r/bobdylan • • 11h ago

Discussion Weekly Song Discussion - 10,000 Men

1 Upvotes

Hey r/bobdylan! Welcome to this week's song discussion!

In these threads we will discuss a new song every week, trading lyrical interpretations, rankings, opinions, favorite versions, and anything else you can think of about the song of the week.

This week we will be discussing 10,000 Men.

Lyrics

Click here to vote for next week's song!


r/bobdylan • • 14m ago

Concert Munich Concert Review (11/15/26)

1 Upvotes

When I first heard that the Patriots were playing in Munich on the same day as Bob Dylan- my two loves together in a city high on my list- I knew I had to go. Then, the rats of Charm City ate through my car engine wires and my tear duct closed, forcing me to spend a lot of money to replace both. It seemed like the responsible thing to not go on the trip so that’s what I temporarily decided to do, knowing I would end up going, because how could I not?

It would be pretty much impossible to see both events in their entirety with a 3:30 Patriots kickoff and a very punctual 8:00 curtain time for Bob.

To prepare for the big day, I had every contingency accounted for. I researched every imaginable way to get from one stadium to the other. I figured out how to make my phone battery last while navigating around and capturing the day. I wore layers to account for the shifting temperatures during the 10+ hours I would be gone. I checked stadium bag policies and brought two extra credit cards in case the first and second ones didn’t work.

One of the benefits of being a pessimist is that we always think about what can go wrong.

Even though everything in the Patriots game went wrong, I got to see the whole miserable thing, including my quarterback’s early exit from it, with my $240 ticket, which was the only one I ever saw under $300. I sat next to a bunch of great guys, bulldozed my way onto the first subway out of there, then again on the first transfer, went through all the lines at the concert venue, grabbed a beer, and made it to my seat at 7:50.

Whew.

  1. The venue was midsize and felt festive with lights and installations surrounding the outside. On the inside, lights lined the tunnels in between the sections, which gave it a Christmasy feel. The floor seats were not divided but instead were in one big clump. Capacity was 15,500 and tickets were sold out.

  2. I was seated to the right of the stage, not technically on the floor but I may as well have been. I was three rows up on the first level in the aisle seat farthest to the left. I had a clear view of the stage (though Julian Lage was often obstructed by the heavy curtain) which had Bob slightly left of center on the keyboard, Julian Lage to his right, Tony Garnier to his immediate left, Anton Fig on drums to Tony’s left, and Joel Patterson on guitar to Anton’s left. Everyone was dressed in black except Bob who wore his white hoodie with black pants and shoes.

  3. Before the show I greeted those around me as I always do and gauged who may have wanted to chat. The gentleman behind me seemed receptive so we talked for a moment. I asked him if he was excited for the show and he said no. I asked if someone had dragged him there and he said no, but that at his age, he was too old to get excited about anything. I found that really sad.

  4. When the lights came on the stage, everyone was at their respective instruments including Bob, and the band began playing Watching the River Flow. The crowd was still chatting, finding their seats and didn’t seem ready for the show. To be honest, I didn’t feel all that ready either. I like to arrive early to places to get settled. Being rushed is just about my least favorite feeling, and it took me a minute to switch from Patriots mode to travel mode to Bob mode.

  5. Of course, the sound at every show is going to depend on where you sit, but from where I was, Bob was deeply expressive, and his enunciation was maybe the clearest I’ve ever heard it. This gave profound context to the songs throughout the show.

  6. He held the endings of his lines on a lot of his songs, starting with Watching the River Flooooowwwww. Sometimes his voice warbles, and I can’t tell if he does this intentionally or if his voice can’t sustain a note that long on certain nights, but he held his notes for a long time tonight. Whatever shape his voice is in, I always want to hear it as clearly as I can, and it always seems too low, including tonight. Even though the band is incredible, they do drown him out a bit.

