r/books • • Apr 28 '23

I'm so tired of authors describing skin like mine with chocolate or mocha. How would you like it if every time a character who looks like you is introduced they get compared to mayonnaise?

12.6k Upvotes

If I see one more chocolate, mocha, caramel in a character description I'm going to scream. Like at this point if you're doing it it has to be on purpose. It annoys me because we'll get character descriptions like:

"The detective was a portly fellow. His face was marked with pot marks that betrayed his age that his jet black toupee was trying to hide. He rubbed the stubble on his face as he looked over the cold case."

"As I scanned the classroom I saw numerous kids at various levels of interest. Jen was one of the kids who was at level zero. Head down and covered by her brunette hair. Her skinny frame looked as if it was getting swallowed by the oversized desk. I went to wake her up."

"Jackson was a man that took care of his body. He worked out twice a day. He had clear smooth skin that a blemish wouldn't dare to sabotage. His only flaw was that he was balding. After growing out his beard he made the big decision to cut all of the hair on his head off. "

Which are cool they give you a quick sense of the character and let you easily formulate a mental picture of the character. And then we'll get descriptions like:

"Ebony was a mocha chocolate queen. Her caramel and cream complexion would have stopped any person in their tracks. Her gold hoop earrings swayed like her hips as she walked towards me."

Like BRUHHHHHH.

All these examples above don't mention race. They could technically be anyone. But it's like they are explicitly saying when someone is black, in a cliché way at that. And when someone is white they don't ever explicitly say. It's just assumed white is the default and everything has to be explained or addressed.

Sorry for the vent. It's just dehumanizing, and fetishizing. I get it you've read one book they described a white person as having milky skin. It's not the same.

If you want better ways to describe skin tone check out this helpful link! I would be fine with literally any description that doesn't have a historical connotation of dehumanizing and fetishizing black people.

If you'd rather have an author who describes people of all colors the best I've ever seen read nk jemisin.

https://www.tumblr.com/writingwithcolor/96830966357/words-for-skin-tone-how-to-describe-skin-color?source=share

People asked for more context of this being an issue so here's more links. I'm trying to reply to folks but many aren't seeing them.

https://www.jstor.org/stable/25070063

https://www.reddit.com/r/dating_advice/comments/kxb8wb/as_a_black_woman_i_absolutely_hate_being_called/

https://gothamist.com/food/naomi-campbell-not-happy-that-cadbury-called-her-chocolate

https://nyunews.com/2018/09/23/09-24-ops-porcher/

This chocolate thing isn't something I'm making up. It's a relatively common complaint into black spaces.

The book "The Delectable Negro: Human Consumption and Homoeroticism within U.S. Slave Culture" also touches on this! If you're not understanding the history, context or just not getting how calling a black person chocolate and a white person milk are different and how it's definitely fetishizing, dehumanizing and sexual, read this book!




Edit: there's seems to be this assumption that I'm young and some kinda Twitter/tumblr sjw who is only looking to be outraged and this isn't isn't a real thing that happens and if it is it's not that bad. And if it's that bad there's more important things we can be talking about.

Also there's a sweeping assumption that I'm a woman because my comments were seen as emotional and frustrated and because no man cares about you this shit.

I'm a dude. I'm black. It's just a topic I care about. Calling black people chocolate is fetishizing and has so much historical context behind it it's jarring. It's also cliché. So much so it's a old topic. I seriously didn't think I'd have to prove this common thing exists.

Yes white people sometimes get described as milky, alabaster or the other terms in comments. No it's not the same thing as describing black people as chocolate. It's dehumanizing and fetishizing.

Ask any black woman who is on dating apps how many times she's called chocolate by white men and then ask her if she likes it.

TLDR: if you're going to describe skin color, describe everyone's skin color not just anyone not white. If you're describing black people don't use chocolate or mocha etc because they are fetishizing and dehumanizing. Have empathy, just bec you personally don't care about this subject doesn't mean it's not important.

For all the people telling me I'm a coward or a bitch for not replying to (insert comment here) and that I'm a troll for not replying.

I did reply. Every chance I get I'm replying to over 1000 comments.

All my comments are down voted to hell. I ain't mad, it's the price of doing business on reddit. But I promise you I replied. Most people casually browsing can't see it because all my replies are going to the literal bottom of each thread.


r/books • • Aug 03 '21

If a fictional universe has dragons and magic in it, there's no real reason it can't also have black people or Asian people in it.

18.7k Upvotes

I think the idea of fantasy worlds are so cool. I love seeing dragons and magic and struggles between good and evil. It's all amazing to me. But when some people get their panties in a twist about forced diversity because one background character is darker than others it just makes me think that you're too indoctrinated by this political climate we live in to enjoy the actual story. There's a fucking dragon getting slayed but you are pissed there's an Asian wizard in the background in the climatic fight scene? That doesn't sound like an actual grevience. Sounds like a personal problem.

I'll take it a step further. I don't care if main characters are diverse. If it's a fictional world not based on any real people I say go nuts. People say it's pandering but litterally it's all pandering. White dudes get pandered too so much they don't even notice it like a fish in water. Let me have a bad ass Asian dude on a quest to unite the four kingdoms with a bad ass party full of knights and wizards. I don't care as long as the story is good but someone being a different skin color in a fantasy setting that's not based on actual things that happened doesn't and shouldn't bother anyone.

Edit: Quick notes because I got pretty overwhelmed with the response.

