r/changemyview • • Nov 19 '23

Delta(s) from OP CMV: People who use the word "herstory" are fucking idiots.

68 Upvotes

Herstory is a word used by ultra feminists instead of history. It is based on the presumption that history is a combination of "his" and "story" and paints a picture of a society dominated by MEN and THE PATRIARCHY. I am no expert of etymology by any means, but it is so FUCKING obvious that this is not the origin of the word history. I am somewhat fluent in French and in French, the word for history is "histoire." The word for his in French is "son," "sa," or "ses" depending on the gender of the object in question. So in French "histoire" has nothing to do with their words for "his." English was heavily influenced by French, and I'm assuming the similarities between "history" and "histoire" are a product of this. The word has nothing to do with "his." It is merely a coincidence. Using "herstory" is based on ignorance and stupidity and false presumptions about etymology that could easily be reversed by a Google search (I just googled the etymology of history and guess what, I'm right.) Anyways, if a feminist thinks a word is inherently linked to the male gender, why flip it around and link it back to the female gender? How is that less sexist? Makes no sense.

Other stupid feminist words: womyn, womxn, hxrstory (fucking lmao), manterupting (even bigger fucking lmao.)


r/changemyview • • Dec 21 '25

Delta(s) from OP CMV: the qa’ran has directly caused the most violence and deaths of any piece of literature

5 Upvotes

(reupload with more specifics) the qaran has directly caused so many wars and killings, i believe it to be objectively worse than other religious books because it is so popular, and worse than the bible because there is no room for interpretation within it like the bible has, and i believe many of the colonists and invasions by Christians use the bible as an excuse rather than being their reason, while the qaran tells muslims to fight a holy war overthrow people and install a sharia law with strict punishments death penalty etc. I believe it to be worse than mein kampf or some of those agricultural etc books that caused mass starvation because those are either just manifestos of deaths caused by the authors, or didn’t directly caused deaths, rather it was a 2 step proces.


r/changemyview • • Jun 08 '25 Bless Up This Helpful

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Anti-white racism is not a serious nor prevalent issue in the United States.

362 Upvotes

First off, let me start with saying that I'd oppose and stand against any actual anti white racism.

But I just simply don't think it's prevelant in American society throughout the vast majority of the nation.

Do people who hate white people exist? Of course, but not the point to which we have a serious and persistent issue of anti white racism that is pervasive.

The main argument I have here is the weakness of the other side's arguments. I feel like those who believe anti white racism is pervasive in America don't really have strong examples.

Many will claim either examples which the backing for is unclear or outright false examples. For instance, many will say DEI is anti white racism, but won't actually tell us how. Or, for instance, they'll use the example of the left's objection to the Afrikaner refugees from South Africa. But that would be more easily and directly explainable by pointing to the left not believing they had valid refugee cases and also Trump's spurning of refugees the left does believe have valid cases.

Overall, it's just a generally unsubstantiated point in my view.


r/changemyview • • Jun 15 '25

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Comparisons between Nazi Germany and Israel as well as calls for Israels dissolution are virtually always anti-semitic and non-prodictive discourse

25 Upvotes

I'd like to clarify this view somewhat, as I am certain there will be a good number of people who will take offense on a personal level from the title. When I say that these types of arguments or discourse talking points are rooted in anti-semitism, I do not mean to say that I believe everyone who has utilized this type of discourse is anti-semitic. Nearly every individual I know personally who has made Nazi-Israel comparisons or stated that they feel the appropriate outcome of the conflict is the destruction of the Israeli state are people whom I know for a fact have no prejudice against Jewish people, but have been swept up in the extreme nature of discussion around the conflict

The establishment of the state of Israel and whether or not one believes the history leading up to the event was morally correct, or was something that should have happened at all is entirely fair grounds to take opinions on. Personally and with the blessing of hindsight, I don't feel that the Zionist movement and establishment of Israel was necessary, and I feel that many options in which no state of Israel were formed would have been preferable. However the country was given the right to self determine via legal and legitimate means and while I believe the League of Nations made a bad decision, it was a decision they had a right to make based on historic precidence. The United Kingdom was granted the Levant in the aftermath of WWI which was very much standard in human history up to that point. One nation/empire defeats another in war and takes their shit, sometimes by force and sometimes as the condition of a surrender/peace treaty. They submitted the decision on what would become of the Mandate of Palestine to the new League of Nations, allowing a coalition of nations to be involved in the solution planning. On the ground, Zionist forces fought for their independence as well which again was the norm in human history.