  7. During Love Sick, he was quite emphatic and convincing in his delivery of *“*I’m so sick of it.” He then changed his delivery into a pained one during “And you leave me hanging on.” His voice cracked during this line, and I also can’t tell if he does this intentionally but either way, I always love when that happens. During his 2015 interview with AARP, he said that this was the best song he ever wrote about heartbreak and loss. He says a lot of things in interviews, and it’s impossible to know what is true or assuming it is, how long it may be true for, but whatever the case it’s an easy answer to defend.

  8. It Ain’t Me Babe was similar to the other night in Vienna with the extra nos (No, no, no, no, no). I like this song, and it is a classic for a reason, but it doesn’t move me when I hear it live. He obviously loves to play it, and the crowd always reacts to it so no complaints from me. I appreciate that there are 15,499 other people there with me, and unlike my students, I do not expect everything to be catered to my exact needs at every given moment.

  9. Tryin’ to Get to Heaven, on the other hand, has become a fast favorite. Version 2 from Fragments has always been the one I listen to most, but this is a strong contender. The upbeat arrangement completely changes the feel of the song. I wouldn’t say it turns it into a cheerful one, but there are a lot of clever lines in there that deserve some appreciation. Someone I was talking to in Vienna said that the line about Miss Mary Jane in Baltimore is one of their favorite lines in all of Bob’s catalogue even though they didn’t really speak English or know where Baltimore was. It’s not Bob’s line, of course (it’s from the folk song Ridin’ in a Buggy) but most of those lines are from other songs which is part of what makes it such a clever song, and there is a lot of humor in it, dark and otherwise. Yes, the theme is heavy but like a lot of his songs, there is a lot of wit in there too, and this arrangement gives the audience permission to acknowledge that.

  10. This High Water arrangement is so different than the “Love and Theft” version and any other live version I’ve heard (minus the Vienna one from the other night.) The tone is so subdued and his delivery of “High water everywhere” was drawn out and even and matter of fact. It really highlights the narrator’s apathy and stresses the line, “I didn’t really care.” In true Dylan form, the world around him is falling apart, and all he really cares about is getting laid.

  11. I Can Tell remains a staple and I haven’t noticed him changing this up much. This may be another one that I’ve heard every time or at least close to it. He sings it well and consistently. Through these first few songs, the band was bouncing around a bit, Joel most of all. Bob was pretty stiff up until this point, even through this number somehow, because it does have a great beat. It really helped me focus on Anton which I did more and more throughout the night. Julian gets a lot of the mentions in these write ups, but there is a reason Dylan has gone back to Anton repeatedly since the mid-80s. The whole band is great, and he really drives it.

  12. The other night in Vienna, I said that it didn’t seem like Bob was directing the band because I couldn’t see him looking around. Tonight, I saw him do it constantly. It wasn’t in a jerking kind of way like he does when he is angry and reacting to something he doesn’t like but in the way he does simply by looking over and then right back at his keys. He did it at the beginning and ending of almost every song, so I’m sure he did it the other night too and I just couldn’t see. I’m so curious what it means. I would imagine at the end of each song it’s a “wrap it up” look, but what could it mean at the beginning? Is he trying to make sure everyone is ready to go?

  13. Black Rider was like It Ain’t Me Babe tonight for me. It wasn’t bad, but it didn’t move me in any kind of way. It’s not my favorite song of his, though I am intrigued by the potential autobiographical implications. There are live versions that have piqued my interest in the past, perhaps in contrast to the album version which, again, I don’t love, but tonight I just felt sort of meh about it. I did notice tonight and the other night that he sort of swallowed (I don’t know how to say this without sounding like innuendo) the line “the size of your cock will get you nowhere” like his grandmother was in the audience or something. The 20-something guy sitting next to me clapped when he said it, and it was the only time he clapped during a song all night which I’m quite curious about.

  14. Tangled Up in Blue was gorgeous and short. He changed up the lyrics for sure, and I think/hope I caught more of them this time. “You look like someone I used to trust. You look like someone I used to know. She gave me a book of poems and said ‘memorize these as you go to and fro’”. I’m sure that’s not exactly it but I think it’s close.