  • when I say Asian I mean people of Asian decent in the story. Not litterally from Asia in a fictional universe. Like you'd describe Asian coded people in your world like how the shu are described in 6 of crows. Not put Asian products africa in your fantasy world.

  • I don't mean only Asian or black people. It's every miniority underrepresented people in fantasy. Gay, Indian, trans, Hispanic etc etc.

  • saying "but what if they changed black Panther white isn't a gotcha. It's a really cliché disengenous argument..

  • Diversity doesn't ever need justification. Ever. I shouldn't ever have to justify my existence. Especially when you never try to justify the existence of white people.

  • representation is important. Just because you don't personally see the value of it doesn't mean it isn't valuable.

  • yes I have read more than one fantasy book. The fact that people would attack me and gatekeep because I haven't read your favorite series is messed up. I'm just as real of a fan as you.

  • me making this post isn't forcing diversity down your throat.

  • saying I don't want diversity I just want good stories is just telling on yourself. Firstly, wanting both is perfectly okay. Secondly, they aren't mutually exclusive.

  • no, "just imagining the characters as whatever you want" isn't an answer. If the character is clearly described as a white dude, and is casted as a white dude in the movies, me imagining he looks like me does nothing to fix the issues we're talking about.

  • asking why people still care about skin color ignores how many people can't choose to ignore their skin color. In America people are still treated differently and have very different lived experiences because of their skin color. Stop saying that like it's a obvious answer it's not and it's off topic.

  • no wanting more diversity isn't racist.

  • I truly don't care about karma. It can't buy me anything. I never understood reddits obsession with karma. I didn't realize there's an unwritten rule about not crossposting after a certain date. So if that bothered you I'm sorry. I updated the post with the bulleted thoughts because the intention wasn't to do that.

Look man all I wanted to do here was vent about how I wanted to see more diverse fantasy but yall one one. No one should be called racist because they care about representation.


r/books • • Mar 23 '24

The 'White Gaze' in Literature: A Discussion Inspired by Toni Morrison

0 Upvotes

I've been pondering the subtle, yet powerful influences of perspective in literature and media, particularly what we often refer to as the 'male gaze' and a concept closely related to it – the 'white gaze.'

The male gaze, as we know, is about how narratives often reflect a masculine point of view, especially in the portrayal of women. It shapes not just visual representation but also the narratives we tell and consume.

The 'white gaze,' on the other hand, centers on how white authors and audiences view and depict narratives, often positioning white experiences and perspectives as the norm. This gaze affects how stories of other ethnicities are told – if they are told at all – often leading to a skewed representation of these experiences.

What really spurred my thoughts on the 'white gaze' was a profound transcript from an interview with Toni Morrison. She eloquently discusses the expectations and assumptions placed upon writers, particularly regarding race. Morrison emphasizes that her work consciously resists the white gaze, which often marginalizes non-white narratives and experiences.

She mentions how African writers like Chinua Achebe and Bessie Head helped shape her understanding of the centrality of her race in her work. Morrison notes the liberation she felt in not having to cater to the white gaze, saying, “I’ve spent my entire writing life trying to make sure that the white gaze was not the dominant one in any of my books.” This stance wasn't about who reads her books but about asserting her sovereignty and authority as a racialized person.

This brings us to a critical point in our discussion: How can we, as readers and writers, become more aware of these gazes – be it the male gaze or the white gaze – and work towards a literature that is inclusive and true to the diversity of human experiences?

Morrison's reflection raises an important question about the expectation for minority writers to write about or for a white audience, subtly imposing a standard that isn't equally expected from white authors. Her words suggest that breaking free from these imposed gazes is not just about broadening representation but about reclaiming narrative sovereignty.

I'd love to hear your thoughts on this. Have you noticed these influences in your reading? How do you think writers and readers can contribute to a change in this dynamic?


r/books • • Apr 03 '25

WeeklyThread Favorite Books with Transgender Characters: April 2025

44 Upvotes

Welcome readers,

March 31 was International Transgender Day of Visibility and, to celebrate, we're discussing our favorite books with transgender characters!

If you'd like to read our previous weekly discussions of fiction and nonfiction please visit the suggested reading section of our wiki.

Thank you and enjoy!


r/books • • May 31 '12

Reading 'Hitchiker's Guide', and came across this...

Thumbnail
imgur.com
309 Upvotes

r/books • • May 29 '24 Bless Up

Project Hail Mary was the first book I DNFd in years

0 Upvotes

I gave up on PHM after about 75%. Just couldn’t make it through anymore. And I’m someone who rarely ever DNFs anything - I’m just stubborn like that.

Despite some truly interesting sf concepts, the book failed to hit the mark in every other department. I think first and foremost it was the writing that made me cave. The prose is just wooden and elementary on a level I couldn’t handle anymore. I know it’s supposed to be a fun popcorn book and not literature but still - even for disposable entertainment it was bad.

Another issue I had was with the main protagonist. He was just annoying without anything interesting or compelling about him as a character. In fact, he kinda reminded me of a Redditor - smug, self-righteous with some of the most groanworthy quips and attempts at humour I’ve experienced in a MC in a while. I’d always read the quotes and memes people posted from this book on Reddit and think “huh maybe it’s actually funny in the right context?” But no, it isn’t really.

