r/buffy • u/Pearl_Jam_ • Feb 06 '25
r/buffy • u/Fun_Neighborhood8178 • Oct 04 '26
Xander Xander is a great character, and he’s so overhated by obnoxious people who all decided to share one opinion for some reason!
Seriously what is up with the Xander hate. Everyone I know who’s seen the show have always told me he sucks cause he’s a stand-in for Whedon, but now rewatching the show after such a long time, he’s really not that bad at all. He’s funny and works both as an audience surrogate and as a protagonist in his own right. The big emotional moments always work like his speech to Dawn or his speech to Willow, has some really good lines and great Xander centric episodes as well, like the one where everybody falls in love with him or the one with the bomb.
It’s like someone decided long ago that he’s a bad character and that has become the law now. I disagree
r/buffy • u/VegetableArtistic705 • Apr 01 '26
NEW VIEWER - No spoilers please! The worst part of Buffy & Angel is Buffy & Angel.
I'm on season 4 & 1, and I was soooo happy to finally get to the split. Forgetting the ages the characters are supposed to be, they're also just obnoxious asf. Their whole relationship is a corny middle school fantasy. Even now, watching Angel, I hate when Buffy's in the show. It just devolves into this stupid softcore every time they're together and not once has it ever felt like they had real chemistry. y
I like the story of the college dude she's dating, they genuinely seem to have a spark. It's just so tragic when the worst element of a show or movie is one of its main plot points.
r/buffy • u/Vanamond3 • Sep 12 '23
Please stop saying Xander is the "Whedon insert character." It doesn't mean what most of you seem to think it means.
Firstly, it doesn't mean everything Xander ever did reflects what Whedon would do. Xander fights demons and does carpentry, for example, which I'm pretty sure Joss does not. It mostly means that sometimes Xander says or does what a non-super-hero would do if he found himself in the show's bizarre situations. It's like being the "straight man" in a comedy routine; it helps the audience know how to react to the events of the story.
Secondly, you know who else is a Whedon insert character? ALL OF THEM. Every single one. The ones you love and the ones you hate are all creations of Whedon's imagination and, to one extent or another and at one time or another, reflect aspects of his personality. It doesn't make sense to assert that Xander is "the" Whedon character without acknowledging that sometimes Buffy is, too, and Willow, and Giles, and so on. They ALL are.
So saying this does not prove Xander is bad and it does not prove that Whedon would do what Xander did in a certain situation. It's badly over-used. Please just drop it.
r/buffy • u/krav_mustaine • Sep 15 '26
Xander Anthony Head was featured in the "in memoriam" of the emmy but not nicky, this not right
anyone feels weird about this ?
r/buffy • u/ikwydls96 • Sep 26 '25
Sequel Controversial opinion: SMG should not be involved in production!
Sarah Michelle Gellar is a great actress. She played buffy very well and I am so glad that she is returning as Buffy, however.. she is going to be involved in the production side of the show as well, which I'm a bit nervous about.
Any show she has been involved in producing has ultimately failed, she also tends to pick mehh projects post-buffy (after buffy I think the grudge was her last successful project!) But the most annoying part of all is she still doesn't get season 6 of buffy. She keeps saying 'I don't even recognise her in that season it felt too off' but that's the whole point of season 6.. where depression can breakdown even the most powerful strong person and change them! That's the point! And thats what makes buffy such a good show! It's relatable too!!
Not to mention she even pitched the idea of buffy and xander getting together by season 7 and yea... let's just say I'm glad that didn't happen lol.
I love Sarah! But she really shouldn't be involved in the writing, production side of the new series. She plays the character well, but she doesn't understand the depth of the show as well as she thinks she does.
EDIT: To make it clear, I'm not saying she should have absolutely NO say in what happens, of course she should! But I don't think she should be in the supervising role for what does and doesn't go into the show! That job should be left for writers and producers, with obvious room for negotiation as well!
r/buffy • u/ComprehensiveFlan638 • Mar 28 '25
This episode irks me.