  15. He also switched up some lyrics to When I Paint My Masterpiece, something about washing his shirt from the grease and that the plane ride made him ill as he was going over the hill. This rendition was rocking as usual, and Bob finally got in the groove here, swaying a bit back and forth as he stood and played. I also love how he stops this one in the middle as if he’s finished, waits for the applause and then picks it up again. So great.

  16. He stood most of the time while he was playing, though he sometimes sat and often sat in between songs for a quick break. When he left at the end of the show it was a strained move to get his legs out from under the keyboard to walk to the front of the stage and not say goodnight. I would imagine he is in a lot of pain in a lot of places.

  17. I’m very curious what the pages on his keyboard are all about. He flips a lot of them from song to song but doesn’t seem to look at them as he is playing. Is it for the lyrics or the music or both? I was watching his hands a lot, and he is playing the whole show but some songs much more vigorously than others. He played most prominently on High Water, Masterpiece, and Soon After Midnight.

  18. Not Dark Yet was the one that made me cry tonight, or I should say started me crying because I didn’t really stop until the end of the show. He was so resigned and calm and his voice was strong, but at the same time, it was only as strong as it is. I listened closely to his voice and to the words, and thought about how disillusioned and disheartened and dissatisfied he has seemed since pretty much forever. Seeing the world for all its faults isn’t hard to do, and it becomes really, really exhausting. It’s too easy at any age to stop getting excited for things, and it’s too easy at any age to always expect the worst, even if preparing for it means you get to a show on time. For some people, looking on the bright side comes easier and for some people, it’s a lot of hard work. For some people, at some point, the work just becomes too hard.

  19. I’ll Make it All Up To You was a new one for me, but not for Bob. He’s played it 68 times since May of 2025. The song was released in 1958, so why did Bob start singing it in May of 2025? This isn’t a set up- I’m asking.

  20. Before my creature double feature today, I went to a church service that was all in German. I don’t speak German, but I’ve been to enough church services that I know the rhythm and flow, and I’ve been a human being long enough that I can follow the cadence of someone’s speech. During the pastor’s sermon, I knew when he was pausing for dramatic effect, when he was about to say something funny, and when he was trying to drive a point home. The message itself was not clear, but I could tell when he wanted me to feel a certain way. I often feel that way about Bob’s songs, and Early Roman Kings is one of them. I don’t really understand what’s going on, but I get a sense of the feeling and the mood, and that is enough for me, for some songs anyway. I wouldn’t love an artist as much as I love Bob if I never understood what they were talking about or if I was never able to make my own meaning out of what they were saying, but every once in a while, just listening to the music and not worrying too much about what it means is a nice break from having to figure it all out.

  21. Soon After Midnight and Million Miles were a great one-two punch here. His singing was clear if not a bit low in the mix. I do find it noteworthy that, while he doesn’t have a ton of love songs that end happily ever after, he does have his share, and he sure doesn’t choose to play them. It may mean something or it may not mean anything, and this just reminded me that I have been wanting to write something about Bob’s happy songs, and I keep not doing it which may mean something or it may not mean anything. (This is what happens when you’re always in your head…)

  22. Under the Red Sky is another one I don’t notice him change up much, which now makes me wonder how he chooses which songs to change up and which ones he keeps the same.

  23. Which brings us to Sugar Baby. I seriously contemplated writing this whole piece about Sugar Baby, because oh, sugar, baby. This was breathtaking. He sang the hell out of this one. I mean, sang, sang. Not spoke sang or the German past tense of Sprechgesang, but really sang it. And he hit high notes that I didn’t know he could hit. It was the most beautiful I’ve ever heard him sing.

  24. And then came Honest With Me which I had never heard him sing live before. Not only was it a fabulous rendition, but he pulled out the harp in the middle of it for the most beautiful harmonica solo I’ve ever heard him do. Right after Sugar Baby. Oh, sugar, baby. It was almost too much.