The fact that so many mainstream opinions are specifically targeting Israel to be dissolved or destroyed (or claiming that it has no right to exist) leads me to believe that such opinions are anti-semitic. Despite nearly every major nation on Earth having a history involving violent land grabs from native populations and ethnic cleansing, the establishment of the Israeli state receives a massively disproportionate degree of focus. If something like the Partition were to happen today, it would be against international law and viewed as barbaric because it is. But at the time it was not remotely unfounded

The knee-jerk defense of critics of Israel is that Zionism and the nature of the state itself are separate from criticism of the Jewish people or Judaism as a whole. In certain contexts and discussion, this is entirely valid. As a sovereign country Israel takes actions and ideologies which are in its national and not necessarily religious interests. The Israeli Prime Minister and Parliament does not hold any spiritual influence over Judaism in the way that the Pope and Cardinals operating in the Vatican do for Catholicism and are not spiritual figures, it just happens to be an independent government based on the faith. However what I find dangerous about the "Zionism is not the same as Jewishness" line of discussion is that often these people are unwilling to understand that Judaism is a part of this conflict whether they like it or not. Failing to admit that Jewish identity is critical to understanding the historic and modern conflict is willfully ignorant and prevents one from being able to have informed discussion on the matter. Anti-Zionism is not inherently anti-semitism; but most people are careless about how often their opinions or words cross the line

Finally, comparing Israel to Nazi Germany is entirely charged by anti-semitism. Most comparisons of modern governments to the Nazi's are historically incorrect, malicious, and highly selective. Virtually all comparisons are made entirely to emotionally manipulate people and not in good faith historical discussion. The Nazi Party was not unique in being a dictatorship, ultra ethno-nationalist, racist, war hungry, violent, oppressive, or genocidal. Many nations and empire throughout history, both in antiquity and modernity have either fully embraced or flirted with aspects of these dangerous descriptions. The Nazi Party was a political movement and government which could only exist in the specific time period and specific region under the specific domestic conditions that it arose from. The parts and cogs of its ideology and motivations while not new or unique, came together as a whole which was in fact new and unheard of. No other country on Earth has been similar enough since the Nazis to really be accurate in full comparison.

Israeli politics and ambitions are very nationalist, right wing, colonial, militaristic, and has resulted in the country commiting acts of genocide and ethnic cleansing at times in its history. There is very little as a leftist that I like about Israel's government or current cultural climate. Their actions in Gaza are criminal, unforgivable, vile, and I feel that many members of its government should be tried and hanged like Saddam was. Despite this, their aggression, expansion, and human rights record is nowhere near as horrific as the !Nazis. Furthermore, the worst actions taken by Nazi Germany have always been fundamentally rooted to and core to their political ideology. The Nazi Party's entire political agenda was ethnic cleansing by way of aggressive military conquest and extermination of the local population. Israel has done numerous criminal acts and has been the immoral aggressor many times in its history, but not within the same conditions as the Nazis. Comparing Israel to the Nazis is a choice which is obviously meant to weaponize the memory of the Holocaust.


r/changemyview • • Sep 16 '25

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Hamas attacked Israel on 10/7 because Iran told it to, not out of “resistance” to Israel

7 Upvotes

Iran hates Saudi (Shia-Sunni schism) and knew Saudi was on the verge of normalizing relations with Israel which would have permanently ducked Iran’s hopes of getting the west out of the Middle East (also ducking Iran’s hopes of being a regional hegemon) so they used their proxies to throw a wrench in the works

That’s why Yemen and Hezbollah were all armed and geared to provide backup - sugar daddy Khomeini knew this was his last shot to shut down the American-Israeli menace

Going back to the 1940s, the major Arab states which attacked Israel in their ineffectual attempts to destroy the West’s beachhead in the Middle East were Jordan, Syria, Iraq, Egypt, and Saudi (ironically Iran wasn’t involved because the Shah wanted to be on the US’ good side) and by Oct ‘23 all of those countries had become American client states (Jordan, Egypt, Saudi) or been disassembled/rendered impotent (Syria, Iraq, Lebanon). Hoping to rebuild Persia as vanguard of the ummah Iran shot its shot.*

*this is part of why Palestinian lives don’t matter to Hamas- Shia Iranian leaders don’t mind deaths among Sunni civilians so regardless of what happens to their people Hamas isn’t worried about losing support from their bankrollers

tl;dr Hamas wasn’t thinking, it was just following orders

https://np.reddit.com/r/IsraelPalestine/s/ZYBpjY7lzY


r/changemyview • • Jul 09 '24

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Unqualified hatred of landlords is either hypocritical or impractical

0 Upvotes

First of all, I'm not a landlord. I don't own any rental properties and haven't ever purchased real estate as an investment, but I've never seen anything intrinsically wrong with doing that.

However, over the last couple of years I've seen an increasing amount of redditors arguing that there is something intrinsically wrong with being a landlord ... that the basic idea of "real estate as an investment" is wrong, and that people who do it are fundamentally immoral. "I wouldn't date a landlord", "landlords shouldn't exist", that sort of thing. To me, that position is either hypocritical, fundamentally impractical, or nonsensical.

Now, to be clear: I'm not saying that all landlords are moral, or that there are no circumstance where "property as an investment" is immoral. I'm not arguing with people who have a problem with slumlords or predatory real estate companies or individual landlords that do everything they can to screw tenants out of money while never meeting their own obligations ... I've dealt with these people, and they suck.

I'm focused on people that think the very idea of a landlord is wrong, which seems to boil down to one of three positions:

  • "Housing is a basic necessity of life, you shouldn't be able to profit off of it!" OK... but the builder who builds the house wants money, the bank that pays the builder makes money off the loan... zooming out, you'll die a lot quicker without food than housing, yet people aren't claiming that farmers are evil or grocery stores are evil or chefs are evil. You'll die even faster without water, but folks aren't saying the utility company is evil for charging you for it. Why is charging people to live in a house they didn't build on land they didn't buy wrong? This is a hypocritical position.