While it contains some new and slightly interesting information about the hellmouth, the way it’s framed is terrible. Plus Andrew is IMO a sniveling, weak, annoying character undeserving of their protection let alone acceptance into the gang. A few tears and panicked apologies when literally threatened with death is not a genuine redemption. Jonathan should have been the season 7 sidekick. At least he recognised the atrocities of the trio’s actions during season 6 and felt guilty about them.
r/buffy
•
u/sKullsHavezzz
•
May 22 '24
The importance of Xander
Yeah we all had the hots for Buffy and she was unobtainable as heck, but Xander absolutely represented us in that regard and he was so relatable it made the whole show 10 times better, at least for me. It helped that NB was amazing in the role, so believable, funny and phenomenal with the serious moments too. When Xander quietly stops Angelus at the hospital in S2 is one of my all time favourite scenes in television.
I was so sad to learn NB had troubles after the show ended and I just wanted to say, if he ever sees this (unlikely) you're like a personal hero of mine, dude. Hope to see you in something big soon x
r/buffy • u/Ok-Help6334 • Jul 12 '26
Introspective Judging Xander's portrayal let alone any aspect of the show by modern standards is dumb
People seem forget that this show was written in the 90s and as a result the way characters in the show are portrayed right down the dialogue they used were a reflection of the time and culture the show was produced under. Even Joss Whedon once said that if he were to make Buffy today it would be totally different, reflecting the fact that times have changed
r/buffy • u/aeryn1227 • Sep 30 '23
Of all the episodes, I cringe at the one where she loses her virginity to Angel
That episode is so cringeworthy knowing that he lost his soul because he had that perfect moment of happiness and in turn it caused Buffy so much heartache when he later treated her like dirt knowing she had been a virgin. .
I'd rather watch The Body 500X or even SR because at least it sent Spike on a quest for his soul because he was so remorseful and shameful over what he tried to do to her. I really had tried to see the so-called beauty in Bangel at the beginning, but it turned out BEYOND ugly. The way he ridiculed her first time was just beyond the pale. I don't care if it was Angelus at the time. No one should cry uncontrollably the way Buffy did over him and then he goes after her and her friends.
r/buffy • u/PlaneAutomatic4965 • Feb 11 '25
Am I the only one who thought Buffy was unreasonable in
s7 in the argument that gets her kicked out of the house?
I know these are fighting words for so many people. Everywhere I go, everybody thinks that Buffy was hard done too and completely in the right and goes on about how awful the others are. I do agree that they were unfair in actually kicking her out, but honestly Buffy was every bit as bad as they were and needed taken down a peg or six as far as I'm concerned.
To start with, she DID get lots of young girls killed in a stupid plan that just involved leading them into Caleb's base, no tactics, no back up, nothing and took no responsibility for it, other than feeling sorry for herself. No reflection, no genuine guilt, etc. Second she was a physically abusive and hypocritical bitch to Faith the entire time she was there when Faith did nothing. She punched her unprovoked twice and took pleasure in it both times.
Okay I understand that if Faith were real we would never side with her, given the whole killing people thing LOL. Still at the same time, by that stage Buffy's house is full of murderers like Spike and Anya and Giles. Hell Buffy herself has killed several guys, like the Knights of Byzantium. Okay you can argue that was in self defense but she didn't need to kill them. She threw a fecking axe at one's chest rather than his leg or arm!
Meanwhile what started the fight that got her kicked out wasn't even that she got four of the girls killed. It was that she wanted to drag them all back there, which by the way would have been a bad plan. She only got the axe from Caleb because she was alone and could easily dodge his attacks. Think that would have worked with a dozen or so teenage girls, many of whom couldn't fight and were also injured? Caleb would have slaughtered them, and Buffy would have been too desperate trying to fight him to protect them she never would have got the axe and it would have ended up like last time.
Rather than talk it through with the girls and the others and actually think of a plan to get into the vineyard, Buffy threw a tantrum when they didn't want to go back there, pinned it all on Faith "you made them hate me by being fun, not me getting four of them killed in a general custer style plan" and then had the cheek to make out it was her way or no way.