Rocky was a cool character though so I’ll give Andy weir credit for that. But still not enough to force myself through the book. It’s weird because The Martian was kinda poorly written too but I still enjoyed it way more because the protagonist wasn’t as irritating.


r/books • • Jan 21 '24

1Q84 is disgusting NSFW Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The initial installment of 1Q84 demanded patience due to its gradual pace, but I persevered given the widespread acclaim for Haruki Murakami's work. The second book, however, gripped my attention more profoundly. It appears the first book serves as an introduction, while the second delves into an elucidation, building up to the climax.

The portrayal of Aomame's friendships struck me as peculiar. The depiction of her engaging in sexual relationships with her female friends raised questions, as her sexual orientation is not explicitly revealed as bisexual. It seems like these descriptions cater more to a male fantasy, akin to a porn scene between two women that falls short of authentically portraying a lesbian relationship.

The discomfort intensified as Tengo, a 29-year-old man, described the breasts of Fukaeri, a 17-year-old girl with dyslexia. But for me, the end of the road wasn't reached until the middle of the second book. In the first book, we encountered a 10-year-old girl who was raped before her menarche and her uterus was torn apart. The leader of the group then used moral relativity to explain that it was not a voluntary decision, that his penis would only get harder, and him lost the control about his own body, while some girls had sex with him. After Aomame kills the leader, the protagonist of the story goes through the same situation. His penis initially hardens from Fukaeri's youthful scent, which is described as something only young girls can smell, like the high school bus in the morning (which in itself sounds like a pedophile). He then fell asleep and when he woke up he couldn't move. The sex scene are depicted as Fukairi's duties and desires, and her hairless genitals are depicted in a manner similar to Vladimir Nabukov's in "Lolita."

What scares me the most is that the work introduces the theme of sexual abuse of girls and then plays a game of moral relativism in which adult men are exempted from this guilt. Tengo's descriptions of his sexual experiences with his penis, including descriptions of the size of his organ's penetration deep into a small teenager body, are disgusting. The book defends Tengo's pedophile behavior, while him seems to portray the hero of the book. I don't know if I have the energy to read a third book, and I'm still trying to understand the hype surrounding this author.His works are described as fiction, but they seem more like a justification for pedophilia.


r/books • • Sep 22 '24

Anachronistic feminism in feminist retellings

0 Upvotes

I'm currently about 20% into Kaikeyi by Vaishnavi Patel and the anachronistic feminism is starting to annoy me. Her throwing a petulant tantrum over the fact that she has no say in who she marries seems really out of norm for a princess in her time. She can think it's unfortunate, but I would think that every member of a royal family just accepts it as their duty. The blurb says that she becomes "a warrior, diplomat, and most favored queen" and I get the feeling that Patel is going to have her Disney Princess girl boss her way through patriarchy (please let me know if I am wrong).

I enjoy strong female MCs and feminist retellings, but the "anything boys can can do, girls can do better" kind of feminism in a historical context just feels... very YA. I think a more nuanced feminist retelling is Circe (Miller) and The Witch's Heart (Gornichec), where they deal with patriarchy by choosing not to engage with the patriarchy, until they are forced to, and their ultimate goal is to be left alone to do as they please. Another great example is Spinning Silver (Novik) where both FMC takes a crappy situation and use their skills and intelligence to turn it around for them, for survival and political gain, not to prove something.

Maybe I am an old, jaded woman, but I'm just annoyed with Kaikeyi because I feel like I'm being pandered to and it's just as annoying when a woman does it, as when a man does it. But, I am only 20% of the way in. There's a very real chance that Kaikeyi goes through some character arc. My understanding is that Kaikeyi is also a villain retelling of a story I am not familiar with, and maybe in the context of her original story, her feminism isn't anachronistic?

Please share your thoughts on feminist retellings. Do you have a favorite? Are they unnecessary? Does it help you better contextualize the original stories? Did I unfairly judget Kaikeyi too early into the book?


r/books • • Jan 13 '18

11 incredible books by writers from shithole countries

Thumbnail
electricliterature.com
27.0k Upvotes

r/books • • Aug 24 '21

Posts from men expressing surprise and delight that they enjoyed a “women’s book” are not heartwarming posts… they are disturbing.

16.0k Upvotes

Yes, this is partly in response to the recent Little Women post, but more broadly about similar posts I have seen here that always seem to get a lot of attention and praise and many comments I’ve seen over the years.

Like so many other teenage girls in high school, I had to read and relate to 95% male-centric stories written by men. I never questioned why we were reading so many “boy books” because the books were not presented as "boy books," they were just presented as normal literature. The curriculum at my school allowed for just a smidgeon of diversity with Pride and Prejudice and The Scarlet Letter. This was never seen as an issue; it’s just how it was. I still remember clearly hearing the boys in my small class groaning about having to read a “girl book” when we started Pride and Prejudice. The fact that the author was a woman or the main characters women or some combination of those two facts in the boys’ minds was enough to make them sneer at it. It was mildly annoying then, but deeply infuriating and sad now looking back on it years later. Maybe, just maybe, if some of the great female authors and female-centric stories that have been written throughout history had been a part of our Literature curriculums starting from a young age and this was presented as NORMAL, we wouldn’t have high school boys joking and sneering at having to read a “girl book.”

You can see the same scenario when men discover that movies like Mean Girls and Legally Blonde are, in fact, great movies. There was a post like this too recently on the movies subreddit. “I didn’t think I would like a chick flick, but it’s actually really good!” Turns out that women are just people, and stories about them and the things they go through are equally as valid and worthy of being told. What a mind-blowing concept!