  • "There's not enough housing -- landlords compete with homeowners to buy up houses and that drives up the cost of housing!" If you think about this for a couple of minutes, you can see that landlords can't be the root cause of the problem here. There is a finite amount of people who need housing in any given market; prices go up because demand for housing outstrips supply of housing. Landlords buying up housing does nothing to decrease the supply of housing ... in fact, if it outpaces the growth of renters, it means rental rates go down, which reduces the value of rental properties. The issue here is that housing supply isn't increasing to meet demand. This is a nonsensical position.

  • "All property is theft. The only value comes through labor." From this perspective, ownership can only come through direct labor; your farm is yours because you work it, the food it produces is yours because it was created with your labor, and so on. Any form of capitalism is wrong; inheriting a house from your parents is wrong, having a 401k is wrong, opening a local bakery and paying employees is wrong ... etc. This is internally consistent, but requires a fundamentally different society than the one we live in -- and one that seems to produce much worse results. Yes, yes, "real communism has never been tried" and so on, but a capitalist-socialist hybrid seems to produce the best outcomes for the average person of any human society, so pragmatically I'm not trying to blow it up to be the next society to prove that real communism has never been tried.

Fair warning: I'm not super eager to debate with people who want to debate point #3 based on the belief that communism is the best economic model. If you're doing your best to actually live by these economic values I give you credit, but you will have to be wildly convincing if you want me to adopt a purely communist worldview.

EDIT: Folks, I'll do my best to respond but there's a lot of responses here and I'm losing track. Here are some common themes I want to address:

  • "There aren't enough legal protections for renters or price controls on landlords to avoid price gauging." OK, then there should be... consumer protections are very reasonable to advocate for, but I started out with no disagreement there.

  • "Landlords don't actually add anything of value, whereas builders do!" I'm not going to respond to any more of these; they're essentially #3 with extra steps. If you view the concept of using capital to pay for labor and then profiting off of owning the business rather than performing the labor as evil, and believe that having a 401K or an IRA is even-more-evil-than-being-a-landlord ... fair play, but I disagree; I think a well regulated capitalist economy with a strong social safety net and aggressive income redistribution has a better track record of producing good outcomes than communist economies, and I need more than a 150-year-old theory to change my mind there.

  • "Landlords use their outsized influence to artificially stop the building of new houses!" No, they don't, at least in the US. This is just not factually accurate; the vast majority of townships (e.g., San Francisco) have residency requirements to vote in municipal elections, and some also have property ownership requirements. US owner-occupied housing is >65%, which means that at the very highest, only 1/3 of the votes against high density housing could come from landlords ... and in fact, probably much less. Your parents' whole generation are the people who are voting against affordable housing being built, not some faceless "landlords". Not only that, but if you do the basic math (e.g., for a town like San Francisco), buying a house at the current market rates in order to rent it out will operate at operating loss of around 50 cents on the dollar per year, whereas building an apartment building on the same lot will generate 50-100% operating profit. If you're a corporate landlord in a high-demand market, the math works for you to want to add housing units to the market, and it does not work for you to want to drive up property prices.

EDIT2: I'm adding one to the above:

  • "Landlords decrease the supply of houses available to buy, which is what we care about."

    • This assumes that 100% of the population is in a position to buy a home, which requires that a) they are willing to live there 5-10 years (long enough to build sufficient equity to cover buying and selling costs, b) they have a substantial down payment on-hand and c) they have sufficient depth of savings to cover unexpected repairs (a new roof, a new HVAC system, mold remediation, etc).

    • Essentially, it assumes that 100% of people that need a home are in an economic position to buy one, and that the 25-30% of landlord-buyers are increasing the price of homes so much that 35% (the actual share of renters) are priced out. This is not a reasonable assumption -- but I recognize that it is possible that there are middle class people who can't buy a home due to competition from landlords and renters, so I've given someone a delta for this one.

    • With that being said, I gotta point out (as I mentioned above) that landlords have a much stronger incentive than owner-occupiers to actually build more housing on the land they own -- so if you care about the cost of housing in general, rather than your own ability to engage in rent-seeking behavior by profiting on the increasing scarcity of land, then that kinda takes the wind out of this one.


r/changemyview • • Dec 03 '20

Delta(s) from OP CMV: most subs on Reddit are far left leaning and will shout anything down that doesn’t fit their agenda, same as their mods. This does not exclude debate subs.

5.7k Upvotes

Now since this is only my personal experience I am open to any input from another perspective.

I have made the experience that people will become very hostile should you explain any idea that is even a little bit right leaning even when it is 100% based on facts or rationality. It also feels like there are some subjects like gay people, transgenderism, pro-life vs. pro choice, mental health, etc. that you can’t discuss at all because people seem to get so triggered at their very sight. It even has gone to the lengths of perma bans and mods insulting me, because of simply voicing an opinion / for simply making a post.

Maybe I have a clouded view, because I‘ve just experienced the worst of the worst, so what are your takes on the matter?

Edit: for clarification, where I am from we don’t differentiate between liberal and left. I‘ve seen this a lot in here so now you know.


r/changemyview • • Apr 26 '26

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Europe deserves more blame for global geopolitical problems than the United States does.

