I was reading a book by a cult expert who grew up in a cult, then joined the army at 18 & became a captain, then went to Harvard to study cult dynamics & psychology. This expert listed 10 cult traits:
exploitation of labor
charismatic leadership
distinguishable vernacular
worldview shift that brings you under the sacred assumption
transcendent mission
self-sacrifice of members
limits access to outside world
Us vs Them mentality
high entry/exit costs
Exploitation of labor
People canvass for free, they defend trump’s actions for free, they did Jan 6 for free, they donate their own money, etc.
Charismatic leadership
Trump might be anti-charismatic to non-republicans, but to republicans he is very charismatic.
Distinguishable vernacular
“Woke” “fake news” “4D chess” “2 weeks” “let’s go Brandon” etc.
Worldview shift that brings you under the sacred assumption
“I used to be [libertarian, independent, etc], but then I heard him telling it like it is, and I realized he’s God’s chosen vessel to fight against [minority group I’m hateful towards &/or afraid of]”
Edit: This one is actually more about assuming the group is sacred and can do no wrong. I did a poor job explaining it. My bad. A much better example would be “Trump redacted all the predators in the files, even though he swore to prosecute them & arrest Clinton on day 1, but he must be doing good in 4D-chess because he is on a sacred mission from God.”
Transcendent mission
“Make America Great Again!” “Fight the holy fight against the forces of evil!” “Spread maga among the stars with the space force!”
Self-sacrifice of members
“My family & friends all hate me now” “I lost my job when I got arrested on Jan 6” “I donated my life savings to his campaign”
Limits access to outside world
“Don’t listen to fake news!” “Libtards aren’t worth hanging out with” “doctors are liars! Fauci is evil!” “Don’t listen to most economists saying the bbb will raise inflation, listen to these few economists that agree with me!”
Us vs Them mentality
“Woke is bad!” “Non-Christians are bad!” “Immigrants are bad!” etc.
High entry/exit costs
You lose friends/family (both entering & leaving the cult).
Ends justify the means mentality
“We have to live with high gas prices & elective wars, because it will make America great again!” “We have to cut food stamps & social security, to pay for the war & the billionaire ballroom! It’ll maga!” “We have to pay tariffs, to cut taxes on billionaires, to make America great again!”
These are all things I’ve heard directly from republicans. I really hope I’m wrong, and 76,000,000 republicans aren’t actually the largest cult in human history. I don’t want to see millions of Americans this way. Please, change my view.
Edit: Explaining why you think xyz group is also a cult, doesn’t make me think republicans aren’t a cult. It makes me think you’re coping with whataboutism. To change my view, you need to explain why you believe that most of the cult traits don’t actually fit the Republican Party. Another group being a cult doesn’t magically make every other cult not a cult. There can be more than 1 cult in the world.
Edit2: having 1-2 cult traits doesn’t mean a group is a cult.
Edit3: Thank you to the people who pointed out that not all republicans are in so deep that they sacrifice their life savings & their lives doing Jan 6 type stuff. Idk how to change my title, but you have changed my view that it’s all republicans. Just like Scientologists, some members are deeply involved & some members aren’t quite that deep into the cult.
Edit 4: people keep saying that I’m applying these cult traits “too broadly” & that all of these traits can easily apply to every other group. I doubt that. What is the sacred assumption of a chess club? If the person running your local chess club covered up the names of predators he swore to prosecute, would you just blindly assume he must have a perfectly valid reason for it? If they asked your chess club to “fight like hell” would they storm the US capital to try to overturn election results? Not every group fits all of these traits so well.
Edit5: I’ve been informed that traits 1, 6, 7, & 9 are less extreme in republicanism than in other cults, unless you count the members who are fairly deep into the cult. That’s a fair point, but aren’t most cults like that? More extreme when you’re deeper into them? Less extreme when you’re just a casual member on the periphery? I’m looking for ways that these traits do not apply to republicanism, not ways that other cults are more extreme.