r/changemyview • u/LolYeahGroup • 2m ago
CMV: Presidential Democracies can be better than Parliamentary systems
Nowadays, most people swear their heart on parliamentary systems as if it's the solution to democracy. But there are several issues with that system i feel like, and here's why.
Executive Patronage
I know, I know. Presidential Democracies have executive patronage as well, but giving the President a genuine term erases the risk of not building up a majority within the legislature and gives more opportunities to the President to actually appoint more technocratic experts in important cabinet posts rather than giving a party one of the more fundamental parts of the cabinet.
Also, sometimes Parliamentary Democracies give the cabinet seats out like candy to form a majority, and eventually you gotta ask, "What does the leader of the right wing nationalist party who spent their entire life as a lawyer, know about health?"
Again, I'm not saying patronage like this doesn't exist in Presidential Democracies, I'm saying they are practically mandated in Parliamentary ones.
2. Government Instability
This is kind of a weak point because I know that a lot of governments in Parliamentary Democracies have been stable. But, the problem is that a lot of Parliamentary Democracies have simple votes of confidence that if the PM fails, they get kicked out of office.
This not only makes governments much more likely to fall, it makes cabinet less technocratic and more incentivized to make quick acts of popularity, thereby leading to a concentration of power in the civil service. You see this in the Netherlands and the UK. IDK why parliamentary democracies don't just use Germany's system if they're so adamant about using it.
3. No Separation of Powers between Executive and Legislature.
Collapsing Executive and Legislature together weakens the purpose of both executive and the legislature. The legislature stops being someone to represent a certain constituency and instead becomes the popularity score of a party leader. It's part of the reason why the UK, despite having first-past-the-post, has such strong whips. A lot of MPs know that the reason they're there isn't really because the people wanted them to represent them, but rather because the people treated their ballot as a presidential vote.
This innately centralizes power to leaders and gives them a near-chokehold the legislature's stance on anything. In FPTP systems like Britain, this compounds. If Labour or the Conservatives get a majority then legally there is nothing stopping them from actively turning the UK into a dictatorship, not even because they don't have a constitution, but because the executive has absolute control on the legislature as well.
Again, I'm not saying that parliamentary democracies are bad or anything. They're perfectly fine in my view. It's just that a lot of people have talked about how parliamentary democracies are the future of democracy and presidential democracy is this old system we should do away with, when in reality, there are flaws to both systems.