r/bobdylan • u/IkeysireKlien • Jul 02 '25
r/bobdylan • u/Existenz_1229 • Jan 22 '26
Discussion Hot Take: "Sara" Is Not a Great Song
Everyone knows the last song on Desire was written for Dylan's then-wife. Their marital woes had presumably been his inspiration for the emotionally complex songs on his previous album Blood on the Tracks, but "Sara" was the first time Dylan had mentioned her by name and spoken directly of their relationship. It's a simple, interesting little melody, which violinist Scarlet Rivera and bassist Rob Stoner make into a brooding piece. But the emotional aspect is oddly lacking.
Even though he named the song after her and he sings her name in the chorus, Dylan doesn't seem to include a living Sara anywhere in the song. He only seems to appreciate her physical beauty ("beautiful lady," "so easy to look at") and his access to her ("still within reach," "we're never apart"), and she never says or does anything to make her more than some remote symbol, a "glamorous nymph with an arrow and bow." He asks, "What ever made you want to change your mind?" But he treats it as nothing more than a rhetorical question, like he doesn't want to address her experience in any way.
He spends an entire verse talking about their children playing on the beach, and mentions how much effort he supposedly spent writing the song "Sad Eyed Lady of the Lowlands" in her honor. So it seems like he's insisting she should stay with him because they have kids and he wrote one of his iconic songs after her. He tells her, "You MUST forgive me my unworthiness," but it doesn't sound like a real apology. Why not act in a way to make yourself worthy? The last line is "Don't ever leave me, don't ever go," but delivered in the same subdued growl that he's used throughout the song to refer to things like old boards on a beach or a calico dress. If he's desperate to keep her, he doesn't sound like it. And, knowing as little as we do about her, how could we blame him?
Am I the only one who's disturbed by the lack of candor in this supposedly personal and confessional song?
r/bobdylan • u/zackandcodyfan • Jun 27 '25
Misc. Happy Pride Month! 🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️ I'm creating an LGBTQ+/pride playlist on Spotify. Which Bob Dylan song should be included? I'll pick the most upvoted answer.
r/bobdylan • u/Sandalwoodincencebur • Jul 24 '25
A Complete Unknown Film "The Complete Unknown" Biopic – Underwhelming?
I just watched The Complete Unknown, and while the acting performances were solid, I found the overall story lacking. It feels like the filmmakers prioritized sticking closely to real-life events at the expense of dramatic tension. For example, Dylan’s life-changing motorcycle accident, a pivotal moment was completely omitted.
The movie also leans heavily into the "mysterious cool guy" aesthetic (sunglasses at night, cigarette posturing), but I wish it delved deeper into his poetic genius. Dylan’s lyrics are Shakespearean in their depth, yet the film reduces him to a kind of edgy enigma. Did anyone else feel like it didn’t fully capture his complexity?
r/bobdylan • u/extranaiveoliveoil • Jan 29 '24
Discussion Why doesn't Dylan speak out more about politics?
I know it's a sensible topic. But as someone who once was the most important political songwriter in the US, why doesn't he speak out in times when the whole democratic system is at stake? You know what I mean... Or do you think he will come out and say something later this year?
r/bobdylan
•
u/hmmmdjdjjd
•
Jun 19 '25
Humor Bob Dylan reminds me of raw broccoli! Who’s with me!!
Any dylanologists care to comment?
r/bobdylan • u/VillainAnderson • Jan 04 '24
Image My CDs in order from my favorite album to my least favorite album.
r/bobdylan • u/Qualier • Dec 10 '23
Question Whats your most hated Dylan song(s) that other people love?
Here's my top 3 1 Lay lady lay 2 Just like a woman 3 Murder most foul
I just hate lay lady lay, it's lyrically boring and silly, it's in his stupid troubadour voice and like most of bobs bad songs, he had nothing to say and not a good way of saying it. I turn it off when it comes on and I don't understand bob-heads who love it.
Obviously there are worse songs (wiggle wiggle, when the night comes falling, etc), but nobody calls them a classic or their fav. What's in your list?
r/bobdylan • u/TheMysteryRapper • Mar 15 '25
Question Do you think Bob Dylan ever ghostwrites for any famous rappers ?
r/bobdylan • u/Weird_Apartment9836 • Dec 04 '25
Question Whats the deal with Love and Theft?
I love Dylans later stuff, but I just can’t get behind Love and Theft. I always see it in people’s top 10s or 5s and Mississippi as their 3rd or 4th favorite song, so what’s the deal with Love and Theft, why is it so special? What am I Missing? I think its mediocre at best…
r/bobdylan • u/eccocasablancas • Sep 10 '24
Discussion Bob Dylan homophobic in his born again Christian phase?
I’m reading a book on Bob (The Cambridge companion to Bob Dylan), and in a passage discussing Bob’s born again Christian era, this passage caught my eye: “As the tour (November 1979) went on though, Dylan began to lecture and scold the audiences more, and the crowds grew more vocally hostile. He delivered lengthy Armageddon scenarios and homophobic rants.” As a reasonably big (but also reasonably new) fan of Bob, i’m not aware or familiar with this. Can anyone elaborate? Merely curious.
r/bobdylan • u/[deleted] • Jun 29 '25
Announcement Hot Take: "Hurricane" is a great song. It is the worst song on "Desire."