The way these statements are phrased as such delightful revelations makes me cringe, and then I feel sad, and then I feel a bit angry, because on some level, whether subconsciously or consciously, the driving force behind these sentiments and posts is that women are “other.” They are not the standard human, they are not fully-fledged standard human people in the same way that men are, so their stories and stories written by them are a sort of “special interest” sub-category of women’s fiction. “Girl books.” “Woman’s book.” “Chick-flicks.”

Consider this hypothetical scenario and how utterly ludicrous it sounds to us:

”As a middle-aged woman, I didn’t think I would be able to enjoy Lord of the Flies. I don’t know what it’s like to be a boy so I didn’t think I could possibly relate to these characters and their struggles, but I actually really enjoyed it! Even though it’s about male characters, I found the story to be really great overall and dealing with deep themes. It’s not just a boy book, it’s great literature!”

See? Sounds pretty damn ridiculous, doesn’t it?

Girls and women are perfectly capable of viewing male-authored/male-centric stories as just normal good literature because that is the way it is presented to us from a young age all the way up to older education. This is how we are conditioned (with no real choice in the matter), while boys and men are never forced to view female-authored/female-centric stories the same way.

So, next time you see on of these posts, I’m not calling for us to be rude and antagonistic to the OPs, because what they are doing is technically good I suppose, but I dislike the way they are wanting a pat on the back and upvotes simply for viewing women’s stories as good valid literature worthy of being read.

It is sad and disturbing that women continue to be seen as the “other” in fiction, a sub-category separate from the established standard of “good literature.”

There is no logical reason other than deeply engrained misogyny in society why a man should be that surprised that Little Women is a good book. It’s sold millions of copies, had tons of adaptations, is extremely well-known and deeply beloved by people all over the globe. It should not be that surprising that this “women’s book” is in fact, just a good piece of literature regardless of the gender of author or characters. Women are literally just people, and their stories are equally as worthy of being told and read as male stories. We are all part of the same humanity.

The sentiment of “Wow, this isn’t just for women, it’s actually a good story!” carries the not-so-subtle implication that things that are “for women” are inherently lesser. They are seen as a separate sub-category other than the standard that can sometimes achieve “great literature” status despite their femaleness. The surprise expressed by men who find these stories to be great implies that their perception shifted, they believed something about the “women’s book” before, and now believe something different having read it.

I am 25 now, so I don't know how things are in high schools nowadays. For anyone who does know, are the English Lit curriculums more balanced now or is it still the vast majority of male author/male story? I'm very curious to know.

I want to hear your thoughts on this matter.

Edit: Huge thank you to the commenters that actually read my post (something that is too much to ask for many people I guess) and understand what I’m saying. This comment from u/SchrodingersHamster is probably buried so I’ll highlight it here:

“Right, I doubt anyone is sorting by new here anymore but SO many people are missing the point of this post.

OP is not "discouraging" men from reading women's literature. Read the post again. She is focusing specifically on the idea that, from a man's perpsective, women's literature being good is surprising, so surprising that it warrants a post on how surprising it is. That the expectation that women's literature (and art in general) is so much lesser than men's that it becomes a shock when a man reads it and enjoys it.

It is NOT OP's responsibility to "encourage men" to read women's books. The fact that so many men are unwilling to read women's literature is an issue brought about by patriarchal assumptions that men should be sorting out, not women. Women don't need to hold our hands, guide us to all the great female writers, pat us on the back and give us a gold star when we enjoy it. It is not their responsibility. It is ours as men.

OP should not be praising these men. In fact OP, along with the rest of us, should be criticising these mindsets. We should look at these posts through a critical lens, otherwise how are we supposed to move forward? There are plenty of people on this comment section who would much rather OP kept quiet and that the issue is never highlighted or solved, simply because it might be too upsetting for men to read. If you're a man and that's really how you respond when reading this post, grow up.”


r/books • • Jul 22 '24 Heartwarming Take My Silver Heart of Silver

Why Colorblind Writing Is Tone-Deaf and Why Describing Race Matters

0 Upvotes

Yo, nothing grinds my gears more than when some writers talk about wanting to do "colorblind" writing. They be out here like, "Oh, I didn't describe skin color at all in my book, so anyone could be anything. You're racist for assuming my characters are white." Nah, miss me with that tone-deaf BS.

Here's the thing, right? When they say they ain't mention skin color, what they don’t get is that there are so many implicit cues in their writing that tell me these characters ain’t Black. Like, I'm Black, and living in America has made me hypersensitive to figuring out if characters look like me. It's a skill I picked up just navigating this world. Writers can signal race without spelling it out, but when they try this "colorblind" approach, all it does is enforce a white default. It's hegemonic, straight up.

Firstly, race is a fundamental part of many people's identities. When you fail to acknowledge it, you’re erasing a significant aspect of who they are. For Black people, our skin color, our culture, our history—these are integral to our experiences and how we navigate the world. Ignoring race isn’t being inclusive; it’s erasing vital parts of characters’ identities and experiences. When characters are described as raceless, it often defaults to whiteness because that's the societal norm. This default erases the rich diversity that exists in the real world and perpetuates a narrow worldview.