  25. As I prepared for the last song, I was hoping for I Shall Be Released, but I was bracing for Every Grain of Sand. Not that it’s a bad way to end a show. It’s a beautiful song, but I really wanted to hear I Shall Be Released. I was warming up to this live version, and I wanted to hear it again, maybe for the last time (I know, I know…). He has been going back and forth during this Lights of Autumn Tour, and I was ready to be a bit disappointed because even after this amazing show, that is just how disillusioned and disheartened and dissatisfied minds work.

Then, he began, “They say everything…”

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Setlist

Watching the River Flow

Love Sick

It Ain’t Me Babe

Trying to Get to Heaven

High Water

I Can Tell

Black Rider

Tangled Up in Blue

When I Paint My Masterpiece

Not Dark Yet

I’ll Make it All Up to You

Early Roman Kings

Soon After Midnight

Million Miles

Under the Red Sky

Sugar Baby

Honest With Me

I Shall Be Released


r/bobdylan • • 36m ago

Song Version Discussion Going going gone

Post image
4 Upvotes

Ft worth show-I am listening to the live version from 1976… three years after this song going going gone came out. One year after diamonds and rust came out…
Joan Baez was on this concert
Bob changed the highlighted lyrics to diamonds and rust on this 1976 show while she was in attendance.
I love how he is always changing lyrics and the direct tie to joan in front of her was crazyyy asf not blind to this


r/bobdylan • • 1h ago

Discussion I’m tired-Most of the Time

14 Upvotes

This is speaking for me.

I’m doing ok.

My wife and I have a newborn, a toddler, jobs. Everyone is healthy.

My OCD, though mostly under control, still gets at me sometimes, and thus I still have some days where it kicks my butt, though ultimately I don’t spiral like I used to.

Just needing to cry tonight if for no other reason than to get the tension out and be ready to do it again tomorrow.

“Most of the time
It's well understood
Most of the time
I wouldn't change it if I could
I can't make it all match up
I can hold my own
I can deal with the situation
Right down to the bone
I can survive and I can endure…
Most of the time”


r/bobdylan • • 2h ago

Discussion 2027 OBS Thoughts

3 Upvotes

Bob did record unreleased material in 1986/1987. Songs like 'Important Words' etc.

He also played with Tom Petty throughout 1986 and in 1987 the Grateful Dead, then went on the brilliant Temples in Flames tour.

I think a really good OBS could be compiled.

The 1986 had some strong shows, but even just a remastered version of Hard To Handle would be great along with any unreleased 1986 studio songs.

And The Dylan And The Dead live album remastered, plus two of the best shows remixed and remastered of the Dead shows (the 1989 release doesn't have the best performances). All those shows were multi track recorded.

And a show from the Temple in Flames tour would be brilliant although I don't know if any of those were captured professionally.

But even a soundboard would be brilliant.

It's an important year in Bob's career. The year he struggled and then got back inside his songs. Would anyone else enjoy a 1986 1987 OBS? It was the dawn before the never ending tour.


r/bobdylan • • 2h ago

Music What are your favorite lines from John Wesley Harding? 🖤

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/bobdylan • • 4h ago

Concert Anyone else at Munich tonight?

20 Upvotes

I'm working on my review now, but I wanted to hear what you thought. I thought it was absolutely incredible. Probably my best show yet. That Sugar Baby arrangement was the most beautiful I've ever heard him sing, and that Honest With Me including the harp...oh my God. Just gorgeous. I don't think I stopped crying from Not Dark Yet through the end.


r/bobdylan • • 4h ago

Question Guitarist on "I Shall Be Released" studio outtake 1971

1 Upvotes

Who's playing guitar with Dylan on this take? Incredible playing and phrasing.


r/bobdylan • • 4h ago

Music I had on this day wondered if these two ever met. And I guess they did

Post image
62 Upvotes

r/bobdylan • • 5h ago

Image One of Bobby Womack’s Last Interviews He Speaks on Jamming with Bob Dylan

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/bobdylan • • 5h ago

Video From the bobdylan community on Reddit: Bob Dylan & The Pope - SNL

Thumbnail
reddit.com
5 Upvotes

SNL CHICAGO POPE AND BOBBY D.


r/bobdylan • • 6h ago

Music sick (slowed + reverb) version of the best Million Miles ever

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

original unedited on YouTube: Million Miles London 11/24/2003

This performance is an all-timer, and it's from a great show. The folks at the Hammersmith Apollo in 2003 were blessed that night.