It actually pisses me off that she is sort of proven right by getting the scythe as again she didn't get it through her plan. It was exactly because she was alone and god that scene where Spike has to make out she is so fabulous makes me want to be sick. He's such an arsehole there. Faith was the only one that didn't want to kick Buffy out. Literally all Faith said was let's not drag a bunch of girls into battle, and Buffy threw a tantrum and then Spike pinned all the blame on her like the simp he was and punched Faith unprovoked with Buffy again smiling at it.
I might add her plan in the finale was equally stupid. Hilariously she did the same thing again and just led a group of teenage girls into the hellmouth like general custer and got scores of them killed, and was only saved because of the amulet.
To me Buffy in the latter half of season 7 is extremely unlikable, jealous, hypocritical and utterly incompetent. Her tactics are basically General Melchett from Blackadder just send wave after wave of your troops in and is only saved by outside factors. She deserved to get taken down a peg or two and is just as to blame for being thrown out by not budging on her own stupid plans.
r/buffy • u/advena_phillips • Jan 11 '23
Xander Xander's "Jealousy"
Scrolling through discourse, there seems to be a common thread when it comes to Xander: his jealousy. Does anyone else find this to be incredibly reductive and simplistic to blame everything on Xander's jealousy when it comes to Buffy? Making it one of his core motivations?
There's so many reasons for why Xander might dislike Angel (on top of jealousy), and so many reasons why Xander would hate Spike, and so many reasons why Xander might have a vested interest in Buffy's personal life.
Like, seriously. Buffy is a hot mess. Just the first few seasons alone:
Buffy is the type of person to manipulate and use people when not-dealing with her mental health (i.e. her "dance" with Xander S2E1).
Buffy is the type of person to run away, not tell anyone anything, not update anyone on whether she's alive, and then return out of the blue and act like nothing happened.
Buffy is the type of person who pushes so hard to save her ex-boyfriend now uber evil monster despite him tormenting her friends, despite him murdering her classmates, despite him threatening to end the world. It's only when Jenny dies that she steps up.
Buffy is the type of person to hide said ex-boyfriend then uber evil monster when he returns from a Hell dimension, despite knowing how her ex-boyfriend had hurt / killed the people closest to her.
Like, I don't know about you, but when it comes to Buffy's personal life, not knowing what's up tends to get you hurt in the end. You can argue jealousy until the cows come home, but Xander has more than enough reason to be uncomfortable with Buffy's relationship with both Angel and Spike, and Buffy hiding her relationship with Angel and Spike.
Like, what are y'alls thoughts on the subject? Like, Xander is a problematic character, but I do feel like personal feelings get in the way of a more objective look at the character. He has issues, but I don't think his jealousy is as big a problem, especially later in the series, as it is made out to be.
EDIT: Because I hadn't made it clear, this is in no way a condemnation of Buffy's choices. The point of framing Buffy that way was to depict, say... an uncharitable perspective of a frustrated Friend who does not have the perspective us Fans have. I am very sympathetic towards some of Buffy's decisions, some of them I critique here. Unlike a lot of people, though, I'm able to also understand that Buffy's actions are hurtful to the people closest to her.
ALSO, I am well aware of Xander's issues as a character, and I am well aware that jealousy is a motivation during the first few seasons. I'm just saying it's not the only motivation.
r/buffy • u/Tuna_96 • Oct 02 '25
NEW VIEWER - No spoilers please! I'm so tired of this

I'm so tired guys, everytime someone with color in their skin shows up in this show (or angel) I assume their going to be either evil or dead. and have a very minimal screentime also, obviously it keeps happening.
Gunn is the only exception but sometimes I wish they just didn't because the writing around him is so SO bad, I could write an entire post about how BAD they did him.
r/buffy • u/[deleted] • Nov 13 '23
Season Six Spike is literally the worst.