1 Upvotes

Before I begin, I want to mention that my post is not in regards to the stuff the orange cheeto is doing today, but historically in general.

I know this is going to sound biased as an American, but I want to say that I am very left-leaning, and I acknowledge that we have done messed up things and ruined many countries due to our foreign policy.

However, I do believe that when it came to the ideas of independence and self-determination, the US has largely been a leader in that front. Most of the issues we see in the world today is largely due to European foreign policy, not American. A lot of Africa's borders today were drawn by European colonizers. Latin American countries were colonized by many countries (mostly Spain), and the USA was the first country to put forth the idea of independence from Europe. Admittedly we may have overstepped in meddling with other countries on many occasions, but we created the foundation for the anti-colonialism movement.

Even countries like Canada was not only a loyal dominion of the United Kingdom, but actively took part in Britain's colonial wars as its top right-hand man. Hell, probably the most famous example currently: for all the talk about America's support for Israel being problematic nowadays, I would like to point out that British colonialism is largely the reason Israel and Palestine is such a hot spot for conflict today. Iran's antipathy towards the west was largely started by Britain when Mossegh tried to kick BP out.

By no means am I saying America is blameless, absolutely not. Especially nowadays, we're in the wrong for enabling situations like Gaza. We meddled a ton in other countries during the Cold War. But at the same time, America also pushed forth the idea of independence from European powers after World War II. Not to throw shade on Europe, but we're essentially cleaning the mess they left us behind.

CMV


r/changemyview • • Jan 01 '24

CMV: Trump is racist

0 Upvotes

First of all, it's not a statement it's supposed to be a question, so I'm sorry for the title.

Second of all, I know political debates generate kind of hate, so please if you're gonna insult me without reading this, don't.

Third of all, I really agree with Trump in 90% of his views like securing the borders and I think it's necessary.

But I really get annoyed when he describes people from Africa and Asia are "poisoning the blood of Americans" and saying that islam hates us. I'm a Muslim and I love Americans and American culture, I disagree with some decisions made by the government like anyone for example in iraq and Palestine issues, but this doesn't mean that I hate America as a country.

I know there are bad extremist Muslims out there but they are just 1% like any extremists in any set of beliefs or political opinions.

So his talk about "poisoning the blood" and islam gave me that impression about him.

And someone told me that he tried to remove the democracy of the US and I really don't know anything about it so please someone explain this to me.

Thanks for reading and sorry for the title if you find it offensive I really didn't mean it, it suppose to be a question

Thanks again

Edit: What I meant about agreeing with him in 90% of his views I meant his views on economy, educational system, borders and not engaging in pointless wars.


r/changemyview • • Mar 10 '24

Delta(s) from OP CMV: HAMAS is at fault for the tragedy in Gaza

881 Upvotes

I'm not super educated in geopolitics and history. I think it should be easy to CMV. I just need to understand better because from the research I did it seemed pretty clear cut and obvious.

Hamas took control of Gaza in 2007. They provided some social services and now the care of the people who live there is under Hamas. Their safety and well-being is now in HAMAS's hands.

How did they take care of their people? Well by shooting missiles at a superior military for two decades. Then when they finally hit Israel a little too hard, and Israel dropped warnings to evacuate, HAMAS told their people it's a bluff and to ignore it... This seems super obvious that HAMAS has been doing this the whole time so that a big enough tragedy happens that they get attention and resources because of the tragedy. Public opinion shift was the goal.

I understand that whole area has a very complicated history. I mean since ancient Mesopotamia crazy events have been taking place in that part of the world. I'm sure if you ask either party who started it, their answers will go back indefinitely since the dawn of civilization.

Is it not rational to assign responsibility during the leadership shift in 2007? I mean if aliens invaded with superior technology, and warned us not to attack, and one of our leaders commanded us to attack... And we get wiped out... That's poor leadership no? As much as we cry that the land should have been ours, the new military might situation requires strategy adjustment to protect lives.

What am I missing here?

Final edit: Maybe a better question would have been "What is the strategic value of guerrilla warfare and ongoing resistance to Israel from the Palestinian people?"

Early resistance made sense to me (1948-1970ish). Once Israel had finally captured strategic locations and proved their power, I would have expected more treaties or appeasements like the one Egypt did.

I also understand the sentiment from many of you that picking a specific time in history to evaluate that leadership and it's strategic choices is arbitrary. Some of you think it makes much more sense to focus on the immediate pulling of a trigger version of cause and effect.

In the same way you should "expect" a certain response when attacking a superior military, in the 1940s the winners of world war II should have "expected" endless generations of resistance to that proposed occupation. And to be prepared for that cost is, somewhat, to be prepared for the full extermination of your enemy if they do not yield. And if you know they won't yield, then maybe that is genocide. Hindsight is 20/20 in this realm of fault being assigned to "should have known" future outcomes. I am now agnostic of fault here, and becoming increasingly solemn the more footage I watch.

PM me or reply again if I missed a deserved delta. It took me some time to let the responses marinate and think about it.


r/changemyview • • Jul 15 '25

CMV: a path to legalisation for all undocumented immigrants will not only not work, it will permanently undermine all future immigration discourse.

93 Upvotes

Simply put, providing a pathway for all undocumented immigrants will only send a message for future-would be undocumented peoples coming in that they can expect future regularisation so long as they did not commit any crimes. In other words, it’s a slippery slope.