Couldn't resist making a slowed + reverb version to see what would happen. I like it. Some more dark blues magic vibes. Wouldn't mind hearing it actually performed at that tempo.


r/bobdylan • • 7h ago

Humor Bob Dylan & The Pope - SNL

Thumbnail
youtu.be
291 Upvotes

r/bobdylan • • 7h ago

Discussion Pain Sure Brings out the Best in People, Doesn't It

14 Upvotes

It's my favorite Dylan song ("She's Your Lover Now") and it's already been Song of the Week here recently but... every now and then I trot it out and listen to the four versions on CUTTING EDGE and I can't help it. I have to love on it.

Both of you so glad

To watch me destroy what I had

Pain sure brings out the best in people, doesn't it?

One of the strongest Dylan openings out there. This song is "Positively 4th Street" on steroids. OK I'll shut up now.

PS - And you, just what do you DO anyway?


r/bobdylan • • 7h ago

Video The melody for the latest version of High Water is one of the most beautiful Dylan has ever written

30 Upvotes

I cannot stop listening to the latest arrangement of Highwater (For Charley Patton) - specifically the version from the second Vienna show (Nov 12), as recorded by Kanarek and remastered by Bennyboy. This strikes me as the most sublime new melody that Dylan has written in decades. I'm addicted to it like a drug. I sincerely hope he writes and records a brand new song using this exact melody. It would be an all-timer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yLlCS4STCck


r/bobdylan • • 10h ago

Question Hello! I am trying to identify this bob dylan bootleg? record i found thrifting. Help?

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

I can't seem to figure this out. The slip of paper seems printed, not wrotten with a pen, as does the label. I've done my due diligence on the internet, as well as with ai, but cant seem to find anything conclusive. Is this just a late 70s bootleg? Does anyone collect these? Thank you so much for any input!


r/bobdylan • • 18h ago

Music Fort Worth ‘76

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/bobdylan • • 21h ago

Question For those who have listened

Post image
76 Upvotes

What are the best shows from this box set?


r/bobdylan • • 22h ago

Misc. Dylan hasn't played Shelter from the Storm in 4,139 days.

69 Upvotes

Why?


r/bobdylan • • 23h ago

Discussion Which of the new 76 releases do you like better?

4 Upvotes

discuss below in the comments. my pick is Fort Collins, I was honestly blown away the first time i listened to it, although Fort Worth has some great highlights like I Threw It All Away, Stuck Inside of Mobile and Lay Lady Lay and the new remasters sound absolutely incredible.

75 votes, 6d left
Live at Fort Collins, Colorado May 23rd
Live at Fort Worth, Texas May 16th

r/bobdylan • • 1d ago

Concert “Honest With Me” in Salzburg

Post image
84 Upvotes

Bob played “Honest With Me” tonight in Salzburg - first time since 2019. Was anyone there? I’d have enjoyed hearing that!


r/bobdylan • • 1d ago

Video Stories about encounters with Bob. And the absolute love that exists for him.

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
1 Upvotes

r/bobdylan • • 1d ago

Video Bob Dylan planted the seed for Farm Aid. Willie Nelson ran with the idea. And the rest is history. Over 80 million dollars raised to current day. Music will always rule the world.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
16 Upvotes

r/bobdylan • • 1d ago

Image King Charles Includes a Bob Dylan Song On His Playlist of Favourite Songs on Elton John’s Podcast

Post image
89 Upvotes