This is the second time I've ever watched Buffy, the first time being when I was a teenager. The first time thru, I remember being head over heels for Spike, he was 100% part of my sexual awakening. Surprise surprise, I ended up being in an abusive relationship for over 10 years. I'm not saying he's the cause, but it's very clear to me now that I had a type and was attracted to things that were extremely unhealthy for me. I've just gotten back into Buffy, and I was SO EXCITED to get to the Spike and Buffy relationship arc. But then I just finished season 6 and have found myself increasingly repulsed... I mean he's attractive physically, but everything about his personality and obsession with Buffy is gag worthy. Ever since he's had that dream and fallen madly in love with Buffy, I don't think there's been hardly a single conversation where he hasn't tried to manipulate her, fetishize her, and beg her... it's actually disgusting. I legitimately don't remember anything about season 7, but season 6 ends with him getting his soul back for her and... I cant even imagine a worthy redemption arc for him, much less Buffy actually falling in love with him. I hate iiit. I wish she would have been able to end up with Riley, he was so good for her. But now I just hope she's happy alone, because UGH Spike is the ultimate sleazeball.
r/buffy • u/12dancingbiches • Oct 24 '24
Spoilers inside! I lowkey hated Xander
I hated Xander sometimes. He was usually funny but he was also the epitome of being a "good guy." He was all poor me! Im emasculated! I treat buffy badly because she's stronger than me and doesn't want to fuck me!! :(
He reminds me of George from Grey's in which they are more often than not treated like one of the girls, not overly masculine, super whiny, and somehow a fan favorite.
r/buffy • u/eden_tantric • Mar 11 '25
Season Seven Spike shouldn't have kept the jacket
Opinions wanted 👇 Spike shouldn't have kept the jacket. That was bad form
r/buffy • u/Fantastic_Exit_6868 • Feb 05 '25
Content Warning Why the bathroom scene was actually necessary
I think it was a very important scene and I’m honestly glad it happened. As back story, they got the idea from a female writer who had done the same to her boyfriend and because Buffy has powers, they switched the roles. This show is so powerful because of a lot of its supernatural metaphors to explain scenarios in the real world and I do think this scene would have worked much better if Spike had tried to turn her against her will. It would have been a metaphor for SA but would have worked in the sense that after Spike realised he couldn’t make Buffy apart of his world, he decide to make himself part of hers. James Marsters had the same opinion as he felt it wasn’t right to show such a real life scenario, especially since Buffy had the power to defend herself, while many of the viewers wouldn’t have the physical ability to do the same if it was them. He tried everything to stop this scene from happening but he had a contract and was forced against his will to film it (which is incredibly ironic to the actual scene). James also made sure that every contract he had since made sure he’d never have to film another scene like it. However, I do still think the scene should not be ignored like most people do because it’s a vital part of Spike’s development.
Spike's morals for the previous 2 seasons is that he wasn't a good person but he would never hurt Buffy because he loved her. He broke that in the bathroom scene (which was also due to the lines they blurred between lust and violence) and regretted it immediately after. It reminds us that he is still a demon and he is evil at his core but once he's hurt Buffy he immediately decides he'll never do it again and he goes to get his soul back.
Coming back to how lines were blurred between lust and violence, there were other times that Buffy had said she didn’t want to do anything, or asked him to stop but her actions would contradict this by giving in anyway. Same thing happened vice versa at one point. The first time they slept together they literally beat each other up to begin with and found pleasure in the violence. It was incredibly toxic but it’s how their relationship was. In the moment, I genuinely believe Spike took longer to realise she genuinely didn’t want to. She’s always denied being attracted to him and clealry proves she is anyway. At this point, Spike was sick of her denying everything when he knew she had feelings for him and was trying to get her to admit she did. Once again, he’s a demon and he’s selfish. He’d been in love with her for over a year and in that moment he needed to hear her say she felt the same. By the time she kicked him off of her, he realized the impact of what he’d just done and that he’d genuinely hurt her and we see the immediate regret. He feels such disgust with himself afterwards that it drives him to make a change that no other vampire has ever done and seeks out his human side (in a way destroying the evil demon that hurt Buffy).