Even temporary or stopgap measures with the promise of future immigration restrictions will not work, because if it happens once, there’s the expectation that it can and will happen again. This will translate to the declining undocumented population (due to regularisation) quickly replenishing by expectant migrants who may cross the border without papers and/or overstay their visas with the expectation that they’ll eventually regularise as long as they simply stay put.

This will undermine the immigration system and permanently undermine all future immigration discourse in the following ways:

  • it’s basically a big middle finger to those legal immigrants who did everything by the book, followed the laws and waited in queue (sometimes for decades)

  • it will also completely change the narrative in the future from calibrating the immigration system to meet the demographic and socio-economic needs of the country to focusing around either providing pathways or deporting undocumented immigrants. (As has been happening in the U.S. for the past several decades)

Disclaimer: I actually posted this yesterday, but for some reason (most likely an app glitch on ht phone) I opened the app to find notifications for the post but couldn’t find the post itself (weird)


r/changemyview • • Jan 18 '24

CMV: The MAGA crowd is a cult full of hate

10 Upvotes

As the 2024 election draws closer and there is essentially no contest between the new Republican candidates and Trump, it's obvious how much these people idolize Trump almost as if he were a deity. While his competition presents new and rational ideas for this country while still retaining conservative values, he continues to simply make fun of Joe Biden or deny that he's ever done anything wrong. All these childish approaches yet the MAGA cult just eats it up. He likes to be spiteful in his speeches, as in piss off anyone who isn't a far right winger, and I think that's why most people love him. They love that he steps on a lot of toes and they radiate that same spitefulness with all the MAGA hats and Trump flags. if you see a pickup truck on the road with a Trump 2024 flag hanging off the back, let's face it that person is just trying to make someone angry or upset. That's just the MAGA culture that Trump has created over the years. He could molest a child and his fans would just tune it out like they have blinders on. Anything bad he does or has done does not matter as long as he wins the presidency, and that's a scary thought.

For the record, I don't have a certain political affiliation, although I do lean slightly to the right. I've been impressed with the fresh, new ideas presented from DeSantis and Haley, and Vivek. I'd like to believe there are still level headed Republicans out there who truly want the best for our country and want to resolve our issues without controversy or hate involved.


r/changemyview • • Jul 02 '26

Delta(s) from OP CMV: US birthright citizenship is in no way harmful to US citizens

0 Upvotes

Conservatives in the US are currently in a frenzy about the SCOTUS decision affirming birthright citizenship for any person born in the United States.
However, I’ve seen no legitimate argument as to how it actually harms US citizens.
The ruling doesn’t protect illegal immigrant parents, and the current administration has shown it will deport immigrants even if they have US citizen children.

Assuming proper enforcement of immigration laws, I see no reason why birthright citizenship is damaging to the country or its people.


r/changemyview • • Jan 06 '25

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Marxists and Flat Earthers have one thing in common: they don’t have a functional model

92 Upvotes

You know when you ask a flat-earther to show you a functioning model of the world? And they have to pull 2 - one for seasons and one for day and night? And neither explain Meteorological phenomena?

That’s kinda how Marxists are. Communism is a stateless, classless and moneyless society. But when you ask them how would that work in the real world, they have no answer.

“Well by seizing the means of productions” - okay but how would that work?

“Well we overthrown the owner of the factory so now we own it”

Okay, that’s great but how do you image a day in the a stateless moneyless and classless world? And I’m not asking in a redundant way of “what about the lazy people?????”

I genuinely want to know how will they organize? How will they trade world-wide? How will they share knowledge? How will they ensure that everyone gets what they need? How will they decide how long to work in absence of gouverning bodies? Do they just work all day? How will they deal with rebels? What about justice? Do courts still exists, as they aren’t technically means of production?

And most importantly how will it happend? In a world-wide revolution? Over the course of 200 years? The transition from feudalism to capitalism was pretty smooth - the importance of landowners slowly faded because after the Industrial Revolution the means of production became more important for society than owning land

But how will people transition into a moneyless society? Will all nations collectively decide to abandon the concept money one day? Or will it be a long process? If it’s a long process how will areas that abandoned money survive?

How will they transition into a stateless society? Do all nations just collectively give up on being nations one day? Or is a long process?


r/changemyview • • Jun 27 '26 Bravo

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Contemporary antizionism is more "pro-war with Israel" than it is "pro-Palestinian"

0 Upvotes

So, first thing's first, what this post is not about: I'm not here to debate on whether or not antizionism is or isn't inherently antisemitic; I'm not here to debate whether or not the war in Gaza constitutes a genocide or not; and I'm not here to discuss the 80-year history of the conflict since at length.

No, I am here with a very straightforward stance: independent of those debates, contemporary antizionists are so focused on their opposition to Israel and so fixated on their desire for Israel to be "abolished" that they will actively oppose peace negotiations and attempts at normalization of relations with Israel.

An example of what I mean: some western antizionists online have responded to the Lebanese government's decision to consider direct talks with Israel with the possibility of reaching a long-term peace deal with a country that is currently waging war in its territory with nothing but horror and indignation. In fact, the response has been to further glorify and lionize Hezbollah, despite the fact that Hezbollah is a) an internationally recognized terrorist organization that has conducted terror and military campaigns abroad (their participation in the Syrian Civil War on Assad's side being the one that springs to mind most recently) and b) the organization that started the war with Israel that prompted the invasion of South Lebanon to begin with.