I'm ready to tango on this.
r/bobdylan • u/patoviking • Nov 25 '21
Meta What's up with the weird photos of Bob?
Basically the title.
We all know he isn't the most public personality out there and it don't think it is hard to understand he's not really into that.
So why so many of his "fans" think it is cool to take a creep shot of him while performing and then post it here? We all know what he looks like anyway.
Just enjoy the show and let him be, man.
r/bobdylan • u/Pretend_Mark_5143 • Mar 14 '26
Contest What’s The Worst Dylan Song From The 1960s?
Unsurprisingly, Like A Rolling Stone won. What a classic amazing song. Now onto worst song from the 60s. It’s harder than I thought actually. The 60s are a very valuable time for Dylan. It seems like even his most basic cover songs turn to gold when I listen to them.
r/bobdylan • u/BillNyeTheVinylGuy • Sep 21 '24
Music Why does Dylan mumble his way through his live shows while singing clearly on his studio recordings?
I am a huge fan that has seen Dylan multiple times on his Rough and Rowdy Ways tour, but isn't he obviously self-aware no one can understand what he's singing half the time on stage? Why does he generally only bring his A-game vocally in the studio?
r/bobdylan • u/HunterThompsonsentme • Apr 19 '24
Discussion Been a while since we had a Bob Dylan album covers tierlist
Curious to hear everyone's opinions. I'm expecting some blowback:)
r/bobdylan • u/[deleted] • Apr 29 '24
Discussion Who’s with me on this? May we never use the word “banger” to describe a Bob Dylan song.
r/bobdylan • u/[deleted] • Jul 29 '24
A Complete Unknown Film Chalamet gives off Chalamet not Bob Dylan
That trailer just didn’t look good. I’m super biased cause I’ve seen all the YouTube clips of early 60’s Dylan I can find, but still, it didn’t look that good. Ginsberg said Bob was “like a column of air” And Timmy reminded me of a pile of dirt. Everything I’ve seen Bob do in this time seemed like it was drenched in irony, but I didn’t see any of that in Timmy.
I just see no mystery in Timmy, and Bob Dylan, imo, is the most mysterious person I’ve ever seen or heard on film. I just feel like timmy didn’t really get the whole mystical, androgynous nymph thing that Bob did during that time. Liam Clancy said Bob was like a shapeshifter.
I know it’s only a trailer but Timmy looks way too serious and grounded to be doing a 60s Bob Dylan impression. He looks like he’s giving too much of a fuck. Bob looked like he gave all fucks to the wind during that time. I really don’t think he took any of the celebrity shit seriously.
Do you guys have hope for this movie?
As controversial as it may be, I think Cate Blanchette did an amazing Bob Dylan impression in ‘I’m not there’, and I thought it was an amazing idea to make her part of the movie black and white.
Frankly the more I watch that movie, the more I think it’s the best type of Dylan movie we could get. It’s incredibly mysterious and symbolic and has different characters playing Bob Dylan, none of which are named Bob Dylan. I feel like this is just gonna be another shit biopic pumped out of Hollywoods burnt out ass.
r/bobdylan • u/Acceptable-Prompt843 • May 06 '24
Question Bob Dylan “CJ” sub
There’s another bob Dylan related sub I keep getting updates from with a nsfw name - you can probably figure out which one. Do y’all also get updates on this? What is the intention of this sub - (if that’s what it’s called newer to Reddit)? Topics are things like quoting Bob “I’m in love with my second cousin.. “ and implying he’s a sicko. I’m pretty sure Bobs not in love with second cousin, his uncle didn’t run a funeral parlor etc. anyway, is this purpose of this group just to H8 on Bob or am I missing something? Thx!
r/bobdylan • u/Vasco2112 • Dec 13 '23
Discussion Unpopular opinion!
Budokon is the worst rearrangements of Bobs songs ever recorded. The only live period that after a few songs of listening I’m completely out... How over produced can you get? I feel like this show should of guested on the Price Is Right or something.
r/bobdylan • u/[deleted] • Mar 11 '25
A Complete Unknown Film Does the proliferation of A Complete Unknown’s inaccuracy of narrative bother you?
I've noticed a big uptick in Dylan fandom and discussion since the film's release, which is great, but I've also noticed a lot of younger people taking the film's narrative as historic fact and forming opinions etc. from that place -- obviously 2 hour standard biopic narrative formulas cannot accurately capture a narrative as complex as early Dylan's, so a lot is left out, obfuscated, blatantly changed, etc. (e.g. inaccurate recollection of events, highly dramatized/simplified and modernized account of Bob's relationship with Joan Baez, total omission of any mention of Warhol and the factory, the culture of the Chelsea, Downtown & modern art at the time and the way it influenced the shift in Bob's output, Sara literally not existing, Seeger arguably misrepresented for the sake of a compelling tension, on and on)
A part of me finds this frustrating, knowing that people are forming opinions etc with this historically inaccurate primary source-- I can't say how many hot takes i've seen lately about Dylan being a jerk to Baez for example, which, he was, but it's being oversimplified; other examples of what I mean abound... On the other hand I also feel it's almost par for the course as Dylan's narrative will always be obfuscated and difficult to parse, as that is an intentional and crafted aspect to his artistic process and how he relates to fame and the public eye (see: Rolling Thunder Revue as very intentionally ahistorical.)
What are your thoughts on this?