There’s never a confirmation on why Spike suddenly had the ability to hurt Buffy without the chip causing him pain but my theory is this. He mentioned that if he even has the intention to harm a human, the chip will set off the searing pain to his brain. He could only hurt Buffy after he fell in love with her and I believe this was because there was no intention of ever physically hurting her. She was actually more powerful in a lot of ways and fighting with her didn’t actually damage her in any way (even if it did she would heal very quickly). Whenever he fought with her, it was to prove to her that they were more similar than she thought and in his own messed up way, it was him showing the affection he had for her. There was never any intention to cause her physical pain. If this is the case, it proves further that the bathroom scene was able to happen because Spike never had any intention to physically hurt her and was unaware that he was. This is completely my own theory but it’s the only reasoning that makes sense to me. If Buffy dying was the trigger, I believe Tara would have been able to find that out but she said that Buffy was very much alive and there was nothing to suggest she came back differently.
In conclusion, a demon who is evil and whose natural instinct is destruction, falls in love and cares for her so much, that he wants to be human for her (well not human, but to have a human soul). This is why the scene is so powerful and should not be ignored because it was the turning point that made an evil demon want to be good.
r/buffy • u/Status-Star-8336 • Mar 14 '26
Sequel Apparently she was only to appear for 30 seconds in the last scene...
Soooo hulu has officially not picked up Buffy as im sure we all know by now
There are reports saying buffy only showed up for the last 30 seconds of the pilot
If thats true then im 100% okay with the show not being picked up
I know theres new characters, etc.
But I want Buffy.
I want her from the first scene and I want her in the last scene.
SMG has famously talked about how hard Buffy was on her, and im wondering if passing the reigns completely is what brought her back, from not being so hard on her body but also stepping so far back she doesn't risk hurting her legacy.
We want Buffy. Everything else comes after.
I think the show was going from the POV of a new slayer, with Buffy at a distance. Much like many remakes nowadays are doing with their legacy characters. Thus why the show was no longer "Buffy" but was retitled to "New Sunnydale"
I think hulu knows Buffy is the show and they want her POV.
I hope it still happens (I doubt it will now) but I really hope its Buffy coming back. I dont want anything less.
r/buffy • u/aceofspades85262 • Jun 22 '25
Xander Why is there so much Xander bashing and blaming
Don't get me wrong, season 1 Xander annoys me to no end, but it feels like most people purposely take the worst readings of his actions in everything he does.
He cheats on Cordy with Willow? Obviously he just wanted willow when she was taken because he's the worst nothing to do with the fact his relationship with cordy is largely based on their past contempt for each other and the amount of arguing they do probably parallels his abusive unhappy parents. Also it's all Xanders fault we'll never bring this up with Willow.
Xander tells Buffy to kick Angelus' ass? He obviously only did that because he hates Angel personally, nothing to do with Angelus killing his teacher and threatening his friends and putting Willow in the hospital and the fact he generally hates vampires, he just wants the Buff that bad.
Telling Buffy off for how she treated Riley? Okay yeah he was not the person who should have been telling her this BUT HE WAS RIGHT Riley was always her rebound, and she never treated him like she should have, and I don't even like Riley! But no Xander is just projecting his desire to be with Buffy on Riley, after all he hates her other boyfriends, y'know guy who never liked him then turned evil and guy who spent 2 years trying to kill them and another year manipulating them whose only alive because Buffy doesn't wanna kill someone who can't do harm.
Leaving Anya at the alter? He should have just stayed with a marriage that he had serious doubts about if he could ever be truly loved and happy and normal even after received fake visions of a future unhappy relationship with him hitting him paralleling his parents, this was totally the wrong thing for him to do. Oh and let's not ever talk about how Anya actually tries to kill him after this, because Anya is funny.
Shaming Anya for sleeping with Spike? Okay yeah this one is bad BUT PEOPLE TAKE IT TOO FAR! Yes Xander should not have said those things but he's right, Spike is evil, even if he can't actually hurt anyone he's still Evil, and yeah Anya is a gigantic murderer too but at that point Xander didn't know she was a demon again.
Refusing to go back to the place where he got his eye gouged out? Wow what a sensitive dumbass Buffy would never let that happen again shes so confident this time, this whole episode and situation is just generally terrible writing just so the writers can get Buffy and Spike away from everyone else (this is literally so bad i hate how s7 was structured) but God forbid Xander not wanna go back to the place he was disabled after his friend who lead him there wouldn't even visit him at the hospital and told them of this plan ON HIS WELCOME HOME PARTY!