And it is in this sense (as well as Western antizionist support and lionization of other armed terrorist groups based solely on their hatred of Israel, such as the Houthis, Hamas or the Iranian Quds) that I've arrived at the view I hope y'all can change. There is a level of hatred and vitriol aimed toward Israel that I have genuinely never seen for any other country, certainly not any other country in the Middle East. I can't quite explain how bizarre it is to see the same ideological cohorts that lambasted the notion of humanitarian intervention and did so primarily in defense of non-action on Syria even after Assad's use of chemical weapons turn around and suddenly claim that Israel ought to be invaded by Western powers for humanitarian reasons.

Because at the end of the day, it seems as if antizionists - and especially Western antizionists who do not have to live with the consequences of either the ongoing conflict or its indefinite extention - are not interested in peace at all, even to the detriment of the Palestinian (or the Lebanese, as the case may be) people. Not to put too fine a point on it, but you don't seek peace with your friends, but with your enemies; and what Palestine, Lebanon and the Middle East need is peace. The issue being - and I'm hoping people can change my view on this - that there is no desire for peace with Israel among antizionists; the obvious implication is that the desire is for war. And I have yet to see a single good argument for why a forever war is somehow preferable to and end to the intransigence that has trapped the region into these constant wars to being with.


r/changemyview • • Jun 08 '26

Delta(s) from OP CMV: If Turkey doesn't oust Erdogan's party in 2028, they should be expelled from NATO

12 Upvotes

To put it simply, imho if Turkey doesn't get rid of Erdogan in 2028 (or perhaps his chosen successor), it's never gonna happen. It's debatable whether that's even possible in Turkey's current system, they're certainly a hybrid regime as opposed to a free and fair democracy, so it'll be harder to get rid of Erdogan than it was Orbán, but they're not fully authoritarian so I won't call it impossible, I will call it "now or never" though.

If Turkey can't get rid of Erdogan's party in 2028, I honestly just don't think they're worth the trouble. We already sank any chance at a Kurdish state in 2019 by siding with them in Syria, Turkey is also openly pro-Hamas atm when we're in the middle of a regional war in the Middle East, Western politicians often avoid acknowledging the Armenian genocide to avoid offending Turkey, so at a certain point I think we in the West have to ask ourselves if it's even worth it anymore.

After the wars in Ukraine and the Middle East are finished, NATO will undoubtably be expanding. Ukraine, Moldova, the three Caucus states, and Israel are all obvious targets for NATO expansion. However I think if Turkey doesn't get rid of Erdogan's cronies in 2028 that they'll get in the way of all this, so not only are their illiberal tendencies an ethical risk to the alliance, but they could also be a strategic risk.

Change my view though if you disagree. Turkey's often a point of debate in our foreign policy because most Westerners generally agree that a Kurdish state has the right to exist, but also that Turkey has at least some strategic value to NATO. So if you think I'm wrong, why?


r/changemyview • • May 25 '26

Delta(s) from OP CMV: The current Republican Party is a cult that fits every single characteristic of a cult.

0 Upvotes

I was reading a book by a cult expert who grew up in a cult, then joined the army at 18 & became a captain, then went to Harvard to study cult dynamics & psychology. This expert listed 10 cult traits:

  1. exploitation of labor

  2. charismatic leadership

  3. distinguishable vernacular

  4. worldview shift that brings you under the sacred assumption

  5. transcendent mission

  6. self-sacrifice of members

  7. limits access to outside world

  8. Us vs Them mentality

  9. high entry/exit costs

Exploitation of labor
People canvass for free, they defend trump’s actions for free, they did Jan 6 for free, they donate their own money, etc.

Charismatic leadership
Trump might be anti-charismatic to non-republicans, but to republicans he is very charismatic.

Distinguishable vernacular
“Woke” “fake news” “4D chess” “2 weeks” “let’s go Brandon” etc.

Worldview shift that brings you under the sacred assumption
“I used to be [libertarian, independent, etc], but then I heard him telling it like it is, and I realized he’s God’s chosen vessel to fight against [minority group I’m hateful towards &/or afraid of]”

Edit: This one is actually more about assuming the group is sacred and can do no wrong. I did a poor job explaining it. My bad. A much better example would be “Trump redacted all the predators in the files, even though he swore to prosecute them & arrest Clinton on day 1, but he must be doing good in 4D-chess because he is on a sacred mission from God.”

Transcendent mission
“Make America Great Again!” “Fight the holy fight against the forces of evil!” “Spread maga among the stars with the space force!”

Self-sacrifice of members
“My family & friends all hate me now” “I lost my job when I got arrested on Jan 6” “I donated my life savings to his campaign”

Limits access to outside world
“Don’t listen to fake news!” “Libtards aren’t worth hanging out with” “doctors are liars! Fauci is evil!” “Don’t listen to most economists saying the bbb will raise inflation, listen to these few economists that agree with me!”

Us vs Them mentality
“Woke is bad!” “Non-Christians are bad!” “Immigrants are bad!” etc.