Secondly, representation matters. When readers see themselves reflected in the characters they read about, it validates their existence and experiences. For Black readers, seeing characters who share their skin color, cultural background, and experiences can be empowering. It’s affirming to see someone like you being the hero, the love interest, or even just a complex individual in a story. It’s not just about seeing yourself in the story; it’s about feeling seen and valued in a world that often sidelines or stereotypes you.

Describing race adds depth and realism to your story. When you acknowledge a character’s race, you also open up opportunities to explore different cultural backgrounds, histories, and perspectives. This enriches your narrative and makes it more relatable to a broader audience. For instance, if a character is Black, mentioning their skin color, hair texture, and cultural practices adds layers to their identity and how they interact with the world around them. It brings authenticity and richness to your storytelling.

Let’s break it down. Names, for example, carry a lot of weight. If a character in America has the last name Freeman or Williams, chances are they're Black. Same with Chinese surnames for Chinese characters. These little things matter. Names like Hernandez, Nguyen, or Patel immediately give context to a character's ethnic background. You can't just ignore these nuances and expect readers to insert their own interpretation. It's lazy and disingenuous. Think about it—names are often one of the first indicators of someone's background. In literature, it’s no different. If you name a character "DeShawn," most people will visualize a Black person, just like naming a character "Mei" might indicate they're Chinese. It's subtle but powerful.

Noting skin color by contrast is perfectly fine, though describing skin color alone isn't always enough. You gotta consider facial features and cultural or religious garments. For instance, afro hair to Black folks can be a dead giveaway, even though there's incredible diversity within Black hair itself. Think about it: tight, loose, thick, thin, dense, light, heavy, springy, silky, sheen, porous. Describing these textures helps paint a vivid picture. Mention the style—whether it's braids, locs, twists, cornrows, bantu knots, or afros. Each style has its own history and cultural significance, and they can say a lot about a character without you having to spell it out. Facial features, like fuller lips or a broader nose, can be additional indicators. It’s not about stereotypes; it’s about reflecting the diversity within races accurately.

Engaging with a character’s culture is another way to show race. If your character is celebrating Chinese New Year and reflecting on what it means to them, we're likely gonna assume they're Chinese. Cultural context, like food, language, and house decor, can communicate a lot about a character's background. A character’s environment and how they interact with it can be telling. Maybe they're in a Black Student Union, or someone tries to recruit them to a school, club, program, or organization that pertains to their race. These little touches add depth and authenticity. Cultural practices, holidays, and traditions can be seamlessly woven into the narrative. For example, a character’s nostalgia over Kwanzaa celebrations or reminiscing about making tamales for Christmas provides rich, cultural context without explicitly stating their race.

The character's voice can reveal a lot too. They might casually mention something specific to their race or face micro-aggressions, hinting at their background. For example, a character might make a quirky or casual statement related to their race, or they might talk about a racial grievance or face racism or micro-aggressions. It’s all about integrating these details seamlessly into the narrative. How a character speaks, their choice of words, slang, and even code-switching can give away their racial background. For instance, a Black character might use African American Vernacular English (AAVE) in their dialogue, providing a cultural marker that doesn't require direct explanation.

Sometimes, it's okay to just state it. Saying a character is Black, Indian, etc., can fit naturally into the narrative without being jarring. Describing parents, what they look like, and how it compares to your character is another smooth way to indicate ethnicity. There’s honestly no shame in just stating a character is Black, Indian, etc. It’s like with any story detail; it should fit naturally as it may be odd to just blurt it without cause. Incorporating physical descriptions alongside their racial identity can be effective. For example, "Her father, with his dark brown skin and close-cropped hair, stood tall next to her fair-skinned mother."

In fantasy settings, describing Black hair when the terms don’t exist is still possible. It's a way to implicitly say what race a character is. In fantasy it's something readers can pick up on! Be descriptive—talk about tight, loose, thick, or springy hair. Mention braids, twists, locs as “neat rows of braids” or “thick, coarse hair pulled into rough locks.” Afro hairstyles can be described in a way that fits the world you’re building. For instance, Bantu knots could be described as “tiny twisted knobs,” cornrows as “neat rows of braids along her scalp,” and locs as “thick ropes of hair.” Using familiar terms in creative ways helps convey the style even if the specific word doesn’t exist in your world. Think of descriptive phrases like “her hair coiled tightly like springs” or “his braids were interwoven into a complex pattern across his scalp.” These descriptions are evocative and maintain the essence of the hairstyle without needing the exact term.

When you describe hair, think about textures and looks: tight, loose, thick, thin, dense, light, heavy, springy, silky, sheen, porous. Afro textures and curls can be described as cloudy, coiled, corkscrews, crimped, curly, natural, poufy, ringlets, spirals, texturized, wavy. For braids, use terms like crossed, folded, interlaced, layered, looped, plaits/plaited, rolled, woven. These words can help be more specific with the look of their hair/hairstyle. Tight, tiny braids. Cloudy puffs of hair in twin pigtails. Even the way hair is maintained or styled can give cultural context. For instance, a character might spend time oiling their scalp, twisting their hair into locs, or using a durag to keep their waves intact.

Another thing to note is that stopping to describe only Characters of Color implies White = default, so be sure to describe your White characters as well within your writing. It’s all about balance and authenticity. Threading indicators like these, at least early on and then throughout the story at your discretion, should be effective for letting us know the character is of a certain race. Describe your white characters too, don’t leave them as the default. If you describe a Black character’s rich brown skin, also take a moment to mention another character’s pale, freckled complexion. This creates a balanced and inclusive narrative.