And of course every bit of Xander bashing is followed by, of course he's Joss' Self Insert, as if the process of writing doesn't involve you putting yourself in everyone on the page, every show has dozens of "self inserts" because characters come from a writer who takes pieces of themselves and expands upon them in characters!
Honestly I can go on and on, there's just so much that Xander gets bashed for and it's so unfair that everyone just reads his character in the worst light possible, I get that he's annoying and his bad actions are some of if not the most normal human bad actions which makes it more easy to grasp as we are normal people who don't typically deal with vampires and demons, but really why this bad for Xander? I don't even have him in my top 5 characters! But goddamn it feels like everyone else has such great hatred for him.
Sorry for the really long rant, if you read the whole thing.
EDIT: I feel like everyone is taking this as, why don't you like Xander, when it's not! This is about how Xander is often viewed in a negative light when things are more complicated than that, part of the reason I made this post because of a comment I saw that said Xander groped Buffy's boobs when she was invisible, when he didn't, the joke is that he reached out at something he couldn't see and touched her. There are hundreds of instances where Xander is just assumed to have the worst intentions, and this post is about that.
EDIT 2: I should not have named this post that, it's not about why people hate Xander its about people taking his actions and intentions in the worst light because they don't like him
r/buffy • u/Royal-Tangelo-5895 • Jul 28 '25
Anya unpopular opinion: i find anya to be annoying and insufferable most times.
dont come at me now, i know anya is a good person and can have her great moments but i found myself sighing when she appeared on screen most times and took me a couple rewatches before i really got to liking her character more. it seemed like every time i walked in on her scene she was talking inappropriately but now i like it alittle bit more and enjoy her but still find her quite annoying
r/buffy • u/hatchbackkk • Oct 23 '24
Buffy & Willow are the only characters that never get unlikeable in my opinion
everyone else has their moments but for me it’s like they could no wrong in my eyes 😫
r/buffy • u/[deleted] • Sep 14 '24
Content Warning Do you think Joss Whedon will make a comeback in the nearest future (about 5-10 years from today)?
As we all know, Joss Whedon has been cancelled since 2019 because he was accused of being rude towards the actors who worked for him when he was making Buffy (and maybe because he was scapegoated for the downfall of Justice Leagye movie). I don't deny that he may be a jerk (but so is James Cameron, yet nobody hates him or thinks he is disgraced), but he didn't do anything illegal. He didn't rape anyone, he didn't steal money from charity organisations, he wasn't selling drugs to children. At worst, Whedon is like Steve Jobs-talented and passionate, but can be very rude. He is not like Harvey Weinstein or Phil Spector. Yet it seems like he was one of the few celebrities who have been permanently cancelled by the court of public opinion....but was he?
I mean, John Lasseter was accused of groping women and yet he is still working in animation industry. Wesley Snipes went to prison for tax evasion and yet he is still starring in the movies. And Mike Tyson straight raped a teenage girl and was still allowed to resume boxing once he got out.
If they could successfully come back despite commiting criminal acts, then I am sure John Lasseter-whose only crime is being an asshole-will also return to the public's good graces sooner or later. I doubt he will never work again in the entertainment industry for the next 30-40 years. I wouldn't even be surpised if he is now writing screenplays under a pen name.
r/buffy • u/Educational_Band_357 • Jan 13 '26
Spike Unpopular opinion: Spike was ruined with chip
When Spike appeared in season 2 he was one of most intimidating vampires in show (altogether with Drusilla). Season 3 dealt pretty good without him but I admit I would watch oryginal Spike more (and that was mistake to break him up wih Drusilla). Season 4 give him chip and here starts overusing him EVERYWHERE and reducing powerful vampire to comic relief punched by everyone and having weird Buffy obsession. Then when chip is gone we have another stupid trigger plot in season 7. What they made with Spike ruined him and the latter seasons of Buffy.