r/buffy • u/James-Samuel17 • 15h ago
Buffy It's kinda crazy the movie career Sarah Michelle Gellar would have had during Buffy
I was doing research on Sarah because... why not ? And I found out how many movie roles were proposed to her by producers in, like, movies that turned out to be huge movies. The list is quite long. I feel like while a lot of actors coming from TV struggles to transition to film (Shannen Doherty is kind of an example as she went from 90210 to Charmed, two hugely successful shows but no really successful movies in her adulthood but then again, her reputation probably played into it despite her amazing acting), Sarah could have had it pretty easy and effortlessly. The list in question : In Romeo + Juliet, she was one of the finalists actresses to play Juliet alongside Jennifer Love Hewitt and Kate Winslet (Natalie Portman was the first choice but apparently considered too young to play along Leo) but she turned it down because of scheduling conflicts (with All My Children this time), and it wouldn't be the first time.
Martin Scorsesse approached her and proposed to her to play Jenny in Gangs of New York, again, alongside Leonardo DiCaprio (it's like fate or something because Leo was also the first choice to play in Harvard Man along SMG but couldn't). In 1999, she was proposed (not even auditioned for it) the role of Marla in Fight Club along Brad Pitt. But again, couldn't because of Buffy scheduling conflicts. Other roles of that time were American Beauty and The Wedding Planner. Sarah was one of the favorites of the producers in X-Men but... let's not repeat ourselves. In 2007 (yeah, way after Buffy), she was proposed the main role in Stardust but didn't want to be apart from Freddie Prinze Jr while the movie was shot in Scotland, Sarah always prioritized what she wanted and her family.
I watch more TV than film, never understood why movies were more "respected" so I don't mind her being in Buffy rather than in those movies because Buffy is like my favorite thing ever and she had more than her share of phenomenal acting in this 7 seasons ride of fantastic writing with equally phenomenal actors. But wow, Sarah just had that thing about her I guess.