When it comes to interactions and dialogue, remember that the way characters speak to each other can be revealing. A younger or older character might boldly note the differences in their skin or looks to the character. Someone might make a funny, awkward, exoticizing, racist, or insensitive comment or joke. These interactions can be subtle ways to indicate race. It’s not just about microaggressions; it’s about the everyday realities characters face that reflect their lived experiences.

Even where a character lives, the community they’re part of, and their surroundings can all hint at their racial background. Is the neighborhood predominantly Black? Are there cultural markers like local soul food restaurants, African markets, or churches with gospel choirs? Describing these elements helps build a world that feels real and inclusive. For example, a character might walk past a mural celebrating Black history or hear the rhythmic beats of a drum circle in a park.

TL;DR:

Colorblind writing is tone-deaf and lazy. Failing to describe race erases a significant part of characters' identities and defaults to whiteness. Describing race matters because it validates readers' experiences, adds depth and realism to stories, and reflects true diversity. Use names, physical descriptions, cultural context, and character voice to indicate race without being stereotypical. Balance descriptions of characters of all races to avoid implying a white default. Representation is crucial for creating inclusive and authentic narratives.


r/books • • Jul 26 '26

Sanderson/Mistborn era 2: when an author can't leave a good thing alone Spoiler

0 Upvotes

[To be clear, this is not another Sanderson shitpost; I think he is in many respects a very good writer, to the point where I have read 10 of his books in the last half year. But a lot of his decision-making baffles me, and I'd like to talk about it with some nuance, if possible.]

*Warning, tons of spoilers for all of Mistborn, up to and including The Lost Metal*

There's a lot to say, but my main argument centres on this: killing off Kelsier in the first book of Mistborn 1 was the best decision Sanderson could have made. Bringing him back as some sort of demi-ghost-god who keeps trying to scheme and influence things was just about the worst thing he could have done.

When I read the original Mistborn trilogy, I was totally gripped by it. I loved the sense of adventure, discovering the intricacies of the world, the magic system. By book 3, I got a little disappointed that everything suddenly went on a cosmic/divine scale, which I already thought detracted from the gravity of the story. It's quite hard to sell the concept of nearly-all-powerful divine beings who constantly influence everything and have various levels of omniscience and foresight, but can still be bested by humans in the very nick of time.

But then Mistborn era 2 just doubles down on that and starts relegating just about everything to the gods. The plots just became more and more needlessly complicated in order to keep stacking the 'gotcha' moments and big reveals. Then Secret History goes and makes everything even more opaque and needlessly complex.

This makes me sad, because some of the character work was genuinely great - the way Wax and Steris' relationship develops is lovely, and Wayne is delightful, with the chapters written from his unreliable narrator point of view a highlight. But it's as if Sanderson doesn't trust his human-level character work and plotting enough, and thinks he needs an added layer of intrigue and mystery to somehow interconnect all of his work and make people keep reading.

The thing is, in the foreword to Secret History, Sanderson himself admits that he was wary of writing that story and bringing back Kelsier since it risks complications and contradictions - but then for some reason he went and did it anyway. To me this is like a painter unable to recognise when the painting is finished and just adding more and more layers of paint with increasingly worse results.

Am I alone in feeling like Mistborn 2 would have worked so much better as a simple standalone series, with some fun nods to era 1 for keen readers, without having to lift everything to crazy complex intergalactic divine levels? Or do you enjoy the cosmic intertwining? Would love to hear some thoughts.


r/books • • Jan 15 '25

How do author's scandals affect your reading of their work?

62 Upvotes

In light of the recent Gaiman scandal/accusations/SA, but also concerning controversies with another authors, even other celebrities (actors, singers,...). Does it change the way you view their work?

I will admit it affects me very little, if at all. I consider authors as separate entities from their work. HP books were a cornerstone of my childhood, and how JKR is now behaving doesn't impact that at all. The same with Gaiman's body of work. I loved his books and what he did or didn't do is irrelevant for that. I do see a possible "conflict of interest" in buying a new book from a disgraced or suspicious author. Is it an approval of his actions and/or lifestyle? I don't know. Would I read something new from Gaiman? Probably yes if it piqued my interest (just like I would decide before this happened). Avoiding reading something, especially if you like the book or it is well regarded, just because an author turned out to be a PoS seems pointless. What are your views?


r/books • • Aug 11 '21

There Is no such thing as "forced diversity". There doesn't need to be a justification for having diverse stories.

3.5k Upvotes

Just to be frank, it really annoys me so much when people complain about forced diversity or, having diversity forced down our throats, or trying to find a reason to "justify" the diversity in whatever book they are reading. Like your favorite book is litterally set in a world with dragons, magic, and witches but having a black dude is where you draw the line and need to justify him and his existence somehow? It makes even less sense in sci fi where we have space ships, cyborgs, flying cars, and laser guns. That's just bullshit. No one ever says a story with a bunch of straight white dudes is "forced". There's never any justification for a story to have only or majority white dudes. They are allowed to just exist and never have to be the "white character". But when you have a gay, Asian, black, woman etc etc character suddenly it's an issue that needs to be explained and justified.

When you really break it down people who use "forced diversity" unironically usually mean, "forced Diversity" as in when diverse people appear in a work for the sole purpose of garnering attention and/or sales or "Forced Diversity" is when diverse people are poorly written.