High entry/exit costs
You lose friends/family (both entering & leaving the cult).

Ends justify the means mentality
“We have to live with high gas prices & elective wars, because it will make America great again!” “We have to cut food stamps & social security, to pay for the war & the billionaire ballroom! It’ll maga!” “We have to pay tariffs, to cut taxes on billionaires, to make America great again!”

These are all things I’ve heard directly from republicans. I really hope I’m wrong, and 76,000,000 republicans aren’t actually the largest cult in human history. I don’t want to see millions of Americans this way. Please, change my view.

Edit: Explaining why you think xyz group is also a cult, doesn’t make me think republicans aren’t a cult. It makes me think you’re coping with whataboutism. To change my view, you need to explain why you believe that most of the cult traits don’t actually fit the Republican Party. Another group being a cult doesn’t magically make every other cult not a cult. There can be more than 1 cult in the world.

Edit2: having 1-2 cult traits doesn’t mean a group is a cult.

Edit3: Thank you to the people who pointed out that not all republicans are in so deep that they sacrifice their life savings & their lives doing Jan 6 type stuff. Idk how to change my title, but you have changed my view that it’s all republicans. Just like Scientologists, some members are deeply involved & some members aren’t quite that deep into the cult.

Edit 4: people keep saying that I’m applying these cult traits “too broadly” & that all of these traits can easily apply to every other group. I doubt that. What is the sacred assumption of a chess club? If the person running your local chess club covered up the names of predators he swore to prosecute, would you just blindly assume he must have a perfectly valid reason for it? If they asked your chess club to “fight like hell” would they storm the US capital to try to overturn election results? Not every group fits all of these traits so well.

Edit5: I’ve been informed that traits 1, 6, 7, & 9 are less extreme in republicanism than in other cults, unless you count the members who are fairly deep into the cult. That’s a fair point, but aren’t most cults like that? More extreme when you’re deeper into them? Less extreme when you’re just a casual member on the periphery? I’m looking for ways that these traits do not apply to republicanism, not ways that other cults are more extreme.


r/changemyview • • Oct 07 '25

CMV: Palestinians should accept any solution that leads to statehood and rejecting them is inherently counterproductive

6 Upvotes

As I say in the title, Palestinians should have accepted any deal that gives way to statehood and even insist on the deals that would give them a statehood, like giving up the right of return.

Rejecting the deals has historically put Palestinians in a worse situation at every turn of history and made the lives of Palestinians miserable for a pipe dream of “river to the sea”

If Palestinians had accepted any deal smaller country and ran with it instead of taking all the land back from Israel, they would have had their state by now, and the whole thing would have been over.

By not capitulating in a lost position, even when they had numerous opportunities to get a free state, they basically shot themselves in the foot and further made their lives miserable.

In my opinion, any Palestinian would have an unquestionably better life if at any turn they had agreed to let go of right of return and agreed to the existence of Israel and its borders. By not doing it every decade their land was diminished, their chance of control of the land they live in diminished and their quality of life diminished.


r/changemyview • • Sep 30 '24

Delta(s) from OP - Election CMV: Kamala Harris is going to lose the 2024 election

2 Upvotes

Earlier this year I made a post to this same effect, but that was under the assumption that Joe Biden would remain the Presidential candidate. Needless to say, the fact that he withdrew from the race confirmed my belief that he was a weak candidate and would have lost against Donald Trump. And for a while-- up until early September-- I saw Kamala Harris as a much stronger candidate with a better chance of winning than Biden ever had. However, I now have extreme doubts that Harris is going to win, for a number of reasons listed below.

  1. Despite being allegedly more popular than Biden, Harris is polling within the margin of error of Biden in all of the swing states. Even a small polling error, which there is almost certain to be, would put Trump over the edge enough to win.

  2. Harris is losing support compared to Biden in "sun belt" states such as Arizona and Georgia, meaning that any victory she does achieve would be much narrower than Biden's, with fewer backup options.

  3. There are rumors of an upcoming Israeli offensive in Lebanon in the coming weeks, and if that happens, it could cause American public opinion to swing strongly against the Biden administration, and by extension Harris.

  4. The leader of a dock-worker's union in New York has announced his intention to go on strike in October, potentially sending the American economy into a tailspin and once again damaging the Biden administration's image at a crucial time.


r/changemyview • • Nov 26 '24

Delta(s) from OP - Election CMV: The 4B Movement and MGTOW are basically the same and both should be treated the same

290 Upvotes

For those that do not know either of those, let me explain.

4B is a movement that was started by feminists in South Korea in response to a highly misogynistic society - no sex with men, no giving birth, no dating men, and no marrying men [called 4B because all those in Korean start with "B"].

MGTOW, Men Going Their Own Way, is a similar movement started by anti-feminists where "men go their own way" - leave women alone and focus on self-improvement. It is considered bad, at least in part because people like Andrew Tate and the right-wing have coopted it.

Both of these movements have misandrists [for 4B]/misogynists [for MGTOW], yet 4B gets praised while MGTOW is considered a hate movement and synonymous with incels. Some women even seek to start a 4B movement in the US in light of the recent election.

I am purely calling out the double-standard here. Why should it be okay for women to have their independence movement, yet men are considered evil creeps for trying to do the same?

