny01 Aug 02 '14
US, Alaska, Hhonors (Citi), AA (some) are all churnable within a year.
1
u/MrDannyOcean Aug 03 '14
Which US Air card is specifically churnable? Is that the one that's something like 40K with an 89 dollar annual fee? (going off memory here, might be slightly different)
2
u/shinypenny01 Aug 03 '14
Yes, that is the card. You can occasionally get it for 30k miles with waived AF, or very rarely 50k miles.
Copied from flyertalk card wiki:
"The general consensus is that you wait 6 months between applications with calling for recon significantly reducing your chances (better to get instant approval). YMMV"
Also, you don't need to close the first card to get the second in all cases.
1
7
u/LumpyLump76 Unknown Aug 02 '14
At some point this weekend, someone new will come to this sub, and ask what is a good card to churn. It will happen again in another couple of days, then again.
Very few of them will have read this post on the original meaning of credit card churning. Nor would they read the wiki with the definition in it.
So my advice is to not get too attached to the meaning, as it will drive you nuts.
3
1
u/workaccountoftoday Aug 04 '14
Well when a bunch of groupies privatize the manufactured spending subreddit we don't have many other places to go!
The communities are similar enough that we may as well all be in the same place without having to go to /r/thingsthatinvolveunusualusesofcreditcards
1
u/sexy_kitten7 PWM Aug 02 '14
I agree 100%. Vocabulary is very important (in life) and also when discussing financial products.
Please remind everyone that buying gift cards is not churning! It is MS.
8
Aug 02 '14
The term churning was coined on the FWF forum for ms purposes long before it become commonly used for the signup bonus game.
Me and my colleagues all use it when referring to MS or general money making tomfoolery.
Language is fluid and varied, it silly to insist a word only means one thing.
-1
u/sexy_kitten7 PWM Aug 02 '14
Hmm. I wasn't aware of that!
I'm a fan of prescriptive language (AKA a grammar Nazi). So technically, "churning" should henceforth be synonymous with MS. But it would be hard to convince the rest of the Internet...
2
Aug 02 '14
I don't think many serious churners/msers really bother much with arguing semantics.
0
u/sexy_kitten7 PWM Aug 02 '14
What? But you and I are serious churners. And the demographics are heavily male/geek/nerd skewed :/
Anyways, I will keep your FWF revelation in mind the next time i see someone (mis)use the term "churning!"
0
Aug 02 '14
[deleted]
4
u/Ilikewordsgood Aug 02 '14
I'm going to have to agree with /u/doktaj here. Amex cards are now considered "unchurnable" solely because the sign up bonus can only be received once in a lifetime, while Citi cards are very churnable because the bonus can be received multiple times. The entire "churn" part of the term is repeating the process.
Now, a lot of the strategies behind hoarding sign up bonuses and churning are the same, so I think all those posts are relevant in this subreddit, but the vocabulary is most definitely different. There is nothing pedantic about wanting to make sure old and new visitors of this sub are all on the same page regarding the terminology.
3
9
u/doktaj Aug 02 '14
No, that is the exact definition.
0
Aug 02 '14
[deleted]
9
u/doktaj Aug 02 '14
This wiki didn't make up the term churning. This is how the mods defined it to make it more open to others. If you are involved in other forums, churning is very specificity what OP said.
If you want examples, read the wiki in these FT threads and see how when they talk about "churning" a card it is referring to opening multiple cards and how to space them out:
And here are some other articles that use the term churning as the OP refers to it:
http://blog.credit.com/2014/03/what-is-credit-card-churning-78373/
0
Aug 02 '14
[deleted]
2
u/doktaj Aug 02 '14
It's a matter of communication. We aren't telling people to go somewhere else. We are just asking that they use the correct terms. If someone says "I want to churn a chase UA card" it means something completely different if what they meant was "I want to sign up for the bonus."
I think you are taking OPs comment too personal.
1
u/FreekForAll Aug 02 '14
There's a bigger world outside of reddit and, you might not like it, reddit has to adapt to it sometimes. Not the other way around. Its for the best of everyone
18
u/bilged Aug 02 '14
Bah. To me churning is using credit cards to get free shit. It encompasses:
signup bonuses (repeated or not)
stacking bonuses such as points for CC spend on something that can be used to pay off that same CC
paying off CC with transfer to no interest CC to get free loans
maximizing other perks for minimum cost (insurance, extra warranties, additional discounts, etc)