The first one usually heard cries of pandering. But that's all advertising is its pandering. To be frank, white people who are usually the ones being pandered to seem to have an issue with it when it's done for others. Like of course you'd market a book about black people to gasp black people. That's smart marketing and knowing your audience. In the world of film Tyler perry is a master at that.(no matter how little I think of his movies). And the vast majority of the time it's never the "sole" reason a character exists, just the one people use to denounce said character. It's one of the many reason that make up the fully developed character. Which leads me to my next point.

People say a diverse character is "forced" if they're poorly written. They never say this about white straight dudes. I can think of dozens of horribly written white dude characters who have never been called forced. Just badly written. White characters seem to be given more leeway in this regard. If a diverse character isn't perfect and have great flaws and motivations they are automatically called "forced". This goes to my earlier point of needing "a reason" or "justification" for diverse characters. Which is just asanine. You shouldn't have to explain why people are gay or justify why black people exist in some fantasy world.

An obvious caveat is if the story is set in a monolithic country I don't expect to find people outside of that ethnic group in that movie. It can be done and done well to make sense in canon but obviously not the norm. Like how nk jemisin does her novels or how six of crows did it in regards to different races. My whole post is more so talking about a country like America where its a melting pot with lots of diversity. And even greater diversity in certain parts. But Like yeah, some fantasy is based on old European myths or whatever. But If a black background character in the background rustles your jimmies that much you got bigger problems. If you need complex lore reasons for lore that explain generational migration patterns, but just accept dragons at face value. I don't know what to tell you.

Another answer some people come up with to solve the forced diversity issue is to write in a colorblind fashion. And that's a problem in and of itself because It defaults whiteness. Plus when people write in a colorblind fashion people still implicitly say their characters are white in lots of ways. You describe your characters hair as "mousey"(hairstyle never attributed to black people), you describe their icey blue eyes or firey red hair, you say they are tall dark and handsome, you talk about how they are blushing, you litterally only mention skin color when it comes to diverse characters.

I remember these few comments very vividly that talked about this phenomenon of defaulting whiteness in literature. here, here & here. They talk about how defaulting whiteness is so pervasive in books that lots of black people just make the characters white in our heads until told otherwise. Like how fucked is that.

To go even further that last point about defaulting whiteness You say John has brown hair blue eyes like ice and is tall, you say Julie is short with mousey pink hair and piercing eyes tattoos. You say James is tall with a bright smile and skin dark as midnite. Usually people don't comment on James' dark brown hair or dark brown eyes. This is common in alot of books and once you notice it you can't stop. John and Julie are implicitly implied to be white here because the author only makes note of skin color when it comes to the black character everyone else they usually describe by hair or eye color at first.

And just to clarify a few points I'm sure will be raised.

"ugh who gives a fuck, I'm tired of hearing about this. It's all virtue signaling from the woke Twittersphere anyway. There's a hidden agenda to force writers to write this crap. And to force it down readers throats. It doesn't matter what color the characters are as long they are good characters, good characters don't make me address and actually research any differences between them and my lived experience. But I'll read the absolute fuck out of dragon v. elves combat without my sense of realism."

Please don’t be this guy. This guy isn't very cash money. But seriously, this knee jerk reaction stifles conversation and is so reactionary. I'm not signaling the virtue of anything I'm just a black dude who likes seeing himself represented in stoeies because for the majority of my life it was litterally outside of my realm of imagination to see a black wizard.

"well acktually there is forced diversity! [insert poc/women/lgbtq] character is actually written good and it's [insert poc /women /Lgbtq+] that's written bad. Checkmate!

Don't be like this guy either. Both those characters have been called forced by virtue of just existing. They both will be held to a different standard that white characters aren't held to. You never compare other white dude characters and say! See this is how you write a white man correctly. No, they are treated as just the default so if they are written badly its not a commentary on the whole gender or race. They just are one singular bad character. But God forbid a diverse character isn't up to the invisible gold standard you set, that you don't hold white dude characters, now they are forced when really they are simply a badly written character.

It's just bad writing. They are badly written. Keep the same energy and don't treat these characters different and hold them to different standards than to white characters.

"actually, forced diversity is very real, if you only have one [miniority] character you only have a token. That's forced. They just wanted brownie points that helped virtue signal to get extra woke tokens so they could use to pay protection money from the alphabet mafia"

Tokenism isn't an example of forced diversity it's just bad writing. If you're writing one character who's underdeveloped, represents everyone of that [race, sex, orientation etc] and is the only representation of them in the story, and is horribly written you are a bad writer who wrote a token. You can fix this by fleshing out their character, adding more diversity so they aren't the literal only representations of that group, research to help with authenticy.

No one is calling for tokens, agendas, or "forcing" authors to write anything. It's implied that people want well written characters. If you don't want to have tokens in your work make them more diverse so that one character isn't the line represenitive representing that [race/gender/sexuality etc]. If you feel forced to write characters other than white dudes. Than maybe take some introspection on why you feel that way. I promise you stories with white dudes still make up the majority of sells. Things getting more diverse isn't taking anything away from you. And if you're a reader upset at the diversity shoved down your throat have some empathy and imagine it must feel for some people to starve to see themselves in the books they read while you take it for granted.