"That doesn't seem fair." - Wanda Maximoff, the Scarlet Witch

EDIT: Made the last line a question as opposed to a statement.

Addendum: I am not MGTOW or endorsing/advocating for it. Matter of fact, by assuming I am, you are proving my point - because I dare equate a women's movement and a men's movement I must be a part of that "dirty group".

Final update: I have had my mind changed by /u/petielvrrr, speficially:

The problem with MGTOW was never that men simply wanted to do their own thing. The problem was that they did it while spouting misogynistic rhetoric, AND they did it in such a way that hurt women in other ways. Example: plenty of MGTOW men have stated openly that they refuse to hire women, if women already work for them they refuse to talk to them, etc. this bars women from economic opportunities, and given that men still control the majority of businesses, it’s not okay for men to have that mindset.

My main issue here is how MGTOW men are treating (ie - causing harm) women. Regardless of what the original or even current intentions of the MGTOW movement are, it is clear they are causing harm that seems to be spurred by hatred. 4B is, I can fairly comfortably say, more a survival-based movement with some bad seeds. I originally thought MGTOW just had similar bad seeds and was co-opted by some [Andrew Tate], but it seems more like a "bad seed" movement.


r/changemyview • • Feb 28 '24

CMV: Setting yourself on fire or murdering yourself for ANY cause is pointless and stupid. It is not brave nor heroic.

10 Upvotes

People are so worried about violence these days. Disagreement is violence. Misgendering is violence. Peaceful words are deemed to incite violence. But when a disturbed anarchist offs himself publicly in one of the most violent ways possible, it is lauded as bravery. He committed an act of supreme violence against himself. And it accomplished nothing except getting himself notoriety. It did not raise awareness of a cause. That cause already has the attention of the entire US. Those who applaud him are practically encouraging other disturbed individuals to mimic him. THAT is the kind of speech that is dangerous.


r/changemyview • • Oct 12 '25

CMV: None of the pro-Palestinian activism has made or will make any changes.

72 Upvotes

None of the protests, online posts, campaigns are effective. No matter how much people spread awareness, that by itself won't stop the conflict/genocide.

And before you say "do you not know how activism works?", I don't believe in activism nowadays at all, so any general statements/examples that activism works (past 20 years) are also welcome.

Explanation: Public pressure has no effect on actual acting powers in this conflict i.e. IDF, US, their suppliers.

So CMV that there's no point, because I'd be happy if there was...


r/changemyview • • Aug 07 '25 Helpful Bless Up

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Much of the “concern” for Palestine is virtue signaling because it’s trendy

38 Upvotes

I’m not sure if anyone else has noticed but the Israel/Palestine conflict is a hot topic on Reddit. It’s pretty hard to go into a single comment section about anything and not see someone bring it up in some way. Almost like a Godwin’s law type phenomena.

Admittedly I know very little about it the conflict because it’s not really something I’m looking into deeply. But clearly a lot of people are concerned with this but I don’t think that concern is genuine based on actually caring about the harm people are facing, but more so based on the fact that it’s a trendy current event that’s easy to get behind.

Most people aren’t actually doing anything except posting on Reddit seemingly just to get karma. 100% of the people I’ve asked about what they’re doing have said something very vague or not even connected. The people I know irl “boycotted” Starbucks for a couple of weeks then just went back.

Along with this, and I’ve said this before in another comment, what about the other conflicts and human rights concerns going on in the world that get ignored? What about the people starving and suffering in your own community? What makes them less important?

Now I’m not saying that people have to be concerned for every single issue in the world, but I do think that the issue many people have chosen is Israel/Palestine not because they truly care but because it’s trendy and makes them look good.

Note because I’m sure I’m going to get asked something along the lines of what I do: I make a monthly donation to an organization that goes around to assist in rebuilding things such as school, hospitals and infrastructure after wars and donate food in my community.


r/changemyview • • Dec 11 '23

Delta(s) from OP CMV: People who think having sex with multiple people is empowering are useful idiots

29 Upvotes

The idea that sexual liberation is seen as a way of empowerment is frankly dumb.

It's one thing to have casual sex because you find it fun, or you just wanna try stuff out, but let's be real, it's not empowering to do so.

One could argue that "Oh people admire those who can pull many guys or girls" but I chalk that up to just being in awe of their charisma or looks and how they can attract many people, not them taking part in it.

Individuals who engage in casual sex for the sake of empowerment are only useful to horny motherfuckers. They'll promote this shit in order to get laid.


r/changemyview • • Apr 15 '24

CMV: White Males Are Not Even Close To Being The Most Hated Demographic In The US

104 Upvotes

A common talking point that I have noticed over the last couple of years, is that a lot of people not just white but of other races have been promoting the notion that White Males have become the most hated demographic in the US.

This is the most ridiculous thing that I have ever heard and I think it is a very huge slap in the face to demographic’s that do face constant discrimination and prejudice.

Just because you might see some articles that you don’t like, or you hear something in the news, does not mean that you are actually being targeted in real life.

And why has it become some sort of competition to see who is the biggest victim? It’s like everyone wants a piece of the pie.

I guarantee if you asked anybody who feels this way if they could change their racial makeup to something that wasn’t a White Male, 99.99999999999% of them would say no.