I made a similar post before on a different sub awhile ago because at the time I really was feeling frustrated with how many black character in comics or in some of fantasy novel or what have you have been called forced or a token. It's unfairly put on other characters too characters who are poc and LGBT too mThe stories we love to read being us to amazing places that only exist in our wildest imaginations. Just because the character isn't a white straight dude doesn't mean that they don't belong. That's all I'm saying.


r/books • • Oct 17 '23

comments contain spoilers Do you think that the fact Jaime, Tyrion and even Tywin (to an extent) are beloved by the ASOIAF fandom while Cersei is hated indicates some gender double standard? Spoiler

364 Upvotes

Most of the main Lannister family (which includes Jaime, Tyrion, Cersei and Tywin) are not particularly good people to put it mildly. However, from what I have seen, the ASOIAF fans at least try to understand where Jaime, Tyrion and Tywin come from and there are a lot of people who think they are not actually evil people even if they have their faults.

Yet, when it comes to Cersei, the fandom just hates her and think she is irredeemable and evil and constantly dehumanizes her and refuses to see things from her perspective even she is no more morally reprehensible than the rest of her family. Tywin as actually done much worse things than her and Tyrion's actions are just as bad as Cersei's and in soe cases can be even worse (I don't recall Cersei organizing a massive invasion against the Vale where many innocent people are killed or feeding human flesh to unsuspecting poor people).

The fans completely ignore the fact that most of the things Cersei has done are done to protect her children from harm and I honestly don't even blame her for her actions against Robert and Ned. Robert raped her and he would have executed her children because Cersei commited the "crime" of cheating on her (which is something Robert also did, but when a man does according to the fandom, it's not a crime, but when a woman cheats on her rapist husband, she is Satan herself and needs to be beheaded along with her children and isn't allowed to do anything to protect her family from this injustice). Ned endangered her kids wit his actions (just to be clear, I don't hate Ned but if you look at things from Cersei's perspective, Ned's actions would have led to her children being executed) and that's why I can't blame her for acting to protect them. But most of the fandom totally ignores how executing a woman and her children because said woman was forced to marry a man she didn't love and cheated on him is morally wrong and laos conveniently ignores that Robert also cheated on her and raped her (if somebody rapes you repeatedly, I personally would be totally fine with you killing said person even in the present day).

Also, there are some double standards that readers use to judge characters when it's convenient to them. For example, Cersei isn't allowed sexual freedom and shouldn't do anything about her husbadn rping her because "that's how things were back then" but when Catelyn is cold towards Jon due to his bastard status or when people don't like Tyrion due to being dwarf, the fans apply modern morality and judge the people who do it harshly even though that also falls under the category of "that's how things were back then".

My point is not that Cersei is 100% good and pure and should be excused of all her faults. My point is that she has reasons to be the way she is and she has relatable reasons behind her actions and she should be judged the same way Tyrion or Jaime are judged by the fandom.


r/books • • Dec 09 '21

Inside the trans publishing purge

Thumbnail
unherd.com
12 Upvotes

r/books • • May 08 '25 Polished Gold Turd

Here are 44 brand-new LGBTQ+ books you can pick up right now

Thumbnail
out.com
61 Upvotes

r/books • • Dec 31 '13

discussion Genderswitched Bilbo makes The Hobbit a better read

Thumbnail
boingboing.net
315 Upvotes

r/books • • Nov 01 '23

Stephen King trying not to write about a woman’s breasts every two paragraphs in harrowing detail challenge (impossible)

15 Upvotes

actually someone please explain why he does this. not only does he describe women’s breasts every two paragraphs, he also describes men’s testicles more often than any regular person would talk about someone’s testicles. Right now i’m taking my example from Rose Madder- describes Norman almost popping a guy’s balls in a weird, violent, and weirdly sexual context. Then goes on to describe the boobies of every female character Rose meets. I love King but god is he fucking weird.


r/books • • Nov 03 '25

Nonwhite readers, how do you deal with racist depictions in older books?

0 Upvotes

White guy asking this.

I'm working my through Lovecraft atm and, of course, every so often his xenophobia makes itself known, and it's bothering a lot more now than when I first discovered him back in high school. Maybe it's the current state of the world politically, maybe it's that in the past couple years I've started confronting my own unconcious prejudices. I used to just shrug my shoulders, say "It was a different time" and read on. Now I find myself cringing.

I'm fully opposed to older works being edited to remove "problematic" elements (I see it no different than a textbook lying about slavery) but this is affecting my enjoyment a bit.

How do nonwhite or other marginalized readers deal with it?


r/books • • Aug 27 '24

Janice Hallett interview: 'Women dominate crime fiction because we fear for our lives'

Thumbnail
telegraph.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/books • • Nov 20 '17

People used to read out loud for fun. Reading silently to oneself is a relatively new phenomenon, beginning as recently as the late 18th century.

Thumbnail
quartzy.qz.com
11.2k Upvotes

r/books • • Feb 06 '16

Young reader builds list of #1000BlackGirlBooks - Middle schooler was tired of reading books about "white boys and their dogs"

Thumbnail
cnn.com
108 Upvotes

r/books • • May 16 '24

Has anyone else left Blood Meridian by C.McCarthy as a ‘DNF’

8 Upvotes

I started reading it and did enjoy it! But then i left it for a few days and now as im reading it im losing more and more interest and im only half way through? It’s been the same thing for so long… Does it change or is this his style or something? I read The Road by him and I see how they are similar in layout but Bloody Meridian is just missing something for me I think? Idk, anyone else had this?